- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
G. Sangappa v. State Of Karnataka
Factual and Procedural Background
WP No. 36337/2010 and WP Nos. 36548-36549/2010 were clubbed and heard together. The petitions challenge the reservation of the Anagodu constituency in Davanagere Zilla Panchayat as reserved for Scheduled Tribe-Woman (ST(W)). The petitioners produced a historical record of reservations for the Anagodu constituency showing:
Year — Reservation
1995 — Scheduled Caste
2000 — Scheduled Tribes
2005 — Scheduled Caste
2010 — Scheduled Tribe (Woman)
Petitioners alleged that the State Election Commission (SEC) repeatedly alternated the constituency only between SC and ST categories to the exclusion of other categories and thereby violated the rotational principle. The SEC defended its allotment practice as being in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions and rules.
The court noted that questions about the validity of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Reservation of Seats in Taluk Panchayats and Zilla Panchayats by Rotation) Rules, 1998 and the interpretation of Article 243-D(1) were the subject matter of a pending Civil Appeal (No. 4523/05) in the Supreme Court and therefore declined to decide those issues. The court proceeded to decide the petitions by reference to Section 162 of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the allotment of reservation to the Anagodu constituency (alternating chiefly between SC and ST categories) violated the rotation principle prescribed by the proviso to Section 162(3) of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993.
- Whether the court should address the validity of the Karnataka Rules, 1998 and the interpretation of the word "may" in Article 243-D(1) of the Constitution (these issues were raised but the court refrained from deciding them because they were sub judice before the Supreme Court).
- What remedial action, if any, should the State Election Commission be directed to take in respect of the impugned notification reserving the Anagodu constituency for ST(W).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments (represented by Sri Ravivarma Kumar and Sri S.S. Koti)
- The Anagodu constituency has been reserved only for SC or ST for the last 20 years (four terms), with the pattern shown in the petitioner's table (1995 SC; 2000 ST; 2005 SC; 2010 ST(W)).
- The reservation practice is interchanging only between SC and ST categories, excluding other categories (BCA, BCA(W), BCB, BCB(W), G, G(W)), which they contend violates the statutory principle of rotation.
- The word "may" in Article 243-D(1) should be treated as mandatory ("shall") so as to enforce rotation (submission advanced by Senior Counsel for the petitioner in WP No. 36337/2010).
- Example offered to demonstrate non-adherence to rotation: Hadadi constituency in Davanagere Taluk was reserved for G(W) in 2005 and again in 2010; the petitioners say premature repetition is unjustified unless the full cycle of categories is exhausted.
- Submission that SC/ST population in Bilichodu suggests that constituency should be allotted for SC/ST reservation category.
Respondent (State Election Commission) Arguments (represented by Sri K.N. Phanindra)
- The SEC had allotted reservations strictly in accordance with the law, relying on Rule 3 of the 1998 Rules and the proviso to Rule 3(4), which discourage repetition of a category in successive terms.
- Out of 34 constituencies in Davanagere Zilla Panchayat, 7 were reserved for SC and 5 for ST; the allotment process followed legal requirements and care was taken to avoid repeating categories across the relevant terms.
- Bilichodu is located in a different Taluk (Jagalur Taluk), and therefore comparisons with constituencies in other Taluks are not directly applicable for the point made by petitioners.
- There is a prior Division Bench order (H.C. Yatheesh Kumar v. The Karnataka Election Commission, ILR 2005 KAR 3323) that set aside the 1998 Rules as ultra vires, but that order is stayed by the Supreme Court on Civil Appeal No. 4523/05; the SEC has appealed and the stay remains in force.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| H.C. Yatheesh Kumar v. The Karnataka Election Commission, ILR 2005 KAR 3323; Civil Appeal No. 4523/05 (Supreme Court) | The Division Bench set aside the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Reservation of Seats in Taluk Panchayats and Zilla Panchayats by Rotation) Rules, 1998 as ultra vires and void; the State Election Commission appealed to the Supreme Court which granted leave and stayed that Division Bench order. | The court noted this precedent and the pending Civil Appeal with an interim stay. Because of the stay and ongoing appeal, the court declined to decide issues regarding the validity of the 1998 Rules or the interpretation of Article 243-D(1) and instead proceeded to decide the petitions on the basis of Section 162 of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first identified that it would not resolve questions about the validity of the 1998 Rules or the interpretation of Article 243-D(1) because those matters were pending before the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 4523/05; a stay had been granted by the Supreme Court. Accordingly, the court confined its decision to the statutory provisions in Section 162 of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993.
The court examined the wording of the first proviso to Section 162(3), which prescribes that seats reserved under subsections (1), (2) and (3) shall be allotted by rotation to different constituencies in the district. Because the statute did not define the term "rotation," the court considered the ordinary, dictionary meanings of the word from neutral sources (Bloomsbury English Dictionary; Collins English Dictionary; Random House Webster's College Dictionary). The dictionaries consistently indicated that "rotation" denotes a regular cycle, a set order or sequence, or a regularly recurring succession.
Applying this ordinary meaning to the statutory context, the court reasoned that the proviso reflects a distributive legislative strategy: reserved seats are to be spread across different constituencies and categories rather than concentrated or repeatedly assigned in a narrow interchange between two categories. The court observed there are nine reservation categories (SC, ST, BCA, BCB, SC(W), ST(W), BCA(W), BCB(W), G(W)) plus the tenth category of non-reserved General seats, and that rotation must be understood so as to give effect to distribution across these categories and constituencies.
The court found that permitting a constituency to alternate repeatedly only between SC and ST categories would defeat the distributive intent in two respects: (a) it would perpetually deprive members of other categories of representational opportunity in that constituency; and (b) it would deprive SC/ST persons in other Zilla Panchayat constituencies of the benefit of reservation. On this basis the court concluded the SEC's practice of repeatedly and alternatively reserving the Anagodu constituency for SC, ST and ST(W) was unsupportable and not in keeping with the rotational principle under Section 162(3).
The court therefore quashed that part of the impugned notification which reserved Anagodu for ST(W), while expressly leaving intact the rest of the notification insofar as it related to other constituencies in Davanagere Zilla Panchayat. The court directed the SEC to issue a modified notification reserving Anagodu for one of the listed alternative categories or to open it to the General category, and allowed the SEC to make consequential changes in other constituencies as necessary.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court quashed that part of the impugned notification reserving the Anagodu constituency for Scheduled Tribe-Woman (ST(W)) and directed the State Election Commission to issue a modified notification reserving the constituency for any one of the following categories: BCA, BCB, BCA(W), BCB(W), G(W), or alternatively to throw the seat open to the General category. The petitions were allowed to that extent. The petitioner's standalone prayer to reserve the constituency in favour of the General category was rejected as not grantable (and later noted as not pressed).
Consequences for the parties:
- The specific reservation of Anagodu for ST(W) in the impugned notification is set aside.
- The State Election Commission is directed to issue a modified notification selecting one of the listed categories (or opening the seat to General), and may make consequential adjustments in other constituencies in Davanagere Taluk.
- The petition for reservation specifically in favour of the General category was refused; one petitioner (D. Nagaraj) later indicated he was not pressing that relief.
- No order as to costs was made.
Broader legal implications: The court expressly declined to decide the broader questions relating to the validity of the 1998 Rules or the interpretation of Article 243-D(1) because those matters were pending before the Supreme Court; accordingly, the decision is limited to the specific statutory interpretation and relief under Section 162 of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act. The opinion does not purport to create a new precedent on the validity of the Rules or the constitutional provision.
ORDER
WP No. 36337/2010 and WP Nos. 36548-36549/2010 are clubbed, heard together and are being disposed of by this common order, as the subject matter of both the petitions is the grievance over reserving the Anagodu constituency in Davanagere Zilla Panchayat for Scheduled Tribe-Woman [ST(W)].
2. Sri Ravivarma Kumar, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for Sri D. Nagaraj for the petitioner in WP No. 36337/2010 submits that the constituency in question is always reserved either for Scheduled Caste (SC) or Scheduled Tribe (ST) for the last 20 years (4 terms). The particulars of the reservation in the said constituency are put in the tabular form hereinbelow:
YearReservation1995Scheduled Caste2000Scheduled Tribes2005Scheduled Caste2010Scheduled Tribe (Woman)
3. It is the grievance of the petitioners that the reservation is being interchanged only between SC and ST categories to the exclusion of the other categories - Backward Class-A (BCA), Backward Class-A-Woman [BCA(W)], Backward Class-B (BCB), Backward Class-B-Woman [BCB(W)], General (G) and General Woman [G(W)]. The petitioners' side would therefore complain of the violation of the rotation principal.
4. Sri Ravivarma Kumar brings to my notice the provisions contained in Article 243-D(1) of the Constitution of India. The said provision is extracted hereinbelow:
“243-D. Reservation of seats.- (1) Seats shall be reserved for-
(a) the Scheduled Castes; and
(b) the Scheduled Tribes,
in every Panchayat and the number of seats so reserved shall bear, as nearly as may be, the same proportion to the total number of seats to be filed by direct election in that Panchayat as the population of the Scheduled Castes in that Panchayat area or of the Scheduled Tribes in that Panchayat area bears to the total population of that area and such seats may be allotted by rotation to different constituencies in a Panchayat.”
5. The learned Senior Counsel submits that, thus the constitutional scheme for the Panchayat Raj institutions is that the reserved seats are to be allotted by rotation to different constituencies in a Panchayat. He requests that the word ‘may’ used in the last part of the afore-extracted Article be treated as ‘shall’.
6. Nextly, he brings to my notice the provisions contained in S. 162(1), (2) and (3) of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 (‘the said Act’ for short). The said provisions are extracted hereinbelow:
“162. Reservation of Seats.- (1) Seats shall be reserved by the State Election Commission in the Zilla Panchayat-
(a) for Scheduled Castes; and
(b) for the Scheduled Tribes;
and number of seats so reserved shall bear, as nearly as may be, the same proportion to the total number of seats to be filled by direct election in the Zilla Panchayat as the population of the Scheduled Castes in the district or of the Scheduled Tribes in the district bears to the total population of the district:
Provided that at least one seat each shall be reserved in a Zilla Panchayat for the persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled tribes.
(2) Such number of seats which shall, as nearly as may be one third of the total number of seats in a Zilla Panchayat shall be reserved by the State Election Commission for persons belonging to the Backward Classes.
Provided that out of the seats reserved under this sub-section, eighty per cent of the total number of such seats shall be reserved by the State Election Commission for the persons falling under category ‘A’ and the remaining twenty per cent of the seats shall be reserved by the State Election commission for the persons falling under category ‘B’.
(3) Not less than one third of the seats reserved for each category of persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes and those of the non-reserved seats in the Zilla Panchayat shall be reserved by the State Election Commission for women:
Provided that the seats reserved under sub-sections (1), (2) and (3) shall be allotted by rotation to different constituencies in the district:
Provided further that nothing contained in this section shall be deemed to prevent the persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes or Backward Classes or women for whom seats have been reserved in a Zilla Panchayat from standing for election to the non-reserved seats in such Zilla Panchayat.”
7. The learned Senior Counsel submits that the reservation provided for SC, ST, BCA, BCB, and the unreserved (general category) and for the woman belonging to the said categories are to be allotted by rotation to different constituencies in a district.
8. Nextly, he brings to my notice Rule 3 of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Reservation of seats in Taluk Panchayats and Zilla Panchayats by Rotation) Rules, 1998 (‘the said Rules’ for short).
“3. Reservation of seats in Taluk Panchayats and Zilla Panchayats by rotation.- (1)(a) Out of the seats reserved for the persons belonging to the Scheduled Tribes in a Zilla Panchayat the State Government shall allot by rotation one seat each to the Taluks to the District giving precedence to the taluks having larger population of Scheduled Tribes:
Provided that where the number of seats reserved for the persons belonging to the Scheduled Tribes exceeds the number of taluks in the district, the seats remaining after allocation under this clause shall again be allotted to taluks giving precedence to those having larger population of Scheduled Tribes:
Provided further that while allotting such seats to the constituencies within a taluk precedence shall be give to the constituencies having larger population of Scheduled Tribes.
(b) The seats reserved for persons belonging to the Scheduled Tribes in a Taluk Panchayat shall be allotted by the Deputy Commissioner by rotation to the constituencies having the highest percentage of population with reference to the population of the taluk, in which seats have not been allotted to them in the previous term.
(2) The seats reserved for Scheduled Castes in Taluk Panchayats and Zilla Panchayats shall be allotted by rotation to the members belonging to the Scheduled Castes in the same manner as specified in sub-rule (1) above:
(3) The seats in Taluk Panchayats and Zilla Panchayats reserved for Backward Classes shall be allotted by rotation by the Deputy Commissioner in the case of Taluk Panchayats and the Government in the case of Zilla Panchayats taking into consideration such factors as the Deputy Commissioner in the case of Taluk Panchayats and the Government in case of Zilla Panchayats may deem fit.
(4) The seats reserved for women in each category referred to in sub-rules (1), (2) and (3) shall be allotted by rotation by the Deputy Commissioner in the case of Taluk Panchayats and the Government in the case of Zilla Panchayats to the constituencies taking into consideration such factors as the Deputy Commissioner in the case of Taluk Panchayats and the Government in the case of Zilla Panchayats may deem fit.
Provided that where a seat in a constituency of the Taluk Panchayat or Zilla Panchayat was allotted to a category referred, to in sub-rules (1), (2) and (3) or for a women during the previous term, the Deputy Commissioner in the case of Taluk Panchayats and the Government in the case of Zilla Panchayats shall not as far as possible allot a seat in that constituency to the same category or for a woman in the succeeding term.”
9. These Rules also mandate that the respondent No. 3 allots the reserved seats by rotation, so submits Sri Ravivarma Kumar.
10. Sri S.S Koti, the learned counsel for the petitioners in WP Nos. 36548-36549/2010 submits that the repetition of the categories is the very antithesis of the principle of rotation. To demonstrate that the State Election Commission has not been adhering to the rotational principle, he gives an example of Hadadi constituency in Davanagere Taluk. He submits that the said constituency was reserved for G(W) both in 2005 and now in 2010. He submits that unless the cycle of 10 categories is exhausted, there is no justification for the repetition of any category prematurely.
11. He further submits that SC/ST population is more in Bilichodu constituency and that therefore the said constituency is required to be allotted for SC/ST reservation category.
12. Sri K.N Phanindra, the learned counsel for the State Election Commission submits that as per Rule 3(1)(b) and the proviso to Rule 3(4) of the said Rules, the reservation given to a particular category in the previous term should not be repeated in the succeeding term. He submits that out of the 34 constituencies in Davanagere Zilla Panchayat, 7 are reserved for SC and 5 for ST. He submits that the allotment of the reservation seats has been done strictly in accordance with law only.
13. He submits that while fixing the category in 2005, the State Election Commission has ensured that there is no repetition of the category, which had the benefit of reservation in 2000. Similarly, while allotting the seats in 2010, care is taken to see that the categories to which the seats were allotted in 2005 are not repeated in 2010.
14. The learned counsel appearing for the State Election Commission in WP Nos. 35648-35649/2010 submits that the Bilichodu constituency is in a different Thaluk. It is in Jagalur Thaluk.
15. He brings to my notice the Division Bench order of this Court in the case of H.C YATHEESH KUMAR v. THE KARNATAKA ELECTION COMMISSION reported in ILR 2005 KAR 3323, in which case the same arguments, which are now advanced by Sri Ravivarma Kumar were made. The Division Bench passed the order giving acceptability to the similar submissions. The Division Bench set aside the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Reservation of Seats in Taluk Panchayats and Zilla Panchayats by Rotation) Rules, 1998 as ultra vires and void. However, the State Election Commission has gone in appeal to the Hon'ble Supreme Court (Civil Appeal No. 4523/05). The Supreme Court has granted the leave and has stayed the Division Bench's order.
16. Sri Phanindra further brings to my notice that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has also dismissed the IA for vacating the interim order of stay.
17. In the course of his rejoinder, Sri Ravivarma Kumar submits that Rule 3(1)(b) of the said Rules has no application whatsoever. It is only for Taluk Panchayat and not for Zilla Panchayat. He submits that the higher court's granting of the stay is only for the operation of an order and not for the interpretation of the statutory provision as such. He submits that the repetition or reversion goes against the principle of rotation.
18. The submissions of the learned counsel have received my anxious consideration. Whether the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Reservation of Seats in Taluk Panchayats and Zilla Panchayats by Rotation) Rules, 1998 are valid or not, whether the word ‘may’ used in the last part of the Article 243-D(1) of the Constitution of India has to be taken as mandatory or directory are the subject matter of the Civil Appeal No. 4523/05 pending consideration before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. I would therefore desist from deciding these cases with reference to the said Article and the Rules.
19. I propose to decide these cases by confining only to the provisions contained in S. 162 of the Panchayat Raj Act. The first proviso to S. 162(3) of the said Act states that the seat reserved under sub-Section (1) for (SC/ST), (2) (for backward classes) and (3) (for woman belonging to the said categories) shall be allotted by rotation to different constituencies in the district.
20. At this stage, it is necessary to know the meaning of the term ‘rotation’. This term has not been defined anywhere in the Panchayat Act or the Rules framed thereunder. When a familiar word is used by a legislative drafter or draftsman, it is usually intended to be given its unadorned, normal meaning. The golden rule is that the words of a statute must prima-facie be given their ordinary or natural meaning.
21. The Bloomsbury English Dictionary (New Edition) gives the meaning of ‘rotation’ as ‘turning motion like that of a wheel around an axis or a fixed point, or the act or process of turning in such a way.’
22. Collins English Dictionary (Harper Collins Publishers, Third Edition) gives the meaning of ‘rotation’ as 1) the act of rotating; rotary motion. 2) a regular cycle of events in a set order or sequence.
23. Random House Webster's College Dictionary gives the meaning of ‘rotation’ as 1) the act of rotating; a turning around as on an axis. 2.a) the movement or path of the earth or a heavenly body turning on its axis. b) one complete turn of such a body. 3) regularly recurring succession, as of people performing a job.
24. The perusal of the meaning of the term ‘rotation’ from the above-referred neutral sources reveals that it is a process where a regular cycle of events in a set order or a sequence takes place. It is a planned sequence in which the complete turn of a body takes place. It is a regular recurrent sequence of events or change of positions. Keeping this neutral meaning of the term ‘rotation’ in view, what it means in the context of the allotment of reservation and general seats to different constituencies in a Zilla Panchayath is required to be examined. When an enactment includes a word, which in itself is neutral or colourless, the context supplies colouring agent. The Courts can neither add works to the statute nor read words into it, which are not there. The words used in a statute are to be trustingly read.
25. It is not in dispute that vertically and horizontally there are 9 reservational categories - SC, ST, BCA, BCB, SC(W), ST(W), BCA(W), BCB(W) and G(W). In addition thereto, the 10th category is the non-reserved seats belonging to the General category. The first proviso to S. 162(3) of the said Act prescribes that the reserved seats be allotted by rotation to the different constituencies in a district. The proviso is certainly reflective of the distributive strategy of the legislators. This cannot be defeated by making a constituency alternate between SC and ST. If a constituency is perpetually reserved for SC and ST, it would entail in two avoidable deprivations:
a) The people belonging to other categories (other than SC/ST category) are perpetually deprived of the representational opportunity.
b) The people belonging to SC/ST in other Zilla Panchayat constituencies of the same Thaluka would be deprived of the reservation.
26. The State Election Commission's decision of repeatedly and alternatively reserving the constituency in question for SC, ST and the woman belonging to the said categories is unsupportable and hence unsustainable. The said arrangement is not in keeping with the rotational principle enshrined in the proviso to S. 162(3) of the said Act.
27. For the aforesaid reasons, I hold that the impugned notification reserving the Anagodu constituency for ST(W) is not sustainable. That part of the impugned notification pertaining to Anagodu constituency is therefore quashed. It is made clear that the impugned notification, insofar as the allotment of seats to other constituencies in Davanagere Zilla Panchayat is concerned, is not quashed. However, the State Election Commission is directed to issue a modified notification reserving the constituency in question for any of the following categories: BCA, BCB, BCA(W), BCB(W), and G(W); it may also throw open the seat to General category. It is also open to the State Election Commission to bring about ht consequential changes in other constituencies in Davanagere Taluk.
28. The petitioner's prayer (in WP No. 36337/2010) that the constituency in question be reserved in favour of General category is not grantable. Therefore, prayer (b) is rejected. It is for the State Election Commission to decide to which category the Anagodu constituency has to be allotted taking into account the relevant factors.
29. At this juncture Sri D. Nagaraj submits that he is not pressing prayer (b) in WP No. 36337/2010. The said prayer is therefore rejected as not pressed.
30. Both the petitions are allowed to the extend indicated hereinabove. No order as to costs.
Alert