Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

P.A Kulkarni And Another v. State Of Karnataka And Another

Karnataka High Court
Dec 18, 1998
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Gangaram Building Collapse

Factual and Procedural Background

On 12 September 1983 at about 3:13 p.m. a multi-storeyed building under construction in Bangalore collapsed. The building is described in the opinion as located at the Gopal Film Theatre Complex, abutting Subedar Chatram Road and Ananthashram Road in Bangalore. The petitioners allege 118 persons died and 67 persons were seriously injured as a result of the collapse; the affidavit filed on behalf of the State acknowledges 118 deaths and states 50 persons were injured. The building is variously identified in the opinion with the names "Ganga Ram" and "N. Gangaram" in connection with construction/ownership.

The State of Karnataka appointed a three-member Commission of Inquiry under Section 3 of the Commission of Inquiry Act, 1952 (notification No. HUD 281 MNY 83 dated 8-11-1983) with detailed terms of reference including the cause of the collapse, licensing and supervision issues, deviations from sanctioned plans, responsibility-fixing, precautionary measures and other relevant questions. The Commission submitted its report on 26 July 1985.

The Commission reported cumulative causes: gross under-design by the structural engineer; poor coordination and supervision by the architect; poor quality materials provided by the owner; and poor quality construction by the contractors. The Commission also found lapses by Corporation officers in failing to require a safety survey to determine whether the existing two-storeyed structure could take the additional load of seven floors and in failing to examine zoning, coverage, set-back and fire safety measures.

The Commission identified specific persons and the Bangalore City Corporation as responsible. The State accepted the report on 3 July 1986 and directed, among other things, (i) launch of criminal proceedings against listed professionals and the owner if not already done; (ii) that licenses for buildings exceeding four floors be cleared first by an Experts' Committee; (iii) constitution of an official committee to consider other recommendations; and (iv) disciplinary action against specified officers. The acceptance did not, however, include directions for statutory compensation to the legal heirs of the deceased or to injured persons beyond some ex gratia payments.

The petitioners, advocates acting in public interest, filed the present writ petition (filed 11 April 1988) seeking enforcement of fundamental rights under Article 21 and directions for full and proper compensation to legal heirs of the dead and to injured persons. The petition proceeded in this Court; the State and the Bangalore City Corporation filed affidavits/objections acknowledging the collapse and certain steps taken but contesting other aspects (including characterizing the collapse as an "act of God" in one response and defending the licensing process).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State (and municipal licensing authority) failed in its constitutional duty under Article 21 to protect life and personal safety by permitting the construction that resulted in the collapse and consequent deaths/injuries.
  2. Whether a public interest writ petition seeking compensation for victims and their dependants is maintainable in these circumstances (i.e., whether the petitioners have locus to prosecute the matter in public interest).
  3. Whether non-joinder of the building owners as party respondents is fatal to the petition and warrants dismissal.
  4. If State culpability is established, what relief and mode of compensation is appropriate and whether the Court may prescribe a scheme for payment and recovery.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The State failed in its constitutional obligation under Article 21 to protect life and safety, warranting judicial intervention and directions for compensation to victims' legal heirs and injured persons.
  • The collapse resulted from use of substandard materials and ignoring structural guidelines; the Commission's report identifies culpable lapses by the structural engineer, architect, contractor, owner and municipal licensing authority.
  • Because the State failed to enact or take statutory steps (analogous to the Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster (Processing Claims) Act, 1985), the Court should issue directions to ensure payment of compensation.
  • The petition was filed in public interest on behalf of poor victims unable to approach the Court themselves; the petitioners' bona fides and consistency were stressed (including earlier approaches to the Supreme Court and Supreme Court Legal Aid Committee).

Respondent No. 1 (State) — Affidavit

  • Admitted the occurrence, appointment of the Enquiry Commission and submission of its report and that the Government accepted the report and issued orders (Government Order dated 3 January 1986 as detailed in the opinion).
  • Stated that some relief was provided: distribution of food and clothing (Rs. 5,000 sanctioned for relief), Rs. 2,91,500 distributed as compensation at Rs. 2,000 per dead person and Rs. 500 per injured person, payments from Chief Minister's and Prime Minister's relief funds (Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 2,500 per death respectively), and that disciplinary proceedings were pending.
  • Mentioned subsequent litigation by a union (Karnataka State Construction Workers Central Union) with multiple compensation cases and awards in some of them.

Respondent No. 2 (Bangalore City Corporation)

  • Admitted the collapse and that a Commission was constituted and report submitted, but contended the petition is "bereft of the matter".
  • Claimed the sanctioned plan and licensing were in accordance with the then existing law, rules and regulations, and that sufficient care and caution were exercised in issuing licences and in compounding deviations.
  • Characterized the collapse as an "act of God" and thereby sought to absolve the respondent of liability.
  • Raised a belated objection claiming non-joinder of necessary parties (the owners), which the Court treated and rejected as neither bona fide nor meritorious at this late stage.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K.V. Amarnath v. State of Karnataka, ILR (1998) 1 Karnataka 730 Test and guidelines for maintainability of public interest litigation and bona fides of petitioners in PILs. The Court relied on this authority to hold that the petitioners had the right to file and prosecute the writ petition in public interest and that the petition was maintainable.
Inder Puri General Store v. Union of India, AIR 1992 J & K 11 Scope and ambit of Article 21 (right to life) — life extends beyond mere existence and includes aspects that make life meaningful, including right to livelihood. One of the judges (Sethi, J.) relied on his earlier observations in this case to expound the broad scope of Article 21 and to support the proposition that State has obligations to protect life and livelihood.
Olga Tellis v. Bombay Municipal Corporation, AIR 1986 SC 180 Authority for the proposition that the right to livelihood is part of the right to life under Article 21. Quoted (via Inder Puri) to reinforce that deprivation of livelihood can amount to deprivation of the right to life and to support a broad reading of Article 21 obligations.
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India, (1987) 1 SCC 395; AIR 1987 SC 1086 Principle that applications for compensation in enforcement of fundamental rights should be decided on substance, not merely dismissed for procedural/formal defects. Cited to justify that the Court may entertain claims for compensation in a writ petition enforcing Article 21 and to look to substance rather than technical form when awarding compensation.
Bandhua Mukti Morcha v. Union of India, (1984) 3 SCC 161; AIR 1984 SC 802 Court's power to issue appropriate directions to enforce fundamental rights (example: release of bonded labour). Referred to as an example of the Supreme Court issuing remedial directions to protect fundamental rights, supporting the Court's power to mould relief here.
Bhim Singh v. State of J. & K., (1985) 4 SCC 677; AIR 1986 SC 494 Authority for directing payment of compensation where fundamental rights (wrongful detention) are infringed. Used to support the proposition that the Court may direct payment of compensation for violation of fundamental rights.
R. Ghandi v. Union of India, AIR 1989 Madras 205 Support for the principle that the State must protect life and liberty of citizens; cited as being to the same effect as other authorities. Cited by the Court as part of the body of authorities reinforcing State obligations to protect life and to provide remedies.
Peoples Union for Democratic Rights v. Ministry of Home Affairs, AIR 1985 Delhi 268 Support for State obligations to protect life and fundamental rights (cited as to same effect as other authorities). Referred to by the Court among authorities supporting intervention to protect Article 21 rights.
Writ Petition No. 4265/1988 (Decided 17 April 1998), reported in AIR 1999 Karnataka 119 Illustration of a Division Bench of this Court awarding compensation and issuing directions in a public interest litigation concerning victims of free eye camp operations. The Court relied on the earlier Division Bench decision as analogous and persuasive in ordering relief and prescribing a compensation scheme for victims of the Gangaram collapse.
Bhopal Gas Leak case (Union Carbide) and Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster (Processing Claims) Act, 1985 Illustrative precedent and legislative response where courts awarded compensation to victims and Central Government enacted a statute to process claims of victims in a large-scale disaster. The petitioners invoked the Bhopal case and the corresponding Central Act to argue that a similar statutory mechanism was required here; the Court referenced the Bhopal experience as a basis for the petitioners' submission and for permitting State recovery measures.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through a structured analysis grounded on the facts as found by the Commission of Inquiry, the State's acceptance of the Commission's report, and constitutional principles under Article 21. The key steps in its reasoning were:

  1. Maintainability and locus: The Court examined whether the petitioners could maintain a public interest writ petition. Relying on K.V. Amarnath and the tests laid down by higher courts, the Court found the petition was filed in bona fide public interest on behalf of poor victims and was maintainable. The Court rejected the contention that the petitioners were busybodies.
  2. Non-joinder objection: The Court considered the respondents' belated plea that owners were necessary parties. It rejected this ground because it was raised late (after more than ten years of pendency), was not raised earlier by respondents, and because the petition sought relief against the State for enforcement of constitutional obligations; the owners were not "States" under Article 12 and non-joinder did not bar relief. The Court noted the distinction between a "necessary party" and a "proper party" and that relief could be moulded to protect absent parties' interests.
  3. Scope of Article 21 and State obligation: The Court undertook an interpretive review of Article 21, citing earlier rulings (including Inder Puri and Olga Tellis) to stress that the right to life includes more than mere subsistence and extends to conditions that make life meaningful, including livelihood. The Court concluded that the State has an obligation to take effective legislative and administrative measures to protect life and to compensate victims where failures of State machinery or public authorities contribute to loss of life or injury.
  4. Application of precedents and remedial powers: The Court invoked authorities (M.C. Mehta, Bandhua Mukti Morcha, Bhim Singh and others) to demonstrate the jurisdiction to grant compensatory relief in public law litigation enforcing fundamental rights and to mould relief to achieve justice, particularly where procedural technicalities would otherwise defeat substantive rights.
  5. Findings from Commission and State conduct: The Court emphasized the Commission's findings that design and construction defects and municipal lapses caused the collapse, and it noted that although the State accepted the Commission report and initiated certain administrative and disciplinary measures, it had not provided systematic compensation to victims' dependants beyond modest ex gratia payments.
  6. Remedy and moulding relief: Given the difficulty of ascertaining individualized compensation claims after the passage of time and lapse of records, the Court concluded that it could prescribe a tentative compensation scheme to protect the interests of justice. The Court set out a tabulated compensation schedule by age and gender for legal heirs and fixed sums for grievous and simple injuries, holding respondents jointly and severally liable. It ordered procedural steps for notice and publication, allowed the State to seek recovery from owners by legal measures (including enactment of a statute if necessary), and authorised withholding utilities from owners pending recovery.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The writ petition is allowed; the Court made the rule absolute and issued directions for payment of compensation to the legal heirs of the deceased and to injured persons in the Gangaram Building collapse in accordance with the scheme prescribed in the opinion (paras 11 and 12), as applicable to the list in Annexure-V of the Commission of Inquiry report dated 26 July 1985 (Annexure-A). The respondents' liability for payment of compensation is held to be joint and several. The petitioners were awarded costs of Rs. 10,000/-. (Order: "Petition allowed.")

Direct consequences and implementation directions:

  • The Court prescribed compensation amounts to legal heirs of the deceased by age group and gender: (a) up to 25 years — Rs. 50,000 (male) / Rs. 40,000 (female); (b) 25–50 years — Rs. 1,25,000 (male) / Rs. 1,00,000 (female); (c) 50–75 years — Rs. 75,000 (male) / Rs. 65,000 (female); (d) 75 years and above — Rs. 40,000 (male) / Rs. 35,000 (female).
  • For injuries: grievous injuries — Rs. 20,000; simple injuries — Rs. 10,000. Both respondents held jointly and severally liable to pay.
  • Respondent No. 1 (State) was directed to intimate persons entitled to compensation individually and by wide publication in State newspapers.
  • The State was authorised to take steps to recover amounts paid from the building owners by lawful means, including enacting legislation if necessary; pending recovery, the State may withhold services such as water and electricity to those owners.
  • Petitioners awarded Rs. 10,000 costs.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles concerning Article 21 and the Court's remedial jurisdiction to award compensation and to mould relief in public interest cases. The opinion does not state that it creates or announces a new legal precedent beyond applying and synthesising existing authorities to the facts of this case.

Petition allowed.
Show all summary ...

R.P Sethi, C.J:— Careless conduct and casual approach adopted by the respondent-State in the matter of fundamental right dealing with life and safety forced the petitioners, belonging to a noble profession of advocates to put off their robes and stand before us as litigant seeking justice for the legal heirs of the dead and compensation for the injured. The deaths and injuries are admitted to have been caused on account of the collapse of a building constructed by the builders by using substandard material besides ignoring the structural guidelines and protections. The rolling tears and the soar wailing cries of the victims of the tragedy did not affect the mighty and careless State but did touch the tender hearts of the petitioners, who initiated this action in public interest with prayer for granting appropriate relief to the needy and deserving. This Court has been moved to take appropriate action by the issuance of requisite directions in furtherance of its obligation to protect the fundamental right of life, personal liberty and safety of the people in the country. It is submitted that the State has failed in its obligation to protect the life and safety of the people as enshrined under Art. 21 of the Constitution. Right to life, as guaranteed by Art. 21 has been acknowledged to be more than survival or animal existence. Such right includes the right to live with human dignity ensuring all aspects of life which go to make a man's life meaningful, complete and worth living. It has cast an obligation upon the State to ensure such right by taking effective legislative and administrative actions as and when required. As the State is alleged to have failed in its obligations as cast upon it under Part III of the Constitution of India, this Constitutional Court which is under oath to protect such rights of the citizens has been approached for relief without caring for the technicalities of law and wrangles of procedure.

2. 118 people are admitted to have died beneath the debris of a multi-storeyed building under construction which collapsed on 12th September 1983 at 3.13 p.m The aforesaid building was being constructed by one Ganga Ram abutting Subedar Chatram Road and Ananthashram Road, a busy and commercial area in the city of Bangalore. Besides 118 deaths caused on account of the collapse of the building another 67 persons were seriously injured. The Government of Karnataka ordered a judicial enquiry vide Notification No. HUD 281 MNY 83, dated 8-11-1983 by constituting three members committee under. S. 3 of the Commission of Inquiry Act, 1952 with the following terms of reference:

(i) The cause of the collapse of the Hotel Building under construction at Gopal Film Theatre Complex in Bangalore City on 12-9-1983;

(ii) Whether the necessary licences under the prevailing Statutes/Rules/Regulations had been obtained before the commencement of the construction;

(iii) Whether the concerned licensing authorities had exercised sufficient care and examined the various aspects connected with the issue of the licence before the issue of the same;

(iv) Whether construction had been made as per the sanctioned plan or whether there were any deviation;

(v) to fix responsibility regarding lapses on the part of officials or other persons connected with licensing, supervision and construction;

(vi) Precautionary measures to be taken to prevent the recurrence of such tragedies in future; and

(vii) To examine any other question relevant to the issue and make suitable recommendations. The Commission submitted its report to the Government on 26th July, 1985. According to the information received by the petitioners, the Commission found that the cause of collapse of the hotel building under construction was the cumulative effect of the following:

(i) Gross under-design by the structural Engineer

(ii) Poor co-ordination and lack of proper supervision by the Architect

(iii) Poor quality materials brought by the owner, and

(iv) Poor quality construction by the Contractors.

The Commission, further, found that the Corporation Officers/Officials of the City of Bangalore were primarily responsible and answerable regarding the lapses for not having insisted on the survey regarding the safety of the existing two storeyed structure to ensure as to whether the said building could hold the burden of additional load of 7 floors and also failing to examine the feasibility of granting the licence with reference to the Zoning Regulation regarding off-street parking, coverage, and Bye-law No. 38 regarding setback and fire safety measures. The Commission found the following persons responsible for the acts of commission and omission resulting in collapse of building and the death of 118 persons besides injury to 67 citizens:

(i) Mr. Deepak C. Master, Partner, Master & Associates, Architects of Bombay, (who can be reached through) Shri N. Gangaram, Gangaram Commercial Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., No. 72-73, M.G Road, Bangalore-1.

(ii) Shri H.R Bhanurriurthy, Structural Engineer, (who can also be reached through) Shri N. Gangaram, Gangaram Commercial Enterprises Private Limited, No. 72-73, M.G Road, Bangalore-1.

(iii) Shri H.B Shivakumar, Managing Director, Digvijaya Engineering Enterprises Private Limited, Contractors (who can also be reached through) Shri N. Gangaram, Gangaram Commercial Enterprises Private Limited, No. 72-73, M.G Road, Bangalore-1.

(iv) Shri N. Gangaram, Employer, Gangaram Commercial Enterprises Private Limited, No. 72-73, M.G Road, Bangalore-1, and

(v) The Licensing Authority, i.e, Bangalore City Corporation, Bangalore.

According to the petitioners the huge loss could have been averted, had the Corporation authorities exercised due care, caution and attention while granting/renewing of the building license and also had the persons mentioned hereinabove done their job assigned to them with due care, caution and attention. It is contended that all the aforesaid persons were capable of purchasing anything and everything including human lives with their money power and influence. They are shown to have played with the innocent lives of the victims despite being aware that what they were doing was not at all that all right.

3. The Government of Karnataka accepted the report of the Commission of Enquiry on 3rd of July, 1986 and directed

(i) that criminal proceedings may be launched if not done already against the Architect (Master and Associates, Bombay), the Structural Engineer (Sri H.R Bhanu Murthy), the Contractor (Digvijaya Engineering Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.,) and the Owner (Sri Gangaram) for their respective lapses leading to the collapse of the building.

(ii) all cases relating to grant of licenses for construction of building exceeding 4 floors (basement plus 4 floors) shall be first considered by an Experts' Committee to be appointed by the Government. No license shall be granted in respect of such a building unless it is cleared by the Committee. Necessary amendments to the existing law may be made, immediately.

(iii) a separate Official Committee comprising of the Officers concerned shall be constituted by Government to examine quickly the other recommendations made by the Commission of Inquiry in respect of terms of reference Nos. (vi) and (vii).

(iv) that in view of the observations made by the Commission of Inquiry, disciplinary action be taken against;

(a) Shri V.T Arasu, the then Superintending Engineer, Bangalore City Corporation (presently working as Chief Engineer, Government of Karnataka);

(b) Dr. K. Rangappa, IAS, former Commissioner of the Bangalore City Corporation;

(c) the persons who had issued the licenses right from 1973-1974 in respect of this building without any regard for the Zoning Regulations and Building Bye-laws.

Disciplinary action was also directed to be initiated against the officers of Engineering Department for the collapse who had submitted their notes leading the orders compounding the deviation made by Dr. K. Rangappa, IAS, the then Commissioner of Bangalore City Corporation, for their failure in bringing out correct facts and provisions of law in their notes. However, no directions were issued and action initiated for compensating the dependants of the victims for the loss of life of their near and dear ones. The dead are reported to be workers who are stated to have left behind their families for starvation, if not duly compensated as the victims of the occurrence were alleged to be only their bread-earners. The victims are reported to have been paid meagre amounts of money as an ex-gratia payment from the Chief Minister's and Prime Minister's fund and no compensation for the loss of life or infliction of the injuries suffered and cause on account of the culpable negligence attributable to the persons responsible for the collapse of building as concluded by the Commission of Inquiry. The State is alleged to have failed in initiating any action against the guilty and responsible for the tragedy and in this way failed to perform the obligations enshrined upon it under Art. 21 of the Constitution. Relying upon the Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster case, the petitioners have submitted that a statutory provision similar as Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster (Processing Claims) Act, 1985 was required to be enacted by the State for ensuring the payment of compensation claims to the dependants of the victims of the tragedy. Prayer has been made for issuance of directions against the respondents for making payment of full and proper compensation to the victims-relations of the dead and to the people who were injured in the Gangaram Building Collapse case.

4. In the affidavit filed on behalf of the respondent No. 1, Sri A.S Gadavi, Under Secretary to the Government, Housing and Urban Development Department has admitted the occurrence of the tragedy, the appointment of the Enquiry Commission and submission of the report by it. On the basis of the report the State Government is claimed to have taken action as per Government Order dated 3rd January, 1986, the details of which have been already noticed hereinabove. As per the enquiry report 118 persons are admitted to have died in the collapse of the building and number of persons injured is stated to be 50. The premises in question is stated to be coming within the limits of Corporation of the City of Bangalore. A sum of Rs. 5,000/- is stated to have been sanctioned by the Bangalore City Corporation for the distribution of food and clothing for those who were affected. A sum of Rs. 2,91,500/- is stated to have been distributed as compensation at the rate of Rs. 2,000/- per dead person and Rs. 500/- per person injured. A sum of Rs. 5,000/- per head per death is stated to have been paid from the Chief Minister's fund and Rs. 2,500/- per head per death from the Prime Minister's Relief Fund. Disciplinary proceedings initiated against the Official responsible for the collapse are stated to be pending till the time when the objections were filed in the Court on 23rd February, 1995. Subsequent to the collapse of Gangaram building one union by name. The Karnataka State Construction Workers Central Union is stated to have filed 34 cases for grant of compensation, out of which 15 are reported to have been withdrawn and the awards were passed in the remaining cases.

5. In the statement of objections filed on behalf of the respondent No. 2 it is admitted that the building called ‘Gangaram Building’ situated in Subhedar Chatram Road had collapsed in September, 1983 resulting in loss of life of inmates and workers and causing injury, to others. It is contended that the present petition filed by the petitioners is bereft of the matter. The constitution of the Commission of Inquiry and the submission of the report by it has been admitted. It has acknowledged that the respondent had sanctioned the plan for the construction of the building which is, however, claimed to be in accordance with the then existing Law, Rules and regulations. Respondent No. 2 is stated to have exercised sufficient care and caution in issuing the licences and also in compounding the deviation. The collapse of the building is termed as an ‘act of God’ absolving the respondent from any liability.

6. During the course of the arguments the respondent did not seriously contest the right of the petitioners herein to file and prosecute the present writ petition. Otherwise also we are satisfied that the present petition has been filed in public interest and is maintainable as such, in view of the test laid down by the Apex Court and various other High Courts including the guidelines provided by this Court in K.V Amarnath v. State of Karnataka, reported in ILR (1998) 1 Karnataka 730. It cannot be disputed that the violation of the fundamental right granted under Art. 21 of the Constitution which requires determination by the Court. The petitioners cannot be termed to be busy body or inter-lopers. Their bona fides are beyond doubt. The prayer sought is for the benefit of the victims of the tragedy who are indisputably poor and downtrodden admittedly not capable of approaching the Court themselves. The present petition has not been filed for any publicity or political purpose. The consistency and the bona fides of the petitioners is, apparent from the fact that immediately after the occurrence they approached the Supreme Court and as no action was taken by the Supreme Court Legal Aid Committee despite direction, they approached this Court and filed the petition in public interest on 11th April, 1988. The petition is, therefore, held to have been filed in public interest and the objection raised by the respondent in this regard is rejected.

7. Taking a clue from the observations made by the Court during the arguments, the respondents have submitted that the petition was liable to be dismissed on account of non-joinder of necessary parties. According to them, the owners of the building were necessary parties and as admittedly such owners have not been impleaded as parties in the petition, the same deserves dismissal. Such a submission has to be noticed for only to be rejected. No such plea has been raised by the respondents in their objections despite pendency of the writ petition in this Court for more than 10½ years. Accepting such a belated and stale plea, at this stage, would defeat ends of justice particularly when the objection raised is found to be neither bona fide nor affecting merits of the case. Otherwise also the objection raised is without any substance. The owners of the building cannot be held to be necessary parties in these proceedings where the relief is claimed against the State for the enforcement of the fundamental rights of the citizens. The prayer is based upon the failure of the State machinery to take effective steps for protecting the fundamental rights of the people. Admittedly the owners are not the ‘States’ within the meaning of the Art. 12 of the Constitution of India. It is well recognised principle of law that necessary party is one without whom no order can be made effectively and a proper party is one in whose absence an effective order can be made but whose presence is necessary for a complete and final decision on the question. All persons who are likely to be directly affected by the decision are necessary party to the proceedings and persons who are apprehended to be remotely affected by such order cannot be termed to be necessary parties. A person would be necessary party only if he is likely to be adversely affected by the grant of relief to the petitioner in the proceedings. If, however, relief can be appropriately moulded which does not directly effect a person not treated as a party, the petition cannot be rejected on the ground of non-joinder of necessary parties. Strict rules of procedures cannot be insisted upon in writ petitions filed in public interest where the party approaching the Court has no personal interest. We are of the opinion that it would have been appropriate if the owners of the building were also added as party respondent to the present petition but by non-impleading them as parties particularly when respondent herein have not raised any such objection, this petition filed in public interest for protecting the right of life and liberty as enshrined under Art. 21 of the Constitution of India and for the benefit of the legal heirs of the dead in the Gangaram Building collapse resulting on account of the failure of the respondents to take effective measures, cannot be dismissed on this technical objection half-heartedly raised at the fag end of the proceedings.

8. Dealing with the scope and ambit of Art. 21 of the Constitution, one of us (Sethi, J), in Inder Puri General Store v. Union of India, reported in AIR 1992 J & K 11 had held:

“5 Article 21 of the federal Constitution provide, that no person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to the procedure established by law. This article embodies the general principle that no person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty and guarantees the most essential of all the rights as enshrined in Part III of the Constitution. This Article puts a limitation on the powers of the executive. The terms ‘life’ used in the Article is not only restricted to the more nominal existence but extends to the inhibition against its deprivation to all those limits and faculties by which life is enjoyed. It also included the right to livelihood. The ambit and scope of ‘right to life’ conferred by this Article is wide and far-reaching which does not mean merely that life cannot be extinguished or taken away but embraces within its ambit the right to livelihood because no person can live without the means of living. If the right to livelihood is not treated as a part of the constitutional right to life, the easiest way of depriving a person of his right to life would be to deprive him of his means of livelihood to the point of abrogation. Chief Justice Chandrachud (as His Lordship then was) of the Supreme Court in Olga Tellis v. Bombay Municipal Corporation, AIR 1986 SC 180 held at page 194:

‘……………..Such deprivation would not only denude the life of its effective content and meaningfulness but it would make life impossible to live. And yet, such deprivation would not have to be in accordance with the procedure established by law, if the right to livelihood is not regarded as a part of the right to life. That, which alone makes it possible to live, leave aside what makes life livable, must be deemed to be an integral component of the right to life. Deprive a person of his right to livelihood and you shall have deprived him of his life. Indeed, that explains the massive migration of the rural population to big cities. They migrate because they have no means of livelihood in the villages. The motive force which propels their desertion of their hearths and homes in the village is the struggle for survival, that is, the struggle for life. So unimpeachable is the evidence of the nexus between life and the means of livelihood. They have to eat to live. Only a handful can afford the luxury of living to eat. That they can do, namely, eat, only if they have the means of livelihood. That is the context in which it was said by Douglas J. in Baksey, (1954) 347 MD 442 that the right to work is the most precious liberty that man possesses. It is the most precious liberty because, it sustains and enables a man to live and the right to life is a precious freedom. ‘Life’, as observed by Field, J. in Munn v. Illinois, (1874).94 US 113, means something more than mere animal existence and the inhibition against the deprivation of life extends to all those limits and faculties by which life is enjoyed. This observation was quoted with approval by this Court in Kharak Singh v. State of U.P, 1963 (2) Cri LJ 329: AIR 1963 SC 1295.

His Lordship further held at page 194:

‘……..If there is an obligation upon the State to secure to the citizens an adequate means of livelihood and the right to work, it would be sheer pedantry to exclude the right to livelihood from the content of the right to life. The State may not, by affirmative action, be compellable to provide adequate means of livelihood or work to the citizens. But, any person, who is deprived of his right to livelihood except according to just and fair procedure established by law, can challenge the deprivation as offending the right to life conferred by Art. 21.’

In M.C Mehta v. Union of India, (1987) 1 SCC 395: AIR 1987 SC 1086 it was held, ‘The application for compensation had been made in this case for enforcement of right under Articles of the persons affected by oleum gas leak. Merely because the petitioner could not apply for amendment of the writ petition so as to include the claim for compensation the application for compensation cannot be thrown out. The Court while making an application for enforcement of a fundamental right must look at the substance and not form.’ In Bandhua Mukti Morcha v. Union of India, (1984) 3 SCC 161: AIR 1984 SC 802 the Supreme Court issued appropriate directions for the release of bonded labour and in Bhim Singh v. State of J. & K. (1985) 4 SCC 677: AIR 1986 SC 494 directed the payment of compensation for wrongful detention of the petitioner. In the Bhopal Gas leak case of an industrial unit owned by Union Carbide, the Supreme Court has already awarded compensation to the effect and still seized of the matter for awarding adequate compensation to the gas victims. The constitutional set up in this country envisages that all communities have a right to life and practice their religion according to their conscience. All citizens of the country have a right to carry on any profession or trade within the limits of law and the State is under an obligation to protect their life and property ensuring them all the benefits of fundamental rights enshrined under the part III of the Constitution. As and when life and property, as discussed herein above, is taken away by any individual or organisation, a duty is cast upon the State representing the will of people to compensate the victim by granting adequate compensation. The monarchical rule has to be distinguished from democratic set up and the State cannot shirk in its responsibility to protect the life, liberty and property of the citizens, State is under a constitutional obligation to compensate the victim adequately. The argument of the learned Advocate General that the State was under no obligation to compensate the victims of communal riots, is without any basis and contradictory in terms in view of the actions already taken in that behalf. If it was not the responsibility of the State to provide compensation, what was the necessity of passing orders for providing ex-gratia grant and lump sum amounts as compensation for the losses suffered. The State represents the will of the lapses of the Rulers, a right accrues to them for award of compensation. As and when the life and liberty of any person is taken away, a presumption arises of the failure of the State machinery to protect the life and property of the individuals involved.”

To the same effect are the judgments reported in R. Ghandi v. Union of India, AIR 1989 Madras 205 and Peoples Union for Democratic Rights v. Ministry of Home Affairs, AIR 1985 Delhi 268.

9. In the light of various pronouncements of the Apex Courts and different High Courts it cannot be denied that protecting life and liberty of the citizen is the duty of a responsible Government who cannot abdicate its function and allow the life and liberty of the citizen in jeopardy. Wherever a loss is caused to a person on account of proved acts of commission and omission of an authority, a welfare State under a democratic system of responsible Government is under an obligation to take effective steps against the erring parties and ensure adequate compensation to the victims of the calamity caused on account of the acts of commission and omission. Failure to take any action against the erring and responsible person or Authority would be a sufficient ground for this Court to intervene and compel the State to perform its constitutional obligations. Technical pleas and procedural wrangles cannot be permitted to be put as obstruction in grating the relief to the victims and their families. Accepting the plea of the respondents, at this belated stage, would amount to give license to the defaulters and violators of the law to perpetuate more agony and torture upon the victims and their families, resulting to facilitate filling up the coffers of the rich, wealthy and influential. The Constitutional Courts in the country cannot permit any individual person or Authority to build their glittering castles on the heaps of human skeletons affixed with their flesh and blood. This Court, under the peculiar circumstances of the case, can mould relief appropriately for ensuring the preservance of the rule of law in furtherance of and strengthening the democratic institutions in the welfare State, as we have in this country.

10. The omission in the discharge of their functions which have been attributable to the respondents are writ large reflecting their casual approach and careless attitude. Even while constituting the Commission of Enquiry, the then political executive of the State did not even deem it proper to make a reference with respect to the plight of the victims of the calamity and ascertaining the responsibility of the guilty vis-a-vis the legal heirs of the deceased and persons who had actually received injuries on account of the collapse of the Gangaram Building. No responsible Government could have ignored the loss of life of 118 persons and serious injuries to 67 persons. The payment of meagre amount out of the Relief Funds cannot be held to be the discharge of Constitutional obligation of the respondents. Even after getting report of the Commission of Enquiry no follow-up action appears to have been taken for granting the relief to the victims of the families of the deceased as has been prayed in the present case. What prevented the state from making a law similar to one which the Central Government had got enacted in Bhopal Gas Leak case is a mystery shrouded with doubts, not tried to be explained on any hypothesis much less reasonably. The respondent-State has been found to have failed in its discharge of constitutional obligations forcing the present petitioners to approach this Court for issuance of appropriate directions. Similarly respondent No. 2 which was found by the Commission of Enquiry, to have failed in the performance of its duties did not take any step either for recovering the amount from the guilty or paying the compensation to the needy and deserving. The respondent-Corporation was proved to have failed in exercising sufficient care and examining various aspects specially Zoning Regulations in regard to the coverage, off-street parking, bye-law No. 38 regarding set-back of fire safety measures while sanctioning or renewing the licence in favour of the owners which ultimately resulted in the death of 118 and injury to 67 persons in Gangaram Building collapse. In view of the finding of the Commission that no valid licence as per the Act had been obtained by the owners of the building before the commencement of the construction, the respondent-Corporation failed to take any action against the erring persons resulting in loss of human lives and injuries to many.

11. Under similar circumstances, a Division Bench of this Court in Writ Petition No. 4265/1988 decided on 17th April 1998 (reported in AIR 1999 Karnataka 119), while dealing with a public interest litigation filed on behalf of the victims who had lost their eyesight consequent upon the operations conducted in the free eye camp at Chintamani during the year 1988 issued appropriate directions against the State and awarded different amounts of compensation to different categories of victims. The present petition is no exception. We are satisfied that the respondents herein have failed in the performance of their constitutional and statutory obligations which necessitates the issuance of appropriate directions for enforcement of fundamental right guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It is true that ascertaining the compensation with respect to each individual victim is difficult particularly in the absence of the claims and lapse of time. However, we feel that the interests of the justice can be protected by prescribing some guidelines for payment of the compensation to the legal heirs of the deceased and the injured who were victims of the Gangaram Building collapse. Remanding the case or issuing directions to the Authorities for ascertaining the compensation at this belated stage is likely to result in the failure of justice, which if permitted, would result in weakening the belief of a common man in the institution of judiciary. We have heard the learned counsel in this behalf also. It is not disputed by the learned counsel appearing for the parties that in case if the petition is allowed, tentative scheme for award of compensation be prescribed by the Court itself and proper directions be issued by protecting the interests of all concerned. We are of the opinion that the ends of justice would be served if the legal heirs of such persons who had died in the tragedy are awarded compensation on the basis of the following criterion:

a) legal heirs of the deceased, in the age group of up to 25 years, be paid compensation amounting to Rs. 50,000/- if male; and Rs. 40,000/- if female;

b) legal heirs of the deceased, in the age group between 25-50 years, be paid compensation amounting to Rs. 1,25,000/- if male; and Rs. 1,00,000/- if female;

c) legal heirs of the deceased, in the age group between 50-75 years, be paid compensation amounting to Rs. 75,000/- if male; and Rupees 65,000/- if female;

d) victims in the age group of 75 years and onwards be paid compensation of Rs. 40,000/- if male; and Rs. 35,000/- if female.

12. Similarly in case of injured (a) persons, suffering receiving grievous injuries be paid a sum of Rs. 20,000/-; and (b) in case of persons who sustained simple injuries be paid a sum of Rs. 10,000/-. Both the respondents are held responsible for making payment of compensation jointly and severally.

13. Under the circumstances, writ petition is allowed. Rule issued is made absolute and direction is issued to the respondents to pay the legal heirs of the deceased and the persons who had suffered injuries in the Gangaram Building collapse as detailed in Annexure-V of the report of the Commission of Enquiry dated 26th July 1985 (Annexure-A) to the extent and limits as prescribed in paras 11 and 12 herein above. The liability of the respondents in paying the compensation is held to be joint and several. Respondent No. 1 is further directed to intimate the persons entitled to compensation about their right to get compensation in terms of this Order. Such notice be issued individually as also by publication in newspapers having wide circulation in the State of Karnataka. Respondent-State is further authorised to take effective steps for the recovery of the aforesaid amount from the defaulters viz., the owners of the building by taking recourse to law including the enactment of a statute for the said purpose if so needed. Upon the payment of amount of compensation and pending recovery if so desired from the owners of the building, the respondents shall be entitled to withhold the facilities including water and electricity provided to such owners till the amount paid to the victims is recovered. The petitioners are also entitled to costs assessed at Rs. 10,000/-.

Petition allowed.