Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vanchiyoor Madhom Dhanwanthari Sannidhanam v. State Of Kerala And Others

Kerala High Court
Jan 8, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Jawahar Lal Gupta, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This batch of matters comprises 46 petitions divided into two groups. The first group consists of O.P. Nos. 27784 and 21923 of 2002; the primary relief sought in those petitions was a declaration that a person who does not possess a recognised qualification and is not registered under the appropriate statute is not entitled to practise medicine. The second group consists of 44 petitions in which the petitioners admit that they do not possess the prescribed qualifications and are not registered. Those petitioners seek a writ of mandamus directing the State to either exempt them from Section 38 of the Travancore‑Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953, or to permit their registration under the Act.

The facts as pleaded in O.P. No. 27784 of 2002: the petitioner is a registered society which draws attention to the Travancore‑Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 and the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970 as statutes intended to prevent unqualified persons from practising medicine. The society alleges the existence of persons in Kerala practising Indian Systems of Medicine (ISM) without qualification or registration, in violation of Section 38 of the 1953 Act and Section 17 of the 1970 Act, and seeks a declaratory judgment to that effect.

The facts as pleaded in O.P. No. 4439 of 1999 (representative of the second group): filed by 138 persons who describe themselves as "Paramparya Vaidyas" practising Ayurveda, Siddha and related systems on the basis of learning from gurus and parents. They allege prior interaction with the Government and a prior writ (O.P. No. 11950 of 1996) that resulted in a direction to the State Government to consider representations; the Government considered drafting a Kerala Medical Practitioners Bill but awaited Central Government approval. Petitioners assert that exemptions under Section 38 of the 1953 Act had been granted historically to some persons by executive orders (copies of orders from 1982, 1983 and 1986 were produced), and they claim they are being prevented from practising because they are not registered.

Procedurally, despite opportunity, no counter‑affidavit was filed on behalf of the respondents. Counsel for the parties were heard by the Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether persons who do not fulfil the prescribed statutory qualifications and who are not duly registered under the relevant statute may lawfully practise as Vaidyas (i.e., whether unqualified and unregistered persons are entitled to practise ISM).
  2. Whether petitioners lacking prescribed qualifications and registration are entitled to a writ of mandamus directing the State to grant exemption from Section 38 of the Travancore‑Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953, or to permit their registration.
  3. Whether the denial of exemption to petitioners who claim long practice and acquired expertise, despite earlier administrative exemptions granted to others, amounts to unlawful discrimination.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (first set: O.P. Nos. 27784 & 21923 of 2002)

  • Only persons possessing the recognised qualifications and duly registered under the relevant statute are competent to practise medicine; persons lacking requisite qualification and registration cannot administer treatment.

Petitioners' Arguments (second set: 44 petitions including O.P. No. 4439 of 1999)

  • They claim long practice and experiential acquisition of expertise from traditional teachers (gurus and parents), asserting competence to practise various indigenous systems.
  • They rely on administrative precedents in which exemptions under Section 38 were granted to others and assert that denying them similar exemption amounts to discrimination; they seek mandamus for exemption or registration.

Respondents' Position

The opinion records that no counter‑affidavit was filed on behalf of the respondents. The Court therefore had no detailed respondent pleadings in the record, though the counsel for the parties were heard.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Calcutta High Court, Matter No. 546 of 1988 Relied upon by petitioners to support a claim for exemption from application of statutory registration provisions (challenge to government notification; included different factual matrix and criminal report under IPC and references to India Medical Degree Act and Bengal Medical Act). The Court held that the Calcutta High Court decision arose from a materially different factual context and therefore was not of real relevance to the present matters; the Calcutta decision did not assist the petitioners here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court framed the controversy succinctly: whether persons who lack the prescribed qualifications and are not registered may practise as Vaidyas. The analysis proceeded from the statutory scheme and its purpose.

1. Statutory purpose and regulatory scheme: The Travancore‑Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 (the "1953 Act") was enacted to regulate qualifications and registration of medical practitioners, including modern, homeopathic and indigenous systems. Section 23 prescribes eligibility for registration and qualifications are set out in the Schedule (Part C for Ayurveda and Siddha). Section 30 requires publication of registered practitioners. The scheme indicates that only those whose names appear on the register are prima facie entitled to practise.

2. Section 38 and the scope of government power: Section 38 prohibits practice by non‑registered persons but contains a first proviso enabling the Government, by notification, to exempt particular persons, classes or areas from the operation of the provision. The Court emphasised that this is a power to grant exemption and, by its nature, must be exercised for good reason and not arbitrarily.

3. Interaction with historical provisions and time‑limits: The Court noted that Section 23(1)(ii) had permitted, as a transitional provision, registration of persons who had practised for five years preceding 1 April 1953, subject to a time limit for application (one year, or a longer period fixed by Government). That transitional opportunity had a temporal limitation, after which the only mechanism for non‑qualified persons to practise would be an exemption under Section 38. The availability of Section 38 does not confer an indefeasible right to exemption; it is an enabling power held by the executive.

4. Purpose of the statutes: Viewed cumulatively with the Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914 (applicable historically in parts of Kerala), the statutes aim to prevent unqualified persons from administering medicine and to check quackery; unregistered persons are, as a general rule, not entitled to practise.

5. Burden of proof and claim of discrimination: Where administrative exemptions had historically been granted to some, petitioners claiming discrimination bore the burden of demonstrating that they were "similarly placed" to those who had earlier received exemptions. The Court found that the petitioners in the second set had not placed on record any evidence showing parity with prior exemptees nor had they shown that they had applied for exemption from the State Government. Consequently, the allegation of discriminatory treatment could not be sustained. The Court invoked the presumption of validity of administrative action and noted that the complainants must prove unequal treatment.

6. Relevance of other judicial decisions: The Court considered counsel's reliance on the Calcutta High Court decision (Matter No. 546 of 1988) but found its facts and circumstances materially different and therefore not helpful to the present matters.

On the basis of the foregoing statutory construction, factual findings from the record, and the absence of proof that the petitioners in the second group were similarly placed to earlier exempted persons, the Court concluded that the petitioners who lacked prescribed qualifications and registration could not succeed in claiming the right to practise or to be exempted as a matter of course.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

- O.P. Nos. 21923 and 27784 of 2002 are allowed. The Court granted the relief sought in those petitions (which, as stated earlier in the opinion, sought a declaration that persons without recognised qualifications and registration are not entitled to practise medicine).

- The remaining petitions (the 44 petitions seeking exemption/registration) are dismissed. The Court found that those petitioners failed to establish entitlement to exemption or that they were similarly placed to earlier exempted persons.

Consequences and implications:

  • The direct effect is that the two petitions seeking a declaratory judgment that unqualified and unregistered persons are not entitled to practise were allowed, while petitioners who lacked qualifications and registration and sought exemption or registration were denied relief.
  • The decision enforces the statutory requirement that practice of medicine is generally confined to those with recognised qualifications and registration, subject to the executive's reserved power to exempt in defined circumstances.
  • The Court did not announce or rely upon any new legal principle beyond statutory interpretation and the application of established burdens of proof in discrimination claims; the opinion does not indicate the establishment of a novel precedent beyond application of the statutes to the facts before it.
  • The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Order accordingly.

Show all summary ...

Jawahar Lal Gupta, C.J:— “Should persons who do not fulfil the prescribed qualifications and are not duly registered under the relevant statute be permitted to practise as Vaidyas?” This is the core of the controversy in this case.

2. We have a bunch of 46 petitions. Out of these, O.P Nos. 27784 and 21923 of 2002 form one part and the remaining 44 petitions constitute the second part. In the first set of petitions, the main prayer is for a declaration that a person who does not possess the recognised qualification and is not registered under the Act is not entitled to practice medicine. In the second set of cases, the petitioners do not possess the prescribed qualifications. They are not even registered. Yet, the prayer is for the issue of a writ of mandamus declaring that they are entitled “either to get exemption from Section 38 of the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 or to get registration under the provisions of the said Act.” The facts as averred in O.P No. 27784 of 2002 (from the first set) may be briefly noticed:

3. The petitioner is a registered society. According to it, the State Legislature had enacted the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953. The persons who had undergone the prescribed course of study and possessed the requisite qualifications were entitled to be registered and practice medicine. The qualifications, etc. as laid down under the Act, have been periodically amended. Later on, the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970 was enacted. The purpose of both the statutes is to ensure that “medicine is not practised by those who were not qualified………..”

4. The petitioner alleges that there are several persons in the State of Kerala practising Indian System of Medicine (ISM) without any qualification or registration”. This is in flagrant violation of the provisions of Section 38 of the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 and Section 17 of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970. On this basis, the petitioner prays for a declaration that a person who does not fulfil the qualification is not entitled to practise medicine. The claim in the connected case viz., O.P No. 21923 of 2002 is on the same lines.

5. A brief reference to the factual position in the other set of cases is also relevant. The facts as averred in O.P No. 4439 of 1999 may be briefly noticed.

This petition has been filed by 138 persons. They claim to be ‘Paramparya Vaidyas’. They are practising in Ayurveda, Siddha, Marma, Balachikitsa, Prakruthi Chikitsa, Yoga, etc. The petitioners claim that these methods had been in vogue for a long time. They have acquired knowledge and experience “from their Gurus and parents…….” The petitioners have also stated that O.P No. 11950 of 1996 had been filed in this Court. It was disposed of by the order dated June 26, 1998 with a direction to the State Government (1st respondent) to consider and decide the representation (Ext. P3). After the disposal of the writ petition, the Government had considered the advisability of enacting a comprehensive legislation governing the registration of Medical Practitioners. The Bill called “Kerala Medical Practitioners Bill” was drafted. It could be promulgated only with the approval of Government of India. The matter was referred to the competent authority. Certain queries were made by the Government of India. In view of this position, the petitioners were informed that their representations can be considered only after the proposal for enacting the legislation is approved by the Central Government. Faced with this situation, the petitioners pray that they have no other remedy except to approach this Court.

It is the case of the petitioners that Section 38 of 1953 Act empowered the State Government “to permit any person to practise medicine without registration…….”. The Government has exercised this power and granted exemption to various persons by different orders. Copies of the orders dated May 5, 1982, June 25, 1986 and August 3, 1983 have been produced to show that exemption has been granted to different persons at different times.

The petitioners are not registered under the 1953 Act. As a result the respondents are creating difficulties and preventing them from practising as ‘Paramparya Vaidyas’.

6. Despite opportunity, no counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of the respondents. The counsel for the parties have been heard.

7. Learned counsel for the petitioners in the first set of cases has contended that only qualified persons are entitled to practise medicine. A person who does not possess the requisite qualification and is not registered under the relevant statute cannot administer any treatment to a sick person. On the other hand, learned counsel for the petitioners in the second set of cases have contended that by continued practice over a long period of time they have acquired the requisite expertise and persons who are similarly placed have been granted exemption from registration in terms of Section 38 of the 1953 Act. The action in denying a similar relief to the petitioners in the 44 petitions listed before the Bench suffers from the vice of discrimination. Thus the respondents should be directed to permit the petitioners to practise as ‘Paramparya Vaidyas’.

8. It is in the light of the above pleas that the question as posed at the outset has to be considered.

9. The Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 was promulgated to regulate the qualifications and to provide for the registration of practitioners of modern medicine. It took within its ambit the homeopathic and the indigenous systems of medicine. Section 23 of the Act inter alia provides that “every holder of a recognised qualification” shall be eligible for registration. The qualifications have been delineated in the Schedule to the statute. So far as Ayurveda and Siddha systems of medicine are concerned, the qualifications are mentioned in Part C. The provision and procedure for registration have been given. Section 30 requires the Registrar of the Council to publish in the Gazette the list of the names and qualifications of all practitioners registered under the Act. Section 38, to which reference has been made by counsel for the parties, provides as under:

“38. Persons not registered under this Act, etc., not to practice — No person other than (i) a registered practitioner, or (ii) a practitioner whose name is entered in the list of practitioners published under Section 30, or (iii) a practitioner whose name is entered in the list mentioned in Section 25 shall practice or hold himself out, whether directly or by implication, as practising modern medicine, homeopathic medicine or ayurvedic medicine, siddha medicine or unani tibbi and no person who is not a registered practitioner of any such medicine shall practise any other medicine unless he is also a registered practitioner of that medicine:

Provided that the Government may, by notification in the Gazette, direct that this section shall not apply to any person or class of persons or to any specified area in the State where none of the three classes of practitioners mentioned above carries on medical practice:

Provided further that this section shall not apply to a practitioner eligible for registration under this Act who, after having filed the application for registration, is awaiting the decision of the appropriate council or of the Government in case of appeal:

Provided also that this section shall not apply to a practitioner eligible for registration under this Act until the period prescribed for application under Section 23 expires.”

10. A perusal of the above provision shows that only a person whose name is entered in the register is entitled to practise medicine. By the first proviso, the Government has been given the power to direct that the provision shall not apply to any person or class of persons. It is a power to grant exemption. The power, in the very nature of things, can be exercised for a good reason. Not arbitrarily.

11. The 1953 Act was enacted to ensure that only competent and qualified persons practise medicine. Those who were not qualified were ineligible and as such were liable to be punished under Section 39. Still further similar provisions were made in the Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914 for the erstwhile Malabar area in the State of Kerala. On a cumulative consideration of the provisions of the two statutes it is clear that persons who have not been registered as medical practitioners are not entitled to administer any medicine. The obvious object of the statutes is to check quackery.

12. The counsel for the petitioners in the second set of cases contend that exemption has been granted to various persons. It is undoubtedly so. Copies of the orders produced by the petitioners indicate that by different orders passed in the years 1983 and 1986 exemption was granted. However, nothing has been placed on record to show that the petitioners in the present set of cases are similarly placed with the persons who were granted exemption. Equally, it has also not been shown that the petitioners have submitted any petition for the grant of exemption to the State Government.

13. Smt. Asha, counsel for the petitioner in one of the cases, submits that an application dated June 10, 1991 had been submitted by the petitioner in O.P No. 8924 of 2000. A similar claim has also been, made on behalf of the petitioners in O.P No. 29838 of 2002. Reference has been made to the representation (Ext. P8).

14. So far as this aspect of the matter is concerned, it deserves notice that the conditions of eligibility for registration etc., have been laid down in Section 23. Under clause (1) sub-clause (ii) even persons who have been practising for a period of five years preceding the first day of April, 1953 were made eligible for registration. Still further, in the proviso, it was laid down that “no practitioner shall be registered under clause (ii) after the expiration of one year, or such other longer period as may be fixed by the Government.” The obvious implication was that the application for registration on the basis of experience had to be made within the prescribed period of one year. Thereafter, the power to grant exemption was under Section 38. It could be invoked. But, the provision does not confer an indefeasible right to the citizen to claim exemption. It only embodies an enabling provision. A person who does not fulfil the qualifications cannot claim, as of right, the grant of exemption. Equally, it cannot be said that the mere fact that exemption has been granted to some persons and not to others, the action is per se discriminatory. In this context, it deserves mention that there is a presumption of validity regarding every action. The burden of proving that the position is otherwise, lies on the person who complains. It was for the petitioners to show that equals had been treated unequally. Nothing has been pointed from the records to show that the petitioners are similarly placed with the persons who had been granted exemption. Thus, the charge of discrimination cannot be sustained.

15. Mr. K.S Babu, learned counsel for the petitioners in O.P Nos. 27727/2000, 34903/2000, 3321/2001 and 6725/2002, very fairly states that in view of the above finding the claim of the petitioners in these petitions for entitlement to prepare medicines cannot be sustained. Thus, the petitions are liable to be dismissed. We order accordingly.

16. Mr. G. Hariharan, learned counsel for the petitioners, has placed reliance on the decision of the Calcutta High Court in Matter No. 546 of 1988 to support the claim for exemption. In this case, the petitioner had challenged the notification issued by the Government of West Bengal. Even a report lodged by the Sub-Inspector of Police, under Sections 417 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code read with Section 5 of the India Medical Degree Act, 1916, Sections 30 and 31 of the Bengal Medical Act, 1914 etc., was under challenge. The factual position in that case was totally different from the present set of cases. Thus, the decision is not of any real relevance to the present controversy.

17. From the facts, it is clear that under the 1953 Act only those persons who have acquired the qualification from the institutions included in the schedule are entitled to practise medicine and claim registration. Since the petitioners in the second set of cases do not fulfil the qualifications, the claim made by them cannot be sustained. As a result, O.P Nos. 21923 and 27784 of 2002 are allowed. The remaining petitions are dismissed. The parties are left to bear their own costs.

Order accordingly.