- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chikkanna Since Dece... v. State Of Karnataka, ...
Factual and Procedural Background
These writ appeals challenge an order dated 10.03.2000 of the Learned Single Judge which dismissed a writ petition filed by the appellants. The writ petition itself challenged an order dated 19.05.2007 passed by the Land Tribunal, Srirangapatna, insofar as that order related to the grant of occupancy rights in favour of respondent Nos. 3 to 9.
The underlying dispute concerns lands in Sy.Nos. 104, 118 and 126 of Channahalli village, Srirangapatna Taluk. Deceased Chikkanna and Chamegowda (sons of Rajegowda) filed applications in Form No. 7 claiming occupancy rights as tenants. The present appellants are the legal representatives of those two deceased persons. The Tribunal had granted occupancy rights to the petitioners in respect of 1 acre 34 guntas in Sy.No. 104 and 26 guntas in Sy.No. 104/2 (in addition, other portions of the lands in the three survey numbers were granted to predecessors-in-title of the private respondents). The appellants challenged the Tribunal’s grant of occupancy rights to other claimants only to the extent that their own claims were rejected.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Land Tribunal committed an illegality in granting occupancy rights to persons who claimed to be sub-tenants when, according to the appellants, sub-tenancies could not lawfully have been created after 02.10.1965.
- Whether persons who are alleged to be sub-tenants but who were not shown to be in possession and cultivation could be regarded as lawful tenants entitled to occupancy rights under the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961 (the "Act").
- How the provisions of Sections 21, 45, 46 and 49 of the Act apply to claims of sub-tenants for registration as occupants, and specifically whether a finding was required about the date when the sub-tenancy arose (i.e., whether it arose prior to 02.10.1965).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The Tribunal erred in treating respondent Nos. 3 to 9 as lawful sub-tenants because no sub-lease was created prior to 02.10.1965; after that date sub-tenancies could not lawfully be created (relying on Section 5 as understood by them and on Section 21).
- Even if the respondents' names appear in the record of rights for 1971-72, that would not entitle them to occupancy rights if their sub-tenancy was not lawfully created before 02.10.1965.
- The appellants relied on several judicial decisions and invited attention to Sections 21, 45, 46 and 49 of the Act to support the proposition that sub-tenancies created after 02.10.1965 are not protected.
Respondents' Arguments
- Respondent counsel (for respondent Nos. 3 and others) supported the Tribunal's order as affirmed by the Learned Single Judge. Respondents asserted they were sub-tenants under the father of the petitioners and had been cultivating the land for the last 40 years (or at least were cultivating immediately prior to the appointed date 01.03.1974), which they contended was sufficient for entitlement to occupancy rights.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Narasimha Jayadeva Rao v. The Land Tribunal, Sirsi Taluk, Uttara Kannada District (reported at 2003 (4) KLJ 239) | The Learned Single Judge had relied on this decision for the proposition that it was sufficient to consider whether the sub-tenant was cultivating the land as on 01.03.1974 or immediately prior thereto. | The Division Bench held that reliance on this case by the Learned Single Judge was misplaced because that decision did not consider the effect of the bar on sub-letting in Section 21(1) of the Act. The Court therefore found it not apposite to the present facts. |
| Bakilana Chinnappa v. Land Tribunal, Mercara Taluk and Others (1978 1 KLJ 75) | The appellants cited it for the proposition (as they urged) that under Section 5 no tenancy could be created after 02.10.1965. | The Court observed that Section 5 was subsequently substituted by the Amendment Act (Act No.1 of 1974) and clarified the operative dates; it concluded that the appellants' reliance on the idea that no tenancy can be created after 02.10.1965 under Section 5 was misconceived in the sense explained in the opinion. |
| Beera Aayu Agera v. Land Tribunal, Ankola and Others (AIR 1998 KAR 2381) | This case was cited for the principle that a person claiming occupancy as a sub-tenant succeeds only if the sub-letting in his favour was prior to 02.10.1965; sub-tenancies acquired after the Act came into force are hit by Section 21. | The Court accepted the proposition as correctly laying down that sub-letting after 02.10.1965 is prohibited by Section 21 and that the Beera Aayu Agera decision correctly stated the law on this point. |
| Vimal Appayya Markal v. The Land Tribunal, Belgaum and Others | This case was cited by appellants; the provided opinion does not state the precise rule or principle from that decision. | The provided opinion records that the case was relied upon by the appellants but does not describe how the Court applied or evaluated it in the present judgment. |
| Timmakka Kom Venkanna Naik v. The Land Tribunal and Others | The decision considered Section 21(1) and held that a tenant could not assign his rights (including by Will) because the bar in Section 21(1) precludes subdivision or sub-letting. | The Court cited this decision to support the view that Section 21 prohibits assignment/sub-letting and that rights cannot be transferred circumventing that prohibition (for example by Will). |
| Sangappa Kalyanappa Bangi (Dead) through Lrs. v. Land Tribunal, Jamkhandi and Others (1998 7 SCC 294) | The Apex Court held that assignment of any interest in tenanted land by a tenant (even by way of bequest under a Will) cannot be held valid in view of Section 21. | The Court relied on this authority to reinforce the principle that Section 21 bars such assignments and that the bar applies to attempts to transfer tenancy by bequest. |
| Sugandhabai v. Tanaji (1975 2 KLJ SN. 11) | The case was cited by appellants; the provided opinion does not set out the specific principle cited from this decision. | The opinion notes the case was relied upon by the appellants but does not explain its specific application to the facts or legal reasoning in this opinion. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by examining (a) the factual findings of the Tribunal and the Learned Single Judge, and (b) the legal effect of key statutory provisions in the Act (primarily Sections 21 and 49, considered with Sections 45, 44 and the definition under Section 2(34) and Section 5 as amended).
1. On facts, respondent Nos. 3 to 9 claimed they were sub-tenants under the appellants' father and asserted cultivation for approximately 40 years; they did not, however, state precisely from which year the sub-tenancy began. The Tribunal and the Learned Single Judge proceeded on the basis that the respondents were sub-tenants as on the appointed date 01.03.1974 and, relying on Section 49 (and the Narasimha Jayadeva Rao decision), treated that as sufficient for entitlement.
2. The Court focused on Section 49, which entitles a sub-tenant to be registered as an occupant "where a tenant has lawfully sublet the land held by him" and only "to the extent" provided in Sections 45 and 46 where the sub-tenant was a sub-tenant before the date of vesting. The Court quoted the text of Section 49 and emphasised that it applies only where the sub-letting was lawful.
3. The Court analysed Section 21 (which prohibits sub-division or sub-letting of land held by a tenant) and noted that this statute came into force with effect from 02.10.1965. The Court concluded that, unless it is established that the predecessor-in-title was a permanent tenant (thus bringing in the proviso exceptions), a tenant could not lawfully sub-let land after 02.10.1965. The Court observed that the facts as pleaded did not make the proviso to Section 21(1) applicable, but did not finally decide that factual question at this stage.
4. Because Section 21 creates a prohibition on sub-letting from 02.10.1965, a sub-tenancy created after that date would not be lawful and therefore would not attract the protection of Section 49 or the provisions for registration as an occupant. Section 4 (deemed tenants) was noted as not bringing within its ambit a sub-tenant inducted contrary to Section 21.
5. The Court reviewed earlier decisions relied upon by the parties. It accepted the legal propositions in authorities such as Timmakka and Sangappa (that Section 21 bars assignment/subdivision and even bequests cannot overcome that bar) and Beera Aayu Agera (that a sub-tenant succeeds only if the sub-letting was prior to 02.10.1965). It held that the Learned Single Judge erred by relying on Narasimha Jayadeva Rao because that decision had not considered the effect of Section 21 and therefore was not apposite.
6. The Court also examined the interplay between Section 5 and later amendment (Act No.1 of 1974). It observed that Section 5 was substituted by the Amendment Act and that the amended Section 5 operates from the commencement of the Amendment Act (the opinion states the commencement date with reference to 01.03.1974). The Court pointed out that a tenant inducted after 02.10.1965 but before 01.03.1974 might still be entitled to occupancy under the substituted Section 5 and the definition of "tenant" in Section 2(34); however, this reasoning relates to creation of tenancy and not to sub-tenancy. The Court reiterated that its present concern is sub-tenancy and that Section 21 prohibits creation of sub-tenancy after 02.10.1965 except as permitted by the proviso.
7. Crucially, the Court found that neither the Tribunal nor the Learned Single Judge made any finding on when the sub-tenancy in favour of respondent Nos. 3 to 9 was created. The Tribunal had merely recorded that the respondents were sub-tenants as on 01.03.1974 and therefore entitled to occupancy rights. The Court held that the Tribunal ought to have determined whether the sub-tenancy originated prior to 02.10.1965 (so as to be lawful under the Act). In the absence of such a finding, the Tribunal's order could not be sustained.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The writ appeals are allowed. The Court set aside the order passed by the Learned Single Judge and further set aside the order dated 19.05.2007 passed by the Land Tribunal insofar as it related to the grant of occupancy rights in favour of respondent Nos. 3 to 9.
Consequent directions / implications:
- The matter is remitted to the Land Tribunal for fresh consideration in accordance with law and in the light of the observations made in this opinion. In particular, the Tribunal must record a finding on when the sub-tenancy (if any) in favour of respondent Nos. 3 to 9 was created (i.e., whether it arose prior to 02.10.1965), and whether any proviso to Section 21(1) applies on the pleaded facts.
- Direct effect: The grant of occupancy rights to respondent Nos. 3 to 9 as recorded in the impugned Tribunal order is set aside; the question of entitlement is to be examined afresh by the Tribunal with specific attention to the date of creation of the sub-tenancy and the applicability of Section 21.
- The Court did not purport to lay down any novel principle of law beyond the application and interpretation of existing statutory provisions and authorities; the immediate consequence is procedural (remittance for fresh consideration), and no new binding precedent was announced in broader terms beyond the legal conclusions about the effect of Section 21 as applied to sub-tenancies.
Note: This summary is strictly based on the text of the provided opinion. Where the opinion listed cases without specifying the precise legal proposition invoked from them, the summary records that those cases were relied upon but does not attribute unexpressed rules to them.
Patil, J.
1. In these writ appeals, order dated 10.03.2000 passed by the Learned Single Judge dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellants herein is challenged. In the writ petition, the appellants herein had challenged the order dated 19.05.2007 passed by the Land Tribunal, Srirangapatna, in so far as it related to the grant of occupancy rights in favour of respondent Nos. 3 to 9 herein.
2. The dispute relates to Sy.Nos 104, 118 & 126 of Channahalli village of Srirangapatna Taluk. Deceased Chikkanna and Chamegowda, both sons of Rajegowda filed applications in Form No. 7 claiming occupancy rights as tenants in respect of these lands. Writ petitioners/appellants herein are the legal representatives of the said Chikkanna and Chamegowda. The Tribunal granted occupancy rights in respect of 1 acre 34 guntas in Sy.No 104 and 26 guntas in Sy.No 104/2 to the petitioners. Different portions of lands comprised in these three survey numbers were granted in favour of the predecessors-in-title of private respondents herein, which they had claimed. Aggrieved by the grant of occupancy rights in respect of different portions of land in favour of other private respondents, the writ petitioners/appellants herein filed the writ petition only to the extent of rejection of their claim.
3. The main contention urged in the writ petition was that the Land Tribunal committed an illegality in granting occupancy rights in favour of the respondents who claimed to be sub-tenants under the original tenants. It was contended that after 02.10.1965, no tenancy could have been created and as such the persons who claimed grant of occupancy as sub-tenants could not be regarded as lawful tenants entitling for confirmation of occupancy rights as per the provisions of the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961 (for short the ‘Act’). It was contended that the so-called sub-tenants were only trespassers. It was also contended that respondent Nos. 3 to 9 were not at all in possession and cultivation of any portion of the lands in question.
4. The Learned Single Judge has held that the minute scrutiny of the records made by him revealed that the names of Chikkanna, Rajegowda and Chamegowda (petitioners and their father) did not figure in column No. 12 of the record of rights, insofar as lands in Sy.Nos 118 & 126 were concerned. As far as the land bearing Sy.No 104, the Learned Single Judge has held that the Tribunal has totally granted 2 acres and 22 guntas of land to petitioner Nos. 1 and 2, whereas their names were found in respect of only 2 acres of land. The contention urged by the writ petitioners stating that respondent Nos. 3 to 9 were only trespassers was repelled holding that the combined reading of the provisions contained in Sections 45 & 49 of the Act, did not leave any doubt that even a sub-tenant was also entitled for grant of occupancy rights. The Learned Single Judge found support for this view from the judgment reported in the case of Narasimha Jayadeva Rao v. The Land Tribunal, Sirsi Taluk, Uttara Kannada District and Others1. Thus, the contentions urged by the writ petitioners have been negatived.
5. Sri B.M Krishna Bhat, Learned Counsel for the appellants contends before us that as there was no sub-lease created prior to 02.10.1965, the Tribunal erred in granting occupancy rights holding that respondent Nos. 3 to 9 were the sub-tenants. He next contended that as per Section 5 of the Act, no tenancy could be created after 02.10.1965 It is his submission that even if it is assumed that the name of the respondents was found in the record of rights for the years 1971 -72, they will not get any right to seek occupancy rights. In this regard, he has placed reliance on the judgments reported in the case of Bakilana Chinnappa v. Land Tribunal Mercara Taluk and Others . 1978 1 KLJ 75. and in the case of Beera Aayu Agera v. Land Tribunal, Ankola and Others . AIR 1998 KAR 2381.. He has also placed reliance on the following Judgments:
(i) Vimal Appayya Markal v. The Land Tribunal, Belgaum and Others4.
(ii) Timmakka Kom Venkanna Naik v. The Land Tribunal and Others5.
(iii) Sangappa Kalyanappa Bangi (Dead) Through Lrs. v. Land Tribunal, Jamkhandi and Others . 1998 7 SCC 294.
(iv) Sugandhabai v. Tanaji . 1975 2 KLJ SN. 11.
He has invited our attention to Sections 21, 45, 46 and 49 of the Act.
6. Sri Shashikiran Shetty, Learned Counsel appearing for respondent Nos. 3, 12 to 15, 20 and 22 has strongly supported the order passed by the Land Tribunal as affirmed by the Learned Single Judge.
7. Having heard the Learned Counsel for both parties and on careful perusal of the entire materials on record, we find that, admittedly respondent Nos. 3 to 9 herein have claimed occupancy rights contending that they were sub-tenants under the father of the petitioners. Though they have not stated in clear terms as to from which year they have been sub-tenants, they have asserted that they have been cultivating the land for the last 40 years. Counsel for the respondents contends that it is sufficient for them to show that they were cultivating the land as sub-tenants immediately prior to the appointed date viz., 01.03.1974 At any rate, it is urged that the sub-tenancy has originated prior to 02.10.1965
8. The Learned Single Judge has not considered the question whether lawful sub-tenancy could have been created after 02.10.1965 He has also not recorded a finding as to whether the respondents herein were sub-tenants prior to 02.10.1965 But, he has proceeded on the basis of Section 49 of the Act and taking support from the Judgment reported in 2003 (4) KLJ 239. Section 49 of the Act reads as under:
“49. Sub-tenants or tenants to be registered as occupants.- Where a tenant has lawfully sublet the land held by him, such sub-tenant of the land, shall, to the exclusion of the tenant, to the extent and subject to the conditions specified in Sections 45 and 46 be entitled to be registered as occupant of the land of which he was a sub-tenant before the date of vesting.”
9. It is important to note from Section 49 of the Act that only in cases where a tenant has lawfully sublet the land held by him, such sub-tenant will be entitled for registration of occupancy rights of which he was a sub-tenant before the date of vesting. At this stage, it is very relevant to notice the provisions contained under Section 21 of the Act, which prohibit sub-letting and assignment of lands. The said provision reads as under:
“21. Sub-division or sub-letting and assignment prohibited.— (1) No sub-division or sub-letting of the land held by a tenant or assignment of any interest therein shall be valid:
Provided that nothing in this sub-Section shall affect the rights, if any, of a permanent tenant:
Provided further that if the tenant dies.-
(i) if he is a member of joint family, the surviving members of the said family, and
(ii) if he is not a member of a joint family, his heirs shall be entitled to partition and sub-divide the land leased, subject to the following conditions.
(a) each sharer shall hold his share as a separate tenant;
(b) the rent payable in respect of the land leased shall be apportioned among the sharers, as the case may be, according to the share allotted to them;
(c) the area allotted to each sharer shall not be less than a fragment;
(d) if such area is less than a fragment the sharers shall be entitled to enjoy the income jointly, but the land shall not be divided by metes and bounds;
(e) if any question arises regarding the apportionment of the rent payable by the sharer it shall be decided by the Tahsildar.
Provided that if any question of law is involved the Tahsildar shall refer it to the Court. On receipt of such reference the Court shall, after giving notice to the parties concerned, try the question as expeditiously as possible and record finding thereon and send the same to the Tahsildar. The Tahsildar shall then give the decision in accordance with the said finding.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in Sub-Section (1), it shall be lawful for a tenant who is a soldier in service in the Armed Forces of the Union or a seaman to sub-let the land held by him as a tenant.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-Section (1), it shall be lawful for a tenant to take a loan and mortgage, or create a charge on his interest in the land in favour of the State Government, [a financial institution, a co-operative land development Bank, a co-operative society), a company as defined in Section 3 of the Companies Act, 1956 in which not less than fifty-one per cent of the paid up share capital is held by the State Government or a Corporation owned or controlled by the Central Government or the State Government or both, for development of land or improvement of agricultural practices; and without prejudice to any other remedy provided by any law, in the event of his making default in payment of such loan in accordance with the terms and conditions on which such loan was granted, it shall be lawful to cause his interest in the land to be attached and sold and the proceeds to be utilised in payment of such loan.”
10. It is thus clear from the provision contained in Section 21 that, a bar is enacted for sub-letting the land held by any tenant except by a permanent tenant. The proviso and the succeeding sub-sections save assignment by way of partition and by certain other categories of tenants like a soldier, seaman or in respect of certain transactions of loan or mortgage executed in favour of State Government or some Companies or Co-operative societies. Section 21 is in the statute book and has come into force with effect from 02.10.1965 Therefore, it is clear that, the prohibition for sub-letting the land is in existence since 02.10.1965 If that be so, unless it is established that the predecessor-in-title of the writ petitioners were permanent tenants of the lands in question, they could not have sub-let the lands after 02.10.1965 The facts as pleaded do not make the proviso to sub-Section (1) of Section 21 applicable to the present case. However, no opinion need be expressed in this regard at this stage. It has to be therefore, noted that if sub-tenancy is created after 02.10.1965, it cannot be regarded as lawful in view of the prohibition enacted under Section 21.
11. Section 4 of the Act which deals with deemed tenants will also not take in its fold a sub-tenant who is inducted contrary to Section 21.
12. In the case of Timmakka Kom Venkanna Naik v. The Land Tribunal and Others (Supra) on which reliance is placed by the appellants, the provisions contained under Section 21(1) of the Act came up for consideration. The question that arose was whether a tenant could bequeath his right of tenancy in favour of a third party under a Will. This Court having considered the effect of Section 45 and Section 21(1) of the Act has held in paragraph 12 that a tenant cannot assign his rights in the land to any other person in view of the bar enacted under Section 21 for subdivision or subletting of the land held by him. It is held that the bar cannot be overcome by a tenant even by creating a Will because what he cannot do during his lifetime cannot be held to be capable of being done immediately after his death. Likewise, in the case of Sangappa Kalyanappa Bangi (Dead) through Lrs. v. Land Tribunal, Jamkhandiand others (Supra) explaining the effect of Section 21 of the Act, the Apex Court held that the assignment of any interest in the tenanted land by a tenant even by way of bequest under a Will cannot be held to be valid. In the case of Beeraaayu Agera v. Land Tribunal, Ankola and Others (Supra) learned Single Judge of this Court has held that under Section 45(1) of the Act a person claiming occupancy on the ground of being a sub-tenant can succeed only if he is able to show that the sub-letting in his favour was prior to 02.10.1965 It is further held that if the sub-tenancy rights were acquired after the coming into force of the provisions of the Act, the said sub-tenancy was hit by the provisions of Section 21 which prohibited sub-letting. In our view, the proposition of law regarding the prohibition of sub-lease as enacted under Section 21(1) with effect from 02.10.1965 is rightly laid down in this decision.
13. In the instant case, the learned Single Judge has not noticed the effect of Section 21. Reliance placed by the learned Single Judge on the decision in the case of Narasimha Jayadevarao v. The Land Tribunal, Sirsi Taluk, Uttara Kannada District and Others (Supra) is not apposite to the facts of the present case. In the said case, the effect of the provisions contained under Section 21 (1) of the Act is not considered. The observations made therein to the effect that all that was required to be considered was as to whether the sub-tenant was cultivating the land as on 01.03.1974 or immediately prior thereto, are the result of non-consideration of the bar for sub-lease under Section 21 (1) of the Act and therefore the learned Single Judge erred in placing reliance on the said judgment and in proceeding on the basis of the provisions of Section 49 without noticing the provisions contained under section 21(1) of the Act.
14. Insofar as the contention urged by the Counsel for the appellants on the basis of the judgment in the case of Bakilana Chinnappa v. Land Tribunal Mercara Taluk and Others (Supra) that as per Section 5 of the Act, no tenancy can be created after 02.10.1965, it has to be stated that Section 5 is substituted by the Amendment Act, Act No. 1 of 1974 with effect from 10.03.1974 The prohibition for creation of lease as per Section 5 as substituted by the Amendment Act of 1974 stipulates that no tenancy shall be created or continued in respect of any land nor shall any land be leased for any period after the date of commencement of the Amendment Act except as provided in the Act. Therefore, it is clear that the bar enacted for the creation of tenancy is with effect from the date of commencement of the Amendment Act i.e, with effect from 01.03.1974 Though there was similar provision in the unamended Section 5 as enacted by the Land Reforms Act, 1961, in view of the substitution of new Section 5 making it clear that no tenancy shall be created after the date of commencement of the Amendment Act read along with the definition of the term ‘Tenant; under Section 2(34) of the Act and coupled with Sections 45 and 44 of the Act, it is clear that even a tenant who is inducted as such after 02.10.1965 and immediately prior to 01.03.1974 is entitled for grant of occupancy rights. In fact, the definition clause under Section 2(34) of the Act includes as per sub-Clause (ii-a) a person who cultivates personally any land on lease created contrary to the provisions of Section 5 and before the date of commencement of the Amendment Act. It is thus clear, that the contention urged by the Counsel for the appellants that no tenancy can be created after 02.10.1965 as per Section 5 is misconceived. At any rate, in this case, we are not concerned with the creation of tenancy after 02.10.1965 We are concerned with the creation of sub-tenancy. As already held by us, no sub-tenancy can be created after 02.10.1965 except as permitted and provided by proviso to sub-Section (1) of Section 21 in view of the prohibition contained under Section 21(1) of the Act.
15. In the instant case, the Tribunal has not gone into the question when the sub-tenancy was created in favour of respondent Nos. 3 to 9. It has simply held that as respondent Nos. 3 to 9 were found to be sub-tenants as on 01.03.1974 they were entitled for grant of occupancy rights. The Tribunal ought to have recorded a finding as to whether the sub-tenancy was created prior to 02.10.1965 In the absence of such a finding, the order passed by the Tribunal cannot be sustained.
16. In the light of the above discussion, we are of the view that these appeals deserve to be allowed. Accordingly, we pass the following:
(i) The writ appeals are allowed. The order passed by the Learned Single Judge is set aside.
(ii) The writ petition is allowed by setting aside the order dated 19.05.2007 passed by the Land Tribunal impugned in the writ petition insofar as it relates to the grant of occupancy rights in favour of respondent Nos. 3 to 9.
(iii) The matter is remitted to the Tribunal for fresh consideration in accordance with law and in the light of the observations made herein above.
Alert