Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Travancore Plywood Industries Ltd. v. Regional Joint Labour Commissioner And Others

Kerala High Court
Jan 19, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The third respondent was an employee of the petitioner-company and retired on superannuation on 19 June 1984. The petitioner-company refused to pay the gratuity due to the third respondent. The third respondent invoked the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, and approached the second respondent (the Controlling Authority). By Exhibit P1 the Controlling Authority directed the petitioner to pay the third respondent a sum of Rs. 1,4450.34 as the balance gratuity after adjusting an advance of Rs. 6,207.20. The petitioner appealed to the first respondent, who, by Exhibit P2, confirmed Exhibit P1 and rejected the petitioner's appeal.

The petitioner challenged the orders in the present original petition under Article 226. The petitioner contended that the gratuity could be withheld because the third respondent had not surrendered possession of certain land (an extent alleged to be 30 cents) which the petitioner-company claimed as its property and said had been given to the third respondent under a licence. The third respondent filed a counter-affidavit denying the petitioner's claims about the land and disputing the authenticity of documents relied upon by the petitioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner-company was justified in withholding the gratuity of the third respondent on the ground that the third respondent had failed to surrender land alleged to belong to the petitioner.
  2. Whether the controversy over title and possession of the disputed land could be effectively adjudicated in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
  3. Whether the authorities acting under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 were within their powers in ordering payment of the gratuity to the third respondent, and whether statutory protections in the Act prevent withholding or attachment of gratuity except in specified circumstances.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (company) — Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that the third respondent was entitled to gratuity only on final settlement of his account and that final settlement had not occurred because the third respondent had failed to surrender possession of an extent of 30 cents of land allegedly belonging to the petitioner and given to the third respondent under a licence.
  • Before the authorities below the petitioner contended that the property was given on lease to the third respondent and that the extent allotted was 30 cents (the petitioner relied on certain documents, including an agreement, to support this position).

Third Respondent — Arguments

  • The third respondent denied applying for any licence for cultivating the portion of property alleged to belong to the petitioner-company and asserted that the property in his possession does not belong to the petitioner-company.
  • He stated that the property was Attupuramboke and that he had been in possession and enjoyment of the property for more than 35 years; he produced tax receipts before the authorities below.
  • The third respondent asserted that the petitioner had produced an alleged title deed and an agreement and that his signature on the agreement was denied and alleged to be forged.
  • The third respondent also pointed to discrepancies between the alleged title deed produced by the company and the tax receipts he produced (different sub-division and survey numbers), arguing this showed the property he possessed did not belong to the petitioner.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two interrelated strands of analysis:

  1. On the procedural/competence question, the court observed that the dispute between the parties involved contested questions of fact concerning title and possession of immovable property. The court held that such disputes "cannot be effectively done in proceedings under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India" and therefore relegated the petitioner to pursue appropriate remedies in other forums better suited to decide factual contests over title and possession.
  2. On the principal substantive question—whether the petitioner could withhold gratuity because of the alleged failure to surrender the land—the court examined the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The court explained that under the Act an employer may withhold gratuity only by satisfying the conditions set out in Section 4(6), and that Sections 13 and 14 give statutory protection to gratuity payments (notably Section 13 prevents attachment of gratuity in execution of a decree or order of any civil, revenue or criminal Court, and Section 14 operates notwithstanding anything inconsistent contained in other enactments or instruments).
  3. The court found that the petitioner did not allege termination of the employee on any of the grounds specified in Section 4(6) of the Act; consequently, the employer was not entitled to withhold gratuity on that basis. The court emphasized that withholding gratuity on the pretext of the employee's occupation of land—even assuming (for argument) that the land belonged to the employer—could not be treated as a failure to settle account that would justify withholding gratuity unless the conditions of the Act were satisfied.
  4. The court concluded that Section 4(6) read with Sections 13 and 14 of the Act provided a complete answer to the petitioner's attempt to withhold the gratuity. As a result, the controlling authority's order directing payment of the gratuity was within the powers conferred by the Act and could not be upset on the grounds advanced by the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED.

Holding: The original petition was dismissed. The court held that the petitioner was not entitled to the reliefs sought and that the authorities under the Payment of Gratuity Act were within their powers in ordering payment of gratuity to the third respondent. The petitioner could not lawfully withhold the gratuity on the ground that the third respondent had allegedly failed to surrender land in his occupation.

Direct implications for the parties: The order directing payment of gratuity to the third respondent stands; the petitioner cannot withhold the gratuity on the stated ground. The petitioner was directed to pursue its claim concerning title/possession of the land through appropriate forums and remedies other than proceedings under Article 226.

Broader implications: The opinion did not expand on broader precedential consequences beyond applying the statutory scheme of the Payment of Gratuity Act. No new legal principle beyond the application of Sections 4(6), 13 and 14 of the Act to the facts before the court was articulated.

Show all summary ...

1. The third respondent was an employee of the petitioner-company. He retired on superannuation on 19 June 1984. Since the petitioner refused to pay gratuity amount due to the third respondent he approached the second respondent Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (for short the Act) for relief. Exhibit P1 is the order passed by the second respondent directing the petitioner to pay to the third respondent a sum of Rs. 1,4450.34 being the balance amount of gratuity due after adjusting a sum of Rs. 6,207.20 being the advance amount received by the third respondent. The petitioner took up Exhibit P1 in appeal before the first respondent, who by Exhibit P2 confirmed Exhibit P1 rejecting the petitioner's appeal.

2. The thrust of the petitioner's contention before respondents 1 and 2 was that the third respondent is entitled to get the gratuity amount only on final settlement of his account. What is treated by the petitioner-company as failure to settle the account by the third respondent is die tatter's failure to surrender possession of an extent of 30 cents of land which according to the petitioner-company belongs to them and has been given to the third respondent under a licence and the third respondent is bound to surrender the same as and when directed to do so by the petitioner-company. The third respondent has filed a counter-affidavit in which it is stated as follows:

3. Third respondent was working as a chargeman in the petitioner company and has retired on superannuation on 19 June 1984. Thud respondent did not apply for licence for cultivating the portion of the properties belonging to the petitioner as alleged in the original petition. As the property in the possession of the third respondent does not belong to the petitioner-company, the question of surrender of the same does not arise at all. The petitioner-company has no right, title or the authority over the property possessed by the third respondent as the same is Attupuramboke. Third respondent was in absolute possession and enjoyment of the property for the past more than 35 years and the tax receipts were also produced before respondents 1 and 2. Before the authorities below the contention of the petitioner-company was that property was given on lease to the third respondent and the extent allotted was 30 cents of land. Third respondent actually is in possession of 50 cents of property. The allegation was that the property possessed by the third respondent is covered by tide deeds. From the; alleged tide deed produced by the company and the tax receipts produced by the third respondent it could be seen that the sub division and the survey number are different. That itself would show that the property possessed by third respondent does not belong to the petitioner. The petitioner-company produced before the authorities below certain documents including an agreement alleged to have been executed by third respondent. Third respondent denied his signature in the agreement the documents are put up and documents and the signature of the third respondent was forged. The petitioner-company has no right, title of authority over the property possessed by the third respondent

4. Having regard to the rival contentions I am satisfied that the controversy between the parties involves adjudication of disputed question of fact relating to title, possession, etc., to immovable property which cannot be effectively done in proceedings under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, the petitioner is relegated to have recourse to appropriate remedies available to them under other forums.

5. That apart, the main question is whether the petitioner-company will be justified in withholding the gratuity amount due to the third respondent on the specious plea that the third respondent failed to surrender that land which is in occupation by him. The eligibility of the third respondent's gratuity has to be decided on the basis of the provisions contained in the Act, under which the amount by way of gratuity due to an employee cannot be withheld otherwise then by fulfilling the conditions contained in Ss. 4(6), 13 and 14 of the Act Under the Act, the employer is entitled to withhold the gratuity of an employee only if the termination of the employee is under S. 4(6) of the Act. Here, the employer has no case that the employer has terminated the service of the employee on any of the grounds mentioned in S. 4(6) of the Act. The petitioner-company therefore, is not entitled to withhold the gratuity on the pretext that the third respondent is in occupation of the land belonging to the petitioner company. That apart, it has to be noted that the legislature itself has granted statutory protection for payment of gratuity to an employee by enacting S. 13 under which no gratuity payable under the Act is liable to be attachment in execution of any decree or order of any civil, revenue or criminal Court. Section 14 of the Act and Rule made thereunder shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any enactment other than the Act of in any instrument or contract having effect by virtue of any enactment other than the Act Section 4(6) read with Ss. 13 and 14 is a complete answer to the petitioner's action in withholding the terminal benefit by way of gratuity due to the third respondent employee. In other words, amount of gratuity due to an employee can be withheld only on any of the grounds mentioned in the Act and not otherwise and at any rate refusal of the employees to surrender the land in his occupation in violation of the directive issued by the petitioner-company-employer, even if it is assumed that the land belongs to the employer cannot be treated as failure to settle the account by the employee thereby forming a basis for withholding dispersal of arrears of gratuity.

6. For the aforesaid reasons, I am of the view that the petitioner is not entitled to the reliefs prayed for in this original petition as the authorities under the Act are well within their powers in ordering payment of gratuity to the third respondent and the said amount cannot be withheld the ground stated by the petitioner as already noted.

7. In the result, the original petition is dismissed.