- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Life Insurance Corporation Of India, Trivandrum v. L. Kamalamma .
Analytical Summary of the Judgment (Kochu Thommen, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This case concerns a suit for recovery of money allegedly due under an insurance contract. The appellant is the Life Insurance Corporation of India (styled in the opinion as the “L.L.C”), which was the first defendant in the suit.
Relevant facts, as set out in the opinion, are:
- On 30-12-1976 Gopalakrishnan Unnithan submitted a proposal for life insurance on the standard form (Ext. B3) and accompanied it by a cheque dated 30-12-1976 for Rs. 725.80 (first premium).
- On 30-12-1976 the Development Officer (described as authorised representative) issued Ext. A1 at Kayamkulam, acknowledging receipt of Rs. 725.80 and stating an official receipt would be issued by the Kayamkulam Branch.
- On 31-12-1976 Unnithan was informed that the premium paid was deficient by Rs. 15.60 due to an arithmetical (clerical) error by the L.I.C office; that deficiency was paid on 31-12-1976. Exts. B8 and B9 are counterfoils alleged by the defendants to be carbon copies of receipts for Rs. 725.80 and Rs. 15.60 respectively.
- Ext. B5 (dated 31-12-1976) is a carbon copy of internal correspondence between Trivandrum and Kayamkulam offices indicating a further deficiency of Rs. 3.10; there was no evidence as to when it was dispatched or if it was communicated to the deceased or his representative.
- At about 1 A.M. on 1-1-1977 the insured, Unnithan, died unexpectedly.
- By letter dated 18-1-1977 the plaintiff (the wife, as legal representative and nominee) claimed the contract amount from the L.I.C. The L.I.C replied by Ext. A2 (dated "January 1, (sic) 1977") repudiating the claim on the ground that no contract of insurance had come into existence because the proposal had not been accepted by a competent authority.
- The trial court decreed the plaintiff's suit, finding that a contract of insurance had come into existence and the L.I.C was liable. The L.I.C appealed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, on the facts, a binding contract of insurance came into existence between the deceased and the Life Insurance Corporation prior to the death of the insured.
- Whether the receipts and other documents (Ext. A1, Exts. B8/B9, Ext. B5) and the alleged limitation on branch officers' authority (Ext. B12 — standing order of 1960) prevented formation of a binding contract.
- Whether the alleged holding of the payments "in suspense" (as represented by counterfoils Exts. B8 and B9) meant that the proposal remained in suspended animation and was not accepted before the insured's death.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (L.I.C) Arguments
- The cheque and the subsequent payment were held in suspense as shown by Exts. B8 and B9, indicating the proposal was in "suspended animation" pending final decision; the insured died before any competent acceptance, so no contract came into existence.
- Ext. B5 shows that the first premium had not been paid in full (a further deficiency of Rs. 3.10), supporting the contention that payment was incomplete.
- Ext. B12 (standing order of 1960) sets out competence rules showing that for policies of Rs. 50,000 the competent authority was the Assistant Divisional Manager at Trivandrum; therefore the Branch Manager or Development Officer at Kayamkulam lacked competence to enter into such contracts.
- The appellant relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in L.I.C of India v. R. Vasireddy, AIR 1984 SC 1014, in support of the position that no contract had come into existence in such circumstances.
Respondent-Plaintiff's Arguments
- The Supreme Court decision in Vasireddy was distinguishable and inapplicable because here the facts showed unqualified acceptance of the proposal by the Branch Manager and Development Officer at Kayamkulam.
- The Branch officers "held themselves out" as authorised, demanded and accepted Rs. 725.80 on 30-12-1976 and issued Ext. A1; the subsequent demand for Rs. 15.60 arose from an arithmetical error by the L.I.C office and was paid and accepted on 31-12-1976.
- Ext. B5 (alleged further deficiency of Rs. 3.10) was not communicated to the insured or the plaintiff; in any event any minor arithmetical deficiency due to the insurer's error could have been adjusted against amounts due rather than used to repudiate the contract.
- To repudiate the contract entirely ignores facts indicating a binding contract; absence of an issued policy does not preclude existence of a contract of insurance.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Halsbury's Laws of England, Vol. 22, 3rd Edn., p. 206 (quoted passage) | States that in non-marine insurance a contract can arise without a policy; receipt of the premium without demur or qualification, or conduct precluding insurers from disputing receipt, may constitute acceptance; acceptance may be conditional and performance of the condition initiates contract. | The court applied this principle to hold that Ext. A1 (an acknowledgement/receipt) evidenced an unconditional acceptance of the tender for the first premium and thus supported the conclusion that a contract had come into existence. |
| L.I.C. of India v. R. Vasireddy, AIR 1984 SC 1014 | Referred to as a Supreme Court decision where facts indicated the total absence of a contract. | The court distinguished this authority on the facts, holding that Vasireddy did not assist the appellant because the facts in the present case demonstrated the existence of a contract, unlike in Vasireddy. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's reasoning proceeded through a factual and legal analysis focused on whether the conduct and documents before the insured's death established a binding contract:
- The court accepted the legal extract from Halsbury's Laws of England that receipt of premium without demur or qualification can amount to acceptance in non-marine insurance and that an acceptance may be conditional, performance of the condition initiating the contract.
- The court examined Ext. A1 (receipt dated 30-12-1976) and concluded it was an acknowledgement issued by the authorised representative (the Development Officer). Ext. A1 contained no qualification as to rejecting acceptance of the tender; it simply acknowledged receipt and indicated an official receipt would follow.
- On the evidence of DW2 (Assistant Divisional Manager) the third defendant was competent to issue Ext. A1 and had signed as authorised representative. On that footing the court treated Ext. A1 as evidencing unconditional acceptance of the amount tendered in payment of the premium demanded in Ext. B3 (the proposal).
- The subsequent payment of Rs. 15.60 on 31-12-1976 — demanded because of an arithmetical error by the L.I.C office — was tendered and accepted; these facts reinforced that a contract was concluded on 30-12-1976 and, at latest, on 31-12-1976.
- The court addressed the defendant's documents purporting to show the payments were "held in suspense" (Exts. B8 and B9). It found no reliable evidence these documents were communicated to the deceased or plaintiff, and even if they were, their wording merely stated the payments were held in suspense to be adjusted "if found in order" — which the court interpreted as the amounts being accepted subject to verification, not as negating contract formation. The defendants had not pleaded repudiation of the contract on account of any deficiency; instead they argued no contract ever existed.
- Ext. B5 was characterised as internal correspondence between offices and was not binding on outsiders; it only indicated a further deficiency of Rs. 3.10, caused by the defendants' negligence. The court held the defendants could not take advantage of their own clerical error.
- Ext. B12 (standing order of 1960) setting out internal competence was not shown to have been published to or communicated to the deceased; therefore it could not alter the legal effect of the Branch's or Development Officer's conduct in relation to a third party.
- The court noted admissions in evidence: DW3 (Branch Manager) admitted the proposal was registered and amount accepted in the belief it was correct, admitting the deficiency was a clerical error; the cheque was cashed immediately. DW2 admitted defendants 2 to 4 acted within limits of their authority and no action had been taken against them for exceeding authority.
- On the cumulative effect of these findings, the court concluded the evidence conclusively proved a binding contract existed during the life of the deceased and that the contract was binding on the first defendant-appellant.
- The court explicitly distinguished Vasireddy: that authority showed absence of contract on its facts, but the facts here were contrary and accordingly Vasireddy did not assist the appellant.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal was dismissed. The court upheld the trial court's decree that a binding contract of insurance had come into existence and that the Life Insurance Corporation was liable to settle the plaintiff's claim.
Implications and direct effects:
- The direct practical effect is that the decree in favour of the plaintiff (the wife and nominee) stands and the L.I.C is bound to satisfy the contractual obligation to the plaintiff as assessed below (the opinion upholds the trial court's conclusion that a contract existed during the insured's life).
- The court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond applying established principles on formation of non-marine insurance contracts (as illustrated by the Halsbury quotation); it distinguished the cited Supreme Court decision (Vasireddy) on the facts rather than extending or overruling precedent.
Appeal dismissed.
Kochu Thommen, J.:— The appellant, the Life Insurance Corporation of India (the “L.L.C”) is the first defendant in a suit for recovery of money allegedly due under a contract of insurance. Gopalakrishnan Unnithan made as per Ext. B3 dated 30-12-1976 a proposal for insurance, on his life. The proposal is made in the standard form issued for the purpose by the L.L.C containing the necessary details of the contract. The proposal was accompanied by cheque dated 30-12-1976 for a sum of Rs. 725.80 representing the first premium payable under the contract Ext. A1 dated 30-12-1976 is the receipt issued by the Development Officer of the L.I.C who is described as the authorised representative. Ext. A1 reads:
“While acknowledging your remittance of Rs. 725.80 (Rupees Seven hundred and twenty-five and paise eighty only) by cheque, I wish to inform you that the official receipt will be issued by Life Insurance Corporation of India, Kayamkulam Branch.
Immediate reference to the above Branch should be made if Corporation's official receipt is not received by you within two weeks.
Cheque No. O/16 No. 350084
Date: 30-12-76………..”
Ext. A1 was issued at Kayamkulam. On the next day, that is on 31-12-1976, Unnithan was informed that the amount paid by him was deficient to the extent of Rs. 15.60 and was called upon to make good the deficiency. Admittedly the deficiency arose on account of an arithmetical error made by the office of the L.I.C This amount was paid on 31-12-1976, Exts. B8 and B9 are two counterfoils produced, by the defendants alleged to be the carbon copies of receipts issued for Rs. 725.80 and Rs. 15.60 We shall have occasion to refer to these documents presently. However the fact is that payment of these two sums on 30th and 31st December, 1976 is admitted by the defendants.
2. At about 1 A.M on 1-1-1977 Unnithan died unexpectedly. Ext. B5 dated 31-12-1976 is a carbon copy of an internal correspondence between the Trivandrum and Kayamkulam offices of the L.I.C It shows that on 31-12-1976 the Trivandrum Divisional Office informed the Kayamkulam Branch Office of the L.I.C that the premium paid was still deficient by Rs. 3.10 Although Ext. B5 is dated 31-12-1976 there is no evidence as to when it was despatched by the Trivandrum Office and whether the Kayamkulam Office had sent any communication to the deceased or his legal representative regarding the balance amount. By letter dated 18-1-1977 the plaintiff, who is the wife of the deceased, made a claim upon the L.I.C for payment of the contract amount due to her from the L.I.C in her capacity as the legal representative and nominee of the deceased. To this the L.I.C replied by Ext. A2 dated January 1, (sic) 1977 repudiating the claim on the ground that no contract of insurance had come into existence. The ground stated for denying the existence of the contract is that the proposal had not been accepted by competent authority. Consequently the plaintiff instituted the present suit which was decreed by the Court below stating that the evidence on record clearly proved that the contract of insurance had come into existence and that the L.I.C was liable to settle the plaintiff's claim.
3. Counsel for the appellant Shri E. Subramani submits that the cheque paid by the deceased on 30-12-1976 for a sum of Rs. 725.80 together with the balance amount of Rs. 15.60 had been held in suspense as evidenced by Exts. B8 and B9. This shows that the proposal was in suspended animation pending consideration and final decision. Before any such decision could be made the deceased had died. In the circumstances no contract had come into existence. Counsel further refers to Ext. B5 dated 31-12-1976 which shows that the first premium had not been paid in full. Counsel felies upon Ext. B12 which is the standing order in 1960 containing provisions relating to the competence of various authorities. Ext. B12 shows that in respect of contract of insurance for Rs. 50,000/- the competent authority was the Assistant Divisional Manager, whose office is at Trivandrum and therefore the Branch Manager or the Development Officer at Kayamkulam had no competence to enter into any contract of insurance for a like sum. Counsel also refers to the decision of the Supreme Court in L.I.C of India v. R. Vasireddy, AIR 1984 SC 1014.
4. Counsel for the respondent-plaintiff Shri. K.C John submits that the decision of the Supreme Court has no application to this case, for, unlike in that case, the facts of this case clearly establish the unqualified acceptance of the proposal made by the plaintiff's deceased husband. The documentary as well as the oral evidence would indicate that the Branch Manager and the Development Officer at Kayamkulam held themselves out as the officers authorised to act on behalf of the L.I.C They demanded and accepted a sum of Rs. 725.80 on 30-12-1976 in terms of Ext. B3 stating that was the correct amount of the first premium, and issued Ext. A1 receipt therefor. Subsequently on the following day, the third defendant informed the plaintiffs husband that an arithmetical error had been committed by the L.I.C office resulting in a deficiency of Rs. 15.60 in the amount demanded for the first premium payable under Ext. B3. This sum was also paid in cash and accepted by the L.I.C Counsel says that Ext. B5 dated 31-12-1976 which is alleged to be the carbon copy of an internal correspondence between the Trivandrum and the Kayamkulam offices of the L.I.C showing that there was a further deficiency of Rs. 3.10 was not communicated to the plaintiffs husband or to her. In any case assuming that there, was still an arithmetical error, that error was committed by the L.I.C's office and the plaintiffs husband was in no way responsible for it. If such an error had in fact occurred and the sum of Rs. 3.10 remained payable, such sum could be adjusted against the amount due to her under the contract. But to repudiate the contract altogether or to say that the contract had never come into effect is to ignore, facts clearly indicating the existence of a binding contract between the parties in terms of which the amount claimed by the plaintiff is payable by the L.I.C
5. No policy has admittedly been issued in the present case. The question, however, is not whether a policy of insurance has been issued — a contract of insurance can come into existence even without a policy — but whether a binding contract has come into existence.
“… Indeed there is no legal necessity, in non-marine insurance, to have a policy at all, writing is necessary in marine insurance, but, in other forms of insurance writing is hot, it seems, necessary, even if the period of the insurance extends beyond a year. Any positive act therefore indicative of an intention to create a contract may be sufficient acceptance; for example receipt of the premium without demur or qualification, or conduct precluding the insurers from disputing receipt of the premium. Even a demand for the premium may be sufficient. An acceptance may, however, be conditional (unless the form of a prior acceptance precludes the imposition of a new condition), and in such a case performance of the condition operates as the initiation of the contract”
(emphasis supplied)
(Halsbury's Laws of England, Vol. 22, 3rd Edn., page 206).
6. Evidence of DW 2 who is the Assistant Divisional Manager shows that the third defendant was competent to issue Ext. A1 receipt. Ext. A1 itself shows that the third defendant signed it as the authorised, representative. Ext. A1 was an unconditional receipt in the sense that the only qualification that it contained was that it was an acknowledgement of receipt of the amount which would be accompanied by an official receipt issued by the Kayamkulam Branch. But there was no qualification in the acceptance of the amount tendered as the first premium. In law therefore Ext. A1 evidenced an unconditional acceptance of a tender made in payment of the premium due under the contract, the offer of which was contained in Ext. B3. Ext. B3 was accepted without qualification by Ext. A1 acknowledgment of the amount demanded and paid as the first premium. It is true that owing to the arithmetical error of the L.I.C's office — an error which was not prompted or caused or induced by the deceased — the balance amount of Rs. 15.60 was demanded, tendered and accepted in cash on 31-12-1976. These facts clearly indicate that on 30-12-1976 and at any rate on 31-12-1976 there was a concluded contract of insurance.
7. Exts. B8 and B9 do not change the position. These are-counterfoils of documents dated 30-12-1976 and 31-12-1976 stating that the two sums received from the deceased, that is Rs. 725.80 and Rs. 15.60, had been held in suspense. This is what they say:
“Suspense Memorandum:
Payment as shown alongside has been received and held in suspense. If the payment is found, in order the amount will be adjusted and Corporation's Official Receipt issued.”
There is no evidence that Exts. B8 and B9 had been communicated to the deceased or to the plaintiff. No question regarding these two documents had been put to PW 1 in her cross-examination on behalf of the defendants. Apart from the interested testimony of the defendants, there is no reliable evidence to show that these documents had been sent to the plaintiff or the deceased. Assuming that they did reach this plaintiffs husband before his death, even so, they do not make any difference for the reason that all that they stated was that the amounts were held in suspense to be adjusted if found in order. That only meant that the total amount paid by the deceased was accepted subject to the amount being correct. In the event of deficiency, the defendants' reserved their right to repudiate their obligations under the contract; The defendants have not pleaded that the contract was repudiated by reason of any deficiency in the amounts paid. Their plea is that there was no contract at all. It is one thing to say that there was a breach of contract, but a totally different thing to deny that a contract has come into existence at all. Ext. B5 is an internal correspondence and therefore has no binding effect on any outside person. All that it indicates is that there was still a further deficiency of Rs. 3.10 This deficiency had occurred solely because of the negligence on the part of the defendants, for which neither under the contract nor in equity can the deceased be held responsible. The defendants cannot take advantage of their own fault. Ext. B12 is the standing order of 1960 regulating the internal arrangement of the L.I.C as regards the competence of its officers. There is no case that Ext. B12 had been published in the gazette or that the contents had been communicated to the deceased. There is no evidence to show that the deceased was aware that the authority of the Branch Officers was limited or that the contract was subject to the final approval of any higher authority. Ext. B12 can therefore have no impact on the efficacy of the contract.
8. DW 3 who is the Branch Manager admits in cross-examination that Ext. B3 proposal was registered and the amount tendered was accepted in the belief that it was the correct amount. He also accepts the deficiency as one of clerical error committed by the L.I.C's office. Significantly the cheque paid by the deceased was cashed immediately on receipt of it. DW 2 admits that defendants 2 to 4 acted within the limit of the authority. He further says that no action had been taken against these officers by the L.I.C for acting in excess of authority.
9. We are satisfied that the evidence in this case conclusively proves the existence of a contract during the life of the deceased Unnithan. The contract, in our view, is binding on the first defendant-appellant.
10. The decision of the Supreme Court in L.I.C of India v. R. Vasireddy, AIR 1984 SC 1014 does not help the appellant, for the facts of that case clearly indicated the total absence of a contract. The facts of this case, however, speak to the contrary.
11. We are satisfied that the learned Judge who had the advantage of seeing the witnesses, watching their demeanour and studying the evidence, came to the right conclusion. The appeal is accordingly dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert