Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ujwal Shetty And Another v. Nil

Karnataka High Court
Jul 10, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

A young professional couple whose marriage was solemnised on 9 May 2001 jointly petitioned under Section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act for dissolution of their marriage. The petition was filed before the Family Court on 27 September 2001, before the statutory one-year period had expired. [1][2]

The parties also applied under Section 14 for leave to present the petition prematurely. The Family Court initially granted that leave but subsequently dismissed the petition on 15 December 2001 solely because it had been filed before the expiry of one year. [2][3][4]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Family Court could dismiss the Section 13-B petition on the ground of prematurity after it had already granted leave under Section 14 to present it before one year had elapsed. [2][3]
  2. Whether the marriage should be dissolved under Section 13-B in light of the parties’ continuing desire for dissolution and the absence of subsisting claims between them. [5][4]

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Section 13-B ordinarily barred presentation of the petition until one year had passed from the date of marriage. Section 14 permitted earlier presentation where exceptional hardship or grave depravity was shown. [1]

The Family Court had considered the Section 14 application and granted leave to present the petition prematurely. The appellate court held that this order became final, and that there was no need for the Family Court to reconsider prematurity at a later stage. [2]

After independently examining the Section 14 application and confirming the position with counsel and the parties’ parents, the appellate court found that the reasons for early presentation were valid and that leave had been properly granted. [6]

The appellate court criticised the subsequent dismissal because the later presiding Judge had effectively questioned, reviewed, or sat in appeal over the earlier order of the same Family Court. [3]

The court further noted that the required procedures had otherwise been completed, the couple continued to desire dissolution, and neither side had any subsisting claims against the other. It therefore concluded that the petition should have been allowed. [5]

Holding and Implications

The appeal succeeded, the Family Court’s order dated 15 December 2001 was set aside, and the marriage solemnised on 9 May 2001 was dissolved by decree under Section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act. [4][7]

The direct effect was dissolution of the parties’ marriage, with no order as to costs. The opinion discusses no broader implications and sets no new precedent. [7]

Show all summary ...

1. A rather unfortunate situation has arisen in this case where, a young couple both of whom are professionals presented a petition under Section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act, to the Family Court praying for dissolution of their marriage which had been solemnised on 9-5-2001. Under Section 13-B there is a bar to the presentation of the petition unless one year has expired since the date of the marriage. Section 14 however prescribes that if it is a case of exceptional hardship or, on the other hand, if it is a situation of grave depravity etc., that the parties may apply to the Court for waiver of this condition in which case, the petition can be presented earlier.

2. The petition under Section 13-B was presented before the Family Court on 27-9-2001 which is hardly four months after the marriage was solemnised. An application was filed under Section 14 of the Act, setting out certain very valid reasons why the Court should be pleased to allow the parties to present the petition prematurely i.e, before the period of one year has elapsed. The record indicates that the learned Judge presiding over the Family Court considered the application and granted the leave to present the petition. In our considered view, once the Court has granted the leave that position assumes finality and there was really no need for the learned Judge presiding over the Family Court at a later stage to address himself once again to the aspect of prematurity at any stage thereafter.

3. Out of abundant caution however we have taken the precaution of examining the application filed under Section 14. We have ascertained from the learned Advocate who represents the joint petitioners as also from the parents of the couple who are present in Court and we are satisfied that the reasons that were presented to the Trial Court for entertaining the petition earlier were valid and that the Court very rightly granted the sanction to present the petition prematurely.

4. After the parties appeared before the Trial Court at the stage of passing orders, the learned Judge has re-examined the position and he has dismissed the petition on the solitary ground that it was presented prior to the period of one year having elapsed. We are surprised at the approach that was adopted because, as pointed out by us earlier, the Family Court had considered the application under Section 14 and had passed the necessary order according its sanction to present the petition prematurely and it was not open to the learned Judge who was presiding over that very Court at the time when the petition was to be disposed of, to virtually question or sit in appeal or review the earlier order that had been passed by his predecessor who was presiding over the same Court.

5. Though the parties are not present before us, the record indicates that the requisite procedures have been complied with before the Trial Court and but for the aforesaid reason the Trial Court would have granted a decree of dissolution of marriage under Section 13-B. Since some time has passed we have re-ascertained from the parents of the respective parties who inform us that the couple are still desirous of dissolution of the marriage and secondly, that there are no claims of any type subsisting on either side.

6. Having regard to this position, the order dated 15-12-2001 passed by the Family Court is set aside. The petition under Section 13-B of the Act is allowed. Marriage solemnised between the appellants on 9-5-2001 shall be dissolved through a decree under Section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act.

7. Office to draw up the decree accordingly.

8. The appeal succeeds and stands disposed of. No orders as to cost.