Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kerala Agricultural University v. Gopinathan Unnithan

Kerala High Court
Jan 31, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Sreedharan, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

Kerala Agricultural University published a notification dated 9 November 1983 inviting applications for selection to the post of Professor of Agricultural Statistics for one vacancy. A selection committee prepared a select list of three candidates which came into force on 14 May 1984. The notified vacancy was filled by the first-ranked candidate; when a second vacancy arose shortly thereafter the second-ranked candidate was appointed. A later (third) vacancy arose. During the pendency of litigation (Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984) an Associate Professor (not included in the select list and who is the appellant in Writ Appeal No. 373 of 1992) challenged appointments to subsequent vacancies and obtained an order of interim stay restraining the University from making appointments to the subsequent vacancy; the stay continued until final disposal of that petition.

After disposal of the earlier petitions, the petitioner in Original Petition No. 9539 of 1988 (ranked No. 3 in the select list) sought appointment to the third vacancy on the basis of inclusion in the select list. The University rejected the representation (Exhibits P4 and P6). The petitioner filed Original Petition No. 9539 of 1988 seeking a writ of mandamus directing appointment in reliance on the select list. The learned Single Judge directed the University to appoint the petitioner; that direction was challenged by the University in these writ appeals. The Division Bench (Sreedharan, J.) heard the appeals and set aside the Single Judge's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether inclusion in a select list prepared for a notified single vacancy confers a legal right on a candidate to be appointed to subsequent vacancies that were not notified.
  2. Whether a High Court may, in exercise of its powers under Article 226, issue a writ of mandamus directing appointment of a candidate merely on the basis of inclusion in a select list.
  3. Whether the equitable principle Actus curiae neminem gravabit (an act of the court should not harm a litigant) can be invoked to justify appointment of a candidate who claims to have been prejudiced by an earlier order of stay.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner / Appellant (in Original Petition No. 9539 of 1988)

  • The petitioner relied on his inclusion at No. 3 in the select list (effective 14 May 1984) and sought appointment to the third vacancy on that basis.
  • It was argued that the earlier order of stay (in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984) prevented his appointment and that, invoking the principle Acts curiae neminem gravabit, he should be restored to the position he would have occupied but for the stay.
  • Learned counsel for the petitioner also sought to rely on an observation in the judgment in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984 (para. 5 of that judgment) to contend that the University cannot dispute his claim to appointment.

University (Respondent)

  • The University filed a detailed counter-affidavit stating the notification dated 9 November 1983 was only for a single vacancy and that the select list (Exhibit P1) was published only for that notified vacancy.
  • The University contended the petitioner ranked No. 3 is not entitled to be appointed to vacancies which arose subsequently and were not notified for recruitment.
  • The University also contended that the decision in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984 did not confer any right on the petitioner to claim appointment to subsequently created vacancies.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ashok Kumar v. Chairman, Banking Service Recruitment Board [1996 (1) L.L.N 795] Support for the proposition that appointment to vacancies not covered by the original notification is unconstitutional. The court relied on this decision to hold that appointments from a select list to vacancies arising after notification (which were not notified) are unconstitutional.
State of Bihar v. Secretariat Assistant S.E., Union [1994 (1) SCC 126 ; A.I.R. 1994 S.C. 736] Inclusion in a select list does not by itself confer a right to appointment. The court cited this authoritative pronouncement to conclude that the petitioner (ranked No. 3) had not acquired any right to the post merely by being on the select list.
State Of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty (Smt) [1987 (I) L.L.N 31] High Court exercising powers under Article 226 cannot issue a writ of mandamus directing appointment of a candidate who is only included in a select list. The court applied this principle to hold the Single Judge erred in issuing a writ of mandamus directing the University to appoint the petitioner.
Jano Singh v. Brij Lal [A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 1631] The maxim Actus curiae neminem gravabit: courts should restore a litigant harmed by a mistake of the court to the position he would have occupied but for that mistake. The court examined this principle and held it was inapplicable because no mistake had been committed by any court in granting the stay; therefore the maxim could not be invoked to justify appointment.
Kerala Public Service Commission v. Dr. Kesavankutty Nair [1977 K.L.T 818] An order of stay granted by the Court in previous litigation cannot be treated as a mistake of the Court for the purpose of invoking Actus curiae neminem gravabit. The Division Bench's view in that case was followed to support the conclusion that the earlier stay was not a mistake and so cannot be the basis for restoring the petitioner to a post he was not legally entitled to.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Division Bench proceeded through the following analytical steps strictly on the basis of the material and law before it:

  1. Re-examination of record: The court found that the learned Single Judge misread the University's counter-affidavit (para. 3), which explicitly stated the select list was published for filling the single notified vacancy and that the petitioner (No. 3) was not entitled to appointment to subsequently created vacancies.
  2. Common factual foundation: It was common ground that the notification dated 9 November 1983 related to only one vacancy and that the select list was prepared only for that vacancy.
  3. Legal principle on select lists: The court reiterated the settled legal position that inclusion in a select list does not itself create a legal right to appointment. It relied on the State of Bihar precedent to support that proposition.
  4. Constitutional dimension: The court held that appointing candidates from a select list to vacancies that were not notified would amount to recruitment in excess of the notified vacancy and would deny the constitutional rights of other eligible persons under Article 14 read with Article 16(1) of the Constitution of India.
  5. Mandamus not available: The court observed established authority (State Of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty) that the High Court should not issue a writ of mandamus directing appointment of a candidate included in a select list; thus the learned Single Judge erred in issuing such a writ.
  6. Actus curiae argument rejected: The petitioner invoked the maxim that court acts should not harm a litigant. The court examined Jano Singh and concluded that the maxim applies to mistakes by the court. Here, the earlier stay order was legally granted and cannot be treated as a mistake; a Division Bench decision (Kerala Public Service Commission v. Dr. Kesavankutty Nair) was cited in support. Consequently, the maxim could not be used to justify appointment.
  7. Precedential consistency: The court remarked that an interpretation of the earlier judgment (Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984) as amounting to a direction to appoint the present petitioner would be incorrect because that earlier judgment dealt with a different claim and because such an interpretation would conflict with the Supreme Court authority cited.
  8. Conclusion of analysis: For these reasons—factual (notification of one vacancy), legal (no right from inclusion in select list), constitutional (potential denial of Article 14/16 rights), and precedent—the Single Judge's direction to appoint the petitioner to the subsequent vacancy could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Division Bench held that the decision of the learned Single Judge directing appointment of the petitioner to the third vacancy was unsustainable, set aside that decision, allowed the writ appeals and dismissed Original Petition No. 9539 of 1988. The court made no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner (ranked No. 3 in the select list) is not entitled to appointment to the third vacancy that was not included in the original notification; the Single Judge's mandamus is vacated and the petition dismissed.
  • Legal consequence: The judgment reinforces the principles that (a) inclusion in a select list does not automatically confer a right to appointment, (b) High Courts should not issue mandamus to appoint candidates based solely on select list inclusion, and (c) an order of stay routinely granted in litigation is not to be treated as a 'mistake of the court' for the purpose of invoking Actus curiae neminem gravabit.
  • Precedential note: The court applied existing authorities to the facts; the opinion does not purport to create any new legal precedent beyond applying settled law to this case.

This summary is confined strictly to information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or holdings beyond the text.

Show all summary ...

Sreedharan, J.:— These writ appeals arise from the decision in Original Petition No. 9539 of 1988. Appellant in Writ Appeal No. 373 of 1992 was not a party to the original petition. She has filed the writ appeal after obtaining leave of this Court.

2. Short facts necessary for the disposal of these writ appeals are as follows:— Agricultural university invited applications for selection to the post of Professor of Statistics as per notification, dated 9 November 1983. It is the agreed case that the notification was for filling up one post of professor of Statistics. Petitioner in the original petition applied for the post among others. A select committee prepared a rank list of three candidates. That rank list came into force with effect the preparation of the select list, one more vacancy in the cadre of Professor of Statistics arose. So candidates ranked Nos. 1 and 2 in the select list were appointed against the two vacancies. When a subsequent vacancy arose in the cadre of Professor of Statistics, an Associate Professor who was not included in the rank list approached this Court by filing Original petition No. 4386 of 1984. Petitioner in 4386 of 1984 is the appellant in Writ Appeal No. 373 of 1992. She raised a contention in that original petition that notification inviting application to the post of Professor of Statistics was in relation to one post only, and against the vacancies that arose subsequently, persons ranked in the select list should not be appointed. It was further stated by her that inclusion in the select list will not confer on the candidate any right to be appointed in the vacancy which was not notified. This Court granted interim stay of appointment of any person against the subsequent vacancy that arose in the cadre of Professor of Statistics. The order of stay passed by this Court was extended until further orders and that was in force till the disposal of the original petition. Original petition was disposed of by judgment, dated 19 November 1987. Thereafter, the petitioner in Original Petition No. 9539 of 1988 filed representation before University seeking appointment against the third vacancy of professor of Statistics. University by Exhibits P4 and P6 communications rejected the request made by the petitioner. Hence he approached this Court inter alia praying for the issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the University to appoint him as Professor in Agricultural Statistics on the strength of the inclusion of his name in the select list which came into force with effect from 14 May 1984.

3. University filed a detailed counter-affidavit disputing the claim of the petitioner for appointment contending that the total number of vacancies notified was only one and the petitioner ranked No. 3 in the select list is not entitled to be appointed in the vacancy which arose subsequently. It was also contended that decision in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984 will not help the petitioner to claim the post of Professor.

4. Learned Single Judge took the view that but for the order of stay issued by this Court in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984 restrianing the University from making appointment to the post of Professor of Statistics the petitioner would have been appointed, that the order of stay passed by this Court cannot adversely affect the interest of the petitioner and that he is entitled to be appointed on the principle that an act of Court should not cause harm to a litigant “Acts curiae neminem gravabit.” In this view the learned Judge issued a direction to the university to appoint the issued a direction to which he was chosen as per the rank list which came into force on 14 May 1984. This direction given by the learned Judge is under challenge.

5. Learned Single Judge in Para. 4 of the judgment found fault with the university in not denying the fact that there existed one vacancy for being filled up by the candidate included in Exhibit P1 select list. In Para. 3 of the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the University, it was specifically stated that Exhibit P1 list was published for filling up the notified single vacancy of Professor of Statistics, that petitioner who was ranked No. 3 in the list, is not entitled to be appinted and that the vacancy to which the petitioner seeks appointment was one created by the University during the pendency of Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984 and that the decision in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984 did not reserve any right in favour of the petitioner to get the vacancy that was created subsequently. In the nature of the specific contention raised by the University in the counter affidavit, it appears that the observation made by the learned Single Judge in Para. 4 of the judgment referred to earlier is based on a wrong reading of counter affidait.

6. It is common case that as per the notification, dated 9 November 1983, published by the Kerala Agricultural University, only one vacancy of professor of Agricultural Statistics was notified. For filling up that one vacancy, a select list was prepared by a properly constituted selection Committee. Three persons who were holding the post of Associate Professor were included in the select list. First man was appointed against the vacancy which was notified. Since another vacancy in the cadre of Professor of Statistics arose immediately therefrom the second candidate ranked in the list was also appointed. Long subsequent to that, a third vacancy of Professor arose. The petitioner who was ranked third has now been directed by the learned Single Judge to be appointed against that vacancy. That direction cannot be sustained for more than one reason.

7. When one vacancy alone was notified, candidates ranked in the select list cannot be appointed to the vacancies that arose subsequently. Recruitment of candidates in excess of the notified vacancy is a denial and deprivation of the constitutional rights of other qualified hands under Art. 14 read with Art. 16(1) of the Constitution of India. Therefore, a person included in the select list cannot be appointed to the subsequent vacancies which were not covered by the notification. Any appointment to the vacancies that had arisen subsequently and which were not notified for recruitment is unconstitutional. Reference may be made to the decision in Ashok Kumar v. Chairman, Banking Service Recruitment Board [1996 (1) L.L.N 795]. In the instant case, as agree to by all parties concerned in this case, the vacancy that was notified on 9 November 1983 was only one post of Professor of Agricultural Statistics. It was for filling up that vacancy only a select list was prepared. From that select list, a candidate can be appointed only for filling up the single vacancy notified. Appointment of candidates in the waiting list to the vacancies subseuently arose is unconstitutional.

8. Learned counsel representing the petitioner respondent advanced an argument that in view of the decision in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984, which has become final, neither University of the appellant in Writ Appeal No. 373 of 1992 can be allowed to dispute the claim of the petitioner for appoinment to the third vacancy. In support of this contention, learned counsel relies on Para. 5 of the the judgment in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1994:

“The only fact that the petitioner was not included in the select list is no reason to hold, that only one post of Professor of Statistics should have been filled up from the select list prepared pursuant to Exhibit P1. If three persons were duly included in the select list and sufficient number of vacancies were available, the petitioner, who was not included in the select list, cannot insist that appointment should have been confined only to one post and the other, vacancies should be notified afresh”.

The said observation, according to us, cannot be treated as one rendered after considering the claim of the present petitioner as against the university. Learned Single Judge in that judgment was concerned with the claim of the appellant in Writ Appeal No. 373 of 1992 against the vacancy that arose subsequent to the filing of that original petition. In that view of the matter, we are not in a position to hold that the above observation made by the learned Single Judge is conclusive and binding on the parties as a direction to appoint the petitioner herein in the third vacancy. Further, such an interpretation if adopted will go against the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the decision referred to earlier.

9. Petitioner in the original petition was ranked No. 3 in the select list which came into force on 14 May 1984. Inclusion of a candidate in the select list will not confer on him any right to the post. Reference may be made to the decision in State of Bihar v. Secretariat Assistant S.E, Union 1986 [(1994) 1 SCC 126 : A.I.R 1994 S.C 736]. In the light of this authoritative pronouncement, petitioner who secured rank No. 3 in the select list, had not acquired any right to the post. On the basis of the inclusion in the select list, he cannot put-forth any claim to the post.

10. Learned Single Judge has issued a writ of mandamus directing the Agricultural University to appoint the petitioner as Professor in Agricultural Statistics. It is trite law that this Court in exercise of the powers under Art. 226 of the Constitution is not to issue a writ of mandamus directing the appointment of a candidate who is included in the select list. In State Of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty (Smt) [1987 (I) L.L.N 31]. Their Lordships after stating that a candidate who is included in the select list has no legal right to the post held that the High Court in exercise of the powers in Art. 226 of the Constitution cannot issue a writ of mandamus directing the authorities to make the appointment. In view of this statement of law, the learned Single Judge was clearly in error in issuing a writ of mandamus directing the University to appoint the petitioner against the third vacancy of Professor in Agricultural Statistics, that arose on a subsequent date.

11. Learned Single Judge then relied on the principle that the order of Court cannot harm the rights of the petitioner. This principle was sought to be presed into service on a wrong premises that but for the order of stay granted by this Court in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1983 petitioner would have been appointed as Professor of Agricultural Statistics. Not only that the said premises is factually incorrect but also the above principle will not apply to the facts on hand. What the Supreme Court stated in Jano Singh v. Brij Lal [A.I.R 1966 S.C 1631], was that:

“There is no higher principle for the guidance of the Court than the one that no acts of Courts should harm a litigant and it is the bounden duty of Courts to see that if a person harmed by a mistake of the Court he should be restored to the position he would have occupied but for that mistake. This is aptly summed up in the maxim: Actus curiae neminem gravabit”.

In the instant case, no mistake was committed by any Court to the prejudice of the petitioner. In Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984 this Court legally granted an order of stay. The granting of the order of stay by this Court can, under no circumstance, be termed as a mistake committed by this Court. When there is no mistake in granting the said order of stay, the principle that no act of Court should harm a litigant cannot have any application. A Division Bench of this Court in Kerala Public Service Commission v. Dr. Kesavankutty Nair [1977 K.L.T 818], on an identical set of facts took the view that an order of facts took the view that an order of stay granted by this Court in a previous litigation cannot be taken as a mistake committed by this Court for pressing the maxim Actus Curiae into service. We are in respectful agreement with the law stated by the Bench. So on the basis of the order of stay granted by this Court in Original Petition No. 4386 of 1984 petitioner in this case cannot put-forth a claim to the post to which he was not legally entitled to.

In view of what has been stated above, we hold that the decision rendered by the learned Single Judge is clearly unsustainable. We set aside that decision.

Writ appeals are allowed and Original Petition No. 9539 of 1988 is dismissed. However, we make no order as to costs.