Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Musthafa Ummer v. Appropriate Authority

Kerala High Court
Nov 30, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns two appeals against the judgment in O.P. 6872 of 1999 challenging orders of the Appropriate Authority, Income-tax Department, Bangalore under S. 269UD(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 directing pre-emptive purchase by the Central Government of immovable property situated in survey No. 882/1 of Ernakulam Village. The petitioners (husband and wife) are promoters and sole shareholders of Palm Court Hotels Pvt. Ltd., a private limited company formed to set up a three-star hotel on the property. In order to obtain a term loan of Rs. 250 lakhs from Kerala State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd. (KSIDC), the petitioners were required to transfer the property to the company so that title deeds could be deposited to create an equitable mortgage.

The petitioners and the company submitted Form No. 37-1 (statement under S. 269UC) disclosing the sale of the property to the company for Rs. 66,99,106/-. The Appropriate Authority obtained an Engineering Report and inspected the property and concluded that the apparent consideration was well below 15% of the market value, treating the transaction as undervalued and proposing pre-emptive purchase under S. 269UD(1) for Rs. 66,99,100/-. Show cause notices were issued and the petitioners replied explaining that transfer was necessitated by the KSIDC loan condition and that there was no cash transaction between effectively the same persons.

The Appropriate Authority issued orders (Exts. P.7, P.9 and P.11) directing surrender of possession. The petitioners filed writ proceedings; the learned Single Judge set aside the impugned orders, holding that the Appropriate Authority had failed to take note of the unique circumstances and directed reconsideration. Both the petitioners and the Appropriate Authority appealed. The present opinion records the hearing, the rival submissions, and the appellate court's decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order for pre-emptive purchase under S. 269UD(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 was valid in the factual circumstances of the case (i.e., whether the transaction could be treated as undervalued with intent to evade tax).
  2. Whether the Appropriate Authority complied with the requirements of natural justice and gave the parties a reasonable and effective opportunity to be heard (including supply of materials relied upon such as the Engineering Report and comparable-file references).
  3. Whether, having regard to the petitioners being promoters/transferors and transferees being the same persons (company of which they are sole shareholders), the transaction ought to be treated differently (including whether the corporate veil can be examined/lifted to determine the true character of the transaction).
  4. Whether this Court sitting under Article 226 should direct the Appropriate Authority to grant a no-objection certificate for the transfer (i.e., whether the Court can give a positive direction to permit the transfer to proceed).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The pre-emptive purchase order under S. 269UD(1) was a grave error because it ignored the unique facts: the transfer was necessitated by the KSIDC loan condition requiring the land to be in the company’s name.
  • There was no intention to under-value the property to evade tax; the transferors and transferees were effectively the same persons and the consideration was by allotment of shares (no cash).
  • The petitioners relied on the Supreme Court decision in C.B. Gautam v. Union of India (199 ITR 530) and other Apex Court decisions to show that the Appropriate Authority and court should examine underlying purpose and can lift the corporate veil to determine the true character of the transaction.
  • Exts. P.7, P.9 and P.11 were bad in law for violation of natural justice because the Engineering Report and other materials relied upon (including a comparable-file entry) were not supplied to the petitioners, causing prejudice.
  • The transfer was bonafide to enable loan disbursement; KSIDC itself had valued the land at Rs. 76.03 lakhs (including registration and stamp duty) leaving actual land cost at Rs. 66,99,106/-.

Appropriate Authority's Arguments

  • The Appropriate Authority lawfully passed orders under S. 269UD(1) on the basis of the Engineering Report and inspection which showed gross undervaluation; a presumption of tax evasion arises from such undervaluation.
  • The fact that the petitioners are promoters of the transferee company does not change the character of the transaction; corporate personality can be disregarded where appropriate and the principle that no man can make a profit out of himself applies.
  • Transaction also engages provisions of S. 257 (capital gains) and authorities such as C.I.T. v. Kharwar (72 ITR 603) were cited to support treating such transactions as taxable even when consideration is in shares.
  • The orders were not in violation of natural justice because the show cause notice described the materials relied upon (including the Engineering Report) and no prejudice was caused; reliance was placed on decisions such as Appropriate Authority v. Sudha Patil (235 ITR 118) and Union of India v. Shatabdi Trading and Investment (P) Ltd. (251 ITR 93) to argue that the court should not interfere under Article 226 where the Appropriate Authority has acted on relevant material.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
C.B. Gautam v. Union of India, 199 ITR 530 Establishes that before ordering compulsory purchase under S. 269UD, parties must be given a reasonable opportunity to show cause; a presumption of tax evasion from undervaluation is rebuttable; various bona fide reasons may explain sale below market value. The court relied extensively on Gautam's case as the primary authority for the requirement of reasonable opportunity and for the proposition that a presumption of tax evasion is rebuttable. The court examined the rival contentions in light of the principles stated in Gautam.
Appropriate Authority v. Sudha Patil, 235 ITR 118 Cited by the Appropriate Authority as supportive of action where there is gross undervaluation (as per the text). The Appropriate Authority relied on this decision; the court noted its citation as part of the Authority's submissions that there had been gross undervaluation.
Union of India v. Shatabdi Trading and Investment (P) Ltd., 251 ITR 93 Invoked by the Appropriate Authority to submit that courts sitting under Article 226 should not sit in judgment over orders made by the Appropriate Authority based on relevant materials. The Appropriate Authority relied on this precedent to argue for non-interference by the court; the opinion records this submission when discussing the Appropriate Authority's stance.
C.I.T. v. Kharwar, 72 ITR 603 Invoked to support the proposition that transactions involving shares as consideration may still give rise to taxable profits and that corporate personality may be disregarded to prevent a person from profiting from himself. Cited by the Appropriate Authority's counsel to support ignoring corporate form and treating the transaction as taxable; the court recorded the reliance.
AIR 1965 SC 40 Cited by petitioners' counsel (as one of several Apex Court decisions) to support examining underlying purpose and lifting the corporate veil (as per the petitioners' reliance). The opinion records that petitioners' counsel relied on this decision among others; the court noted the reliance but primarily focused on Gautam's case for detailed principle.
(1986) 1 SCC 264 Cited by petitioners' counsel in support of the proposition that underlying purpose may be examined (as listed by counsel). The court recorded that petitioners' counsel placed reliance on this citation; the opinion does not elaborate further on its specific application beyond noting reliance.
AIR 1986 SC 1370 Cited by petitioners' counsel among several Apex Court decisions referenced to justify examining the transaction's true character. Recorded as cited by petitioners' counsel; the court did not elaborate further in this opinion on a distinct application beyond noting the citation.
AIR 1967 SC 819 Cited by petitioners' counsel as part of authorities supporting the examination of transaction purpose and possibly lifting the corporate veil. Cited by petitioners' counsel; the court noted the reliance but focused its analysis on Gautam and statutory provisions.
(1988) 4 SCC 59 Cited by petitioners' counsel among other Apex Court authorities relied upon for examining underlying purpose. Recorded as cited by petitioners' counsel; no further specific application is detailed in the opinion beyond acknowledging the reliance.
AIR 1988 SC 1737 Cited by petitioners' counsel as one of several authorities relied upon. Cited by petitioners' counsel; the court recorded reliance but did not treat it as the central precedent for decision-making in the opinion.
(1991) 70 Com. Cases 127 Cited by petitioners' counsel among other authorities relied upon to argue that the court can examine substance over form. Recorded as relied upon by petitioners' counsel; the court noted these citations while primarily drawing principles from Gautam.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by reference to the principles laid down in C.B. Gautam v. Union of India, which interpreted Chapter XXC of the Income Tax Act (Ss. 269U to 269UO) and, in particular, the operation of S. 269UD. The court extracted and reiterated Gautam's key holdings: that before an order for compulsory purchase under S. 269UD is made, the intending purchaser and seller must be given a reasonable opportunity to show cause; that although a presumption of attempt to evade tax may be raised on undervaluation, such presumption is rebuttable; and that there may be several bona fide reasons for transacting below apparent market value.

The court then examined the statutory scheme of Chapter XXC as inserted by the Finance Act, 1986, and noted the function of S. 269UC (requirement of Form No. 37-1), and S. 269UD (power to order purchase by Central Government within specified time). The court further noted the later insertion (by Finance Act 1993) of sub-section 1A to S. 269UD requiring that a reasonable opportunity of being heard be given before making an order under sub-s. (1).

Applying these principles to the facts, the court observed that the Appropriate Authority concluded on the basis of an Engineering Report and inspection that the apparent consideration was significantly below market value and therefore proceeded to draw the presumption of tax evasion. However, the court found merit in the petitioners' contention that materials relied upon by the Appropriate Authority (notably the Engineering Department's report and a comparable-file) were not furnished to the petitioners, resulting in violation of the principles of natural justice.

The court emphasized that an order under S. 269UD potentially has far-reaching consequences (petitioners would part with valuable immovable property) and thus the materials forming the basis of such an order must be supplied so that the opportunity to be heard is adequate and effective rather than a mere formality. Non-observance of natural justice principles could result in arbitrariness and infringement of Article 14.

Consequently, the court upheld the learned Single Judge's quashing of the impugned orders, but it refused to grant a positive direction (i.e., it would not direct the Appropriate Authority to issue a no-objection certificate). Instead, the court directed reconsideration by the Appropriate Authority in light of its observations, required that copies of the Engineering Report and other relied-upon materials be made available to the petitioners, and ordered that final orders be passed within two months of receipt of the judgment's copy.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Both appeals were disposed of by the court in a manner that upheld the learned Single Judge's quashing of the impugned orders and directed the Appropriate Authority to reconsider the matter in the light of the observations in the judgment. The court ordered that the materials relied upon (including the Engineering Report) be supplied to the petitioners and that the Appropriate Authority pass final orders within two months from receipt of the judgment's copy. The court declined to give a positive direction to issue a no-objection certificate.

Implications: The direct effect is that the impugned pre-emptive purchase orders were set aside and the Appropriate Authority must re-open its consideration, furnish the materials relied upon to the petitioners, and issue a fresh decision within the specified time. The opinion applies and reiterates the principle (from C.B. Gautam) that a presumption of tax evasion from undervaluation is rebuttable and that parties must be given a reasonable opportunity to rebut such a presumption. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying established principles; it remands the matter for fresh consideration in accordance with those principles.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

K.S Radhakrishnan, J.:— Both these appeals are preferred against the judgment in O.P 6872 of 1999. Challenge is against an order passed by the Appropriate Authority, Income-tax Department, Bangalore under S. 269 UD(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ordering pre-emptive purchase of immovable property situated in survey No. 882/1 of Ernakulam Village by the Central Government. A writ of mandamus was also sought to issue no-objection certificate to the petitioners for transfer of the immovable property as envisaged under S. 269UL of Income Tax Act. The order was set aside by the learned Single Judge holding that the Appropriate Authority has failed to take note of the unique circumstance in which the transfer was necessitated. Learned single Judge therefore quashed the impugned orders. A direction was given to the authorities to consider the petitioner's application Ext. P.6 afresh and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law.

2. Writ Petitioners are husband and wife. They are promoters of a private limited company by name Palm Court Hotels Private Ltd., a company incorporated as a private limited company by the certificate of incorporation No. 09-8831 of 1995. Petitioners are the only share holders of the company. Main object of the company is to construct buildings for hotels and to carry on business of hotels. Petitioners who are Promoters and Directors of the company decided to set up a Three Star Category Hotel Complex at Ravipuram in Kochi in the property mentioned hereinbefore. They approached the Kerala State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd. (in short K.S.I.D.C) for financial assistance, K.S.I.D.C vide its letter dated 13th April 1998 sanctioned a term loan of Rs. 250 lakhs to the company for setting up a Three Star Category Hotel Complex on certain terms and conditions. Sanction letter also stated that KSEDC's disbursement would commence only after the company complying with all the terms and conditions of sanction and completion of documentation ie., signing of loan agreement/hypothecation agreement by the company and guarantees by promoters and deposit of title deeds to create equitable mortgage on land of the company. Memorandum of understanding dated 17.2.98 was entered into between K.S.I.D.C and first petitioner who was promoter of the company. Memorandum of conditions of loan was submitted inter alia on certain conditions such as land registered in the name of the promoter directors should be registered in the name of the company towards mortgaging to K.S.I.D.C Petitioners who are promoters of the company therefore decided to convey the property in question to the company which was a condition precedent for sanctioning the loan by the K.S.I.D.C

3. Petitioners and the company submitted the application under S. 269 UC of Income Tax Act in Form No. 37-1, R. 48-L to the Appropriate Authority. Details of property was given in the application. The property is situated in survey No. 882/1 of Perumanoor Desom, Ernakulam District which was acquired by the first petitioner as joint holder as per document No. 1232/1994. Petitioners decided to transfer the said property to Palm Court Hotels Pvt. Ltd. of which they are the sole directors for a consideration of Rs. 66,99,106/- and an agreement of sale dated 7.10.90 was also entered into. Initially there was some defects in the application and the same was rectified on 13.11.1998

4. The application was considered by the Appropriate Authority. They obtained an Engineering Report prepared by the Executive Engineer of the Valuation Cell, Income Tax Department, Trivandrum. Members of the Appropriate Authority had also inspected the property. After considering the report and evaluating what has been seen during the inspection Appropriate Authority came to the conclusion that the apparent consideration shown in Form 37 I is well below 15% of the market value of the property shown as being sold in Firm No. 37 I. Following are the reasons which weighed with the Appropriate Authority to reach such conclusion.

5. “The property is located in Srikandeth Road off M.G Road on the eastern side of M.G Road. The distance from M.G Road to the property is 70 metre. The locality is residential & commercial mixed. Multistoreyed apartments are existing nearby this property. The potential for commercial development is very high due to its location in the nucleus of Cochin City, the commercial capital of Kerala. The land rate works out to Rs. 2,16,100/- cent (without considering the cost of piles already driven).

6. This is also comparable with the following instances:

In the File No. AA/CHN/9(6) 12/97-98 for the sale of the property situated at Sy. No. 995/1, Part of Ernakulam Village on Kurusupally Road, Ernakulam South, the land rate works out to Rs. 435811/- per sq. ft situated about 300 m. from the property under consideration towards south.”

7. The Appropriate Authority noticed under valuation of the property, therefore drew a presumption that under valuation of the property was done with a view to evade tax. Appropriate Authority therefore proposed to pass an order for pre-emptive purchase of the schedule property under S. 269 UD(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for Rs. 66,99,100/- which is the discounted value of apparent consideration for the Central Government.

8. Appropriate Authority then issued a show cause notice dated 12.2.99 to the writ petitioners as well as to the transferee M/s. Palm Court Hotels (P) Ltd. to show cause why the pre-emptive purchase should not be effected. Parties were directed to show cause on 26.2.99 at 11 a.m failing which it was ordered that it would be presumed that they have no cause to show against such a pre-emptive purchase and the proceedings would be finalised accordingly.

9. Writ Petitioners then filed a detailed reply dated 22.2.99 They explained the circumstances under which the property was decided to be sold to the company. We may extract the relevant portion of the same for easy reference:

“The company had applied for a loan of Rs. 250 lakhs for the Hotel Project from the Kerala State Industrial Development Corporation. According to the condition stipulated by the K.S.I.D.C vide their sanction letter No. Scy 8/165 dated 13.4.98 (herein enclosed), the land on which the hotel was proposed to be constructed had to be transferred to the Company against shares to be allowed by the Company to the shareholders ie., the transferors. Even though it was advantageous to the shareholders (transferors) to show the price of the land on document at a much higher figure, in which case the value of their shareholding will be elevated and the Company could negotiate a higher loan on the security of the land, with a view to reducing the total project cost and thereby the amount of loan to be sanctioned, KSIDC valued the land at Rs. 76.03 lakhs which includes the capitalised value of the registration charges and stamp duty, leaving the actual cost of the land at Rs. 66,99,106/-.

10. Petitioners pointed out that the transfer has been effected due to special circumstances and not for evading tax. Further it was stated since the transferor and transferee are the same there was no money transaction, but only allotment of shares. Petitioners stated that the transaction was a bonafide transaction and unless and until the property is transferred in the name of the Company KSIDC would not disburse the loan. Reply submitted by the petitioners was not acceptable to the Appropriate Authority. They passed order on 26.2.99 directing the transferor/transferee or any other person who may be in possession of the said property to surrender and deliver vacant possession of the scheduled property to the Appropriate Authority within 15 days from the date of receipt of the order. Another letter dated 3.3.99 was also served;on the petitioners as well as to the company by the Appropriate Authority to surrender or deliver possession of the immovable property. Challenging those proceedings Writ Petition has been filed. Learned Single Judge quashed the impugned order and directed the Appropriate Authority to consider the matter afresh, against which both the petitioners and Appropriate Authority have filed appeals. When the matter came up for hearing we heard counsel on either side at length.

11. Counsel appearing for the petitioner Sri. Pathrose Mathai submitted the Appropriate Authority has committed a grave error in passing the order of pre-emptive purchase under S. 269 UD(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and also drawing a presumption that the transaction entered into between petitioner and the company as under valuation of the property with a view to evade tax. Counsel also submitted Appropriate Authority lost sight of facts and circumstances of the case which cannot be compared with any normal transfer of assets between two persons. Counsel submitted transferors as well as transferees are practically the same persons and the transfer of the property was effected due to peculiar circumstance. Counsel submitted that the petitioner and the company preferred a joint statement in Form 371 on 6.10.98 to the Income Tax Department declaring their intention to transfer the immovable property in favour of the company the promoters of which are petitioners. This is one of the special conditions agreed upon between the company and K.S.I.D.C for sanctioning loan of Rs. 250 lakhs for hotel project. Since the petitioners are promoters of the company there was no money transaction between them but the value of the property was shown as consideration by allotment of shares. Petitioners are only share holders of a private limited company. Placing reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in C.B Gautam v. Union of India, 199 ITR 530 counsel submitted transaction in question would satisfy the principle laid down by the Apex court in Gautam's case. Counsel submitted they had no intention to under value the property for evading tax. Under valuation of the same was done in the peculiar nature of the case since the transferors and transferees are practically the same, transferees being the sole promoters of the company who are none other than the writ petitioners themselves. Counsel placing reliance of the decisions of the Apex Court in AIR 1965 SC 40, (1986) 1 SCC 264 : AIR 1986 SC 1370, AIR 1967 SC 819, (1988) 4 SCC 59 : AIR 1988 SC 1737, (1991) 70 Com. Cases 127 etc. submitted that Appropriate Authority as well as this Court ought to have examined the underlying purpose and object of the transaction and the reasons which prompted the petitioners and the company entered into such a transaction. Counsel submitted in order to appreciate the true character of the transaction, the Appropriate Authority for that matters the court can lift the corporate veil and examine the real purpose of the transaction. Counsel submitted if the object and purpose was to evade tax and to generate black money they could have sold the property in open market for higher price. This is a case where the parties agreed for the transfer of the property for a price so as to avail of loan from the KSIDC which would show the bonafide nature of the transaction. Counsel submitted learned Single Judge ought to have given a direction to the Appropriate Authority to issue no objection certificate for the transfer of the property.

12. Counsel also submitted Exts. P.7, P.9 and P.11 orders are bad in law since they are issued in violation of natural justice. Counsel submitted the Appropriate Authority has failed to take into consideration the relevant materials and relied upon irrelevant materials while issuing the impugned orders. Counsel submitted the orders were issued by the Appropriate Authority placing reliance on the Engineering Report prepared by the Executive Engineer of the Valuation Cell Income Tax Department, Trivandrum. Reliance was also placed on file No. AA/CHN/9(6) 12/97-98 for sale of the property situated in Sy. No. 995/1, Part of Ernakulam Villageon Kurisupally Road, Emakulam South. Placing reliance on those materials Appropriate Authority decided to pass order for pre-emptive purchase under S. 269 UD (1) of the Income tax Act. Those materials were never made available to the petitioners. Non-availability of those documents, counsel submitted, caused prejudice to the petitioners.

13. Senior counsel appearing for the Appropriate Authority Sri. P.K Raveendranatha Menon submitted Appropriate Authority has issued Ext. P.7 order dated 12.2.1999 under S. 269 UD(1) of the Income Tax Act 1961 as well as Ext. P.9 order dated 26.2.99 as per S. 269 UD(1) of the Income Tax Act Laying stress on the principle laid down by the Apex Court in Gautam's case (supra) as well as the decision of the Apex Court in Appropriate Authority v. Sudha Patil, 235 ITR 118, counsel submitted that there has been a gross under valuation of the property which would attract S. 269 UE of the Act, Counsel submitted that a mere fact that petitioners are promoters of the company would not change the character of the transaction. Counsel also submitted transaction would also attract the provisions of S. 257 of the Income Tax Act which gives rise to capital gains taxable under the Act. Counsel submitted if there is under valuation of the property Appropriate Authority could always draw a presumption that transaction proposed to be entered into is to evade tax. Counsel submitted the mere fact that the company has issued shares to its promoters in consideration of the sale of the property would not render the transaction legal. Placing reliance on the passage in Kanga on Income Tax, 8th Edition, page 124 counsel submitted when a company sells its trading assets for fully paid shares in another company, the profit on the transaction is assessable although no cash passes. Reliance was also placed on the decision of the Apex Court in C.I.T v. Kharwar, 72 ITR 603 and contended that the corporate personality should be ignored and the principle that no man can make a profit out of himself should be invoked. Counsel submitted that the order was passed not in violation of any principles of natural justice. Counsel submitted the materials relied on, especially, the Engineering Report clearly stated in the show cause notice itself and mat no prejudice has been caused to the petitioners. Placing reliance on the decision of the Apex Court in Union of India v. Shatabdi Trading and Investment (P) Ltd., 251 ITR 93, counsel submitted this court sitting under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India shall not sit in judgment over the order passed by the Appropriate Authority which was made on the basis of relevant materials.

14. We may at the outset indicate mat counsel on either side relied upon the decision of the Apex Court in Gautam's case to bring home their rival contentions. Before we examine the rival contentions it is profitable to refer to certain passages of the said decisions for our purpose. Apex Court was considering the validity of the various provisions in Chapter XXC inserted in the Income Tax Act, 1961 by the Finance Act, 1986. While considering the scope of S. 269 UD(1) the Apex Court held as follows:

“In the light of what we have observed above, we are clearly of the view that the requirement of a reasonable opportunity being given to the concerned parties, particularly, the intending purchaser and the intending seller rnust be read into the provisions of Chapter XXC. In our opinion, before an order for compulsory purchase is made under S. 269 UD, the intending purchaser and the intending seller must be given a reasonable opportunity of showing case against an order for compulsory purchase being made by the appropriate authority concerned………………We have further pointed out that, although a presumption of an attempt to evade tax may be raised by the appropriate authority concerned in case of the aforesaid circumstances being established, such a presumption is rebuttable and this would necessarily imply that the concerned parties must have an opportunity to show cause as to why such a presumption should not be drawn. Moreover, in a given transaction of an agreement to sell, there might be several bona fide considerations which might induce a seller to sell his immovable property at less than what might be considered to be the fair market value. For example, he might be in immediate need of money and unable to wait till a buyer is found who is willing to pay the fair market value for the property. There might be some dispute as to the title of the immovable property as a result of which it might have to be sold at a price lower than the fair market value or a subsisting lease in favour of the intending purchaser. There might similarly be other genuine reasons which might have led the seller to agree to sell the property to a particular purchaser at less than the market value even in cases where the purchaser might not be his relative. Unless an intending purchaser or intending seller is given an opportunity to show cause against the proposed order for compulsory purchase, he would not be in a position to rebut the presumption of tax evasion and to give an interpretation to the provisions which would lead to such a result would be utterly unwarranted. The very fact that an imputation of tax evasion arises where an order for compulsory purchase is made and such an imputation casts a slur on the parties to the agreement to sell leads to the conclusion that, before such an imputation can be made against the parties concerned, they must be given an opportunity to show cause that the undervaluation in the agreement for sale was not with a view to evade tax.”

15. We have to examine the issue raised in this case in the light of the above mentioned principle laid down by the Apex Court.

16. Chapter XXC of the Income Tax Act consisting of Ss. 269U to 269UO was inserted in the Income Tax Act by the Finance Act, 1986 with effect from 1.10.1986 Many of the provisions of the earlier Chapter XXA was found to be unworkable and the task of satisfactory determination of the fair market value of the property in question was also found to be difficult. This chapter defines what is agreement for transfer under S. 269UA(a). 269UA(b) defines aparent consideration. S. 269 UC deals with restrictions on transfer of immovable property subject to certain conditions. This section makes it obligatory that any transfer of property of such value as mentioned above should be preceded by an agreement reduced to writing in the form of a statement in Form No. 37-1 and should be furnished to the appropriate authority. Form No. 37-1 must be filed before the transfer is effected. The statement required to be furnished to the appropriate authority under sub-s. (3) of S. 269UC shall be in Form No. 37-1 and shall be signed and verified in the manner indicated therein by each of the parties to the transfer. If the Authority finds transaction is genuine it could grant permission under S. 269 UC of the Act. The function of the appropriate authority is not merely confined to issuing a no objection certificate. It is coupled with a duty to make a decision as to pre-emptive purchase, if the real market value of the immovable property warrants it. S. 269UD empowers the appropriate authority within two months from the end of the month in which the section 269 UC statement is received, to order the purchase of the property by the Central Government at an amount equal to the apparent consideration set out in the agreement of sale and serve such order on the transferor and transferee. In this connection it is profitable to extract S. 269 UD on which the impugned orders have been issued in this case:

“269UD. Order by appropriate authority for purchase by Central Government of immovable property—(1) Subject to the provisions of sub-ss. (1A) and (IB) the appropriate authority after the receipt of the statement under sub-s. (3) of S. 269. UC in respect of any immovable property, may, notwithstanding any thing contained in any other law or any instrument or any agreement for the time being in force make an order for the purchase by the Central Government of such immovable property at an amount equal to the amount of apparent consideration:

Provided that no such order shall be made in respect of any immovable property after the expiration of a period of two months from the end of the month in which the statement referred to in S. 269 UC in respect of such property is received by the appropriate authority:

xxx xxx xxx xxx

(2) The appropriate authority shall cause a copy of its order under sub-s. (1) in respect of any immovable property to be served on the transferor, the person in occupation of the immovable property if the transferor is not in occupation thereof, the transferee, and on every other person whom the appropriate authority knows to be interested in the property”.

17. We may indicate the words “and for reasons to be recorded in writing” which were there in the earlier S. 269 UD were omitted by the Finance Act 1993 with effect from 17.11.1992 At the same time S. 1A reads as follows:

“1A. Before making an order under sub-s. (1) the appropriate authority shall give a reasonable opportunity of being heard to the transferor, the person in occupation of the immovable property if the transferor is not in occupation of the property, the transferee and to every other person whom the appropriate authority knows to be interested in the property”.

18. It was inserted by the Finance Act, 1993 with effect from 17.11.1992

19. The provisions of Chapter XXC relate to the purchase by Central Government of immovable properties in certain cases of transfer that the apparent consideration is less than the real consideration. All the same there are various exceptions as pointed out by the Apex Court in Gautam's case (supra). There might be genuine reasons which might have led the seller to agree to sell the property to a particular purchaser at less than the market value even in cases where the purchaser might not be his relative. If mere is under valuation of property although a presumption could be drawn that there is attempt to evade tax such a presumption is rebuttable one. If the parties could furnish materials to show that transaction is genuine presumption could be rebutted. In otherwords, all depends, upon facts and circumstances of each case. We are not prepared to say that the facts and circumstances highlighted in this case are irrelevant so as to warrant a conclusion that there has been undervaluation and the undervaluation was made so as to evade tax.

20. We also find force in the contention of the petitioners that there has been violation of principles of natural justice since the report of the Engineering Department as well as the documents relied upon by the appropriate authority were not furnished to the petitioners. This is a case where if the order is given effect to the petitioners will have to part with their valuable immovable property in favour of the Central Government. The order to be passed under S. 269 UD will have far reaching consequence as far as the petitioner is concerned. The materials on which appropriate authority has based its conclusion have therefore necessarily to be supplied to the petitioners. Opportunity of being heard must be adequate and effective and shall not be an empty formality. Arbitrariness which results from non-observance of the principles of natural justice leads to infringement of Art. 14 of the Constitution of India and any act which is repugnant to the said provision is null and void. We have therefore no hesitation to say that the order passed is in violation of the principles of natural justice. We therefore uphold the judgment of the learned single Judge. However, sitting in this jurisdiction under Art. 226 of the Constitution this Court is not justified in giving any positive direction to the Appropriate Authority to issue no objection certificate. We therefore direct the appropriate authority to reconsider the matter in the light of the observations contained herein. Copy of the Engineering Report as well as other materials based on which they issued the impugned order should be made available to the writ petitioners and final orders would be passed by the appropriate authority within a period of two months from the date of receipt of copy of this judgment.

21. Both the appeals are disposed of accordingly.