Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ranjini v. State Of Kerala

Kerala High Court
Jul 17, 2009
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Basant, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition seeks a writ of habeas corpus for production and release of Santhosh Kumar, who was detained under Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti‑Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAAPA). Two reports by N. Gopalakrishnan, IPS, Deputy Commissioner of Police (Law and Order) (dated 9‑12‑2008 and 13‑3‑2009) were submitted to the District Collector / District Magistrate. The first report (Ext.P3, 9‑12‑2008) was received but did not prompt detention; the District Magistrate directed completion of pending Section 107 Cr.P.C proceedings. After receipt of the further report of 13‑3‑2009, the District Magistrate passed the order of detention (Ext.P1) dated 26‑3‑2009; the detenu was arrested on 2‑4‑2009 and the detention was subsequently approved by the Government and confirmed by the Advisory Board under KAAPA.

Four criminal cases against the detenu are noted in the record:

  • Crime No. 22/02 (U/s 326 IPC) — offence dated 13/2/2002 — trial pending;
  • Crime No. 31/06 (U/s 451 IPC) — offence dated 29/1/2006 — trial pending;
  • Crime No. 13/08 (U/s 365 IPC) — offence dated 15/1/2008 — investigation pending;
  • Crime No. 645/08 (U/s 308 IPC) — offence dated 26/10/2008 — investigation pending.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Which Police Officer can make a report to the Government/District Magistrate under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA?
  2. Can an offence allegedly committed beyond seven years from the date of the order of detention be reckoned to bring a person within the sweep of "known goonda" under Section 2(p) of the KAAPA?
  3. Can an offence allegedly committed, the investigation into which by the police is not finally completed, be taken into reckoning while considering inclusion of a person within the expressions "known goonda" and "known rowdy" under Sections 2(o)(ii) and 2(p)(iii) of the KAAPA?
  4. Is the omission to furnish the document (a further report by the Police Officer under Section 3(1), on the basis of which the requisite satisfaction is entertained under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA) fatal?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The third respondent (Deputy Commissioner of Police (Law & Order)) is not a competent officer to submit a report under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA because he is not the District Superintendent of Police or Commissioner of Police.
  • Crime No. 1 (offence dated 13‑2‑2002) is beyond seven years from the detention order and therefore should not have been considered to label the detenu a "known rowdy" under Section 2(p).
  • There was total non‑application of mind by the detaining authority in passing Ext.P1.
  • Cases Nos. 3 and 4 were at the investigation stage (investigation incomplete) and should not have been taken into account under Sections 2(o)(ii) / 2(p)(iii).
  • The further report dated 13‑3‑2009 (on which the subjective satisfaction was primarily based) was not furnished to the detenu, thereby impairing his right to know the grounds of detention and to make an effective representation (Article 22(5) and Section 7(2) of KAAPA).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Government Pleader submitted that the third respondent is of the requisite rank: in the Commissionerate at Thiruvananthapuram a Deputy Commissioner is always an officer of the rank of Superintendent of Police (or above), and thus qualifies as "a Police Officer not below the rank of a Superintendent of Police" under Section 3(1) of KAAPA.
  • The Additional Director General of Prosecutions relied on the decision in Elizabeth George v. State of Kerala (2008 (4) K.L.T 425) to contend that even while investigation is pending, if the investigating officer forms the requisite satisfaction, the offence may be counted under Sections 2(o)(ii) and 2(p)(iii).
  • Implicitly, respondents relied on the two reports submitted (9‑12‑2008 and 13‑3‑2009) as the information upon which the detaining authority formed subjective satisfaction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Elizebeth George v. State of Kerala [2008 (4) K.L.T 425] Proposition that even before a final report is filed, if the investigating officer entertains the requisite satisfaction, the offence may be treated as one "found on investigation" for the purposes of Sections 2(o)(ii) / 2(p)(iii) of the KAAPA. The Court noted this authority was relied upon by respondents, but expressly disagreed with the relevant observations in Elizabeth George. The Court held that incomplete investigations or provisional conclusions by a police official cannot be sufficient to attract Sections 2(o)(ii) / 2(p)(iii). The Court indicated this point had been considered and rejected in its earlier decision (Sathi) and said the matter could merit a Full Bench reference though it declined to refer the case to a Full Bench here.
Sathi v. State of Kerala (W.P(Crl.) No. 201/2009 dated 2‑7‑2009) The Court's own prior consideration of the issue dealing with whether incomplete investigations can be relied upon to classify a person under Sections 2(o)(ii) / 2(p)(iii). The Court relied on and referred to its observations in Sathi where it had disagreed with Elizabeth George on this point. The Court reiterated its view that incomplete investigations/provisional conclusions are insufficient and noted the question could be referred to a Full Bench but chose not to do so in the present case to avoid delay.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds issue‑by‑issue, addressing each of the petitioner's grounds in light of the KAAPA and the facts in the record.

Competency of the reporting police officer (Ground No. 1):

  • The court examined Section 3(1) of the KAAPA which permits the Government or an authorised officer to make a detention order if satisfied on information received from "a Police Officer not below the rank of a Superintendent of Police".
  • The court interpreted the statutory phrase literally and held that the requirement is rank‑based, not post‑based; the police officer need only be of or above the rank of Superintendent of Police, and it is not necessary that the officer be the District Superintendent of Police or Commissioner of Police.
  • Given there was no dispute that the third respondent was of and above the rank of Superintendent of Police (the Government Pleader asserting that a Deputy Commissioner in the Commissionerate is of that rank), the court rejected the contention that the third respondent was incompetent to submit reports under Section 3(1).

Seven‑year temporal requirement for "known rowdy" (Ground No. 2):

  • The court quoted Section 2(p) which requires that acts relied upon must have been done within the previous seven years as calculated from the date of the order imposing detention.
  • Applying that provision, the court held Crime No. 1 (act dated 13‑2‑2002) could not be considered when the detention order was dated 26‑3‑2009, and therefore that offence must be excluded from consideration for determining whether the detenu is a "known rowdy".
  • The court thus allowed the challenge on this ground and directed that Crime No. 1 be excluded from the detaining authority's consideration.

Alleged non‑application of mind (Ground No. 3):

  • The petitioner argued the detaining authority failed to consider whether Crime No. 1 could validly be taken into account. The court reiterated its conclusion on Ground No. 2 (Crime No. 1 must be excluded).
  • The court referred to Section 7(4) of the KAAPA which permits an order of detention to remain valid despite some facts cited among the grounds being vague, non‑existent, irrelevant or invalid, provided the minimum conditions are satisfied and the remaining facts justify detention.
  • Consequently, the court held that mere omission to note Crime No. 1 cannot by itself invalidate the order if the detention can be supported on other valid facts; on the non‑application point itself the challenge failed for that reason.

Use of pending investigations (Ground No. 4):

  • The court analyzed whether offences under investigation (Cases 3 and 4) could be treated as "found on investigation" under Sections 2(o)(ii) / 2(p)(iii).
  • It observed the respondents' reliance on Elizabeth George which suggested that provisional satisfaction by an investigating officer could suffice even before a final report. The court disagreed with those observations, aligning instead with its prior reasoning in Sathi.
  • The court concluded that an incomplete investigation or provisional conclusions reached by a police official cannot be held sufficient to attract Sections 2(o)(ii) or 2(p)(iii) of the KAAPA.

Failure to furnish the further report dated 13‑3‑2009 (Ground No. 5):

  • The court reconstructed the sequence: the initial report (9‑12‑2008) did not cause detention; the later report (13‑3‑2009) apparently tilted the scales and was the primary basis on which the detaining authority purportedly formed subjective satisfaction and passed Ext.P1.
  • The further report (13‑3‑2009) was not furnished to the detenu. The court acknowledged the settled principle that omission to furnish every document will not always invalidate detention, but emphasized that where subjective satisfaction is entertained mainly on the basis of a single crucial document, non‑furnishing of that document can cause serious prejudice.
  • The court held that omission to supply the report of 13‑3‑2009 impaired the detenu's rights under Article 22(5) of the Constitution and Section 7(2) of KAAPA to know the grounds of detention and to make an effective representation. This failure was deemed fatal to the detention.

On balance, the court found that while several challenges failed (notably competency of the reporting officer and the non‑application point insofar as other facts could sustain detention), the omission to furnish the decisive further report (13‑3‑2009) infringed fundamental procedural safeguards and warranted invalidation of the detention.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Writ petition allowed; the order of detention (Ext.P1) and the consequent detention of Santhosh Kumar is set aside.

Direct Consequences

  • The Writ Petition is allowed and Ext.P1 (order of detention) is set aside.
  • If the detenu's detention is not necessary in connection with any other case, he shall be released forthwith from custody by the prison authorities at the Central Prison, Trivandrum.
  • The Registry is directed to communicate the order to the prison authorities forthwith.

Broader Implications Noted by the Court

  • The court expressed the view that an incomplete police investigation or provisional conclusions reached during investigation cannot, by themselves, be treated as sufficient to attract Sections 2(o)(ii) or 2(p)(iii) of the KAAPA. The court referred to its prior decision in Sathi and rejected the opposite view in Elizabeth George for the purposes of this matter.
  • The court observed that the question might merit a Full Bench reference, but declined to refer the matter to a Full Bench in this case to avoid protraction of proceedings.
  • The court's decision directly affects the parties by setting aside the detention; the opinion does not purport to record a formal Full Bench determination beyond the views expressed in this judgment.

This summary is limited to and derived exclusively from the contents of the provided opinion. No information beyond the text of the opinion has been added.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

Basant, J.

1) Which Police Officer can make a report to the Government/District Magistrate under Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities(Prevention) Act, 2007 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘KAAPA’)?

2) Can an offence allegedly committed beyond seven years from the date of the order of detention be reckoned to bring a person within the sweep of ‘known goonda’ under Section 2(p) of the KAAPA?

3) Can an offence allegedly committed, the investigation into which by the police is not finally completed, be taken into reckoning while considering inclusion of a person within the expression known goonda and known rowdy under Section 2(o)(ii) and 2p(iii) of the KAAPA?

4) Is the omission to furnish the document (a further report by the Police Officer under Section 3(1), on the basis of which the requisite satisfaction is entertained under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA, fatal?

2. The petitioner has filed this petition for issue of a writ of habeas corpus to cause the production of her husband Santhosh Kumar, who is detained under Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘KAAPA’), to set aside the order of detention, Ext.P1 and to set him at liberty.

3. Against the said Santhosh Kumar, four cases are pending, the details of which are shown below:

Sl. No. Crime No. Offences Date of offence Stage

alleged

(inter alia)

Crime No. 22/02 U/s.326 IPC 13/2/2002 Trial pending

of Vanchiyoor

1 Police Station.

Sl. No. Crime No. Offences Date of offence Stage

alleged

(inter alia)

Crime No. 31/06 U/s.451 IPC 29/1/2006 Trial pending

of Vanchiyoor

2 Police Station.

Crime No. 13/08 U/s.365 IPC 15/1/2008 Investigation

of Vanchiyoor pending

3 Police Station.

Crime No. U/s.308 IPC 26/10/2008 Investigation

645/08 of pending

Fort Police

4 Station

4. A report under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA was submitted by N. Gopalakrishnan, IPS, Deputy Commissioner of Police (Law and Order), Thiruvananthapuram City(Respondent No. 3) to the District Collector and District Magistrate (Respondent No. 2). Ext.P3 is the said report dated 9-12-2008. That report was received by the second respondent, but no action was taken on that report. The District Magistrate, it appears, only directed that proceedings under Section 107 Cr.P.C which was pending against the detenu as Crime No. 182/2008 of Vanchiyoor Police Station must be completed expeditiously.

5. At that stage, the third respondent submitted a further report dated 13-3-2009 to the District Magistrate (respondent No. 3). It is thereafter that order of detention (Ext.P1) was passed by the District Magistrate. The detenu was arrested on 2-4-2009. His detention was approved by the Government under Section 3(3) of the KAAPA. He had made a representation to the Advisory Board. The recommendations of the Advisory Board has been received and the order of detention has been confirmed under Section 10(4) of the KAAPA.

6. The petitioner, the wife of the detenu has come to this Court with a prayer that the order of detention may be set aside and her husband, the detenu may be set at liberty. Counter affidavits filed and the documents produced have been perused. Arguments have been heard.

7. The learned counsel for the petitioner assails the impugned order of detention on the following grounds:

1) The third respondent is not a competent officer who can submit the report under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA.

2) Case No. 1 referred above in which the alleged incident took place on 13-2-2002 should not have been taken into account to decide whether the detenu is a known rowdy under Section 2(p) of the KAAPA.

3) There has been total non-application of mind before passing Ext.P1 order of detention.

4) Case Nos. 3 and 4 referred above should not have been taken into reckoning to decide whether the detenu is a known rowdy under Section 2(p) of the KAAPA.

5) At any rate, the omission to furnish the further report dated 13-3-2009 submitted by the third respondent to the second respondent, to the detenu has adversely affected his right to know the grounds of detention and to make an effective representation against the order of detention.

8. Ground No. 1: Under Section 3 of the KAAPA, the Government or its delegate, the District Magistrate can act only on the basis of information received from specified officials. Section 3(1) which we extracted below clearly settles the position beyond any doubt.

“3. Power to make orders detaining Known Goondas and Known Rowdies.- (1) The Government or an officer authorised under sub-section (2) may, if satisfied on information received from a Police Officer not below the rank of a Superintendent of Police with regard to the activities of any Known Goonda or Known Rowdy, that with a view to preventing such person from committing any anti-social activity within the State of Kerala in any manner, it is necessary so to do, make an order directing that such person or detained.”

(emphasis supplied)

9. In the instant case action has been taken on the basis of two reports dated 9-12-2008 and 13-3-2009, both submitted by the third respondent herein. Counsel raises a contention that the third respondent is only a Deputy Commissioner of Police(Law and Order). He is not the District Superintendent of Police or the Commissioner of Police and, in these circumstances, he is not a competent official who can submit the relevant report under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA. We are unable to accept this contention. Under Section 3 of the KAAPA “a police officer not below the rank of a Superintendent of Police” is competent to furnish information to the Government/its delegate. The plain words of Section 3 make it very clear that such police officer need not necessarily be the District Superintendent of Police or the Commissioner of Police. The scheme of the KAAPA shows that only a police officer can furnish the requisite information to the Government/delegates to the District Magistrate and such police officer must be one not below the rank of a Superintendent of Police. The Superintendent of Police is a rank in the police hierarchy. Any police officer, of and above the rank of a Superintendent of Police can furnish the relevant information to the Government/District Magistrate. There is nothing in the language of Section 3(1) of the KAAPA extracted above that such police officer must not only be of and above the rank of a Superintendent of Police but must also be a District Superintendent of Police or Commissioner of Police. There is nothing in the language of Section 3 which can persuade us to read and understand the expression “a police officer not below the rank of a Superintendent of Police” to mean the head of the District Police-i.e District Superintendent of Police or the Commissioner of Police.

10. Any police officer of and above the rank of a Superintendent of Police - whichever police establishment in the State he is serving can furnish the information. A Superintendent of Police working in the Crime Branch Wing or the Special Branch Wing or any other Wing of the police establishment can also definitely furnish the requisite information under Section 3 of the KAAPA. We do not, in these circumstances, find any merit in the contention that merely because the third respondent does not head the police outfit in the City of Thiruvanthapuram (that is he is not the Commissioner of Police, Thiruvananthapuram), his report under Section 3(1) is incompetent. We repeat that the only requirement is that the police officer furnishing information must be of and above the rank of a Superintendent of Police. He cannot be below the rank of a Superintendent of Police.

11. There is no dispute before us that the third respondent is not an official “not below the rank of a Superintendent of Police.” The learned Government Pleader asserts that the second respondent is a Superintendent of Police and in the Commissionerate at Thiruvananthapuram, a D.I.G heads the establishment as the Commissioner and the Deputy Commissioner is always an officer of the rank of a Superintendent of Police. There is no assertion contra. We accept the same. The challenge on the first ground must in these circumstances fail.

12. Ground No. 2. The learned counsel for the petitioner contends that offence No. 1 referred above allegedly committed on 13-2-2002 should not have been taken into reckoning to decide whether the detenu is a known rowdy. The learned counsel relies on the language of Section 2(p) of the KAAPA, the relevant portion of which is extracted below:

“2p. ‘Known Rowdy’ means any person, who had been, by reason of acts done within the previous seven years as calculated from the date of the order imposing any restriction or detention under this Act.”

(emphasis supplied)

13. In this case the first case relates to an offence committed on 13-2-2002. The order of detention is dated 26-3-2009. The charge sheet in respect of the first case may have been filed after 26-3-2002. But that has no relevance or significance at all considering the language of Section 2(p) which we have extracted above. The act done which brings a detenu within the sweep of the expression ‘known rowdy’ must have been committed within the previous seven years as calculated from the date of the detention order. The detention order was passed on 26-3-2009 and the history prior to 26-3-2002 is irrelevant while considering whether a person is a known rowdy, contends counsel. We are in complete agreement with the learned counsel for the petitioner that case No. 1 referred above should not have been taken into reckoning at all to decide whether the detenu is a known rowdy or not. The challenge on this ground succeeds. The same (crime/offence No. 1 referred above) must have been excluded from consideration by the second respondent when he considered whether the detenu is a known rowdy or not.

14. Ground No. 3. It is contended that there is non-application of mind as the second respondent had not considered whether the first case can be validly taken into account or not. We have already upheld the challenge raised on Ground No. 2. Even if that is excluded, Section 7(4) mandates that if the mind is properly applied to the other circumstances, the order of detention can be supported. We extract Section 7(4) of the KAAPA below:

“The order of detention shall not be deemed to be invalid merely because one or more of the facts or circumstances cited among the grounds are vague, non-existent, irrelevant or invalid for any reason whatsoever and such order shall be deemed to have been made by the Government or the Authorised Officer after having been satisfied about the need for detention with reference to the remaining facts and circumstances, provided that the minimum conditions for being classified as a known goonda or known rowdy are satisfied.”

In the circumstances, mere omission to note that case No. 1 referred above cannot be taken into reckoning while considering whether the detenu is a known rowdy and that the same was taken into consideration cannot be of any help to the detenu, if he is otherwise found to be a known rowdy excluding case No. 1 referred above. The challenge on the ground that there is non application of mind for the above reason cannot hence succeed. If the order of detention can be supported on other grounds as mentioned in Section 7(4), this inadequacy cannot by itself invalidate the detention.

15. Ground No. 4. It is contended that in any view of the matter cases shown above as Sl. Nos. 3 & 4 should not have been taken into account at all as they were on the relevant dates pending at the stage of investigation and final reports had not been filed.

16. Section 2(o)(ii) and Section 2(p)(iii) are worded almost identically and the question to be considered is whether before an investigation is completed, it can be held that a person has been “found on investigation ….. by a competent police officer …. to have committed any offence”.

17. In the instant case investigation into cases shown above as Sl. Nos. 3 and 4 are not complete on the date of the order. Investigation was only continuing. The learned Additional Director General of Prosecutions relies on the decision in Elizebeth George v. State of Kerala [2008 (4) K.L.T 425] to contend that even before final report is filed, if the requisite satisfaction is entertained by the investigating officer, it can be held that the person falls under Section 2(o)(ii) or 2(p)(iii). We have already adverted to this aspect in Sathi v. State of Kerala (W.P(Crl.) No. 201/2009 dated 2-7-2009). In paras. 60 and 61 of the said decision dated 2-7-2009, we had disagreed with the observations of the Division Bench in Elizabeth George which appear in Paras. 12 to 14. We have already opined that the matter deserves to be referred to a Full Bench in an appropriate case. But even in this case we do not feel the need to make a reference in the light of the conclusion which we propose to reach later on Ground No. 5. For fear that such a reference to the Full Bench may entail unnecessary protraction of the proceedings, we are not making a reference to the Full Bench in this case also. We are certainly of the opinion that an incomplete investigation or provisional conclusions pending such investigation reached by a police official cannot be held to be sufficient to attract Section 2(o)(ii) or Section 2(p)(iii) of the KAAPA.

18. Ground No. 5. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the most crucial and vital document on which the subjective satisfaction is shown to have been entertained by the second respondent has not been furnished to the detenu. The learned counsel refers to the further report dated 13-3-2009. In this context, we deem it necessary to advert to the sequence of events once again.

19. A report under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA was submitted by the third respondent to the second respondent. That report is dated 9-12-2008 and a copy thereof is produced as Ext.P3 This report was duly received by the second respondent. But the second respondent did not take further action on the basis of Ext.P3 The second respondent, it is now evident, took note of proceedings under Section 107 Cr.P.C pending as Crime No. 182/2002 of Vanchiyoor police station and directed the Sub Divisional Magistrate to complete the proceedings at the earliest. He was evidently not satisfied that an order of detention under Section 3 was necessary on the basis of that report dated 9-12-2008. It is at that juncture that a further report dated 13-3-2009 was submitted by the third respondent to the second respondent. That further report appears to have tilted the scales and the second respondent allegedly entertained the requisite subjective satisfaction after pursuing that further report dated 13-3-2009. He then proceeded to pass the impugned order of detention.

20. Admittedly that further report dated 13-3-2009 has not been furnished to the detenu. There is no dispute on that aspect. It is by now trite that the omission to furnish any and every document may not entail invalidation of the detention order. But in this case, subjective satisfaction is entertained solely and mainly on the basis of one document, i.e the report dated 13-3-2009 submitted by the third respondent to the second respondent. That document has not been furnished. We have no hesitation to agree that the failure/omission to furnish copy of such all important report has caused serious prejudice and denial of justice to the detenu. His rights under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India and Section 7(2) of the KAAPA to know the basis on which he was detained and to make an effective representation to the Government and the Advisory Board have been blatantly impaired by such omission to furnish the crucial, vital and the all important document. We repeat that the sequence of events clearly shows that it is only on the basis of such further report that the detaining authority changed its view and allegedly entertained the subjective satisfaction. That omission/failure is fatal and cannot but persuade us to invalidate the detention.

21. We make it clear that we are convinced that the omission to furnish a copy of the further report dated 13-3-2009 has resulted in impairment of the right of the detention to make a representation under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India and 7(2) of the KAPPA and it is hence that we hold that the detention deserves to be invalidated. If we were not convinced about such infraction of the vital right under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India and Section 7(2) of the KAAPA to know the reason/basis of the order of detention and to make an effective representation against the order of detention, our conclusion may have been different.

22. It follows from the above discussions that the detention of the detenu deserves to be set aside.

23. In the result:

a) this Writ Petition is allowed;

b) Ext.P1 order of detention and the consequent detention of the detenu Santhosh Kumar is set aside.

c) If the detention of the detenu is not necessary in connection with any other case, he shall forthwith be released from custody by the prison authorities from the Central Prison, Trivandrum.

d) The Registry shall forthwith communicate the order to the prison authorities.