Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Miss. Pushpaleela v. State Of Karnataka And Others

Karnataka High Court
Apr 17, 1998
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed as a Public Interest Litigation on behalf of victims who lost eyesight following cataract operations conducted at a Free Eye Camp in Chintamani (Kolar District) on 28–29 January 1988. The camp was organised under the joint auspices of the Lions Club of Chintamani and Bangalore and the Commonwealth Society for the Blind, New Delhi. 151 persons were operated upon; subsequently 72 persons lost sight in one eye and 4 persons lost sight in both eyes due to post-operative infection. A number of affected persons were shifted to Minto Regional Institute of Ophthalmology, Bangalore and S.N.R. Hospital, Kolar for treatment.

Procedurally, this Court had earlier, by order dated 23-6-1988, directed interim compensation of Rs. 5,000 to each of the four totally blind persons (in addition to Rs. 1,000 already paid). By order dated 6-9-1988, this Court directed Rs. 250 per month to each of 66 victims; the Government issued orders implementing those payments. A one-man Commission of Enquiry headed by Padmabhushan Dr. P. Shiva Reddy was constituted on 3-3-1988 and submitted a report on 2-11-1989 (the Court reproduced the report's conclusions in the opinion). A further Government order dated 6-10-1990 ordered a detailed joint enquiry against the surgeons; the outcome of that enquiry was not stated in the opinion. During the pendency of writ petitions, 27 of the victims died and 45 remained alive. The present petition seeks directions for adequate compensation, medical facilities and rehabilitation for the victims.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether negligence was committed by the doctors and those organising/operating the Free Eye Camp that caused loss of sight to the victims.
  2. What amount of compensation is payable to the victims (or their legal representatives) in light of the facts, earlier interim payments, and remedial steps taken by the State and others.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Position

  • The petition was filed in public interest on behalf of the victims who lost eyesight after the surgeries at the Free Eye Camp; the petitioner prayed for directions to respondents to pay adequate compensation, provide medical facilities and rehabilitate victims under welfare schemes.
  • The petition emphasised the loss of sight, the suffering and the inadequate relief already provided, seeking lump-sum compensation and rehabilitative measures.

Respondents' Objections

  • The respondents did not dispute the factual matrix: they admitted the conduct of operations, the number of persons affected and related facts.
  • The respondents contended that they provided the best treatment possible until the victims were cured and sought to justify actions taken after the tragedy.
  • The State expressed sympathy and stated it would do its best to rehabilitate the victims; common statements of objection were filed but did not contest the primary factual findings.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded on the following lines, strictly as set out in the opinion:

  1. Initial task: The Court framed the issues as whether negligence occurred in the conduct of the eye-camp surgeries and what compensation should be awarded.
  2. Investigative basis: The Court relied substantially on the detailed report of the one-man Commission of Enquiry headed by Padmabhushan Dr. P. Shiva Reddy (report dated 2-11-1989), reproducing the report's conclusions and observations as evidence of causation and negligence.
  3. Findings from the Commission's conclusions (reproduced verbatim in the opinion):
    • The selected site/building for operations was unsuitable: operating room lacked doors and shuttered windows; lavatories were very close to the theatre and not closed during surgery — creating a real possibility of infection.
    • The procedure adopted for sterilisation was unsatisfactory and could have caused infection.
    • Paramedical staff were inexperienced in sterilization and theatre assistance; absence of methodical assistance, lack of job allocation and lack of expert supervision increased the risk of human error.
    • Although bacteriological tests of saline used showed no pathological organisms, the saline had been exposed continuously and could have become a source of infection.
    • The Commission allocated responsibility to specific personnel: Surgeons of the Mobile Ophthalmic Unit (Dr. H.N. Thimma Setty) and the staff nurse (Smt. Nancy D'Souza) were to be held responsible for the tragedy because of failure to ensure proper pre-operative, operative and post-operative care; the greatest lapse identified was in sterilization procedures.
  4. The Court further reproduced detailed observations from the Commission describing specific lapses in practice, including:
    • Single nurse performing multiple roles (preparing theatre, sterilizing instruments, assisting during operations, writing notes) — an implausible and unsafe practice for the volume of work.
    • Lady Health Visitors with no theatre experience assisting surgeons.
    • Absence of a confident, dedicated person supervising sterilization; same staff carrying used and unused instrument trays and assisting surgeons.
    • Improper handling of linen sterilization — transfer from autoclave to previously sterilized drum that was repeatedly opened, rendering linen unsterile.
    • Immersion of sharp instruments in Ethicon fluid one day and transferring to cidex the next day was inadequate.
    • Only six sets of instruments used for four tables — insufficient instrument sets.
    • Non-pressure water sterilizer placed in operating room, making conditions hot and uncomfortable.
    • Saline for irrigation was prepared at Victoria Hospital, exposed continuously and thus could have been a source of infection.
  5. On the basis of these conclusions and observations, and noting that the Government of India guidelines for organising eye camps were not properly followed, the Court concluded that the tragedy resulted from non-precautionary measures and failure to follow prescribed guidelines; this established carelessness and negligence in the conduct of the camp surgeries.
  6. Assessment of compensation: The Court noted interim and continuing payments already made (including Rs. 5,000 interim to each of four totally blind persons and Rs. 250 per month to victims), acknowledged post-operative treatments and rehabilitative steps taken by the State and others, but found those measures insufficient. The Court stated that justice required lump-sum compensation and specified the quantum for different categories of victims (set out in the holding).
  7. Supplementary orders: The Court ordered that interim monthly payments continue until the lump-sum amounts were paid, clarified that the lump-sum awards exclude amounts already paid, restricted the award to the present case (not to serve as precedent), and awarded costs of Rs. 5,000 to the petitioner for prosecuting the petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was allowed. The Court directed the respondents to pay lump-sum compensation in specified amounts to victims and legal representatives, to continue interim monthly payments until the lump sums were paid, and to pay costs of Rs. 5,000 to the petitioner. The Court ordered payment of compensation within two months and costs within four weeks from the date of the judgment.

The specific compensation structure ordered by the Court (as reproduced in the opinion) is:

  • Legal representatives of victims who lost vision (and have died):
    • If death occurred within two years of the incident: Rs. 40,000
    • If death occurred after two years up to the date of judgment: Rs. 50,000
  • For those who have lost sight of one eye and are alive now: Rs. 75,000
  • For those who have lost vision of both eyes: Rs. 1,50,000

Implications (as expressly stated by the Court):

  • The lump-sum compensation ordered is to be paid within two months, and interim payments of Rs. 250 per month shall continue until such payment is made.
  • The compensation ordered is exclusive of any amounts already paid to victims.
  • The Court explicitly limited the award to the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case and stated that the quantum awarded "shall not be a precedent or guiding factor for any other case."
  • The direct effect on the parties is monetary relief to the victims or their legal representatives and an award of costs to the petitioner; no broader precedent or general rule was declared by the Court for application in other cases.

DISPOSITION: Petition allowed; directions for payment of compensation and costs as stated above.

Show all summary ...

1. In this petition filed by way of Public Interest Litigation on behalf of the victims who have lost the eye-sights consequent upon the operations conducted in the Free Eye Camp at Chintamani during the year 1988, the petitioner has prayed for a direction to the respondents to pay adequate compensation and all other medical facilities to the victims and to suitably rehabilitate them under any of the welfare schemes.

2. The brief facts of the case are that on 28th and 29th January 1988 a Free Eye Camp was organised at Chintamani in Kolar District under the joint auspecies of Lions Clubs of Chintamani and Bangalore and Common Wealth Society for the Blind. New Delhi. 151 persons were operated for cataract problem at Vasavi Kalyana Mandira and their list has been produced as Annexure-A in the connected W.P No. 4351/88 which was dismissed for non-prosecution on 26-5-1997. Among them 72 persons had lost one eye-sight, 4 victims had lost both the eyes on account of infection developed after the surgery with severe pains. The affected victims were shifted to Minto Regional Institute of Opthalmology. Bangalore and S.N.R Hospital Kolar to provide medical assistance. On 3-3-1988 the Government constituted a one-man Commission of Enquiry headed by Padmabhushana Dr. P. Shiva Reddy to enquire into the circumstances leading to the tragedy and to suggest remedial measures and to submit a report. Such a report was submitted on 2-11-1989 copy of which has been produced at page 26 along with the Synopsis filed by the Government Advocate. We shall later refer to the report. In the meantime, by an order dated 23-6-1988 this Court directed payment of Rs. 5,000.00 as interim compensation to the four persons who have become totally blind, in addition to the sum of Rs. 1,000.00 already paid. Vide Government Order dated 1-8-1988 such a payment had been made. Thereafter, on 6-9-1988 this Court had directed payment of Rs. 250.00 per month to each of the 66 victims. By Government order dated 7-8-1990 the said amount has been paid and such payment is being made as of today. At present there are only 45 victims alive and the remaining 27 victims have died during the pendency of the writ petitions. The list of the remaining victims is produced. On behalf of the respondents common statement of objections have been filed for both the writ petitions. Whatever facts stated above have not been disputed by the respondents. The conduct of operation, the number of persons affected and all other facts have been admitted. On the other hand, what the respondents have contended is that they have provided the best treatment possible till the victims were completely cured. Respondents sought to justify the action they have taken after the tragedy had occurred. At the end it is stated that the Stale Government has sympathy for the victims and will do their best to rehabilitate the victims. This is the sum and substance of the objections filed on behalf of the respondents.

3. In the light of the aforementioned facts, it has to be tested as to whether there was negligence on the part of the doctors who had performed the operations and what is the amount of compensation payable to the victims.

4. It is to be noted that the Government by its order dated 6-10-1990 has ordered a detailed joint enquiry against the surgeons who had performed the operations to the ill-fated victims. It is not known as to what happened to that enquiry. However, the fact remains that a considerable number of persons have been affected after the operations. Much investigation is not necessary to ascertain as to whether the damage had been caused on account of negligence and carelessness in conducting the eye camp in the light of the report submitted by Padmabhushan Dr. P. Shiva Reddy. The conclusions/opinion arrived at in the said report are self-explanatory and they are reproduced hereunder in order to arrive at a conclusion. The conclusions/opinion are as under:—

“After going through the above points and in view of my personal examination of the camp site and personal examination of the persons involved, I feel that the following circumstances could have led to the tragic incident that has caused loss of sight to some of the patients got operated at Chintamani Eye Camp:—

1. The site/building selected for conducting operations was not suitable since the room in which operations were performed has got no doors and shuttered windows. In addition, the lavatories were also very close to the theatre and were not closed during surgery. Hence, there was every possibility of getting the cases infected.

2. The procedure adopted for sterilisation was most unsatisfactory as discussed earlier and could have been a cause for infection.

3. The paramedical staff, who have worked in the camp were not experienced in handling the sterilization and assisting the surgeons in theatre. As per the statements of the individuals, the surgery was not assisted by the individuals methodically. No particular job was entrusted to each individual and the entire camp lacks expert supervision and guidance, which could have given way for human error.

4. Though the result of the bacteriological examination of saline used for washing sharp instruments and irrigation of Anterior chamber during surgery shows presence of no pathological organisms, it could have been a source of infection since it was exposed continuously.

5. I find that the Surgeons of the Mobile Opthalmic Unit, Dr. H.N Thimma Setty and the Staff Nurse. Smt. Nancy D'Souza are to be held responsible for the tragedy that has taken place, as I feel that it is their responsibility to look after the pre-operative, operative and post-operative care of the patients. I find that the greatest lapse is the procedure adopted for sterilization of the instruments, equipment and the appliances etc. in the operation theatre”.

5. In order to arrive at the above conclusions, it was observed that:—

“A single nurse preparing theatre, sterilizing the instruments, doing 150 syringings and assisting the Surgeon during operations with limited sets and writing operation notes was unbelievable.

Lady Health Visitors, who have got no theatre experience, assisting the surgeons in theatre was unimaginable.

Handling of sterilization of instruments was done by the deputed staff on whom the surgeon has got no confidence. In addition, no particular individual had supervised the sterilization. The same staff was also made to carry the trays of instruments, used and unused, and to assist the Surgeons during operations.

Linen was sterilized in a single drum autoclaved and later transferred to a big dressing drum that was previously sterilized by flaming with surgical spirit. Repeatedly the drum was opened to remove the contents of the small autoclaved drum. Thus making it unsterile.

Immersion of sharp instruments in Ethicon fluid one day before operations and transferring to cidex next day was not sufficient.

Only six sets of instruments were used, which are not sufficient for four tables.

The procedure adopted in washing and the used instruments is also not satisfactory. The non-pressure water sterilizer was placed in the operation room itself, making the place hot and uncomfortable for the operating surgeon as well as the other staff.

The saline which was used for irrigation of A/c during the surgery was made at Victoria Hospital. Bangalore and further exposed continuously could have been a source of infection.”

6. The Government of India has fixed guidelines for organising Eye Camps. The report says that the said guidelines have not been followed properly. It is also held that the procedure adopted for sterilisation was not up to the mark. Thus, it becomes clear that as a result of non-precautionary measures taken and on account of not following the guidelines prescribed by the Government of India, the tragedy had occurred. The carelessness and negligence are evident from this. While performing operations on important vital organs like eyes, special care and attention should have been taken. That has not been done in the instant case. Consequently, the poor, illiterate and aged villagers have become the victims and sufferers.

7. Now coming to the quantum of compensation payable to the victims, it is no doubt true that shall amount has already been paid towards compensation and a sum of Rs. 250.00 is being paid every month to the victims. What has been paid and is paying will not be sufficient for the poor victims who have lost their vision for no fault of theirs. For such persons, justice must not only be done but must be seen to be done. We bear in mind that the poor victims have lost their vision and had suffered a lot on account of severe pains. They have been deprived of their normal functioning on the one hand and were made a burden to the family. Some of them are no more now? But the sufferings they undergone cannot be forgotten. At the same time, we also take note of the steps taken by the State and other organisations in the matter of providing post operation treatments, the rehabilitative measures undertaken and the compensation amount paid and is being paid every month. Taking into consideration the overall circumstances of the case and the situation in which the ill-fated victims were placed, we are of the opinion that ends of justice would be met if lump sum compensation is awarded to the victims in the following manner:—

(a) Amount payable to the legal representatives of the victims who have lost vision of one or both eyes and who have died:—

i) Within two years of the incident Rs. 40,000-00 ii) After two years upto now Rs. 50,000-00 b) For those who have lost sight of one eye and alive now Rs. 75,000-00 c) For those who have lost vision of both eyes Rs. 1,50,000-00

8. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed and we direct the respondents for payment of compensation as above within two months from today. Until the payment of the compensation awarded as above, the payment of interim compensation that is being paid now shall continue.

9. We make it clear that the compensation ordered above is excluding what ever compensation already paid having regard to the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case treating this as a special case.

10. The quantum of compensation awarded herein shall not be a precedent or guiding factor for any other case. The compensation awarded is restricted to this case only.

11. Before parting with, the case, we feel it necessary to observe that even though the connected W.P No. 4351/88 was also filed in public interest namely in the interest of the present victims, the petitioners in that writ petition have not prosecuted the same and allowed the same to dismiss for non-prosecution. However, the petitioner has in the present petition has prosecuted it properly and was successful in securing justice to the ill-fated victims. While appreciating her social work, we feel that it is necessary to award costs to her for the interest she has shown in the public cause, the pains she has taken as also the money and time spent for the prosecution of this case. Accordingly, we direct payment of costs of Rs. 5,000.00 by the first respondent to the petitioner within four weeks from today.

12. Petition allowed.