Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Trading Corporation Of India Ltd. v. Sales Tax Officer, Mattancherry & Others

Kerala High Court
Jan 25, 1972
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, State Trading Corporation of India Ltd., was assessed by the Sales Tax Officer under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963, for the year 1964-1965. The assessment included turnover on four items, one being rock phosphate, charged at 3% tax, amounting to Rs. 14,01,966.34. The petitioner paid the tax accordingly. Subsequently, the petitioner filed an application under Section 43 of the Act to rectify the assessment, claiming the turnover on rock phosphate should be taxed at 2%, seeking a refund of Rs. 14,019.66 for the excess tax paid. This application was rejected by the Sales Tax Officer (second respondent), who advised settling the matter via appeal or revision.

The petitioner then filed a revision before the Deputy Commissioner of Agricultural Income-tax and Sales-tax (third respondent), who dismissed it on the ground that the matter should be decided by the appellate authority and that revision was not available against an appealable assessment order. The petitioner further sought revision before the Board of Revenue (fourth respondent), which also dismissed the revision application. The petitioner filed this writ petition to quash the orders rejecting the rectification application and revisions and to direct refund of the excess tax collected.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an application under Section 43 of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act to rectify an error apparent on the face of the record in the assessment order can be rejected on the ground that the matter is appealable and not subject to revision.
  2. Whether the decision rejecting the rectification application is appealable or revisable under the Act.
  3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to refund of the excess tax collected due to the error in the assessment order.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The turnover on rock phosphate was liable to tax at 2% as per the First Schedule to the Act, but was erroneously assessed at 3%.
  • The application under Section 43 was rightly filed to rectify this error, and the excess tax paid should be refunded.
  • The rejection of the rectification application on the ground that the matter is appealable was incorrect because the decision to reject the rectification itself is not appealable but revisable.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The second respondent declined to invoke Section 43, suggesting the petitioner should appeal the original assessment.
  • The Deputy Commissioner held that revision is not maintainable against an appealable assessment order.
  • The Board of Revenue maintained that the letter rejecting rectification was either not a proceeding under Section 43 or, if so, was a supplementary proceeding appealable under the Act, making appeal the proper remedy.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court recognized that rock phosphate is correctly taxable at 2%, and the assessment at 3% was an obvious error on the face of the record. Section 43 empowers the assessing authority to rectify such errors, whether the tax was underassessed or overassessed, including refunding excess tax collected. The Deputy Commissioner has revisional powers under Section 35 but is restricted from revising orders if an appeal lies or if the order is under appeal.

The court found the second respondent’s refusal to entertain the rectification application on the ground that the matter was appealable to be a patent error. The Board of Revenue’s view that the rejection letter was a supplementary proceeding appealable under the Act was also rejected. The court clarified that an application under Section 43 is independent and not a supplementary proceeding to the assessment. If the application is rejected, the remedy is revision, not appeal.

The excess tax collected was without legal authority, and the petitioner was entitled to refund. The rejection orders by the respondents were based on untenable technical grounds and were quashed. The court directed refund of the excess amount within two months and ordered costs in favor of the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED the rejection orders and directed refund of Rs. 14,019.66 to the petitioner.

The court’s decision directly affects the parties by quashing the orders rejecting the rectification application and revisions, mandating refund of the excess tax collected. No new legal precedent was established beyond clarifying the proper remedy against rejection of rectification applications under Section 43 of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963.

Show all summary ...

1. The petitioner is the State Trading Corporation of India Ltd., who was assessed by the first respondent the Sales Tax Officer, Special Circle, Mattancherry under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 for the year 1964-1965 by his order Ext. P. dated 24-11-1965. The assessee's return was accepted; and the assessment was made on that basis. The total turnover related to four items, one of which was rock phosphate. The turnover in respect of that item was Rs. 14,01,966.34 and it was charged to tax at 3%. The petitioner paid the whole tax as per the assessment. Subsequently, the petitioner filed an application, Ext. P-1 dated 31-12-1966 before the second respondent, the Sales Tax Officer, III Circle, Mattancherry, to whom the petitioner's case had been transferred, under S. 43 of the Act praying to rectify the order of assessment on the ground that the turnover on rock phosphate was chargeable to tax only at 2% and that the assessment at 3% in respect of that item was an error on the face of the record. The application also prayed for refund of a sum of Rs. 14,019.66 which represented the excess tax collected on account of the above error. The application was rejected by the second respondent by his letter Ext. P-2 dated 23-3-1967, stating that it may settle the matter in appeal or revision, and that he could interfere at that stage.

2. Then, the petitioner filed revision before the third respondent, the Deputy Commissioner of Agricultural Income-tax and Sales-tax, Central Zone, Ernakulam, who dismissed it by his order, Ext. P-4 dated 7-9-1968, stating that the question whether the assessment of the turnover in respect of rock phosphate at 3% was correct or not has to be decided by the appellate authority, and that there was no provision to entertain a revision petition against an assessment which is appealable under the Act. The petitioner took the matter in revision before the fourth respondent, the Board of Revenue, who dismissed the revision application by its order Ext. P-6 dated 22-9-1969. This writ petition has been filed to quash Exts. P-2, P-4 and P-6 and to direct the second respondent to refund to the petitioner the sum of Rs. 14019.66 alleged to have been collected from it without any authority of law.

3. There is no dispute that rock phosphate is a chemical fertilizer which is item No. 54 in the First Schedule to the Act and its turnover is liable to tax only to 2%. That being so what the second respondent was requested to do by the petitioner was to rectify that obvious error; and lam unable to appreciate the ground stated by him for rejecting the petitioner's application under S. 43 of the Act. There can be no doubt that, if as a result of an error, the assessee happened to be assessed at too low a rate, the assessing authority, by virtue of his power under S. 43 of the Act, would be entitled to rectify the error, correct the assessment and demand the proper tax that would be payable by the assessee. Similarly, if by mistake the assessment has been made at a higher rate, then also, it is within his power under S. 43 of the Act to rectify the mistake and refund the excess amount collected. The third respondent has also power under S. 35 of the Act to revise any order erroneously passed by a subordinate authority. That section reads:—

“35. Powers of revision of the Deputy Commissioner sua motu.—(1) The Deputy Commissioner may, of his own motion, call for and examine any order passed or proceedings recorded under this Act by the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner or any officer or authority of rank below that of an Inspecting Assistant Commissioner and may make such enquiry or cause such enquiry to be made, and subject to the provisions of this Act, may pass such order thereon as he thinks fit.

(2) The Deputy Commissioner shall not pass any order under sub-section

(1) if—

(a) the time for appeal against the order has not expired;

(b) the order has been made the subject of an appeal to the Appellate Assistant, Commissioner or the Appellate Tribunal or of a revision in the High Court; or

(c) more than four years have expired after the passing of order referred to therein.

(3) No order under this section adversely affecting a person shall be passed unless that person has had a reasonable opportunity of being heard.”

4. The only ground on which he refused jurisdiction was that there was no provision to entertain a revision against an assessment order which is appealable under this Act. This is a patent error. The Board of Revenue in its order Est. P. 6 stated the following reasons for refusing relief to the petitioner:—

“(1) Actually in this case, the Sales Tax Officer has not issued any proceedings as such. In his letter dated 23-3-1967, he has only declined to invoke S. 43 with the result that the original assessment for 1964-1965 is left in tact. The proper remedy in such a situation is to prefer an appeal before the appellate authority.

(2) If as a matter of fact, the letter of the Sales Tax Officer dated 23-3-1967 is considered as proceedings under S. 43, then such proceedings form only supplementary proceedings of assessment which have no separate existence independent of the original assessment. In this view also, the order dated 23-3-1967 is appealable.

In any view of the matter, it is clear that the proper remedy available to the petitioner is by way of appeal.”

5. The Board of Revenue seems to have thoroughly misunderstood the legal position. Ext. P-2, the communication from the second respondent, was his decision rejecting the petitioner's application under S. 43 to rectify the error in the assessment. Such a decision is not subject to any appeal under the Act; and the only remedy for an assessee aggrieved thereby is revision. The Board of Revenue is also wrong in its view that Ext. P-2 can be treated as a supplementary proceeding to the assessment; and an appeal can be filed from that. Any error apparent on the face of the record in an assessment can be rectified on an application made within three years of the order of assessment. If an order rejecting an application for rectification is a supplementary proceeding to the assessment, which has no separate existence independent of the original assessment and an appeal can be filed from that, as the Board of Revenue seems to think, any assessee can file an application under S. 43 of the Act within the aforesaid time, and if the application is rejected, he can then file an appeal from the original assessment. This is a hardly stateable position. It is true that if an assessment is rectified, it would stand amended, as it happens if it were modified as a result of an appeal or revision. That does not mean that a proceeding under S. 43 of the Act is one supplementary to the assessment.

6. The sum of Rs. 14019.66, which the petitioner seeks to get refunded is, on the admitted facts of the case, an amount collected by the respondents without any authority of law. In that view of the matter also, the petitioner is entitled to get the said amount refunded. It is surprising that the petitioner's application for refund of that amount which the Government should not have collected, and which happened to be collected as a result of an obvious error in the order of assessment, has been rejected by all the three authorities on sheer technical and totally untenable grounds. I quash the orders, Exts. P-2, P-4 and P-6 and direct the respondents to refund to the petitioner the sum of Rs. 14010.66 within two months from this date. The respondents will pay the casts of the petitioner.

7. Allowed.