Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ms M C I Leasing (P) Ltd v. Commissioner Of Central Excise

Karnataka High Court
Sep 22, 2011

N. Kumar, J.

1. The assessee has preferred this appeal challenging the order passed by the Tribunal [ 2009 (14) S.T.R. 54 (Tri.-Bang.)] which has held that a refund claim beyond the statutory time limit cannot be granted and it is barred by time. The assessee is a Private Limited Company registered under the category of Banking and Financial Services. They are engaged in providing loans to customers. They are registered under the Finance Act, by time. Therefore, he directed recovery of the balance amount sanctioned as it was already paid to the assessee.

2. Aggrieved by the said order the assessee preferred an appeal to the Tribunal. The Tribunal confirmed the said order and dismissed the appeal. Aggrieved by the same, the assessee has preferred this appeal.

3. The learned counsel appearing for the assessee assailing the impugned order contended that admittedly the assessee was not liable to pay Service Tax under the Act. By mistake the said amount is paid. Therefore the amount paid and the amount claimed as refund is not an amount which falls within the Finance Act, 1994. It is only in respect of amounts which are paid under the Act, the amounts which are due under the Act, the period of limitation prescribed under Section 11B is attracted and therefore he submits that the authorities were not justified in holding that the claim for refund beyond the period of 1994 as service providers. The assessee paid Service Tax on the interest collected from customers based on the self-assessment made by them. Subsequently they realised that the interest charged on loans and advances are not liable for payment of Service Tax. Therefore they preferred a claim Petition on 1-12-2004 under Section 11B read with Section 83 of the Finance Act, 1994. In the said claim Petition they claimed refund of tax paid by them for the period July, 2001 to August, 2004. The adjudicating authority after considering the entire material on record passed an order on 25-4-2005 allowing the claim of the assessee in its entirety. The Commissioner of Central Excise in pursuance of the power conferred on him under Section 83 of the Finance Act, 1994 initiated suo motu proceedings to revise the said order passed by the adjudicating authority. After hearing the assessee he held that only a sum of Rs. 92,006/- is leviable out of Rs. 2,31,658/- as the balance amount was clearly barred one year was barred by time. In respect of his contentions she relied on the Judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Writ Appeal Nos. 2992-93/2009 [ 2012 (26) S.T.R. 195 (Kar.)] where this Court has held that if the amount due claimed as refund did not fall within the act, the provisions of section 11b are not attracted. This general law of limitation is applicable and therefore the claim beyond one year is not barred by time. The party has a right to choose the Forum. On the ground that in the guise of choosing a Forum he chooses a wrong Forum he cannot be denied the relief. That is the order passed in the Writ Appeal directing refund of tax on his net proceeds arising under the Finance Act or the Central Excise Act, 1944. If the amount paid is not within the Act, the Act is not applicable. So any amount paid outside the Act could be recovered under the General law either by filing a suit or by filing a writ petition. There is no quarrel with the said legal position. In the instant case, the assessee has registered itself as a service provider under the Act. The tax paid by the assessee is under the Act. Infact it is not a tax which is levied, it is a tax which is due under the Act. As understood by the assessee and paid voluntarily it is not any tax paid under protest. Later, the assessee realized that he is not liable to pay tax and therefore he has claimed refund. Therefore it cannot be said that it is an admission made outside the provisions of the Act. That is precisely the reason why Section 11B was invoked and an application for refund is filed. Once the party chooses the Forum and infact as in this case succeeds in getting refund of the entire amount, the revisional authority in exercise of the power conferred on them exercises its jurisdiction and interferes with the order interpreting Section 11B. It cannot be disputed that if the amount of tax paid is not under protest and any payment made under the Act if refund is sought it has to be done within one year from the date of such payment. When once the period of limitation is prescribed under the Act the provisions of the General Law stand excluded. If the application is not filed within the time stipulated the claim would be time barred. Infact, the Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in the case of Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India [ 1997 (89) E.L.T. 247 (S.C.)] had an occasion to go into this question and they have in categorical terms laid down the law on the point.

ii. Where, however, a refund is claimed on the ground that the provision of the Act under which it was levied is or has been held to be unconstitutional, such a claim, being a claim outside the purview of the enactment, can be made either by way of a suit or by way of a writ petition. This principle is, however, subject to an exception : where a person approaches the High Court or Supreme Court challenging the constitutional validity of a provision but fails, he cannot take advantage of the declaration of unconstitutionality obtained by another person on another ground; this is for the reason that so far as he is concerned, the decision has become final and cannot be re-opened on the basis of a decision on another person's case; this is the ratio of the opinion of Hidayatullah, C.J. In Tilokchand Motichand and we respectfully agree with it.

Such a claim is maintainable both by virtue of the declaration contained in Article 265 of the Constitution of India and also by virtue of Section 72 of the Contract Act. In such cases, period of limitation would naturally be calculated taking into account the principle underlying Clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 17 of the Limitation Act, 1963. A refund claim in such a situation cannot be governed by the provisions of the Central Excise and Salt Act or the Customs Act, as the case may be, since the enactments do not contemplate any of their provisions being struck down and a refund claim arising on that account. In other words, a claim of this nature is not contemplated by the said enactments and is outside their purview.

4. It has been held that all refund claims except those mentioned under Proposition (ii) below have to be and must be filed and adjudicated under the provisions of the Central Excise Act or the Customs Act, as the case may be. It is necessary, to emphasise in this behalf that the Act provides for a complete mechanism for correcting any errors whether of fact or law and that not only an appeal is provided to a Tribunal - which is not a departmental organ - but to this Court, which is a Civil Court. The proposition referred to by them reads as under:-

ii. Where, however, a refund is claimed on the ground that the provision of the Act under which it was levied is or has been held to be unconstitutional, such a claim, being a claim outside the purview of the enactment, can be made either by way of a suit or by way of a writ petition. This principle is, however, subject to an exception : where a person approaches the High Court or Supreme Court challenging the constitutional validity of a provision but fails, he cannot take advantage of the declaration of unconstitutionality obtained by another person on another ground; this is for the reason that so far as he is concerned, the decision has become final and cannot be re-opened on the basis of a decision on another person's case; this is the ratio of the opinion of Hidayatullah, C.J. In Tilokchand Motichand and we respectfully agree with it.

Such a claim is maintainable both by virtue of the declaration contained in Article 265 of the Constitution of India and also by virtue of Section 11 of the Contract Act. In such cases, period of limitation would naturally be calculated taking into account the principle underlying Clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 17 of the Limitation Act, 1963. A refund claim in such a situation cannot be governed by the provisions of the Central Excise and Salt Act or the Customs Act, as the case may be, since the enactments do not contemplate any of their provisions being struck down and a refund claim arising on that account. In other words, a claim of this nature is not contemplated by the said enactments and is outside their purview.

The facts of the case do not fall under the proposition and therefore as is clear from the aforesaid Judgment when the Act provides a complete mechanism for correcting any errors whether on fact or on law the burden is to work out his remedy within four corners of law. If the remedy is to be worked out within the four corners of law the party has accepted invoking the jurisdiction of the authority to refund within the period prescribed under the Act. In that view of the matter, we do not find any merit in this appeal. The order passed by the Tribunal is strictly in accordance with law and the law declared by the Apex Court. There is no merit in this appeal. Accordingly it is dismissed.