- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Unit Trust Of India v. Indian Overseas Bank & Others
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This revision challenges the order of the Sub Court, Kottayam in I.A. No. 512 of 2000 in O.S. No. 455 of 1993. The revision petitioners are defendants 4 and 5 in the suit. The first respondent (the plaintiff bank) sued for recovery of amounts alleged due from defendants 1 and 2 who had availed a loan of Rs. 75,000 on 10-05-1990 and executed a demand promissory note promising payment on demand with interest at 17.5% per annum. As security, defendants 1 and 2 pledged a Unit Certificate issued by the revision petitioners (valued at Rs. 100,000). After default, the plaintiff sought to realise the certificate through Unit Trust of India (the fifth defendant). The plaintiff alleged interpolation of the authorization in favour of the bank and that Unit Trust of India issued cheques credited to defendants 1 and 2, who withdrew proceeds. The plaintiff sued for recovery (plaint claimed Rs. 1,24,636/-).
The revision petitioners were represented in the lower court but were later declared ex parte and a decree was passed on 30-11-1995. The decree holder filed execution (E.R. No. 177 of 1997). On notice in the execution petition, the revision petitioners filed I.A. No. 510 of 2000 (to set aside the ex parte decree) and I.A. No. 512 of 2000 (to condone delay in filing I.A. No. 510). The court below dismissed I.A. No. 512, and consequently I.A. No. 510 was dismissed. The revision petition challenges the dismissal of I.A. No. 512.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the court below erred in dismissing the application (I.A. No. 512 of 2000) to condone the delay in filing the petition to set aside the ex parte decree (I.A. No. 510 of 2000).
- Whether, applying the test under Section 5 of the Limitation Act (the concept of "sufficient cause"), the delay in filing the application to set aside the ex parte decree can be condoned in view of the facts alleged (including counsel's inaction and alleged fraud by other parties).
- Whether condonation of delay should be made subject to conditions (specifically imposition of costs) given the competing equities between the revision petitioners and the decree-holders/respondents.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioners' Arguments
- Learned counsel for the revision petitioners contended that the reason given by the court below for dismissing the petition to condone delay was not justifiable.
- There are sufficient reasons stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition for condoning the delay (more than four years) in filing the petition to set aside the ex parte decree.
- The fact that the revision petitioner is a public limited company does not, by itself, justify refusing condonation of delay.
- Affidavit evidence and witness testimony (PW1 and PW2) indicate that the petitioners were unaware of the ex parte decree until they received notice in the execution petition, and that their counsel had not informed them of the order (counsel had left India and the junior refused to move to set aside the decree), implying laches on the part of counsel rather than the petitioners themselves.
The opinion does not present a detailed, separate statement of the respondents' counter-arguments in opposition to condonation; the respondents' factual case (plaint) and evidence are described in the background and in the court's analysis.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ram Nath Sao alias Ram Nath Sabu v. Gobardhan Sao ((2002) 3 SCC 195 : AIR 2002 SC 1201) | Construction of "sufficient cause" under Section 5 of the Limitation Act — the expression should receive a liberal construction to advance substantial justice; courts should not adopt a fault-finding, pedantic approach and should weigh resultant effects on parties; acceptance of explanation should be the rule where no negligence, inaction or want of bona fides is imputable. | The court applied the principle to conclude that the petitioners' explanation (including laches by counsel and officers and circumstances alleged) constituted sufficient cause to condone the delay, subject to payment of costs, and thus set aside the impugned order dismissing the condonation application. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by examining the factual matrix and the procedural history relevant to condonation of delay:
- Factual findings: The court reiterated admitted facts — defendants 1 and 2 took a loan secured by a UTI certificate issued by the revision petitioners; defendants 1 and 2 defaulted; the plaintiff alleged interpolation/forgery by Unit Trust of India (fifth defendant) and that cheques were issued and credited to defendants 1 and 2 and withdrawn.
- Procedural posture: Revision petitioners had been represented before the lower court but were ultimately declared ex parte and a decree issued. They later moved to set aside the ex parte decree (I.A. No. 510) and filed a condonation application (I.A. No. 512) which the lower court dismissed.
- Evidence on notice and counsel conduct: The court considered affidavits and the testimony of witnesses (PW1 and PW2). PW1 stated that upon service of summons the revision petitioners engaged counsel but were not aware of the ex parte decree until they received notice in the execution petition; on contacting counsel, they were told the counsel had left India and the junior refused to apply to set aside the decree. PW2 (representative of the fifth respondent) similarly stated that the counsel handling the case had not informed about the posting or the ex parte decree until notice of execution was received. The court treated these factual assertions as relevant to explain the delay.
- Application of legal standard: The court applied the guiding principle laid down by the Apex Court in Ram Nath Sao (cited) concerning the liberal construction of "sufficient cause" under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. The court emphasized that sufficiency depends on the facts of each case, that courts should not adopt a hyper-technical approach, and that acceptance of explanation should be the rule rather than the exception where no negligence or want of bona fides is imputable to the defaulting party.
- Balancing competing interests: The court acknowledged that the petitioners' status (public limited company) alone could not justify condonation of long delay, and that the respondents had suffered difficulties and incurred expenses. Therefore, while the court found the petitioners' explanations sufficient to justify condonation, it imposed a condition to protect the respondents' position — payment of costs of Rs. 3,000.
- Outcome-oriented directive: On these bases the court set aside the impugned dismissal of I.A. No. 512, condoned the delay on the condition of costs being paid within one month, and directed the trial court to take I.A. No. 510 on file and consider it afresh.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: THE CIVIL REVISION PETITION IS ALLOWED; the delay in filing the petition to set aside the ex parte decree is condoned subject to payment of costs.
Direct consequences and orders made by the court (as stated in the opinion):
- The impugned order dismissing I.A. No. 512 of 2000 is set aside.
- The delay in filing the petition to set aside the ex parte decree (I.A. No. 510 of 2000) is condoned, conditional on the petitioners depositing Rs. 3,000 as costs with the trial court within one month.
- The court below (trial court) is directed to take I.A. No. 510 of 2000 on file and consider it afresh.
- The Civil Revision Petition is allowed.
The opinion does not purport to lay down any novel legal principle; it applies the established principle from Ram Nath Sao regarding liberal construction of "sufficient cause" and balances equities by imposing costs. No new precedent is stated to have been created by this decision.
1. This revision petition is filed by a public limited company against the order passed by the Sub Court, Kottayam in I.A No. 512 of 2000 in O.S No. 455 of 1993. The revision petitioners are defendants 4 and 5 in the suit. The suit was filed by the first respondent for realisation of an amount of Rs. 1,27,984/- from the defendants. As per the plaint averments, the plaintiff wanted to realise the amount due from defendants 1 and 2. Defendants 1 and 2 availed a loan of Rs. 75,000.from the first respondent bank, plaintiff in the suit, for domestic purpose on 10-5-1990, on executing a demand promissory note in favour of the plaintiff, promising to pay off the said amount on demand with interest at the rate of 17.5% per annum. It is also averred in the plaint that as security for the loan, defendants 1 and 2 secured Unit Certificate No. 872307690 of the revision petitioners, valued for Rs. One lakh as constituted by 1000 units of Rs. 100/- each. Since defendants 1 and 2 made default in repayment of the loan amount, the plaintiff bank informed the matter to the revision petitioners. Thereafter, the Certificate pledged by defendants 1 and 2 along with Authorisation Letter were forwarded to Unit Trust of India, Madras, 5th defendant, under registered post requesting them to re-purchase the units and to remit the proceeds to the plaintiff bank for liquidating the outstandings in the loan account of defendants 1 and 2. The authorisation made in favour of the plaintiff by defendants 1 and 2 was witnesses by the plaintiffs Assistant Manager and another senior staff. Since the proceeds were not forthcoming from the fifth defendant, the plaintiff reminded them on various dates such as 23-4-1991, 4-8-1991, 15-4-1992 and 19-5-1992. Even after the reminders, there was no reply from the fifth defendant or any remittance of proceeds by them. Hence, the then Senior Manager of the plaintiff visited the office of the fifth defendant at Madras and it was found that the authorisation made in favour of Indian Overseas Bank was scored of cross-wise and the name of Canara Bank, Kottayam, the sixth defendant, with Savings Bank Account No. 21094/37 was interpolated.
2. Defendants 1 and 2 were introduced to the plaintiff by Mr. Aniyan Athikayam, the third defendant. He is the father of the second defendant Mrs. Anitha Abraham John. Mr. Aniyan Athikayam is dealing with the plaintiff for the past several years and he is credit worthy also. The plaintiff informed the above incidents to the third defendant and he promised to adjust the account shortly. Hence, for the definite repayment of the loan with interest, on 29-09-1992 he executed a Guarantee letter in favour of the plaintiff guaranteeing the payment of all monies which shall at any time thereafter during the continuance of the said guarantee be due from defendants 1 and 2. Since the authorisation/endorsement was witnesses by the plaintiffs Assistant Manager and another senior staff with IOB Address, that portion is seen left undisturbed. Since no authentication or alteration was made by the plaintiff, the interpolation was made by the Unit Trust of India, Madras, the fifth defendant, within the connivance of defendants 1 and 2 for getting unlawful gain. It was further understood that the Unit Trust of India, Madras had issued four cheques numbering 20/4188 to 4191 for Rs. 23,000/- each and despatched on 7-2-1992 vide registered post. The cheques were drawn on Canara bank, Kottayam marked payable at par in the name of the beneficiaries, namely, defendants 1 and 2, quoting SB Account No. 21094/37. Only to establish the said fact, Canara Bank, Kottayam is made a formal party in this suit. It was further understood from Canara Bank, Kottayam, the sixth defendant, that the four cheques referred above amounting to Rs. One lakh were credited in defendants 1 and 2's SB Account No. 21094/37 on 12.2.1992 and the proceeds were withdrawn by defendants 1 and 2. Since Unit Trust of India, Madras, the fifth defendant has also joined in committing fraud, fourth and fifth defendants are jointly and severally liable for the plaint amount along with defendants 1, 2 and 3. Hence the plaintiff Bank filed the suit for recovery of a total amount of Rs. 1,24,636/- as the amount outstanding in the name of defendants 1 and 2.
3. The revision petitioners being entrusted with the Certificates, they were made parties to the suit. The revision petitioners were represented before the lower court by counsel. But the revision petitioners were declared exparte and a decree against the revision petitioners and other defendants was passed on 30-11-1995. The decree holder filed E.R No. 177 of 1997 in O.S No. 455 of 1993 for execution of the decree. On receiving notice in the execution petition, the revision petitioners filed I.A No. 510 of 2000 for setting aside the exparte decree and I.A No. 512 of 2000 for condoning the delay in filing the petition for setting aside the exparte decree. I.A No. 512 of 2000 was dismissed by the court below. Consequently, I.A No. 510 of 2000 was also dismissed. Against the dismissal of I.A No. 512 of 2000, the revision petitioners filed this revision.
4. Learned counsel for the revision petitioners submits that the reason stated by the court below for dismissing the petition for condoning the delay in filing the petition to set aside the exparte decree is not justifiable. There are sufficient reasons stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition for condoning the delay of more than four years in filing the application for setting aside the exparte decree. The fact that the revision petitioner institution is a public limited company by itself is not a ground for condoning the long delay occurred in filing the application for setting aside the exparte decree.
5. Admittedly, defendants 1 and 2 had taken loan from the first respondent Bank on securing UTI Certificate worth Rs. One lakh and defendants 1 and 2 made default in repayment of the loan amount. It is also to be noted that the Certificate issued by the revision petitioners was valid and alive till it was forwarded for encashment. But defendants 1 and 2 committed fraud and cheated the Bank with the connivance and consent of some of the officers of the revision petitioners. That apart it is stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition for condonation of delay that the counsel appearing for the revision petitioners had not informed the revision petitioners about the order passed by the court below. In this context evidence of PW1 is relevant PW1 stated before Court that when summons were served on the revision petitioners, they engaged counsel. PW1 had given further evidence to the effect that till the date of receipt of notice in the execution petition the revision petitioners were not aware of the exparte decree. When they contacted the counsel at Kottayam on receipt of notice in the execution petition, it was informed that the counsel left India and his junior refused to file an application for setting aside the exparte decree. It is also to be noted that the evidence given by PW2, who is representative of the fifth respondent, is that the counsel to whom the case was entrusted has not informed anything about the posting of the case or about the exparte decree passed by the court below till notice was received in the execution petition. Because of the laches occurred on the part of the counsel or some of the officers of the revision petitioners the grievance of the revision petitioners cannot be brushed aside. It is to be noted that the Apex Court as per the judgment in Ram Nath Sao alias Ram Nath Sabu v. Gobardhan Sao ((2002) 3 SCC 195 : AIR 2002 SC 1201) held that while considering an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act the Court should see that there are sufficient reasons to condone the delay in filing the application for setting aside the exparte order. The expression ‘sufficient cause’ stated in Section 5 of the Limitation Act could be interpreted as “sufficient cause to administer justice or to mitigate the grievance of the petitioner” and sufficiency of the reasons or cause could be interpreted from the facts and reasons stated in the application for invoking the judicial discretion of the court under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. The Apex Court further stated as follows:
“11. Thus it becomes plain that the expression” sufficient cause” within the meaning of Section 5 of the Act or Order 22 Rule 9 of the Code or any other similar provision should receive a liberal construction so as to advance substantial justice when no negligence or inaction or want of bona fide is imputable to a party. In a particular case whether explanation furnished would constitute “sufficient cause” or not will be dependent upon facts of each case. There cannot be a straitjacket formula for accepting or rejecting explanation furnished for the delay caused in taking steps. But one thing is clear that the Courts should not proceed with the tendency of finding fault with the cause shown and reject the petition by a slipshod order in over jubilation of disposal drive. Acceptance of explanation furnished should be the rule and refusal an exception more so when no negligence or inaction or want of bona fide can be imputed to the defaulting party. On the other hand, while considering the matter the Courts should not lose sight of the fact that by not taking steps within the time prescribed a valuable right has accrued to the other party which should not be lightly defeated by condoning delay in a routine like manner. However, by taking a pedantic and hyper technical view of the matter the explanation furnished should not be rejected when stakes are high and/or arguable points of facts and law are involved in the case, causing enormous loss and irreparable injury to the party against whom the lis terminates either by default or inaction and defeating valuable right of such a party to have the decision on merit. While considering the matter, Courts have to strike a balance between resultant effect of the order it is going to pass upon the parties either way.”
6. Considering the entire facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the View that the delay occurred in filing the application for setting aside the exparte decree can be condoned. However, only on the reason that the matter is of so importance and the revision petitioners are public officers, it is not possible to take a view in favour of them ignoring the difficulties and undue expenses met by the respondents. Hence the delay can be condoned to payment of cost of Rs. 3,000/- and this Court ordered accordingly. Consequently, the impugned order is set aside and the delay in filing the petition for setting aside the exparte decree is condoned. The court below shall take is file the petition to set aside the exparte decree, I.A No. 510 of 2000, and consider the same afresh. The cost now ordered by this Court shall be deposited by the petitioners before the trial court within one month from today.
7. The Civil Revision Petition is allowed.
Alert