Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Thilakan v. Sukumaran

Kerala High Court
Nov 21, 1980
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision petition was filed by the accused in S.T No. 1/79 before the Sub Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Kunnamkulam, seeking revision of an order dated 25-6-79 that issued summons to the petitioners or alternatively to quash the complaint. The first respondent had filed a private complaint alleging an offence punishable under Section 500, Indian Penal Code. The Magistrate took cognizance and proceeded to conduct an enquiry under Section 202, Criminal Procedure Code, posting the matter for examination of witnesses on several dates. On 20-3-79 two witnesses were examined (recorded as Cws. 1 and 2) and the Magistrate's order of that date noted that "The examination of these witnesses does not help the complainant to prove his case against all the accused" and posted the matter for further examination. Subsequently, after further adjournments and examination of additional witnesses, the Magistrate, on 25-6-79, issued summons to the accused and directed the complainant to deposit process fees. The accused challenged those actions by filing the present revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate's order dated 20-3-79 amounted to a dismissal of the complaint under Section 203 Cr. P.C.
  2. Whether a Magistrate conducting an enquiry under Section 202 Cr. P.C. is empowered to issue summons to witnesses and examine them (i.e., whether issuing summons to witnesses in a Section 202 enquiry is within the Magistrate's jurisdiction).
  3. Whether continuation of proceedings after the 20-3-79 order (including issuance of process against accused) amounted to an illegal review of that order.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners asserted that the date in the petition erroneously showed 25-7-79 but the real impugned order was 25-6-79.
  • They contended the Magistrate exceeded his jurisdiction by issuing summons to witnesses during a Section 202 enquiry.
  • They argued that the Magistrate's order of 20-3-79 was in effect an order of dismissal under Section 203 Cr. P.C., and that the Magistrate had no power of review under the Code to continue proceedings after having found that no case was made out.
  • They submitted that continuation of proceedings after 20-3-79 amounted to an illegal review of that order.

First Respondent's Arguments

  • The first respondent maintained that the impugned orders were legal and within the Magistrate's jurisdiction.
  • He argued Section 202 Cr. P.C. confers ample power on the Magistrate to conduct an enquiry to test the truth or falsity of allegations in the complaint.
  • He denied that the Magistrate had reviewed any earlier orders and contested the submission that the 20-3-79 order amounted to an order under Section 203 Cr. P.C.
  • The respondent also contended that revision petitioners cannot seek quashing of the complaint in the present proceeding (and that quashing should be pursued separately).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Bihar v. Ranesh Singh, 1978-1 S.C.R. 257 : 1977 SCC (Cri) 533 That at the initial stage a strong suspicion which leads the court to think there is ground for presuming the accused has committed an offence suffices to proceed; the court should not require proof beyond reasonable doubt at this stage. The court relied on this authority to explain that the Magistrate in a Section 202 enquiry must decide whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding (not whether evidence proves guilt) and therefore the 20-3-79 order could not be treated as a dismissal under Section 203 Cr. P.C.
Chandra Deo v. Prakash Chandra, AIR 1963 S.C. 1430 That one object behind Section 202 Cr. P.C. is to ascertain whether allegations in a complaint are intrinsically true and to enable the Magistrate to scrutinize allegations to prevent frivolous complaints. The court cited this case to explain the proper scope and object of Section 202 enquiries and to support the proposition that the Magistrate may take evidence to ascertain truth of allegations.
Dr. V. Naidu v. K. Janardhana, AIR 1959 Mys. 119 Cited by the petitioners in support of the contention that a Magistrate has no power to issue summons and examine witnesses in an enquiry under Section 202(1). The court noted the citation but observed that in Dr. V. Naidu the specific question whether a Magistrate can issue summons to witnesses in a Section 202 enquiry did not arise for consideration.
P.S. Ramaswami v. R. Viswanathan, 1957 Crl. L.J. 673 Cited by the petitioners as authority concerning the nature and limits of enquiries under Section 202 Cr. P.C. The court recorded the citation and observed that this case did not decide the specific issue of power to issue summons in a Section 202 enquiry.
Dattaraya v. Wadialal, AIR 1958 Bom. 335 Cited by the petitioners in support of the contention that issuing summons in a Section 202(1) enquiry is impermissible. The court observed that in Dattaraya the specific question whether a Magistrate is empowered to issue summons to witnesses in a Section 202 enquiry did not come up for consideration.
Mainal Haque v. Ganga Prasad, AIR 1957 Assam 76 Cited by the first respondent for the proposition that a Magistrate may conduct a thorough enquiry under Section 202 and that an enquiry is not limited to any particular form. The court referred to this case to support the view that the Magistrate has discretion as to the form a Section 202 enquiry may take and that there is nothing in the section expressly preventing issuance of summons and examination of witnesses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a step-by-step analysis limited to the material in the opinion:

  1. Examination of the 20-3-79 order: The court described that order as "unsatisfactory" because it stated that the two witnesses examined "does not help the complainant to prove his case against all the accused" but concluded that this does not amount to an order under Section 203 Cr. P.C. dismissing the complaint. The court emphasised that the issue at the Section 202 stage is whether there is "sufficient ground for proceeding" and not whether the evidence is sufficient to secure a conviction.
  2. Legal standard at Section 202 stage: Relying on State of Bihar v. Ranesh Singh, the court clarified the correct test — the Magistrate must consider whether there is sufficient ground to proceed, which can be satisfied by strong suspicion; the Magistrate is not to weigh evidence as a trial court would.
  3. Material permissible for the Magistrate's consideration: The Magistrate may consider the allegations in the complaint, the complainant's sworn statement, and evidence recorded in the enquiry under Section 202 (or statements recorded during an investigation for the purposes of the enquiry).
  4. On review and continuation of proceedings: Because the 20-3-79 order did not amount to a dismissal under Section 203, continuation of proceedings and subsequent issuance of process did not amount to an illegal review. The court noted that after the 20-3-79 order the complainant filed a fresh list of witnesses, additional witnesses were examined, and thereafter processes were directed against the accused.
  5. Power to summon witnesses in a Section 202 enquiry: The court analysed sub‑section (2) of Section 202 Cr. P.C., observing that it authorises the Magistrate "if he thinks fit, [to] take evidence of witnesses on oath." The court concluded that subsection (2) does not restrict examination to witnesses who are already present or produced by the complainant; instead it permits the Magistrate, in his discretion, to summon and examine witnesses if he deems it necessary for the enquiry.
  6. On precedents cited: The court reviewed earlier decisions cited by both sides. It noted that while several earlier decisions were cited in support of the petitioners' contention, the specific question whether a Magistrate can issue summons to witnesses in a Section 202 enquiry often did not arise for decision in those cases. The court treated Mainal Haque as supportive of the proposition that the Magistrate may conduct a thorough enquiry and that an enquiry is not restricted to a particular form.
  7. Rights of the accused during Section 202 enquiry: The court observed that under the scheme of Chapter XVI an accused has no right to take part in an enquiry until process is issued; the Magistrate cannot permit the accused to participate in the enquiry as of right. An accused may be present in person or through counsel to be informed of proceedings but cannot, as of right, examine witnesses or ask questions of witnesses at his instance; although the Magistrate may put questions to witnesses to find out the truth.
  8. Disposition: Having found no illegality or lack of jurisdiction in the Magistrate issuing summons to witnesses and in subsequently issuing process against the accused, the court dismissed the revision petition while remarking the manner in which the enquiry was conducted was unsatisfactory.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect of the decision is that the Magistrate's orders (including issuance of summons to witnesses and subsequent issuance of process against the accused) are upheld and the revision petition challenging those orders is dismissed.
  • The court clarified the proper legal standard at the Section 202 enquiry stage — the Magistrate must determine whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding (a test of reasonable suspicion), not whether the evidence would suffice for conviction.
  • The court held that Section 202(2) Cr. P.C. permits the Magistrate, in his discretion, to take evidence on oath and to summon witnesses if necessary for the enquiry. Several earlier authorities were discussed, and the court observed that in many of them the precise question of issuing summons in a Section 202 enquiry had not arisen for decision.
  • No broader declaratory pronouncement or change of precedent is recorded in the opinion beyond the court's application of established principles to the facts; the opinion notes that the manner of conducting the enquiry was unsatisfactory but did not find it illegal or beyond jurisdiction.

Outcome recorded in the opinion: "Dismissed."

Show all summary ...

1. This revision petition is filed by the accused in S.T No. 1/79 on the file of the Sub Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Kunnamkulam, seeking to revise an order passed by the Magistrate on 25-6-79 issuing summons to the petitioners or in the alternative, to quash the complaint.

2. The first respondent herein filed a private complaint before the court below against the petitioners alleging that they committed an offence punishable under S. 500 I.P.C The Magistrate after taking cognizance on examining the complainant proceeded to conduct an enquiry under S. 202 Cr. P.C and the case was posted for that purpose to a particular date on which date, although the complainant was present, as the document necessary for the purpose of the case had not been received from the office of the Deputy Superintendent of Police, the case was adjourned directing that the witness will appear. On that day, the complainant was absent and on his application the case was adjourned to another date, on which date as witnesses were absent, summonses were issued to witnesses 3 and 4 and the case was adjourned for the examination of the witnesses. On 20-3-79, the complainant and the two witnesses were present and they were examined as Cws. 1 and 2 and the case was posted for further examination of witnesses, and after two adjournments two more witnesses were examined. On 25-6-79, the Magistrate stating that he was of opinion that there was sufficient ground to proceed against the accused, issued summonses to the accused, directing the complainant to deposit the process fees.

3. The learned advocate appearing for the petitioner at the time of hearing submitted that really it is the order passed on 25-6-79 that is sought to be revised in this case and that it was under a mistake that this date was shown as 25-7-79 in the petition. The counsel very strongly contended that the learned Magistrate has gone beyond his jurisdiction in conducting an enquiry of this nature by issuing summons to witnesses; that the order passed on 20-3-79 is in effect an order of dismissal under S. 203 Cr. P.C, that there is no power of review conferred on him under any of the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure; that having found that no case was made out against the accused by his order dated 20-3-79, he should have dismissed the complaint, and that the continuation of the proceedings after 20-3-79 amounts to review of that order which is illegal.

4. The learned advocate appearing for the first respondent submitted that the orders impugned are perfectly legal and within the jurisdiction of the Magistrate; that S. 202 Cr. P.C confers ample power on the Magistrate to conduct an enquiry to find out the truth or falsity of the averments in the complaint; that the learned Magistrate has not reviewed any of the orders passed by him as contended on behalf of the petitioners; that it is also not correct that on 20-3-79 he passed an order stating that no case has been made out against the accused and that the order passed on 20-3-79 cannot, in any view be considered or treated as an order coming under S. 203 Cr. P.C The counsel also submitted that in a proceeding of this nature, the revision petitioners cannot ask for quashing the complaint.

5. The order passed by the Magistrate on 20-3-79 is as follows:

“Two witnesses present examined Cws. 1 and 2. The examination of these witnesses does not help the complainant to prove his case against all the accused. Posted for further examination of witnesses. Posted to 10-4-79. Issue summons to No. 5”.

6. This, no doubt, appears to be an unsatisfactory order. But the question is whether this amounts to an order under S. 203 Cr. P.C in effect dismissing the complaint. The question of proving the case beyond reasonable doubt does not arise at this stage. What the learned Magistrate has to satisfy is whether or not there is sufficient ground for proceeding with the case. For determining whether process has to be issued or not, what the Magistrate has to be satisfied is whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding and not whether there is sufficient ground for conviction, or whether the evidence disclosed on the examination of the witnesses is sufficient to prove the case against, the accused. In order to come to this conclusion, the Magistrate is entitled to consider the allegations in the complaint, the sworn statement of the complainant, and the evidence recorded in the enquiry under S. 202 Cr. P.C, or statements recorded during an investigation under the said section, as the case may be.

7. It would appear that the Magistrate was under a misconception that in an enquiry of this nature, the evidence forthcoming should be of such a nature as is sufficient to prove the case against the accused. At this stage, the Magistrate is not to weigh the evidence meticulously as if he were the trial court. The test is that at the initial stage, if there is strong suspicion which leads the court to think that there is ground for presuming that the accused has committed an offence, then it is not open to the court to say that there was no sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused; see (State of Bihar v. Ranesh Singh 1978-1 S.C.R 257 : 1977 SCC (Cri) 533). In any view, it is not possible to hold that the order passed by the Magistrate on 20-3-79 amounts to a dismissal of the complaint under S. 203 Cr. P.C In the absence of such an order, there is no substance in the contention that the Magistrate has reviewed his previous order. After passing this order, the case underwent a few adjournments and the complainant filed a fresh list of witnesses and from the list two were examined and it was only thereafter processes were directed to be issued against the accused. Although the action of the Magistrate in this regard cannot be said to be illegal or one without jurisdiction, I am constrained to note that the manner in which the enquiry was conducted by the Magistrate was unsatisfactory.

8. The other argument advanced on behalf of the petitioners is that there is no provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure to issue summonses to the witnesses to conduct an enquiry under S. 202 Cr. P.C There is no provision in S. 202 which expressly states that the Magistrate conducting an enquiry under sub-section (1) is empowered to issue summonses to witnesses to make them available for examination According to the counsel for the petitioners, in an enquiry under S. 202(1) Cr. P.C a Magistrate is only empowered to examine only such witnesses who are present or are produced by the complainant and therefore the Magistrate has acted beyond his jurisdiction by issuing summonses to witnesses. There is nothing in sub-section (2) of S. 202 indicating that the Magistrate is empowered to examine only witnesses who are present or witnesses who are produced. What sub-section (2) states is that in an enquiry under sub-section (1), the Magistrate may, if he thinks fit, take evidence of witnesses on oath. This enquiry, as stated earlier, is to find out whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding with the case and for this purpose, as is clear from sub-section (2), witnesses can be examined on oath. That means the Magistrate has got power to take evidence of witness on oath, irrespective of the fact whether these witnesses are persons present in court or produced in court by complainant or summoned by the Magistrate. If a Magistrate in his discretion finds that it is necessary for the purpose of an enquiry under this sub-section that witnesses should be summoned he can certainly summon the witnesses and examine them. The scope of enquiry under S. 202(1) has been considered by the Supreme Court in Chandra Deo v. Prakash Chandra AIR. 1963 SC. 1430. It has been held in that case that one of the objects behind S. 202 Cr. P.C is to ascertain whether the allegations made in the complaint are intrinsically true and also to enable the Magistrate to scrutinize carefully the allegations made in the complaint with a view to prevent a person named therein as accused from being called upon to face an obviously frivolous complaint the counsel for the petitioners cited decisions in Dr. V. Naidu v. K. Janardhana (AIR. 1959 Mys. 119); P.S Ramaswami v. R. Viswanathan (1957 Crl. LJ. 673); and Dattaraya v. Wadialal (AIR. 1958 Bom. 335) in support of his contention that the Magistrate has no power to issue summons and examine witnesses in an enquiry under sub-section (1) of S. 202. The counsel for the first respondent cited a decision reported in Mainal Haque v. Ganga Prasad (AIR. 1957 Assam 76) in support of his contention that the Magistrate can conduct a thorough enquiry under this section and there is nothing in the section preventing issue of summonses and examination of witnesses in Dr. V. Naidu's case (AIR. 1959 Mys. 119) or in Dattotraya's Case (AIR. 1958 Bombay 335) the question whether a Magistrate is empowered to issue summonses to witnesses and examine them in an enquiry under S. 202 Cr. P.C never came up for consideration. So also this question did not come up for consideration and decision neither in P.S Ramaswami's case (1957 Crl. L.J 673) nor in Mainal Haque's case (AIR 1957 Assam 76), where while dealing with an enquiry under S. 202 Cr. P.C it was held that an enquiry within the meaning of S. 202 is not limited to and does not necessarily mean an enquiry by examining witnesses or by holding investigation into the case in any particular form and it was open to the Magistrate to enquire into the case in any manner that he could have adopted if the accused had been in attendance. In that case the Magistrate made a local inspection of the scene of offence. With respect I do not know how an accused would ordinarily be present or in attendance in an enquiry under S. 202 Cr. P.C The very scheme of Chapter XVI of the Code shows that an accused has no right to be present or to take part in an enquiry until process is issued. The Magistrate has also no jurisdiction to permit an accused to participate in an enquiry under S. 202 Cr. P.C This does not mean that an accused is precluded from being present, when an enquiry is held by the Magistrate. An accused can be present either in person or through his lawyer or agent with a view to be informed of what is going on against him but as of right he cannot take part in an enquiry under S. 202 Cr. P.C Although a Magistrate is empowered to put questions to the witnesses examined in the enquiry with a view to find out the truth, it is not open to him to examine any witness at the instance of the accused or to put questions to witnesses at the instance of the accused. Regarding the prayer for quashing the complaint, the counsel submitted that he would take appropriate steps in a separate proceeding for that purpose. In the result this revision petition fails and is hereby dismissed.

9. Dismissed.