Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Milan Minerals Pvt. Ltd., Bangalore v. Union Of India And Others

Karnataka High Court
Feb 28, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Mining Lease Writ Petitions

Factual and Procedural Background

An area of 2,560 acres in Hombalghatta, Gollarahalli and other villages was previously held under a mining lease by Sri P.K. Sarangapani Mudaliar. After expiry of that lease, the State Government issued a notification dated 15-6-1999 under Rule 59 of the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960 calling for applications for grant of mining lease. Twenty-nine applications were filed in response, including those of the petitioners, the 4th respondent and others.

The petitioners learned from official sources that the State Government had taken a decision to grant the mining lease to the 4th respondent and had initiated steps to seek the Central Government's approval under Section 5 of the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957 (MMRD Act). The petitioners challenged the process and decision by filing writ petitions under Article 226 seeking quashing of the State Government proceedings that sought Central approval for grant of the lease to the 4th respondent.

The State Government and the 4th respondent filed statements of objections justifying the selection. The 4th respondent also raised a preliminary objection as to maintainability, relying on a prior decision (Binani Zinc Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan) and contending that, absent Central Government approval under Section 5, the writ petitions were premature.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ petitions are maintainable at this stage or are premature because the Central Government had not yet accorded approval under Section 5 of the MMRD Act.
  2. Whether the State Government and the Department complied with the statutory procedure (particularly Section 11 of the MMRD Act and Rule 26 of the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960) in processing and forwarding applications for consideration and in affording affected applicants an opportunity of hearing prior to rejecting applications.
  3. Whether the decision of the State Government to select the 4th respondent for grant of mining lease should be quashed for non-compliance with the Act and the Rules and for abuse of the selection process.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The decision of the State Government to grant the lease to the 4th respondent was contrary to the provisions of the MMRD Act and the Rules and amounted to illegality.
  • The petitioners were not afforded an opportunity of hearing before their applications were rejected, in breach of Rule 26 of the Rules.
  • The departmental procedure was flawed because, although 29 applications had been filed, only a short‑listed set of applications (initially four, later five) were forwarded to the State Government for consideration, contrary to the statutory scheme requiring collective consideration of applications received pursuant to a notification.
  • The petitioners made a detailed representation to the Chief Secretary requesting appropriate directions to have their applications considered.

State Government's Arguments

  • The State Government justified its selection of the 4th respondent and stated that it had forwarded for consideration those applications which were in order.
  • The State contended that notices had been issued to other applicants calling upon them to supply omissions or necessary documents and that some applicants had failed to comply, which justified forwarding only the applications that were complete.

4th Respondent's Arguments

  • The 4th respondent relied on Binani Zinc Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan and argued that grant of a mining lease by the State Government requires prior approval from the Central Government under Section 5 of the Act; absent such approval the petitions were premature and not amenable to interference under Article 226.
  • Even if a decision by the State Government to reject other applications existed, the appropriate remedy for the petitioners would be to challenge such decision by way of a revision petition under Rule 54 of the Rules (as per respondent's counsel).
  • The 4th respondent also contended that, post‑amendment of Section 11, no opportunity of hearing was mandated before rejecting applications (contention that Rule 26 no longer had application following that amendment).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Binani Zinc Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1996 Raj 238 Authority relied upon to argue that a writ petition is premature where Central Government approval under Section 5 has not been accorded. The Court considered the Binani decision raised by the 4th respondent but distinguished the present facts: due to the demonstrated procedural irregularity and the State Government's decided-but-uncommunicated action, the court held interference was appropriate and that the petitions were maintainable despite the lack of Central approval at that stage.
Indian Metals & Ferro Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 1991 SC 818 (also reported as 1991 (5) JTSC 236) Interpretation of Section 11: sub‑section (4) overrides sub‑section (2) so that applications received pursuant to a notification are to be considered together on merits and not purely on a "first come, first served" basis. The Court relied on the principle (as cited from this decision) to hold that whether the amended or unamended Section 11 applied, applications must be considered on their merits and, where applicable, treated as if filed on the same day. The Court used this principle to criticize the departmental practice of short‑listing and forwarding only some applications while withholding others.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined the maintainability objection premised on lack of Central Government approval under Section 5. The 4th respondent urged that, following Binani Zinc, petitions would be premature where Central approval has not been accorded. The court acknowledged that in Binani the Central Government had given approval and the Rajasthan High Court held the petition premature in that factual matrix.

Notwithstanding that preliminary objection, the court analyzed the record and the statutory scheme governing grant of mining leases:

  • Section 5 of the MMRD Act imposes restrictions requiring Central Government approval for certain minerals.
  • Section 11 (sub‑sections (1), (2) and (4)) governs preferential rights where reconnaissance permits or prospecting licences have been given and prescribes how applications received pursuant to a notification should be treated (notably that all applications received during the specified period shall be considered simultaneously as if received on the same day under s.11(4)).
  • Rule 26 of the Mineral Concession Rules requires the State Government to afford an opportunity of being heard before refusing to grant a mining lease and to issue notices to applicants to cure omissions or supply documents with a sixty‑day period for compliance.

Applying those provisions to the facts, the court found procedural non‑compliance: although 29 applications were filed in response to the notification, the Department forwarded only four applications initially (and one more later) to the State Government by short‑listing, leaving many applications unforwarded and their applicants apparently uninformed. The court observed that when applications are received pursuant to a notification, they should all be forwarded to the State Government if in order so that the State can consider them collectively as required by Section 11(4) (or under the unamended scheme as appropriate).

The court further found that the petitioners and other applicants were not given an opportunity of hearing before their applications were rejected, in apparent breach of Rule 26. The State Government's justification that notices were issued and applicants failed to comply did not, on the record, establish that the required opportunity and procedural steps (including any further hearing before refusal) were in fact afforded.

The court also relied on the principle from Indian Metals & Ferro Alloys that the grant of a mining lease should be on the basis of merit and capacity and not merely by mechanical adherence to a "first come, first served" approach, reinforcing that applications filed pursuant to a notification should be processed together.

Given these procedural irregularities and the risk of further litigation if an improvident approval were sought and a lease granted without rectifying the process, the court concluded that intervention at the present stage was warranted to set right the selection process at the threshold rather than await later challenges.

Holding and Implications

Writ Petitions are allowed.

Direct dispositional orders (as recorded in the opinion):

  1. The proceedings of the State Government granting a mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent are quashed.
  2. A direction is issued to the State Government to consider all applications which are pending and to pass appropriate orders in the light of the observations made in the judgment (i.e., having regard to Section 11, Rule 26 and the requirement to afford opportunities and consider applications collectively on merits).

Implications: The immediate consequence is that the State Government's decision in favour of the 4th respondent is set aside and all 29 applications must be reconsidered in accordance with law. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new, broader precedent beyond its application of existing statutory provisions and cited authorities to the facts; it confines itself to quashing the impugned proceedings and directing lawful reconsideration to avoid future litigation.

Show all summary ...

1. The petitioners in these writ petitions have sought for quashing of the proceedings of the State Government seeking approval of the Central Govt., for grant of mining lease under Sec. 5(1) of the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as MMRD Act, 1957), on the application filed by 4th respondent pursuant to the notification bearing No. DMB/ML/DV/99-5575, dated 15-6-1999, as contrary to law and for other reliefs.

2. The facts in these cases are as follows:—

An area of 2560 acres in Hombalghatta, Gollarahalli and other villages were held under mining lease by Sri. P.K Sarangapani Mudaliar. After the expiry of the lease, the State Government issued a notification dated 15-6-1999 published in the Official Gazette for regrant under Rule 59 of the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’). The petitioner, 4th respondent and 27 other persons filed applications for grant of mining lease. It is submitted that the petitioners learnt from the office of respondents 2 and 3 that the State Government has sought for approval of the Central Government under Sec. 5 of MMRD Act, for grant of lease in favour of 4th respondent without considering the other applications as contemplated under the Act and the Rules and have filed these writ petitions seeking for quashing of the proceedings. The petitioner (in WP/19291/01) also has submitted a detailed representation to the Chief Secretary to the Government of Karnataka, requesting for suitable direction to the 2nd respondent for grant of mining lease in its favour by seeking approval from the Secretary (Mines). Central Govt., under Sec. 5 of the Act, a copy of which is produced as Annexure D to the petition.

3. The grievance of the petitioners is that in spite of the said representation, the Govt. has not taken any action and on the other hand has taken a decision to grant mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent and has taken steps to move the Central Govt., for approval as provided under Sec. 5 of the MMRD Act.

4. Sri. D.L.N Rao, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that the decision of the State Government to grant mining lease in favour of respondent 4 is in total disregard of all provisions of the Act and the Rules.

5. The State Government in its statement of objections has justified the selection of 4th respondent for grant of mining lease. Respondent 4 also in the statement of objections justified his selection by the State Govt., for grant of mining lease. In addition to this the 4th respondent has raised a preliminary objection regarding maintainability of the writ petitions relying upon the decision in the case of Binani Zinc Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1996 Raj 238. According to the learned counsel for the respondent, grant of mining lease if any, by the State Government is only after approval by the Central Govt. as contemplated under Sec. 5 of the Act, and in the instant case since the Central Govt, is yet to accord its approval these petitions are premature and liable to be dismissed. Further, it is submitted that even assuming that the State Govt. has taken a decision to grant mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent and if the petitioners are aggrieved of the said decision, the appropriate remedy for the petitioners is to challenge the said decision by way of filing a revision petition under Rule 54 of the Rules.

6. Before considering the case on merits with reference to the relevant provisions of law referred to above, I propose to consider the point raised by Sri. R.N Narasimha Murthy, learned senior counsel regarding maintainability of the writ petitions.

7. Sri. R.N Narasimha Murthy, appearing for the 4th respondent in all the petitions, submits that in the absence of any approval by the Central Govt, as provided under Sec. 5, of the Act, the writ petitions are liable to be dismissed as they are premature. It is further submitted that it is not known whether the Central Govt. would accord sanction or not and therefore at this stage, it is not appropriate for this Court to interfere in these writ petitions under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India. In support of this, he relied upon the decision in the case of Binani Zinc Ltd. (referred to supra). In that case, the Central Govt. has accorded approval for mining lease in favour of respondent 4 under Sec. 5 of the Act. But the State Govt. pursuant to the said approval had not passed an order granting mining lease in favour of respondent 4. On those facts, the High Court of Rajasthan has held that the writ petition is premature. In the instant case, on the basis of the information furnished by the concerned Officer of the State Govt. the petitioners have filed these petitions challenging the very process of selection on the ground that the selection of respondent 4 is contrary to the provisions of the Act and the Rules.

8. From the records, if it is shown that the State Govt. has not followed the procedure prescribed for the purpose of granting mining lease, in my opinion, in order to prevent any further litigation, it would be better to set right things at the threshhold itself. In the instant case, there were 29 applications for grant of mining lease. Out of the 29 applications only four applications were forwarded by short listing to the State Govt. in the first instance and subsequently one more application was forwarded to the State Govt. No doubt, only these five applicants are before the Government. So far as the rest of the applicants are concerned, it appears they are not even aware of what has happened to their applications. Therefore, in the event if the Central Govt. were to accord approval and pursuant to the said approval if mining lease is granted in favour of the 4th respondent, then there would be revision petitions or writ petitions challenging the said decision. Therefore, in order to avoid future litigation and to set right the irregularity or illegality in the matter of selection, I feel it appropriate at this stage to interfere with the process of selection.

9. Further, from the records made available by the learned Govt, pleader, I find that the State Govt. has taken a decision to grant mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent rejecting the applications of the other four applicants. This decision no doubt has not been communicated to the petitioners. Normally, wherever a decision is taken adverse to the interest of other applicants, and the State Govt. has taken steps to ask for approval of the Central Govt. the State Govt. should have communicated its decision to the applicants whose applications have been rejected. In the instant case, there is no such communication to the petitioners. If the decision of the State Govt. has been communicated to the petitioners, the petitioners should have challenged the said decision, by way of filing a revision petition before the Central Govt. Under Rule 54 of the Rules and in such circumstances, the Central Govt. would have considered the decision of the State Govt. before according approval to the State Govt. to grant mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent. But there is no such communication and therefore in order to prevent abuse of process of law. I hold, it is just and proper for this Court to interfere with the process of selection. Hence, I hold the writ petitions filed by the petitioners in this regard are maintainable in law.

10. In order to consider the rival contentions, it is useful to refer to certain provisions of the Act, and the Rules. Section 5 of the Act, provides for restrictions on the grant of prospective licences or mining lease. The proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 5 of the Act, reads as follows:—

“Provided that in respect of any mineral specified in the First Schedule, no reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease shall be granted except with the previous approval of the Central Government.”

Under Section 11(1) of the Act, where a reconnaaissance permit or prospecting licence has been granted in respect of any land, the permit holder or the licensee shall have a preferential right for obtaining a prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, in respect of that land over any other person;

Under sub-section (2) of Section 11, where the State Govt. has not notified in the official gazette the area for grant of mining lease, and when two or more persons have applied for mining lease in respect of any land in such area, the applicant whose application was received first shall have the preferential right to be considered for grant of mining lease. Under the proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 11, where the area is not notified for grant of lease, all applications, received pursuant to such notification during the specified period, including the pending applications received prior to the notification for grant, will have to be considered as if all the applications are received on the same day. Under sub-section (4) where the State Govt. notifies in the official gazette an area for grant of mining lease, all applications received during the period as specified in such notification, which shall not be less than 30 days, shall be considered simultaneously as if all such applications have been received on the same day.

11. Rule 26 of the Rules reads as follows:—

“Refusal of application for grant and renewal of mining lease — The State Govt. may, after giving an opportunity of being heard and, for reasons to be recorded in writing and communicated to the applicant, refuse to grant or renew a mining lease over the whole or part of the area applied for.

(2) An application for the grant or renewal of a mining lease made under Rule 22 or Rule 24-A, as the case may be, shall not be refused by the State Govt. only on the ground that Form I or Form J, as the case may be, is not complete in all material particulars, or is not accompanied by the documents referred to in sub-clauses (3), (e), (f), (g) and (h) of Clause (i) of sub-rule (3) of Rule 22.

(3) Where it appears that the application is not complete in all material particulars or is not accompanied by the required documents, the State Govt. by notice, require the applicant to supply the omission or, as the case may be, furnish the documents, without delay and in any case not later than sixty days from the date of receipt of the said notice by the applicant.”

12. From a reading of the abovesaid rule, it is clear that State Government shall afford an opportunity of hearing before refusing to grant a mining lease. Further, under the abovesaid rule, the State Govt. shall not refuse the application if it is incomplete or necessary documents have not been produced without issuing a notice calling upon the applicant to supply the omission or to furnish the necessary documents without any further delay within sixty days from the date of receipt of the said notice.

13. The State Govt. issued a notification dated 15-6-1999, calling for applications for grant of mining lease under Rule 59 of the Rules. The petitioners and others are the applicants seeking for grant of mining lease. If the applications are filed in response fo the notification of the State Govt., all applications received during the period as specified in such notification, shall be considered as if the said applications have been filed on the same day under sub-section (4) of Section 11 of the Act. In the instant case all these applications are in response to the notification issued by the State Govt. Therefore, the preferential right as provided under sub-section (2) of Section 11, has no application. Sri R.N Narasimha Murthy, learned senior counsel appearing for the contesting respondent submits that as on the date the notification was published calling for applications, present Rule 11 was not in force and therefore, the unamended Section 11 is applicable. The contention of the petitioners is that even if the unamended section is applied in respect of applications filed prior to the amendment of Section 11, the State Govt. is required to consider all applications filed on a particular date together. In order to appreciate this contention, I looked into the records. From the records, I find, out of 29 applications many of the applications have filed their applications for grant of mining lease on 9-8-1999 i.e on which date the petitioners have also filed their applications. Under the scheme of the Act, and the Rules, all applications filed shall be forwarded to the State Govt. by preparing a list on the basis of the dates on which applications were filed. In the instant case, the Department has forwarded only four applications in the first instance and one application subsequently by short listing. This in my opinion is impermissible. When once applications are filed, all applications should be forwarded provided if they are in order to the State Govt. The State Govt. thereafter has to consider on the basis of the preferential right as per the unamended Section 11 of the Act. In the instant case such procedure has not been followed by the Department.

14. The contention of the State Govt. is that even though the State Govt. has issued notices to other applicants calling upon them to supply the omission or to furnish documents, they have not complied with the requirement as per the notice and therefore, the Department has forwarded only five applications which were in order. Under Rule 26 of the Rules, if there is any deficiency in the application, an opportunity should be given to supply the deficiency. In the absence of non compliance of the requirement, within sixty days from the date of receipt of the notice by the applicants, an opportunity should be given to them before passing an order refusing to grant the mining lease. In the instant case, even assuming that the persons to whom the notices have been issued to comply with the requirements, no opportunity has been given to such of those applicants. The petitioners also were not provided with an opportunity of hearing before taking a decision to reject their applications for grant of mining lessee. Therefore, there is non compliance of Rule 26 of the Rules.

15. It is the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners, that Section 11, as amended is applicable to the facts of this case since Section 11 of the Act has been substituted by Act, 38 of 1999 and it was in force as on the date of consideration of the applications by the State Govt. In support of this submission the learned Counsel for the petitioners relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court, in the case of Indian Metals & Ferro Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India 1991 (5) JTSC 236 : (AIR 1991 SC 818), the Supreme Court in the abovesaid judgment has held as follows at page 840-841; of AIR:—

“20. Now, to turn to the contentions used before us: Dr. Singhvi, who appeared for ORIND, vehemently contended that the rejection of the application of ORIND for a mining lease was contrary to the statutory mandate in S. 11(2); that, subject only to the provision contained in S. 11(1) which had no application here, the earliest applicant was entitled to have a preferential right for the grant of a lease, and that a consideration of the comparative merits of other applicants can arise only in a case where applications have been received on the same day. It is no doubt true that S. 11(2) of the Act, read in isolation gives such an impression which, in reality, is a misleading one. We think that the sooner such an impression is corrected by a statutory amendment the better it would be for all concerned. On a reading of S. 11 as a whole, one will realise that the provisions of sub-section (4) completely overide those of sub-section (2). This sub-section preserves to the S.G a right to grant a lease to an applicant out of turn subject to two conditions, (1) recording of special reasons and (b) previous approval of the C.G it is manifest, therefore, that the S.G is not bound to dispose of applications only on a first come, first served” basis. It will be easily appreciated that this should indeed be so for the interests of national mineral development clearly mining lease should be given to that applicant who can exploit it most efficiently. A grant of M.L in order of time, will not achieve this result.”

From the above, it is clear whether it is amended or un-amended, the application should be considered on its own merits and it is not on “first come first serve basis.” Further, even assuming that the applications are prior to the amendment introduced to Section 11 of the Act, what is the law to be applied is the law that is in force on the date of consideration of the applications on merits. If that is so, all 29 applications, if they were in order and were not rejected after affording opportunity of hearing to applicants as provided under Rule 26, of the Rules should have been forwarded by the Department and the State Govt. should have considered all the said applications on their own merits as contemplated under Section 11(4) of the Act, as if the said applications were filed on the same day.

16. From the records made available by the State Govt. I find the Secretary to the Government, Dept of Commerce and Industries, has made a note which reads as follows:—

“Under the Rules in vogue, all applications for mining leases should be processed only after 30 days, and then it should be collected together irrespective of the date of application and decisions will have to be taken on merits and capacity for performance and then referred to the Govt. for taking appropriate action.”

This aspect of the matter has not been considered by the concerned Minister while taking a decision to grant mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent. From the file, I also find that because of the call by the private secretary to the Hon'ble Minister for Mines, the file has been put up before the Hon'ble Minister for his perusal. Ultimately the concerned Minister has taken a decision to grant mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent. This decision is in violation of all the procedures prescribed under the provisions referred to above.

17. Sri. R.N Narasimha Murthy, learned counsel for repondent 4 submits that Section 11 of the Act, does not provide for affording an opportunity of hearing to the applicants before rejecting their applications for grant of mining lease and therefore, the petitioners are not entitled for hearing even assuming there is a decision by the State Govt. to reject the applications of the petitioners. From the records, it is seen the concerned Minister has taken a decision to grant mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent and at the same time rejected the applications of the petitioners. The argument of Sri. R.N Narasimhamurthy, is that Section 11 of the Act has been amended by Act 38/1999. As per the amended section, no opportunity is required to be given before passing an order rejecting the applications and therefore, Rule 26 which was in force from the beginning has no application and consequently no opportunity of hearing need be given to the applicants before passing an order rejecting their applications. If the intention of the Govt. is that there is no need to afford an opportunity of hearing to the applicants before rejecting their applications for grant of mining lease, as the said applications are required to be considered on merits, the State Govt. would have suitably amended Rule 26 of the Rules to delete sub-rule (1) of Rule 26 after the amendment of Section 11 of the Act. In the instant case, the very fact that Rule 26 is on the statute book it is to be presumed that the Govt. in its wisdom is of the view that an opportunity should be given to the applicant before rejecting his application, even after the amendment of Section 11 of the Act. In these cases as found from the records, no opportunity has been afforded to the petitioners before passing the order rejecting their applications and no opportunity has also been afforded to the other applicants whose applications are still lying in the Dept. without being forwarded to the State Govt.

18. When a statute provides a thing to be done in a particular manner, it should be done only in that manner. In the instant case, no procedure prescribed under the Act and the Rules, has been followed by the State Govt, and thereafter in order to avoid the abuse of process of law, I am of the considered view that the selection if any of the 4th respondent by the State Govt, is to be quashed and all 29 applications filed by the applicants shall be considered in accordance with law and in the light of the observation made above. Hence, I pass the following order:—

Writ Petitions are allowed.

(1) The proceedings of the State Govt. granting mining lease in favour of the 4th respondent are quashed;

(2) Direction is issued to the State Govt. to consider all applications which are pending and pass appropriate orders in the light of the observations made above.

Petition allowed.