Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Teekoy Rubbers (India) Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax.

Kerala High Court
Sep 18, 1989
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — K.S. Paripoornan, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from references made by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (the Tribunal) to this Court in proceedings involving the assessee and the Revenue for the assessment years 1974–75 and 1975–76.

The central factual locus is that the assessee sold old rubber trees during the relevant years and disclosed the sale receipts in Part III of the original returns. It is admitted that any capital gains arising from those sales were not brought to tax in the original assessments.

The Income-tax Department's Audit drew the Income-tax Officer's attention to the omission. The Assessments for both years were reopened under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner found the reassessment proceedings invalid, but the Tribunal sustained the reopening and referred specific questions of law to this Court. The Tribunal had remitted the matter for fresh investigation and assessment if the reopening was held valid.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. For assessment year 1974–75: Whether the Tribunal was right in holding that the assessment was validly reopened under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961?
  2. For assessment year 1974–75: Whether the Tribunal was justified in finding that the materials collected and relied upon by the assessing officer for arriving at the market value of rubber trees as on January 1, 1954, are relevant?
  3. For assessment year 1975–76: Whether the Tribunal was right in holding that the assessment was validly reopened under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961?
  4. For assessment year 1975–76: Whether, in light of facts admitted in the appeal memorandum, the Tribunal was justified in holding that the real "information" for reopening was not the audit note of the Internal Audit Party?
  5. For assessment year 1975–76: Whether there was evidence on record to support the finding that the Income-tax Officer had received information after the date of the original assessment justifying reopening under section 147(b)?
  6. For assessment year 1975–76: Whether the materials collected and relied upon by the assessing officer for arriving at the market value of rubber trees as on January 1, 1954, are relevant?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Assessee's) Arguments

  • Counsel for the assessee (Mr. Joseph Vellapally) contended that the Income-tax Officer ought to have made necessary enquiries earlier once the sale proceeds of rubber trees were shown in the return; therefore the reopening amounted to a mere change of opinion.
  • The assessee argued that the reassessment involved only reworking arithmetic or a change of opinion by the officer, which is insufficient to initiate proceedings under section 147(b).
  • Implicitly, the assessee challenged the validity of treating the Audit note as new information or as an interpretation that would justify reopening.

Respondent's (Revenue's) Arguments

  • Counsel for the Revenue submitted that even if relevant information was present in the original return, the Income-tax Officer had not applied his mind to the legal implications at that time. Reopening is permissible when the officer subsequently realises that income has escaped assessment.
  • The Revenue relied on subsequent correspondence and investigations undertaken by the Income-tax Officer as constituting the real information justifying reopening.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
United Mercantile Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, Kerala, [1967] 64 ITR 218 (Division Bench) Principle that particulars in the original return become an item of "information" for reopening only when their existence and legal implications are realized by the officer. The Court relied on this holding to support the proposition that disclosure in the return does not preclude reopening once the officer subsequently recognises the tax implications.
Anandji Haridas and Co. (P.) Ltd. v. S.P. Kasture, AIR 1968 SC 565 The Supreme Court referred with approval to the United Mercantile principle regarding when return contents become actionable information for reopening. The Court noted that the United Mercantile decision was referred to with approval by the Supreme Court, reinforcing the view that later realisation of implications can justify reopening.
S. Narayanappa v. CIT, [1967] 63 ITR 219 (SG) That the reasons enabling the Income-tax Officer to reopen an assessment need not be disclosed to the assessee at the investigatory stage; the process is inquisitorial and prior disclosure is not required. The Court applied this principle to hold there was no violation of natural justice in not communicating the reasons for reopening before issuing a notice; the officer was not bound to disclose such reasons at the investigatory stage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court focused primarily on whether the Income-tax Officer validly reopened the assessments under section 147(b) for the two assessment years. The analysis proceeded in distinct steps:

  1. Characterisation of the Audit note: The Tribunal (and this Court agreeing with it) held that the Audit report merely drew the Income-tax Officer's attention to an omission (that capital gains were not brought to tax) and did not amount to a legal interpretation that would itself be the decisive information. The Court accepted the Tribunal's view that the audit note alerted the officer but was not the substantive information on which the reopening rested.
  2. Identification of the "real information": The Tribunal found, and this Court endorsed, that the real information enabling reopening was the subsequent correspondence between the Income-tax Officer and the assessee and the further investigation conducted thereafter. That correspondence supplied particulars (e.g., number of trees sold, estates concerned, and other details) which were not available or realised earlier.
  3. Subsequent investigation and materials: On receiving the disclosures in that correspondence, the Income-tax Officer further investigated the value of rubber trees as on January 1, 1954, by consulting the Tariff Commission, the Rubber Board, and comparative sales information. Those post-assessment enquiries provided the material facts relied on.
  4. Application of precedent and principles: The Court invoked United Mercantile (and its approval in Anandji Haridas) to explain that information present in the original return becomes information for reopening only when the officer realises its existence and legal implications. Because the officer only later recognised that income had escaped assessment (through the subsequent correspondence and investigation), reopening under section 147(b) was permissible.
  5. Natural justice and disclosure: Addressing the contention that reasons for reopening were not disclosed to the assessee (alleged breach of natural justice), the Court held that the investigatory stage is inquisitorial. Reasons recorded to justify reopening need not be communicated to the assessee until a notice is issued and substantive assessment proceedings commence. Relying on S. Narayanappa, the Court concluded there was no duty to disclose the reasons at the earlier investigatory stage.
  6. Consequence for other referred questions: Because the Court upheld the validity of the reopening, it considered the Tribunal's remittal of issues about assessability and quantum to the Income-tax Officer. Given that the Tribunal had not made final findings on assessability or quantum, the Court found the remaining referred questions to be academic and declined to answer them.

Holding and Implications

Holding:
The assessments for the years 1974–75 and 1975–76 were validly reopened under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

Implications:

  • The appellate conclusions holding the reopenings valid were affirmed in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee for the specific question whether reopening was valid for each year.
  • The Tribunal had not made definitive findings on whether the capital gains were assessable or on the quantum; those matters were remitted for fresh investigation and determination by the Income-tax Officer pursuant to the valid reopenings.
  • The Court declined to answer the other referred questions (relating to relevance of materials or whether the audit note constituted the "real information") as they were academic in light of the finding on reopening.
  • A copy of the judgment was to be forwarded to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench, and the references were disposed of accordingly.

Note: This summary is confined strictly to the facts, arguments, reasoning, precedents, and outcomes as set out in the provided opinion and does not include material beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

K.S Paripoornan, J.:— At the instance of the assessee, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (in short “the Tribunal”) has referred the following questions of law for the decision of this court:

“For the assessment year 1974–75:

(1) On the facts and in the circumstances of the case, was the Tribunal right in holding that the assessment was validly reopened under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961?

(2) Was the Tribunal justified in its finding that the materials collected and relied upon by the assessing officer for arriving at the market value of rubber trees as on January 1, 1954, are relevant?

For the assessment year 1975–76:

(1) On the facts and in the circumstances of the case, was the Tribunal right in holding that the assessment was validly reopened under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961?

(2) On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in the light of the facts admitted in ground No. 2 of the appeal memorandum filed before the Tribunal, was the Tribunal justified in holding that the real ‘information’ for the reopening of the assessment was not the audit note of the Internal Audit Party?

(3) Was there evidence on record to support the finding of the Tribunal that the Income-tax Officer had received information after the date of the original assessment justifying reopening of the assessment under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961?

(4) Was the Tribunal justified in its finding that the materials collected and relied upon by the assessing officer for arriving at the market value of rubber trees as on January 1, 1954, are relevant?”

2. We are concerned with the assessment years 1974–75 and 1975–76. Two questions have been referred relating to the assessment year 1974–75 and four questions have been referred for the assessment year 1975–76. The respondent in both the cases is the Revenue.

3. We heard counsel for the applicant (assessee) as also counsel for the Revenue. The controversy involved in these two cases is regarding the assessment to capital gains on the sale of old rubber trees by the assessee for the two years. Admittedly, capital gains that accrued on the sale of old rubber trees (if any) was not brought to tax in the original assessments made.

4. The assessments were reopened under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act. The reassessment proceedings were found to be invalid by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner; but sustained by the Appellate Tribunal for both the years. It is agreed at the Bar that if the reopening of the assessments is valid, the Appellate Tribunal has only remitted the matter to be investigated afresh and so the answer to the other questions referred by the Appellate Tribunal will be only academic.

5. We proceed to consider whether the Income-tax Officer validly reopened the assessments under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act for both the years. In considering the said question, the Appellate Tribunal adverted to the fact that the assessee had shown the receipts from the sale of old rubber trees in Part III of the original return. It was also found that no efforts were made to bring to tax the capital gains embedded in the said receipts. The Audit Department drew the attention of the Income-tax Officer to the fact that certain receipts are shown on sales of rubber trees and no steps were taken for computing the capital gains therefrom. Thereafter, the Income-tax Officer entered into correspondence with the assessee. He ascertained the number of trees that were sold, the details of the estates with trees, the details from the Rubber Board referring to the report of the Tariff Commission, etc., and thereafter initiated proceedings to reopen the assessments. On the basis of the materials available before it, the Appellate Tribunal came to the conclusion that the audit note merely drew the attention of the Income-tax Officer to the omission and the audit note was not an interpretation of the law as contended by the assessee. On the facts, the Appellate Tribunal also came to the conclusion that the materials that were available before the Income-tax-Officer-constituted information, on the basis of which, the assessments were reopened.

6. Counsel for the assessee, Mr. Joseph Vellapally, vehemently contended that, in the background of the appellate order of the Tribunal for the earlier year, the Income-tax Officer should have made necessary enquiries when once the sale proceeds of the rubber trees were shown in the return, wherein was embedded the accrual of the capital gains, if any. Counsel submitted that this is a case of mere change of opinion by the Income-tax Officer or a mere display of arithmetic in arriving at the figure, which is insufficient to initiate proceedings under section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act. On the other hand, counsel for the Revenue submitted that though it may be said that the information relied on for the purpose of reopening the assessments was there even at the time when the original assessments were made, the concerned Income-tax Officer did not apply his mind, nor adverted to the fact of capital gains, and in such circumstances, the proceedings under section 147(b) are not barred.

7. On hearing the rival contentions of the parties, we are of the view that the reopening of the assessments is valid. The Appellate Tribunal, in our opinion, correctly held that the audit report in this case only drew the attention of the Income-tax Officer to the omission, namely, that the capital gains, which accrued, was not brought to tax. The Appellate Tribunal on the basis of materials available before it, held that the real information on the basis of which the assessments were reopened was the subsequent correspondence which the Income-tax Officer entered into with the assessee and the subsequent investigation with regard to the value of the rubber trees as on January 1, 1954. According to the Appellate Tribunal, both these points were material for deciding whether there was information available to the Income-tax Officer. Proceeding further, the Appellate Tribunal categorically found that the correspondence with the assessee gave most of the information with regard to the sales, etc., which was not available earlier. On the basis of the materials disclosed during the correspondence, the Income-tax Officer made further investigation with regard to the value of the rubber trees as on January 1, 1954, by referring to the findings of the Tariff Commission, details obtained from the Rubber Board and comparative sales in and around 1954, etc. In the light of the above findings, the Appellate Tribunal came to the conclusion that the assessments were validly reopened. We are of the view that in the light of the findings of the Appellate Tribunal that the real information on the basis of which the assessments were reopened was the facts that were disclosed or came to light as a result of the subsequent correspondence between the Income-tax Officer and the assessee, there was information within the meaning of section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act which enabled the Income-tax Officer to reopen the assessments for the two years. Even if the assessee disclosed in the original return the factum of sale of rubber trees and had claimed that it was exempt from tax, if the legal implications were not realised by the Income-tax Officer then, it will not preclude the Income-tax Officer from reopening the assessments on subsequent realisation that income has really escaped assessment. The details available in the original returns were transmitted into an item of information in the possession of the Officer only when its existence is realised and its implications are recognised. A Division Bench of this court in United Mercantile Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Kerala*, [1967] 64 ITR 218 has held so. The said decision was referred to with approval by the Supreme Court in Anandji Haridas and Co. (P.) Ltd. v. S.P Kasture, AIR 1968 SC 565. In the light of the above, we have no hesitation to hold-that the assessments were validly reopened for both the years.

8. It was next contended that the information on the basis of which the assessments were reopened was never disclosed to the assessee and so there is violation of natural justice. We are of the view that the reasons which enabled the Income-tax Officer to reopen the assessments need not be disclosed or communicated to the assessee. The proceedings for assessment start only after a notice is issued and served on the assessee. The assessee becomes a party to the proceedings only then. The reasons for reopening the assessments are to be recorded at an earlier stage of the proceedings, long before the assessee becomes a party to the proceedings. The procedure to be followed, then, is “inquisitorial” rather than accusatorial or adversarial, in nature. At that stage, no duty is cast on the Income-tax Officer either to afford an opportunity to the assessee or to furnish the reasons for reopening the assessments. That is a stage long before the assessee becomes a party to the proceedings.—See S. Narayanappa v. CIT, [1967] 63 ITR 219 (SG). In this view of the matter, we answer question No. 1 for the assessment year 1974–75 and also question No. 1 for the year 1975–76 in the affirmative, against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue.

9. The Tribunal has held that the assessments were validly reopened. The Tribunal has not entered a definite finding regarding the assessability of capital gains, and even so, the quantum thereof. This has been directed to be done by the Income-tax Officer. In the light of such finding, we are of the view that question No. 2 for the year 1974–75 and questions Nos. 2 to 4 for the year 1975–76 are really academic at this stage and we decline to answer these questions in the light of our conclusion that the reopening of the assessments is valid.

10. The income-tax references are disposed of as above.

11. A copy of this judgment under the seal of this court and the signature of the Registrar will be forwarded to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench.