Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

National Spices v. Andhra Bank

Kerala High Court
Jun 29, 1987
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

An order rejecting an application to implead an additional defendant, the Export Credit Guarantee Corporation (E.C.G.C), was challenged by the first defendant in revision. The first defendant is a partnership firm, and the other defendants are its partners. The suit was filed by Andhra Bank for recovery of amounts advanced under various loans. The defendants contended that the advances were guaranteed by E.C.G.C and that the Corporation was a necessary party to the suit. The plaintiff and E.C.G.C opposed the application to implead E.C.G.C. The transaction between the plaintiff and defendants was independent of the agreement between the plaintiff and E.C.G.C, to which the defendants were not parties. The plaintiff did not claim relief against E.C.G.C and did not wish to implead it. The application to implead was filed after the suit had been pending since 1984 and was already in trial, raising concerns that the application was intended to delay proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Export Credit Guarantee Corporation (E.C.G.C) is a necessary or proper party to the suit filed by Andhra Bank against the defendants.
  2. Whether the court can implead a party against the wishes of the plaintiff, especially when the plaintiff does not claim any relief against that party.
  3. Whether the application to implead E.C.G.C was permissible at the stage of trial or was intended to protract the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

First Defendant's Arguments

  • The advances made by the plaintiff were guaranteed by E.C.G.C, making E.C.G.C a necessary party to the suit.
  • The transaction between defendants and E.C.G.C was connected to the plaintiff's claim and thus E.C.G.C should be impleaded.

Plaintiff's and E.C.G.C's Arguments

  • The plaintiff’s transaction with the defendants is independent of the agreement between the plaintiff and E.C.G.C, to which defendants are not parties.
  • The plaintiff has not made any claim against E.C.G.C and does not seek any relief from it in the suit.
  • The liability of defendants towards the plaintiff is independent of any liability or claim involving E.C.G.C.
  • The application to implead E.C.G.C was opposed as it was not necessary and would only delay the trial.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sampo Frozen Foods v. Karnataka Bank Ltd. (1983 RLT 447) Principles on necessary and proper parties under Order 1 Rule 10 of CPC Supported the principle that only persons with direct interest in the cause of action should be impleaded; incidental interest is insufficient.
P.V George v. Bank of Madura Ltd. (1986 KLT 406) Interpretation of necessary and proper parties in litigation Reinforced that the plaintiff is the master of litigation and should not be compelled to litigate against parties not connected to the cause of action.
P.R Nallathambi v. V. Raghavan (AIR 1973 Madras 25) Scope of impleading parties under Order 1 Rule 10 Confirmed that only parties necessary for complete adjudication should be impleaded.
B. Somaiah v. Amina Begum (AIR 1976 A.P 182) Legal principles on joinder of parties Supported the court's discretion in impleading parties only when necessary or proper.
Herdeva v. Ismail (AIR 1970 Rajasthan 167) Criteria for necessary and proper parties Affirmed that parties with only commercial or indirect interest cannot be impleaded without plaintiff's consent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined whether E.C.G.C was a necessary or proper party to the suit under Order 1 Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC). It noted that the plaintiff is the master of the litigation and entitled to choose against whom to seek relief. The plaintiff’s claim was solely against the defendants based on loan transactions to which E.C.G.C was not a party. The agreement between plaintiff and E.C.G.C was independent and related to an insurance-type guarantee, not the cause of action in the suit. The defendants’ contention that E.C.G.C guaranteed the advances was not prima facie correct and was denied by plaintiff and E.C.G.C. The court emphasized that impleading a party against the plaintiff’s wishes is permissible only if that party is necessary or proper—i.e., if their presence is essential for complete adjudication of the questions involved in the suit. Since E.C.G.C had no direct interest in the cause of action or relief sought, and the plaintiff did not seek any relief against it, the Corporation was neither a necessary nor proper party. The court also considered that the application to implead was made late in the trial and appeared to be an attempt to delay proceedings. Therefore, the court concluded that the application to implead E.C.G.C was illegal and unreasonable.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the revision petition challenging the order rejecting the application to implead E.C.G.C, with costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that E.C.G.C will not be impleaded as a party in the suit, and the litigation will proceed only between the plaintiff and the defendants. No new precedent was set, and the ruling reaffirmed established principles regarding necessary and proper parties and the plaintiff’s control over the litigation.

Show all summary ...

1. An order rejecting the application to implead an additional defendant is challenged by its first defendant in-revision.

2. First defendant is a partnership from and other defendants are its partners. Suit was filed by the Andhra Bank for realisation of amounts advanced under various beads of loans. Contention was that the advance was guaranteed by the Export Credit Guarantee Corporation (E.C.G.C) and therefore the Corporation is a necessary patty. A separate application filed for that purpose was opposed both by the plaintiff as well as E.C.G.C Admittedly the transaction between the plaintiff and the defendants is independent of the agreement (Ext B1) between plaintiff and E.C.G.C to which detendants are not parties. There seems to be some independent transaction between defendants and E.C.G.C in which plaintiff is not interested and is not a party. The contention of the defendants that E.C.G.C guaranteed the advances to them by the plaintiff does not appear prima facte to be correct. Such a claim was denied both by the plaintiff and E.C.G.C and the contention is that the transaction between E.C.G.C and defendants is entirely different and unconnected with the plaint transaction. The E.C.G.C has issued a Whole Packing credit guarantee to the plaintiff Bank under winch when the whole or any portion of the amount due from, the defendants is ultimately found irrecoverable after exhausting all remedies independently, there will be a specific liability for the E.C.G.C That is rather in the form of an insurance unconnected with the transaction between plaintiff and defendants and the relief claimed against the defendants in the ‘suit…

3. Plaintiff has not made any claim-in the suit against E.C.G.C and plaintiff does tot want to implead the Corporation or ask for any relief. The ultimate claim, if any, of the plaintiff against E.C.G.C is independent of the plaint transaction by which defendants are exclusively liable. Liability of the defendants towards the plaintiff is also independent of the claim of the plaintiff against E.C.G.C and also independent of the claim of the defendants, if any, towards E.C.G.C The only relevant factor is that in case the plaintiff becomes unable to enforce, the liability against defendants after exhausting all remedies, plaintiff may get a cause of action against E.C.G.C Under such circumstances the question is whether the E.C.G.C is a necessary or proper party.

4. There is one other aspect. The suit was filed in 1984. Written statement was also filed in 1984. After settlement of issues the suit was included is the special list and it is being tried. It was at that stage that the impleading application was filed. There is great force in the contention that the application is intended to protract the trial of the suit.

5. Order I, C.P.C deals with parties to suits. Rules 1 and 3 specify as to who may be joined is plaintiffs or defendants. Even in cases covered by Rules 1 and 3 courts are entitled to order separate trials as enjoined by Rules 2 and 3A. All who could be joined as plaintiffs need not necessarily be plai-ntiffs and the sense is the case with defendants also. All persons interested in the subject-renter need not necessarily be plaintiffs or defendants.

6. Plaintiff is the do minus lites. He is the person who approaches the court for relief on payment of court fee. He is the master of the litigation and the best judge of his own interest. It should be left to him to choose his opponent from whom he has to seek the relief. It is none of the lookout of the court or the defendant to see whether he should be asked to claim relief against other persona when he is not bound to do so. Normally he cannot be compelled to fight with persons against whom he does not want to fight. The contrary could be had only in exceptional cases and we are at the question what those exceptional cases ere.

7. It is open to the court to implead a new party as defendant even against the consent of the plaintiff and inspite of his opposition in a fit and proper case. In Such cases the test is not whether it is according to the wishes of the plaintiff or any investigation into a question not arising out of the cause of action alleged by the plaintiff becomes necessary. The test is whether the relief claimed by the plaintiff will directly affect the person to be impleaded in the enjoyment of his tights. Persons whose interests are likely to be affected by the decision in the suit are entitled to come in to protect their interests especially when it is likely to be jeopardised by the persons already on record. Any how the persons sought to be added should have a direct interest as distinguished from a commercial interest in the subject-matter of the litigation.

8. Additions inspite of the wishes of the plaintiff could be only of two classes of persons. They are necessary parties namely persons who ought to have been impleaded and proper parties without whose presence the questions in the suit cannot be completely and effectively adjudicated upon. Where a person is neither a necessary party nor a proper party the court has no jurisdiction to add him. Merely because one is likely to be incidentally affected by the decision he need not and cannot be added when the plaintiff does not want to fight with him.

9. When a person is sought to be impleaded against the will of the plaintiff who is to control the litigation, what the court has mainly to look into is whether there is anything in the suit which cannot be determined on account of his absence in the party array or whether there will be prejudice by bis not being added. The words in Order 1 Rule 10(2) are “whose presence before the court may be necessary in order to enable the court effectively and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions Involved in the suit.” ‘Questions involved in the suit’ are only questions as between the plaintiff and the defendants and not questions that may arise between plaintiffs and third parties or defendants and third parties unconnected with the plaint cause of action and relief. Impleading should be had where if is really necessary for a complete adjudication of the questions involved in the suit and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. On the mere ground that She addition of parties may save the third party or the defendant from expenses of a separate litigation, the subject of which is not directly or substantially the subject matter of the pending litigation, impleading cannot be had. A pro forma party cannot be so impleaded.

10. Many persons may have direct or indirect or remote interest in the subject-matter of the litigation. That is not the question. Their direct interest in the cause of action and the relief as between the plain tiff and the defendant and the possibility of their right or interest being affected by the decision is the consideration. Those who are not so affected by the decision but having interest in the subject-matter on different causes of action could very well seek their remedies elsewhere if they so want. All persons interested in the subject-matter need hot be necessary or proper parties. The plaintiff, who approaches the court for a specific relief against, a particular defendant on a subject-matter under a specific cause of action in which others are not directly interested or their interests are not likely to be affected by the decision, cannot be compelled to enlarge the scape of the litigation and complicate the same by adding new parties againat whom he does not want any relief or with whom he does hot want a fight. He could so be compelled only in the cases covered by Order 1 Rule 10. These positions are well established and if at all authority is required it could be had from the decisions in Sampo Frozen Foods v. Karnataka Bank Ltd.. (1983 RLT 447), P.V George v. Bank of Madura Ltd. (1986 KLT 406), B. Somaiah v. Amina Begum (AIR 1976 A.P 182), P.R Nallathambi v. V. Raghavan (AIR 1973 Madras 25) and Herdeva v. Ismail (AIR 1970 Rajasthan 167). The subject-matter of this suit is only enforcement of a loan liability by the plaintiff against the defendants on the basis of a transaction to which” they alone are parties. E.C.G.C is not a parity to that transaction and it has nothing to do with enforcement of the liability by the plaintiff against the defendants. Agreement between the plaintiff and E.C.G.C is independent of that cause, of action and defendants are not parties to it. The fact that ultimately plaintiff may have a causa of action against E.C.G.C if the amount or any portion of it is not realisable from the defendants is independent of and unconnected with the causa of action as between plaintiff and defendants. The transaction, if any, between defendants and E.C.G.C is also independent of the transaction between plaintiff and defendants and plaintiffs and E.C.G.C Plaintiff does not want any relief against E.C.G.C is this suit and E.C.G.C also does not want to corns in as a defendant. If at all anybody other than the parties will be affected by this suit it is only E.C.G.C who is not interested in a fight. In such a situation the stand of the defendants to bring in E.C.G.C is illegal and unreasoaale. Liability of the defendants towards the plaintiff is also not in any way connected with their liability towards and slaim against E.C.G.C It naturally follows that E.C.G.C is not at all interested in the cause of action or relief in the suit and hence it is not a necessary or proper party. Plaintiff cannot be compelled by the defendants to litigate against such a party.

11. The revision petition is without any merits and it is hereby dismissed with costs.

M.MDismissed.