- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Oil Seeds, Oil Trade... v. State Of Karnataka A...
Structured Summary of the Opinion (V.P. Mohan Kumar, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
These writ petitions arise from a clarification issued by the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (the 2nd respondent) under section 3-A of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957. The clarification stated that de-oiled rice bran cake does not fall within the classification of "rice bran" in the Second Schedule to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act and should instead be taxed under the residuary clause, section 5(1). Prior to the clarification, the department had been assessing the product as “rice bran” (Part C, entry 8(iii) of the Second Schedule). The petitioners challenge the Commissioner’s clarification.
The petition was heard by V.P. Mohan Kumar, J., with Mr. Kishore Mallya and Mr. Nazeer representing the petitioners and Ms. S. Sujatha, learned Government Pleader, appearing for the respondents. The Court disposed of the writ petitions by quashing the Commissioner’s clarification (annexure A) and holding that de-oiled rice bran falls within the ambit of Second Schedule, Part C, entry 8(iii).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether rice bran and de-oiled rice bran cake are one and the same product or are different products.
- Whether de-oiled rice bran cake should be classified under Part C, entry 8(iii) of the Second Schedule to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act or treated as a residuary item taxable under section 5(1) as per the Commissioner’s clarification.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments (as summarised in the opinion)
- Rice bran and de-oiled rice bran cake are practically the same commodity; the only change is a reduction in oil content.
- An analysis report (Central Poultry Training Institute, Bangalore) shows that all ingredients of rice bran remain present after oil extraction (moisture, ash, acid insoluble ash, crude fat, crude fibre, crude protein and carbohydrate); there is no transformation in molecular structure or creation of a new product.
- Because the character and ingredients remain, de-oiled rice bran should be covered by Part C, entry 8(iii) (rice bran) of the Second Schedule.
Respondents' Arguments (as summarised in the opinion)
- De-oiled rice bran undergoes a material change — primarily reduction of fat/oil content — and the resulting commodity is different from rice bran.
- The statute itself contemplates different entities (rice bran, oil-cake, rice bran oil) and therefore the commodity after oil extraction is a distinct stage not covered by the Schedule and hence falls in the residuary entry under section 5(1).
- Reliance on the common parlance rule of interpretation (as applied in cited Supreme Court decisions) to contend that a consumer of "rice bran" would not be satisfied by de-oiled rice bran for all purposes.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sri Lakshmi Coconut Industries v. State of Karnataka, [1980] 46 STC 404 (Kar) | Principles for interpreting sales-tax entries: use ordinary/common parlance for non-technical terms; avoid interpretations that create multi-point taxation; if two interpretations reasonably possible, favour the assessee. | The Court adopted these principles as the foremost guide to interpret whether de-oiled rice bran retains the character of "rice bran" and to resolve classification in favour of the assessee where reasonable doubt exists. |
| Omrao Industrial Corporation (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Sales Tax Officer, [1974] 33 STC 343 (All.) | Descriptive exposition of de-oiled rice bran as a bye-product of rice-milling; used normally as cattle feed and an ingredient in mixed feed after de-oiling. | The Court relied on the case’s description and Survey of India's material to show de-oiled rice bran retains the characteristics and uses of rice bran (especially as cattle/poultry feed), supporting classification under rice bran. |
| Bhagwan Oil and Potato Chips Factory v. State of U.P., [1975] 35 STC 514 (All.) | Consideration of whether oil-cake constitutes cattle feed and related analysis of de-oiled bran use. | The Court noted this authority supports the view that de-oiled rice bran continues to be used for feed and is not devoid of the character of rice bran after de-oiling. |
| Mukesh Kumar Aggarwal & Co. v. State of Madhya Pradesh, [1988] 68 STC 324 (SC) | Application of the common parlance rule in interpreting fiscal statutes (example: distinction between timber and firewood). | The Government Pleader relied on the decision; the Court distinguished its application here, observing that where meaning is not in doubt and the commodity retains its characteristics, recourse to the common parlance rule does not change the classification. |
| Annapurna Biscuit Manufacturing Co. v. Commissioner of Sales Tax, [1981] 48 STC 254 | Illustration of construing tax-law words in ordinary local parlance and context (example: whether biscuits are "cooked food"). | The decision was cited by respondents to support reliance on common parlance; the Court acknowledged the rule but held it inapplicable where there is no difficulty in understanding the expressions and the commodity's characteristics persist. |
| Mariamman Industries v. State of Tamil Nadu, [1986] 61 STC 358 (Mad.) | Another example applying common parlance theory in classification under sales tax schedules. | The Court noted the authority but reiterated that common parlance is not determinative where the technical/chemical analysis demonstrates continuity of character between rice bran and de-oiled rice bran. |
| Hinde v. Allmond, (1918) LJKB 893 (cited within other authority) | Example used in prior authority to explain context-driven common-sense interpretation of statutory words (whether tea was an "article of food"). | Used illustratively by earlier authority cited in the opinion; the Court did not base its decision on this older example but acknowledged its use in precedent discussing common parlance. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a structured way.
- Interpretative framework: The Court began by recalling established principles (as summarized in Sri Lakshmi Coconut Industries) for construing entries in sales-tax laws: use ordinary/common parlance for non-technical terms, avoid interpretations that would lead to multipoint taxation on the same commodity, and if two reasonable interpretations exist, adopt the one favouring the assessee.
-
Character of the product: The Court examined scientific analysis (Central Poultry Training Institute, Bangalore) comparing rice bran and de-oiled rice bran. The analysis showed:
- Rice bran contains crude oil/fat among other ingredients (moisture, ash, crude fibre, crude protein, carbohydrate).
- After oil extraction, the percentage of oil is substantially reduced but all other ingredients remain present; protein percentage may increase by proportion, but there is no change in the presence of those constituents.
- There is no alteration of molecular structure nor emergence of new chemical components; oil remains traceable and can be reintroduced (soaking de-oiled bran in oil restores oil content).
- Functional use and purpose: The Court observed that the primary commercial use of both rice bran and de-oiled rice bran is for manufacture of cattle and poultry feed. The purpose for which rice bran is de-oiled is to make it more suitable for feed; removal of oil is not a change of commodity but a preparation for the same end use.
- Statutory construction and limits of administrative clarification: Although the statute lists separate entries for rice bran, oil-cake and rice bran oil, the Court held that this does not authorize the Commissioner to exclude de-oiled rice bran from the rice-bran entry by administrative clarification when de-oiled rice bran materially retains the characteristics of rice bran. If the Legislature intended to create a distinct taxable entry for "de-oiled rice bran cake," it could have done so.
- Treatment of contrary authorities: The Court acknowledged several authorities relied upon by the respondents on the common parlance rule but distinguished them. It accepted that where the meaning is unclear, common parlance is relevant; however, where the product's characteristics and commercial use are clear and show continuity between pre- and post-processing materials, the common parlance rule does not justify reclassification into the residuary entry.
- Conclusion of analysis: Applying the interpretative principles to the scientific and commercial facts, the Court concluded that de-oiled rice bran does not become a different commodity merely because oil has been extracted and hence must be held to fall within the rice bran entry in the Second Schedule.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The Court quashed the Commissioner’s clarification (annexure A) and held that de-oiled rice bran cake falls within the ambit of Second Schedule, Part C, entry 8(iii) of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957.
Direct implications for the parties:
- The administrative clarification treating de-oiled rice bran as outside the "rice bran" entry and placing it under the residuary clause (section 5(1)) has been annulled.
- De-oiled rice bran is classified under the Schedule item that the opinion identifies as "rice bran" (Part C, entry 8(iii)). The opinion earlier notes that rice bran under that entry is taxed at 2% with effect from April 1, 1997; the Court’s classification places de-oiled rice bran within that Schedule entry.
- The writ petitions were disposed of accordingly and annexure A was quashed.
Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new general principle beyond its application to the facts before the Court. It resolves classification for the product at issue and restricts the scope of the Commissioner’s administrative clarification in this context.
Disposition: Writ petitions disposed of as stated in the opinion.
V.P Mohan Kumar, J.:— Common question arises for consideration in all these petitions. The question posed for consideration is whether rice bran and de-oiled rice bran cake are one and the same or different products. As per entry 8(iii) of Part C of the Second Schedule, rice bran is taxed at 2 per cent with effect from April 1, 1997. Part O of Second Schedule, entry 1 deals with oil-cake. Part R of Second Schedule, entry 7 deals with rice bran oil. They are separately taxed. The position was that rice bran, which undergoes the process and from which rice bran oil is extracted, is sold thereafter for manufacture of fodder as de-oiled rice bran cake. The department hitherto was assessing the same as rice bran coming under Part C, entry 8(iii) of Second Schedule. While so, a clarification has been issued by the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, the 2nd respondent herein, to the effect that it does not come within the classification of rice bran provided in the Schedule to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957 and as such, it should be taxed under the residuary clause, namely, section 5(1). This has given rise to the controversy in these proceedings. The petitioners herein challenge the clarification issued by the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes invoking his power under section 3-A of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act.
2. I have heard Mr. Kishore Mallya and Mr. Nazeer, learned counsel for the petitioners, as also Ms. S. Sujatha, leamsd Government Pleader appearing on behalf of the respondents. At the outset, we will keep in mind the rale of interpretation to be followed while interpreting fiscal statutes and what has been laid down in this behalf by the Supreme Court in many cases. Following the said construction of interpretation, their Lordships in Sri Lakshmi Coconut Industries v. State Of Karnataka, [1980] 46 STC 404 (Kar), stated as under:
“11. The principles which should be applied in the interpretation of entries in the sales tax laws laid down by the Supreme Court in the various decisions referred to earlier may be summarised as follows:
(1) A sales tax statute, being one levying tax on goods, any particular term used to specify an item of goods on which tax is levied, must, not being a term of science or art, be presumed to have been used in the ordinary sense and, therefore, it should be understood according to the meaning ascribed to it at common parlance. Therefore, while interpreting any item subjected to tax under the sales tax laws, resort should be had to their popular meaning or the meaning attached to them by those dealing in them, i.e, in the commercial sense and not to the scientific or technical meaning of such term.
(2) If the intention of the Legislature was to levy a single point tax on a particular item, an interpretation which would in effect result in the levy of multipoint tax on the same commodity should not be given,
(3) If two interpretations are reasonably possible, the one in favour of the assessee should be accepted.
Therefore, the decision on the crucial question arising for consideration in these cases, viz., as to whether the desiccated coconut has to be considered as coconut and nothing more or it should be treated as a separate commercial commodity and, consequently, liable to tax under the Central Act also, should be arrived at by applying the aforesaid principles.”
3. Therefore, the foremost consideration when interpreting these entries would be to understand the meaning of the expression in the common parlance and if two interpretations are possible to adopt and interpret the same in a manner which, as far as possible, would be beneficial to the assessee.
4. The first question to be considered, therefore, would be to understand as to what is “de-oiled rice bran cake”. Mr. Kishore Mallya, learned counsel for the petitioners, placed before me the result of the analysis report made by the Central Poultry Training Institute, Bangalore, with respect to rice bran and de-oiled rice bran. It is seen from the analysis report that rice bran contains a larger extent of crude oil and fat. After the distilling process is completed and oil therein is distilled, what remains is only traces of oil content, whereby it is reduced to a negligible extent. In that process, we notice that protein contents of the rice bran has increased from what it was before distilling of the oil. But one has to notice that all ingredients of rice bran remains the same. It contains moisture, ash, acid insoluble ash, crude fat, crude fibre, crude protein and carbohydrate. There is absolutely no change in these ingredients. The molecular structure of the rice bran cake does not alter. All that what it denotes is that there is a variation in the percentage of oil after the distilling of the oil. There is no transformation of other items. The manufacturing process used in this behalf is only to distill the oil and the rice bran remains the same minus large content of oil. The oil is still traceable in the contents to a negligible extent. There is no release of a new product with different chemical components. As there is no total transformation, it does not cease to possess the character of rice bran even after the distilling is over. Here, it is pertinent to note that it is still possible to restore the character of rice bran provided the de-oiled rice bran is soaked in the rice bran oil. By that, whatever that lost is regained. In the circumstances, it is not easily possible to say that there has been a change of character in the rice bran by virtue of the extraction of oil.
5. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners was that rice bran and de-oiled rice bran are practically one and the same and there is no change. According to them, all that is done is that, as far as possible, the oil content is separated, the character of the other ingredients of the rice bran remains the same and has not changed and as such it cannot be said that de-oiled rice bran is a different product from rice bran. It should also be covered by entry 8(iii) made mention of above.
6. On the contrary, the contention of Ms. Sujatha, learned Government Pleader appearing for the respondents, is that there is a total change in the components of the de-oiled rice bran. She submits that the fat contents of the oil in rice bran is lost and is reduced and there is difference in the oil contents. The commodity thus produced after the oil extraction process is different from the rice bran subjected to oil extraction. She further submits that by virtue of the provision in the statute itself, it can be seen that the statute contemplated 3 different entities. In the first place, it taxes rice bran as entry 8(iii). Secondly, it taxes the oil cake, thirdly it taxes the rice bran oil. It necessarily contemplates a stage between rice bran and rice bran oil. That commodity is what is not covered by the Schedule and, therefore, it is a residuary. It is hence to be taxed as a residuary item under section 5(1) of the Act. I do not think the contention of the learned Government Pleader can be accepted. The rice bran has certain properties. It is constituted of several ingredients. The ingredients remain the same even after extraction of oil. All that has taken place is that some of the quantum of oil ingredient has decreased whereas other ingredients have not decreased. No new product is brought out by this process. As stated by soaking the rice bran cake in rice bran oil, the oil content can be restored. Hence, there is no change in the commodity. The rice bran, as noticed by this Court, can be used for the same purpose for which the rice bran cake is also utilised, namely, cattle feed (as the primary use of rice bran is for manufacture of cattle and poultry feed). In order to extract oil, it is treated by a process and that whatever remains is still usable as the cattle feed. The oil forms part of rice bran; it is unnecessary for the cattle feed and hence it is removed. One cannot say that by this removal, the de-oiled rice bran loses the character of rice bran. It is to be remembered that there is no total transformation and production of a different product by virtue of the extraction of oil. The de-oiled rice bran cake does not lose the character of rice bran as noticed from the scientific analysis report and the ingredients that are present in the rice bran are still present in the de-oiled rice bran cake. As such it has to be held that the de-oiled rice bran cake continues to remain the same even after oil is extracted from it. It is to be noted, as submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner, that the oil which may not be a helpful ingredient for the manufacture of the cattle feed is removed, so as to make a rice bran useful for manufacturing cattle feed. It is certainly not a case of transforming to some other commodity.
7. Several decisions were cited in this behalf by the respondent side. I do not think it is necessary to advert to these decisions. But nevertheless, we may deal with [1974] 33 STC 343 (All.) [Omrao industrial Corporation (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Sales Tax Officer] and [1975] 35 STC 514 (All.) (Bhagwan Oil and Potato Chips Factory v. State of Uttar Pradesh) which deal with the case which considered the case as to whether oil-cake is a cattle feed. In this behalf in [1974] 33 STC 343 (All.) [Omrao Industrial Corporation (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Sales Tax Officer] their Lordships have considered the question as to what are the characteristics of de-oiled rice bran; after referring to the Survey of India's Export Potential of Oil-Cakes, Vol. IV, page 1, it was statedjas hereunder:
“De-oiled rice bran : Rice bran is a bye-product of rice (paddy) and is the basic raw material for rice bran oil. During the process of rice-milling, the layer round the endosperm is removed together with a portion of the polishing. This separated layer is called ‘rice bran’. The quantity of rice bran obtained is variable as it depends upon the degree of polishing. Bran constitutes roughly 6 to 10 per cent of paddy rice. Bran is normally used as cattle feed.”
8. These details furnish the constituents of the rice bran.
9. Then after de-oiling process, it is noticed as hereunder:
“The de-oiled rice bran is mainly used as an ingredient for mixed feed for poultry and pigs in more advanced countries like the U.K, Japan and the U.S.A in addition to being used as cattle feed.”
10. This also indicates that the essential use of rice bran is for manufacturing cattle feed.
11. Therefore, there is no difference between the use of rice bran and de-oiled rice bran and that also indicates as to what is the classification to be adopted. In Bhagwan Oil and Potato Chips Factory v. State of Uttar Pradesh case, [1975] 35 STC 514 (All.) referred to above, also proceed on the same line. It also indicates that de-oiled rice bran is not devoid of the character of rice bran after the process of de-oiling. In contrast, the learned Government Pleader cited the decision of the Supreme Court, reported in [1988] 68 STC 324 (Mukesh Kumar Aggarwal & Co. v. State of Madhya Pradesh) to highlight her contention that the meaning of the expressions occurring in fiscal statute in particular, should be understood applying the common parlance theory. In the said case, their Lordships were considering the question as to the difference between the expressions timber and firewood. The relevant entry in the statute reads as follows:
“32A : Timber Entry 12 : Firewood and charcoal. Entry 1 : All other goods not included in Schedule I or any other part of the Schedule.”
12. The question was as to whether eucalyptus firewood and Nilgiri fuelwood, etc., are timber within the meaning of Schedule II. After discussing the various issues, their Lordships took the view that in understanding the meaning of the expression, the description of the articles in common parlance should be applied. As there existed in the statute a specific entry as “timber” and “firewood”, the rule of interpretation applied there cannot apply to the question herein. Likewise, the learned Government Pleader cited the decision of the Supreme Court reported in [1981] 48 STC 254 (Annapurna Biscuit Manufacturing Co. v. Commissioner of Sales Tax, U.P). In particular, she relied on the following passage:
“It is a well-settled rule of construction that the words used in a law imposing a tax should be construed in the same way in which they are understood in ordinary parlance in the area in which the law is in force. If an expression is capable of a wider meaning as well as narrower meaning the question whether the wider or the narrower meaning should be given depends on the context and the background of the case. In Hinde v. Allmond, (1918) LJKB 893 the question was whether tea was an ‘article of food’ within the meaning of an order designed to prohibit the hoarding of food, namely, Food Hoarding Order of 1917. The learned Judges held it was not, even though in some other decisions it had been held to be an ‘article of food’. Shearman, J., one of the Judges, said that he rested his judgment on the ‘common sense interpretation of the word “food” in the order, apart from its meaning in any other statute’. It is interesting to note that in a case before the Allahabad High Court in Annapurna Biscuit Manufacturing Co. v. State of U.P, [1975] 35 STC 127, the assesses had contended that biscuit was an article of confectionery and that contention was negatived. It is relevant to note, as we have mentioned earlier, that when tie Hindi text of the notification was issued contemporaneously with the English version, the words *pakaya hua bhojan were used as the equivalent of the words ‘cooked food’.
It may be that biscuit is served at tea time and in its wider meaning ‘cooked food’ may include biscuit. But ordinarily biscuit is not understood as cooked food. If a person goes to a hotel or restaurant and asks for some cooked food of pakaya hua bhojan certainly he will not be served with biscuits in Uttar Pradesh. While it is not necessary to state in the present case as to what all items may be called as cooked food, we can definitely say that in the context and background of the notification biscuit cannot be treated as cooked food.”
13. If this rule is applied, according to her, a customer needing rice bran will not be satisfied with de-oiled rice bran. Fir similar purpose, she relied on the decision of the Madras High Court in Mariarnman Industries v. State of Tamil Nadu, [1986] 61 STC 358 wherein their Lordships have considered the question in understanding the meaning of the expression on the basis of common parlance theory. One cannot quarrel with this proposition. It is true that the common parlance theory has to be applied in cases where here is difficulty in understanding the expression; but when it is not so, there is no need to depend on the common parlance theory. We find that here there is absolutely ho difficulty in understanding the meaning of rice bran and de-oiled rice bran which still retains all ingredients of rice bran. It is not a totally different product. When the Schedule to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act has clearly indicated as to what are all the items to be included, it had classified by specific connotation of expression two distinctive commodities, namely, rice bran and rice bran oil. If so, all commodities possessing the characteristics of rice bran are to be classified thereunder. There cannot be a classification of an item, namely, “rice bran with lesser quantity of oil”. If there is an intention to tax separately rice bran oil cake, nothing prevented the Legislature from doing so and it is not in the province of the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes to issue a clarification and bring in de-oiled rice bran cake also into the purview of residuary item by declaring the same to be a different and independent commodity. The same is covered by the. Second Schedule, Part C, entry 8(iii) and as such the clarification issued calls for interference.
14. In view of what is stated above, I am of the view that annexure A cannot be sustained. I, therefore, quash the same. I hold that de-oiled rice bran comes within the ambit of the Second Schedule, Part C, item 8(iii) of the Act. The writ petitions are disposed of as above.
15. Writ petitions disposed of accordingly.
Alert