- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jomi C. Nidheeri v. Elanji Grama Panchayat
Structured Summary of the Opinion — J.B. Koshy, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
A private limited company (the fourth respondent) proposed to establish an Artificial Granite and Sand Manufacturing Unit with quarrying operations in Elanji Grama Panchayat. It purchased 22.31 acres of land in the appellant panchayat area and intended to use a portion for the unit. The fourth respondent applied to multiple statutory authorities (including the Geologist, District Industries Centre, Revenue Authorities, District Medical Officer, Ground Water Department, Chief Controller of Explosives, Director of Mining and Geology and others) and obtained various permits and licences. The Pollution Control Board granted a quarrying permit subject to conditions for initial setup and noted it would grant final consent only after a trial run and satisfaction that no pollution would be caused.
The then-President of the appellant Panchayat Committee granted permission for construction of the factory building. Local people appealed to the Tribunal for Local Self Government Institutions; the Tribunal remanded for reconsideration before the Grama Sabha. After expert opinion, the Panchayat refused permission by letter Ext. P7 dated 25.1.2006. The fourth respondent filed a statutory appeal to the Tribunal. By interim order Ext. P9 the Tribunal allowed completion of the building and construction of an internal road subject to an undertaking to remove the building if the final finding were adverse. By Ext. P10 dated 27.5.2006 the Tribunal set aside the Panchayat's refusal and directed the Panchayat to issue a licence to the fourth respondent, subject to conditions (including prohibition on extraction of ground water except for drinking purposes and compliance with conditions imposed by the Pollution Control Board and the District Medical Officer).
The Grama Panchayat challenged the Tribunal's order by filing Writ Appeals. There was also involvement of a third respondent (convenor of Koorumala Samrakshana Action Council) in related proceedings; that third respondent's appeal (W.A. No. 172 of 2007) did not challenge the Tribunal's order before this Court in the writ petition context. The Grama Panchayat subsequently filed W.A. No. 208 of 2007.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Appellate Tribunal for Local Self Government Institutions has the power to set aside an order of a Panchayat and decide an appeal on merits, or whether its power is limited to curing procedural irregularities and remanding for fresh decision (issues framed with reference to R.18 of the Tribunal Rules and S.271S of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994).
- Whether the Tribunal's decision to set aside the Panchayat's refusal (and to direct issuance of licence to the fourth respondent subject to conditions) was correct, having regard to environmental protection concerns and the permissions/conditions imposed by various statutory authorities.
Arguments of the Parties
Grama Panchayat's Arguments
- The Appellate Tribunal lacked power to set aside the Panchayat's order and decide the case on merits; it could only cure procedural defects and, at most, remand the matter for reconsideration. This contention invoked R.18 of the Tribunal Rules and S.271S of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any distinct legal arguments advanced by other parties in the appeal.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court addressed the jurisdictional issue first. It reproduced and considered the statutory provisions and rules relied upon:
- It noted S.271S(1) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act (which provides for constitution of a Tribunal to consider and dispose of appeals or revisions filed against decisions of Local Self Government Institutions) and S.276 (which authorises appeals to the Tribunal).
- The Court examined R.18 of the Tribunal Rules, which permits the Tribunal, where it is satisfied that a notice or order was not issued or taken in accordance with procedure under the Panchayat Act or rules, to direct the Panchayat or Secretary to issue notice or order or take action afresh complying with the procedure under law. The Court read this rule as addressing procedural irregularities.
- The Court then reviewed other rules (Rule 16 — issuance of notice to counter-petitioners; Rule 19 — hearing and power to decide ex parte; Rule 20 — requirement that the Tribunal issue a written order after considering the petition and connected records or after completion of trial) to assess the Tribunal's overall competence.
On the basis of the statutory text and the Rules taken together, the Court concluded that R.18's provision permitting remand in case of procedural irregularity does not restrict the Tribunal's broader powers. The Tribunal is vested with authority to hear appeals on merits and to decide them like any other appellate authority; it is not restricted to procedural remedies only. Accordingly, the Court held that the objection that the Tribunal could not decide on merits was not tenable.
Turning to the correctness of the Tribunal's substantive decision, the Court balanced environmental protection concerns (invoking the constitutional right to life under Article 21 and the need for precautionary measures) with the requirements of development. The Court examined the documentary record of statutory permissions and conditions (referred to in the opinion as exhibits such as Ext. R4 and its parts), and noted:
- Several statutory authorities had granted permissions or certificates subject to conditions — including the Division Officer, Fire and Rescue Services (with conditions limiting groundwater use to domestic needs and prescribing industrial water sourcing), the Geology Department, the Pollution Control Board (which imposed ten conditions including rainwater harvesting and stated that final consent would be given only after a trial run and satisfaction that no pollution would be caused), the District Magistrate (no objection for licence under the Explosives Act), the Tahsildar (no objection), the District Medical Officer (certificate), and the Ground Water Department.
- The appellate authority (Tribunal) had considered the entire matter, including contentions and documents, and affirmed issuance of quarrying permission subject to conditions (as recorded in Ext. R4(9) and related exhibits).
- The Pollution Control Board's permission was expressly conditional and included periodic checking and the requirement that the petitioner stop activities if pollution were caused; final consent awaited a satisfactory trial run.
On this factual and documentary basis, the Court found that the fourth respondent had taken measures intended to prevent pollution and had obtained the requisite statutory permissions subject to conditions. The Court observed that if any of the conditions imposed by statutory authorities are violated, the appellants (or others) remain free to raise those violations before the relevant statutory authorities, because compliance with those conditions is required both before commencement of operations and thereafter.
The Court endorsed the view of the learned Single Judge, who had considered the matter and concluded that no interference under Article 226 of the Constitution was required. The appellate Court therefore agreed with the Single Judge's conclusions.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Writ Appeals filed by the Grama Panchayat are dismissed.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The Tribunal's order (Ext. P10) setting aside the Panchayat's refusal and directing issuance of a licence to the fourth respondent (subject to specified conditions, including restrictions on groundwater extraction and compliance with the conditions of statutory authorities such as the Pollution Control Board and the District Medical Officer) stands affirmed by this Court.
- Enforcement and oversight: The licences and permissions granted by statutory authorities remain subject to the conditions imposed by those authorities, including the Pollution Control Board's requirement of a satisfactory trial run and ongoing monitoring; any violation of conditions can be pursued before the responsible statutory authorities.
- Broader legal posture: The Court held (as part of its reasoning) that the Appellate Tribunal is empowered to hear and decide appeals on merits and is not restricted solely to remanding for procedural defects. The opinion does not explicitly state that it is laying down a novel precedent beyond its conclusion in this case; the direct and immediate consequence recorded is dismissal of the Writ Appeals and affirmation of the Tribunal's decision.
This summary is confined to the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond what the opinion itself states.
J.B Koshy, J.:— Fourth respondent, a private limited company, proposed to set up an Artificial Granite and Sand Manufacturing Unit with quarrying operation in Elanji Grama Panchayat and purchased 22.31 acres of land within the area of the appellant panchayat and a portion of the above land is to be used for the above unit. It approached various statutory authorities, namely, Geologist, District Industries Centre, Revenue Authorities, District Medical Officer, District Officer of the Ground Water Department, Chief Controller of Explosives, Director of Mining and Geology and various authorities for permission. All of them granted permits and licences. Pollution Control Board also granted quarrying permit subject to certain conditions for initial setting up of the plant. They have also stated that they will give the final consent only after the trial run. The then President of the appellant Panchayat Committee granted permission for construction of the factory building. Appeal against the above decision was filed before the Tribunal for Local Self Government Institutions by the local people. The Tribunal remanded the matter after considering the reconsideration of the matter on recommendation from the Grama Sabha. After obtaining expert opinion, Panchayat decided not to grant permission to the fourth respondent for the establishment of Rock Crusher and Artificial Granite Sand Manufacturing Unit at Koorumala by Ext. P7 letter dated 25.1.2006 Against Ext. P7 order, statutory appeal was filed before the Tribunal for Local Self Government Institutions, Thiruvananthapuram. By Ext. P9 order, Tribunal by an interim order allowed the fourth respondent to complete the building and also to construct the road through his property on condition that he undertakes before the Panchayat to remove the building if the ultimate finding went against him. Thereafter, by Ext. P10 order dated 27.5.2006 after hearing all the interested parties and after considering the various contentions and documents, it was held that impugned decision of the Panchayat is unsustainable and liable to be set aside in view of the consent granted by the Pollution Control Board and the District Medical Officer and the suggestions of the District Officer of the Ground Water Department and the appellate authority directed the Panchayat to issue licence to the fourth respondent for the establishment of the factory incorporating a condition prohibiting extraction of ground water from its area except for drinking purposes and subject to complying with the conditions imposed by the Pollution Control Board and District Medical Officer. This order was challenged by the Grama Panchayat in the Writ Appeal. Third respondent in the Writ Petition who is stated to be the convenor of Koorumala Samrakshana Action Council filed W.A No. 172 of 2007 has not challenged the order of the Tribunal before this court in Writ Petition. Even though objections were raised about the maintainability of the appeal filed by the third respondent in the Writ Petition, subsequently, Grama Panchayat filed W.A No. 208 of 2007.
2. Preliminary ground taken by the Grama Panchayat was that the Appellate Tribunal has no power to set aside the order of the Tribunal considering R. 18 of the Tribunal for the Kerala Local Self Government Institutions Rules, 1999 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’) read with S. 271(5) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’).
3. It is the contention of the appellants that only procedural defects can be cured by the Tribunal and, at the maximum, it can remand the matter and the Tribunal has no power to decide the matter on merits. Sub-s. (1) of S. 271-S of the Act reads as follows:
“271S. Constitution of Tribunal for local Self Government Institutions:— (1) The Government shall constitute a Tribunal for every district or for more than one district, to consider and dispose of the appeal or revision filed against the decisions of the Local Self Government Institutions under S. 276 of this Act and S. 509 of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994.”
4. Sub-clause gives the same power as vested in the civil court when trying suit under the Code Of Civil Procedure with regard to certain Acts. It is also mentioned that the proceeding before the Tribunal shall be deemed to be proceeding within the meaning of S. 193 and 228 of the Indian Penal Code. S. 276 of the Act authorises appeal to be filed before the Tribunal.
5. It also further provides that appeals pending before other authorities also shall be handed over to the Tribunal. R. 18 of the Rules reads as follows:
“18. Directions to the Local Self Government Institutions:— If the Tribunal, on considering the petition and connected records, is satisfied that any notice or order issued or action taken by the Village Panchayat, Municipality or its Secretary as the case may be, is not issued or taken in accordance with the procedure under, the Panchayat Act or the Municipality Act or the rules made thereunder it may direct such Village Panchayat or Municipality or the Secretary to issue notice or order or to take action afresh complying the procedure under law.”
6. R. 18 only provides, if there is any procedural irregularity, the Tribunal can remand the matter and direct the Secretary to issue notice and comply with the procedure and pass fresh orders. Then, the above rule will not restrict the power of the Tribunal in hearing the appeal and passing orders on merit. Rule 16 provides issuance of notice to the counter petitioners before passing orders. Rule 19 speaks about hearing to be granted by the Tribunal and power of the Tribunal to decide the matter ex parte. R. 20 of the Rules reads as follows:
“20. Order of the Tribunal:—
(1) The Tribunal shall, after considering the petition and connected records of, if there is trial of the parties, after the completion of such trial, issue an order recording its decision on the petition:
Provided that if the Tribunal thinks it necessary so to do, it may declare in advance a date to issue such order and shall issue the order on that date.
(2) An order of the Tribunal shall be in writing and shall bear the signature and seal of the Tribunal on it.”
7. A reading of the statutory provisions would show that the Appellate Tribunal is vested with the power to hear the appeal on merit and can decide the matter like any other appellate authority and Tribunal's order is not restricted regarding the procedural matters only. Therefore, Tribunal can hear and dispose of the matter on merits as a full-fledged appeal and objection by the petitioners to that effect is not tenable.
8. Next question is whether the Tribunal's decision is correct or not. It is true that environment is to be protected and strict measures have to be adopted for the protection of environment as otherwise it will affect the right to live guaranteed by Art. 21 of the Constitution of India. At the same time, developmental activities are also necessary, but, while making developmental activities, it is the concern of the parties and courts to see that pollution is minimised and environment is protected. For that precautionary measures have to be done. In this case, all statutory authorities passed orders favourable to the petitioner. Ext. R4 shows that Division Officer, Fire and Rescue Services, gave permission to install machineries subject to certain conditions. It was directed that only domestic water requirement of workers and staff may be met by available ground water and that too should be limited to 2000 liters per day and the water requirement for industrial unit may be met from the surface water bodies or rivers in the far off area. Various other conditions were also prescribed and petitioner filed undertaking to fulfill those conditions. Geology Department has also granted permission subject to certain conditions by Ext. R4(8). Ext. R4(2) is the certificate issued by the Divisional Officer, Fire and Rescue Services Department. Ext. R4(3) is issued by the Pollution Control Board with ten conditions which include provision for rain water harvesting and various measures to restrict pollution. No objection certificate was given by the District Magistrate for issuing licence under the Explosives Act by Ext. R4(6). No objection certificate was given by the Tahsildar by Ext. R4(5). District Medical Officer of Health granted certificate by Ext. R4(7). The appellate authority in appeal filed by the petitioners considered the entire matter and appeal was dismissed and issuance of quarrying permission was affirmed as can be seen from Ext. R4(9). Permission of the Ground Water Department is Ext. R4(10). A reading of various exhibits would show that all statutory authorities have granted the permission. Pollution Control Board's order further makes it clear that permission is granted for construction etc. and it also stated that final consent will be given after trial run only after satisfying that no pollution or environmental problems are caused. There will be periodica] checking and if any pollution is caused, petitioner will have to stop the activities. Thus, fourth respondent has taken all the measures to prevent pollution. All the statutory authorities have given permission and various conditions were prescribed and if any of the conditions prescribed are violated, appellants will be free to raise it before the statutory authorities as the conditions prescribed by the statutory authorities have to be complied with by the fourth respondent before starting operation as well as after starting operation. The learned single Judge considered the entire matter and found that no interference is required by this court under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India. We fully agree with the conclusions reached by the learned single Judge. Hence, we dismiss the Writ Appeals.
Alert