Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vishista Solvent Oil... v. Deputy Commissioner ...

Karnataka High Court
Aug 2, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by V.K. Singhal, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

Two writ petitions were heard together and disposed of by a common order because they involved the same controversy. The petitions challenged assessment orders which treated solvent extracted oil (produced from oil cake and sold to vanaspati manufacturing units or refining units) as non-edible oil for tax / assessment purposes. The petitioners relied on statutory control orders and the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955, as well as a circular of the Commissioner and an expert opinion from the Director, Oil Technological Research Institute, Anantapur, to contend that the solvent extracted oil (unrefined) is within the scope of "edible oil" (as a non-refined edible oil or a "potential edible oil") and thus should be classified accordingly for tax purposes. The respondents contended that the oil in question is vegetable non-edible oil not fit for direct human consumption and relied on prior case law and Commissioner circulars to support their classification. The petitions sought relief from the assessment treatment and related tax consequences.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether solvent extracted oil obtained from oil cake (and sold to vanaspati/refining units) falls within the statutory category of "edible oil" (including non-refined edible oil) for purposes of classification and taxation.
  2. Whether the regulatory Control Orders (e.g., Solvent Extracted Oil, De-oiled Meal and Edible Flour (Control) Order, 1967 and related orders) and the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules render solvent extracted oil "non-edible" or whether they merely regulate sale for direct human consumption until refining is completed.
  3. Whether the decision in B.P. Oil Mills Ltd. v. Sales Tax Tribunal (1998) — which construed "manufacture" in the context of another state's Sales Tax Act and found that processing could radically alter crude oil into marketable refined oil — is applicable to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act when that Act does not define "manufacture".

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The solvent extracted oil manufactured from oil cake should be treated as "edible oil" (specifically non-refined edible oil) within the meaning of applicable statutes, including the Essential Commodities Act and the Pulses, Edible Oil Seeds and Edible Oils (Storage Control) Order, 1977 (as amended).
  • The Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955 include non-refined sunflower oil extracted from oil cake within the definition of edible oil; thus unrefined solvent extracted groundnut oil is a "potential edible oil" and not "non-edible".
  • An expert opinion (Director, Oil Technological Research Institute, Anantapur) supports that unrefined solvent extracted groundnut oil is essentially groundnut oil and is edible after refining; chemically and physically it remains groundnut oil.
  • A circular issued by the Commissioner treated oil manufactured from oil cake as edible oil (non-refined), supporting petitioners' classification approach.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The oil produced by the petitioner from oil cake via solvent extraction is vegetable non-edible oil and is not fit for direct human consumption.
  • From April 1, 1993, a separate entry in Part E of the Second Schedule treated certain edible oils distinctly; the respondents asserted the petitioner's interpretation of the Second Schedule entry was incorrect.
  • Solvent extracted oil sold to vanaspati manufacturing or refining units is not intended for direct human consumption and therefore should not be treated as edible oil for the relevant tax entries.
  • Reliance was placed on prior decisions (including State of Uttar Pradesh v. Kores and Chandausi Oil Mills) and Commissioner circulars dated July 20, 1991 and July 31, 1991 which, as represented by respondents, support the proposition that solvent extracted oil cannot be considered as edible oil (non-refined) under the relevant Schedule.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Kores (India) Ltd., [1977] 39 STC 8 (SC) Cited by respondents to support the view that solvent extracted oil cannot be considered as edible oil (non-refined) under the Second Schedule (as interpreted by the Allahabad High Court). The court recorded that respondents relied on this authority but considered the broader statutory and regulatory scheme and expert opinion in reaching a different conclusion on classification under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act.
Chandausi Oil Mills v. Sales Tax Commissioner, U.P., [1961] 12 STC 310 (All.) Cited by respondents; the Allahabad High Court occasioned to consider the meaning of "edible oil" and held solvent extracted oil cannot be considered as edible oil (non-refined under the Second Schedule to the KST Act). The court noted this decision was relied upon by respondents but analyzed statutory definitions and control orders and reached conclusions contrary to the broad application of that authority to the facts under the Karnataka Act.
Milkhi Ram Oil & Dali Mills v. State of Punjab, [1992] 84 STC 206 (P&H) Considered washed cotton-seed oil as edible oil; found cotton seed oil is to be further processed for refining. The court noted this authority as part of the authorities regarding whether certain crude/unrefined oils can be considered edible oil subject to refining; it informed the court's view that some unrefined oils may be edible after refining.
Tungabhadra Industries Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, [1960] 11 STC 827 (SC) Explains that refining removes non-oleic matter and that refined oil continues to be the same oil (e.g., groundnut oil) despite changes in colour, taste and odour. The court relied on the reasoning to support the proposition that refining does not change the basic character or identity of the oil, a point relevant to classifying solvent extracted oil as falling within the genus "edible oil".
State of Maharashtra v. Shiv Datt & Sons, [1992] 84 STC 497 (SC); 1993 Supp (1) SCC 222; AIR 1992 SC 692 Held that immersing a battery in electrolyte and charging was not a process of manufacture (example of activities not amounting to manufacture). Included among authorities illustrating that various alterations or processes do not necessarily amount to manufacture; used to situate the question whether refining/processes change identity of goods.
State Of Maharashtra v. Central Provinces Manganese Ore Co. Ltd., [1976] 39 STC 340 (SC); (1977) 1 SCC 643; AIR 1977 SC 879 Mixing of different grades of manganese ore and selling under a different name was not considered a manufacturing process. Relied on as an authority that certain operations which change appearance or grade do not necessarily create a new commodity; used for analogy in assessing whether processing/refining creates a new commodity.
Tata Exports Ltd. v. Union of India, (1985) 22 ELT 732 (MP) Pigment slurry prepared by mixing pigment powder with water and wetting agents was held not to amount to manufacture of a new and different commodity. Referenced among cases illustrating operations that do not amount to manufacture; used in the court's purposive comparison of processes that may not change the essential identity of a good.
Commissioner of Sales Tax, U.P. v. Harbilas Rai and Sons, [1968] 21 STC 17 (SC) Cleaning and arranging bristles and tying them in bundles was not considered a process of manufacture. Referred to as an example reinforcing the principle that certain processes leave the core identity intact and thus are not manufacture.
Commissioner of Sales Tax, Lucknow v. D.S. Bist, [1979] 44 STC 392 (SC); (1979) 4 SCC 741; AIR 1980 SC 169 Tea grown by agriculturist undergoing processes continued to be agricultural produce; processing did not change its character. Used to support the proposition that processing may not change the fundamental character of a product for statutory classification.
Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax (Law), Board of Revenue (Taxes), Ernakulam v. Pio Food Packers, [1980] 46 STC 63 (SC); 1980 Supp SCC 174; AIR 1980 SC 1227 Processing of pineapple into slices and packing did not make it a different commodity; it retained original identity. The court used this as an illustration that removal of inedible portions and other processes do not necessarily alter the commodity's essential identity for classification.
B.P. Oil Mills Ltd. v. Sales Tax Tribunal, [1998] 111 STC 188 (SC) Considered the definition of "manufacture" (in the U.P. Sales Tax Act) and observed that processing may radically change crude oil to marketable refined oil; the crude oil taxed earlier was held liable to pay tax again after refining. The court distinguished this authority: since the Karnataka Sales Tax Act contains no definition of "manufacture", the extended meaning relied upon in B.P. Oil Mills could not be applied to the Karnataka Act. Thus the court found B.P. Oil Mills inapplicable to the present statute.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the controversy by examining statutory classifications, control orders, expert technical opinion, and precedent to determine the proper classification of solvent extracted oil for tax purposes under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act.

  1. Statutory framework and schedules: The court noted that under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, entry 1 of Part E of the Second Schedule classifies edible oil into non-refined, refined and hydrogenated oil and cooking oil. From April 1, 1988, non-refined and refined oils were taxed at the same rate (4%), and from April 1, 1995 they were taxed at the same lower rate (2%). The court emphasized that the legislature did not, in the Schedule, contemplate a difference between refined and non-refined edible oils for the purpose of classification and tax rate.
  2. Regulatory control and production rules: The court examined the Solvent Extracted Oil, De-oiled Meal and Edible Flour (Control) Order, 1967, and related Vegetable Oil Products Orders, which regulate production and prohibit sale of solvent extracted oil for direct human consumption unless it is refined to prescribed quality standards. The Control Order defines solvent extracted oil as vegetable oil obtained by the use of solvent and prohibits its direct sale for human consumption in the public interest.
  3. Expert technical opinion: The court considered the opinion of the Director, Oil Technological Research Institute, Anantapur, which stated that solvent extracted groundnut oil is essentially groundnut oil and that while it contains more soluble impurities (and solvent residues such as hexane), chemically and physically it remains the same oil and is "potential edible oil" that becomes fit after refining.
  4. Nature of processing and identity of the commodity: Drawing on authorities and technical description of refining processes, the court reasoned that refining primarily removes non-oleic impurities (free fatty acids, phosphatides, waxes, colouring matter, etc.) and does not change the basic character or identity of the oil. The court observed that both oil obtained from direct crushing/expeller and oil obtained from solvent extraction share the same basic character as oil derived from the seed, differing mainly in impurity content (including solvent residues in the case of solvent extracted oil).
  5. Interpretation of "edible oil" in public and statutory senses: The court concluded that, in popular and statutory senses, "edible oil" is a genus that includes the species refined and non-refined oils as well as hydrogenated oils. The Control Orders' prohibition on direct sale of solvent extracted oil for human consumption was seen as a public health/regulatory restriction, not as a legislative exclusion of solvent extracted oil from the category "edible oil" per se. Thus oils that become fit for human consumption after processing (refining) may still fall within the broader genus "edible oil".
  6. Tax treatment and legislative intent: The court reasoned that it was unlikely the legislature intended to tax refined oil at a higher or different rate while excluding oil that becomes edible only after refining; such an interpretation would produce anomalous results (e.g., double taxation or penal treatment) inconsistent with rates and entries in the Second Schedule. The notification dated March 30, 1992 (published March 31, 1992) reducing tax on edible oils (non-refined) was read to indicate the phrase "non-refined edible oil" applies broadly and includes oils which become edible after refining.
  7. Application of precedents and distinction of B.P. Oil Mills: The court surveyed numerous precedents indicating that certain processes do not change the essential identity of goods and that refining need not be treated as manufacture creating a distinct commodity. Specifically regarding B.P. Oil Mills (1998), which had applied an extended meaning of "manufacture" under the U.P. Sales Tax Act and held crude oil could be taxed again after refining, the court distinguished that decision on the ground that the Karnataka Sales Tax Act contains no definition of "manufacture". Therefore, the extended interpretation in B.P. Oil Mills could not be applied under the Karnataka statute.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Writ petitions allowed.

Direct consequence: The court directed the respondents to pass fresh orders in the assessments challenged in the writ petitions, keeping in view the observations made in the opinion (including statutory interpretation, regulatory context, expert opinion, and the court's analysis regarding the identity of the oil and inapplicability of B.P. Oil Mills to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act).

Broader implications: The opinion explains the court's interpretative approach — that solvent extracted oil is not excluded from the genus "edible oil" merely because it requires refining before being fit for direct human consumption, and that regulatory prohibitions on direct sale do not equate to a statutory classification as "non-edible." The court expressly distinguished the B.P. Oil Mills decision for lack of a comparable statutory definition of "manufacture" in the Karnataka Act. The opinion does not explicitly state that it establishes a new binding precedent beyond the decision for the parties and the directed fresh assessments.

Order: Petitions allowed; respondents to pass fresh orders in light of the court's observations.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

V.K Singhal, J.:— Both these writ petitions are disposed of by a common order since the controversy involved is one and the same.

2. Assessment orders have been challenged on the ground that the solvent extracted oil sold to vanaspathi manufacturing units or to refining units has been wrongly treated as non-edible oil. A circular was also issued’ by the Commissioner, in which, the oil manufactured from oil cake was treated as edible oil (non-refined). It is submitted that, the manufacturer is covered by the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 and the Pulses, Edible Oil Seeds and Edible Oils (Storage Control) Order, 1977, as amended from time to time governs the storage of solvent extracted oil. “Edible oils” is defined under clause 2(g) in which, it is stated that, any oil used directly or after processing for human consumption and includes hydrogenated vegetable oil, is an edible oil. Under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955, the edible oil will include the non-refined sunflower oil extracted from oil cake. Non-refined edible oil has been used only to make a distinction that it could be consumed after refining. The opinion of the Director, Oil Technological Research Institute, Anantapur, has also been produced in the petition, which is to the following effect:

“(1) In India, the groundnut oil cake is solvent extracted to recover all the available oil present in the oil cake. Groundnut (seeds) are not subjected to solvent extraction directly, though, it is technically feasible. In advanced countries like U. K., U.S.A, and West Germany and Canada, high oil content seeds like groundnut, sunflower, soyabean, rapeseed, and mustard, cotton seed, etc., are directly solvent extracted from recovery of oils.

To make matters clear, I would like to state that the groundnut oil cake is nothing but cooked, crushed and partially de- oiled groundnut seed. Therefore, the oil obtained either from the groundnut seed or groundnut oil cake remains nothing but groundnut oil and both are very much groundnut oils.

Basically, the chemical and physical characteristics of both the oils are one and the same, except, they may vary in the contents of soluble impurities, colour and flavour.

(2) The unrefined solvent extracted groundnut oil cannot be termed as ‘non-edible’ as pointed out in your letter. On the other hand, it is perfectly edible oil, only after refining, and therefore, it should be known as potential edible oil.”

3. On behalf of the respondents, it is stated that the edible oil which is produced by the petitioner is from oil cake from the process of solvent extraction, and is vegetable non-edible oil, and is not fit for human consumption. From April 1, 1993, there is a separate entry enumerated in Part E of the Second Schedule as edible oils other than the edible oils falling under serial No. 28 of the Fifth Schedule which included non-refined and refined oils and hydrogenated oils. The contention of the petitioner that the goods fall under entry 1 of Part E of the Second Schedule as edible oil other than edible oils falling under serial No. 28 of the Fifth Schedule as non-refined oil was not accepted as correct interpretation. Since oil meant for direct human consumption could be considered as edible oil and not the oil which is sold to vanaspathi manufacturing units or to refining units. Reliance is placed on the judgment given in State of Uttar Pradesh v. Kores (India) Ltd., [1977] 39 STC 8 (SC) and in Chandausi Oil Mills, Chandausi, Moradabad v. Sales Tax Commissioner, U.P, [1961] 12 STC 310 (All.). The Allahabad High Court occasioned to consider the meaning of edible oil. It was held that solvent extracted oil cannot be considered as edible oil (non-refined under the Second Schedule to the KST Act). Circulars of the Commissioner dated July 20, 1991 and July 31, 1991 was also relied.

4. In Milkhi Ram Oil & Dali Mills v. State of Punjab, [1992] 84 STC 206 (P&H), washed cotton- seed oil, was considered as edible oil. It was found that the cotton seed is to be further processed for refining.

5. I have considered over the matter.

6. Under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, under entry 1, Part E of the Second Schedule, edible oil has been classified as non-refined, refined and hydrogenated oil and cooking oil. Non-refined and refined oil from April 1, 1995 has been treated at par and earlier for the period from April 1, 1988 to March 31, 1995, they were liable to tax at 4 per cent and with effect from April 1, 1995, they are taxable at 2 per cent. We are not concerned with SI. No. 28 of the Fifth Schedule in respect of the product of village industry. Solvent Extracted Oil, De-oiled Meal and Edible Flour (Control) Order, 1967 regulates production of solvent extracted oil. The solvent extracted oil cannot be sold for the purpose of direct human consumption and could be sold after refining. The refining has to be in accordance with the standard of quality prescribed. The sale or movement of stock of solvent extracted oil, cannot be to any other person and the user has to use the oil for the intended purpose. There is another Vegetable Oil Products (Control) Order, 1947, under which, vegetable oil product has been defined that any vegetable oil subjected to a process of hydrogenation in any form, or an admixture thereof with any other substance for edible purpose. In the Vegetable Oil Products (Standards of Quality) Order, 1975, names of various vegetable oils have been given, from which hydrogenated oils can be produced, which includes solvent extracted oil as well. From the opinion of the Director, Oil Technological Research Institute, Anantapur, it is opined that the solvent extracted oil cannot be treated as non-edible oil, though, it becomes edible, after refining. In Tungabhadra Industries Ltd., Kurnool v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kurnool, Kiirnool, [1960] 11 STC 827 (SC), it was observed that:

“When raw groundnut oil is converted into refined oil, there is no doubt processing, but this consists merely in removing from raw groundnut oil that constituent part of the raw oil which is not really oil. The elements removed in the refining process consist of free fatty acids, phosphotides and unsaponifiable matter. After the removal of this non-oleic matter therefore the oil continues to be groundnut oil and nothing more. The matter removed from the raw groundnut oil not being oil cannot be used, after separation, as oil or for any purpose for which oil could be used. In other words, the processing consists in the non-oily content of the raw oil being separated and removed, rendering the oily content of the oil 100 per cent. For this reason refined oil continues to be groundnut oil within the meaning of rules 5(1)(k) and 18(2) notwithstanding that such oil does not possess the characteristic, colour, or taste, odour, etc., of the raw groundnut oil.

6.(a) Groundnut, gingelly, coconut and mustard oils are used for human consumption since they are free from phosphates, waxes and other impurities and are used for human consumption and which are known as traditional oils. Sunflower, soyabean, cotton seed, rice bran, palm and safflower oils are not fit for human consumption as they contain impurities and toxic substances like phospholipids, proteinous matters, carbohydrates, resins, colouring matters, fatty alcohols and high melting waxes and free fatty acids. These impurities are removed by the process of degumming, neutralization, bleaching and deodorization. In degumming oils is heated at a temperature of 60-65°c by the use of high pressure steam. 0. 1 per cent of food grade phosphoric acid is mixed to the heated crude oil to precipitate the phosphatides or gums. After precipitation the oil is pumped into the heat exchanger.

In neutralization, the temperature of degummed oil is increased to 70-75°c by the use of high pressure steam and the degummed oil is pumped into the mixer through the oil flow meter. Pre-calculated caustic soda lye is added to the crude oil through the flow meter, oil emulsion and caustic soda are subsequently passed through to the centrifuge which is a highly sophisticated machinery that revolves at 15,000 rpm facilitating the separation of oil and soap slurry by centrifugal force. Free fatty acids are converted into soap stock which is a by-product. Soap stock is separately collected and is sold as raw material in the manufacture of acid oil. Crude oil so converted passed through a series of plate heat exchangers and the temperature is cooled to 20°c and fed to the crystallizer where the temperature is further reduced to 5°c by the technology known as winterization. In the process of reduction in temperature, wax is sliced. Neutral oil is allowed to settle in order to allow the precipitated wax to mature which then forms into mature crystals. Wax which has come out is used as a raw material in cosmetics, pharmaceuticals and polish industries. The temperature of dewaxed oil is then reduced to 80-90°c by using high pressure steam and a proportionate quantity of boiling water is infused into the oil. Oil emulsion and water is passed through water washing centrifuge separators.

In bleaching, neutral oil is increased to 100°c by the use of high pressure steam moisture is eliminated. Activated bleaching earth and activated carbon are added. The product is again churned under vacuum. Neutral oil is bleached by the method of adsorption and absorption. The temperature of oil is reduced to 75°c to avoid oxidation and oil is filtered through pressure leaf filters and filtered oil then collected in storage tanks. Spent earth and carbon are then dried out by steam and discharged.

Bleached oil is then transferred to the deodoriser which is maintained under high vacuum throughout the operation. High vacuum in the deodoriser is produced by ejector booster system. The product is then heated up to 190°c and live steam is sparged through the oil. Volatile matters known as aldehides and ketones which are responsible for odour and residual free fatty acids are vapourised at this temperature and distilled under high vacuum. The distillate is then collected in the fatty matter catch all. The temperature is further reduced to 80°c and the oil is pumped into the vacuum cooler. The oil is now refined. The temperature is further reduced to 40°c and filtered through a polish filter to give a shine to the oil. The oil so refined is fit for human consumption.

6.(b) “Groundnut oil” gets rancid in hot and humid season due to oxidative degradation of unsaturated fat present in it and is normally used for soap making, but the basic character of the oil remain that of groundnut oil.

In State of Maharashtra v. Shiv Datt & Sons, [1992] 84 STC 497 (SC); 1993 Supp (1) SCC 222 : AIR 1992 SC 692 immersing the battery in electrolyte and charging with electric current was not considered the process of manufacture.

In State Of Maharashtra v. Central Provinces Manganese Ore Co. Ltd., [1976] 39 STC 340 (SC); (1977) 1 SCC 643 : AIR 1977 SC 879 mixing of different grades of manganese ore and selling it by giving different name was not considered to be manufacturing process.

In Tata Exports Ltd. v. Union of India, (1985) 22 ELT 732 (MP), pigment slurry prepared, by mixing pigment powder with water consisting of chemical wetting agents was held, does not amount to manufacture of a new and different commodity.

In Commissioner of Sales Tax, U.P, Lucknow v. Harbilas Rai and Sons, [1968] 21 STC 17 (SC) cleaning and arranging of bristles according to their sizes and colours and tying them in bundles was not considered as process of manufacture.

In Commissioner of Sales Tax, Lucknow v. D.S Bist, [1979] 44 STC 392 (SC); (1979) 4 SCC 741 : AIR 1980 SC 169 tea grown by agriculturist undergoing processes were held continued to be agricultural produce.

In Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax (Law), Board of Revenue (Taxes), Ernakulam v. Pio Food Packers, [1980] 46 STC 63 (SC); 1980 Supp SCC 174 : AIR 1980 SC 1227, processing of pineapple fruit into pineapple slices for the purpose of being sold in sealed cans, the commodity continues to possess its original identity, notwithstanding the removal of inedible portions from the pineapples slicing and packaging it, was held that it does not become a different commodity.

7. In the case of solvent extracted oil also, impurities are removed, but the basic character of oil remains. Edible oil is a genus which has both the species, viz., refined and non-refined beside the hydrogenated oil. The Legislature has not contemplated any difference while specifying the edible oil in Part E in the Second Schedule between refined and non-refined and same rate of tax continues from April 1, 1988 for both the species. Thus, it can be considered that in popular sense the edible oil would include refined oil as well as non-refined oil. The Control Order, 1977 also covers within the sweep of edible oil all those oils which are used directly for human consumption or which could be used after processing. The Solvent Extracted Oil, De-oiled Meal and Edible Flour (Control) Order, 1967 has regulated the production and sale of solvent extracted oil and thus, it is only after the process through which, the solvent extracted oil has to go, it could be sold for human consumption, i.e, after refining. It could not have been the intention of the Legislature, that refined edible oil if subjected rate of tax, and the petitioner has to pay higher rate of tax on the non-refined oil and then he is deprived of lesser rate of tax. The Karnataka Sales Tax Act has not defined edible oil and even if the definition, in common parlance, is taken into consideration, then, it is the oil produced from a particular seed which is considered as edible oil. While extracting oil from the oil seed, different process of extractions are employed. There may be even a situation where the oil seed is crushed and no oil is taken at the stage any by a solvent extraction process, the entire oil is extracted. In another process, after crushing, certain oil is obtained and the residue remained in the oil cake is extracted by solvent extraction process. Even different machinery used for expellers may have the potentiality to extract different percentage of oil. The oil extracted from the expeller, though could be used directly for human consumptions, but contains impurities. Similarly, the oil extract from the oil cake also contains impurities, more particularly of hexane which is the solvent and the oil so obtained is known as solvent extracted oil. The Control Order prohibits sale of solvent extracted oil for direct human consumption. Solvent Extracted Oil, De-oiled Meal and Edible Flour (Control) Order, 1967 defines the solvent extracted oil as vegetable oil in any form obtained by the use of solvent. In the public interest, the Control Order prohibits the sale of such solvent extracted oil directly for human consumption unless it is refined. Even if the oil which is obtained from crushing of oil-seed, the Legislature may restrict to sell it unless it is refined. Hence some percentage of impurity always remains even in the oil which is obtained by the process other than the solvent extract process. The basic character of the oil which is obtained from crushing/expeller from the seed as well as the oil obtained from the oil cake remains the same, except, to the extent of impurity of hexane. It is for this reason that there is a prohibition for direct sale of such oil. Refining has been considered as not changing the basic character of the oil and as such, the solvent extracted oil cannot be considered as not falling within the proper category of edible oil.

8. Notification dated March 30, 1992 published on March 31, 1992 reduced the rate of tax on edible oils (non-refined) at 3 per cent. The entry of which is at SI. No. 1, Part E of the Second Schedule. The word non- refined edible oil applies to all types of non-refined oils and the word edible oil could be considered in respect of those edible oils which becomes edible oil after refining. There may be certain edible oils which are non-refined and still they are edible, that however will not be excluded.

9. In B.P Oil Mills Ltd. v. Sales Tax Tribunal, [1998] 111 STC 188 (SC) definition of “manufacture” in the U.P Sales Tax Act, 1948 was considered which envisages processing as well. It was observed that:

“firstly, because it considered the definition of “manufacture”

(which, of course, is identical with its definition under the Act) in the context of ‘resale’ of goods as defined in that Act and secondly, because of the nature and extent of the process which the crude oil undergoes to radically change itself to marketable refined oil.”

10. The crude oil on which the tax was paid was accordingly held liable to pay tax again on sale of oil after refining. Under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, there is no definition of “manufacture” and therefore the judgment which was given in the case of B.P Oil Mills Ltd. v. Sales Tax Tribunal, [1998] 111 STC 188 (SC) based on extended meaning of definition of “manufacture” cannot be made applicable to the provisions of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act. Writ petitions are allowed. The respondents are directed to pass fresh orders keeping in view the observations made above.

11. Petitions allowed.