- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bindu Vijayakumaran Nair v. Bindu Rajappan
Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition (C.R.P.) was filed by the 1st counter petitioner in O.P. (Election) No. 3/2000 on the file of the II Additional Munsiff's Court, Thiruvananthapuram, challenging the order dated 18-01-2001 in I.A. No. 10870/2000. The original election petition (O.P.) was filed by the respondent-petitioner challenging the election of the revision petitioner from Ward No. 15 (Kariyam Constituency) of Sreekariyam Grama Panchayat.
The revision petitioner (who was the respondent in the election petition) had moved an interlocutory application to raise a preliminary issue of maintainability: he alleged that the election petition was not maintainable because copies of the petition served on him were not attested as true copies by the petitioner on pages 1 to 4, in alleged violation of the mandatory provisions of Section 89(1) & (2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, and therefore the O.P. ought to be dismissed in limine.
The Munsiff's Court held that non-attestation on every page was not fatal and that attestation at the foot of the petition amounted to sufficient compliance; it dismissed the interlocutory application. The present revision challenges that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a revision under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is maintainable against an order passed by the Munsiff's Court (subordinate court) while trying an election petition under the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994.
- Whether failure to have each page of the copy of an election petition attested as a true copy by the petitioner (i.e., absence of attestation/signature on some pages) constitutes a fatal non-compliance of Section 89(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, warranting dismissal of the election petition in limine.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioner's Arguments
- The copy of the election petition served on the revision petitioner did not contain attestation/signature on all pages (pages 1 to 4 lacked attestation), thereby violating the mandatory provisions of Section 89(1) & (2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994.
- Because of that violation, the election petition is not maintainable and must be dismissed in limine.
- Relied upon several rulings (including A. Mohamed v. Nalakath Soopy and the Bombay High Court decision in Narendra Bhikahi Darade) to support the contention that signatures/attestations missing on pages render the served copies not true copies.
Respondent's Arguments
- There was no violation of Section 89(1) & (2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act; the election petition was filed in compliance with the Act.
- It is not necessary to attest every page; attestation (signature) at the foot of the copy of the petition is sufficient to constitute attestation as a true copy under Section 89(2).
- Initially relied upon M. Leela v. E. Pusbpam & Another to argue that orders of the Munsiff's Court in election petitions are not revisable under Section 115 CPC because the Munsiff acted persona designata; later contended that the Division Bench decision in Sushama v. Mercy Antony (1999) (3) KLT 818 is distinguishable but the court found that it was applicable to maintainability of revision under Section 115.
- Relied on the Supreme Court decision in F.A. Sapa v. Singora ((1991) 3 SCC 375) and the single-judge decision in Advocate Thomas v. Varghese Paul (1996 (2) KLJ 283) to support the proposition that attestation at the foot of the copy is substantial compliance with the statutory requirement.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| M. Leela v. E. Pusbpam & Another (1996 (2) KLT 350) | Held that orders passed by the Munsiff's Court while hearing an election petition under the Panchayat Raj Act are not revisable under Section 115 CPC because the Munsiff was functioning as persona designata and not as a court under the CPC. | The respondent relied on this decision to urge non-maintainability of the present revision. The court noted this submission but treated it in light of the subsequent Division Bench authority (Sushama) and did not accept it as barring revision in the present matter. |
| Sushama v. Mercy Antony (1999 (3) KLT 818) | Division Bench held that a revision under Section 115 CPC is maintainable against orders passed by subordinate courts exercising jurisdiction under the Panchayat Raj Act. | The court applied this Division Bench authority to hold that the order of the Munsiff's Court is revisable under Section 115 CPC and overruled the respondent's objection to maintainability of the revision petition. |
| A. Mohamed v. Nalakath Soopy (1997 (1) KLT 697) | Single Judge observed that absence of signatures/attestation in copies at appropriate places may mean the copies do not correspond to the original; suggested affixing at least another signature at the bottom of concerned pages to constitute substantial compliance with the requirement of attestation. | The revision petitioner relied on this decision to argue that signatures should appear on all pages. The court noted this authority but preferred other decisions that followed the Supreme Court's dictum and therefore did not adopt this view as determinative. |
| Narendra Bhikahi Darade v. Kalyanrao Jaywantrao Patil (AIR 2000 Bom. 362) | Bombay High Court observed that absence of verification/affidavit in the copy may constitute non-compliance and that the true copy requirement may not be satisfied. | The petitioner's counsel relied on this decision to support the contention of non-compliance. The court considered it but proceeded to follow the authority of the Supreme Court and the single-judge decision that accepted attestation at the foot as sufficient. |
| F.A. Sapa v. Singora ((1991) 3 SCC 375) | Three-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court: the statutory requirement is that each copy be attested by the petitioner under his signature as a true copy; the requirement is satisfied by signing at the foot of each copy—no particular form of attestation prescribed; signature at the foot shows the petitioner's responsibility for the copy being true. | The court regarded this Supreme Court dictum as authoritative, observed that Section 81(3) of the R.P. Act (considered by the SC) is identical to Section 89(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, and followed this reasoning to hold that attestation at the foot of the copy is sufficient compliance. |
| Advocate Thomas v. Varghese Paul (1996 (2) KLJ 283) | Single Judge of this court, following the Supreme Court in F.A. Sapa, held that attestation at the foot of the petition is a substantial compliance of Section 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act. | The court expressly preferred and followed this single-judge decision (which followed the Supreme Court) over the contrary single-judge decision in A. Mohamed, and applied it to conclude attestation at the foot was sufficient. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in two principal stages: first on the maintainability of the revision under Section 115 CPC, and second on the construction and application of Section 89(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act concerning attestation of copies of election petitions.
1. Maintainability of Revision (Section 115 CPC)
- The respondent argued that the Munsiff's Court, when trying election petitions under the Panchayat Raj Act, acts persona designata and therefore orders are not revisable under Section 115 CPC (relying on M. Leela).
- The court considered a subsequent Division Bench decision (Sushama v. Mercy Antony) which held that revision under Section 115 CPC is maintainable against orders passed by subordinate courts exercising jurisdiction under the Panchayat Raj Act.
- The court reasoned that if a law (or procedural rule) applies to an appellate authority functioning under a special statute or general law, the same law should be applicable to a subordinate authority functioning under the same provisions; therefore the Division Bench decision was applicable and the objection to maintainability was overruled.
2. Interpretation and Application of Section 89(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act
- The court set out the statutory text: Section 89(1) prescribes time for presentation of election petitions and Section 89(2) mandates that every election petition should be accompanied by as many copies as there are respondents, and “every such copy should be attested by the petitioner under his signature to be the true copy of the petition.”
- The revision petitioner's contention was that the served copy lacked attestation/signatures on several pages and thus there was a fatal breach of Section 89(2), requiring dismissal in limine.
- The court reviewed conflicting single-judge decisions of this court and other authorities. It identified a critical Supreme Court authority—F.A. Sapa v. Singora ((1991) 3 SCC 375)—which interpreted an identical provision (Section 81(3) of the Representation of the People Act) as requiring attestation by the petitioner under his signature but not prescribing any particular form: signing at the foot of each copy satisfies the requirement because it shows the petitioner takes responsibility that the copy is a true copy.
- The court noted that a single-judge decision in this court (Advocate Thomas v. Varghese Paul) followed the Supreme Court and held attestation at the foot was substantial compliance; another single-judge decision (A. Mohamed v. Nalakath Soopy) reached a stricter result but did not advert to the Supreme Court decision.
- Applying these authorities, and giving precedence to the Supreme Court's dictum as applied by the single-judge decision that followed it, the court concluded that attestation at the foot of the copy of the petition is sufficient compliance with Section 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act. The mere absence of the election petitioner’s signature on some pages of the copy served is not a fatal non-compliance that would render the election petition unsustainable.
The court therefore found that the lower court was correct in holding that non-attestation on every page is not fatal and that the election petition was maintainable. The objection that the election petition must be dismissed in limine for failure to attest each page was negatived.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision petition is DISMISSED.
Implications:
- The court upheld the view that a revision under Section 115 CPC is maintainable against orders passed by a Munsiff's Court trying matters under the Panchayat Raj Act (applying the Division Bench authority in Sushama v. Mercy Antony).
- The court held that attestation at the foot of the copy of an election petition is sufficient compliance with Section 89(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994; lack of the petitioner’s signature on some pages of the copy served is not a fatal defect warranting dismissal in limine of the election petition.
- As a direct effect on the parties: the lower court's order dismissing the interlocutory application and holding the election petition maintainable is affirmed; the revision petition was found devoid of merits and dismissed.
- The opinion does not set out or announce any broader new precedent beyond applying and preferring existing Supreme Court and Division Bench authority; no broader implications beyond the direct effect between the parties are discussed in the judgment.
1. This C.R.P is filed by the 1st counter petitioner in O.P(Election) 3/2000 on the file of the II Addl. Munsiffs Court, Thiruvananthapuram challenging the order dated 18-1-2001 in I.A No. 10870/2000. The above O.P is filed by the respondent-petitioner challenging the election of the revision petitioner from Ward No. 15 (Kariyam Constituency) of Sreekariyam Grama Panchayat. The revision petitioner filed the above I.A to consider the preliminary issue regarding the maintainability of the O.P alleging that the O.P is not maintainable since it is filed in violation of the mandatory provisions of Sec. 89(1) & (2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 in so far as the copy of the election petition served upon the revision petitioner is not attested as true copy by the respondent in page Nos. 1 to 4 of the petition and therefore, the O.P is liable to be dismissed in limine.
2. The respondent has contended that there is no violation of Sec. 89(1) & (2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act and the O.P is filed in strict compliance of the provisions of the Act. The respondent has also contended that it is not necessary to attest every page of the copy of the election petition by the petitioner and it is sufficient if the petitioner attested the last page of the petition. The lower court found that the non-attestation on all pages in the O.P by the petitioner therein is not fatal and it is sufficient if the petitioner attested at the foot of the petition and therefore, held that the election O.P is maintainable. Accordingly, the lower court dismissed the I.A Hence this revision is preferred by the petitioner before this court.
3. The counsel for the respondent relying upon the decision in M. Leela v. E. Pusbpam & Another (1996 (2) KLT 350) submitted that the orders passed by the Munsiffs Court while hearing an election petition under the Panchayat Raj Act are not revisable under Sec. 115 of the C.P.C since the Munsiff's Court was functioning as persona designata and not a court under the C.P.C and therefore, the above revision challenging the order passed by the Munsiffs Court in the above election petition is not maintainable before this court.
4. But in a subsequent decision in Sushama v. Mercy Antony (1999 (3) KLT 818) a Division Bench of this court has held that a revision under Sec. 115 of the C.P.C is maintainable against the orders passed by the Subordinate Courts exercising jurisdiction conferred under the Panchayat Raj Act.
5. The counsel for the respondent submitted that the above decision of the Division Bench of this court is not applicable to the facts of this case since the question that arose before the Division Bench was whether a revision under Sec. 115 of the C.P.C is maintainable before this court aginst the order passed by the appellate authority viz. the District Court on appeals filed under Sec. 113 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 or under Sec. 189 of the Municipalities Act, 1994 and the question involved in this case is whether this court has got jurisdiction to entertain a revision under Sec. 115 of the C.P.C against the order passed by the Munsiffs Court considering the election petition under the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 19.94
6. The above submission made by the counsel for the respondent is of no force. If the law is applicable to the appellate authority functioning under special statute or under general law, the same law is applicable to the subordinate authority functioning under the same provisions of law. Therefore it is clear that the above order passed by the Munsiffs Court regarding the maintainability of the election petition is revisable by this court under Sec. 115 of the C.P.C Therefore, the objection raised by the respondent against the maintainability Of the revision petition is overruled.
7. The contention of the revision petitioner is that the above election petition is not sustainable in view of the violation of the mandatory provision of Sec. 89(1) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 and therefore the same is liable to be dismissed inlimine. Section 89 of the Panchayat Raj Act deals with the filing of election petitions. Section 89(1) stipulates that the election petition should be presented before the competent court within 30 days of the election. Section 89(2) mandates that every election petition should be accompanied by as many copies thereof as there are respondents mentioned in the petition and every such copy should be attested by the petitioner under his signature to be the true copy of the petition.
8. The revision petitioner/first respondent in the election petition has contended that the copy of the election petition received by him did not contain the attestation on all the pages of the copies and therefore there is no compliance of the mandatory provision of Sec. 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act and therefore the election petition is liable to be dismissed inlimine being unsustainable.
9. The counsel for the revision petitioner submitted that there is no dispute that the copy of the election petition served upon the revision petitioner did not contain the verification and signature of the petitioner in the election petition in all the pages. Therefore according to him, the mandatory provision of Sec. 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act is violated. He submits that even if there is no verification in all the pages of the copy of the election petition, there should be atleast signature of the election petitioner in all the pages of the election petition. In support of his contention, the counsel for revision petitioner relied upon several rulings.
10. In the decision reported in A. Mohamed v. Nalakath Soopy (1997 (1) KLT 697), a single Judge of this court observed as follows:
“It is no doubt true that the affixing of the signature in original in the copy at the place where the deponent has signed and at the place where the petitioner has signed in the original and at the place where the petitioner has verified the original may not be necessary. But in the absence of those signatures at the place where they are now placed, it could not be said that the copies would correspond to the original or that the copies could be considered as true copies of the original. In such a situation, in my view, affixing of at least another signature at the bottom of the concerned pages even if there is no attestation as the true copy by the petitioner was needed at least to hold that there was substantial compliance with the requirement of attestation as true copies within the meaning of Sec. 81(3) of the Act.”
11. In the decision reported in Narendra Bhikahi Darade v. Kalyanrao Jaywantrao Patil (AIR 2000 Bom. 362), a single Judge of the Bombay High Court has observed as follows:
“In the copy of the Election Petition absence of verification of concise statement and affidavit can be treated as not only a defect under Sec. 83(2), but also a non-compliance of the Section 81(3) of the Act as the true copy of the Election Petition cannot be said to be served on the respondent.”
12. The counsel for the respondent submitted that Sec. 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act mandates only attestation of copy as true copy of the election petition by the petitioner and it does not stipulate that every page of the copy should be attested and attestation of the copy of the election petition at the foot of the petition is sufficient compliance of Sec. 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act. In support of his contention, the counsel for the respondent relied upon the decision reported in F.A Sapa v. Singora ((1991) 3 SCC 375), wherein a three Judges bench of the Supreme Court has observed as follows:
“On a plain reading of Sec. 81(3) it becomes clear that the requirement of that provision is: (i) the election petition should be accompanied by as many copies thereof as there are respondents mentioned in the petition and (ii) every such copy shall be attested by the petitioner under his own signature to be a true copy of the petition. There is no dispute in regard to the compliance of the first part. So far as the second part is concerned, all that the section requires is that the copy should be attested by the petitioner to be a true copy of the petition under his own signature. The requirement of this part of the provision is met by each copy having been signed at the foot thereof by the concerned petitioner. What is essential is that the petitioner must take the responsibility of the copy being a true copy of the original petition and sign in token thereof. No particular form of attestation is prescribed; all that the sub-section enjoins is that the petitioner must attest the copy under his own signature to be a true copy of the petition. By clarifying the same as true copy and by putting his signature at the foot thereof, the petitioner of each election petition had clearly complied with the letter and spirit of Sec. 81(3) of the R.P Act.”
13. In the decision reported in Advocate Thomas v. Varghese Paul (1996 (2) KLJ 283), a Single Judge of this court following the above dictum, laid down by the Supreme Court, observed as follows:—
“Attestation made at the foot of the petition is substantial compliance of the provisions of Sec. 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act.
14. It is not in dispute that Sec. 81(3) of the Representation of People's Act under which the aforementioned case arose before the Supreme Court and the provisions of Sec. 89(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, are identical. Therefore, the counsel for the respondents submitted that the decision reported in 1996 (2) KLJ 283 relying upon the above judgment of the Supreme Court reported in (1991) 3 SCC 375 laying down that attestation of the election petition at the foot of the copy of the petition is proper compliance of Sec. 89(2) of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act should be accepted, in preference to the judgment of another single Judge of this court reported in 1997 (1) KLT 697, relied upon by the counsel for the petitioner.
15. The counsel for the revision petitioner submitted that in the decision reported in (1991) 3 SCC 375, the question came up before the Supreme Court was regarding attestation of the copy of the election petition served upon the respondents as true copy of the original petition and not the signature of the election petitioner to be put in all pages of the copies. It is clear from the observations made by the Supreme Court in the judgment that the Supreme Court has considered the requirement of attestation as well as the signature in the copy of the election petition while laying down the law as aforesaid. Therefore this contention raised by the revision petitioner that the Supreme Court has only considered attestation and did not consider the requirements of signature in every page of the copy of the petition is not sustainable.
16. It is submitted by the counsel for the petitioner that in view of the settled position of law that when there is conflict of decision between two benches of co-ordinate jurisdiction, the decisions rendered by the court later in point of time should be followed the judgment reported in 1997 (1) KLT 697 relied upon by him should be followed. It is seen that the judgment reported in 1997 (1) KLT 697 is pronounced by the single Judge of this court on 22-8-1996 and the decision reported in 1996 (2) KLJ 283 is pronounced by another single Judge of this court on 16-8-1996. Therefore the judgment reported in 1997 (1) KLT 697 is later in point of time. But it has to be noted that in the decision reported in 1997 (1) KLT 697 the judgment rendered by the three judges bench of the Supreme Court reported in (1991) 3 SCC 375 is not adverted to or considered by the Single Judge. Probably that decision might not have been brought to the notice of the Single Judge while considering the case. But in the decision reported in 1996 (2) KLJ 283, the learned single Judge has extracted the observations made by the Supreme Court in the decision reported in (1991) 3 SCC 375 and followed the dictum laid down by the Supreme Court in that judgment. Therefore I am inclined to follow the judgment of the single Judge reported in 1996 (2) KLJ 283, following the decision of the supreme court reported in (1991) 3 SCC 375 in preference to the judgment of this court reported in 1997 (1) KLT 697 and hold that attestation at the foot of the copy of the petition is sufficient compliance of Sec. 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act and due to the mere fact that the signature of the election petitioner is not affixed in some of the pages of the copy served upon the respondent, it cannot be contended that the mandatory provisions of Sec. 89(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act is not complied with and therefore the election petition should be dismissed inlimine.
17. It is clear from my foregoing discussions that the contention raised by the revision petitioner that the respondent should attest the copy of the election petition served upon her as true copy on all the pages in compliance of Sec. 89(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act and non-compliance of that mandatory provision is fatal and as such the election petition is not maintainable and the same should be dismissed in limine is not sustainable. It is also clear that the failure to attest the copy of the election petition as true copy on all pages of the copy of the election petition is not fatal, if it is properly attested at the foot of the petition. Therefore, the lower court is perfectly justified in negativing the contentions raised by the revision petitioner that the election petition is liable to be dismissed in limine for violation of the mandatory provisions of Sec. 89(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act. Hence I find the above revision petition is devoid of any merits and the same is dismissed.
Alert