Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Carbeauti And Another v. The Karnataka Bank Ltd. And Others

Karnataka High Court
Jun 3, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Dattu, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are defendants in an application (O.A. No. 681/1995) filed by Karnataka Bank Ltd. before the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT) seeking recovery of certain amounts. During the pendency of that application the defendants filed an application under Section 19(6) read with Section 19(8) of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (the Act) read with Rule 19 of the Debt Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1993, requesting permission to raise a counter claim for Rs. 65 lakhs plus current and future interest. The applicant (the Bank) opposed the counter claim.

When the defendants' counter claim application was presented to the Tribunal Registry it was returned with a direction to pay the court fee. The learned Presiding Judge of the Tribunal ordered payment of the requisite court fee to consider the application. The defendants appealed to the Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal, Chennai, in M.A. No. 5/2002. The Appellate Tribunal, by order dated 4.4.2002, allowed the appeal, permitted the appellants to file their counter claim before the DRT, Bangalore with the requisite court fee, and directed the Presiding Officer of the Tribunal to entertain and dispose of the counter claim along with the original application in accordance with law.

The petitioners challenged the Appellate Tribunal's order by filing the present Writ Petition. The petitioners' counsel argued that no provision under the Act or Rules required payment of court fee on the counter claim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a defendant who files a counter claim under Section 19(8) of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (as amending provision), must pay the requisite court fee prescribed under Rule 7 of the Debt Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1993.
  2. Whether the Appellate Tribunal's direction that the defendants pay the requisite court fee before the DRT entertains the counter claim was legally sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Petitioners (defendants) contended that they were not required to pay court fee on the counter claim filed in the original application and that there is no provision under the Act or the Rules requiring payment of court fee on such a counter claim.
  • Counsel for petitioners relied on provisions of Sections 2(g), 19(8) of the Act (including the Amendment/Ordinance of 2000) and Rule 7 of the Rules to support the contention that no court fee was payable.

Applicant (Bank)

The opinion records that the applicant opposed the counter claim, but it does not contain a detailed account of the applicant's specific legal arguments in opposition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Laxmikant R. Bhojwani v. Pratap Singh M. Paradeshi, 1995 6 SCC 576 Explains the limited scope of High Court's jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution where legislature has provided finality to appellate authority; High Court should not assume unlimited prerogative to correct all hardships but intervene only in cases of grave dereliction or flagrant abuse. The court invoked the principle to frame the parameters of interference under Article 227, concluding that interference with the Appellate Tribunal's order was not warranted absent grave injustice; this informed the decision to refuse relief and reject the writ petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by closely analysing the statutory provisions and the Rules cited by the parties, in particular:

  1. Statutory definitions and scheme:
    • Section 2(g) defines "debt" as any liability (inclusive of interest) claimed as due from any person by a bank or financial institution.
    • Chapter IV of the Act governs procedure before the Tribunal; Section 19 deals with applications to the Tribunal.
  2. Counter claim provisions:
    • Section 19(8) permits a defendant, in addition to pleading set-off under s.19(6), to set up by way of counter claim any right or claim in respect of a cause of action accruing to the defendant against the applicant either before or after filing the application but before delivery of the defence.
    • Section 19(9) provides that a counter claim under s.19(8) shall have the same effect as a cross-suit so as to enable the Tribunal to pass a final order on both the original claim and the counter claim.
  3. Rule 7 of the Debt Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rules:
    • Rule 7 requires every application under Section 19 (interlocutory application, application for review etc.) to be accompanied with the fee provided in sub-rule (2); sub-rule (2) contains a table specifying the nature of application and amount of fee.
  4. Construction and legislative context:
    • The court observed that prior to the 2000 amendment, the Act did not provide for counter claims against a bank in the DRT and counter claims based on separate causes of action had to be filed in civil courts with separate court fees. The 2000 amendment inserting s.19(8) remedied that anomaly by permitting counter claims before the Tribunal.
    • Because the counter claim is a separate and independent cause of action and, by s.19(9), has the effect of a cross-suit, the court reasoned it follows that the procedural requirements (including payment of prescribed court fee under Rule 7) apply to such counter claims filed under Section 19.
  5. Application of Article 227 jurisprudence:
    • The court noted the limited scope of interference under Article 227 (as explained in Laxmikant R. Bhojwani) and concluded that the Appellate Tribunal's order — which required payment of the requisite court fee and directed the Tribunal to entertain and dispose of the counter claim upon payment — did not exhibit such grave dereliction or abuse as to warrant interference by this Court.
  6. Conclusion of analysis:
    • The appellate tribunal's conclusion that a counter claim under s.19(8) should be treated as a cross-suit for purposes of enabling the Tribunal to pass final orders, and therefore attract the court fee prescribed under Rule 7, was held to be correctly arrived at by the Appellate Tribunal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Writ Petition was rejected. The High Court found no illegality in the Appellate Tribunal's order directing payment of the requisite court fee on the counter claim and directing the Tribunal to entertain and dispose of the counter claim along with the original application.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The defendants must comply with the Appellate Tribunal's direction to pay the requisite court fee on the counter claim; once paid, the Debt Recovery Tribunal is to entertain and dispose of the counter claim together with the original application in accordance with law.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion does not state that it is setting any new or broader precedent beyond applying the statutory scheme and Rule 7; the court emphasized the existing statutory text and the limited scope for High Court interference under Article 227. The decision affirms that counter claims under s.19(8), treated as cross-suits by s.19(9), attract the application fee requirements in Rule 7.

Disposition

The Writ Petition was rejected without reference to respondents as ordered by the court.

Show all summary ...

Dattu, J.:—

An interesting question arises in this Writ Petition for a decision of this Court. Petitioners herein are the defendants in the application filed by the Karnataka Bank Ltd., in O.A No. 681/1995 pending before the Debt Recovery Tribunal. The application is for recovery of certain amounts from the defendants.

2. During the pendency of the application, defendants have filed an application under Section 19(6) read with Section 19(8) of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 read with Rule 19 of the Debt Recovery Tribunal (procedure) Rules, 1993. In the said application, they have requested the Tribunal to permit them to raise a counter claim in a sum of Rs. 65 lakhs together with current and future interest. That application is opposed by the applicant.

3. When the application was filed by the defendants before the Registry of the Tribunal, the same came to be returned with a direction to pay the Court fee on the counter claim. Basing on the note made by the Registry, the learned Presiding Judge of the Tribunal has ordered for payment of the requisite Court fee to consider the aforesaid application. Aggrieved by the same, defendants in the original application have filed first appeal before the Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal at Chennai, in M.A No. 5/2002. The appellate Tribunal by its detailed and well considered order dated 4.4.2002 has disposed off the appeal and further had permitted the appellants therein to file their counter claim before the Debt Recovery Tribunal, Bangalore, with requisite Court fee, and has further directed the learned Presiding Officer of the Tribunal to entertain the counter claim and dispose off the counter claim along with the original application in accordance with law. Aggrieved by the said order made by the Appellate Tribunal, petitioners are before this Court.

4. Learned Counsel Sri K.V Narasimhan appearing for the petitioners contends that petitioners need not have to pay the Court fee on the counter claim made by them in the original application and further the learned Counsel would submit that there is no provision either under the Act or under the Rules, which requires them to pay the Court fee on the counter claim filed by them in the original application filed by the Karnataka Bank Ltd. In support of these contentions, learned Counsel invites my attention to the provisions of Sections 2(g), 19(8) of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions (Amendment) Ordinance, 2000 (‘Act’ for short) and Rule 7 of the Debt Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1993 (‘Rules’ for short).

5. To appreciate the contentions canvassed by the learned Counsel, provisions of Sections 2(g), 19(8) and 19(9) of the Act and Rule 7 of the Rules requires to be noticed. Therefore, they are extracts. They read as under:

“Section 2(g)-debt: Debt means any liability (inclusive of interest) which is alleged as due from any person by a bank or a financial institution or by a consortium of banks or financial institutions during the course of any business activity undertaken by the bank or the financial institution or the consortium under any law for the time being in force, in cash or otherwise, whether secured or unsecured, or whether payable under a decree or order of any Civil Court or otherwise and subsisting on, and legally recoverable on, the date of the application.

Section 19(8): A defendant in an application may, in addition to his right of pleading a set off under sub-section (6), set up by way counter claim against the claim of the applicant, any right or claim in respect of a cause of action accruing to the defendant against the applicant either before or after the filling of the application but before the defendant has delivered his defence or before the time limited for delivering his defence has expired, whether such counter-claim is in the nature of a claim for damages or not.

Section 19(9): A counterclaim under sub-section (8) shall have the same effect as a cross-suit so as to enable the Tribunal to pass a final order on the same application, both on the original claim and on the counter claim.

Rule 7: Application Fee: (1) Every application under Section 19, interlocutory application or application for review of a decision of the Tribunal shall be accompanied with a fee provided in sub-rule (2) and such fee may be remitter either in the form of crossed demand draft drawing on a nationalised bank in favour of the Registrar and payable at the station where Registrar's office is situated or remitted through a crossed Indian Postal Order drawn in favour of the Registrar and payable in Central Post Office of the station located at any place within local limits of the jurisdiction of a Tribunal.”

6. Section 2(g) of the Act defines the meaning of the expression ‘debt’ which means, any liability inclusive of interest which is claimed as due from any person by a Bank or a financial institution.

7. Chapter IV of the Act provides for procedure before the Tribunal. Section 19 speaks of application to the Tribunal. Section 19(8) of the Act provides for an application being filed by a defendant in addition to his right of pleading a set off as envisaged under Sub-Section (6) of the Act, set up, by way of counter claim against the claim of the applicant any right or claim in respect of cause of action accruing to the defendant against the applicant either before or after filing of the application.

8. Sub-section (9) of Section 19 of the Act provides for the procedure to be adopted by the learned Presiding Officer of the Tribunal while deciding the counter claim. It says, if a counter claim is made under sub-section (8) of the Act by the defendant, the same will have the effect of a cross-suit so as to enable the Tribunal to pass final orders on the same application, both on the original claim and on the counter claim.

9. Rule 7 of the Rules, 1993, provides for payment of the application fee. It says, every application filed under Section 19 of the Act, interlocutory application, application for review of a decision of the Tribunal, shall be accompanied with a fee as provided under sub-rule (2) of Rule 7 of the Rules.

10. sub-rule (2) of Rule 7 of the Rules provides for the table showing the nature of the application and the amount of fee payable on an application for recovery of debts due, application for review, application for interlocutory order and a vakalathnama.

11. Keeping the possible construction that could be placed on the aforesaid provisions and also the parameters of the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution as explained by Apex Court in the case of Laxmikant R. Bhojwani v. Pratap Singh M. Paradeshi . 1995 6 SCC 576. wherein it is stated that where the Legislature has, in its wisdom not provided second appeal or revision to the High Court, the object is to give finality to the decision of the appellate authority and the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India cannot assume unlimited prerogative to correct all species of hardship or wrong decisions. It must be restricted to cases of grave dereliction of duty and flagrant abuse of fundamental principles of law or injustice, where grave injustice would be done unless the High Court interferes, let me notice the fact situation and the orders made by the Appellate Tribunal in M.A No. 5/2002.

12. Bank has filed a suit against the defendants for recovery of debts due to it. After service of notice of the application, the defendants before the Tribunal, have filed an application I.A No. 15/2001 under Section 19(8) of the Act claiming counter claim against the applicants. But, along with the application, they had not paid the requisite Court fee. Office of the Tribunal has taken exception for filing of the application without a proper Court Fee. The note made by the Registry of the office is accepted by the learned Presiding Judge. That is how the matter had gone before the Appellate Tribunal. The Appellate Tribunal after noticing the amended provisions of sub-section (8) of Section 19 of the Act and Rule 7 of the Rules, has come to the conclusion that since the counter claim requires to be decided as a cross-suit, the applicants seeking counter claim should pay the requisite Court fee. This reasoning of the Appellate Tribunal is based on the basis of the language employed in sub-sections (8) and (9) of Section 19 of the Act read with Rule 7 of the Rules.

13. Prior to the amendment of provisions of Section 19 of the Act some time in the year 2000, the Act did not provide for any counter claim and/or damages against the Bank. The Debt Recovery Tribunal had no powers to enforce any claim against the Bank and as such the counter claim could not have been claimed against the Bank. By virtue of the amended provisions namely, sub-section (8) of Section 19 of the Act, a defendant in an application in addition to his right of pleading a set off under sub-section (6), set up, by way of counter claim against the claim of the applicant, any right or claim in respect of a cause of action accruing to the defendant against the applicant. Earlier to the amendment to the provisions of Section 19 of the Act, an application for counter claim was required to be filed before the Civil Court against the bank, since the counter claim is based on separate and independent cause of action. The suit was required to be filed by paying separate Court fee within the period of limitation. Even in such of those cases where the suit and the counter claim is filed by the Bank and the defendant's suit is pending before the Civil Court and after Constitution of Debt Recovery Tribunal, by virtue of Section 31 of the Act, what could be transferred is only the suit filed by the Bank, the counter claim was still required to be delinked from the original suit and decided by the Civil Court alone. Because of this anomalous situation and keeping in view the interest of the defendants also, the Legislature has thought fit to amend the provisions of, Section 19 of the Act by inserting sub-section (8) to Section 19 of the Act, by which the defendants can make an application in addition to his right of pleading a set off as envisaged under sub-section (6) to make a counter claim against the claim of the applicant and since the counter claim is based on separate cause of action, and independent claim against the bank, the same requires to be filed within the period of limitation by paying separate Court fee and by virtue of provision of sub-section (9) of Section 19 of the Act, a counter claim made under sub-section (8) will have the same effect as cross-suit and the Tribunal is required to pass final order on the counter claim by following the procedure as required for disposal of the bank's application filed under sub-section (1) of Section 19 of the Act. Since the application for counter claim is made under Section 19 of the Act, the party, who makes that application is required to pay the Court fee as prescribed under Rule 7 of the Rules. This aspect of the matter has been rightly understood by the Appellate Tribunal while directing the petitioner herein to pay the requisite Court fee on the counter claim made by them in O.A No. 681/1995. In that view of the matter, I do not find any illegality in the orders made by the Appellate Tribunal, which calls for my interference.

14. Accordingly, Writ Petition is rejected without reference to respondents. Ordered accordingly.