- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
N. Rudramuni & Others v. Department Of Law Ju...
CASES REFERRED AT PARAS 1. (2012) 6 SCC 502 : AIR 2002 SC 2006 Brij Mohan Lal v. Union of India (Ref) 8 2. (2012) 6 SCC 502 Brij Mohan Lal v. Union of India (Ref) 9 3. (2013) 3 SCC 658 Debabrata Dash v. Jatindra Prasad Dash (Ref) 20 4. (2012) 11 SCC 656 Mahesh Chandra Verma v. State of Jharkhand, (Ref) 20 5. 2013 (3) SCALE 93 State of Orissa v. Sri Jagabandhu Panda (Ref) 20 6. (1984) 4 SCC 450 O.P Singla v. Union of India, (Ref) 20 7. 1995 Supp (1) SCC 572 V. Sreenivasa Reddy v. Govt. of Andhra Pradesh (Ref) 20 8. (2002) 4 SCC 247 All India Judges Association v. Union of India (UOI), (Ref) 20
9. (1990) 2 SCC 715 Direct Recruit Class II Engineering Officers' Association v. State of Maharashtra (Ref) 21 10. (1999) 8 SCC 287 L. Chandra Kishore Singh v. State of Manipur (Ref) 21 11. (1999) 9 SCC 596 Ajit Kumar Rath v. State of Orissa (Ref) 21 12. 1991 Supp (2) SCC 51 O.P Garg v. State of U.P (Ref) 21 13. (2000) 8 SCC 25 Rudra Kumar Sain v. Union of India (Ref) 21 14. 2008 AIR SCW 7042 B.S Mathur v. Union of India (Ref) 21 15. 1986 Supp SCC 239 G.K Dudani v. S.D Sharma (Ref) 21 16. 2002 AIR SCW 1706 All India Judges Association v. Union of India (Ref) 23 17. (1992) 1 SCC 119 All India Judges Association v. Union of India (Ref) 23
18. (1993) 4 SCC 288 All India Judges Association v. Union of India (Ref) 23 19. (1993) 3 SCC 371 West Bengal v. Aghore Nath Dey (Ref) 29 20. (2012) 8 SCC 633 State of Haryana v. Vijay Singh (Ref) 29 21. (2011) 3 SCC 267 Pavan Prathap Singh v. Reevan Singh (Ref) 46 22. (2001) 5 SCC 581 Swapan Kumar Pal v. Samitabhar Chakraborthy, (Ref) 50 23. MANU/SC/1345/2011 State of Uttaranchal v. Rajendra Singh Kandwal (Ref) 51 24. (1978) 1 SCC 405 Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner (Ref) 54 25. (2005) 7 SCC 627 Hindustan Petroleum Corpn., Ltd. v. Darius Shahpur Chennai (Ref) 54
26. (2006) 10 SCC 346 Uttaranchal Forest Rangers' Assn., (Direct Recruit) v. State of U.P (Ref) 56 27. 2013 (8) SCALE 504 P. Sudhakar Rao v. U. Govinda Rao, (Ref) 58 28. MANU/JH/0055/007 Ajit Prasad Verma v. State of Jharkhand (Ref) 65.2 29. (1973) 3 SCC 862 Lalith Mohan Dey v. Union of India (Ref) 65.2 30. (2006) 6 SCC 558 K. Madalaimuthu v. State of Tamil Nadu (Ref) 67.1
Advocate/s for Petitioner/s:
Sri. Basavaprabhu S. Patil, Sr. Advocate for Sri. Brijesh Patil in W.P Nos. 41684-41691/2012
Sri. Puttige R Ramesh, Advocate in W.P No. 28147/2013
Advocate/s for Respondent/s:
Sri. P.S Rajagopal, Sr. Advocate, A/W Sri Raghavendra G Gayathri, AGA for R1-3;
Sri Puttige R Ramesh, Advocate, for Sri Sachin V.R for R5, 32, 33, 42, 47 and 50,
Sri Sharath S. Gowda, Advocate, for R8 & 35,
Sri K.V Narasimhan, Advocate, for R6, 9, 12, 14, 15, 19, 21, 23, 31, 48, 55, 56, 66 & 72,
Sri L K Srinivasa Murthy, Advocate, for R10,
Sri S.V Narasimhan, Advocate, for R20, 22, 24, 28, 34, 36, 40, 43, 44, 53, 58, 63, 64, 67, 71, 74, 77 to 80, 82, 83,
Sri K Shrihari, Adv., For R46,
Respondent Nos. 7, 11, 13, 16 TO 18, 25 TO 27, 29, 30, 37 TO 39, 41, 51, 52, 57, 59, 61, 62, 65, 68 TO 70, 73, 75, 76, 81, 84, 85 in W.P Nos. 41684-41691/2012
Sri. Raghavendra G. Gayathri, AGA for R1 & R2.
Sri. Basava Prabhu patil, Sr. Advocate for R3 to R10 in W.P 28147/2013
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Dilip B. Bhosale, J.:— The question of inter-se seniority between promotees and direct recruits has always been a matter of controversy that engaged the attention of the Supreme Court and High Courts on several occasions and there are many decisions bearing upon the controversy. This is one more.
2. The petitioners-direct recruits have instituted these writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India calling in question the legality of Notification dated 14th September, 2012 issued by respondent No. 3-Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka, Bangalore (for short “the RG”), whereby, a final seniority list of District Judges has been published. In the final seniority list, according to the petitioners, respondent Nos. 4 to 85, (for short “the respondent-DJs”) who were promoted/appointed in the cadre of District Judge subsequent to their appointments as District Judges, have wrongly been placed above them. Petitioners have also prayed for a direction to the RG to redraw the seniority, taking into consideration the actual date of appointment of the petitioners (direct recruits) and the dates of promotion of the respondent-DJs in the cadre of District Judge.
3. Petitioners were appointed as District Judges under 25% category of direct recruits as provided for in Rule 4 of the Karnataka Judicial Services (Recruitment) Rules, 2004 (for short “2004 Rules”) vide Notification dated 13.2.2008 The Notification dated 13.2.2008, to the extent it is relevant reads thus:
“NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred under Article 233 of the Constitution of India, the Governor of Karnataka hereby appoints the following Advocates as District Judges with immediate effect.”
(emphasis supplied)
4. Having regard to huge pendency of cases and for disposal of long pending sessions and other cases, the Eleventh Finance Commission recommended a scheme for creation of 1734 Fast Track Courts (for short FTCs) in the country. The Ministry of Finance sanctioned an amount of Rs. 502.90 crores as “special problem and upgradation grant” for judicial administration. The scheme was temporary and for a period of 5 years. Government accorded its approval for the continuation of 1562 Fast Track Courts that were operational as on 31.3.2005 for a further period of 5 years i.e, upto 31st March, 2010.
5. In view of the recommendation of the 11 Finance Commission the Government of Karnataka created FTCs and decided to appoint Civil Judges as District Judges temporarily on ad-hoc basis and accordingly respondent-DJs were promoted by issuing four different notifications as ad-hoc District Judges. The respondent-DJs, at the relevant time, were working in the cadre of Civil Judge (Sr.Dn). They were promoted temporarily on ad-hoc basis to officiate as District Judges vide Notifications dated 15-2-2003, 19-3-2003, 15-11-2003 and 20-3-2004. Though a specific request was made vide letter dated 27-12-2002 by the RG, addressed to the Chief Secretary, Government of Karnataka, requesting him to move His Excellency the Governor of Karnataka and obtain orders promoting the Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) named therein, under Article 233 of the Constitution of India as ad-hoc District Judges temporarily, subject to reversion at any time, the notifications did not make any reference to Article 233 of the Constitution of India. It would be convenient to reproduce the first Notification dated 15.2.2003 (Annexure-R9), to the extent it is relevant, which reads thus:
“NOTIFICATION
The following eighteen Civil Judges (Senior Division) are promoted, temporarily on adhoc basis to officiate as District Judges with immediate effect to man the Fast Track Courts subject to reversion at any time.”
(emphasis supplied)
The language of remaining three Notifications dated 19.3.2003, 15.11.2003 and 20.03.2004 is similar.
5.1 Total 82 Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) were promoted temporarily on ad hoc basis to officiate as District Judges with immediate effect to man the Fast Track Courts subject to reversion at any time. The expression “to man the Fast Track Courts” in the aforesaid notifications, however, was deleted vide Corrigendum dated 21.4.2003
5.2 After their appointments, they took charge as ad-hoc District Judges and continued till they were promoted/appointed under 50% and 25% quota to be filled by promotions on the basis of seniority-cum-merit and through Departmental Competitive Examination (for short ‘accelerated promotion’), respectively as provided for under Rule 4 of the 2004 Rules vide Notifications dated 1 June 2009, 27 June 2009 and 29 July 2009. (Annexure-R22 to Annexure-24). All the three notifications, were issued by the Governor of Karnataka, in exercise of the powers conferred on him under Article 233 of the Constitution of India appointing them on the existing vacancies in the cadre of District Judge, under the 2004 Rules, with immediate effect.
5.3 The first Notification dated 1 June, 2009, issued by the Governor of Karnataka, to the extent it is relevant, reads thus:
“NOTIFICATION
I, Rameshwar Thakur, Governor of Karnataka in exercise of the powers conferred on me, under Article 233 of the Constitution of India, hereby appoints the following 48 Ad-hoc District Judges/Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) filling up 50% of the existing vacancies in the cadre of District Judges by promotion on the basis of seniority-cum-merit under the Karnataka Judicial Service (Recruitment) Rules, 2004, with immediate effect.”
(emphasis supplied)
5.4 The second Notification dated 29.7.2009 appointing 14 ad-hoc District Judges/Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) in the cadre of DJ, filling up 50% of the existing vacancies is identical. The third Notification dated 27.6.2009, whereby 45 ad-hoc DJs/Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) filling up 25% of the existing vacancies in the cadre of District judges by accelerated promotion reads thus:
“GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
No. DPAR 35 SHC 2009Karnataka Government Secretariat, “Vidhana Soudha” Bangalore, dated: 27 June, 2009
NOTIFICATION
I, Rameshwar Thakur, Governor of Karnataka in exercise of the powers conferred on me, under Article 233 of the Constitution of India, hereby appoint the following 45 Ad-hoc District Judges/Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) filling up 25% of the existing vacancies in the cadre of District Judges who have put in not less than 5 years of service strictly on the basis of merit through limited departmental competitive examination in accordance with the guidelines framed by the High Court under the Karnataka Judicial Service (Recruitment) Rules, 2004, with the immediate effect.”
(emphasis supplied)
6. Perusal of the above notifications, clearly demonstrate that the respondent-DJs were promoted as District Judges in 2009 under the 2004 Rules against the vacancies available in the cadre. In other words, their regular promotion/appointments in the cadre of District Judge were made, for the first time under the 50% and 25% category/quota provided for in the 2004 Rules, on the basis of seniority-cum-merit and through departmental competitive examination i.e, accelerated promotion, respectively.
6.1 Initial appointments, i.e, before their temporary promotions on ad hoc basis, of respondent-DJs as Munsiffs were, however, made under the Karnataka Judicial Services (Recruitment) Rules, 1983 (for short “1983 Rules”) and then as ad hoc District Judges, from the cadre of Civil Judge (Sr.Dn) on the basis of seniority-cum-merit in 2003-04, in view of the recommendation of the 11 Finance Commission for FTCs. I would deal with the question whether their appointments as ad hoc District Judges were made under 1983 Rules or as per the Scheme and policy of appointment of ad-hoc District Judges for the Fast Track Courts little later.
6.2 It is not in dispute that their (respondent-DJs) promotions as ad hoc DJs temporarily in 2003–2004 were made after following the due procedure in force i.e, the procedure adopted by the High Court as contemplated by 1983 Rules.
7. Having regard to the dates of their (respondent-DJs) appointments under Article 233 of the Constitution as DJs, on the existing vacancies in the cadre of District Judge, and the date of appointment of the petitioners, they contend that they were born in the cadre of District Judge in 2008, while respondents-DJs in 2009 and in view thereof, they (petitioners) were initially treated as senior to the respondent-DJs and were posted as District Judges with independent charge or as principal District Judge/s.
8. Respondent-DJs, therefore, made representations dated 24 August, 2009 and 3rd November, 2009 addressed to the RG, requesting to recognize/consider their service rendered as ad hoc District Judges as the service rendered in the District Judge cadre and accordingly, their seniority may be fixed from the date of their initial appointments as ad hoc District Judges in view of the directions issued by the Supreme Court in Brij Mohan Lal v. Union of india . 2012 6 SCC 502, (for short “Brij Mohan Lal-1”).
8.1 In view thereof, the RG, vide notice dated 15 September, 2010, requested the petitioners-direct recruits to file their response to the representations made by the respondent-DJs. The petitioners accordingly submitted their response dated 21 September, 2010.
9. The representations of respondent-DJs were placed before Administrative Committee No. I, which in the meeting held on 23.8.2010 constituted a Committee of Mrs. Manjula Chellur. J (as she then was) and Mr. K.L Manjunath, J and requested to consider the request/prayer to fix their seniority as District Judges from the date of their appointments on ad hoc basis after giving an opportunity of hearing to the officers who were likely to be affected. Before the report was submitted by the Committee, Mrs. Manjula Chellur, J was appointed as Chief Justice and hence it was re-constituted consisting of Mr. K.L Manjunath, J and Mr. Ajit J. Gunjal, J (for short “the Committee”). The Committee considered the request made by the respondent-DJs in the light of judgment of the Supreme Court in Brij Mohan Lal-1, in particular, direction 6 and 14 in paragraph-10 thereof, and paragraphs 6 and 7 of the judgment in Brij Mohan Lal v. Union of India . 2012 6 SCC 502, (for short “Brij Mohan Lal-2”) and in the concluding paragraph, stated thus:
“In view of the judgment rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, there is nothing for the Committee to fix the date of seniority of the ad hoc Judges who have worked as Judges in the FTCs. Since Hon'ble Supreme Court has already ruled that services rendered in the FTCs by a judicial officer will be deemed to be in service for such higher grade on his promotion to higher grade in the permanent cadre (as District and Sessions Judge). Based on the above, we are of the view that it is for the Registry to work out and fix the inter-se seniority of all the Adhoc Judges who have been promoted latter as regular District Judges by taking into consideration the rights of the District Judges who have been directly appointed and also rights of the District Judges who have been promoted from amongst the Civil Judges who were selected on their success in limited examination.”
(emphasis supplied)
10. The report of the Committee was placed before Full Court held on 14 July, 2012. The Full Court passed the following resolution:
“Discussed. The Full Court considering the office note, materials on record, judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Transferred Case No. 22/2001 in the case of Brij Mohan Lal v. Union of India and the report of the Committee constituted to fix the Seniority of Ad-hoc District Judges on their promotion as Regular District Judges, RESOLVED to accept the report submitted by the Committee headed by Hon'ble Shri Justice K.L Manjunath and further resolved to direct the Registrar General to prepare a draft seniority list keeping in view the Karnataka Judicial Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1983, Karnataka Judicial Service (Recruitment) Rules, 2004 and Full Court resolutions governing the same and circulate the same to affected Officers calling for objections and thereafter finalise the seniority list with the approval of the Hon'ble Chief Justice.”
(emphasis supplied)
11. In view of the resolution passed by the Full Court a provisional seniority list of District Judges based on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Brij Mohan Lal-1 was prepared by the RG dated 27-7-2012 inviting objections from the aggrieved Judges. In the provisional list, respondents-DJs (promotee judges) were placed above the petitioners (direct recruits). As a result thereof, the petitioners filed objections to the provisional list.
12. The RG, as per the directions issued by the Full Court in its meeting dated 14 July, 2012, after considering the objections, finalised seniority list and obtained approval of the Hon'ble Chief Justice. From perusal of the submission of the RG, which runs into about 22 pages, it appears that he rejected the objections raised by the petitioners, based on the observations made by the Committee and by the Supreme Court in Brij Mohan Lal-1. The relevant paragraph in the submission of the RG reads thus:
“The Hon'ble Committee which has gone into the question as to from which date the Adhoc District Judges who were subsequently promoted as District & Sessions Judge were entitled to count their seniority in the cadre of District & Sessions Judges. After considering the effect of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Brij Mohan Lal's case which has dealt with this very specific issue has given a report stating that all such Officers are entitled to count their seniority in the cadre of District & Sessions Judges from the date when they were initially posted as Adhoc District Judges. This observation of the Hon'ble Committee is a complete answer to all the objections by this group of Officers in as much as once they are entitled to count their seniority from the date when they initially became Adhoc District Judges which being prior to the date of coming into force of the Karnataka Judicial Service (Recruitment) Rules, 2004, with effect from 9.9.2005, they will have to be ranked above the candidates promoted under the said provision from the cadre of Senior Civil Judges. Further once the Hon'ble Committee has held that the date of seniority is from the date of posting as Adhoc District Judges, the matter as to whether some of them had taken the limited departmental examination and were unsuccessful in the same does not make any material difference to the said legal position. In other words, in view of the Brij Mohan Lal's decision and the report of the Committee, they are automatically entitled to count their seniority from the date of their becoming Adhoc District Judges and therefore their taking limited departmental examination was wholly superfluous in the eye of law. Accordingly, the contention raised in this behalf cannot be sustained.”
(emphasis supplied)
13. Accordingly, the impugned Notification dated 14 September, 2012 (Annexure-A) came to be issued in which respondents-DJs were placed above the petitioners taking into account their service as ad hoc District Judges and treating it as service rendered in the District Judge cadre. The Notification dated 14 September, 2012 to the extent it is relevant reads thus:
“GOB(I)343/2009High Court of Karnataka Bangalore, Date: 14.09.2012
NOTIFICATION
A Provisional Seniority List from and subsequent to 01.01.2003 of Directly Recruited District Judges, District Judges promoted on seniority-cum-merit basis under 50% category, District Judges promoted from the cadre of Senior Civil Judges under 25% category by holding limited departmental competitive examination has been published by the High Court, inviting objections, if any, to the said Provisional Seniority List, vide this office letter of even number dated 28.07.2012
The High Court of Karnataka considered the objections received and on such consideration resolved to publish the Final Seniority List of District Judges who have been promoted/appointed after 01.01.2003”
14. In this backdrop, before I make reference and advert to the diverse contentions urged by Learned Counsel for the parties, in support of their case, it would be relevant to make a brief reference to the relevant rules in the 1983 Rules. These Rules were made in exercise of the powers conferred by Articles 233, 234 and the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India by the Governor of Karnataka after consultation with the Karnataka Public Service Commission and the High Court of Karnataka.
14.1 Rule-2 provides for method of recruitment, minimum qualifications, etc., Schedule appended to Rule-2 provides category of posts and method of recruitment and minimum qualifications. The category of posts mentioned therein are District Judges (Super-time scale), District Judges, Civil Judges and Munsiffs. In the present case we are concerned with the cadre of District Judge. Rule 2 and Item Nos. 1 and 2 in Schedule thereto, with which, we are concerned in the present case, read thus:
“2. Method of recruitment, minimum qualifications, etc., — In respect of each category of posts specified in column (2) of the Schedule below, the method of recruitment and the minimum qualifications shall be as specified in the corresponding entries in columns (3) and (4) thereof:—
SCHEDULE
Sl. No Category of posts Method of recruitment Minimum qualifications etc. 1. District Judges (Supertime scale) By promotion by selection from the cadre of District Judges by the High Court of Karnataka Must have put in at least 5(five) years of service as District Judge. 2. District Judges By promotion on the basis of seniority-cum-merit from the cadre of Civil Judges: Provided that such number of posts as may be determined by the High Court from time to time, but not exceeding in the aggregate 33 ⅓% of the posts in the cadre of District Judges may be filled by Direct recruitment). Note- The High court of Karnataka may, subject to those rules, adopt such procedure as it deems fit for selecting the candidates by direct recruitment or by promotion by seniority-cum-merit. For Direct Recruitment. — Must be holder of a degree in Law or equivalent qualification; and Must be practicing on the last date fixed for submission of applications, as an Advocate and must have so practised for not less than seven years as on such date. Age: Must not have attained the age of (forty-eight) years on the last date fixed for submission of application.) Probation.— Two years. During the period of probation he must undergo such training as may be specified by the High Court of Karnataka Officiation.-2 years.
(emphasis supplied)
14.2 Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 3 states that subject to Articles 233, 234 and 235 of the Constitution of India, provisions of Rules 5, 6(2), 6(3), 8, 9, 10 to 13 of the Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977, shall, insofar as they are not inconsistent with these rules, mutatis mutandis, apply to recruitment of DJs, Civil Judges and Munsiffs under these Rules. Sub-Rule(2) of Rule 3 states that all rules regulating the conditions of service of the members of the State Civil Services made from time to time under any law or the Proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India shall, subject to Articles 233, 234 and 235 be applicable to the Munsiffs, Civil Judges and the District Judges recruited and appointed under these rules.
14.3 Rule 5 provides for repeal and savings. It states, the Karnataka District Judges (Recruitment) Rules 1962, the Karnataka Civil Judges (Recruitment) Rules 1966, and Karnataka Munsiffs (Recruitment) Rules 1981, and all Rules made on the subject are repealed, provided that the said repeal shall not affect (a) previous operations of the said Rules or anything duly done or suffered thereunder or any right, liability or obligation acquired, accrued or incurred under the said Rules; (b) the validity of the list of selected candidates for the posts of DJs or Munsiffs, as the case may be, prepared under the repealed rules and appointments of such selected candidates; and (c) all proceedings, including action taken to make recruitment and preparation of the list of selected candidates, commenced under the repealed rules etc.
15. Another set of Rules we are concerned with, is the 2004 Rules which were published vide Notification dated 9 September, 2005. Those Rules were also made by the Governor of Karnataka, in exercise of powers conferred upon him by Articles 233 and 234 and the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, and in consultation with the Karnataka Public Service Commission and High Court of Karnataka.
15.1 Rule 2 (e) defines “Recruiting Authority” which means the High Court of Karnataka. Rule 2(f) defines “service” which means the Karnataka Judicial Service. Rule 3 states that the appointing authority for the posts in the cadre of District Judges and Civil Judges (Jr.Dn) shall be the Governor and for the posts in the cadre of Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) shall be the High Court.
15.2 Rule 4 provides for method of recruitment, qualification and age limit in respect of three cadre of posts i.e, District Judge, Civil Judge (Sr.Dn) and Civil Judge (Jr.Dn). In the present petitions, we are concerned with the cadre of District Judge. The relevant Rule 4 to the extent, it is necessary, reads thus:
“4. Method of recruitment, qualification and age limit—
In respect of each cadre of posts specified in column (2) of the table below the method of recruitment and minimum qualification, age limit, etc., shall be as specified in the corresponding entries in columns (3) and (4) thereof
Sl. No. Cadre Method of Recruitment Qualification, age limit, etc (1) (2) (3) (4) 1. District Judges 50% of the total posts in the cadre shall be filled by promotion from the cadre of Civil Judges (Sr. Dn.) on the basis of seniority cum merit.) (For the said purpose, the High Court shall devise and evolve a test in order to ascertain and examine the legal knowledge of the candidates and to Assess their continued efficiency with adequate knowledge of case laws). By direct recruitment:— Must be holder of a degree in law granted by a university established by law in India. Must be practicing as an advocate in the High Court or in a subordinate Court on the last date fixed for receipt of applications and must have so practiced for a period not less than seven years as on such date. 25% of the posts in the service shall be filled by promotion from the cadre of Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) who have put in not less than 5 years of service strictly on the basis of merit through limited Department competitive examination in accordance with the guidelines to be framed by the High Court. Must not have attained the age of forty-eight years in the case of candidates belonging to Schedules Castes or Scheduled Tribes and forty-five years in the case of others, as on the last date fixed for receipt of applications.” 25% of the posts in the cadre shall be filled by direct recruitment on the basis of the aggregate marks obtained in a competitive examination (written & viva voce) conducted by the High Court.
(emphasis supplied)
15.3 Rule 5 provides for competitive examination. Part-I of Rule 5 provides for examination for recruitment of District Judges which consists of written examination of two papers each for 150 marks in Civil law and in Criminal law and viva voce examination for maximum 100 marks which provides for selection of candidates in order of merits on the basis of aggregate of the marks obtained in the written examination and viva voce test subject to the Government Orders relating to reservation of posts for scheduled castes, schedule tribes and other backward classes. Part-II of Rule-5 provides for competitive examination for recruitment of Civil Judges, junior division, we are not concerned with this part of the Rule. Rule 6 provides for disqualification for appointment such as the person shall be eligible for appointment to the service only if he is a citizen of India.
15.4 Rule 7 provides for recruitment, sub-Rule(1) thereof provides for filling up of vacancies by promotion for which the recruiting authority shall take all necessary steps well in advance so as to finalise the list of persons considered eligible for promotion atleast 10-15 days before the occurrence of the vacancy. Sub-Rule (2)(i) and (2) (ii) provides for the procedure for filling up of vacancies by direct recruitment.
15.5 Rule-8 provides for conditions, suitability, fitness and character. Rule-9 provides for fees required to be paid along with the application.
15.6 Rule-10 provides for joining time for appointment. Rule 12 which provides for repeal and savings is also similar to Rule 5 in the 1983 Rules.
15.7 Neither the 1983 Rules nor the 2004 Rules provide for an appointment on ad-hoc basis or on temporary basis or provide for temporary posts or promotion against vacant posts created temporarily. The 1983 and 2004 Rules insofar as such appointments are concerned are silent.
15.8 It is clear from the 1983 Rules, and other documents referred to herein above, that no specific procedure was prescribed in the Rules to be followed for granting promotions and it was left open to the High Court (Administrative Committee and Full Court) to adopt such method as it deemed fit to accord promotion to Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) to the post of District Judge on seniority-cum-merit. Accordingly, the Administrative Committee as well as the Full Court seem to have promoted Civil Judges (Sr.Dn) temporarily by Notifications dated 15-2-2003, 19-3-2003, 15-11-2003, 20-03-2004 to the posts of ad hoc District Judges (FTC) after following the procedure adopted as contemplated by Rule 2 of the 1983 Rules.
16. At this stage, I would like to make a brief reference to the stand/case of the respondents as reflected in the statements of objection filed on their behalf. Several respondents have filed statements of objections. The RG has filed two statements of objections. The first statement of objections dated 12-6-2013 filed by the RG was not clear, which is evident from the following quotations, by way of an illustration, from paragraphs-3, 5 and 7:
“3…………………. Initially, all are appointed on adhoc basis which was later came to be given regular promotions and all these contesting Respondents placed as Ad-hoc judges in that vacancy arise and quota available and that the promotions are appointment by limited competitive examinations.
5. ……………… Therefore, neither under the earlier Rules nor under the Amended Rules, there is a provision to the fill up the Posts by way of promotion by promoting eligible Judicial Officers in the cadre of Civil Judge Senior Division and only ⅓ is recruited to be filled up by way of direct recruitment which is further reduced to 25% by way of amended Rules of 2004.
7. ………… Therefore, even though these contesting Respondents were initially promoted on adhoc basis, subsequently, there promotions have been regularized by issuing the order dated 01.07.2009 and all such promotions were taken place only to fill up the post of the District Judges available for promotions.”
16.1 The RG was, therefore, allowed to file additional statement of objections dated 25.6.2013 making their stand clear in respect of the respondents-DJs and the date of their seniority.
16.2 In the subsequent statement of objections, the RG has referred to the procedure that was followed for granting promotions to the respondents-DJs on ad-hoc basis in view of the FTCs scheme. The norms/guidelines that were followed and taken into consideration for granting promotions on ad-hoc basis are also reproduced in the statement of objections.
16.3 It is further stated that the Administrative Committee No. II considered senior-most Civil Judges for promotion to the cadre of District Judge on ad-hoc basis, out of which, few of them were recommended for promotion. The recommendations made by the Administrative Committee were placed before the Full Court. The Full Court accepted the recommendations of Committee No. II for according promotion to the senior most Civil Judges to the cadre of District Judges on ad hoc basis. Then the RG had requested the Government of Karnataka, to seek approval of the Governor of Karnataka. The recommendations made by the High Court were accordingly approved and the Notifications were issued in 2003-2004, in the name of the Governor of Karnataka.
16.4 The statement of objections make reference to 1983 Rules and 2004 Rules and so also to the direction 14 in paragraph 10 in judgment of the Supreme Court in Brij Mohan Lal-1 to justify the date of seniority fixed pursuant to the Full Court resolution.
16.5 While narrating the facts we have made reference to all the documents which are referred to by the RG in both the statement of objections as Annexures-R1 to R24. From bare perusal of the statement of objections and the annexures it is clear that the RG has simply stated the procedure that was followed for appointing respondent-DJs and the manner in which their appointment orders/notifications were issued. He has made reference to the decision of the Committee and the Full Court and also the correspondence made with the Government requesting to issue notifications of promotion of respondent-DJs. In short, the RG has emphasized that the due procedure was followed while granting temporary promotions as ad-hoc District Judges and hence their appointments in the cadre of District Judge in 2009 will have to be counted from the dates of their appointments as ad hoc District Judges in 2003-04.
17. The other respondents also, though filed separate statement of objections, have taken similar stand. Their focus is also on the direction No. 14 in paragraph-10 in Brij Mohan Lal-1 to contend that the date of their initial appointments as ad-hoc DJs was rightly taken into consideration for fixing seniority and the decision deserves no interference by this Court in the present writ petitions. In one of the statements of objections it is stated that the High Court never made a distinction between ad hoc District Judges and regular District Judges, and their pay-scale was also on par with the regular District Judges, which, further, it is stated, shows that though they were not promoted under Article 233 of the Constitution, they were appointed after following the due procedure and with approval of the Governor. It has also been stated that the petitioners have no locus standi to question as to when the respondents-DJs became eligible to be appointed as District Judges. In other words, it is stated that eligibility of respondents-DJs for promotion to the cadre of District Judge cannot be questioned by the petitioners as long as their number does not exceed the quota fixed for promotion as on the date of appointment of the petitioners.
18. I have, with the assistance of Learned Counsel for the parties, formulated the following question for consideration:
“whether promotions of respondents-DJs as ad hoc District Judges vide notifications dated 15-2-2003, 19-3-2003, 15-11-2003 and 20-3-2004 for being posted in the Fast Track Courts could be treated as regular promotions in the cadre of District Judge under the 1983 Rules and/or services rendered by them as ad hoc Fast Track Judges can be counted for the purpose of seniority in the cadre of District Judge from the date of the aforesaid notifications or it should be from the date on which they were promoted under the 2004 Rules vide notifications dated 1.6.2009, 27.6.2009 and 29.7.2009?”
18.1 Alongwith the aforementioned question, it would be necessary to consider peripheral issues, such as whether the procedure in force in the matter of promotion to the posts of District Judge was followed while appointing respondent-DJs, as ad-hoc DJs for the Fast Track Courts; whether their promotions as ad hoc District Judges are traceable to 1983 Rules; whether vacancies, that occurred prior to the date on which the 2004 Rules were brought into force, can be taken into consideration for giving deemed date of promotion from the dates of their promotions on ad hoc basis in 2003-04; whether or not the seniority list affects rights of the parties; and whether the respondents-DJs, who were promoted vide notification 26 June, 2009 to fill up 25% vacancies through departmental competitive examination, under the 2004 Rules would be entitled for the same benefits that could be extended to those, who were appointed under 50% quota to be filled up by promotion on the basis of seniority-cum-merit.
19. In view of a categoric stand taken by the RG that while making appointments/promotions all respondent-DJs in 2003–2004 the procedure in force as under the 1983 Rules was followed, Mr. Patil, Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners, did not raise any dispute in respect thereof. On the contrary, he made submissions on the assumption that the due procedure, adopted by the High Court as contemplated by 1983 Rules read with Articles 233 and 236 of the Constitution of India, was followed. He submitted that the procedure adopted by the High Court for promotion as District Judges was followed while promoting the respondent-DJs as presiding officers of FTCs temporarily on ad hoc basis and not as regular DJs in the light of the direction (1) & (2) in paragraph 10 of Brij Mohan Lal-1.
19.1 From the materials placed on record by the RG and the submissions advanced by Learned Senior Counsel for the parties, it is clear that the due procedure adopted by the High Court as contemplated by the 1983 Rules for temporary promotions of the Civil Judges, from amongst eligible judicial officers was scrupulously followed. The RG has placed on record the material supporting their stand to which I have made reference while narrating the facts in the earlier part of the judgment. Since no dispute in respect thereof is raised, this question need not detain me any future, and I hold that the due procedure in force was followed for appointing respondent-DJs as ad hoc DJs for FTCs. However, I would consider the question whether their appointments are traceable to the 1983 Rule little later.
20. I would now proceed to consider the principal question and the peripheral issues raised in the course of arguments. Mr. Patil, Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners submitted that under any circumstances, promotions of the respondent-DJs in 2003-2004, cannot be treated as regular promotions against vacant posts. At the relevant time, respondent-DJs, who were working as Civil Judges (Sr.Dn), were temporarily made as Presiding Officers of the FTCs and their appointment was to an ad hoc ex cadre post. In other words, the posts held by respondent-DJs were not part of sanctioned strength of the cadre of District Judge or to any sanctioned posts in service, whether permanent or otherwise. Their promotions were for to FTCs which was only a temporary arrangement. He further submitted that the appointments to the ad hoc FTCs, being outside the cadre of District Judge, the functions of the ad hoc District Judges were also limited. The mere fact that the procedure prescribed for appointment to the posts of District Judges was followed for appointing respondent-DJs as ad hoc Fast Track Judges cannot be a basis to treat their appointments as regular promotions or their promotions in the cadre of District Judge. The procedure applicable to promotion of District Judge was followed in the light of paragraph 10 (1) of Brij Mohan Lal-1. Thus, he submitted, merely because, the procedure contemplated was followed, the same cannot be the basis to claim seniority in the cadre of District Judge from the dates of their appointments in 2003-04. He submitted that the 1983 Rules do not provide for an appointment as District Judges either on temporary basis or creation of posts of District Judges on temporary basis or on ad hoc basis and in view thereof, the promotion of respondent-DJs are not traceable to the 1983 Rules. Further, he submitted, that the record shows that as on the date of ad hoc appointment there were no vacant posts and therefore, there could not have been any regular promotion. It was submitted that the contention raised on behalf of respondent-DJs that their officiating promotions have to be counted for seniority also deserves to be rejected outright. He submitted that merely because the orders of appointment are issued in the name of Governor the same will not change the complexion of appointments which are ad hoc and to temporarily created FTCs and outside the service/cadre of District Judge. Then in reply to the submissions advanced by Sri P.S Rajagopal, Learned Senior Counsel on behalf of the High Court based on Karnataka Civil Services Rules and Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977, he submitted that the term “officiate” and appointments by promotion being on “officiating basis” has no application as the said rules contemplate officiating in relation to “post in service” and not something out of service/cadre as in the present case. In support of these contentions, he placed reliance upon the following judgments of the Supreme Court: i) Brij Mohan Lal-1; ii) Brij Mohan Lal-2, iii) Debabrata Dash v. Jatindra Prasad Dash . 2013 3 SCC 658 (for short “Debabrata Dash”); iv) Mahesh Chandra Verma v. State of Jharkhand . 2012 11 SCC 656; v) State of Orissa v. Sri Jagabandhu Panda . 2013 3 SCALE 93; vi) O.P Singla v. Union of India . 1984 4 SCC 450; vii) V. Sreenivasa Reddy v. Govt. of Andhra Pradesh . 1995 Supp 1 SCC 572; viii) All India Judges Association v. Union of India (UOI) . 2002 4 SCC 247.
21. On the other hand Mr. P.S Rajagopal, Learned Senior Counsel on behalf of the High Court submitted that to fill up certain permanent posts and temporary posts, the respondent-DJs were promoted, temporarily on ad hoc basis to officiate as District Judges. All those promotions, he submitted, were regular promotions against vacant posts created temporarily and were made under the 1983 Rules. He then submitted that the promotions being on officiating basis, count for seniority, particularly, because they were continued uninterruptedly till the promotions were made permanent against permanent vacancies in 2009. Then it was contended that only for the reason that the promotions were against temporary vacancies and on ad hoc basis cannot be the reason not to treat them for regular promotion. In other words, he submitted that merely because words “temporarily” and “ad hoc” were used in the notifications, the substance of appointments cannot be overlooked in the light of the 1983 Rules. In support, he placed reliance upon Rule 19 of the Karnataka Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977 and Rule 8 (31) of the Karnataka Civil Services Rules, 1958, which defines the expression “officiating”. He also invited my attention to the resolutions passed by the Administrative Committee No. II and the Full Court and submitted that it clearly demonstrate that the respondent-DJs were fit and suitable to be promoted temporarily as ad hoc District Judges on officiating basis. Then he invited my attention to the definition of “cadre” as defined by Rule 9 (7) of the Karnataka Civil Service Rules and submitted that the promotion order should be read in the light of these rules and if so read, it is clear that was a regular officiating promotion on the temporary vacancies subject to reversion at any time. He submitted that words “temporary” and “ad hoc” and the expression “subject to reversion at any time” would not mean that the promotions in 2003–04 cannot be treated as regular promotion since those posts were continued until their regular promotions were made in 2009. Lastly, he submitted that it is true that the posts against which their promotion orders issued were temporary/officiating promotions and were to lasts until subsistence of the temporary vacancies, and when such temporary vacancies cease to be available, entailing reversion of such promotees, but then the temporary vacancies against which promotions of the respondent-D Js were made subsisted until the permanent vacancies arose and in view thereof their seniority will have to be continued from the dates of their appointments in 2003-2004. In support of the contentions urged on behalf of the High Court, Mr. Rajagopal, Learned Senior Counsel placed heavy reliance upon the following judgments: (i) Direct Recruit Class Ii Engineering Officers' Association v. State of Maharashtra . 1990 2 SCC 715; (ii) L. Chandra Kishore Singh v. State of Manipur . 1999 8 SCC 287; (iii) Ajit Kumar Rath v. State of Orissa . 1999 9 SCC 596; (iv) O.P Garg v. State of U.R . 1991 Supp 2 SCC 51; (v) Rudra Kumar Sain v. Union of India . 2000 8 SCC 25; (vi) B.S Mathur v. Union of India . 2008 AIR SCW 7042, (vii) G.K Dudani v. S.D Sharma . 1986 Supp SCC 239. He also placed reliance upon some of the judgments relied upon by Mr. Patil, Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners, in support of his contentions.
22. Before I advert to the diverse submissions advanced on behalf of the parties, it would be advantageous to refer to the judgments of the Supreme Court in Brij Mohan Lal-1, Brij Mohan Lal-2 and Debabrata Dash. Not only in the course of arguments by Learned Counsel for the parties, but even in the decision making process, the Committee and the Full Court placed heavy reliance upon the first two judgments. Some other judgments were also referred to and relied upon by Learned Counsel for the parties in support of their submissions to which I would make reference at appropriate stage.
22.1 Mr. Patil, Learned Senior Advocate for the petitioners at the outset submitted that the Committee as well as the Full Court committed a grave error of law in fixing the seniority based on the direction 1 and 14 in paragraph-10 of Brij Mohan Lal-1. He submitted, this judgment was considered by the Supreme Court in Debabrata Dash and direction 14 in paragraph-10 in particular to hold that until the vacancy occurred in the cadre of superior judicial service (senior branch) which was to be filled up by promotion, the service rendered by the petitioners-promotee therein in the Fast Track Court cannot be deemed to be service rendered in the superior judicial service, senior branch. In our case it is District Judge. He submitted that, until then, the promotees continue to be member of the parent cadre, that is, Senior Judge (Sr.Dn) in our case. He submitted that it clearly shows that direction-14 was not understood correctly and was wrongly interpreted to hold that respondents-DJs are entitled for deemed date of promotion from the dates on which they were appointed as ad hoc District Judges in 2003 and 2004.
22.2 On the other hand, Mr. P.S Rajagopal, Learned Senior Advocate on behalf of High Court, based on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Debabrata Dash, submitted that even if the deemed seniority is given to the respondents-DJs, from the dates on which the vacancies in the cadre of DJ occurred that would not change the seniority fixed by way of impugned notification. He submitted that even before the petitioners were appointed as DJs, under 25% quota of direct recruits, there were sufficient number of vacancies in the cadre of District Judges in 50% quota for promotions and 25% quota for accelerated promotions. He therefore submitted, under any circumstances, based on the judgment of Debabrata Dash, this Court need not interfere with the impugned notification. He also submitted that in fact the judgment in Debabrata Dash, has no application to the facts of the present case.
23. In Brij Mohan Lal-1, the Supreme Court was dealing with a case related to the establishment and functioning of Courts described as Fast Track Courts (“FTCs”). Challenge was made to the FTCs scheme in various High Courts, primarily on the ground that there was no constitutional sanction for employment of retired Judges and that effective guidelines were not in operation. Several deficiencies were pointed out and a plea was made that instead of retired officers, eligible members of the Bar should be considered for the appointment. The stand of the Union of India was that there was no mandatory requirement for appointment of retired Sessions/Addl. Sessions Judge or other officers and that ad hoc promotion of judicial officers would meet the objective of the scheme. It was pointed out that consequential vacancies created on account of ad hoc promotions can be filled by a special drive so that there is no shortfall in the personnel of lower Courts. The Supreme Court considered its several judgments including All India Judges Association v. Union of India . 2002 AIR SCW 1706; All India Judges Association v. Union of India . 1992 1 SCC 119; and All India Judges Association v. Union of India . 1993 4 SCC 288.
23.1 The Supreme Court held that there was nothing constitutionally improper in the scheme. It was further observed that High Court has to play a pivotal role in implementation of the scheme for its effective implementation and achievements of the objectives of the scheme, of course, complying with the constitutional requirements embodied in the relevant provisions of Chapter-VI of the Constitution. The Supreme Court, then, in paragraph-10 of the report, proceeded to issue directions, keeping in view the laudable objective with which the FTCs scheme had been conceived and introduced, to take care of initial teething problems highlighted by the parties. The relevant directions for our purpose find place in sub-paras-1 and 14 in paragraph 10 of the report, which read thus:
“1. The first preference for appointment of judges of the Fast Track Courts is to be given by ad-hoc promotions from amongst eligible judicial officers. While giving such promotion the High Court shall follow the procedures in force in the matter of promotion to such posts in Superior/Higher Judicial Services.
14. No right will be conferred on Judicial Officers in service for claiming any regular promotion on the basis of his/her appointment on ad-hoc basis under the Scheme. The service rendered in Fast Track Courts will be deemed as service rendered in the parent cadre. In case any Judicial Officer is promoted to higher grade in the parent cadre during his tenure in Fast Track Courts, the service rendered in Fast Track Courts will be deemed to be service in such higher grade.”
(emphasis supplied)
24. Then the Supreme Court again in Brij Mohan Lal-2, dealt with the writ petitions filed under Article 32 of the Constitution and some Special Leave Petitions, filed against various judgments of different High Courts, with respect to the scheme and policy of appointment of ad hoc Judges of FTCs and for directions to the respondents to extend the FTC scheme for another five years or even till 31-3-2015 and to release necessary funds for that purpose. The Supreme Court considered the contention urged in those writ petitions that the constitutional scheme contained under Articles 233 and 235 read with Articles 309 and 310 of the Constitution of India does not contemplate and permit appointment of retired Judges as ad hoc District and Sessions Judges. The Supreme Court also considered the submission that there is no constitutional provision which empowers the authorities concerned to make such appointments and observed that the purpose of those objectives obviously was to ensure that only the members of bar were appointed by direct recruitment to the post of ad hoc District and Sessions Judges. Then the Supreme Court after considering the direction issued in Brij Mohan Lal-1 as reflected in paragraph-10 thereof, in paragraphs-6 and 7, to the extent it is necessary for our purpose, observed thus:
“6. As is evident from the above directions in Brij Mohan Lal-1, the appointments to FTCs were to be made on adhoc basis………………
7. This Court had foreseen the possibility of the closure of the Fast Track Courts Scheme (FTC Scheme). It directed that the service in FTCs will be deemed as service of the promoted judicial officers rendered in the parent cadre. However, no right would accrue to such recruits promoted/posted on ad hoc basis from the lower judiciary for regular promotion on the basis of such appointment……………”
(emphasis supplied)
24.1 Then, in paragraph 176 of the Report, the Supreme Court noted that while appointing Fast Track Court Judges, it was clearly stipulated that such appointments would be ad-hoc and temporary and that the appointees shall not derive any benefit from such appointments.
25. From perusal of the judgments of the Supreme Court in Brij Mohan Lal-1 and Brij Mohan Lal-2, it is clear that though the Supreme Court exhaustively dealt with the FTC Scheme and issued useful guidelines, related questions did not have an occasion to address the question/issue of seniority, as has been raised in these petitions, between the direct recruits and ad hoc promotees. The observations made by the Supreme Court, and the guidelines/directions issued therein, however, would definitely guide/help us to resolve the question raised in these petitions.
contd………..
Alert