Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gopinath Alias Gopinath v. The Superintendent Of Police, Karnataka Lokayukta Bijapur And Another

Karnataka High Court
Dec 6, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner moved this Court seeking quashment of the First Information Report filed by the Lokayukta Police in Crime No. 8 of 2013 dated 25-9-2013 under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, before the District and Sessions Judge, Bijapur. The petitioner served as Project Manager of Nirmithi Kendra, Bijapur, a body registered under the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960, described in the record as a private society governed by its own governing body and bye-laws. The Court heard learned counsel for the petitioner and counsel for the Lokayukta. Annexures before the Court include a letter from the State Housing Department and bye-laws of the society; the petitioner contends no government funds were received and that he is not a public servant.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner falls within the definition of "public servant" under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (notably Section 2(c) and Section 2(c)(xii)), and/or within Section 2(12) of the Karnataka Lokayukta Act, 1984.
  2. Whether the Lokayukta Police had jurisdiction to file the complaint/FIR under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 against the petitioner.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner is Project Manager of a private society (Nirmithi Kendra) registered under the Societies Registration Act and not a government or public servant within Section 2(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act or Section 2(12) of the Lokayukta Act.
  • The society has not received financial assistance from the State or Central Government; its governance, appointment terms and service conditions are internal; hence provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act do not apply to the petitioner.
  • The complaint and initiation of proceedings by the Lokayukta are without jurisdiction, an abuse of process and defamatory.

Lokayukta's Arguments

  • Relying on Section 2(c)(xii) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, the Lokayukta contended the petitioner is an office-bearer of an institution which is receiving or has received financial assistance from the State or Central Government and therefore falls within the Act.
  • The Lokayukta relied on the decision in State of Punjab v. Karnail Singh (AIR 2009 SC 372) as addressing similar issues where a cooperative institution established by Government was implicated.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Punjab v. Karnail Singh, AIR 2009 SC 372 Cited by Lokayukta to support initiation of action where an institution (Co-operative Agricultural Development Bank Limited) established by Government was treated as within scope for reconsideration. The Court recorded the Lokayukta's reliance on this decision but found facts here distinguishable because there was no prima facie material that Nirmithi Kendra had received government funds; thus Karnail Singh did not justify jurisdiction in this case.
State of Maharashtra v. Laljit Rajshi Shah, (2000) 2 SCC 699 : AIR 2000 SC 937 Discussed the status of office-bearers under the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act and their classification as public servants for certain purposes but not for prosecution under Section 21 IPC or Section 161 of the Co-operative Societies Act. The Court noted the petitioner's reliance on this decision to show limitations on treating society office-bearers as public servants; the decision was treated as persuasive authority on distinctions of statutory classifications.
M.A. Parthasarathy v. The Special Deputy Commissioner, Bangalore District, Bangalore, 2009 KAR 1940 : 2009 (3) KCCR SN 139 Held that Lokayukta/Upa-Lokayukta investigations are confined to complaints against "public servants" as defined under Section 2(12) of the Lokayukta Act; a report is a condition precedent only when allegations are substantiated against public servants. The Court applied this principle to conclude that Lokayukta has no jurisdiction where the person complained against does not fall within the statutory definition of "public servant"; absence of prima facie material that petitioner fell within Section 2(12) led to quashing of proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the nature and governance of Nirmithi Kendra (a society registered under the Societies Registration Act) and the factual record regarding receipt of government funds. The Lokayukta relied on Section 2(c)(xii) of the Prevention of Corruption Act and an analogous Supreme Court decision, but the Court found no prima facie material showing the society had received financial assistance from the State or Central Government. Although the bye-laws provided for the possibility of receiving such funds, the record did not demonstrate any actual receipt or misuse of governmental funds. The Court applied the principle from M.A. Parthasarathy that Lokayukta jurisdiction is restricted to complaints against persons falling within the statutory definition of "public servant" (Section 2(12) of the Lokayukta Act). Concluding there was no material to demonstrate the petitioner fell within that definition, the Court held the Lokayukta had no jurisdiction to initiate the present proceedings; it characterized the filing of the complaint as an abuse/misuse of power. The Court observed that any question about disproportionate assets could be pursued by another competent authority.

Holding and Implications

Petition allowed; the entire proceedings are quashed.

Consequences: The FIR and subsequent proceedings in Crime No. 8 of 2013 under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act are quashed for want of jurisdiction, as the petitioner was not shown prima facie to be a "public servant" within the relevant statutory definitions. The opinion does not announce any broader precedent beyond the application of existing definitions and authorities; its direct effect is to terminate the proceedings against the petitioner.

Show all summary ...

Huluvadi G. Ramesh, J.:— Petitioner is before this Court seeking to quash the First Information Report filed by the Lokayukta Police in Crime No. 8 of 2013 on 25-9-2013 under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 before the District and Sessions Judge, Bijapur.

2. Heard the learned Counsel for the petitioner and the Counsel representing the Lokayukta.

3. It appears that petitioner has been serving as Project Manager of Nirmithi Kendra, Bijapur, which is said to be a private society and unconnected with Government activities. The objects of Nirmithi Kendra are to develop skills in construction area may it be private or public as assigned by way of Civil contract. The Kendra is governed by its governing body duly constituted as per rules and regulations framed there under. The entire control, administration and management is solely governed by the Government (sic governing) body of the Nirmithi Kendra Association. The terms of appointment and service conditions are within the memorandum of Association. It is submitted that from the source of information, respondent has initiated a case against the petitioner.

4. It is the contention of the petitioner that even an IAS Officer deputed to a Co-operative Society drawing his salary from Society cannot be a public servant and the provisions of Prevention of Corruption Act, does not apply. The petitioner is not a public servant within the meaning of Section 2(c) of Prevention of Corruption Act. The petitioner falls totally outside the definition of public servant and jurisdiction of Lokayukta Police and there is no scope and also looking into the body of the six bye-laws framed, though it is a private sector, it has to receive funds from the State Government or Central Government, no such fund has been received by the society for which the petitioner is the Project Manager. Only on the ground that the petitioner is a Project Manager, a case is registered against him.

5. The letter at Annexure-Cl from the Housing Department of the State Government addressed to the President of the Nirmithi Kendra clearly mentions that as per the Rule 20 — appointment by deputation, the Nirmithi Kendra is registered under the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960, it is not a Government Department and also petitioner cannot be called as Government servant. Accordingly, it is contended that a false case has been initiated against the petitioner by the Lokayukta by filing a complaint before the Lokayukta Police, Bijapur, alleging violation of Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Hence, this petition.

6. Various Annexures produced by the petitioner do depict that except the Society is registered under the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, petitioner cannot be said to be a public servant or Government servant as such, according to the petitioner, filing of the complaint and initiation of action against petitioner is without jurisdiction and also in violation of the provisions of the Karnataka Lokayukta Act, 1984 as well as Prevention of Corruption Act and the power exercised by the respondent by filing a complaint is nothing but abuse of process of law and also defamatory.

7. The learned Counsel for the Lokayukta referring to Section 2(c)(xii) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 which read.—

“2. (c)(xii) Any person who is an office-bearer or an employee of an educational, scientific, social, cultural or other institution, in whatever manner established, receiving or having received any financial assistance from the Central Government or any State Government, or local or other public authority”.

8. Submitted that petitioner is an office bearer of Nirmithi Kendra which is receiving or having received any financial assistance from the State Government or Central Government, as such any violation forms the basis to initiate action against the petitioner under the provisions of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The learned Counsel also relied upon the decision in the case of State of Punjab v. Karnail Singh, AIR 2009 SC 372 wherein the Apex Court was dealing with similar case of Co-operative Agricultural Development Bank Limited, that was established by the Government and the appeal filed by the State was allowed and matter was remitted for reconsideration.

9. The submission of the learned Counsel for the petitioner is that neither the Society has received the funds from the State Government or Central Government nor appointments are made by the Government and is having no character of any authority or local authority under the State. The filing of the complaint and initiation of proceedings against the petitioner is nonest in the eye of the law and is nothing but abuse of process of laws.

10. The petitioner is said to be the Project Manager of an institution which undertakes contracts taking no assistance of the State Government or Central Government. Accordingly, it is submitted the institution has no character of the Government or Governmental body. It is also submitted, there is a provision made to receive the amount from both the State Government or Central Government however, no such amount is received so far nor any financial assistance is extended to the Project Manager i.e, Nirmithi Kendra.

11. The learned Counsel for the petitioner also relied upon the judgment in the case of State of Maharashtra v. Laljit Rajshi Shah, (2000) 2 SCC 699 : AIR 2000 SC 937 wherein referring to Section 2 of the Mharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 and also Section 21 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 as regards a ‘Public Servant’ the Apex Court has held that the Chairman of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, though, a public servant under Societies Act but not so, under Section 21 of Indian Penal Code and he cannot be prosecuted for offences under the India Penal Code and he cannot be prosecuted for the offence under Section 161 of the Co operative Societies Act. The learned Counsel also relied upon the judgment of this Court in the case of M.A Parthasarathy v. The Special Deputy Commissioner, Bangalore District, Bangalore, 2009 KAR 1940 : (2009 (3) KCCR SN 139) wherein it held that as per Scheme of the Karnataka Lokayukta Act, 1984. The condition precedent for submitting the said report is, only when the allegation is substantiated either wholly or partly against public servants so that follow up action may be taken against them by the Government. As per Section. 7 of the Lokayukta Act, the investigation to be conducted by the Lokayukta and Upa-Lokayukta is in respect of a complaint against a public servant only. The words ‘public servant’ has been defined under Section 2(12) of the Lokayukta Act.

12. The question in this case is with respect to the petitioner who is a Project Manager of Nirmithi Kendra which is neither enunciated by the State Government or Central Government, except a Society registered under the Societies Registration Act and the case of the petitioner does not fall within the definition of Section 2(12) of Lokayukta Act, so as to initiate action under Section 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. In the above cited decision of the High Court, it is specifically held that Lokayukta or Upa-Lokayukta have no jurisdiction to entertain a complaint against the person who does not come within the definition of a public servant as defined under the Act. This makes it clear that except a provision that has been made in the bye-laws of Nirmithi Kendra to receive the funds etc., by the State Government or Central Government, in the absence of any such fund being received from the State Government or Central Government and without there being any misuse of power or misuse of the amount so available with the society, there was no scope for the Investigation Officer to file a complaint to the Lokayukta and the said complaint even if it filed, is non est.

13. In view of the fact that there is no prima facie material made out by the complainant to demonstrate that the petitioner falls within the definition of Section 2(12) of the Lokayukta Act, the question whether the petitioner has got assets disproportionate to known source of income or not could be taken note of by some other authority. The very fact of filing a complaint against the petitioner is nothing but abuse of power and misuse of power by the complainant.

14. Petition is allowed. The entire proceedings are quashed.