Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Albert v. State Of Kerala

Kerala High Court
Jan 12, 1993
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a Junior Superintendent belonging to the Directorate of Public Instruction (DPI) who was serving on deputation in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education (DHSE), under the Director of Higher Secondary Education (respondent No. 2). The petitioner has since been promoted in his parent department (DPI) as Superintendent. The State of Kerala (respondent No. 1) issued an order (No. D3/9051/93.DPI dated 28-1-1993) extending the deputation of other employees but not the petitioner; the State proposes to terminate the petitioner's deputation and repatriate him to his parent department.

The petitioner filed the present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking: (i) a direction to the State to stop all proceedings to transfer the petitioner from the office of respondent No. 2, and (ii) a direction to respondents 1 and 2 to complete the formalities of absorption and regularisation of the petitioner in respondent No. 2's office before filling up the vacancy of the Joint Director (Examinations).

The respondents explained that the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education was constituted to implement a re-organisation under the National Education Policy whereby Pre-degree courses (11th and 12th standards) would be transferred from universities to higher secondary schools. The DHSE commenced with a small (nuclear) staff including a Special Officer, a Junior Superintendent and clerks; the petitioner was part of that nuclear staff taken on deputation from the DPI. As Pre-degree courses are transferred, ministerial staff in universities may become surplus. To protect surplus university staff and the interests of existing deputationists, the Government allocated specific posts among the Directorate of Collegiate Education, the Directorate of Public Instruction and personnel from universities: one junior superintendent each for deputationists from Collegiate Education and DPI (the petitioner occupying the latter), the senior superintendent post re-allotted to Kerala University staff, and the Joint Director (Examinations) reserved for university personnel. The petitioner is proposed for repatriation because he has been promoted in his parent department and the senior superintendent post in DHSE has been allotted to the Kerala University.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a petitioner on deputation has a right to continue on deputation and to be absorbed in the receiving department (DHSE) such that the State is precluded from repatriating him when the State elects not to extend his deputation.
  2. Whether the State's decision to repatriate the petitioner (not extend deputation) and to allocate posts to protect surplus university staff and distribute opportunities among departments is arbitrary or otherwise legally impermissible.
  3. Whether the legal distinction between "appointment" (with features such as probation and confirmation) and "deputation" (a temporary assignment) governs the petitioner's entitlement to absorption in the receiving department.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contends that having served on deputation in the DHSE he has a right to be absorbed and regularised in that Directorate.
  • He argues that continued deputation will give him better prospects of promotion (e.g., to Joint Director (Examinations)) and that bringing deputation employees from the universities will harm his promotion prospects.
  • Implicitly, the petitioner contends that the State's refusal to extend his deputation and the decision to repatriate him are unlawful or arbitrary.

Respondents' (State and DHSE) Position

  • The respondents rely on the National Education Policy-driven re-organisation that transfers Pre-degree education from universities to the school system and the consequent constitution of the DHSE with a small nuclear staff initially drawn on deputation from DPI and other sources.
  • The Government has to consider absorption for potentially surplus university ministerial staff and claims by private college employees; to protect these interests and the interests of existing deputationists, the Government apportioned posts among DPI, Directorate of Collegiate Education and universities.
  • The petitioner is proposed to be repatriated because he has been promoted in his parent department (DPI) and because the relevant posts (e.g., Senior Superintendent and Joint Director (Examinations)) have been reserved or allotted to university personnel or other units to secure a fair distribution of opportunities.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Parkash Makkar v. State of Haryana ((1992) 4 SCC 725 : AIR 1993 SC 1974) The distinction between "appointment" (characterised by features such as probation and confirmation) and "deputation" (a temporary assignment lacking those features); where posting includes probation and confirmation it is appointment and may give rise to entitlement to absorption, whereas postings lacking those indicia are deputation. The court applied the principle to explain that an employee on deputation (lacking features of appointment) has no right to be absorbed; the petitioner's posting was treated as deputation and therefore did not create a right to absorption in DHSE.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the statutory source of the Government's power to depute and receive officers: Rule 9B of Part II of the Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1958. The court set out the ambit of the Rule: it authorises deputation or transfer of officers between services and departments and permits the Government to send to or take in officers from other governments or statutory bodies (including universities). The court also noted the Rule's limitations: deputation/transfer must be in public interest, reasons must be recorded in writing (unless for security), and the public service commission must be consulted when consultation has not been specifically excluded.

From the language of Rule 9B the court concluded that deputation is a power vested in the Government and not a right of an employee; continuation on deputation depends on public interest as determined by the Government, and the Government may repatriate an employee if public interest does not require continued deputation. The court emphasised that the Rule also permits the Government to receive officers from statutory bodies such as universities.

The court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Ram Parkash Makkar to clarify the legal distinction between appointment and deputation: appointment (for example, by transfer where probation and confirmation are envisaged) can give rise to an entitlement to absorption, whereas postings that lack such indicia are deputation and do not create such a right. The court expanded on the ordinary meaning of "appoint" (to assign an office or job) versus "depute" (to delegate a task temporarily), observing that deputation is inherently transitory.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the petitioner had been temporarily assigned to DHSE (a deputation during its infancy) and that his recent promotion in the parent department (DPI) supported repatriation. The court further considered the Government's allocation of posts among DPI, Directorate of Collegiate Education and university personnel as an exercise of discretion aimed at a fair distribution of employment opportunities and protection of potentially surplus university and college staff. The court summarised the considerations that influenced the Government's exercise of discretion: the petitioner's promotion in the parent department; the need for a fair distribution of opportunities between DPI and Collegiate Education staff; and fairness towards surplus university staff.

On this basis the court concluded that the Government had exercised its Rule 9B discretion on sound considerations and that the decision not to extend the petitioner's deputation was not arbitrary.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner's challenge to the decision not to extend his deputation and to the proposed repatriation is rejected; the court upholds the Government's decision to repatriate the petitioner in light of his promotion in the parent department and the allocation of posts designed to protect surplus university staff and fairly distribute opportunities.
  • No broader legal innovation: The opinion applies existing legal principles (including the distinction between appointment and deputation as explained in Ram Parkash Makkar) and does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond the application of those principles to the facts at hand.

This summary is confined to the content and reasoning expressly contained in the provided opinion.

Show all summary ...

1. The pelitioncr, a Junior Superintendent in the eslablishment of the directorate of Public Instruction, the respondent No. 3 herein, is currently working as Junior Superintendent in the offices under the control of the Director of Higher Secondary Education, the respondent No. 2. He is on deputation to the office under the Director of Higher Secondary Education. He has since been promoted as superintendent in his parent department, namely, the Directorate of Public Instruction. Therefore the respondent No. 1 the Slate of Kerala proposes to terminate his deputation with the respondent No. 2. By order No. D3/9051/93.DPI dated 28-1-1993, the State of Kerala extended the deputation of all employees except the petitioner. In this petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India the petitioner seeks an order (i) directing the State of Kerala the respondent No. 1 to Stop all proceedings to transfer the petitioner from the office of the 2nd respondent where he is on deputation and (ii) a direction to the respondents 1 and 2 to complete the formalities of absorption and regularisation of the service of the petitioner in the office of the respondent No. 2 before filling up the vacancy of the Joint Director (Examinations). In a nutshell, the petitioner's case is this. He has been on deputation in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education where he expects to be promoted to higher positions like the Joint Director (Examinations). The State of Kerala has set afoot the process of absorption and regularisation of the employees on deputation. The petitioner, if continued on deputation has a “right” to be so absorbed and promoted to a higher post created in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education. The proposed action of the respondents in bringing on deputation employees from the Universities will harm the petitioner's prospects of promotion in the Directorate where he seeks absorption.

2. In order to appreciate the submissions made herein the facts in regard to the petitioner's deputation and the reason for the action of the respondents may be set out. The facts are in the counter-affidavit of the State of Kerala. The National Education Policy envisages re-organisation of the Secondary and Collegiate Education, where under the Predegree Course or the 11th and 12th standards would become a part of the organisation of the Higher Secondary Education. In other words, the Pre-degree education would be transferred to the schools. Inorder to effectuate the policy the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education was constituted. It commenced its work with a nuclear staff consisting of a Special Officer, a Junior Superintendent and clerks. The petitioner, a deputationist, belongs to this nuclear staff. The deputalionists were initially taken from the Directorate of Public Instruction. As and when the Pre-degree course is transferred from the Universities and is made a part of the Higher Secondary Education, the ministerial staff in the Universities may be rendered surplus. The employees of the private colleges affiliated to the colleges have also staked their claims for absorption in the Higher Secondary Education Department which the Government is committed to consider. With the twin object of protecting the interest of surplus staff of the Universities and protecting the existing deputationists working in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education the posts have been allocated to different units. One post each of junior Superintendent has been allotted to the deputationists from the Directorate of Collegiate Education and the Directorate of Public Instruction. The petitioner occupies one such post. The only post of Senior Superintendent has been re-allotted to the staff of the Kerala University which may be rendered surplus. The post of Joint Director of Examination has been reserved for the personnel from the universities. The petitioner is proposed to be repatriated to the parent department because he has been promoted as senior superintendent in the parent department and the post of senior superintendent in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education has been allotted to the Kerala University.

3. The legality of the respondents' action has to be considered against the background of the facts set out in paragraphs 2 and 3 above.

4. The Government's authority to depute its officers or receive officers on deputation is contained in Rule 9B of Part II of the Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules 1958. The Government's authority encompasses the power to:

(i) depute or transfer its officers

(a) from one service to another

(b) from one department to another within the same service

(ii) send to or take in officers

(a) from other Governments

(b) from statutory bodies.

5. The exercise of the above power is subject to these limitations:—

(a) the deputation/transfer should be in public interest;

(b) for reasons to be recorded in writing unless thedeputation/transferis in the interest of security; and

(c) the public service commission shall be consulted whenever such, consultation has not been specifically excluded.

6. The language of Rule 9B shows that to depute an employee to another department or continue him on deputation is a power of the Government and not a right of an employee. If the public interrat requires that an employee shall continue on deputation, the Government may do so subject to the provisions of the rule. As a necessary corollary it follows that if the Government finds that public interest docs not require the continued deputation of any of its servant it may repatriate him to his parent department. Significantly the power under Rule 9B is not confined to deputing Government employees from one Department to another. It extends to “taking in officers from other Government or statutory bodies” into the establishment of the Government Departments. Therefore the Government possesses the power not only to depute the officers of one department to another but also to receive officers from the statutory bodies like the Universities.

Rule 9B creates a discretion in the Government to depute officers or receive officers on deputation. The employee has no right to be deputed or to continue on deputation.

7. The petitioner claims a right to continue on deputation and seeks absorption in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education. The status of an employee on deputation can be understood from the Supreme Court's decision in Ram Parkash Makkar v. State of Haryana ((1992) 4 SCC 725 : AIR 1993 SC 1974). Ram Parkash a stenographer in the Secretariat was appointed as Assistant in the Directorate of Local Bodies. His request for absorption in the Directorate was rejected on the ground that he was on deputation. The appointment was on transfer basis. The order of appointment envisaged confirmation in the Directorate. Upon such “appointment by transfer” he was indeed placed under probation. These facts were held inconsistent with the idea of deputation and consistent with appointment. Therefore the Supreme Court held that Ram Parkash was entitled to be considered for absorption in the Directorate. The distinct features of appointment being probation and confirmation, the posting which lacks these features is deputation. This is the principle that emerges from the decision of the Supreme Court.

8. Consider the meaning of the words. To appoint means to assign an office or job, to a person. For in stance, apeison is appointed as manager or secretary. One docs not ordinarily say that Mr. X is deputed as manager. On the other hand, to depute a person is to delegate a task or job to him. He is a delegate or deputy of one department to another. He docs not belong there. His assignment is by its very nature Of a limited nature - limited by time or the fulfilment of the assignment. This transitory, passing, fleeting character of assignment makes it a deputation.

9. The petitioner belongs to the Directorate of Public Instruction where he has since been promoted. His services were temporarily assigned to the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education during its infancy.

10. The fact that the petitioner, if he is continued on deputation in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education, will have better prospects of promotion by virtue of his seniority and experience does not create a right in him to continue on deputation, for, being a deputation's, his assignment is transitory.

11. It was then urged that the exercise of discretion by the Government in deciding to repatriate the petitioner to the parent department is arbitrary. As I have already stated the Government's decision not to extend the petitioner's deputation is based on the consideration of allocating the opportunities of employment in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education between members of the staff of the Directorate of Collegiate Education, the Directorate of Public Instruction and the Universities. The anticipated retrenchment of the ministerial staff of the universities and colleges demands consideration of their absorption in the Directorate of Higher Secondary Education. Bearing all these circumstances in mind the respondents have apportioned the posts so that there is a fair distribution of jobs between the different departments of the Government and the universities. The considerations on which the discretion has been exercised by the Government may be summarised.

12. Firstly it takes into account the fact that the petitioner is promoted as superintendent in the parent department Secondly it effects fair distribution of opportunities between employees of the Directorate of Public Instruction and the Directorate of Collegiate Education. Thirdly the consideration of fairness to the surplus staff from the universities, entered exercise of the discretion. In my opinion the Government has exercised its discretion on sound considerations. The impugned decision of the Government is not arbitrary. It is fair and just to all concerned.

13. For all these reasons there is no merit in this O.P It is therefore dismissed.

14. Dismissed.