Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

A.N. Sainalabdeen Musaliar v. District Collector

Kerala High Court
Jul 8, 1993
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Writ Appeal arising from O.P. 9732/1992)

Factual and Procedural Background

Kallada Bricks and Tile Works was owned by the deceased Varghese Daniel. On his death the business devolved upon his legal heirs, including the third respondent, who acted as Managing Partner. While the third respondent was managing the factory, the fourth respondent (an employee) was dismissed, leading to Industrial Dispute No. 31/1988 before the Labour Court, Kollam.

By award dated 17-4-1989 in I.D. 31/1988 the Labour Court directed the management to reinstate the dismissed worker with all back arrears and attendant service benefits. Because the workman was not reinstated or paid the arrears, he filed Claim Petition No. 85/1989 under Section 33C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act. By order dated 18-9-1991 the Labour Court fixed the amount payable at Rs. 52,388/-.

The writ petitioner (appellant in this appeal) purchased the factory and premises under three sale-deeds dated 6-9-1991, 15-11-1991 and 28-6-1992. Revenue Recovery proceedings were initiated and the factory and stock were attached for non-payment of the amount fixed in Claim Petition 85/1989. The writ petitioner approached the High Court to quash the revenue recovery proceedings and to obtain a declaration that he was not liable for the amount covered by the award and the Claim Petition order. A learned Single Judge dismissed the Original Petition by judgment dated 23-3-1993; the present writ appeal challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant (the purchaser of the factory and premises) is a successor-in-interest or assign of the establishment and therefore bound by the award in I.D. 31/1988 pursuant to Section 18(3)(c) of the Industrial Disputes Act.
  2. Whether, if the award is held to be binding on the appellant, the order passed in Claim Petition 85/1989 under Section 33C(2) (which quantified the amount due) is enforceable against the appellant.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The award in I.D. 31/1988 on the file of the Labour Court, Kollam is not binding on the appellant.
  • Even if the award in I.D. 31/1988 is binding on the appellant, the order in Claim Petition 85/1989 under Section 33C(2) could not be enforced against him.
  • The sale-deeds under which the appellant purchased the factory contained indemnity clauses and express undertakings that the property was free from encumbrances, so the appellant should not be fastened with the liability arising from the earlier award/order.

The opinion does not contain a detailed, separate statement of the respondents' arguments; the narrative describes facts and the court's response to the appellant's contentions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A.C.A. & I. Society v. Workmen, AIR 1963 S.C. 1489 Factors to determine whether a purchaser of an industrial concern is a successor-in-interest of the vendor for purposes of industrial adjudication (e.g., purchase of whole business, whether purchased as a going concern, continuity of place and operations, absence of substantial break, whether goodwill was purchased, whether purchaser continued same/similar business, and other relevant factors). The court applied the A.C.A. & I. Society factors to the facts: it found that the appellant purchased the factory as a going concern, continued the factory operations, and that the indemnity clause in the sale-deeds did not change the appellant's character as a successor-in-interest. On evaluation of these factors, the court concluded that the appellant is a successor-in-interest and therefore bound by the award in I.D. 31/1988.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two linked analytical steps, grounded in statute and precedent:

  1. Statutory premise: Section 18(3)(c) of the Industrial Disputes Act makes an award passed by a Labour Court binding on "all successors or assigns in respect of the establishment to which the dispute relates." The central question was whether the appellant, having purchased the factory and premises, was such a successor or assign.
  2. Application of precedent and facts to successor-in-interest question:
    • The court relied on the factors set out by the Supreme Court in A.C.A. & I. Society v. Workmen to decide if a purchaser is a successor-in-interest. Those factors include whether the whole business was purchased, whether it was a going concern, continuity of place and operation, breaks in continuity, purchase of goodwill, and whether the purchaser carried on essentially the same business.
    • On the facts the court found that the appellant purchased the entire factory and premises, the sale-deeds specifically authorized the transferee to carry on the tile industry, and the appellant continued the factory. The appellant himself averred that until the sale deed the third respondent was the Managing Partner and repeatedly described the sale as in relation to the "factory". These facts supported a finding that the purchase was of a going concern and that the appellant continued the same business.
    • The court addressed the indemnity clause in the sale-deeds (which purported to transfer the property free from encumbrances and contained vendor undertakings to make good losses). The court observed that an indemnity clause does not alter the purchaser's character as an assignee or successor-in-interest; the Supreme Court's decision in A.C.A. & I. had involved a transfer with a clause obliging the transferor to pay liabilities, yet the transferee was still treated as successor-in-interest. Following that precedent, the court held the indemnity clause did not prevent the appellant from being a successor-in-interest bound by the award.
  3. Binding effect of the Claim Petition order under Section 33C(2):
    • The court interpreted the statutory definition of "award" to include not only the main determination but also "any question relating thereto." The quantification of back arrears and attendant benefits was characterised as a question relating to the award.
    • Section 33C(2) provides the Labour Court jurisdiction to decide questions as to amounts due when a workman is entitled to receive money or benefits capable of being computed in money. The Claim Petition 85/1989 was filed under that provision to quantify amounts due because the employer had failed to reinstate the workman and pay arrears.
    • Given the court's finding that the appellant was bound by the main award (I.D. 31/1988), the court reasoned that any order passed in execution, or to give effect to that award—such as the quantification in Claim Petition 85/1989—must also be binding on the appellant. The Labour Court in 85/1989 was carrying out execution/quantification pursuant to the award and had not varied or modified the award.
    • The court rejected the appellant's contention that the Claim Petition order could not be enforced against him, noting that accepting this contention would create an incongruous result in which an award is binding but an execution/order effectuating it is not.
  4. Limited reservation: the court noted that its conclusions on binding effect did not preclude the appellant from claiming the benefit of the indemnity clause in the sale-deeds as against his vendors; the indemnity might operate as a contractual remedy between purchaser and vendors but did not prevent the purchaser from being treated as a successor for industrial adjudication purposes.

Holding and Implications

Final Holding: The writ appeal fails and is accordingly DISMISSED.

Direct Implications for the Parties:

  • The appellant is a successor-in-interest of Kallada Bricks and Tile Works and is therefore bound by the award in Industrial Dispute No. 31/1988 passed by the Labour Court, Kollam (award dated 17-4-1989).
  • The appellant is also bound by the Labour Court's order in Claim Petition No. 85/1989 under Section 33C(2) (quantifying the workman's entitlement at Rs. 52,388/- by order dated 18-9-1991), because that order was an execution/quantification giving effect to the award.
  • The court observed that the appellant may still pursue contractual remedies under the indemnity clause in the sale-deeds against his vendors; the indemnity does not defeat the appellant's status as a successor for the purposes of enforcing the award and the Claim Petition order, but it may provide relief as between purchaser and vendor.

Broader Legal Implications: The decision applies the established factors from A.C.A. & I. Society v. Workmen to determine successor status and affirms that indemnity clauses in sale deeds do not automatically prevent a purchaser from being regarded as a successor-in-interest for industrial adjudication. The opinion does not state that it establishes a new legal principle beyond applying the cited precedent.

Show all summary ...

Sreedharan, J.:— Writ petitioner in O.P 9732/1992 challenges the judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 23-3-1993 dismissing the said Original Petition.

2. The short facts necessary for the disposal of this writ appeal are as follows. Kallada Bricks and Tile works was owned by the father of third respondent. On his death, the business devolved on third respondent, his mother and brothers and sisters. Third respondent was the Managing Partner of the factory 4th respondent was an employee in that factory. He was dismissed from service. That gave rise to Industrial Dispute 31/1988 Labour Court, Kollam directed the management to reinstate the worker with all back arrears and other attendant service benefits by its award dated 17-4-1989. As the workman was not paid his wages in terms of the award, he approached the Labour Court, Kollam by moving Claim Petition 85/1989 under Section 33C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, herein after referred to as “the Act”. That Court, by order dated 18-9-1991, fixed the amount payable to the workman at Rs. 52,388/-. After the award in I.D 31/1988, writ petitioner purchased the factory and ifs sine under three documents executed by third respondent and his realizations, the legal heirs of deceased Varghease Daniel, the father of the third respondent. These documents were executed on 6-9-1991, 15-11-1991 and 28-6-1992. Pursuant to these sals deeds, writ petitioner-appellant was ranging the factory. While so, on account of the non-payment of the amount to the workman covered by the Claim Petition 85/1989 under Section 33C(2) of the Act, proceedings under the Revenue Recovery Act were initiated, Factory and the stock therein were attached by, the revenue authorities. Writ petitioner thereupon approached this Court to quash the proceeding initiated by the revenue authorities under the Revenue Recovery Act and also for a declaration that he is not liable for the amount covered by the award and the order in the Claim Petition passed by the Labour Court, Kollam.

3. The mam argument advanced by the learned counsel representing the appellant is that the award in I.D 31/1988 on she file of the Labour Court, Kollam is not binding on the appellant. It is also his contention that even if the award in I.D 31/1988 is found to be binding on the appellant, the order on Claim Petition 85/1989 filed under Section 33C(2) of the Act cannot be enforsed as against him.

4. It is the common case of parties that Kallada Bricks and Tile works was owned and run by deceased Varghese Daniel. On his death the factory and the premises devolved on third respondent and other legal heirs. Thereupon third respondent was running the firm as its Managing Partner. While the factory was being run by the third respondent as Managing Partner, 4th respondent, an employee in the factory, was dismissed from service. The said dismissal gave rise to I.D 31/1988 on the file of the Labour Court, Kollam. That case was disposed of on 17-4-1989 by passing an award directing the management to reinstate 4th respondent with all arrears of wages end of her attendant benefits. Since the workman was not reinstated with arrears of salary, he moved the Labour Courts under Section 33C(2) of the Act by filing Claim Petition 85/1989. Pending that application, appellant purchased the properties and the factory under three sale-deeds dated 6-9-1991, 15-11-1991 and 28-6-1992. Claim Petition under Section 33C(2) of the Act was disposed of on 18-9-1991 by quantifying the amount due to the workman at Rs. 52,388/-.

5. Sale-deed taken by the appellant specifically provided for the appellant fo conduct the tile industry in the property covered therein. Document dated 6-9-1991 covers 20 Cents of property in which the factory building, sheds and other machinery are situated. As per that document, the transferee was authorised to effect mutation to use the building and to conduct the tile industry. The sale-deed dated 15-11-1991 contains a provision that the transferor relinquishes entire possession over the schedule properties, sheds, tile manufacturing factory and machinery. The transferee is authorised to carry on the factory. The sale-deeds contain indemnity clause stating that the schedule property as absolutely free from any encumbrance claims and also free from sales tax, income tax, purchase tax and revenue tax. The transferor have undertaken to make good the loss of the transferee in case contrary to their undertaking if he happens to suffer any loss. On account of indemnity clause, it is argued that the liability of the third respondent to pay the amount covered by the Claim Petition should not be fastened on the appellant.

6. The legal heirs of deceased Varghese Daniel was running the Kallada Bricks and Tile works. While that factory was being run by them third respondent as the Managing Partner, appellant herein purchased the property and the factory. The purchase was effected at a time when award in I.D 31/1988 passed by the Labour Court, Kollam was in force. It is also worthwhile to note that the claim petition filed by 4th respondent pursuant to the award was also pending before the Labour Court. As per Section 18(3)(c) of the Act an award passed by a Labour Court shall be binding on all successors or assigns in respect of the establishment to which the dispute relates. The question that arises for consideration is whether the appellant its the successor or assigns in respect of the Kaliada Bricks and Tile Works, to which the dispute in I.D 31/1988 related to. As stated earlier, third respondent was the Managing Partner of the Kallada Bricks and Tile works. While it was being run by the third respondent, 4th respondent was dismissed from service 4th respondent got award in that industrial dispute in his favour. So that award is binding on the third respondent and the establishment. Appellant herein purchased that establishment under three documents. By that purchase will he not become the successor or assign in respect of that establishment?

7. In A.C.A & I Society v. Workmen (AIR 1963 S.C 1489) a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court examined the question as to whether a purchaser of an industrial concern can be held to be a successor in interest of the vendor. Their Lordships laid down certain factors to be taken into consideration. They are.

“Did the purchaser purchase the whole of the business? was the business purchased a going concern at the time of the sale transaction? Is the business purchased carried on at the same place as before? Is the business carried on without a substantial break in time? Is the business purchased carried in at the same or similar to the business in the hands of the vendor? If there has been a break in the continuity of the business, what is the nature of the break and what were the reasons responsible for it? What is the length of the break? Has goodwill been purchased? Is the purchase only of some parts and the purchaser having purchased the said parts purchased some other new parts and started a business of his own which is not the same as the old business but is similar to it? These and all other relevant factors have to borne in mind in deciding the question as to whether the purchaser can be said to be a successor-in-interest of the vendor for the purpose of industrial adjudication. It is hardly necessary to emphasise in this connection that though all the facts to which we have referred by way of illustration are relevant, it would be unreasonable to exaggerate the Importance of any one of these facts or to adopt the inflexible rule that the presence or absence of any one of them is decisive of the matter one way or the other”.

8. In the instant case, appellant purchased the entire factory and it's premises. At the time when he purchased the factory. It was being run by the third respondent as Managing Partner. What is averred by him in paragraph 2 of the writ petition is:—

“Until the execution or Ext. P1 sale deed the 3rd respondent herein was the Managing Partner of the factory in question”.

9. The fact that appellant purchased the “factory” is not in controversy. He has reiterated in his Original Petition at various places that the sale deed taken by him was in relation to the “factory” In question. These show that when the sale deed was taken by the appellant, it was a going concern. Appellant continued the factory. His only contention appears to be that the factory in question has been sold free from all encumbrances. The fact that vendor has taken upon himself the liability to discharge the encumbrances will not in any way change his character as an assignee of the factory. In the above mentioned decision rendered by the Supreme Court the sub-deed contained a clause that the transferor company will pay all its liabilities, secured and unsecured, determined or to be determined and the society will not be liable to pay the same. Inspire of such an indemnity clause. Their Lordships come to the conclusion that the assignee was a successor in interest of the company. On an evaluation of all the relevant factors in this case, we have no hesitation in coming to the conclusion that appellant herein is a successor in interest of Kallads Bricks and Tile Works, the management in I.D 31/1988. It, therefore, follows that the appellant is bound by the award in I.D 31/1988. Another argument advanced by the learned counsel representing the appellant is that even if the award is held to be binding on the appellant under Section 18(3)(c) of the Act, the order in Claim Petition 85/1989 filed under Section 33C(2) of the Act cannot be enforced as against the appellant. An “award” under the Act inter-alia means an interim or a final determination of any industrial dispute os of any question relating thereto by any Labour Court. It means an award comprehends within it the determination of any question relating to the award as well. An “Industrial dispute” inter-alia means a dispute or difference between an employer and workman. Consequently the “award” under the Act is comprehensive enough to take within its ambit not only disputes between the parties, but also Includes determination of any question relating thereto. By the award in I.D 31/1988, the Labour Court directed the management to reinstate the worker with all back arrears add other attendant service benefits. Quantification of the back arrears and other attendant circumstances necessarily falls within the ambit of any question relating to the award. Decision on such a question must necessarily, come within the purview of “award” as defined under the Act Under Section 33C(2) of the when a workman is entitled to receive from the employer any money or any benefit which is capable of being computed in terms of money and if any question arises as to the amount of money due or as to the amount at which such benefits should be computed, then the question may be decided by the Labour Court. Invoking this provision, 4th respondent moved the Labour Court by filing Claim Petition 85/1989. That Claim Petition Was necessitated on account of the failure of the third respondent and the appellant herein in reinstating the 4th respondent. This we say because of our finding that the appellant is bound by the award in I.D 31/1988 by virtus of Section 18(3)(c) of the Act. When the main award is binding, any order passed in execution of that award should also be binding on the appellant. In the ordinary circumstances Section 33C(2) provides the forum for execution of the award passed in the industrial disputes. The Labour Court exercising its jurisdiction under Section 33C(2) was only giving effect to the award in I.D 31/1988 and it had not gone behind the award. Nor has it gone to vary or modify the award either. Viewed in this light, we find no merit in the contention of the appellant that he is not bound by the order passed by the Labour Court under Section 33C(2) of the facts and circumstances of this case, we have no hesitation in holding that the order of the Labour Court in Claim Petition 85/1989 as one passed in execution of the award in I.D 31/1988 and the appellant is bound by the same. Any view contrary to this, if taken, will result in an incongruous situation wherein an original award will he binding, but not an order passed in execution thereof. It, therefore, follows that the appellant is bound by the award in I.D 31/1988 and the order in Claim Petition 85/1989 passed by the Labour Court, Kollam. This may not deny him of the benefit of the indemnity clause incorporated in the sale deeds taken by him as against his vendors.

10. The result, therefore, is writ appeal fails and it is accordingly dismissed.