- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
R.S Boss v. K.P Krishnan Nair And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was a candidate for admission to the B.H.M.S. Degree Course at Athurasramam N.S.S. Homeo Medical College, Sachivethamapuram, Kottayam for the 1982–1983 academic year. The selection list produced as Ext. P-3 dated 18-3-1983 placed the petitioner at number 5 on the waiting list with 290 marks in the qualifying optional subjects. A candidate identified as the 5th respondent was selected in the reservation quota for "other backward communities" and stood at number 4 in that quota with 262 marks.
The petitioner (an Ezhava) and the 5th respondent (a Chakkala) both belong to communities included in the Government list of "socially and educationally backward classes" (Ext. R-4(b)). The petitioner challenged Explanation III to Government Order Ext. R-4(a), which the respondents rely upon to justify the selection, and filed this original petition seeking writ of certiorari to quash Explanation III and for consequential reliefs. Respondents 1 to 4 include members of the college selection committee (the 4th respondent being the Principal). Counter-affidavits were filed on behalf of respondents 1 to 4 asserting that selection was made in accordance with Exts. R-4(a) and R-4(b).
Ext. R-4(a) prescribes a 20% reservation of total seats (50 seats total) for Scheduled Castes/Tribes; in the absence of sufficient SC/ST candidates, remaining seats in that quota are to be filled on merit from backward minority communities if the college is run by a backward minority community, and otherwise from among other backward communities. Explanation III to Ext. R-4(a) defines "Other Backward Community" as the communities included in categories IV and V of Ext. R-4(b), effectively excluding categories I to III from that sub-quota. During 1982–1983 there were only six SC candidates, leaving four seats (from the 10 reserved) to be filled by other backward communities, and, because of Explanation III, the petitioner was not selected even though he had higher marks than the selected 5th respondent.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Explanation III to Ext. R-4(a), which confines the benefit of the "other backward communities" reservation to categories IV and V of Ext. R-4(b) and thereby excludes categories I to III (communities otherwise classified as socially and educationally backward), is sustainable in law consistent with Article 15(4) of the Constitution.
- What consequential relief, if any, should be granted to the petitioner who would have been selected but for the operation of Explanation III, given that the selected candidate has already undergone part of the course.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner asserted that he belonged to an acknowledged "socially and educationally backward" community (Ezhava, listed in Category I of Ext. R-4(b)) and had a higher qualifying mark (290) than the 5th respondent (262), yet was not selected because Explanation III limited the "other backward communities" reservation to categories IV and V.
- The petitioner contended that, since categories I to III remain included in the government's list of socially and educationally backward communities, exclusion by Explanation III was improper and caused the petitioner to lose an available reserved place.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents (by counter-affidavits of respondents 1 to 4 and of the 1st respondent on behalf of the 2nd) maintained that the selection was made in accordance with Government Orders Ext. R-4(a) and Ext. R-4(b), including Explanation III, and therefore the 5th respondent’s selection was permissible under those orders.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| A. Periakaruppan v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 1971 SC 2303 | Affirms that classification of backward classes by caste falls within Article 15(4) if the castes are shown to be socially and educationally backward; reservation under Article 15(4) is for advancement of such classes. | The court relied on this decision to state that Article 15(4) permits reservation for backward classes but does not permit discrimination among those classified as socially and educationally backward; the opinion uses this authority to support the conclusion that Explanation III's selective exclusion is impermissible. |
| Rajendran's case, (1968) 2 SCR 786 : AIR 1968 SC 1012 | Authority for the proposition that classification of backward classes on the basis of caste is within the purview of Article 15(4) if those castes are shown to be socially and educationally backward. | Referenced within the discussion (via the Periakaruppan exposition) to support the general proposition that caste-based classification for reservation is permissible when justified as socially and educationally backward, but not as a basis for discriminatory selection among such classes. |
| P. Susila v. State of Madras, AIR 1970 Mad 399 | Holds that once a community is included in a government list of backward classes for educational purposes, it cannot be arbitrarily omitted from consideration during selection without a proper governmental modification; it is unreasonable to treat a community as backward for some concessions and not for admissions. | The court relied on this Madras High Court decision to reinforce that omission or selective exclusion (as effected by Explanation III) is unreasonable and illogical; it supports the conclusion that the petitioner should have been considered on the basis that he belongs to a backward class. |
| Punjab Engineering College, Chandigarh v. Sanjay Gulati, AIR 1983 SC 580 : (1983) 3 SCC 517 | Addresses remedial approach where selections were found unlawful but selected candidates had completed two semesters; Supreme Court declined to cancel admissions and instead directed creation of additional seats for the aggrieved candidates to be admitted in the next academic year. | The court applied this decision as precedent for an appropriate remedy: because the selected candidate had already undergone part of the course, the court declined to cancel that admission and instead directed the State to sanction an additional seat for the petitioner in the next academic year and directed the college to admit the petitioner to that additional seat. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by examining the statutory and factual matrix established by the Government Orders Ext. R-4(a) and Ext. R-4(b). Ext. R-4(b) lists communities the Government has declared to be "socially and educationally backward" within Article 15(4). Explanation II to Ext. R-4(a) treats all communities in Ext. R-4(b) as backward communities; Explanation III, however, narrows the definition of "Other Backward Community" to only categories IV and V of Ext. R-4(b), thereby excluding categories I to III from the benefit of the particular reserved sub-quota.
The court noted there was no dispute that the communities in categories I to III (which include the petitioner’s Ezhava community) continue to be formally classified by the Government as socially and educationally backward; the State did not assert that those communities had been removed from the backward list or had progressed so substantially as to justify deletion. The court also noted that another college's prospectus (Government College of Homoeopathy, Trivandrum) did not impose the restriction of Explanation III and made the reservation quota available to all backward communities according to merit.
Relying on precedent, the court reasoned that Article 15(4) permits reservation for the advancement of socially and educationally backward classes, but it does not permit discrimination among those classes once they have been classified as backward. The court invoked A. Periakaruppan (and Rajendran's case as authority) to underscore that classification by caste is permissible when grounded in backwardness, but that the Government should not pick and choose among communities already classified as backward to confer or withhold benefits arbitrarily. The Madras High Court decision in P. Susila was used to demonstrate that a community included in a government list for reservation purposes cannot be omitted from consideration in selection without a proper governmental modification of that list.
Applying these principles to the facts, the court concluded that Explanation III's confinement of the "other backward communities" reservation to categories IV and V—thereby excluding categories I to III despite those categories remaining on the official list of backward communities—was discriminatory and unsustainable in law.
On the question of remedy, the court acknowledged that the 5th respondent had already undergone at least two terms of the first year B.H.M.S. course. Citing Punjab Engineering College v. Sanjay Gulati, the court considered it impractical and unproductive to cancel the admission of the 5th respondent at that stage. Consequently, rather than depriving the selected candidate of an education already in progress, the court adopted the remedial approach of directing an additional seat to be sanctioned by the State for the next academic year and directing the college to admit the petitioner to that additional seat. The Principal (4th respondent) had offered no objection to this course.
Holding and Implications
Original petition allowed.
Direct consequences and orders made by the court:
- The court held that Explanation III to Ext. R-4(a), which restricts the benefit of reservation for "other backward communities" to categories IV and V of Ext. R-4(b) and thereby excludes categories I to III, is discriminatory and unsustainable in law.
- Because the 5th respondent had already completed at least two terms of the B.H.M.S. course, the court declined to cancel that admission. Instead, the court directed the State (6th respondent) to sanction an additional seat for the first year B.H.M.S. Degree Course in the Athurasramam N.S.S. Homoeo Medical College for the next academic year, and directed the 4th respondent (the Principal) to admit the petitioner to that additional seat. The Principal raised no objection to this relief.
- There will be no order as to costs.
Implication: The direct effect on the parties is that the impugned Explanation III is set aside as unlawful, the petitioner is to be provided an alternative remedy (admission to an additional sanctioned seat in the next academic year), and the 5th respondent's existing admission is not disturbed.
End of summary — all statements are based solely on the provided opinion.
1. This original petition as amended is for the issue of a writ of certiorari to quash Explanation III to the Government Order produced as Ext. R-4(a) along with the counter-affidavit filed by the 4th respondent and for consequential reliefs. The petitioner was a candidate for the B.H.M.S Course in the Athurasramam N.S.S Homeo Medical College, Sachivethamapuram. Kottayam for the academic year 1982-1983. Ext. P-3 dated 18-3-1983 is a true copy of the list of candidates selected for admission for the B.H.M.S Degree Course in the said college. Ext. P-3 shows that the petitioner is number 5 in the waiting list and had obtained in the qualifying examination in the optional subjects a total of 290 marks. The 5th respondent, who is one among the selected candidates in the quota available for “other backward communities” in the absence of sufficient number of scheduled castes/tribes candidate, is No. 4 in the reservation quota. He had obtained only 262 marks in the optional subjects. The petitioner belongs to the Ezhava community included in the socially and educationally backward classes of citizens within the meaning of Art. 15(4) of the Constitution. The 5th respondent also belongs to a community classified as falling in the socially and educationally backward classes. The petitioner's grievance is that even though both himself and the 5th respondent are members of communities classified as socially and educationally backward, he has not been selected even though he had much higher marks in the qualifying examination than the 5th respondent. Respondents 1 to 4 are members of the selection committee of whom the 4th respondent is the Principal of the College concerned. A counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of respondents 3 and 4. There is also a counter-affidavit filed by the 1st respondent on behalf also of the 2nd respondent. The stand taken in the counter-affidavits is that selection was made in accordance with the Government Orders Exts. R-4(a) and R-4(b) produced along with the counter-affidavit of respondents 3 and 4. Ext. R-4(a) prescribes the mode of selection and the percentage of seats to be reserved for Scheduled Castes/Tribes and backward communities in the three private Homeo Colleges in the State, mentioned therein 20% of the total number of seats in each college shall be reserved for candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes/Tribes and in the absence of sufficient number of candidates from those communities, the remaining seats available in the quota reserved for them shall be filled on the basis of merit from among backward minority communities, in case the college is run by a backward minority community and from among other backward communities in all other cases. The Government Order contains three explanations. As per Explanation I backward minority community means the communities mentioned in categories II, III and IV of the Annexure to G.O (P) 208/66.Edn. dated 2-5-1966. The Annexure to the aforesaid G.O (P) is produced along with the counter-affidavit of respondents 3 and 4 as Ext. R-4(b). According to Explanation II to Ext. R-4(a) backward community means all communities included in Ext. R-4(b) and per Explanation III Other Backward Community means the communities included in categories IV and V of Ext. R-4(b).
2. The total number of seats available for admission to the course in the Athurasramam N.S.S Homeo Medical College is only 50, out of which as per Ext. R-4(a) 10 seats are reserved for Scheduled Castes/Tribes candidates. During the relevant year 1982-1983 there were only six Scheduled Castes candidates and the remaining four seats were available to the Other Backward Communities in the order of merit. There is no dispute that the Athurasramam N.S.S Homeo Medical College is not one run by a backward minority community. But for Explanation III in Ext. R-4(a), the petitioner would have been selected for admission to the course instead of the 5th respondent. It is not disputed that numbers 1 to 4 shown above the petitioner in the waiting list do not belong to any backward community, and if there is no restriction as contained in Explanation III to Ext. R-4(a), the petitioner would have been entitled to selection to the last place available in the reserved quota on account of the non-availability of sufficient number of Scheduled Castes/Tribes candidates.
3. Ext. R-4(b) shows the list of communities declared by the Government as falling under the “socially and educationally backward classes of citizens” within the meaning of Art. 15(4) of the Constitution. Category 1 in Ext. R-4(b) is Ezhava including Ezhavas, Thiyyas, Ishuvan, Izhuvan, Illuvan and Billava. The petitioner comes under category 1 mentioned in Ext. R-4(b). As per Explanation II to Ext. R-4(b) all the communities mentioned in Ext. R-4(b) belong to the socially and educationally backward classes. Explanation III restricts Other Backward Communities to Categories I to III of Ext. R-4(b) Categories I to III of Ext. of Ext. R-4(b) are totally excluded from the benefit of reservation on account of Explanation III. The 5th respondent being a Chakkala belongs to Category V of Ext. R-4(b). He is selected to the reserved quota for backward communities for the reason of Explanation III restricting the reservation for other backward communities, to Categories IV and V of Ext. R-4(b).
4. The question therefore is whether the reservation confined to categories IV and V among other backward communities as is referred to in Explanation III in Ex. R-4(a) is sustainable in law. There is no dispute that all the communities referred to in Ext. R-4(b) continue to be classified as belonging to the socially and educationally backward classes within the meaning of Art. 15(4) of the Constitution. The State has no case that Ezhavas or the other communities mentioned in categories I to III of Ext. R-4(b) have made such progress in the social and educational field and hence had been deleted from the list of communities classified as falling under the socially and educationally backward classes. All those communities continue to be included in the list of communities classified as socially and educationally backward. It is also brought to my notice that in the prospectus issued by the Government College of Homoeopathy, Trivandrum for the year 1982-1983 there is no restriction of reservation to other backward communities referred to in Explanation III of Ext. R-4(a). The reservation quota is available according to merit to all the communities classified as socially and educationally backward.
5. In the decision of the Supreme Court in A. Periakaruppan v. State of Tamil Nadu reported in AIR 1971 SC 2303 it is stated thus at page 3310:—
“31. Rajendran's case, (1968) 2 SCR 786 : (AIR 1968 SC 1012) (supra) is an authority for the proposition that the classification of backward classes on the basis of castes is within the purview of Art. 15(4) if those castes are shown to be socially and educationally backward. No further material has been placed before us to show that the reservation for backward classes with which we are herein concerned is not in accordance with Article 15(4). There is no gainsaying the fact that there are numerous castes in this country which are socially and educationally backward. To ignore their existence is to ignore the facts of life. Hence we are unable to uphold the contention that the impugned reservation is not, in accordance with Art. 15(4). But all the same the Government should not proceed on the basis that once a class is considered as a backward class it should continue to be backward class for all times. Such an approach would defeat the very purpose of the reservation because once a class reaches a stage of progress which some modern writers call as take off stage then competition is necessary for their future progress. The Government should always keep under review the question of reservation of seats and only the classes which are really socially and educationally backward should be allowed to have the benefit of reservation.”
The reservation permissible under Article 15(4) is for the advancement of socially and educationally backward classes of citizens or for the Scheduled Castes and Tribes. This article does not permit a discrimination among those classified as socially and educationally backward. The Government is not competent to pick and choose some among those classified as socially and educationally backward for the conferment of benefits of reservation in educational institutions or in Government service. Almost a similar question arose before the Madras High Court in P. Susila v. State of Madras (AIR 1970 Mad 399). In the prospectus in respect of the first year Integrated M.B.B.S course for the year 1969-1970, the C.S.I Christian Community of Kanyakumari District and Shenkottah Taluk, of Tirunelveli District included, as per Government Order, in the category of socially and educationally backward classes, was omitted from among the communities belonging to the socially and educationally backward classes. The Madras High Court held as follows (at p. 400):—
“3……..It is no doubt open to the Government, from time to time, to add to or substract from the list of backward classes. But once a classification has been made for educational purposes, by an order of Government and the order continues to be in force, we do not see how without expressly modifying that order by a proper decision of the Government, a mere omission of a particular community from the list of backward classes, appended to the prospectus, can justify elimination of the community from consideration as backward at the selection. To do so, will be unreasonable an illogical. It cannot be that, for the purpose of concession in educational institutions, a community is considered as backward and not so for the purposes of admission in educational institutions. There appears to be no substance in the dividing line. We consider, therefore, that the petitioners ought to have received consideration, at the selection, on the basis that they belong to a backward classes.”
Explanation III to Ext. R4(a) restricting the benefit of reservation to some alone among the communities declared as socially and educationally backward is therefore clearly discriminatory and unsustainable in law.
6. It is not disputed in the present case that but for the restricted application of the principle of reservation to some alone among the backward communities, the petitioner would have been selected instead of the 5th respondent. The selection was made in March, 1983 for the academic year 1982-1983. The 5th respondent has already undergone the course of study for at least two terms of the first year B.H.M.S course. It will also serve no useful purpose if a direction is made to admit the petitioner at this late stage of the academic year. In the decision of the Supreme Court in Punjab Engineering College, Chandigarh v. Sanjay Gulati (AIR 1983 SC 580 : (1983) 3 SCC 517) it was found that the selection of 16 candidates for admission to the Punjab Engineering College was not in accordance with law. Nevertheless for the reason of their having completed two semesters, the Supreme Court declined to cancel their admission, and instead directed the admission of 16 O'hers who would have otherwise got admission on the basis of merit in the next academic year in 16 additional seats directed to be sanctioned by the Government. Since the petitioner wants to join the course and qualify himself as a homoeopathic doctor, there will be a direction to the 6th respondent State of Kerala to sanction an additional seat for the I year B.H.M.S Degree Course in the Athurasramam N.S.S Homoeo Medical College for the next academic year and the 4th respondent is directed to admit the petitioner to the additional seat so sanctioned. The 4th respondent, the Principal of the College concerned, has no objection to this course.
The original petition is allowed as indicated above. There will be no order as to costs.
Petition allowed.
Alert