- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nalini v. State Of Kerala
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal was preferred by the Manager of a Lower Primary (L.P.) School challenging the judgment in O.P. No. 31294 of 1999. The Manager had filed a writ petition against orders of educational authorities directing appointment of the sixth respondent, Smt. M. Pravida, as L.P.S.A. with effect from 7.6.1994.
Relevant factual chronology recorded in the opinion:
- Sixth respondent was appointed as L.P.S.A. for the period 1.7.1992 to 28.9.1992 and that appointment was approved by the Assistant Educational Officer on 31.8.1992.
- She was subsequently removed from service due to a reduction in posts (fall of division).
- A permanent vacancy arose on 20.11.1997; the sixth respondent alleged the Manager did not take steps to appoint her on earlier vacancies that arose on 7.6.1994 to 30.11.1994, 6.9.1996 to 4.12.1996, 13.1.1997 to 21.3.1997 and 2.6.1997 to 29.8.1997.
- Sixth respondent lodged complaints with the Assistant Educational Officer (A.E.O.) and the District Educational Officer (D.E.O.). A personal hearing was held on 10.9.1998.
- The A.E.O. found the Manager had not complied with the provisions of the Kerala Education Act and Rules and the Director of Public Instruction's circular dated 6.1.1997, and directed the Manager on 24.9.1998 to appoint the sixth respondent within seven days.
- The Manager did not comply; the A.E.O. issued a show-cause notice dated 2.11.1998 proposing disciplinary action under R.7 Chapter III of the Kerala Education Rules. The Manager filed revision before the Government.
- The Government, after notice dated 5.7.1999, held the Manager had failed to comply with Note 2 to R.51A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules, declared the sixth respondent entitled to appointment notionally from 7.6.1994 with service benefits (pay and allowances to be paid only from date of joining, but if delay then from date of Government order and recoverable from Manager).
- The Manager's writ petition was dismissed by the Single Judge; this appeal followed. The court heard counsel for the parties and the Government Pleader.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the sixth respondent, having been previously appointed and approved (1.7.1992–28.9.1992), is entitled to preferential reappointment under R.51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules when vacancies arose subsequently.
- Whether a purported relinquishment (allegedly handwritten on the reverse of an appointment order dated 19.11.1997) by the sixth respondent, or the Manager's failure to act earlier, extinguishes her preferential right under R.51-A.
- Whether the Manager complied with Note 2 to R.51-A and with the Circular of the Director of Public Instruction dated 6.1.1997 concerning the procedure for appointment and for acceptance/approval of any relinquishment of claim.
- Whether the interpretation given by the Division Bench in Lakshmikutty Amma v. Vijayalakshmikutty (1992 (2) KLT 341) — particularly the mandatory nature of Note 2 to R.51-A — is binding and applicable to this case despite the Manager's reliance on other authority.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Manager's) Arguments
- The Manager contended the sixth respondent had relinquished her claim when an appointment order was issued on 19.11.1997 and she wrote on the reverse of the appointment order in her own handwriting, in the presence of witnesses, that she relinquished the appointment; therefore she lost her right under R.51-A.
- The Manager argued that R.51-A claims are available only to those relieved under R.49 or R.52 or termination of vacancies, and that the sixth respondent, by relinquishing, did not satisfy requirements of R.49 or R.52 for reappointment.
- The Manager asserted the sixth respondent was aware of earlier vacancies (being resident nearby) and did not claim appointment earlier, and that when an offer was made she was unwilling to accept it.
- Counsel relied on a decision of a learned single Judge reported as Manager, MUUPS, v. A.E.O (1998 (2) KLJ 871), contending that that decision represents the correct interpretation of R.51-A and that the Division Bench decision in Lakshmikutty Amma v. Vijayalakshmikutty (1992 (2) KLT 341) requires reconsideration.
Sixth Respondent's Arguments
- Sixth respondent submitted the Manager was bound to follow Note 2 to R.51-A, which requires issuing an appointment order by Registered Post Acknowledgment Due and allow 14 clear days to join duty; those procedures were not complied with.
- She contended the Manager did not issue appointment orders on the earlier vacancies listed and denied execution of any relinquishment letter or that an offer of appointment had been made to her.
- Counsel relied on earlier authorities including Pathumma v. State of Kerala (1986 KLT 166) and Vijayalakshmikutty v. State of Kerala (1991 (2) KLT Short Notes 11 Page 9) to support her entitlement under R.51-A and the requirement of following statutory procedure.
Government's Position (as recorded)
- On revision the Government found the Manager failed to comply with Note 2 to R.51-A of Chapter XIV-A and had illegally denied appointment to a R.51-A claimant, i.e., the sixth respondent.
- The Government declared the sixth respondent entitled to appointment notionally from 7.6.1994 with all service benefits including seniority, with pay and allowances payable only from the date of joining; and if there was delay in issuing appointment, pay and allowances would be paid from the date of the Government order and recoverable from the Manager.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Lakshmikutty Amma v. Vijayalakshmikutty, 1992 (2) KLT 341 | Held that Note 2 to R.51-A is mandatory; preferential right under R.51-A cannot be forfeited except by the procedure prescribed in Note 2; relinquishment letters do not effect forfeiture unless procedure (including departmental approval) is complied with; rules based on public policy to defeat malpractices. | The court followed this Division Bench decision as authoritative and binding, applied its holding to reject the Manager's contention that a purported relinquishment deprived the sixth respondent of her R.51-A right, and reiterated that Note 2 must be complied with as mandatory procedure. |
| Manager, MUUPS, v. A.E.O., 1998 (2) KLJ 871 (learned Single Judge) | Relied on by the Manager as an interpretation of R.51-A purportedly supporting forfeiture where factual circumstances differed. | The court rejected the Manager's attempt to rely on this decision to overturn Lakshmikutty Amma, distinguishing the single judge's facts (teacher absenting herself while in service and not a termination under R.49) and concluding there was no reason to depart from the Division Bench's view. |
| Pathumma v. State of Kerala, (1986 KLT 166) | Cited by the sixth respondent in support of her position regarding entitlement and procedural requirements (specific principle not elaborated beyond reliance). | The opinion records reliance by the sixth respondent on this decision; the court's reasoning did not reject the reliance and proceeded on the basis that statutory procedure must be followed. |
| Vijayalakshmikutty v. State of Kerala, 1991 (2) KLT Short Notes 11 Page 9 | Cited by sixth respondent to support her contention about entitlement and procedure (specific principle not elaborated beyond reliance). | The court noted the sixth respondent's reliance on this authority; the opinion relies on the Division Bench precedent rather than treating this authority as determinative. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded step-by-step through the legal and factual matrix, applying statutory provisions and precedent as recorded in the opinion:
- The court accepted the undisputed factual premise that the sixth respondent had been appointed and her earlier service (1.7.1992–28.9.1992) had been approved by the A.E.O. It observed R.52 of Chapter XIV-A provides that a teacher relieved due to reduction in posts shall, on reappointment, start on the same pay as at the time of relief; thus the sixth respondent was entitled to reappointment under R.51-A.
- The Manager's primary factual-legal contention was that the sixth respondent had relinquished her claim by writing on the reverse of an appointment order dated 19.11.1997; therefore, she could not claim reappointment under R.51-A. The Manager also argued that R.51-A claims arise only where a teacher is relieved under R.49 or R.52, and that the sixth respondent no longer satisfied those requirements due to the alleged relinquishment.
- The court addressed the authoritative Division Bench decision in Lakshmikutty Amma (1992 (2) KLT 341), which it summarized as holding that Note 2 to R.51-A is mandatory, that the procedure under Note 2 (including two registered notices and specific timings) must be followed, and that voluntary relinquishment letters cannot effect forfeiture of the preferential right unless the prescribed procedure (including departmental approval) is followed.
- Applying Lakshmikutty Amma, the court concluded the Note 2 procedure is mandatory and prevents managers from bypassing the statutory safeguard; it emphasized that statutory acts required in a particular manner can only be done in that manner.
- The court rejected the Manager's reliance on Manager, MUUPS, v. A.E.O. (1998 (2) KLJ 871) as distinguishable: that decision involved a teacher who absented herself while in service and who was held not to have a claim under R.51-A; the court found no basis to treat that single-judge decision as overruling or displacing the Division Bench's clear pronouncement.
- The court noted the Manager had not complied with the departmental circular dated 6.1.1997 prescribing a procedure where relinquishment letters are involved (including requirement of written consent, period specification for temporary relinquishment, approval by the Educational Officer, non-withdrawal after approval, and forwarding of relinquishment letters for approval of appointment proposals). The Manager did not assert compliance with that procedure.
- Given the Manager's failure to show compliance with Note 2 to R.51-A and the D.P.I. circular, and the history of vacancies without proper appointment action, the court found the Manager's contentions to be untenable attempts to circumvent the statutory procedure and the Division Bench precedent.
- The court therefore upheld the Government's determination that the sixth respondent was entitled to appointment notionally from 7.6.1994, and that the Manager must comply with the Government order. The court also recorded the Government's position on pay and allowances and the right of the department to recover amounts paid in case of delayed appointment.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED
Direct effects and remedial directions (as recorded in the opinion):
- The appeal is dismissed and the judgment of the Single Judge is affirmed.
- The Manager is directed to comply with the Government order and give appointment to the sixth respondent in accordance with the Government's determination; the Manager must comply within two weeks from the date of the judgment.
- The Manager is ordered to pay costs of Rs. 2,500/- to the sixth respondent.
- The Government's prior direction (dated 11.1.1999) stands: the sixth respondent is entitled to appointment notionally from 7.6.1994 with service benefits including seniority; pay and allowances are payable from the date of joining, but if there is delay, pay and allowances will be paid from the date of the Government order and the amount so paid would be recovered from the Manager.
- If the Manager fails to comply within the two-week period, the department will take appropriate disciplinary proceedings.
The court explicitly applied and reaffirmed the Division Bench interpretation in Lakshmikutty Amma v. Vijayalakshmikutty (1992 (2) KLT 341) that Note 2 to R.51-A is mandatory and that relinquishment does not effect forfeiture unless the prescribed procedure (including departmental approval) is followed. The opinion records that the Manager's request to revisit that Division Bench decision lacked bona fides and was an attempt to over-reach established principle.
No other broader legal implications or new precedents were created beyond the reaffirmation and application of the Division Bench's interpretation of Note 2 to R.51-A and the related departmental circular; the decision enforces compliance with those established procedures.
K.S Radhakrishnan, J.:— This appeal is preferred by the Manager of a L.P School, aggrieved by the judgment in O.P No. 31294 of 1999. Writ Petition was preferred by the Manager challenging the orders passed by the educational authorities directing the Manager to appoint Smt. M. Pravida, sixth respondent, L.P.S.A with effect from 7.6.1994
2. Sixth respondent was appointed as L.P.S.A during the period 1.7.1992 to 28.9.1992 That appointment was approved; by the fifth respondent, Assistant Educational Officer, as per order dated 31.8.1992 On 20.11.1997 a permanent vacancy arose in the school. Sixth respondent submitted that even though regular vacancy arose Manager did not take steps to appoint her. Consequently she filed complaint before the Assistant Educational Officer on 30.7.1998 She also filed complaint before the District Educational Officer Kannur and the same was forwarded by the District Educational Officer to Assistant Educational Officer, Taliparamaba. Assistant Educational Officer gave personal hearing to all the parties on 10.9.1998 Sixth respondent and Manager appeared before the Assistant Educational Officer on the said date. Enquiry revealed that vacancy of L.P.S.A arose for the period from 7.6.1994 to 30.11.1994, 6.9.1996 to 4.12.1996, 13.1.1997 to 21.3.1997 and 2.6.1997 to 29.8.1997 and again permanent vacancy on 20.11.1997 Before the Assistant Educational Officer Manager submitted that appointment order was issued to sixth respondent on 19.11.1997 but due to health reasons she relinquished the said appointment by writing on the reverse side of the appointment order in the presence of witnesses. The Manager took up the stand that under such circumstances she could not be appointed. Assistant Educational Officer did not accept the contention of the Manager and found that the Manager has not complied with the provisions of the Kerala Education Act and Rules and also the Circular issued by the Director of Public Instruction dated 6.1.1997 Assistant Educational Officer passed an order on 24.9.1998 directing the Manager to appoint sixth respondent within seven days of receipt of the said order. Manager did not take any action on the basis of the said order passed by the Assistant Educational Officer. Consequently Assistant Educational Officer issued a notice dated 2.11.1998 to show cause why disciplinary action should not be taken against the Manager as per R. 7 Chapter III of the Kerala Education Rules. Manager aggrieved by the order passed by the Assistant Educational Officer filed revision before the Government. Government issued notice to all the affected parties on 5.7.1999 Government found that Manager failed to comply with Note 2 to R. 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules and has illegally denied appointment to sixth respondent who is a R. 51-A claimant. Government declared that sixth respondent is entitled to get appointment from 7.6.1994 onwards notionally with all service benefits including seniority, subject to condition that pay and allowances will be paid only with effect from the date from which she joins duty in the school. It was also made clear that if there is any delay to give appointment order to sixth respondent she would be paid pay and allowances from the date of the Government order and the amount so paid would be recovered from the Manager. In spite of that Manager did not take any steps to give appointment to sixth respondent and filed the Writ Petition which was dismissed by the learned single Judge against which the present appeal has been filed.
3. We heard learned counsel for the appellant Sri. Govindh K. Bharathan and counsel for sixth respondent Sr. M.C Narabiar and also learned Government Pleader Sri. C.K Pavithran.
4. It is not in dispute that sixth respondent was appointed in the school for a period from 1.7.1992 to 28.9.1992 and the said appointment was approved by the Assistant Educational Officer dated 31.8.1992 Subsequently she was thrown out of service due to fall of division. R. 52 of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules says that teachers who are relieved on account of any reduction in the number of posts under orders of the department shall on reappointment in the same school or in another school under the same management or a different management start on the same pay as they were getting at the time of relief, whether the new appointment is permanent or not. Since sixth respondent was appointed and the period during which she worked had been approved, admittedly she is entitled to get reappointment under R. 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of K.E.R
5. The above mentioned legal position is not disputed by either side. But the stand of the Manager is that even though sixth respondent, a R. 51-A claimant she has lost her right for re-appointment under R. 51-A since she has relinquished her right when order of appointment was made to her on 19.11.1997 Manager submitted on the same day on the reverse side of the appointment order sixth respondent in her own handwriting relinquished her claim for appointment in the presence of witnesses. She is therefore not entitled to get the benefit of R. 51-A. Manager submitted that claim under R. 51 -A is available to those persons who were relieved as per R.49 or R.52 or on account of termination of vacancies. Since sixth respondent has relinquished her claim, she does not satisfy the requirement of R. 49 or R. 52. It is his contention that sixth respondent was aware of the vacancies which arose on various occasions. However she has not made any claim for appointment. When offer of appointment was made also she was not willing to accept the same. It is under such circumstances counsel submitted that Manager could not comply with Note 2 to R. 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of K.E.R Counsel also made reference to the decision of a learned single Judge of this court in Manager, MUUPS, v. A.E.O (1998 (2) KLJ 871). It is his contention that the principle laid down by the learned single Judge is the correct interpretation of R. 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of K.E.R and therefore the decision of this court in Lakshmikutty Amma v. Vijayalakshmikutty reported in 1992 (2) KLT 341 requires reconsideration.
6. Counsel for sixth respondent on the other hand submitted that the Manager is bound to comply with the statutory requirement of Note 2 to R. 51-A of Chapter XIV-A K.E.R As per Note 2 to R. 51 - A Manager is bound to issue appointment order to the teacher by Registered post acknowledgment due and give a period of fourteen clear days to the teacher to join duty. Various procedures laid down in the said Note were not complied with by the Manager. Counsel also contended that in spite of the fact that vacancy arose in the school on various occasions; namely 7.6.1994 to 30.11.1994, 6.0.1996 to 4.12.1996, 13.1.1997 to 21.3.1997 and 2.6.1997 to 29.8.1997 the Manager did not take any steps to issue appointment order to sixth respondent. Sixth respondent also denied the alleged execution of the relinquishment letter or that the Manager had made an offer of appointment. Counsel placed reliance on the decision of this Court in Pathumma v. State Of Kerala (1986 KLT 166) and also the decision in Vijayalakshmikutty v. State of Kerala 1991 (2) KLT Short Notes 11 Page 9.
7. We are of the view that the question raised in this case is no more res integra. This court in Lakshmikutty Atnma's case (1992 (2) KLT 341) elaborately considered the scope of Note II to R. 51-A and reminded Managers of schools the necessity of complying with the said procedure which the court has held as mandatory. This court took the view that R. 51-A and the Note thereunder are clearly based on public policy so as to defeat malpractices in employment in various aided schools. This Court held:
“The procedure contained in Note 2 to R. 51-A is mandatory and that there cannot be forfeiture of right accrued under R. 51 -A in any manner otherwise than by the procedure provided by Note 2 and that consequently the relinquishment letters even if executed voluntarily by the teacher relinquishing his or her right under R. 51-A cannot result in the forfeiture of the preferential right to appointment. R. 51 -A and Note 2 thereunder are based upon public policy and they are intended to prevent malpractices.”
8. With regard to Note 2 to R. 51-A the Court held as follows:-
“The Note contemplates that initially the Manager should issue an order of appointment to the teacher concerned by Registered Post acknowledgment due and give 14 clear days to the teacher to join duty. If the teacher did not join duty in time; the Manager is bound to give a further notice to the teacher stating that another person would be appointed instead and that the preferential right under R. 51-A would be forfeited if not exercised within seven clear days. If nothing is heard during that time also, the preferential right under the Rule will be regarded as forfeited. In other words, Note 2 requires two registered notices to be issued as stated above, and under the second notice, the Manager has to give the option to the teacher to exercise the preferential right within seven clear days. It is only when such an option is not exercised by the teacher, her or his preferential right would be forfeited. It is now well settled that if a statute prescribes that an act has to be done in a particular manner, that act can be done only in that manner, and in no other manner. If a statute gives a power to do a certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all and other methods of performance are necessarily forbidden.”
9. We cannot also accept the contention of the counsel for the appellant that learned single Judge has taken a different view in the aforementioned case. That was a case where the teacher absented himself from duty while she was in service. Therefore learned Judge said there was no question of termination of service arises under R.49 Consequently she lost her claim under R. 51-A. However, learned single Judge has also took the view that petitioner therein was not qualified to hold the post. In such circumstance the claim for reappointment under R. 51-A was negatived. In such circumstances we find no reason to take a different view from that of Lakshmikutty Amma's case, (supra).
10. We may also point out that Manager is bound to comply with R.51-A of Chapter XIV-A as and when vacancy arises subsequent to the relief of a teacher under R.49 or R.52 Teacher gets the right to preferential appointment under R.51-A and as and when the vacancy arises Manager is bound to comply with the procedure under R.51-A. Manager cannot deny the statutory claim under R.51-A on the plea that the teacher had submitted a relinquishment letter to the Manager.
11. We are of the view when court gives an interpretation to a particular provision, the Government and the Manager of aided schools are bound to follow the interpretation. Nobody can ignore the court's interpretation of a rule on the plea that they were not parties to the judgment. The request of the appellant to consider the judgment of the Division Bench in Lakshmikutty Amma's case lacks bona fide. This is only an attempt to over-reach the principle laid down by the Division Bench. We may also indicate even in case where there is a genuine letter of relinquishment of a claim under R. 51-A, Manager is bound to follow the procedure laid down in the Circular No. ET3/87201/96 dated 6.1.1997 and to get approval of the department for relinquishment of right under R. 51-A. The department accordingly laid down the following procedure in the case where relinquishment letter is submitted by teachers. We may extract the relevant portion for easy reference.
“1) whenever the Manager intends to appoint or promote a person other than the senior claimant, the Manager shall obtain a written consent in advance from such senior claimant renouncing his/her claim either permanently or temporarily.
2) In the case of temporary relinquishments the period of relinquishment should necessarily be furnished in the relinquishment letter.
3) Such relinquishment letters accepted by the appointing authority shall have the approval of Educational Officer concerned (A.E.O in the case of Primary and D.E.O in the case of Secondary).
4) Employees shall not be allowed to withdraw the relinquishment of their claim once accepted and approved by the Controlling Officer.
5) While making appointments/promotions of juniors on the strength of relinquishment letters of rightful claimants, the letters renouncing the claim duly accepted by the appointing authority and approved by the Controlling Officers should invariably be sent along with the proposals for approval of appointments.
12. Manager has no case that he has complied with the above procedure laid down by the Director of Public Instruction. In other words, Manager has not complied with Note 2 to R. 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of K.E.R as well as the Circular issued by the Director of Public Instruction on 6.1.1997 We also notice from the facts stated above that four vacancies arose prior to 20.11.1997 Manager has no case that he had offered appointment to sixth respondent and he has no case that sixth respondent had relinquished the claim for appointment in those vacancies. Manager's case is that sixth respondent is residing nearby the school and is therefore aware of the vacancies.
13. We are of the view untenable contentions are being raised to get over the statutory procedure and the principle laid down by the Division Bench of this Court and the Circular issued by the Department. In this case we notice that teacher was kept out of service for number or years without following the statutory procedure and contrary to the principles laid down by this Court. In such circumstances we are inclined to dismiss this appeal with costs of Rs. 2,500/- to be paid to sixth respondent. Government in the order dated 11.1.1999 have stated that if there was any delay on the part of the manager to give appointment order to the sixth respondent she would be paid pay and allowances from the date of the Government order and the amount so paid would be recovered from the Manager. We make it clear that direction given by the Government would stand. Manager would comply with the judgment within a period of two weeks from today; failing which department will take appropriate disciplinary proceedings. The appeal is dismissed as above.
Alert