- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kunhiraman v. Kumaran
Factual and Procedural Background
The case concerns an eviction petition filed by a landlord under Section 11(4)(iii) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, which regulates leasing, prevents unreasonable eviction of tenants, and controls rents. The Rent Control Court and Appellate Authority ordered eviction on the ground that the tenant was already in possession of another building reasonably sufficient for his requirement. The tenant challenged this eviction order, contending that the courts below misunderstood the scope of Section 11(4)(iii), leading to an erroneous conclusion. The revision petition was filed under Section 20 of the Act to contest the eviction order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the courts below correctly applied Section 11(4)(iii) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, in ordering eviction on the ground that the tenant possessed another building reasonably sufficient for his requirement.
- Whether possession of another building by the tenant, which is reasonably sufficient for his requirement, justifies eviction under Section 11(4)(iii).
- What is the burden of proof on the landlord and tenant regarding possession and sufficiency of other premises under Section 11(4)(iii).
Arguments of the Parties
Tenant's Arguments
- The courts below misunderstood the scope and ambit of Section 11(4)(iii), leading to an erroneous eviction order.
- The tenant is willing to pay a monthly rent of Rs. 750/- from 1.3.2004 onwards.
- The tenant may have put up or possess another building but may not be in actual occupation due to legitimate reasons such as financial constraints or leasing it out to repay loans, which should be considered.
Landlord's Arguments
- The tenant is already in possession of another building reasonably sufficient for his requirement in the same locality, justifying eviction under Section 11(4)(iii).
- The rent of the tenanted building is considerably low, implying the tenant does not require the premises for occupation.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Pakran v. Kunhiraman Nambiar, 2004 (1) KLT 824 | Scope of revisional jurisdiction under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act being wider than revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 CPC. | Used to establish the Court’s authority to examine whether the lower courts correctly applied Section 11(4)(iii) in the facts of the case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the provisions of Section 11(4)(iii), which allows eviction if the tenant possesses another building reasonably sufficient for his requirement in the same city, town, or village at the time of the eviction petition. The Court emphasized the burden of proof lies on the landlord to prima facie establish possession and sufficiency of the alternate building. The tenant may rebut this by showing non-possession or insufficiency.
The Court examined the evidence, including the Commission Report and lease deed, to assess the condition and usability of the tenanted premises and the building allegedly in possession of the tenant. The Commission’s detailed observations revealed the tenanted premises were in poor condition but the alternate building was also found to be squalid and closed, used as a godown rather than a residence or suitable accommodation.
Comparing the premises, the Court concluded that the building possessed by the tenant was not reasonably sufficient in terms of extent or convenience. The Court found a misreading of evidence by the lower authorities in granting eviction. It also noted the tenant’s willingness to pay rent at a specified rate.
Accordingly, the Court set aside the eviction order under Section 11(4)(iii), holding that the landlord failed to establish the tenant’s possession of a reasonably sufficient alternate building.
Holding and Implications
The revision petition is allowed, and the eviction order passed under Section 11(4)(iii) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, is set aside.
The tenant is directed to pay rent at the rate of Rs. 750/- per month from 1.3.2004 onwards. The landlord retains the right to seek fixation of fair rent beyond this amount by approaching the Rent Control Court.
This decision directly affects the parties by restoring the tenant's possession and setting the rent payable but does not establish any new precedent beyond the application of existing legal principles under the Act.
K.S Radhakrishnan, J.:— The object and purpose of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 is to regulate the leasing of the buildings, prevention of unreasonable eviction of tenants and for the control of rents. The provision of the Rent Control Act has given an overriding effect by employing the non obstante clause in S. 11 of the Act. S. 11(4)(iii) has been enacted so as to enable a landlord to seek eviction. Rent Control Court and Appellate Authority in the instant case ordered eviction on the ground that the tenant is already having in his possession a building reasonably sufficient for his requirement.
2. Counsel appearing for the tenant Sri. P.V Mohanan submitted that the Courts below have misunderstood the scope and ambit of S. 11(4)(iii) and consequently reached an erroneous conclusion and therefore liable to be interfered with under S. 20 of the Act. This Bench in Pakran v. Kunhiraman Nambiar, 2004 (1) KLT 824, held that the revisional jurisdiction under S. 20 is wider than the revisional jurisdiction of this Court under S. 115 CPC. We may therefore examine whether the Courts below have correctly applied S. 11(4)(iii) in the facts of this case. S. 11(4)(iii) contemplates three situations where the landlord could successfully maintain a petition for eviction. If the tenant has come into possession of a building before or after commencement of the tenancy which is reasonably sufficient for his requirement in the same city, town or village and continued to be in his possession on the date of filing of the petition the landlord could seek an order for eviction S. 11(4)(iii). So also if the tenant after the commencement of the tenancy acquire possession of or puts up a building, reasonably sufficient for his requirements in the same city, town or village and continues to be in possession on the date of filing of the application that is also a ground available for eviction to the landlord. Landlord could seek eviction under S. 11(4)(iii) even if the tenanted building is not bona fide required for his own occupation or for additional accommodation.
3. The underlying object of the provision is that tenant shall not keep unto himself so many tenanted premises lest there will be scarcity of accommodation for the needy tenants. Burden of proving that the tenant has in his possession of a building and continues to be in possession of that building or has put up a building is on the landlord. Landlord has also to establish prima facie that the building which is in the possession of the tenant is reasonably sufficient for the tenant's requirement. The tenant can disprove the same by establishing that he is not in possession of the building on the date of the application and if at all he is in possession that is not reasonably sufficient for his requirement. The Court has to weigh the evidence adduced by the landlord and tenant and render a finding as to whether the tenant is in possession of a building which is reasonably sufficient for the requirement on the date of filing of the petition. However, in a given case the tenant can even explain that though he has put up a building the circumstances are such that he cannot occupy the same. Construction of building availing of loan from financial institution is quite common and unless tenant gets a reasonable return it will not be possible to repay the loan amount. In such circumstance the tenant may rent out the building, so that he can repay the loan. Tenant may in a given case put up building after availing loan from prospective buyers or even from prospective tenants, so that the mere fact that tenant has put up a building is not sufficient to show that he is in possession so as to occupy the same without any hindrance. However, the onus is on the tenant to show the circumstances which stands in his way of not occupying the premises. The burden is on the landlord to prima facie show that the building acquired by the tenant and building subsequently put up by the tenant is also reasonably sufficient for his requirement.
4. It is well settled canon of evidence that the point in issue is to be proved by the party who asserts the affirmative. It is settled law that in a suit for ejectment or a petition for eviction the burden of proof lies on the party who seeks eviction before the onus is shifted to the defendant or tenant to prove that he has a right to be continue in possession. In our view the landlord, the person who seeks an order of eviction has to show that the tenant has in his possession on the date of the filing of the petition a building reasonably sufficient for his requirement in the same city, town or village. The question to be considered in this case is whether the landlord could succeed in showing that the tenant has already in his possession a building on the date of filing the application for eviction is reasonably sufficient for his requirement in the same city, town or village. In order to determine the said question we have to examine the area in the occupation of the tenant and the area which is available with the tenant for occupation. The only independent evidence available to determine the said question in this case is the Commission Report C1 dated 7.4.1993 Ext. A1 lease deed also would give the nature of the tenanted premises. Commission Report has described the tenanted premises as follows:
“The petition scheduled shop is situated east of Peruvattumthazha Road, facing west in ward No. 31 and the building is numbered as 307 by the Badagara Municipality.
At the time of my visit in the petition scheduled shop, I saw a name board on the wall of the building written.” “The particular room was kept open. At the western side of the shop, there is a small verandah and no furniture were seen there. 3 bags of copra were seen in the room bearing door No. 31/307. A table and 3 chairs were also seen there. The room is electrified. On the western side of the room there is a door which was opened. At the southern side also there is another door to enter into the copra yard, which was very spacious one, situated at the south of the petition scheduled shop.
At the western side of the copra yard, a thatched shed is in existence. At the southern side of the above shed, a smoke-house also is noticed.
It is tiled but on the western side, tiles were seen removed and the reapers were seen either eaten away by white ants or damaged. In the smoke-house, arrangements to dry the copra were seen, but it was not in an usable condition. On the reaper like arrangement to dry the copra, about 30 tiles were seen placed. At the northern side and eastern side of the smoke-house, wooden frames for passages were seen. These passages were completely covered by cobweb. It reveals that no one used to enter in the smoke-house for drying copra.
In the shed attached to the smoke-house, situated at the north and south to the petition scheduled shop, 100 bags of licko coal are seen. In another comer of the shed, 5 bags of cement (loose) also were seen.
The said copra yard was also not in an usable condition. The floor of the copra yard is full of growing grass and dry shrubs. The waste part of licko coal also were noticed on the ground of the yard. The copra yard is surrounded by a wall, about 7 feet height, but no net was seen covering the yard.
From the verandah of the shop, one cannot enter into the shed, as the opening into the shed from the verandah was seen closed by using wooden planks (nirappalakas) from inside of the shed. The wooden planks and the iron rod, which connected the wooden planks, were seen full of cobweb and accumulated dust.”
5. The above mentioned details given by the Commissioner would give an idea of the tenanted premises. The landlord stated that the tenant is in possession of another building just opposite to the schedule building which was also examined by the Commissioner. With regard to that building Commissioner has stated as follows:
“Just opposite to the petition schedule shop, about 20 meters south from the shop and on the western side of the Peruvattumthazha road, a shop owned by Sri. Kunhiraman, the first respondent is noticed; as told by one Mr. Manojan, son of the owner of the Manohar Restaurant situated at the northern side of the shop and another Pavithran, a shop keeper of an Ayurvedic shop situated eastern side of the above shop. According to them, the particular shop is owned by Kunhiraman, the first respondent, and that is being used as godown for storing cement and licko coal for sale. They further told me that after issuing bills from the shop, numbered as 31/307, the customers used to get their cement and licko coal from this particular shop. This shop was seen kept closed at the time of my inspection. No daily business is carried out there, as the surroundings of the shop seems to be a squalid one”.
6. We have gone through Ext. A1 kychit as well as the oral and documentary evidence adduced in this case. When we compare the tenanted premises with the premises stated to be in the possession of the tenant on the basis of the Commission Report we can safely come to the conclusion that the premises which in the possession of the tenant is not reasonably sufficient for his requirement in the matter of extent as well as convenience. We are therefore of the view courts below have committed a grave error in passing an order of eviction. In our view there is a complete misreading of evidence by the authorities below. Counsel appearing for the landlord submitted that the rent of the building is also considerably low. Counsel appearing for the tenant submitted that he is willing to pay Rs. 750/- per month with effect from 1.3.2004 We record the said submission. Since we have found that the landlord is not entitled to get order of eviction under S. 11(4)(iii) we are inclined to set aside the orders of the Rent Control Court and Appellate Authority and allow the revision. We may indicate that the grounds urged under S. 11(2)(b), 1(4)(ii) and 11(4)(v) were already rejected by the Rent Control Court and Appellate Authority.
7. Under such circumstance this revision is allowed and the order of eviction passed under S. 11(4)(iii) would stand set aside. However, the landlord is entitled to get rent at the rate of Rs. 750/- per month from 1.3.2004 onwards. We make it clear that if the landlord has got a case that he is entitled to get more rent than Rs. 750/- it is for him to approach the Rent Control Court for fixation of fair rent.
Alert