Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Philo

Kerala High Court
Feb 1, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, second opposite party in W.C.C No. 85 of 1992 before the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Ernakulam, filed an appeal under Section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act. The original application sought compensation for the death of Sri Thomas, who was employed as a driver of a tourist taxi owned by the first opposite party. On 16 June 1991, Thomas was engaged to drive the taxi with tourists but did not return after the tour. It was reported that he was killed and the taxi stolen by an unknown person. The claimants sought Rs. 1,00,000 as compensation based on Thomas's monthly income of Rs. 2,000 and age of 45 years. The first opposite party admitted employment and salary but the appellant denied liability, contending that the death was a cold-blooded murder by a third party and not an accident arising out of employment. The Commissioner awarded Rs. 67,776 as compensation with interest, rejecting the appellant's contentions. The appellant challenged this order in the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the killing of a workman by an unknown person during the course of his employment can be considered as death caused by an accident arising out of employment under the Workmen's Compensation Act?
  2. Whether the accident arose out of employment so as to attract liability on the employer or insurer to pay compensation?
  3. Whether the burden of proof to establish a causal connection between the accident and employment was discharged by the claimants?
  4. Whether the deceased was responsible for placing himself in peril, thereby negating employer liability?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The incident was not an accident but a deliberate murder by a third party.
  • The death did not arise out of or in the course of employment.
  • The deceased voluntarily placed himself in peril by accepting the tourists' invitation to share their room, thus breaking the causal connection with employment.
  • There was no special risk incidental to the duties of employment causing the injury.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The deceased was engaged in the course of employment when killed.
  • The killing qualifies as an accident arising out of employment under the Act.
  • The deceased was compelled to stay with the tourists due to lack of employer arrangements, so no contributory negligence existed.
  • The causal connection between employment and injury was established and burden of proof was discharged.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Varkeyachan v. Thomman [1979 (1) L.L.N 477] Definition of "accident" includes injury not designed by the workman himself; test for accident arising out of employment. Adopted to hold that death by unknown assailant during course of employment qualifies as accident arising out of employment.
Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway v. Highly [1917 A.C 352] Test whether injury was part of employment to hazard, suffer, or do. Applied to assess causal connection between employment and injury.
M. Mackenzie v. I.M Issak [(1969) 2 SCC 607 : A.I.R 1970 S.C 1906] Approved test from Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway case regarding causation in employment injury claims. Referenced to affirm the legal test for arising out of employment.
Bhagubia v. General Manager, Central Railway [A.I.R 1955 Bom. 105] Requirement of causal connection between accident and employment; peril incidental to employment; burden of proof. Relied upon to reject appellant's contention and hold that causal connection was established.
Public Works Department Bhopal v. Kausa [A.I.R 1966 M.P 297] Supporting authority on causal connection and burden of proof in workmen compensation claims. Cited to reinforce principles regarding arising out of employment.
Kartick Chandra v. State [A.I.R 1968 Cal. 127] Supporting authority on principles of arising out of employment and burden of proof. Used to support the court's reasoning on causal connection.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by framing the issue whether the killing of a workman by an unknown person during employment qualifies as an accident arising out of employment under the Workmen's Compensation Act. It noted the admitted facts that the deceased was employed as a taxi driver and was killed while performing his duties. The Court referenced the decision in Varkeyachan v. Thomman, which broadly defines "accident" to include injuries not designed by the workman himself and held that the killing was an accident within this meaning.

The Court then examined the causal connection test drawn from Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway v. Highly and approved by the Supreme Court in M. Mackenzie v. I.M Issak. The test requires that the injury must be part of the employment hazard or risk. The Court further relied on Bhagubia v. General Manager, Central Railway, which emphasized the need for a proximate or prominent cause linking the accident and employment, and clarified that the peril must be incidental to employment and not personal to the employee.

Applying these principles, the Court found that but for the deceased's employment as a driver, he would not have been in the place or situation where he was killed. The causal connection was thus complete. The Court rejected the appellant's argument that the deceased voluntarily placed himself in peril by sharing the tourists' room, reasoning that the deceased was compelled to find lodging due to lack of employer arrangements and that this did not break the causal chain.

The Court also rejected the contention that the claimants failed to discharge the burden of proof, relying on the observations in Bhagubia and related cases. The Court concluded that the accident arose out of and in the course of employment, justifying the compensation award.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed in limine.

The Court upheld the compensation awarded by the Commissioner, holding that the killing of the workman by an unknown assailant while in the course of employment constitutes an accident arising out of employment under the Workmen's Compensation Act. The decision affirms the broad legal interpretation of "accident" and the causal connection test for employer liability in compensation claims. No new precedent was set; rather, the Court applied and followed established jurisprudence to the facts.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Ramakrishnan, J.:— The short question arising for consideration in this appeal filed under S30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act (for short the Act) is whether the killing of a workman while he was in the course of his employment, by an unknown person, can be considered as death caused as a result of an accident arising out of his employment?

2. Briefly the facts relevant are thus: The second opposite party in W.C.C No. 85 of 1992 on the file of the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation (Deputy Labour Commissioner), Ernakulam, is the appellant in this appeal. The application filed was for compensation for the death caused to one Sri Thomas, husband of the first respondent and father of respondents 2 to 4 in this appeal. According to the applicants the deceased Thomas was the driver of Tourist Taxi Car KRV 5250 owned by the first opposite party. On 16 June 1991; the deceased was engaged by the first opposite party to drive the taxi car with passengers for hire. Accordingly the deceased west to Valliyoor, near Kuttalam, taking the tourists in the taxi car. He did not return alter the tour and it was reported that he was killed and the car was stollen by somebody. In the application, the monthly income and age of the deceased were shown as Rs. 2,000 and 45 respectively. A total amount of Rs. 1,00,000 was claimed as compensation. The first opposite party admitted fiat the deceased was the driver of his tourist taxi and that he was paying a monthly salary of Rs. 2,000 to the deceased. There was also no dispute regarding the age of the deceased It was submitted that the taxi car has been duly insured with the second opposite party and the policy was in force at the time of the death of the driver. The appellant as second opposite party denied the allegation that deceased Thomas has sustained fatal injuries by the accident arising out of and in the course of his employment It was contended that the incident is not an accident and that it was a cold blooded murder and that the murder by a third party cannot be an accident and hence it was not liable to pay any compensation. After taking evidence and hearing the arguments, the Commissioner rejected the contentions taken by the appellant and awarded a sum of Rs. 67,776 as compensation to the claimants together with interest from 16 June 1991 onwards ft is aggrieved by the said order that the appellant has preferred this appeal.

3. In the appeal, the learned counsel for the appellant has not pursued the contentions taken up the appellant as second opposite party before the Commissioner to the effect that the incident in question is not an accident and even if it is an accident it is not one which arose in the course of the employment. We think that the learned counsel for the appellant was justified in not pursuing them in the light of the decision of this Court in Varkeyachan v. Thomman [1979 (1) L.L.N 477], where a Division Bench of this Court has held that in Para at page

“the term accident for the purpose of the law relating to compensation for personal injuries sustained by workmen and the employer's liability in that behalf, includes any injury which is not designed by the workman himself and it is of no consequence that the injury was designed and intended by the person inflicting the same”.

In the light of the admitted fact that the deceased was engaged as a driver by the first opposite party and that he was killed while he was in the course of performing his duties as a driver, mere may not be any justification in law to contend that the accident has not occurred in the course of his employment.

4. As regards the question to be considered in the appeal it was contended that the accident cannot be considered as one which arose out of the employment and as such neither the first opposite party nor the appellant can be legally made liable to pay compensation to the applicants under the Act It is in evidence that the deceased had accepted me offer of the tourists to occupy the room hired by them to spend the night. It was while the deceased was in the room occupied by the tourists that he was killed It was a case of cold blooded murder committed with the motive of stealing the car. In a case like the one on hand, the claimants must show that the injury caused was due to the fact that the workman was specially exposed to such peril because of his employment or that the injury was due to some special risk that the workman had to undergo. There was no such evidence in the case. The burden of proof primarily rests on the workman or the claimants to prove that the accident arise out of the employment. In the absence of any evidence to show that the injury caused was due to the fact that the workman was specially exposed to the peril because of his employment or that the injury was due to some special risk that the workman had to undergo, the Commissioner ought to have rejected the claim. The works “arising out of employment” should be understood to mean that “during the course of the employment injury has resulted form some risk incidental to the duties of the service, which, unless engaged in the duty owing to the master, it is reasonable to believe the workman would not otherwise have suffered.” It was submitted that there was no causal relationship between the accident and the employment. The immediate cause which put the deceased to the peril in this case was the acceptance of the offer by the deceased to share the room occupied by the tourists and as such the deceased should be held to be responsible for placing himself in this situation in which he has suffered the fatal injuries. On that ground also the claim is liable to be rejected.

5. In the decision reported in Varkeyachan v. Thomman [1979 (1) L.L.N 477] (vide supra), referred to already by us, this Court has accepted the test laid down by Lord Summer in Lancanshire and Yorkshire Railway v. Highly [1917 A.C 352] and approved by the Supreme Court in the M. Mackenzie v. I.M Issak [(1969) 2 SCC 607 : A.I.R 1970 S.C 1906], in the case of a claim by the legal representatives of a deceased workman which we may quote here usefully:

“There is, however, in any opinion, one test which is always at any rate applicable, because it arises upon the very words of the statute, and it is generally of some real assistance. It is this: Was it part of the injured person's employment to hazard, to suffer, or to do that which caused his injury? If yea, the accident arose out of his employment. If any, it did not, because, what it was not part of the employment to hazard, to suffer, or to do, cannot well be the cause of an accident arising out of the employment To ask if the cause of this was within the sphere of the employment or was one of the ordinary risks of the employment, or reasonably incidental to the employment, or conversely, was an added peril and outside the sphere of the employment, are all different ways of asking whether it was a part of his employment, that the workman should have acted as he was acting, or should have been in the position in which he was, whereby in the course of that employment he sustained injury.”

6. Dealing with identically similar contentions raised in a case where compensation was claimed by the legal representatives of a deceased workman, Chagla, C.J, speaking for a Bench of the Bombay High Court has laid down the law pithily in the following terms:

“Now it is clear that there must be a casual connection between the accident and the employment in order that the Court can say that the accident arose out of the employment of the deceased. It is equally clear that the cause contemplated is the prominent cause and not any remote cause. The authorities have clearly laid down that if the employee in the course of his employment has to be in a particular place and by reason of, his being in that particular place he has to face a peril and the accident is caused by reason of that peril which he has to face, then a casual connection is established between the incident and the employment. It is now well settled that the fact that the employee shares that peril with other members of the public is an irrelevant consideration. It is true that the peril which he faces must not be, something personal to him; the peril must be incidental to his employment. It is also clear that he must not by his own act add to the peril or extend the peril. But if the peril which he faces has nothing to do with his own action or his own conduct, but it is a peril which would have been faced by any other employee or any other member of the public, then if the accident arises out of such peril, a casual connection is established between the employment and the accident.” (Bhagubia v. General Manager, Central Railway [A.I.R 1955 Bom. 105].

As regards the burden of proof lying on the applicant, the learned Judge has observed thus in the same decision:

“……….. Once the peril is established, it is for the employer then to establish either that the peril was brought about by the employee himself, that he added or extended the peril, or that the peril was not a general peril but a peril personal to the employee……..”

Similar views have been expressed by the Madhya Pradesh and Calcutta High Courts in Public Works Department Bhopal v. Kausa [A.I.R 1966 M.P 297] and Kartick Chandra v. State [A.I.R 1968 Cal. 127].

7. Applying the principles laid down in the above decisions with which we respectfully agree, to the facts of this case, we are convinced that the view taken by the Commissioner in this case is fully justifiable. But for the engagement as the driver of the taxi, the deceased would not have been in the place and in the situation where he was at the time when he was killed. The casual connection is complete and we have no doubt in our mind to hold that the accident which has resulted in the death of the workman has arisen out of the employment.

8. The contention that the claimants have failed to discharge their burden to prove the casual relationship between the accident and the employment is only to be rejected in the light of the observations contained in Shrimati Bhagubai…(Original Applicant) v. The General Manager, Central Railway…(Original Opponent)*, Central Railway [A.I.R 1955 Bom. 105] (vide supra), with which we respectfully agree.

9. Similarly, the contention that the deceased was really responsible for placing himself in peril by accepting the invitation of the tourists to share their room to spend the night is also totally untenable. As the tourists were halting at that particular place to spend the night, the deceased was also bound to stay there for the night. The first opposite party as employer of the deceased had not made any special arrangements for the stay of the driver at the halting place. Hence the deceased was bound to find out for himself a place to stay for the night and sleep there. In the circumstances, the fact that the deceased had accepted the suggestion of the tourists and stayed along with them in their room will not furnish a reasonable ground to record a finding that the deceased was solely or mainly responsible for placing himself in peril. As such the accident can only be considered as an accident which arose out of his employment.

10. We would accordingly dismiss the appeal in limine.