- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mohammed Kani Rowther v. Hassan Rowther Bulghese Beevi And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff, who is the revision petitioner, challenged the order of the lower court directing him to pay additional court-fee for the plaint. The plaint was rejected on 10-2-1970 under Order 7, Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) for non-payment of the additional court-fee as ordered. The revision petition was filed on the same day, 10-2-1970, and admitted on 11-2-1970 after the plaint was rejected. The order rejecting the plaint under Order 7, Rule 11 was treated as a decree as defined under Section 2(2) of the CPC. The petitioner was advised that the proper remedy was to file an appeal against the order rejecting the plaint and challenge the correctness of the order requiring payment of additional court-fee in that appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a revision petition is maintainable against an order directing payment of additional court-fee for the plaint when the plaint is rejected under Order 7, Rule 11 of the CPC before admission of the revision petition.
- Whether the rejection of the plaint under Order 7, Rule 11 constitutes a decree under Section 2(2) of the CPC and the appropriate remedy for challenging such an order.
- The legal effect of setting aside an order in revision that rejected a plaint for non-payment of additional court-fee, and whether the suit proceeds on merits thereafter.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioner's Arguments
- Relied on precedents including Chappila & Others v. Chemmaran & Others, Radhakrishnaru v. Madhavan Pillai, and Mathew Kuruvilla v. Rajagopala Iyer to contend that if the order rejecting the plaint is set aside in revision, the decree will stand automatically set aside and the lower court must proceed with the suit on merits.
Court's Observations on Arguments
- The facts of the precedent cases cited were distinguished or found not applicable.
- Specifically, the court disagreed with the view in Mathew Kuruvilla v. Rajagopala Iyer that an order dismissing an appeal based on rejection of a petition to condone delay is void and can be set aside in revision.
- The court held that such illegal orders must be challenged in a second appeal, and revision is not the appropriate remedy.
- The court noted that the correctness of the order for payment of additional court-fee can be challenged in the appeal against the decree.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Chappila & Others v. Chemmaran & Others, 1960 Ker LT 1361 (AIR 1961 Ker 200) | Effect of setting aside an order rejecting plaint in revision and its impact on suit proceeding on merits. | Distinguished on facts; found not applicable to the case before the court. |
| Radhakrishnaru v. Madhavan Pillai, 1961 Ker LT 3 | Effect of rejection of plaint before or after admission of revision petition. | Unclear from precedent whether facts matched; no conclusive application. |
| Mathew Kuruvilla v. Rajagopala Iyer, 1966 Ker LT 916 | Validity of order dismissing appeal based on rejection of petition to condone delay and scope of revision remedy. | Disagreed with the precedent; held that dismissal of appeal is illegal order but not void; revision is not the remedy; second appeal or Section 115 CPC remedy available. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the procedural posture of the plaint rejection under Order 7, Rule 11 of the CPC for non-payment of additional court-fee. It noted that such an order is a decree under Section 2(2) of the CPC. The petitioner’s proper remedy is to appeal against the decree rather than seek revision. The court carefully examined the precedents cited by the petitioner and found them either factually distinguishable or legally incorrect in principle. Specifically, the court rejected the argument that setting aside the order in revision would automatically revive the suit on merits. It emphasized that illegal orders dismissing appeals must be challenged in a second appeal or under Section 115 CPC, not by revision. Consequently, the court concluded that a revision petition filed before admission against such an order is not maintainable. The court refrained from expressing an opinion on revision petitions filed after admission of the revision petition.
Holding and Implications
The revision petition is dismissed.
The direct effect of this decision is that a revision petition filed against an order directing payment of additional court-fee leading to rejection of the plaint under Order 7, Rule 11 CPC is not maintainable if filed before admission of the revision petition. The petitioner must challenge such orders by filing an appeal. No new precedent was set beyond the dismissal of the petition, and the court did not express views on revision petitions admitted post plaint rejection.
Krishnamoorthy Iyer, J.:— The plaintiff who is the revision petitioner complains against the order of the court below directing him to pay additional court-fee for the plaint. It is seen that the plaint was rejected on 10-2-1970 under Order 7, Rule 11 of the CPC, for non-payment of additional court-fee as ordered. The revision petition was also filed on 10-2-1970 and it was admitted on 11-2-1970 after the rejection of the plaint. An order rejecting a plaint under Order 7, Rule 11 is a decree as defined under Section 2(2) of the CPC. The proper remedy of the plaintiff is to file an appeal against the order rejecting the plaint and canvass the correctness of the order calling upon the party to pay additional court-fee in that appeal.
2. But counsel for the revision petitioner relying on the decisions in Chappila & Others…* v. Chemmaran & Others…, 1960 Ker LT 1361 : (AIR 1961 Ker 200) Radhakrishnaru v. Madhavan Pillai, 1961 Ker LT 3 and Mathew Kuruvilla v. Rajagopala Iyer, 1966 Ker LT 916, contended that if the order sought to be revised is set aside in revision even though the order rejecting the plaint is a decree it will stand automatically set aside and the lower court will have to proceed with the suit on the merits.
3. The facts in 1960 Ker LT 1361 : (AIR 1961 Ker 200) are peculiar and they have no application to the case before us. It is not possible to find out from 1961 Ker LT 3, whether the rejection of the plaint was before or after the admission of the revision petition by this Court. In 1966 Ker LT 916, Vaidialingam, J. has taken the view that when the order dismissing the petition to condone the delay in filing an appeal is interfered with in revision the order of the Judge dismissing the appeal based on the rejection of the petition to excuse delay will be absolutely void and will have no effect in law. We cannot agree. The order dismissing the appeal can be only an illegal order which will have to be set aside only in a second appeal and not in a revision petition. If against such dismissals no second appeal will lie, it is open to this Court to set aside the order suo motu under Section 115 of the CPC. We are therefore of the view, with great respect to the learned Judge that the decision in 1966 Ker LT 916, is not correct. It was not contended before us that the correctness of the order for payment of additional court-fee cannot be impeached in the appeal that may be filed against the decree.
4. We are therefore of the view, that in cases where a plaint is rejected under Order 7, Rule 11 of the CPC for default to pay additional court-fee even before the admission of a revision petition filed against order calling for payment of additional court-fee, the revision petition is not maintainable. We are not expressing an opinion as to the effect of allowing a revision petition on orders rejecting a plaint after the revision petition is admitted.
5. We, therefore, dismiss the revision petition. No costs.
6. Revision dismissed.
Alert