Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Administrator, U.T Of Lakshadweep v. Musthak

Kerala High Court
Apr 1, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (K.A. Abdul Gafoor, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Administration of the Union Territory of Lakshadweep (petitioner) challenged a common order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Kochi Bench (Ext. P7), by filing Original Petitions. The recruitment exercise at issue concerned Lower Division (L.D.) Clerks.

Key factual points found in the opinion:

  • There were 39 vacancies of L.D. Clerks reported to the Employment Exchange.
  • The Employment Exchange recommended 425 candidates; the recruitment included written and practical (typing) tests and a prescribed typing speed.
  • A rank list containing 164 names was produced; appointment orders were issued to 40 candidates (including two physically handicapped candidates).
  • Candidates who failed the typing test challenged the recruitment in several Original Applications before the Tribunal, contending that a list of 164 candidates should be treated as the select list to be operated for appointments.
  • The Tribunal disposed of earlier O.As by directing that a list (A-1 in O.A. 446/95) containing 164 names be treated as the select list and that appointments be made from that select list (Ext. P4). The Administration's review was dismissed (Ext. P5).
  • The Administration subsequently cancelled the list; the cancellation was challenged and disposed of by the Tribunal as per Ext. P7, which directed that the A-2 list be operated as a select list and restrained fresh selection unless the list was exhausted or cancelled, fixing its validity for three years and assuming a reference date of 18.4.94 for the list.
  • The Administration contested Ext. P7 before this court; the petition seeks to quash the Tribunal's direction to operate the select list for vacancies beyond those notified to the Employment Exchange.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal (in Ext. P7) could direct the Administration to operate a select list so as to make appointments for vacancies in excess of those notified to the Employment Exchange.
  2. Whether inclusion of a candidate's name in a select list confers an enforceable right to appointment for vacancies arising after the vacancies that were originally notified.
  3. Whether operating a select list to fill vacancies beyond those notified offends Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution (equality and equality of opportunity in public employment).
  4. Whether the Tribunal was correct in fixing a period of validity for the A-2 list and directing its operation for existing and future vacancies up to the fixed period.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (Administration of the Union Territory of Lakshadweep) — Arguments

  • Only 39 vacancies were reported to the Employment Exchange; the Administration was not liable to follow or operate a list for vacancies beyond those notified.
  • Even if the list contained 164 candidates, mere inclusion in a select list does not confer a right to appointment.
  • The Tribunal's direction in Ext. P7 to follow the list and make appointments for vacancies beyond those notified was impermissible and bad.
  • Appointments made in excess of notified vacancies would deprive other aspiring candidates of rights under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
  • Counsel cited decisions including Ashok Kumar v. Chairman, Banking Service Recruitment Board; Sanjoy Bhattacharjee v. Union of India; Madan Lai v. State of J. & K.; and Kerala Agricultural University v. Gopinathan Unnithan in support of these contentions.

Respondents (Applicants before the Tribunal) — Arguments

  • The Administration could not now contest the findings in Ext. P4 and the dismissal of the review (Ext. P5); Ext. P4 had found that the Administration's list contained 164 candidates, and that finding was binding.
  • There was no evidence before the Tribunal to show that only 39 vacancies had been reported to the Employment Exchange; thus, the Administration cannot insist that appointments stop at 40 while the list contains more names.
  • The Administration's cancellation of the list was an attempt to avoid or frustrate the valid findings of the Tribunal and was mala fide.
  • Therefore, the Tribunal's directions in Ext. P7 to quash A-1 and operate A-2 (treating A-2 as select list) were justified and should not be interfered with by this Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ashok Kumar v. Chairman, Banking Service Recruitment Board, (1996) 1 SCC 283 Operation of a select list to fill up more vacancies than were notified offends the rights under Article 16 and the equality principle; a select list cannot be applied to vacancies over and above those verified at the time of preparation. The court relied on Ashok Kumar to hold that the Tribunal erred in directing appointments from the select list to fill more vacancies than were notified to the Employment Exchange; such operation would violate rights under Arts. 14 and 16.
Sanjoy Bhattacharjee v. Union of India, (1997) 4 SCC 283 : AIR 1997 SC 2179 The list prepared cannot be made operative for vacancies that had arisen subsequently (i.e., a select list cannot be enforced for later vacancies beyond those for which the list was prepared). The court treated this decision as confirming the principle that a select list cannot be enforced for subsequent vacancies and used it to support the conclusion that Ext. P7 was erroneous in directing appointments for vacancies beyond those notified.
Madan Lai v. State of J. & K., (1995) 3 SCC 486 Similar effect: select lists cannot be enforced to fill vacancies arising after the notified vacancies; reinforces the principle limiting the enforceability of select lists. The court cited Madan Lai as being to the same effect as Ashok Kumar and Sanjoy Bhattacharjee to conclude that the Tribunal's direction to make appointments for more vacancies than notified was wrong.
Kerala Agricultural University v. Gopinathan Unnithan, 1996 (1) KLT 344 High Court should not issue a writ of mandamus directing appointment of a candidate simply because the candidate is included in a select list; select list inclusion does not create a legal right to appointment (citing State Of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty). The court relied upon this decision (and the authorities it cites) to emphasize that inclusion in a select list alone does not entitle a candidate to an absolute right to appointment and that mandating such appointments by writ is improper.
State Of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty (Smt), (1986) 4 SCC 632 : AIR 1987 SC 331 Authority for the proposition that a candidate included in a select list has no legal right to the post and that courts exercising writ jurisdiction should not issue mandamus directing appointment from a select list. Quoted within the discussion of Kerala Agricultural University; the court used this authority to reinforce that mere inclusion in a select list does not create a right enforceable by mandamus and to deny that the Tribunal could compel appointments beyond notified vacancies.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the factual findings recorded earlier by the Tribunal (Ext. P4) and the contentions advanced in Ext. P7 and the present petitions. The analysis unfolded in the following steps:

  1. Fact-finding from Ext. P4: The Tribunal had called for the rank list and found that a rank list containing 164 names was produced; the letters produced suggested the notified vacancies were 39. The court expressly relied on this extract from Ext. P4 to conclude that the notified vacancies were 39.
  2. Legal principle regarding the validity and application of select lists: The court observed that no statutory provision prescribing any period of validity for a select list was pointed out by either party, and therefore a select list is necessarily applicable only to the vacancies that were notified and for which the recruitment process commenced.
  3. Precedential support: The court examined and applied precedents (Ashok Kumar; Sanjoy Bhattacharjee; Madan Lai; Kerala Agricultural University and State Of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty) which establish that (a) operating a select list to fill more vacancies than were originally notified violates Article 16 and the equality principle, and (b) inclusion in a select list does not create a legal right to appointment enforceable by mandamus.
  4. Application to the present facts: Given the Tribunal's own earlier finding (Ext. P4) that the notified vacancies were 39, the court concluded that the Tribunal went into error in Ext. P7 by directing appointment to more vacancies than those notified from the select list. The Tribunal cannot direct appointments of persons included in such a list for vacancies that had not been notified at the time the list was prepared and for which the recruitment process had not commenced.
  5. On the Administration's prior appointment of 40 persons (including a physically handicapped candidate): the court rejected the respondents' argument that the Administration's having appointed 40 persons estopped the Administration from asserting that only 39 vacancies were notified. The court held that any illegality (if appointments beyond notified vacancies had occurred) could not be perpetuated to the detriment of others who might have rights to subsequently notified vacancies.
  6. Conclusion: Relying on the factual finding about the 39 notified vacancies and legal precedents restricting the enforceability of select lists beyond notified vacancies, the court found that Ext. P7's direction to operate the select list for additional vacancies was erroneous.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The court SET ASIDE the impugned order Ext. P7 and allowed the Original Petitions accordingly.

Immediate implications (direct effect on the parties):

  • The Tribunal's direction to operate the A-2 select list so as to make appointments for vacancies beyond those notified (as recorded in Ext. P7) has been quashed.
  • The Administration is not bound by the Tribunal's direction in Ext. P7 to make appointments in respect of vacancies that were not notified to the Employment Exchange when the recruitment process commenced.
  • The court reaffirmed that inclusion in a select list does not, by itself, create a legal right to appointment for subsequently arising vacancies, and that appointments beyond notified vacancies are susceptible to challenge under Articles 14 and 16.

Broader precedent: The decision applies existing precedents to the facts and does not purport to lay down a new principle beyond the authorities cited; the court's decision follows and applies earlier authoritative statements limiting the enforceability of select lists.

Show all summary ...

K.A Abdul Gafoor, J.:— These Original Petitions were filed by the Administration of Union Territory of Lakshadweep impuging a common order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Kochi Bench, Ext. P7. Few facts are necessary for disposal of these cases. Those are as follows:

2. There were 39 vacancies of L.D Clerks in the service of the petitioner Administration. The vacancies were reported to the Employment Exchange in the Union Territoiy. The Employment Exchange recommended altogether 425 candidates. The recruitment process includes written and typing test. A minimum prescribed speed in typewriting was also essential for appointment. All the candidates were issued with intimations to participate in the said tests. All of them were subjected to both the tests. Those who had passed in the practical test as well as the written test were ranked in the top of the list. All others were also included in the list. Appointment orders were issued to 40 candidates altogether, two among them being physically handicapped candidates. There upon the contesting respondents in this cases who were sponsored by the Employment Exchange, but did not succeed in the typing test approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, contending that there was a list of altogether 164 candidates, who shall be appointed to the available, existing and ensuing vacancies. There was a dispute raised by the Administration that the list produced by the said respondents before the Tribunal in O.A No. 1521/94 and connected cases was not the rank list. Any how, the said O. As were disposed of as per Ext. P4 with certain directions, considering the list produced by the said respondents containing 164 names, as the select list. The directions issued were as follows:

“We direct respondent:

a) to treat A-1 in O.A 446/95 as the select list.

b) to make appointments from that select list in the order in which the candidates are ranked or till the list is cancelled.

c) not to make a fresh selection and make appointments unless A-1 in O.A 446/95 is exhausted or cancelled.

3. We further direct the Administration to publish the number of vacancies existing and anticipated in all cases in future so that rank arbitrariness or allegations of the rank are eliminated. We express our displeasure at the manner in which pleadings are drawn up and the manner in which two lists are maintained, calling one the select list and calling the other the rank list and making appointment from the rank list outside the select list, at once arguing that an appointment cannot be made except from the select list We allow the application to the extent here-in-before mentioned.”

4. The petitioner Administration attempted review application. It was also dismissed as seen from Ext. P5. There upon the Administration cancelled the list so that the list could not be operated in terms of Ext. P4 order of the Tribunal. This cancellation has been challenged again by the said respondents in O.A 869/96 and connected cases, which were disposed of as per the impugned order Ext. P7. Ext. P7 directed the petitioner Administration as follows:

“In the light of the discussion above, we consider that there are two options available to the respondents, namely, either to cancel the select list A. 2 in these applications in its entirety or to operate A-2 to the extent vacancies are available treating the entire A. 2 list as the select list as directed by the Tribunal in O.A 1521/94. We accordingly allow these applications and quash A. 1 in these applications. We further declare that respondents shall not hold a fresh test for selection to the post of Lower Division Clerks and similar grades for the existing and future vacancies without exhausting the select list A. 2. The period of validity of A2 will be fixed as three years as prayed for in prayer (iii) and all vacancies which have arisen before 18.4.97 in the Lower Division Clerk and similar grades will be filled by operating A. 2 select list (since the select list was never published, the date of A. 2 is not known), we are assuming the date of 18.4.94 for the select list which is the date on which appointment orders were issued to the first 34 persons in A. 2 list. We also have taken into account the fact that no selections have been held from 1993 till 18.4.1997 and so, no prospective applicants for the posts would be adversely affected, if the select list is operated upon till 18.4.1997”

5. It is contended that this direction could not have been issued by the Tribunal, as only 39 vacancies have been reported. Even if the list contained 164 candidates as contended by the said respondents, the administration did not have the liability to follow the list for the vacancies, over and above those notified to the Employment Exchange. It is further submitted that, even if one's name is included in the select list he does not acquire any right of appointment Therefore, the direction of the Tribunal in Ext P7 to follow the list and to effect appointment is bad. It is further submitted that any appointment in excess of the notified vacancies will result in deprivation of the rights guaranteed under Art. 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, to other candidates who may aspire for the subsequent vacancies, that may arise in future. In this regard, the learned counsel for the petitioner cited the decisions reported in Ashok Kumar v. Chairman, Banking Service Recruitment Board, (1996) 1 SCC 283, Sanjoy Bhattaeharjee v. Union of India, (1997) 4 SCC 283 : AIR 1997 SC 2179, Madan Lai v. State of J. & K., (1995) 3 SCC 486 and Kerala Agricultural University v. Gopinathan Unnithan (1996 (1) KLT 344).

6. It is submitted by the counsel for the said respondents, the applicants before the tribunal below that, the administration cannot now put forth contentions as aforesaid in the light of the binding findings contained in Ext P4 and dismissal of review application filed by them as per Ext P5. It has been found by the Tribunal that the list prepared by the petitioner administration contained 164 candidates. Necessarily that list has to be followed. There is no evidence to show that only 39 vacancies had been reported to the Employment Exchange. Even if that contention is taken as true, the administration themselves had appointed admittedly 40 candidates. Therefore, they cannot contend that they will stop the appointment with 40 and will not operate the list to the vacancies that had arisen later. The attempt of the administration to cancel the list which was found as to be followed in Ext. P4, has really the effect of avoiding the finding by a lawful authority. It is mala fide. So there is no reason for any interference from the hands of this court, they submit.

7. Ext. P4 discloses as follows:

“It is argued by applicants that here was no select list and that appointments have been made in an irregular manner. We called for the rank list and that was produced and it contains 164 names. Incidently, applicants have produced a copy of the same list without authentication as A-1 in OA. 446/95. Besides the rank list, standing counsel for respondents produced a manuscript, of what is described as notification F. No. 12/13/94—services signed by Secretary Administration bearing the date 9.3.94 It contains 39 names. We had also called for the communication to the Employment Exchange to ascertain the number of vacancies. The letters produced suggest that the notified vacancies were 39.”

8. In the light of this finding relied on by the said respondents themselves, it cannot be contended that more vacancies were reported.

9. No provision has been brought to our notice by either side prescribing any period of validity of a list prepared for appointment Necessarily, the list will be applicable only for the vacancies notified, for which the recruitment process commenced. In the decision reported in Ashok Kumar v. Chairman, Banking Service Recruitment Board, (1996) 1 SCC 283, the Apex court has clearly held that, operation of a select list prepared, after verifying the number of vacancies, to fill up more vacancies than notified will offend the rights of others under Art. 16 of the Constitution. In other words it will violate the equality clause enshrined in the Constitution. This court also had again considered that aspect with respect to the appointment in Agricultural University in Kerala Agricultural University v. Gopinathan Unnithan (1996 (1) KLT 344). Para 10 there of reads as follows:

“Learned Single Judge has issued a writ of mandamus directing the Agricultural University to appoint the petitioner as Professor in Agricultural Statistics. It is trite law that this court in exercise of the powers under Art. 226 of the Constitution is not to issue a writ of mandamus directing the appointment of a candidate who is included in the select list. In State Of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty (Smt) ((1986) 4 SCC 632 : AIR 1987 SC 331), Their Lordships after stating that a candidate who is included in the select list has no legal right to the post held that the High Court in exercise of the powers in Art. 226 of the Constitution, cannot issue a writ of mandamus directing the authorities to make the appointment. In view of this statement of law, the learned single Judge was clearly in error in issuing a writ of mandamus directing the University to appoint the petitioner against the third vacancy of Professor in Agricultural Statistics, that arose on a subsequent date.”

10. The dictum in Ashok Kumar's case has been followed by this court and held that more vacancies than that notified cannot be filled up, enforcing the list so prepared, as it will offend the rights of others under Arts. 14 and 16 of the Constitution. In the decision reported in Sanjoy Bhattacharjee v. Union of India, ((1997) 4 SCC 283 : AIR 1997 SC 2179) the Supreme Court has also made it clear that the list prepared cannot be made operative for the vacancies that had arisen subsequently. The dictum laid down in the decision reported in Madanan Lai v. State of J. & K., (1995) 3 SCC 486) is also almost to the same effect. When it is discernible from Ext. P4 order of the Tribunal quoted and relied on by the said respondents themselves that, only 39 vacancies alone had been notified to the employment Exchange, the Tribunal went in error in directing appointment to more vacancies than notified, from out of the select list made mention of in Ext. P4. The tribunal also cannot direct appointment of persons included in such list. Ext. P4 was found to be binding on the petitioner administration, to the effect that the list prepared by them contained 164 persons. Even then they did not have the liability to appoint more persons than the number of vacancies notified. Merely because they have appointed fourty persons, for which they have the excuse that 40th person was also a physically handicapped person, the said respondents cannot contend that such illegality, if any, shall always be perpetuated. If we do so, It will really violate the right of others who are aspiring for further appointment to the vacancies yet to be notified. Accordingly, we are of the view that the Tribunal went wrong in issuing direction as contained in para 10 of the impugned order, Ext. P7.

11. Accordingly, we set aside the impugned order. Original Petitions are allowed accordingly.