- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gem Granites v. State Of Kerala
Factual and Procedural Background
This batch of cases raises whether the State Government may demand "dead rent" under Rule 29(1)(d) of the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1967 for periods during which a minor lease remained idle. A learned Single Judge upheld the demand and dismissed the Original Petitions; the present appeals were filed challenging that outcome.
For disposal the court referred to facts in O.P. No. 630 of 1999 (challenged in W.A. No. 148 of 2003). The petitioner is a partnership concern engaged in quarrying and exporting granite. On 14.05.1996 the first respondent granted a quarrying lease for extraction of granite dimension stone to M/s Indus Granites over 6.7608 hectares for three years. The lease deed was executed on 29.05.1996.
M/s Indus Granites could not operate due to financial constraints and sold the land to the petitioner, who sought transfer of the lease. The Director of Mining and Geology transferred the lease to the petitioner by proceedings dated 9.5.1997 under Rule 34. The petitioner did not carry out quarrying operations between 29.05.1997 and 28.05.1998. A demand notice dated 25.6.1998 was issued by the third respondent for Rs. 45,648 as "dead rent" for that period under Rule 29(1)(d).
The petitioner challenged the demand by seeking declarations that Rule 29(1)(d) is ultra vires the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957 and violative of Article 14 when applied to patta land; the petitioner also sought a declaration that clause 22 of the lease deed dated 29.05.1996 is illegal and a writ of certiorari to quash the demand notice.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the State Government has power to demand "dead rent" under Rule 29(1)(d) of the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1967 for the period during which a minor (quarrying) lease was kept idle.
- Whether Rule 29(1)(d) is ultra vires the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957 or violative of Article 14 of the Constitution insofar as it is made applicable to patta land (i.e., where the surface owner is also the lessee).
- Whether a pattadar (surface landowner) holding surface rights can be required to pay dead rent in addition to or instead of royalty/seigniorage.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Petitioner)
- The concept of dead rent does not apply to patta land because dead rent represents a minimum royalty payable to the owner where mining permission is granted by the Government; it is premised on the Government as grantor, not on private surface ownership.
- So far as pattadar lands are concerned, payment of dead rent should not arise because the quarry operator is also the land owner; a pattadar cannot be required to pay anything other than the royalty or seigniorage fee payable in respect of minerals actually extracted.
- Section 9A of the Act indicates that "dead rent" relates to minimum fixed rate in cases of mining leases granted by the Government; levying dead rent on patta land beyond normal assessment is ultra vires the Act.
- Relied on the Division Bench decision in Kumaresan v. State of Tamil Nadu (I.L.R. 1994 (3) Madras 41) to support limits on retrospective enforcement of dead rent.
Respondent's Arguments (State / Government Pleader)
- Section 9 of the Kerala Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957 read with Rule 15(3) of the Rules makes the petitioner liable to pay either royalty or dead rent; dead rent provides a minimum guaranteed return to the State and incentivizes continuous working of the lease.
- The petitioner is only a pattadar with surface rights; minerals underneath the surface belong to the Government and therefore the State can demand dead rent when a competent quarrying lease exists.
- State power to fix and collect dead rent is conferred by Sections 15(3) and 25(2) of the Act; Rule 29(1)(d) specifically provides for the liability to pay dead rent.
- Reliance on the Madras decision in Kumaresan was misplaced; that decision concerned prospective enforceability from a specific government order and did not negate State power generally to demand dead rent.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of H.P. v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd., (2005) 6 SCC 499 | Elucidation of the meaning of "royalty" and "dead rent"; paragraphs 49–58 define "dead rent". | The court relied on this apex court decision for the accepted legal definitions and held that further elucidation was unnecessary; used the decision to distinguish dead rent (fixed return payable whether worked or not) from royalty (variable return tied to extraction). |
| D.K. Trivedi and Sons v. State of Gujarat, 1986 Supp SCC 20 | Earlier apex court authority distinguishing dead rent as fixed return and royalty as proportionate/variable return. | The State's characterization of dead rent as fixed and royalty as variable was supported by reference to this decision, as cited by the apex court in State of H.P. v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd. |
| Kumaresan v. State of Tamil Nadu, I.L.R. 1994 (3) Madras 41 | Madras Division Bench held that provisions demanding dead rent could be enforced only from the date of a government order (9.12.1988) that fixed the rate; thus enforcement was prospective. | The petitioner relied on this case; the Government argued and the court observed that Kumaresan was concerned with prospective enforcement from a specified date and did not generally preclude the State from demanding dead rent under appropriate rules. |
| Shibu v. Tahsildar, 1993 (2) KLT 870 (Division Bench of this Court) | Consideration and validation of the Maharajah of Travancore's proclamation (14.6.1881) vesting minerals in the sovereign (State). | The court treated the decision as conclusively holding that all minerals are vested in the Government of the State for lands in the erstwhile Travancore, supporting the State's power to charge dead rent. |
| Thressiamma Jacob v. District Office (Dept. of Mining & Geology), 2000 (2) KIT 162 (Full Bench) | Held that lands in the erstwhile Malabar area are not proprietary mineral owners (Ryotwari pattadars were not considered proprietors); minerals belong to Government and royalty must be paid for quarrying leases. | The court relied on this Full Bench decision to support the proposition that ownership of surface land does not confer ownership of minerals and to validate the State's entitlement to royalty/dead rent on such leases. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a structured statutory and precedent-driven manner:
- Identified the central statutory provisions: Section 9 and Section 9A of the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957, Section 15(3) empowering State rulemaking for minor minerals, and Rule 29(1)(d) of the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1967 which prescribes dead rent liability for lessees.
- Examined authoritative definitions of "dead rent" and "royalty" from the apex court's decision in State of H.P. v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd. The court quoted Wharton's Law Lexicon defining "dead rent" as a rent payable on a mining lease in addition to royalty, payable whether the mine is worked or not, and contrasted it with "royalty" being proportionate to the use or extraction.
- Recalled the legal history specific to the region: the Maharajah of Travancore's proclamation (14.6.1881) vesting minerals in the sovereign, and prior decisions of this court (Shibu and Thressiamma Jacob) holding that minerals in the erstwhile Travancore and Malabar areas are vested in the State. These authorities underpinned the position that surface ownership (patta) does not carry mineral ownership.
- Interpreted Section 15(3) and Rule 29(1)(d) together to show that the holder of a mining lease or other mineral concession is liable to pay royalty or dead rent, and that Rule 29(1)(d) specifically fixes yearly dead rent (except the first year) within limits and provides that where a lease permits working of a mineral the lessee shall be liable to pay dead rent or royalty whichever is higher but not both.
- Applied these principles to the facts: the petitioner held a competent quarrying lease under the Rules for the relevant land and thus fell within the class of persons liable under Rule 29(1)(d). The demand for dead rent for the period the lease remained idle (29.05.1997 to 28.05.1998) therefore rested on a valid statutory and rule-based foundation.
- Addressed the petitioner's contention that dead rent should not apply to patta land by affirming the distinction between surface ownership and mineral ownership; because minerals are vested in the State, a lessee who holds the quarrying lease is liable to pay dead rent irrespective of surface proprietorship.
- Considered the petitioner’s reliance on Kumaresan, noting that the Madras decision dealt with prospective enforceability from a specific government order and did not negate the broader statutory power of the State to fix and demand dead rent under rules framed under the Act.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: The Government has the power to demand "dead rent" as per Rule 29(1)(d) of the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1967 for the period during which a mining/quarrying lease is kept idle; accordingly, the appeals and writ petitions are dismissed.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The demand notice dated 25.6.1998 for Rs. 45,648 as dead rent issued to the petitioner under Rule 29(1)(d) stands; the petitioner is not entitled to the declarations or reliefs sought to quash that demand.
- The court affirmed that holding a competent quarrying lease under the Rules triggers liability under Rule 29(1)(d) even if the lease remains idle, and that surface ownership (patta) does not negate State entitlement to dead rent because minerals vest in the State.
The opinion does not indicate that it intended to lay down any novel or wider precedent beyond applying established statutory provisions and existing case law; it applied settled principles to the facts and dismissed the challenges.
K.S Radhakrishnan, A.C.J:— The question that is posed for consideration in this batch of cases is whether State Government has got power to demand dead rent as per R. 29(1)(d) of the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1967 for the period during which minor lease was kept idle. Learned single Judge found no infirmity in the demand and dismissed the Original Petitions. Aggrieved by the same these appeals have been preferred.
2. For disposal of these cases we will refer to the facts in O.P No. 630 of 1999 against which W.A No. 148 of 2003 was filed. Petitioner is a partnership concern carrying on business of quarrying and exporting granite. By proceedings dated 14.05.1996 first respondent granted quarrying lease for extraction of granite dimension stone of M/s. Indus Granites over an extent of 6.7608 hectares in survey numbers 122/1 and 122/2 of Vandanmedu village in Udumbanchola taluk in Idukki district for a period of three years.
3. Lease deed was executed in favour of M/s. Indus Granites on 29.05.1996 Indus Granites could not carry on quarrying operation in the above mentioned land due to financial constraints. Consequently they had sold the above mentioned property for valuable consideration to the petitioner and requested the third respondent to transfer the quarrying lease in favour of the petitioner. The Director of Mining and Geology by proceedings dated 9.5.1997 transferred the lease granted to M/s. Indus Granites over the above extent of land in favour of the petitioner as per R. 34 of the aforesaid Rules.
4. Petitioner however could not carry on the quarrying operation in the above mentioned land during the period from 29.05.1997 to 28.05.1998 Consequently demand notice dated 25.6.1998 was issued by the third respondent directing the petitioner to remit an amount of Rs. 45,648/- towards “dead rent” for the above mentioned period. Demand was made under R. 29(1)(d) of the Rules. Petitioner is aggrieved by the said demand and has preferred the Original Petition seeking a declaration that R. 29(1)(d) of the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1967 is ultra vires the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 and is violative of Art. 14 of the Constitution of India in so far as it is made applicable to patta land. Petitioner has also sought a declaration that clause 22 of the lease deed dated 29.05.1996 is illegal and without the authority of law and also for a writ of certiorari to quash the demand notice dated 25.6.1998
5. Counsel appearing for the petitioner Sri Joseph Kodianthara submitted that the concept of dead rent has no application to patta land since dead rent only represents the minimum royalty payable to the owner of the land in respect of lands which are the subject matter of the grant of mining permission. Counsel submitted so far as patta lands are concerned, payment of dead rent could not arise since the quarry operator is also the owner of the land. Counsel also submitted that S. 9A of the Act indicates that the word “dead rent” only relates to the minimum fixed rate in the case of mining leases granted by the Government and as rules originally stood, lessees are being called upon to pay apart from area assessment, seigniorage fee quantified on the basis of the mineral quarried or the dead rent quantified on the basis of the area of land leased whichever is higher so as to ensure a minimum royalty in relation to the land leased by the Government. Counsel also submitted that pattadar cannot be required to pay any amount other than the royalty or seigniorage fee payable in respect of the minerals exploited or won from the land and levy and collection of any other amount other than normal assessment in relation to patta land would be ultra vires the Act. Counsel placed considerable reliance on the decision of the Division Bench of the Madras High Court in Kumaresan v. State of Tamil Nadu (I.L.R 1994 (3) Madras 41).
6. Senior Government Pleader Sri T.R Ravi on the other hand contended that S. 9 of the Kerala Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957 read with R. 15(3) of the Rules framed thereunder makes the petitioner liable to pay either, royalty or dead rent. Counsel submitted that dead rent is envisaged to derive a minimum guaranteed return from the lessee for the lease granted to the minerals belonging to the State. Counsel submitted that the objective of the fixed rent is to ensure that the lessee will work at all times. Counsel submitted that petitioner is only a pattadar and is having only the surface right and the minerals underneath the surface belongs to the Government. Government Pleader submitted that the lands in question are also situated within the territorial limits of the erstwhile Travancore and therefore the petitioner is liable to pay the royalty or dead rent, not both, as the case may be. Further Government Pleader also submitted that the claim for dead rent for minor minerals is not made directly under S. 9-A of the Mines and Minerals (R & D) Act, 1957. State Government is empowered to fix and collect dead rent vide Ss. 15(3) and 25(2) of the Act and R. 29(1)(d) of the Kerala Minor Minerals Concession Rules, 1967 provides for the liability to pay the dead rent. Counsel submitted that the reliance placed on the decision of the Division Bench of the Madras High Court in Kumaresan's case, supra is misplaced. Counsel submitted that the Madras High Court has only held that the provisions in the Madras Rules demanding dead rent can be enforced only from the date of coming into force of the government order dated 9.12.1988 since there was no provision fixing the rate of dead rent until it was specifically provided for by the above Government order dated 9.12.1988 Counsel submitted that the Madras High Court has held that the demand for dead rent can be enforced only prospectively with effect from 9.12.1988
7. We heard counsel on either side at length and also examined the decisions cited at the bar. Meaning of the words “royalty” and “dead rent” occurring in the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957 has been elaborately considered by the apex court in State of H.P v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd. ((2005) 6 SCC 499) and hence requires no further elucidation. Apex court in paragraphs 49 to 58 of the above decision has succinctly defined the meaning of the expression “dead rent”. The court quoted the definition of “dead rent” given in Wharton's Law Lexicon as follows:
“Dead rent - A rent payable on a mining lease in addition to a royalty, so called because it is payable whether the mine is being worked or not.”
“Royalty” is a payment reserved by the grantor of a patent, lease of a mine or similar right, and payable proportionately to the use made of the right by the grantee. Referring to the earlier decision of the Apex Court in D.K Trivedi and Sons v. State of Gujarat, 1986 Supp SCC 20), the court pointed out that while dead rent is a fixed return to the lessor, royalty is a return which varies with the quantity of minerals extracted or removed.
8. Land in question lies in the erstwhile State of Travancore. State Government in the counter affidavit filed in O.P No. 630 of 1999 has stated that the Maharajah of Travancore by his proclamation dated 14.6.1881 irrespective of the tenure of land had vested all the minerals in its territory with the sovereign. Validity of the above proclamation was considered by a Division Bench of this Court in Shibu v. Tahsildar (1993 (2) KLT 870) and has conclusively held that all the minerals are vested with the Government of the State. Liability in respect of lands situated in the erstwhile Malabar area also came up for consideration before a Full Bench of this Court in Thressiamma Jacob v. District Office of the Department of Mining and Geology (2000 (2) KIT 162) and the court held that lands in question in the erstwhile Malabar area are in respect of Ryotwari Pattadars and the Ryotwari Pattadars were not considered as proprietors of the land. The court held that in so far as the lands in the erstwhile Malabar area are concerned the minerals belong to the Government and Royalty has to be paid to the Government for quarrying leases.
9. The above mentioned decisions rendered by this court would enable the Government to demand dead rent on minerals irrespective of its ownership. Ownership of the land or surface rights does not in any way suggest ownership of minerals lying underneath or sub surface rights. Owner of the land is bound to pay the dead rent. Land owner is never called upon to remit any amount simply because the land in his possession contained mineral deposit. Demand is made only when a person holds a quarrying lease as per the rules to extract the minor mineral which is vested in the State.
10. S. 9A of the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957 deals with dead rent to be paid by the lessee. S. 15 empowers the Government to make rules in respect of minor minerals. S. 15(3) is extracted below.
(3) The holder of a mining lease or any other mineral concession granted under any rule made under sub-s. (1) shall pay royalty or dead rent, whichever is more in respect of minor minerals removed or consumed by him or by his agent, manager, employee, contractor or sublessee at the rate prescribed for the time being in the rules framed by the State Government in respect of minor minerals.
11. R. 29(1)(d) fixes the liability for payment of dead rent on a lease holder which is extracted below for easy reference.
“(d) The lessee shall pay the State Government for every year except the first year of lease such yearly dead rent within the limits specified in Schedule II, as may be fixed from time to time by the State Government. Where the lease permits the working of any mineral, the lessee shall be liable to pay dead rent or royalty in respect of that mineral, whichever be higher in amount but not both:
Provided that where the lease permits the working of more than one mineral in the same area, the lessee shall be liable to pay dead rent or royalty in respect of each mineral subject to the restriction mentioned above in respect of any mineral.
Provided further that where the quarrying of one mineral involves the quarrying of any other mineral or minerals and lease permits the working of such other mineral or minerals also the lessee shall be liable to pay dead rent for only one mineral the highest dead rent being payable for this purpose in lieu of the combined royalty, if the latter is less than the former.
Petitioner, as we have already indicated, was served with demand notice under R. 29(1)(d) of the Rules, since the petitioner has obtained a competent quarrying lease in respect of the land in survey numbers 122/1 and 122/2 of Vandantnedu village, Udumbanchola taluk and the owner of the surface of the land as per the revenue register is Sri Thirumalai Varadarajan and M/s. Indus Granites had transferred the lease to the petitioner. Land owner was never called upon to the pay the amount simply because the land in his possession contained mineral deposit. Demand was made only when the petitioner had held the quarrying lease as per rules to extract the minor mineral which is vested in the State. We have already found that grounds raised by the petitioner against the demand for dead rent are not sustainable. We hold that the Government have got the power to demand “dead rent” as per R. 29(1)(d) of the Rules for the period during which the mining lease is kept idle. In such circumstances, we are inclined to dismiss all the appeals and Writ Petitions. We find no reason to grant the reliefs prayed for in the appeals and Writ Petitions.
Alert