Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shakti Prakash v. Hindustan Machine Tools Limited (Hmt Limited) And Another

Karnataka High Court
Nov 2, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant filed an Original Second Appeal (O.S.A) challenging the order dated 24.11.2000 passed by the learned Company Judge in Company Petition No. 8/1998. The Company Judge declined to issue a direction for winding up of the respondent company but allowed the appellant to file a suit regarding the disputed amount in accordance with law. The appellant claimed payment of bills for work executed along with interest and issued a notice demanding payment of interest and additional penal interest, which went unanswered. The appellant contended that despite confirming the actual due amount and denying liability to pay interest, the company did not pay, prompting the winding up petition. The respondent company argued it had deposited more than the claimed bills and made sufficient payments during the pendency of the proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Company Court can issue a winding up order under Section 433 of the Companies Act based on a disputed contractual claim for payment and interest.
  2. Whether non-payment of bill amount under a contractual agreement constitutes an admitted debt warranting winding up of the company.
  3. The scope and applicability of Section 433 of the Companies Act in the context of contractual disputes between a creditor and a company.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant is a small scale industry entitled to interest once it entered into a contract with the respondents.
  • The learned Company Judge erred by not considering paragraph 7 of the petition and by holding that no conditions were shown for applicability of the Companies Act for winding up.
  • The appellant contended it was entitled to winding up on the basis of the interest amount claimed.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent company deposited Rs. 16,49,260.31 and made sufficient payments during the pendency of the proceedings.
  • The appellant withdrew the deposited amount without prejudice to its rights.
  • The company denied liability to pay interest and disputed the claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court noted the existence of a contract between the appellant and the respondents which must be governed by its terms. It emphasized that any violation of contractual terms does not automatically invoke Section 433 of the Companies Act to warrant winding up. The court explained that the Company Court is not intended to function as an ordinary Civil Court to adjudicate contractual disputes or to hold trials on claims of individual creditors. The court observed that non-payment of bills under a contract, especially when disputed, cannot be treated as an admitted debt. It clarified that a debt generally refers to borrowed money under settled terms, which can be renegotiated. Given these considerations and the fact that the company is not shown to be unable to pay its debts, the court found no basis to invoke Section 433 for winding up. Consequently, the order of the learned Single Judge was upheld and the appeal dismissed.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the Original Second Appeal, thereby affirming the order of the learned Company Judge declining the winding up of the respondent company.

The direct effect of this decision is that the appellant must pursue its disputed claim through ordinary civil proceedings rather than by winding up proceedings. The court’s decision clarifies that Section 433 of the Companies Act cannot be invoked merely on the basis of disputed contractual claims and that winding up is not the appropriate remedy for such disputes. No new precedent was set beyond the reaffirmation of the established principles regarding the scope of winding up petitions under the Companies Act.

Show all summary ...

Jain, C.J:—

This O.S.A is filed against the order of the learned Company Judge dated 24.11.2000 passed in Co. P. No. 8/1998 whereby the learned Company Judge has declined to issue a direction for winding up of the company. However the learned Company Judge left it open to the appellant to file a suit in regard to the disputed amount in accordance with law.

2. In the instant case the appellant claimed payment of bills for the work executed along with interest and notice was issued for payment of interest and also additional penal interest. No reply was sent. However, it is stated that on earlier reply to notice confirming the actual due and denying the liability to pay any interest, the company did not pay the amount and therefore filled this petition for winding up.

3. The learned Counsel for the respondents-company has stated that the company has deposited more than the bills claimed and also made sufficient payments during the pendency of proceedings. The learned Single Judge on consideration found that it is seen that payment made by the first respondent during the pendency of the writ exceeded the amount claimed by the petitioner and for the claim of interest which has been denied by the respondent, directed to file a suit in regard to the said disputed amount in accordance with law as stated above.

4. The main grievance of the learned Counsel for the appellant is that the appellant is a small scale industry, and once it has entered into a contract with the respondents, the appellant is entitled to interest and the learned Company Judge has lost sight of paragraph 7 of the petition. The learned Company Judge has erred in observing that no averment was made in the petition to show that the conditions prescribed for applicability of the Act apply to the supplies by the appellant to HMT and therefore it is entitled to get winding up on the basis of the interest amount claimed.

5. On the other hand, learned Counsel for the company submits that they have deposited the amount of Rs. 16,49,260.31 ps. and the appellant has withdrawn the same without prejudice to his rights.

6. We have heard the learned Counsel for the appellants and the learned Counsel for the respondent and perused the material on record.

7. On consideration, we find that as per the averments there is a contract between the appellant and the respondents and the same has to be dealt with as per the terms of the agreement. Any violation of the terms of the contract cannot ipso facto come within the purview of Section 433 of the Companies Act for winding up for the company. It is also seen that it is not the legislative intention that Company Court should be converted itself into a ordinary Civil Court and proceed to hold a trial at the instance of individual claiming to be a creditor of the company on the basis of a contract. Under the circumstances, no direction as prayed for can be issued. It is also seen that non-payment of bill amount under a contractual agreement cannot be said to be an admitted debt, even when it is disputed. That apart debt is something which is borrowed by a person on settled terms and conditions and settled rate of interest and it can also be resettled between the parties. Be that as it may. In any view of the matter and in the facts of the given case, it cannot be said that company is unable to pay its debt and Section 433 cannot be invoked. As discussed, we do not find any error or illegality in the order of the learned Single Judge so as to call for any interference. This writ appeal is dismissed.

CJ: & VGSJ:

27.11.2001

O.S.A No. 6/2001

This case has come for “for being spoken to” today.

Learned Counsel for the parties submit that this O.S.A has been dismissed on 2.11.2001, but due to inadvertence, in the Judgment at page 3 in para 3, at 7th line, it has been typed as “during the pendency of the Writ” instead of “During the pendency of the Company petition” and in the last line of page-5, it has been typed as “Writ Appeal” instead of “Appeal”.

While maintaining the order, it may be read as follows:

“during the pendency of the Company Petition” at page-3 in para 3 at 7th line and “Appeal” at page-5 in the last line.

Ordered accordingly.