- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gopi v. Sudarsanan
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, accused in C.C No. 326 of 1992 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Attingal, and appellant in Crl. Appeal No. 330 of 1993 before the Additional Sessions Court, Thiruvananthapuram, challenges concurrent findings of guilt under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The petitioner was sentenced to one year of rigorous imprisonment and fined Rs. 5000 (with a default imprisonment of three months). The complaint, filed by the first respondent financier, alleged that the petitioner borrowed Rs. 2,70,000 in two instalments and issued a cheque (Ext. P1) for repayment, which was dishonoured due to insufficient funds. Despite a written notice (Ext. P6), the amount remained unpaid.
During trial, the petitioner admitted issuing the cheque but contended it was without consideration, asserting that he issued the cheque as a mediator for another person, Sivadasan Chandran, who had initially borrowed from the complainant and later repaid. The petitioner claimed the cheque was security and not for a legal debt, a position supported by the notice (Ext. P6) and case law cited by the petitioner.
The courts below found the petitioner guilty, holding that the cheque was issued to cover a legal liability and that no evidence showed Chandran had repaid the complainant.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is criminally liable under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act for issuance of a cheque that was dishonoured due to insufficient funds.
- Whether a cheque issued as security or to cover another person's debt attracts criminal liability under section 138.
- Whether the existence of an agreement to return the cheque upon repayment before a specified date affects the petitioner's criminal liability.
- Whether the petitioner, acting as a mediator and issuing a cheque for another's debt, is exculpated from liability under section 138.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The cheque was issued without consideration and only as security for a transaction between the complainant and Sivadasan Chandran.
- The petitioner intervened only as a mediator and did not receive any money from the complainant.
- The cheque was not issued to cover the petitioner's own legal liability.
- Reference to case law indicating that a cheque issued as security does not attract criminal liability under section 138.
- The existence of an agreement that the cheque would be returned if the amount was repaid before 31.3.1992, which was not produced in court.
Complainant's Position
- The petitioner borrowed Rs. 2,70,000 and issued Ext. P1 cheque towards repayment.
- The cheque was dishonoured due to insufficient funds.
- Despite service of Ext. P6 notice, the amount was not paid.
- No evidence was adduced to prove repayment by Chandran.
- The cheque was issued to discharge a legal liability and thus falls within the scope of section 138.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Alexander v. Joseph Chacko, 1993 (2) K.L.T 326 | Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act does not require the debt to be that of the drawer himself; cheque issued for discharge of another's debt falls within scope. | The court relied on this precedent to hold that the cheque issued by the petitioner to cover another person's liability is actionable under section 138. |
| Taher N. Khambath v. Vinayak Enterprises, 1995 (1) K.L.T S.N 5 | Clarification that a cheque not issued by way of security but as an instrument covering debt, with an agreement to return if repaid, still attracts liability if repayment not made. | Distinguished facts; court found the cheque here was not issued as security but as discharge of legal liability. |
| Sreenivasan v. State Of Kerala, 1999 (3) K.L.T 849 | Followed Taher N. Khambath; reiterated that cheque issuance in discharge of debt attracts liability. | Used to support the conclusion that the cheque was issued to cover debt and not merely as security. |
| Krishna Bai v. Arti Press, 1992 (2) K.L.T 40 | Cheque issued by a company to cover liability of an individual; facts distinct from the present case. | The court held this precedent inapplicable due to differing facts but acknowledged the principle that cheque issuance covering legal liability attracts liability. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, noting that it penalizes dishonour of a cheque issued for the discharge of any legally enforceable debt or liability. It clarified that the statute does not require the debt to be that of the drawer alone; liability for another's debt can also attract criminal liability. The court relied on the presumption under section 139 that a cheque is issued for discharge of debt unless disproved.
The petitioner’s contention that the cheque was security was rejected due to absence of evidence and the nature of the agreement. The court noted the petitioner admitted the cheque was issued to cover Chandran’s debt but no proof was furnished that Chandran repaid the complainant. The alleged agreement to return the cheque upon repayment was not produced, and no payment was shown to have been made before the cheque was dishonoured.
Precedents were applied to confirm that a cheque issued to cover another’s liability falls within section 138. The court distinguished cases cited by the petitioner on factual grounds. Consequently, the court upheld the conviction and sentence but modified the fine, substituting it with a direction to pay compensation of Rs. 2.9 lakhs to the complainant within three months, enforceable by the trial court if unpaid.
Holding and Implications
The petition is disposed of with modification.
The conviction of the petitioner under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and the substantive sentence of one year rigorous imprisonment are upheld. However, the fine of Rs. 5000 is set aside and replaced with an order directing the petitioner to pay compensation of Rs. 2.9 lakhs to the complainant within three months. Failure to comply will result in enforcement by the trial court according to law.
This decision directly affects the parties by confirming the petitioner's liability and imposing compensation but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the application of existing principles.
1. The petitioner is the accused in C.C No. 326 of 1992 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Attingal and the appellant in Crl. Appeal No. 330 of 1993 of the Additional Sessions Court, Thiruvananthapuram. He challenges the concurrent findings of the said two court that he is guilty of the offence under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act as also the sentence of R.I for one year and fine of Rs. 5000/-(in default R.I for three months) imposed therefor. In his complaint the present first respondent alleged that he is a financier, that the petitioner borrowed a sum of Rs. 2,70,000/- in two instalments of Rs. 2,05,000/- and Rs. 65000/- on 11.3.1991 and 15.3.1991 respectively; that towards repayment of the said amount Ext. P1 cheque was issued based on an assurance contained in an agreement that the cheque would be returned in case the amount was repaid before 31.3.1992; that on presentment the cheque was dishonoured for want of funds on 24.4.1992 and that inspite of Ext. P6 notice served on the petitioner the amount remained unpaid.
2. During trial, the petitioner conceded that Ext. P1 cheque was given to the complainant, but took the stand that it was devoid of consideration. According to him, what actually happened was that one Sivadasan Chandran received some amount from the complainant and when he failed to repay the same the petitioner intervened and gave his own cheque. The aforesaid Chandran subsequently repaid the amount thereupon return of Ext. P1 cheque was sought for. This was not complied with and the case is filed in this background.
3. The learned counsed for the petitioner submitted that there is nothing to show that the petitioner got any amount from the complainant or that the cheque was issued to cover a legal liability. Actually it was given only as security for the transaction between the complainant and Chandran. This fact is admitted in Ext. P6 notice also. Case law was relied on to show that in case a cheque is issued by way of security no criminal liability could arise from the dishonour of such cheque.
4. It is conceded in Ext. P6 that the complainant had agreed with the petitioner that no action would be taken based on Ext. PI cheque in case the amount due was paid on or before 31.3.1992 and that a separate agreement was executed. The question is whether the execution of such an agreement (not produced in this case) would affect the criminal liability of the petitioner. Yet another aspect to be gone into is whether the contentionn that there was no legally enforceable debt due from the petitioner on the date of execution of Ext. P1 and whether the allegation that actually the petitioner, as a mediator, issued the cheque to cover up the liability of Chandran exculpates him from liability.
5. It may be mentioned here that even though the contention taken is that Chandran had repaid the amount due to the complainant, no evidence whatsoever is adduced on the point.
6. Point:
section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act reads as follows:
“138. Dishonour of cheque for insufficiency, etc., of funds in the account. Where any cheque drawn by a person on an account maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of money to another person from out of that account for the discharge, in whole or in part, of any debt or other liability, is returned by the bank unpaid, either because of the amount of money standing to the credit of that account is insufficient to honour the cheque or that it exceeds that amount arranged to be paid from that account by an agreement made with that bank, such person shall be deemed to have committed an offence and shall, without prejudice to any other provision of this Act, be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year, or with fine which may extend to twice the amount of the cheque, or with both:
Provided that nothing contained in this section shall apply unless—
(a) the cheque has been presented to the bank within a period of six months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of its validity, whichever is earlier.
(b) the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque, as the case may be makes a demand for the payment of the said amount of money by giving a notice, in writing, to the drawer of the cheque, within fiften days of the receipt of information by him from the bank regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid, and
(c) the drawer of such cheque fails to make the payment of the said amount of money to the payee, or as the case may be, to the holder in due course of the cheque, within fifteen days of the receipt of the said notice.
Explanation.— For the purposes of this section, “debt or other liability” means legaly enforceable debt or other liability.”
7. This section does not in any way debar a person from taking up another person's liability or insist that the cheque should be one drawn to discharge the liability of the drawer. Under section 139 of the Act there is a presumption, unless the contrary is proved, that the holder of a cheque received the cheque for the discharge in whole or in part of any debt or other liability. ‘Any debt’ would cover the liability of another person as well. Here the accused's own case is that the cheque was executed with the intention that it should cover the liability of another person. Even if his said contention is accepted, Ext. P1 cheque is one issued to cover a legal liability.
8. Alexander v. Joseph Chacko (1993 (2) K.L.T 326) considered the question whether for the purpose of section 138 of the N.I Act it is necessary that a debt for which the cheque is executed should be the liability of the drawer himself. It was found that the section does not say that the cheque should have been drawn for the discharge of any debt or other liability of the drawer towards the payee. If the intention of the Parliament was otherwise the words “of any debt or other liability” appearing in section 128 of the Act would have been further qualified by adding the words “of the drawer”. The object of the Legislature being to enhance the credibility or acceptability of the cheque and in view of the wording in section-138 of the N.I Act as available now, it is immaterial whether the cheque was issued for the discharge of his own debt or liability. It was specifically found that the cheque issued for discharge of another man's debt or liability could also come within the scope of section 138 of the N.I Act.
9. In view of said decision and in the absence of any thing to show that Chandran, whose debt the petitioner allegedly took up, has cleared the same by paying the amount to the complainant, I am of the view that the courts below were right in holding that Ext. P1 is capable of maintaining a cause of action in favour of the complainant.
10. During hearing reliance was placed on the decision of the High Court in Taher N. Khambath v. Vinayak Enterprises, 1995 (1) K.L.T S.N 5 (Case No. 7) and Sreenivasan v. State Of Kerala, 1999 (3) K.L.T 849. In fact, the later decision was based entirely on the former. Here the cheque was not issued by way of security. The alleged agreement was only that if money was paid within a specified time the cheque would be returned. The cheque was the only instrument given to cover the debt and the understanding alleged also enabled the payee to collect the cheque unless payment was made before 31.3.1992 There is nothing to show that any such payment was made. Hence the cheque has to be taken as one issued in discharge of the legal liability.
11. Krishna Bai v. Arti Press, 1992 (2) K.L.T 40 relied on by the revision petitioner is also a case of different facts. That was a case where for the liability of an individual the company's cheque was issued. The facts being not identical, the said decision also cannot apply to the present case. The issuance of cheque to cover a legal liability, though of another person; the dishonour of the same for want of funds and also failure to pay the amount inspite of Ext. P6 notice stand proved. The courts below were therefore right in concluding that the petitioner has committed the offence under section 138 of the N.I Act. In the circumstance, the conviction entered against the petitioner and the substantive term of imprisonment imposed therefor do not warrant any interference. I am of the view that the imposisiton of fine of Rs. 5000/- in the case does not meet the ends of justice. It is set aside and the petitioner-accused in directed to pay compensation of Rs. 2.9 lakhs to the complainant. In case he fails to pay the said amount within three months from today, the trial court will enforce payment thereof in accordance with law.
12. With this modification the revision is disposed of.
Alert