- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Kerala State Co-Op. Consumers Federation Ltd. v. The Sub-Registrar
Factual and Procedural Background
Petitioner, a registered co-operative society under Government control, purchased immovable property from Palakkad Wholesale Co-op. Consumer Stores Ltd., another co-operative society under liquidation. The purchase was made at a public auction conducted by the Liquidator and confirmed by the High Court by its order dated 20-01-1998. The petitioner sought exemption from stamp duty under a Government Order (Ext. P1) that grants exemption for inter-Co-operative Societies sale deeds. Accordingly, a sale deed on white paper was presented for registration. The Sub Registrar doubted the eligibility for exemption under the Kerala Stamp Act, 1959 and impounded the document, referring it to the District Registrar for adjudication under Section 33(1) of the Stamp Act. The District Registrar, also doubting the exemption claim, referred the matter to the Government for opinion under Section 54(2) of the Act. The Government held that the instrument was not entitled to exemption and ordered recovery of stamp duty, leading to the filing of this writ petition challenging that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner, a registered co-operative society purchasing property from another co-operative society under liquidation, is entitled to exemption from stamp duty under the Government Order Ext. P1 and the Kerala Stamp Act, 1959.
- Whether the sale by the Liquidator on behalf of the society under liquidation qualifies as a transaction "for the purpose of business" of the society, thereby entitling exemption from stamp duty.
- The proper interpretation of the exemption clause in the Government notification Ext. P1, particularly the applicability of conditions related to instruments executed by or on behalf of registered co-operative societies.
Arguments of the Parties
Government's Arguments
- Exemption from stamp duty is available only when the transfer of property is for the purpose of business of the society.
- Sale of property in liquidation proceedings by a co-operative society does not qualify as a business purpose.
Petitioner's Arguments
- Any deed executed on behalf of a registered co-operative society is entitled to full exemption from stamp duty and registration charges as provided in Ext. P1 notification.
- The condition that the deed must be for the purpose of business applies only to instruments executed by officers or members of the society, not to deeds executed on behalf of the society itself.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the eligibility for exemption under Ext. P1 Government Order with reference to the person liable for stamp duty under Section 30(b) of the Kerala Stamp Act, 1959, which places liability on the grantee (the purchaser). Since the petitioner is the purchaser, it is liable to pay stamp duty unless exempted. The court found that the petitioner, a registered co-operative society engaged in business and under Government control, purchased the property for its business purpose, satisfying the notification's condition.
The court further examined the exemption clause 1(a) of Ext. P1, which exempts instruments executed on behalf of any registered co-operative society. The seller society was still registered as its cancellation under Section 74 of the Co-operative Societies Act had not been effected. The sale by the Liquidator was on behalf of the registered society, so the sale deed qualifies for exemption under the first part of clause 1(a).
The latter part of the exemption clause, which requires the instrument to be executed for the purpose of business, applies only to instruments executed by officers or members of the society, not to deeds executed by the Liquidator on behalf of the society. Additionally, exemption is available for documents executed pursuant to awards or orders of the Registrar or Arbitrators under the Co-operative Societies Act, which further supports exemption in this case.
Therefore, the court concluded that the Government's interpretation in Ext. P3 denying exemption was incorrect and unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
O.P. is allowed and the order denying exemption from stamp duty (Ext. P3) is set aside.
The respondents are directed to release the impounded sale deed document after registration, immediately upon production of a copy of this judgment by the petitioner.
This decision directly affects the parties by granting exemption from stamp duty on the sale deed in question. No broader precedent beyond the facts of this case is established.
1. Petitioner, a registered co-operative society under the control of the Government, purchased immovable property from another co-op. society by name Palakkad Wholesale Co-op. Consumer Stores Ltd., which was under liquidation. The purchase was in public auction conducted by the Liquidator which was confirmed by High Court by it's orders dated 20-1-1998. Since Ext. P1 Govt. Order grants exemption from stamp duty, for documents including inter-Co-operative Societies sale deeds, sale deed in white paper was presented for registration. The Sub Registrar, however, expressed doubt about the eligibility for exemption from stamp duty under the Kerala Stamp Act, 1959 based on the above notification, and therefore he impounded the document and forwarded the same to the District Registrar, Palakkad under Section 33(1) of the Stamp Act for adjudication. Since the District Registrar acting in exercise of power under Sections 31 and 39 of the Stamp Act himself felt doubt about the chargeablity of the instrument, he referred the matter for opinion of the Government under Section 54(2) of the Act Pursuant to reference the Government heard the petitioner and held that instrument is not entitled to exemption from stamp duty under Ext. P1 notification claimed by the petitioner, and consequently stamp duty was ordered to be recovered vide Ext. P3 proceedings against which this W.P.C is filed.
2. I have heard senior counsel Sri. Pathrose Mathai appearing for the petitioner and Government Pleader appearing for the respondents. The relevant clause in the notification M.S 795/60.Agri, dated 8-10-1960, produced as Ext. P1 in the O.P, which was published in the gazette dated 18-10-1960, is extracted hereunder for easy reference:
1. The stamp duty registration fees and fees for encumbrance certificate payable under the stimp act and the Registration Act in force in the state shall be remitted to the co-operative societies in the following cases to the extent indicated in each case.
(a). The whole stamp duty with which under the Kerala Stamp Act 1959 (Act 17 of 1959) instruments executed by or on behalf of any registered co-operative society or instruments executed by any officer or member of such society and relating to the business thereof and decisions, awards, or orders of the Registrar of the Arbitrators under the said co-operative Societies Act, provided that in the case of sale deeds, the Vendors have been continuously the members of such society for a period of two years immediately prior to execution of the instrument.
3. In exercise of delegated powers under Section 54(2) of the Stamp Act, the Land Revenue commissioner vide Ext. P3 held that petitioner is not entitled to exemption from stamp duty under the above Govt, order for the reason that sale is not for the purpose of business of the society. Government Pleader during hearing also highlighted this argument and contended that exemption is available only when transfer of property is for the purpose of business of the society and not when co-operative society sells property in liquidation proceedings. Senior counsel appearing for the petitioner on the other hand contended that any deed executed on behalf of the registered co-operative society is entitled to full exemption from stamp duty and registration charges as provided in the notification. According to him, the qualification of the deed as one for the purpose of business applies only in respect of instruments executed by any officer or member of such society.
4. On going through the above notification and after hearing both sides, I am unable to agree with the reasoning in Ext. P3 for denying exemption from stamp duty for more than one reason. In the first place eligibility for exemption under Ext. P1 G.O has to be considered with reference to the person who is liable for stamp duty under the Act. Section 30(b) of the Stamp Act provides that stamp duty is payable in the case of conveyance by the grantee. Therefore petitioner being the purchaser is liable to pay stamp duty under the Act for the instrument and department has also no case to the contrary because stamp duty is demanded from the petitioner. If the petitioner is liable, then the question to be considered is whether the purchase is for the purpose of business of the petitioner which is also not disputed by the Government as petitioner, a Co-operative Society, is admittedly a going conccm engaged in business and is under the control of the Government. Therefore, purchase is admittedly for business purpose of the petitioner and so much so the condition in the notification is satisfied. Secondly, the exemption clause 1(a) refers to several types of instruments. Under the first category, documents executed on behalf of any registered society are exempted from stamp duty. The seller in this case is a registered co-operative society, though under liquidation.
5. The Liquidator effected sale in public auction and High Court confirmed the same. In fact it is admitted that cancellation of registration of the seller society is not effected by the Registrar under Section 74 of the Co-op. Societies Act and so much so the society, property of which was sold by the Liquidator after confirmation by the High Court, continues to be a registered society. Draft sale deed produced in this Court also contains a recital that the sale is on behalf of the registered co-op. society by the Liquidator acting in his capacity as such. Since the sale by the Liquidator is on behalf of the Registered society, the sale deed to be executed is entitled to exemption under the first part of clause 1(a) of Ext. P1 G.O The later part which deals with exemption with additional condition that such exemption will be available only when instruments are executed for the purpose of business applies to cases where instruments are executed by any officer or a member of such society which obviously can be instruments executed for and on behalf of the society by the employees or even documents executed in favour of the society by members. Besides these two categories, exemption is also available for any document executed pursuant to awards, or orders of the Registrar or Arbitrators under the Co-op. Societies Act. Since petitioner's case is purchase of property from another co-op. society in liquidation proceedings, exemption from stamp duty is available under this limb of Ext. P1 notification also. Therefore the interpretation given by the Commissioner of Land Revenue in Ext. P3 on Ext. P1 notification is wrong and unsustainable. In the circumstances, O.P is allowed vacating Ext. P1 with direction to respondents to release the impounded document after registration to the petitioner immediately on production of a copy of this judgment
Alert