Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

T.S Govindarajulu Naidu v. State Of Kerala

Kerala High Court
Aug 16, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by V.P. Gopalan Nambiyar, C.J.

Factual and Procedural Background

These tax revision cases arise from sales tax assessments made on the revision petitioner (the assessee) for the years 1972-73 and 1973-74. The assessee is a dealer in synthetic gems who purchases such gems locally and sells them in Tiruchi and at places outside the State. On those purchases and sales the assessing authorities treated the assessee as liable under section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963. The Court considered the interaction between section 5A (a levy of purchase tax in specific circumstances), section 5(1) (the general charging provision), and a governmental exemption notification issued under section 10 (G.O.(Ms.) No.95/72.TD dated 30-11-1972) exempting polished synthetic gems from sales tax.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, having regard to section 5A(1)(a) (which makes a purchaser liable where goods are purchased in circumstances in which no tax is payable under section 5, and are consumed in manufacture), the assessee dealing in synthetic gems could be held liable to tax when a notification under section 10 exempts polished synthetic gems from tax on sale.
  2. Whether the exemption granted under section 10 (which refers to the sale of polished synthetic gems) has the effect of rendering the goods not liable to tax under the Act for the purposes of section 5A (i.e., whether the goods fall outside the class "the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act").
  3. Whether an exemption that refers explicitly to sale (and not purchase) is co-extensive with the liability created by section 5A, which speaks of "sale or purchase" — in other words, whether an exemption of sale alone defeats the charge under section 5A in respect of purchase.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • The exemption notification issued under section 10 (exempting polished synthetic gems from tax on sale) means that the sale or purchase of those goods is not "liable to tax under the Act", and therefore section 5A cannot be invoked to charge purchase tax on the assessee.
  • Alternatively, even if the exemption did not wholly nullify liability, the exemption places the transactions within the phrase "in circumstances in which no tax is payable under section 5" in section 5A(1), so that section 5A still does not apply to the assessee.
  • Where synthetic gems are taxed only at the point of sale under section 5(1)(ii), an exemption referring to sale is effectively a total exemption for those goods (i.e., there is a good reason why the notification addresses sale rather than purchase).
  • The assessee relied on the decision in Malabar Fruit Products Company v. Sales Tax Officer, Palai ([1972] 30 S.T.C. 537 at 553) as authority for treating exempted goods as not "liable to tax" for purposes of a provision like section 5A.

Government Pleader's Arguments

  • The language of the statute distinguishes between non-liability to tax under the Act and an exemption granted under the Act; therefore an exemption under section 10 does not amount to the same thing as absence of liability for the purposes of section 5A.
  • The exemption notification refers only to the sale of polished synthetic gems and not to purchase, so the exemption is not co-extensive with the reach of section 5A (which speaks of "sale or purchase"). As a result, section 5A may still impose liability on purchases even though sales are exempted.
  • The Government Pleader relied on an earlier Supreme Court decision (referred to as Fernandez's case [1957] 8 S.T.C. 561 S.C.) to support the distinction between non-liability and exemption.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Malabar Fruit Products Company v. Sales Tax Officer, Palai [1972] 30 S.T.C. 537 at 553 Interpreted the phrase "goods the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax" to mean that goods exempted under section 10 are not "goods liable to tax" for the purposes of a provision like section 5A; held that the qualification refers to exemptions and therefore such goods should not be charged under the anti-evasion provision. The Court treated this decision as supportive of the assessee's contention and relied on its reasoning that an exemption can remove goods from the category of "taxable goods" so that section 5A should not apply.
State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K. Kandaswami [1975] 36 S.T.C. 191 S.C. Construing provisions similar to section 5A (section 7-A read with section 17(1) in that Act), the Supreme Court held that goods totally exempted at all points are excluded from being "taxable goods", explained the distinct concepts of 'taxable person', 'taxable goods' and 'taxable event', and held that a provision like section 7-A could not be applied to goods exempted by statute. The Court regarded this Supreme Court decision as directly in the assessee's favour, followed its analysis of the three inter-related concepts (taxable person, taxable goods, taxable event), and accepted its conclusion that exempted goods cannot be charged under the provision analogous to section 5A.
Fernandez's case [1957] 8 S.T.C. 561 S.C. Used by the Government Pleader to stress a distinction between non-liability under the Act and an exemption granted under the Act (supporting the argument that an exemption is different from absence of liability). The Court noted this earlier decision but held that subsequent authority (State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K. Kandaswami) and the statutory context led it to reject the Government Pleader's reliance on Fernandez's case as prevailing authority in the present context.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first isolating the relevant statutory provisions and the factual matrix:

  • Section 5A(1)(a) imposes purchase-tax liability where a dealer purchases goods (from a registered dealer or any other person) that are "the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act" in circumstances in which no tax is payable under section 5, and the goods are consumed in manufacture (the Court confined the case to sub-clause (a) of section 5A(1)).
  • Section 5(1)(ii) makes goods not in the First or Second Schedule (including synthetic gems) taxable at the points of sale and not at the point of purchase.
  • Under section 10, the Government issued a notification exempting polished synthetic gems from tax on sale.

Applying these provisions to the facts, the Court addressed the central interpretive question whether the exemption removes the goods from the class of "goods the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act" (and thereby prevents section 5A from attaching).

The Court examined precedent. It found Malabar Fruit Products and the Supreme Court decision in State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K. Kandaswami persuasive: both treat an exemption granted under the statute as excluding goods from being "taxable goods" for the purposes of an anti-evasion or purchase-tax provision similar to section 5A. The Court accepted the analytical distinction articulated in the latter case among three concepts—taxable person, taxable goods and taxable event—and agreed that where goods are exempted at all points under the Act they cannot constitutionally or logically be subjected to the charge created by a provision like section 5A.

The Government Pleader's counter-argument that exemption is not identical to non-liability was considered. The Court acknowledged that linguistically there can be a difference between "non-liability" and "exemption", and noted Fernandez's case had been cited in support of that distinction. However, the Court held that the combined practical effect of a charging provision together with an exemption notification is to produce absence of liability in practical terms. Given the later Supreme Court authority and the statutory scheme, the Court accepted the assessee's interpretation.

The Court further addressed the narrower contention that the exemption referred only to sale (not purchase) and thus did not cover the scope of section 5A which speaks of "sale or purchase". The Court observed that synthetic gems are taxed only at the point of sale under section 5(1)(ii); accordingly an exemption referring to sale is effectively a total exemption for the class of goods in question. Having found that the exemption removes the goods from the ambit of tax liability, the Court concluded that the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal's contrary conclusion could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petitions were allowed and the orders of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal were set aside. The Court concluded that, in the circumstances of this case, the exemption granted under section 10 in respect of polished synthetic gems precluded imposition of purchase-tax under section 5A. There was no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The assessee obtained relief from the purchase-tax assessments for the years in question; the Tribunal's orders were quashed and the petitions allowed.
  • Scope of ruling: The Court applied existing authority (including a Supreme Court decision) to reach its conclusion. The opinion does not purport to announce a novel principle beyond applying the cited precedents and statutory interpretation to the facts; the decision resolves the assessments before the Court by treating the exemption as removing the goods from the taxable class for purposes of section 5A in the circumstances described.

Petitions allowed; no order as to costs.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

V.P Gopalan Nambiyar, C.J:— These tax revision cases are concerned with the assessment to sales tax passed on the revision petitioner for the years 1972-73 and 1973-74. The assessee is a dealer in synthetic gems. The assessee purchases the gems locally and sells them in Tiruchi and other places outside the State. For purchases and sales thus made by the assessee he was made liable under section 5A of the Act. The provisions of the said section may be read:

“5 A. Levy of purchase tax.—(1) Every dealer who in the course of his business purchases from a registered dealer or from any other person any goods, the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act, in circumstances in which no tax is payable under section 5, and either—

(a) consumes such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise; or

(b) disposes of such goods in any manner other than by way of sale in the State; or

(c) despatches them to any place outside the State except as a direct result of sale or purchase in the course of inter-State trade or commerce,

shall, whatever be the quantum of the turnover relating to such purchase for a year, pay tax on the taxable turnover relating to such purchase for that year at the rates mentioned in section 5.

(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), a dealer (other than a casual trader or agent of a non-resident dealer) purchasing goods, the sale of which is liable to tax under section 5, shall not be liable to pay tax under sub-section (1) if his total turnover for a year is less than twenty-five thousand rupees:

Provided that where the total turnover of such dealer for the year in respect of the goods mentioned in clause (i) of sub-section (1) of section 5 is not less than two thousand five hundred rupees, he shall be liable to pay tax on the taxable turnover in respect of those goods.

(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing provisions of this section, a dealer referred to in sub-section (1), who purchases goods the sale of which is liable to tax under clause (ii) of sub-section (1) of section 5, and whose total turnover for a year is not less than twenty-five thousand rupees but not more than thirty thousand rupees may, at his option, instead of paying the tax in accordance with the provisions of subsection (1), pay tax at the rate mentioned in sub-section (1) of section 7 in accordance with the provisions of that section.”

2. Stated broadly and briefly, the ingredients necessary to attract liability are: (1) that the assessee must be a purchaser from a registered dealer or from any other person of goods, the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under the Act; and (2) the purchase must have been in circumstances in which no tax is payable under section 5; and (3) the goods purchased must have been consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise. The rest of the section is not material and need not be noticed. In other words, for the purpose of this case, it is only sub-clause (a) of subsection (1) of section 5A that has application and no other sub-clause. We may now turn to section 5(1) of the Act, which is the charging section. The said section, in so far as it is material, reads:

“5. Levy of tax on sale or purchase of goods.—(1) Every dealer (other than a casual trader or agent of a non-resident dealer) whose total turnover for a year is not Jess than twenty-five thousand rupees and every casual trader or agent of a non-resident dealer, whatever be his total turnover for the year, shall pay tax on his taxable turnover for that year,—

(i) in the case of goods specified in the First or Second Schedule, at the rates and only at the points specified against such goods in the said schedules; and

(ii) in the case of other goods, at the rate of four per cent at all points of sale,”

3. Synthetic gems, which are the goods with which we are concerned in this case, are goods not specified in the First or Second Schedule and, therefore, governed by sub-clause (ii) of section 5(1) and liable to be assessed to tax only at all points of sale (and not at the point of purchase) under section 5(1)(ii). Section 9 of the Act grants exemption from tax to a dealer in respect of goods specified in the Third Schedule to the Act; and section 10 confers a power on the Government to grant exemption or reduction in the rate of tax on the sale or purchase of any goods specified or class of goods at all points or specific point or points, etc. In pursuance of section 10, Notification G.O (Ms.) No. 95/72.TD dated 30th November, 1972 (S.R.O No. 658/72), has been issued, which is as follows:

“In exercise of the powers conferred by section 10 of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 (15 of 1963), the Government of Kerala, having considered it necessary in the public interest so to do, hereby make an exemption in respect of the tax payable under the said Act by any dealer on the sale of polished synthetic gems, whether they are sold loose or as part of any article in which they are set.”

4. In pursuance of these provisions, counsel for the assessee contended that the effect of section 5A read with the exemption granted under section 10 would be to make the sale or purchase one which is not liable to tax under the Act. Alternatively, it was contended that even if the operation of the exemption does not have the effect of nullifying the liability under the Act, the sale or purchase must be regarded as “in circumstances in which no tax was payable” under the latter part of section 5A(1) of the Act. Either way, it was claimed, that the provisions of section 5A would operate in favour of the assessee to relieve him from liability to tax. Counsel for the assessee relied upon the decision of a learned Judge of this Court in Malabar Fruit Products Company v. Sales Tax Officer, Palai [1972] 30 S.T.C 537 at 553, where the learned Judge dealt with the effect of an exemption from tax liability, and held after noting the ingredients under section 5A of the Act and the definition of “goods” that the goods must be understood as “taxable goods”. It was observed:

“The term ‘goods’ is exhaustive enough to include all kinds of movable property and growing crops, grass or things attached to or forming part of the land. Therefore, what is the purpose of the further qualification to the term ‘goods’, namely, the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax? The qualification can possibly refer only to the provisions for exemption such as that in section 10 of the Act. Section 10 provides that Government may, if they consider it necessary in the public interest, by notification in the Gazette make an exemption or reduction in rate, in respect of any tax payable under the Act on the sale or purchase of any goods, at all points or at a specified point or points in the series of sales or puschases by successive dealers. Several goods have been exempted at all points of sale or purchase in the State by any person, as, for example, vegetables. They are no doubt goods as the term is defined, but are not goods liable to tax under the Act because of the exemption under section 10. If this clause ‘the sale or purchase of which is liable to payment of tax’ is not read in this manner, the entire clause becomes redundant as otherwise all goods are brought within the scheme of taxation under section 5 of the Act. All movable properties included in the definition of the goods are automatically within the scheme of taxation at some point or other under section 5(1) of the Act. If that be the case, the qualification of the term ‘goods’ by the words ‘sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act’ if intended as a qualification can only refer to such provisions of section 10 of the Act. Such a construction is evidently reasonable because in regard to such goods which are exempted at all points there is no reason to think that tax should be levied under section 5A as there could not be any idea of checking of evasion in regard to sales tax on such goods.”

5. In State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K Kartdaswami, construing the provisions of section 7-A read with section 17(1) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, almost similarly, if not identically, worded, the Supreme Court also came to the conclusion that the effect of a provision for exemption coupled with the provision making the tax exigible would be to nullify liability and to lead to the conclusion that the goods in question are not liable to tax. Section 7-A of the Act there construed was practically the same as section 5A of our Act. The Court observed:

“We are unable to accept this interpretation which would render section 7-A(1) wholly nugatory. With due respect, it seems to us that in arriving at this erroneous interpretation, the learned Judge mixed up the concept of goods liable to tax with the transactions liable to tax under the Act. The scheme of the Act involves three inter-related but distinct concepts which may conveniently be described as ‘taxable person’, ‘taxable goods’ and ‘taxable event’. All the three must be satisfied before a person can be saddled with liability under the Act. Nevertheless, the distinction between them, if overlooked, may lead to serious error in the construction and application of the Act. ‘Goods’ is defined in section 2(j) as:

‘All kinds of movable property (other than newspapers, actionable claims, stocks and shares and securities) and includes all materials, commodities, and articles (including those to be used in the fitting out, improvement or repair of movable property); and all growing crops, grass or things attached to, or forming part of the land which are agreed to be severed before sale or under the contract of sale.’

‘Taxable person’ is a ‘dealer’ as defined in section 2(g). ‘Taxable event’ is the ‘sale or purchase of “goods'” effected during the accounting period although the tax liability is enforced only after quantification is effected by assessment proceedings. ‘Sale’ is defined in section 2(n) as:

‘Every transfer of the property in goods by one person to another in the course of business for cash or for deferred payment or other valuable consideration, but does not include a mortgage, hypothecation, charge or pledge.’

Section 3(2), which is the main charging provision, enjoins that in the case of goods mentioned in the First Schedule, the tax under this Act shall be payable by a dealer at the rate and only at the point specified therein on the turnover in each year relating to such goods whatever be the quantum of turnover in that year.

The focal point in the expression ‘goods, the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under the Act,’ is the character and class of goods in relation to their exigibility. In a way this expression contains a definition of ‘taxable goods’, that is, goods mentioned in the First Schedule of the Act, the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax at the rate and at the point specified in the schedule. The words ‘the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under the Act’ qualify the term ‘goods’ and exclude by necessary implication goods, the sale or purchase of which is totally exempted from tax at all points under section 8 or section 17(1) of the Act. The goods so exempted—not being ‘taxable goods’—cannot be brought to charge under section 7-A.

The words ‘under the Act’ will evidently include a charge created by section 7-A also. It is to be noted that section 7-A is not subject to section 3; it is by itself a charging provision. Section 7-A brings to tax goods the sale of which would normally have been taxed at some point in the State, subsequent to their purchase by the dealer if those goods are not available for taxation, owing to the act of the dealer in (a) consuming them in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise, or (b) despatching them in any manner other than by way of sale in the State, or (c) despatching them to a place outside the State except as a direct result of sale or purchase in the course of inter-State trade or commerce.”

6. The decision seems to be directly in favour of the assessee. But the learned Government Pleader contended that on the language of the section, there is a difference between non-liability to tax under the Act and an exemption from liability in pursuance of its provision. This may well be so. But the combined effect of a provision imposing liability to tax and of one granting exemption from the said liability is, for all practical purposes, to hold that there is no liability to tax under the Act. This view is what prevailed with the learned Judge of this Court in Malabar Fruit Products Company v. Sales Tax Officer, Palai, and with the Supreme Court in State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K Kandaswami [1975] 36 S.T.C 191 S.C.. The learned Government Pleader stressed the distinction between non-liability and an exemption from tax with respect to the decision of the Supreme Court in Fernandez's case [1957] 8 S.T.C 561 S.C.. But in view of the later decision of the Supreme Court in State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K Kandaswami on the scope of the provisions of an Act almost similarly worded, we think the contention of the counsel for the assessee must prevail. We accept the same.

7. We are also of the view that whatever be the combined effect of an imposition of tax under section 5A and the grant of aa exemption in pursuance of a notification under section 10, the latter part of section 5A(1) is wide enough to make out a case in favour of the assessee. By reason of the exemption granted, we think it could well be contended by the assessee that the sale or purchase of the synthetic gems was “in the circumstances in which no tax is payable under section 5”.

8. The learned Government Pleader had a contention that the range of the exemption is not co-extensive with the range of liability to tax under section 5A. It was pointed out that section 5A imposes liability on goods the “sale or purchase of which” is liable to tax under certain conditions and circumstances dealt with in the section; whereas the exemption from tax granted by the notification in question is only in respect of the sale of polished synthetic gems and not in respect of the purchase of such gems. It was, therefore, said that it cannot be said that there is a total exemption from the sphere of tax liability. Counsel for the assessee replied that while both a sale and a purchase are covered by section 5A, and a sale alone is referred in the exemption notification, there is a good justifying reason for the same; viz., that synthetic gems are liable under section 5(1)(ii) of the Act only at the point of sale and not at the point of purchase. In view of this, we agree with the counsel for the assessee that as far as the synthetic gems are concerned the exemption is total and the combined effect of the exemption together with the provision in section 5A, for all practical purposes, is to hold that the sale of the synthetic gems is not liable to tax under the Act or is under circumstances under which no tax is payable. Being of this view, the contrary conclusion taken by the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal cannot be sustained. We allow these tax revision cases and set aside the orders of the Tribunal. There will be no order as to costs.

9. Petitions allowed.