- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Tharangini Records v. State Of Kerala
Analytical Summary of the Judgment
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, M/s. Tharangini Records, is engaged in recording music on blank cassettes and selling pre-recorded cassettes. The petitioner was assessed for the periods 1981-82 and 1982-83 under both the Central Sales Tax Act and the Kerala General Sales Tax Act. The petitioner contended that the rate of tax applied was excessive and erroneous and filed appeals (evidenced by Exts. P8, P10, P13 and P14). The appellate authority initially remanded the matter (Ext. P4) and ultimately disposed of the appeals adversely to the petitioner (Exts. P11 and P12).
During the progression of these proceedings, on 28-7-1986 the State Government issued a clarification (Ext. P15) under S.59A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, stating that "record players and cassettes will come under entry 155 of the 1st schedule" and be liable to sales tax at 15% at the point of first sale within the State. The petitioner challenged Ext. P15 before this Court, seeking quashment of Ext. P15 and a declaration that cassettes were not assessable under Entry 155 for the relevant period.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Government's clarification (Ext. P15), issued under S. 59A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, validly classifies record players and cassettes under Entry 155 of the First Schedule and thereby subjects them to tax at 15% at the point of first sale within the State.
- Whether "tape cassettes" can be interpreted to fall within the statutory category "gramophone records" (Entry 155), given the legislative history and technological differences.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner maintained that the rate of tax imposed for the periods 1981-82 and 1982-83 was excessive and erroneous.
- The petitioner contended that cassettes are not properly classifiable as "gramophone records" under Entry 155 and therefore should not be taxed under that entry for the relevant period.
- Accordingly, the petitioner sought quashment of Ext. P15 and a declaration that cassettes were not liable under Entry 155 for the relevant years.
State / Governmental Position
- The Government issued Ext. P15 under S. 59A clarifying that record players and cassettes fall under Entry 155 and are liable to sales tax at 15% on first sale within the State.
- The Board of Revenue took the view that cassettes could be brought under "Gramophones and component parts thereof and records" (Entry 155), relying on the decision in Shyam & Co. v. Commr. of Sales Tax (1980) 45 S.T.C. 167.
- The Law Department advised the Government to agree with the Board of Revenue's suggestion, referring to the 1980 STC 45 decision, and the Government issued Ext. P15 on that footing.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S. Partap Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 1964 SC 72 | Admissibility of tape-recorded conversation as evidence; tape record treated as primary/direct evidence. | Cited as part of authorities showing that tape recordings have been judicially treated as admissible evidence in India. |
| Shri N. Sri Rama Reddy v. Shri V.V. Giri, (1970) 2 SCC 340 : AIR 1971 SC 399 | Reaffirmation that tape records are primary evidence and admissible. | Relied on in the discussion of evidentiary treatment of tapes; cited to demonstrate established legal treatment of tape evidence. |
| R. M. Malkani v. State of Maharashtra, (1973) 1 SCC 471 : AIR 1973 SC 157 | Judicial treatment of tape-recorded evidence. | Used to illustrate jurisprudence on admissibility of taped conversations. |
| Z.B. Bukhari v. B.R. Mehra, (1976) 2 SCC 17 : AIR 1975 SC 1788 | Further authority on tapes and evidence. | Cited among Supreme Court authorities that discuss tape-recorded material in evidence law. |
| R v. Maqsud Ali, (1965) 2 All E.R. 464 | English criminal law authority discussing tape records as evidence. | Cited as an international authority treating tape records in the evidentiary context. |
| Nixon v. Richey, 168 U.S. App. D.C. 169 | American authority referencing recorded material (contextual). | Referenced as part of comparative discussion on recorded tapes and legal treatment in other jurisdictions. |
| Presidential Records and Materials Preservation Act, Public Law 93-526; Nixon v. Administrator of General Services, 433 U.S. 425 | US statutory and constitutional treatment of Presidential records; upholding constitutionality of the Act. | Referred to as an instance of special legislation regarding recorded materials in the US and judicial validation thereof. |
| Richard Nixon v. Warner Communications, Inc., 435 U.S. 589 | US Supreme Court decision dealing with commercial exploitation of Presidential tapes. | Used in the opinion to illustrate legal issues about the commercial use of recorded material in the US context. |
| The Statute of Liberty case, (1968) 2 All E.R. 195 | International authority referenced in relation to tape records and evidence. | Cited to show other decisions touching tape-recorded material. |
| R. v. Robson & Harris, (1972) E.R. 699 | Another English decision on tape records. | Referred to among authorities considering taped evidence. |
| Silvester v. R. Balakrishna Pillai, O.P. Nos. 5055 & 4125 of 1986 (reference order) | Reference order that discussed aspects related to tapes and related technology. | Cited as an instance where legal mechanics and scientific details of television/accessories were considered. |
| Sony Corp. v. Universal City Studios, 464 U.S. 417 | US decision addressing legal mechanics and scientific details of video recording (e.g., time-shifting, VTR). | Referred to for comparative analysis of the legal and technological issues surrounding recording devices and media. |
| Heraid-Sun T.V. Proprietary Limited v. Australian Broadcasting Tribunal, (1984-85) 156 C.L.R. 1 | Commonwealth decision dealing with television and accessories. | Referenced among international decisions examining legal mechanics of television/video technology. |
| Commercial Radio Cofs Harbour Limited v. Fuller, (1986) 161 C.L.R. 47 | Australian decision relevant to broadcasting/recording law. | Used as an example of foreign jurisprudence on related technological issues. |
| R v. General Medical Council exp Colman, (1990) 1 All E.R. 489 | English authority on regulatory/administrative aspects; cited in context of technological/legal discussion. | Referenced among other international authorities discussing technology and law. |
| Shyam & Co. v. Commissioner of Sales Tax, (1980) 45 S.T.C. 167 | Authority relied upon to support the proposition that record players and records fall within the entry "Gramophones and component parts thereof and records". | Relied upon by the Board of Revenue and the Government to justify placing cassettes under Entry 155; the Court noted the Board's reliance but also criticised that the Board and Government did not adequately examine the facts and reasoning of that decision for the present complex tax question. |
| (1977) 40 S.T.C. 57 | Cited regarding the use of the word "include" in statute—whether it enlarges meaning or gives an exhaustive meaning. | Referred to in the Government file reasoning considered by the Court when discussing whether Entry 152 could cover record players and cassettes. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by first setting out the factual and procedural matrix: assessments for 1981-82 and 1982-83, appeals, remand by the appellate authority, final adverse disposal, and issuance of a Government clarification (Ext. P15) under S. 59A classifying record players and cassettes under Entry 155. The Court observed that once a Government clarification of that nature was issued, one could ordinarily expect lower authorities to follow it.
The Court then examined technological and legislative context. It emphasized that gramophone records pre-dated the popular use of cassettes and tapes. The Court found it difficult on a plain understanding to include "tape cassettes" within the statutory expression "gramophone records". This observation led the Court to question the sustainability of Ext. P15.
The Court directed production of the Government files and reviewed the internal analysis. Initially the Government considered whether cassettes could be brought under Entry 152 (cinematographic equipment and sound recording and reproducing equipment). The Government file discussed the interpretative effect of the word "include"—whether it enlarges meaning or gives an exhaustive definition—and noted that if "include" were used exhaustively, only sound equipment used exclusively for cinematographic purposes would fall under Entry 152.
The Board of Revenue disagreed with the Law Department's initial view and asserted that cassettes could be brought under the "Gramophone and component parts thereof and records" entry (Entry 155), relying on the Allahabad High Court decision in Shyam & Co. The Law Department then advised the Government to agree with the Board's suggestion in view of that decision, and the Government approved Ext. P15 on that basis.
The Court critically examined the conduct of the Board and the Law Department. It found the Law Department's advice to be casual and careless and stated that the Board, in relying on Shyam & Co., had not carefully considered either the facts of that case or its reasoning. The Court observed that Shyam & Co. merely assumed that record players and records fell within the gramophone entry; that assumption was of little assistance in resolving the complex tax question before the Court. The Court emphasised that the Board should have examined the legislative history and scientific characteristics of the items before concluding as it did.
On the substantive point, the Court held that it was difficult to include tape cassettes within the Entry "gramophone records" on a plain understanding and with reference to legislative history. Consequently, the Court concluded that the Governmental exercise under S. 59A reflected in Ext. P15 was unsustainable.
The Court also noted that the question of classification had limited relevance for later years because the Finance Act of 1987 (effective 1-7-1987) amended the schedules to bring tapes and cassettes within Entry 191, and thereafter such items would be taxed as unclassified items under that entry.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed; Ext. P15 is held to be unsustainable and the relief sought by the petitioner is granted.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The Court allowed the writ petition challenging the Government clarification Ext. P15; Ext. P15 was found unsustainable and the petition was allowed in favour of the petitioner. The Court did not make any order as to costs.
- Broader consequence noted by the Court: For later years the issue was of reduced practical significance because the Finance Act, 1987 (effective 1-7-1987) brought tapes and cassettes within Entry 191, meaning such items would thereafter be taxed as unclassified items under that entry.
- No new wide-reaching precedent on taxation categories beyond the decision in this case is stated by the Court; the decision rests on the specific legislative history, technological distinctions between gramophone records and tape cassettes, and the procedural deficiencies the Court found in the Government's reliance on prior authority without adequate scrutiny.
No costs were ordered despite the petitioner having been subjected to "sufficient harassment", as recorded by the Court.
JUDGMENT
1. Discordant voices in relation to the tax liability imposable on some musical equipments have led to this original petition. The petitioner, M/s. Tharangini records, carries on the business of recording music in blank cassettes and selling the recorded cassettes.
2. Music, of course, is no mere mechanical feat. Shakespeare referred to it as ‘food of love’. Any entirety of sweetness is the oriental concept. Its inspirational origin and artistic frame are too transparent. Scientific discoveries have facilitated transmission of the voice through various equipments; and its preservation for endless years.
3. The petitioner was assessed for the periods 1981-82 and 1982-83. According to the petitioner, the rate of tax was excessive and erroneous. Appeals were filed. The appellate authority who heard the cases, and the long arguments, as is referred to in that order, thought it better not to trouble himself with the mental exercises necessary for an exhaustive examination of the legal contentions. It was easy to make a remand. That he did under Ext. P4 order.
4. The fight in the assessing arena continued. Added might was furnished by additional objections raised. They were, however, of no avail, when the assessing authority passed an assessment, scuttling the entire contentions by a single sentence reading:
“Though what is sold by the dealers is pre-recorded cassette, it can still be used for fresh recording of sound in it and hence, the contention that this is a general item cannot be accepted”.
5. The assessee approached, again, the appellate authority for relief. The appeals for the two years, as against the assessments made both under the Central Sales Tax Act and Kerala General Sales Tax Act, are evidenced by Exts. P8, P10. P13 and P14. It would have been the obvious obligation of the appellate authority to look into the contentions and render a reasoned decision. The appeals were disposed of by Exts. P11 and P12 orders, adversely to the petitioner.
6. Another event intervened in the meanwhile. On 28-7-1986, the Government issued a clarification, Ext. P15, invoking S. 59A of the KGST Act. It has referred to G.O(P) 102/86.TD and published in the gazette dated 28-7-1986. The operative portion of the clarification reads:
“Having examined the matter in detail Government by virtue of the powers conferred under S. 59A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 hereby clarify that record players and cassettes will come under entry 155 of the 1st schedule to the said Act liable to sales tax at 15% at the point Of first sale within the State”.
7. In as much as the Government has issued a clarification as in the above terms, one cannot ordinarily expect from the Appellate Assistant Commissioner a view contrary to the one contained in the clarification.
8. The petitioner therefore approached this Court to quash Ext. P15 and for a declaration that the cassettes are not liable to be assessed under Entry 155 of the KGST Act as it stood during the relevant time.
9. The writ petition merits examination only in relation to this general question and having regard to the rigid stand now taken on behalf of the State and its functionaries.
10. Some basic scientific events and inventions may be briefly referred to, to understand the vexed tax problem involved in the case.
11. There was a time when administrators were not enthusiastically involved or interested in scientific innovations. Edison had one such experience when heattempted to demonstrate his new invention to an audience which included a Member of Parliament. Edison replied to his query that there will be a time when the products of electricity would be of much concern for the State. Later events demonstrated the prophetic message. Electric and electronic goods changed the very pattern of life. The manufacture, sale and distribution, and even their use and utility had been subjected to legal controls. Large chunks of revenue were contributed by the excise duty, Value Added Tax, sales-tax and the like by those products.
12. Even while dealing with legal questions in the familiar field of Evidence Act, the electronic gadgets and their utility had been noted by courts of law. Our own Supreme Court dealt with the question whether a tape recorded conversation was admissible in evidence. A well known case where a tape recorded conversation was admitted in evidence in S. Partap Singh v. State Of Punjab., AIR 1964 SC 72. Tape record is primary and direct evidence and therefore admissible-was the view reiterated in Shri N. Sri Rama Reddy, Etc. v. Shri V.V Giri , (1970) 2 SCC 340 : AIR 1971 SC 399. Other decisions of the Supreme Court dealing with the evidentiary aspect of it are: R. M. Malkani v. State Of Maharashtra, (1973) 1 SCC 471 : AIR 1973 SC 157 and Z.B Bukhari v. B.R Mehra, (1976) 2 SCC 17 : AIR 1975 SC 1788. The English and American courts also have treated tape records of conversation, as evidence, (vide R v. Maqsud Ali, (1965) 2 All E.R 464 and Nixon v. Richey, 168 U.S App. D.C 169). A special law was brought by American congress-Presidential Records and Materials Preservation Act, Public Law 93-526 in thewake of the “Water Gate”. The constitutional validity of the Act was upheld by the Supreme Court of America in Nixon v. Administrator of General Services, 433 U.S 425. Yet another decision of that court dealing with the commercial exploitation of the Presidential tapes in Richard Nixon v. Warner Communications, INC., 435 U.S 589 : 55 L Ed 2d 570. Tapes have been discussed in the context of the Law of Evidence by Cross on Evidence, 5th Edn. Pages 13-14. Two other decisions touching that aspect are The Statute of Liberty case, (1968) 2 All ER 195 and R. v. Robson & Harris, (1972) E.R 699.
13. Technical literature regarding tapes is now available a plenty. Video Tape Recorders by Barry Kybett, 2nd Edn. is one such handy book. Some of these aspects had been discussed in the reference order in Silvester v. R. Balakrishna Pillai, O.P Nos. 5055 & 4125 of 1986. Some recent decisions which had occasion to go into the legal mechanics as also the scientific details of television and the accessories are available in Sony Corp. v. Universal City Studios, 464 U.S 417 : 78 L Ed 2d 574, Heraid-Sun T.V Proprietary Limited v. Australian Broadcasting Tribunal, (1984-85) 156 Commonwealth Law Reports 1, Commercial Radio Cofs Harbour Limited v. Fuller, (1986) 161 C.L.R 47 and R v. General Medical Council, exp Colman, (1990) 1 All E.R 489. Words and phrases in the vocabulary of television and video tape recorders, are available from the discussion in the American case-such as about ‘betamax Video Tape Recorders (V.T.R),’ the practice of ‘time-shifting’, and the like.
14. India has almost caught up with the developed countries as regards the use of electronic media. Millions noware moved to their cosy corners at home to watch the televised programmes. These are, however, only recent developments. Even advanced countries had extensive use of them only after 1960s.
15. As to how the State Legislature viewed these developments and adapted their stratagies in relation to the taxing operation may now be considered.
16. It is not necessary to trace all the sales tax laws and the Entry regarding gramophone in the schedules thereunder. It is sufficient if we start from the time the Travancore-Cochin State was formed.
17. It will be seen that even in 1949, there was an entry “Radio Gramophones” as covered by S. 3(2) of the General Sales Tax Act, 1125. The tax burden was somewhat light; only three paise in the rupee. Radio gramophones and component parts of radio gramophones came under Entry 8 when the Act stood amended by Act 21 of 1958. The 1963 enactment also contained the entry relating to ‘gramophones’ the component parts there of and records under Entry 10 of the First Schedule. In other words, the Legislature had noticed the gramophones and the gramophone records and the tax yielding source thereunder, even prior to the amendment of the Act in 1980.
18. Even on a plain understanding, it will be difficult to include “tape cassettes” within the Entry “gramophone records”. For one thing, the gramophone records, as is known from scientific history, were available long before 1960 at about the time when cassettes and tapes become popular. Ext. P15 is consequently unsustainable.
19. In as much as the Governmental exercise of power under S. 59A, evident from Ext. P15 was somewhat strange, the court directed the production of the relevant files.
20. It would appear that, initially the question which was considered by the Government, was whether cassettes would come under sound recording and reproducing equipment. That was considered in the background of Entry 152 of the First Schedule, reading:
“152. Cinematographic equipments, including cameras, projectors and sound recording and reproducing equipments, lenses, films and parts and accessories required for use therewith.”
The opinion indicated the reasons:
“The word “include” is ordinarily used in order to enlarge the meaning of words and phrases occurring in the body of the statutes and when it is so used these words or phrases must be construed as comprehending not only such things as they signify according to their natural import, but also those things which the interpretation clause declares that they shall include. It gives an extended statutory meaning to the word defined which is in addition to its ordinary popular and natural sense. If this meaning is accepted for purposes of classifying the present entry there is nothing wrong in finding that the Record Players and Cassettes are sound recording and reproducing equipments falling under entry 152 of the 1st Schedule to the K.G.S.T Act It may also be noted that some times the word “include” is used by the Legislature not to extend the meaning of a word but to give an exhaustive meaning of the word by way of clarification (1977) 40 S.T.C 57). If this view is to be followed it can be safely held that sound recording and reproducing equipments used exclusively for the purpose of cinematographic equipments alone will fall under this entry. In other words, record players and cassettes if they are not used or are not intended to be used in connection with use of the cinematographic equipment they will not fall under entry 152. It is the well settled law that the taxation laws should be interpreted to the advantage of the assessee.”
21. The view that was accepted by the Government on the basis of an advice tendered by the Law Department was communicated by the Government to the Board of Revenue. However, the Board of Revenue expressed its dissent. The gist of the letter was that cassettes can be brought under “Gramophone and Component parts thereof and records” as detailed in Entry 155. A decision of the Allahabad High Court reported in Shyam & Co. v. Commr. of Sales Tax, (1980) 45 S.T.C 167 was relied on to support that stand. The Government was requested to issue a clarification to that effect.
22. The Government again sought advice from the Law Department of the Government. The Law Department gave its opinion in these terms:
“In view of the judgment reported in 1980 STC 45 this department may agree with the suggestion of the Board of Revenue at ‘X’ orr page 39 c.f
Joint Secretary,
dated 16-6-86.”
23. It is unfortunate that the Law Department gave its views in a casual and careless manner.
24. The Board of Revenue, which relied on Shyam & Co. v. Commr. of Sales Tax, (1980) 45 STC 167, also does not appear to have carefully looked into the facts of the case or the reasoning. The decision in (1980) 45 STC 167 supra, assumed that record players, and records fall within the category of the entry ‘Gramophones and component parts thereof and records’. This assumption is of no avail in the determination of a complex tax question. That aspect of the matter should have occurred to the board which has a tradition of expertise in such matters. The Board should have addressed itself to the history of the legislation and the scientific information in relation to the articles. The ill-informed and incorrect view of the Board was approved by the Government without adequate independant scrutiny. The resultant order Ext. P15 is consequently unsustainable.
25. The question does not have much relevance for later years, in view of the amendment effected by the Finance Act of 1987, effective from 1-7-1987, when tapes and cassettes for electronic equipments have been brought within the purview of Entry 191. It will then follow that the item will have to be taxed only as an unclassified item. The writ petition is accordingly allowed as indicated above, I do not make any order as to costs, though the assessee had been subjected to sufficient harassment.
26. Allowed.
Alert