Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Income-Tax Officer v. Diza Holdings (P.) Ltd.

Kerala High Court
Nov 16, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal under section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 was brought at the instance of the Income-tax Officer (Revenue) and was admitted on two substantial questions of law formulated by this Court.

The assessee is a private limited company engaged in money-lending for the assessment year 1988–89. The company filed a return showing a loss of Rs. 1,320. The Assessing Officer (AO) found deposits totalling Rs. 3,33,700 credited in the books for the previous year ending June 30, 1987, described as deposits from eleven persons. The AO called for explanations, summoned and examined the alleged depositors, and conducted an enquiry. On the basis of evidence and inferences drawn, the AO concluded that the sums were not advanced by those alleged depositors and that payments were linked to Jaya Electricals (a partnership in which a director of the assessee, P.D. John, was a partner). The AO also found that the funds were channelled into the assessee-company and in many cases made their way back to the director and his family. The AO therefore treated the amount of Rs. 3,33,700 as the income of the assessee for that previous year and assessed it under section 68 of the Income-tax Act.

The assessee appealed to the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)], who deleted the addition, accepting the assessee's argument that the payments were made and received by account-payee cheques and hence genuine. The Revenue appealed to the Appellate Tribunal, where a Single Member Bench agreed with the CIT(A) without discussing the AO's evidentiary findings and dismissed the appeal. The Revenue then appealed to this Court under section 260A.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was right in law in cancelling the order of the Assessing Officer who had held deposits totalling Rs. 3,33,700 in the names of 11 depositors as unexplained cash credits and assessed the same under section 68 of the Income-tax Act?
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in interfering with the reasoning of the Assessing Officer who had concluded that the bank account, through which the deposits were said to have been routed, had been opened only to lend a shade of genuineness to transactions which were not genuine?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Revenue / Assessing Officer)

  • The Assessing Officer conducted an enquiry, summoned the alleged depositors and recorded detailed findings and inferences from the evidence.
  • The AO found that the alleged depositors could not prove receipt or authenticity of the funds; some lacked resources and were not fully aware of the alleged deposits.
  • Jaya Electricals (a partnership with P.D. John, a director of the assessee) had paid the amounts to the depositors and the payments were channelled into the assessee-company and, in many cases, returned to the director and his family, indicating the transactions were not genuine.
  • Therefore, under section 68 the AO treated the Rs. 3,33,700 as income of the assessee and made the addition; the AO's decision was supported by the evidence and properly reasoned.
  • The CIT(A) and the Appellate Tribunal erred in not addressing the AO's evidentiary findings and in allowing the appeal solely because payments were by cheque.

Respondent (Assessee)

  • The assessee argued that the amounts were paid by Jaya Electricals to various persons by cheques and those persons in turn paid the amounts to the assessee-company by cheques, showing that the transactions were genuine.
  • The assessee's counsel contended that once it is found deposits were made by account-payee cheques and credited to the assessee's account, the AO had no jurisdiction to further inquire into whether the person who made the deposit had the source to make such a deposit.
  • Counsel for the assessee also referred to a subsequent assessment under section 147 in the name of "Jaya Trust" (unclear if same as Jaya Electricals) where Rs. 1,50,000 out of Rs. 3,33,700 was treated as income of Jaya Trust on the basis that advances/payments were bogus; the assessee argued this decision's impact should be considered and might affect double taxation concerns.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in these main steps, following the terms of section 68 of the Income-tax Act:

  1. Statutory framework: Section 68 places the burden on the assessee to offer a satisfactory explanation about the nature and source of any sum found credited in the books; mere furnishing of particulars or the fact that payment was by account-payee cheque is not conclusive.
  2. Findings about the AO's investigation: The AO was entitled to call for an explanation, did so, and, finding the prima facie explanation unsatisfactory, held an inquiry. The AO summoned the alleged depositors and recorded their evidence. The AO pointed out infirmities and improbabilities in the transactions and found the depositors could not prove authenticity or source of funds; some depositors were not even aware of the alleged deposits.
  3. Specific material facts: The AO found a link between Jaya Electricals and the depositors/payments and noted that Jaya Electricals had P.D. John (a director of the assessee) as a partner; many payments were channelled back to the director and his family. On the basis of the material and inferences, the AO concluded the amounts were not genuine advances and added Rs. 3,33,700 to the assessee's income under section 68.
  4. Errors by lower authorities: The Court found that the CIT(A) and the Appellate Tribunal erred in law by failing to ask the right question and by being carried away by the mere fact that payments were by cheque. Both bodies did not advert to or properly consider the AO's evidence and reasoning and thus misdirected themselves into an erroneous line of inquiry.
  5. Application of legal principle: Given the burden under section 68 and the evidentiary record compiled by the AO, the Court concluded the AO had made the correct approach and that his findings were amply supported by the materials. The mere presence of cheque payments did not preclude the AO from finding the deposits unexplained.
  6. Remittal for related assessment impact: The Court accepted the assessee's point that a subsequent assessment under section 147 had treated Rs. 1,50,000 (out of the Rs. 3,33,700) as income of Jaya Trust. While it was unclear whether Jaya Trust was identical to Jaya Electricals, the Court directed that the Assessing Officer be asked to consider the impact of that assessment (dated August 29, 1995) and to recompute the assessee's income if necessary, passing consequential orders.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal by the Revenue was allowed; the orders of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal were set aside and the order of the Assessing Officer was restored.

Implications and consequences:

  • The Assessing Officer's addition of Rs. 3,33,700 to the income of the assessee for the relevant previous year (assessment under section 68) stands restored by this Court.
  • The matter is remitted to the Assessing Officer with directions to consider the effect, if any, of the assessment dated August 29, 1995 (under section 147) against "Jaya Trust" in respect of Rs. 1,50,000 and to recompute the assessee's income and pass consequential orders after deciding the specific question relating to that Rs. 1,50,000.
  • No broader precedent or new legal principle was announced beyond the application of section 68 to the facts; the Court emphasized that cheque payment is not conclusive and that the burden on the assessee to satisfactorily explain credits remains.
Show all summary ...

P.K Balasubramanyan, J.:— This appeal under section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, at the instance of the Income-tax Officer was admitted by this court on the following-substantial questions of law:

“1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal is right in law in cancelling the order of the Assessing Officer who held the deposits totalling to Rs. 3,33,700 in the name of the 11 depositors as unexplained cash credits and assessed the same under section 68 of the Income-tax Act?

2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal is justified in interfering with the reasoning of the Assessing Officer who logically concluded that the bank account, through which the deposits are said to have been routed, have been, opened only to lend a shade of genuiness to these transactions which were not genuine?”

2. On receipt of notices on these substantial questions of law on which the appeal was to be heard, the assessee appeared through counsel. Both sides were finally heard. For the assessment year 1988–89, the assessee, a private limited company, filed its return of income showing a loss of Rs. 1,320. The company is running the business of money-lending. The Assessing Officer found that deposits for various amounts in the names of 11 persons were found credited in the books of the assessee maintained for the previous year ending on June 30, 1987. The Assessing Officer called for explanation about the nature and source of the said credit entries or deposits amounting to Rs. 3,33,700. The assessee explained that they were deposits received from eleven persons and furnished the names of those persons. The. Assessing Officer was not satisfied immediately about the explanation of the assessee. The Assessing Officer thereupon summoned the 11 depositors as per the books of the company and examined them. He also conducted an enquiry. Thereafter he recorded the finding that the explanation offered by the assessee regarding the nature and source of the sum found credited in the books of the company was not satisfactory and hence the amount had to be charged to income-tax as income of the assessee for the previous year. The Assessing Officer recorded the clear circumstances emerging from the evidence and the inferences drawn by him from the evidence gathered by him in support of his conclusion. He ultimately concluded after a discussion of all the relevant aspects that the deposit of Rs. 3,33,700 shown as having been advanced by 11 depositors was, in fact, never advanced by them and that they had no connection with the money. The Assessing Officer also found that Jaya Electricals which is said to have paid the amounts to the depositors, who had allegedly deposited the amounts in the assessee-company, was a partnership wherein P.D John, a director of the assessee-company, was a partner. The Assessing Officer also found that the payments were channelled into the assessee-company and have in most of the cases found their way back to the director, Mr. P.D John, his wife, and his son in one way or another. It was thus that the Assessing Officer treated this amount as income of the assessee for the previous year.

3. The assessee appealed. The argument on behalf of the assessee was that the amounts were paid by Jaya Electricals to the various persons shown as depositors in the assessee-company, by cheques and that they had in turn paid the amounts to the assessee-company by way of cheques and this showed that the transactions were genuine and the Assessing Officer was in error in treating the sum of Rs. 3,33,700 as the income of the assessee-company for the previous year. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) did not consider the reasons given by the Assessing Officer for coming to the conclusion that the explanation of the assessee was not satisfactory and treating the amount as income of the assessee for the previous year based on the evidence he had taken. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) even without discussing or adverting to such evidence, accepted the argument on behalf of the assessee that since the payments were made by way of cheques, the Assessing Officer was not entitled to treat the amount shown as deposits received by the assessee-company as the income of the company for the previous year in terms of section 68 of the Income-tax Act. Thus, the. Commissioner of Income-tax deleted the addition of Rs. 3,33,700. The Revenue appealed before the Appellate Tribunal. A single Member Bench of the Tribunal, again, without adverting to the evidence and the circumstances discussed by the Assessing Officer, simply agreed with the approach and conclusion of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and dismissed the appeal. It is the submission of the appellant that the decision of the Tribunal suffers from substantial errors of law as reflected by the two substantial questions of law referred to above.

4. Section 68 of the Income-tax Act reads thus:

“Where any sum is found credited in the books of an assessee maintained for any previous year, and the assessee offers no explanation about the nature and source thereof or the explanation offered by him is not, in the opinion of the Assessing Officer, satisfactory, the sum so credited may be charged to income-tax as the income of the assessee of that previous year.”

5. There is no doubt that a sum of Rs. 3,33,700 was found credited in the books of the assessee maintained for the previous year relevant to the assessment year. The Assessing Officer was, therefore, entitled to call for an explanation regarding the credit thus shown. The Assessing Officer called for an explanation. The assessee offered an explanation. Finding that, prima fade, the explanation could not be accepted without an enquiry into it, the Assessing Officer conducted an enquiry. The sum was shown as being credited as deposits from 11 persons, whose names the assessee furnished. The Assessing Officer thereupon summoned those persons and examined them. One alone was not available for examination. The Assessing Officer in his order has detailed the evidence given by these persons and has also pointed out the infirmities and improbabilities surrounding the transactions. None of them could prove the authenticity of the receipt of the funds and the only fact was that they were routed through the bank. Some of them could not even show on what basis or for what reason Jaya Electricals had paid them such an amount. Thus, on an assessment of the materials available, which, on going through the elaborate discussion by the Assessing Officer, we find to be satisfactory and proper, the Assessing Officer held that the sum of Rs. 3,33,700 had to be charged to income-tax as the income of the assessee for the previous year.

6. According to us, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) did not ask himself the right question. He was carried away by the fact that Jaya Electricals had paid these amounts to the 11 persons by way of cheques and that the deposits had been made by way of cheques. He did not advert to the reasons given by the Assessing Officer for finding that the explanation of the assessee for this sum credited in the books of the assessee was not satisfactory. He had nothing to say about the evidence gathered by the Assessing Officer while completing the assessment on the basis that the sum had to be treated as income in terms of section 68 of the Act and charged to income-tax as the income of the assessee for the previous year. Accepting the case of the assessee that since the deposits were made by way of cheques nothing more remains, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) allowed the appeal and deleted the sum of Rs. 3,33,700. As we have noticed, the Appellate Tribunal has also done the same, thereby misdirecting itself into an erroneous line of enquiry.

7. It is clear on the terms of section 68 of the Act, that the burden is on the assessee to offer a satisfactory explanation about the nature and source of the amount found credited in the books of the assessee. It is also clear that the mere furnishing of particulars is not enough. The mere fact that payment was by way of account payee cheque is also not conclusive. Therefore, the Assessing Officer was entitled to consider whether notwithstanding the fact that the payments were made by cheques, whether the assessee has satisfactorily explained the nature and source of the amounts found credited in the books of the assessee. It is clear that the Assessing Officer was satisfied that the so called depositors did not have the resources to make such deposits. A reading of the order of the Assessing Officer also shows that some of the alleged depositors were not even fully aware of what had happened regarding these deposits alleged to have been made by them in the assessee-company. In this situation, according to us, the Assessing Officer was fully justified in finding that the explanation of the assessee was unsatisfactory regarding the amount found credited in the books of the assessee.

8. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Appellate Tribunal, in our view, have committed a substantial error of law in not properly approaching the question arising for consideration and arising out of the findings rendered by the Assessing Officer. According to us, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Appellate Tribunal have not asked themselves the right question. In such a situation, it has to be held that they have committed a substantial error of law in interfering with the order of the assessing authority without proper basis. We are therefore, satisfied that interference by this court is called for in this appeal filed under section 260A of the Income-tax Act. Then the question is whether the Assessing Officer was justified in proceeding to treat the deposit as income of the assessee in the previous year in terms of section 68 of the Income-tax Act. We have already indicated that the Assessing Officer has made the correct approach to the question and the finding rendered by him is-amply supported by the materials relied on by him and discussed by him in his order. In that situation, we are of the view that the Assessing Officer was justified in adding a sum of Rs. 3,33,700 towards the income of the assessee for the previous year relevant to the assessment year. Hence, we answer, the substantial questions of law formulated in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee. The result of the same is that we have to restore the order of the Assessing Officer. Hence, we restore the order of the Assessing Officer.

9. Learned counsel for the assessee argued that once it is found that the deposits into the assessee-company were made by way of cheques and the amount had been credited to the account of the assessee, he had no jurisdiction to enquire into the question whether the person who is said to have made the deposit had the source to make such a deposit. In the context of section 68 of the Act and in the light of the materials available in the case, this argument on the side of the assessee cannot be accepted. Learned counsel for the assessee brought to our notice that subsequent to the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), an assessment has been made under section 147 of the Income-tax Act in the name of Jaya Trust (it is not clear whether this is the same as the Jaya Electricals referred to in the present proceeding). According to-counsel for the assessee, an amount of Rs. 1,50,000 out of Rs. 3,33,700 has been treated as the income of Jaya Trust on a finding that the advances or payments alleged to have been made as commission, etc., by Jaya Trust was bogus and that the same was liable to be added to the income of Jaya Trust. Counsel also points out that there is also reference to the decision of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) in the case relating to the present assessee, while completing the assessment against Jaya Trust. Counsel submitted that the impact of this order on the present proceeding has also to be considered by this court. If a sum of Rs. 1,50,000 out of sum of Rs. 3,33,700 is found to be a fictitious payment by Jaya Trust (if it is the same as Jaya Electricals) and the same is disallowed by the Assessing Officer in the case of Jaya Trust, the question would arise whether the said sum of Rs. 1,50,000 already taxed at the hands of Jaya Trust could get taxed also at the hands of the assessee. In any event, there cannot be any doubt regarding the amount other than Rs. 1,50,000 said to have been taxed at the hands of Jaya Trust referred to by counsel for the assessee. That part of the order of the Assessing Officer is final. We think that in the circumstances, the Assessing Officer must be directed to recompute the income of the assessee, if it is necessary, after considering the impact of the order of assessment dated August 29, 1995, against Jaya Trust. To consider whether any such deletion is needed or warranted and to pass consequential orders based thereon, the matter will stand remitted to the Assessing Officer.

10. In the result, we allow the appeal and setting aside the orders of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, restore the order of the Assessing Officer. We remit the proceedings to the Assessing Officer to consider the claim of the assessee regarding the sum of Rs. 1,50,000 as set out in paragraph 9 (page 578) of this judgment and pass consequential orders after deciding that question relating to the sum of Rs. 1,50,000.