Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

B.K Kamath v. The Institute Of Chartered Accountants & Anr.

Kerala High Court
Feb 25, 2003
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged a notification (Ext. P1) issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) which restricted the number of tax audit assignments a Chartered Accountant (CA) can accept under Section 44-AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961, to 30 in a financial year. The notification, effective from April 1, 1989, was issued under Part II of the Second Schedule to the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, and declared that accepting more than the specified number would constitute professional misconduct. The petitioner contended that this restriction was unreasonable and violated Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India. The ICAI defended the notification as a reasonable restriction in the public interest under Article 19. The matter was heard with counsel representing both parties and the second respondent.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the restriction imposed by Ext. P1 notification limiting a Chartered Accountant to 30 tax audit assignments under Section 44-AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961, amounts to an unreasonable restriction on the right to practice profession guaranteed under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India.
  2. Whether Ext. P1 violates the equality guarantee under Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
  3. Whether the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India had the statutory authority under the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, particularly Section 30 and the Second Schedule, to issue such a notification.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Ext. P1 imposes an unreasonable restriction on the right to carry on the profession of Chartered Accountancy.
  • The notification violates Article 14 of the Constitution by being discriminatory and arbitrary.
  • The Council lacks specific power under the Chartered Accountants Act to issue a notification that effectively regulates the professional work of Chartered Accountants in this manner.
  • Reliance on the Madras High Court decision in Bhagavatheeswaran v. Institute of Chartered Accounts, which held such restrictions to be a serious inroad into the right to practice freely and discriminatory.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The notification is a reasonable restriction permitted under Article 19 of the Constitution in the interest of the general public.
  • The Chartered Accountants Act empowers the Council, under Section 30 and the Second Schedule, to regulate the profession and maintain professional standards, which includes issuing such notifications.
  • The restriction aims to ensure equitable distribution of work, prevent monopoly, and maintain the quality and accuracy of tax audits, which are time-bound and require precision.
  • Reference to the Division Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court in Arun Grover v. Institute of Chartered Accountants, which upheld the validity of the notification as a reasonable and regulatory measure.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhagavatheeswaran v. Institute of Chartered Accountants, (1998) 93 Company Cases 625 Held that restrictions on accepting professional engagements can be an unreasonable restriction on the right to practice profession. The court respectfully declined to follow this view, finding the restriction reasonable and regulatory in nature.
Arun Grover v. Institute of Chartered Accountants, (1998) 93 Company Cases 618 Upheld the restriction on tax audit assignments as a reasonable ceiling for effective and business-like audit practice. The court adopted this view, considering the notification valid and within the Council’s powers.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the statutory scheme of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, noting that the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India is an autonomous professional body incorporated under Section 3 of the Act. The Council is empowered under Section 9 to manage the affairs of the Institute and under Section 15 to carry out the provisions of the Act. Crucially, Section 30(1) grants the Council broad power to make regulations to carry out the objects of the Act, with Section 30(2)(k) specifically authorizing regulation of the status and standards of professional qualifications of members.

The court found that the impugned notification was validly issued under the Second Schedule of Part II, which deals with professional misconduct, and that the Council’s regulatory powers are broad and not confined only to enumerated powers in Section 30(2). Therefore, the notification was not ultra vires the Act.

The restriction limiting tax audit assignments to 30 per year was found to be a reasonable restriction aimed at maintaining quality and accuracy in audit work, which is time-bound and has statutory significance under the Income Tax Act. The restriction also serves to prevent monopoly and ensure equitable distribution of audit work among Chartered Accountants.

The court acknowledged the differing views of other High Courts but favored the reasoning of the Madhya Pradesh High Court Division Bench, which upheld the restriction as a regulatory measure consistent with the objects of the Act and public interest.

Accordingly, the court concluded that the notification does not violate Articles 14 or 19(1)(g) of the Constitution and is a permissible and necessary regulatory restriction.

Holding and Implications

The original petition is dismissed.

The court held that the restriction on the number of tax audit assignments a Chartered Accountant may accept under Section 44-AB of the Income Tax Act is a reasonable and valid regulatory measure enacted by the Council of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India under its statutory powers. The notification does not violate constitutional guarantees of equality or the right to practice a profession. The direct effect is that the impugned notification remains valid and binding on Chartered Accountants. The decision does not establish a new precedent beyond affirming the regulatory authority of the Council and the reasonableness of such professional restrictions.

Show all summary ...

1. Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India guarantees the right to freely practise any profession, or to carry on any occupation, trade or business subject to any law providing for reasonable restrictions in the interests of the general public. Institute of Chartered Accountants of India issued a notification specifying that a Chartered Accountant shall not accept more than the specified number of tax audit assignments referred to under Section 44 AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961 Does it amount to an unreasonable restriction? Ext. P1 notification issued by the first respondent is under challenge. By the said notification the first respondent introduced certain restrictions restricting the number of tax audit assignments under Section 44-AB of the Income-tax Act 1961 to 30 in a financial year in the case of an individual Chartered Accountant irrespective of the fact that he is having a proprietary concern or a firm. Under Section 44-AB of the Income tax Act every person carrying on business, if his total sales turnover or gross receipts in business exceeds Rs. 40 lakhs in a year and every person carrying on the profession having gross receipts exceeding Rs. 10 lakhs in a year is liable to have the accounts audited by a Chartered Accountant. The first respondent issued Ext. P1 notification under Part II of the II Schedule to the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), wherein it is provided that a member of the Institute whether in practice or not shall be deemed to be guilty of professional misconduct, if he accepts more than the specified number of tax audit assignments under Section 44 AB of the Income Tax Act 1961. The notification came into force on 1-4-1989 and 30 was fixed as the specified number.

2. It is the case of the petitioner that Ext. P1 is an unreasonable restriction on the right to carry on a profession and the same is also violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. According to the first respondent, there is no violation of the rights of the petitioner guaranteed under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India, and Ext. P1 contains only a reasonable restriction permitted under Article 19 of the Constitution of India, in public interest.

3. Heard Sri. K.R Balasubramanyan, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Sri. C.M Devan, learned senior counsel appearing for the first respondent and the Senior Central Government Standing Counsel for the second respondent.

4. In order to properly understand the background of the impugned notification and the competence of the first respondent to issue such a notification, it is necessary to have an overview of the Scheme of the Act. It is seen from the Statement of Objects and Reasons of the Act that the second respondent sought to authorise the incorporation by Statute “an autonomous professional body”. Preamble of the Act says that it is an ‘Act to make provision for the regulation of the profession of Chartered Accountants’. Institute of Chartered Accountants of India is incorporated as per Section 3. Section 9 deals with the constitution of the Council of the Institute designed and designated “for the management of the affairs of the Institution and for discharging the functions assigned to it under this Act”. Section 15 stipulates that “the duty of carrying out the provisions of this Act shall be vested in the Council”. Section 30 deals with the power of the Council to make regulations “for the purpose of carrying out the objects of this Act”. Section 30(2) provides for the scope and extent of the power. To the extent it is relevant, the same reads as follows:—

30(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, such regulations may provide for all or any of the following matters:—

XXXXXX

(k) the regulation and maintenance of the status and standard of professional qualifications of members of the Institute”.

(emphasis supplied)

5. Second Schedule to Part II deals with professional misconduct in relation to members of the Institute generally requiring action by a High Court. It is provided therein that;

“A member of the Institute, whether in practice or not, shall be deemed to be guilty of professional misconduct, if he—

(ii) is guilty of such other act or omission as may be specified by the Council in this behalf, by notification in the Gazette of India”.

6. The impugned Ext. P1 notification is issued under the Second Schedule of Part II.

7. Looking at the scheme of the Act it can be seen that the Act is intended for regulating the profession of Chartered Accountants. The Council of the Institute is bestowed with the duly of carrying out the provisions of the Act. In order to cany out the duties effectively only the Council is given power to make regulations. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the impugned notification is beyond the power of the Council since the enumerated powers do not in any way specifically empower the Council to issue a notification which has the effect of regulating the professional work of a Chartered Accountant. I am afraid the contention cannot be accepted. For one thing it has to be seen that the power to make regulations under Section 30 is without prejudice to the generality of the power under Section 30(1) namely power to make regulations “for the purpose of carrying out the objects of the Act”. Section 30(2) only enumerates some specific powers without in any way affecting the general power which is all perversive. In other words, merely because certain regulation making areas are specifically enumerated under Section 30(2), it cannot be said that the Council cannot tread beyond the enumerated powers, since the general power for making regulations for the effective implementation of the Act is reserved to the Council. The object of the Act is to regulate the profession of the Chartered Accountants. Therefore, the impugned notification cannot be held to be ultravires the objects of the Act.

8. Section 30(2)(k) of the Act vests power on the Council to make regulations for regulating and maintaining the status of members of the Institute and standard of professional qualifications of members of the Institute. It is in this context the purpose of the impugned notification assumes importance. Tax audit assignment is a time bound assignment in every financial year. In order to maintain and also improve the quality of tax audit assignments in the case of those coming under Section 44-AB of the Income-tax Act, 1961 the Council, oh the basis of the recommendations of the Professional Development Committee of the Council, resolved to restrict the number of tax audit assignments to 30 in a financial year with effect from 1-4-1989. It is not quite clear as to whether the number 30 is in aggregate; the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Arun Grover v. Institute of Chartered Accountants, (1998) 93 Company Cases 618) has taken the view that the number is 30 in the case of businessman and 30 in the case of professional, thus in aggregate 60 in a financial year. Be that as it may; it has to be noted that this restriction confines only to the audit assignment under Section 44-AB. In other words, there is no restriction as far as other audit works are concerned except of course the restriction under Section 224 of the Companies Act wherein a Chartered Accountant is not permitted to audit more than 20 companies in a financial year.

9. It is stated in the counter affidavit that such a restriction is intended to ensure an equitable distribution of work among the Chartered Accountants and prevent monopoly. Though it may appear to be an unreasonable restriction, in fact it is not. Unlike other professional fields, the work of audit requires precision. The certificate of audit issued by a chartered accountant has statutory force for the purpose of the Income Tax Act. Audit is a time bound work. Taking note of all these relevant factors it cannot be said that the impugned provision is in any way unreasonable or discriminatory. In the nature of the work of the Chartered Accountants, in fact such provisions are required for ensuring quality in work and accuracy in execution of the work. Such reasonable restrictions are not only permitted but are mandated in the circumstances. After all it is the Council of Chartered Accountants which has issued the notification and that too on the basis of the recommendation of the Professional Development Committee. It is a Council of its members, it is a Council by the members and it is a Council for the members. As per Section 7 of the Act all members of the Institute are known as Chartered Accountants. Therefore, there is no basis for the contention of violation of Article 14 or Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India. The Council which is to regulate the professional body, thought it fit to introduce such restrictions in the interests of the profession. It is regulatory in nature and such regulation is permissible under the Act. Under Section 15 of the Act it is the duty and function of the Council to make provision for regulating and maintaining the status of the members of the Institute and Section 30(2)(k) empowers the Council to frame appropriate regulations in that regard. The source being thus traceable to the provisions under the Act, the impugned notification cannot be faulted on the ground of lack of power either. The regulation does not in any way affect the rights of the Chartered Accountants under the Constitution of India, being only a reasonable restriction.

10. Learned counsel for the petitioner relying on the decision of the Madras High Court in Bhagavatheeswaran v. Institute of Chartered Accounts, (1998) 93 Company Cases 625 submits that introduction of such restrictions could be a serious inroad into the right to practice freely the profession. It is submitted that it is for the client to be concerned of the quality of the work and it is not just and proper to restrict the freedom of a client to choose a professional man for the only reason of workload; According to Y. Venkatachalam, J. “accepting a legitimate professional engagement by a professional can never be considered unprofessional and be made a misconduct.” Therefore, the impugned notification was held to be discriminatory and unreasonable. A Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court, however, has taken a contra view in Arun Grover v. Institute of Chartered Accountants, (1998) 93 Company Cases 618. The Division Bench observed that the impugned notification does not take away the right of the Chartered Accountants to carry on the profession, but it only limits and places ceiling for the purposes of effective and business-like audit. The notification was issued in the background of the experience of the Council regarding the demand to maintain high degree of efficiency in audits.

11. With great respect I am unable to follow the view of Venkatachalam, J. of Madras High Court Unlike other professional bodies, Chartered Accountants Act itself is enacted for regulating the profession and in the process regulating and maintaining the status of the Chartered Accountants. Therefore, the measures now taken, which are intended to maintain and improve the quality of work and ensure equitable distribution of work among the Chartered Accountants cannot in any way; be stated to be an unreasonable restriction since in the opinion of the Council, such restrictions are necessary for maintaining the status of the Chartered Accountants and also for ensuring the quality of the work by the Chartered Accountants. The statutory body of professionals having taken a decision within their powers in the interests of the profession, the Court may not be justified in substituting its vies.

12. In the nature of the work of Chartered Accountants only, a similar restriction was introduced under Section 224 of the Companies Act wherein a Chartered Accountant is permitted to audit only 20 companies in a financial year. That provision is there eversince 1974. It has to be appreciated that such regulatory measures are provided in view of the onerous and time-consuming nature of the work of the Chartered Accountant requiring accuracy and perfection. The Income Tax Act attributes much importance to the certificate of audit by the Chartered Accountant and therefore, it is in public interest also, as observed by the Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court to introduce certain restrictions in the volume of work lest it would affect the professional standard apart from affecting the professional status. I do not find any unreasonable restriction. Ext. P1 notification is valid and validly issued by the first respondent. All this apart, there is no case for the petitioner that he has in any way suffered pursuant to the impugned notification. Looking from that angle also I do not find any justification in interfering with the impugned notification.

13. There is no merit in the original petition. It is dismissed.