- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chikka Kullegowda v. State Of Karnataka & Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Full Bench Reference on Rule 43‑G and Rule 43‑J)
Factual and Procedural Background
Portions of two surveyed holdings in Mysore District had been temporarily leased to certain persons belonging to Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes before commencement of the Mysore Land Revenue (Amendment) Rules, 1960. Those lands were subsequently granted to the lessees or their legal heirs under Rule 43‑J at a price of Rs. 500 per acre.
By an Official Memorandum dated 7/12.3.1968 the Assistant Commissioner confirmed the grants subject to payment of Rs. 500 per acre and requested the Tahsildar to issue permanent Saguvali Chits. The memorandum did not impose any conditions. The Tahsildar issued permanent Saguvali Chits in 1968 "Grant Certificate" form acknowledging receipt of price and stipulating terms; the Tahsildar added by hand a term that the land shall not be alienated for fifteen years. Despite this, the grantees sold the lands to the appellants within a few months of issue of the Saguvali Chits.
The Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978 (the PTCL Act) came into force on 1.1.1979. Proceedings under Section 5 of that Act resulted in the Assistant Commissioner declaring the alienations in favour of the purchasers null and void on the ground of contravention of the fifteen‑year bar; the Deputy Commissioner confirmed those orders. A learned single Judge of this Court upheld the orders (reported in Chikka Kullegowda v. State, ILR 1991 KAR 4557). Purchasers appealed, and a Division Bench referred to the Full Bench the question whether conditions in Rule 43‑G apply to grants under Rule 43‑J.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the conditions prescribed for grant of lands under Rule 43‑G of the Mysore Land Revenue (Amendment) Rules, 1960 are applicable to grants of lands under Rule 43‑J of those Rules.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The grant under Rule 43‑J contained no condition prohibiting alienation; Rule 43‑J (as amended) does not impose any prohibition on sale.
- Rule 43‑G (which stipulates several conditions including a bar on alienation) applies to grants under the Rules preceding it (i.e., Rules 43‑C and 43‑D) and is inapplicable to grants under Rule 43‑J made to persons already in occupation pursuant to temporary leases.
- The Assistant Commissioner, who was the authority empowered to make the grant, did not stipulate any condition barring alienation; the Tahsildar's act in adding a fifteen‑year bar on the Saguvali Chit was a ministerial act beyond the Tahsildar's competence to alter the terms of grant, and hence that condition was ineffective and invalid.
- Therefore, the immediate sales by grantees to appellants after grant did not contravene the terms of grant or the Rules and were valid.
Grantees' Arguments
- Grants made under Rule 43‑J to persons belonging to Scheduled Castes and Tribes were subject to and governed by Rule 43‑G; specifically Rule 43‑G(4) contains a bar on alienation for fifteen years which applied to these grants.
- The Saguvali Chits issued pursuant to the grants contained the specific condition prohibiting alienation for fifteen years; the sales occurred within a few months of issuance.
- Section 4 of the PTCL Act invalidates alienations that contravene either the terms of the grant or the law providing for the grant; since the sales contravened both Rule 43‑J read with Rule 43‑G(4) (per their contention) and the express term in the Saguvali Chit, the sales were void and resumption/restoration under Section 5 of the PTCL Act was proper.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Smt. Siddamma v. Chikkegowda & Others (Division Bench) | Held that the conditions stipulated in Rule 43‑G are inapplicable to grants under Rule 43‑J; provided reasoning based on the scheme of the Rules and the textual connection that Rule 43‑G applies to the preceding Rules (43‑C and 43‑D). | The Full Bench reviewed this holding, extracted and reproduced the reasoning from Siddamma, and ultimately agreed with that construction—expressing respectful concurrence and answering the referred question in the negative. |
| Chikka Kullegowda v. State (ILR 1991 KAR 4557) (Learned Single Judge) | The Single Judge upheld the orders of the authorities (resumption and restitution) declaring alienations void under the PTCL Act (as per the factual matrix of those cases). | The opinion records that the Single Judge upheld the authority orders in that reported decision; those orders were part of the procedural history that led to the reference to the Full Bench. |
| Chikkegowda v. State of Karnataka | Listed among prior decisions addressing whether Rule 43‑G conditions apply to Rule 43‑J grants; part of a series of earlier authorities on the point. | The court noted this as one of several earlier decisions which consistently held that Rule 43‑G conditions apply only to grants under Rules 43‑C and 43‑D and not to Rule 43‑J. |
| Shivanna v. State of Karnataka | Another earlier decision concerning applicability of Rule 43‑G to Rule 43‑J grants (cited as part of consistent line of authority). | The decision was cited to demonstrate consistency in earlier holdings that Rule 43‑G does not apply to Rule 43‑J grants. |
| Venkatamma v. State of Karnataka | Part of the earlier case law addressing the same interpretive issue (applicability of Rule 43‑G). | Cited as reinforcing the established line that Rule 43‑G conditions govern grants under the preceding Rules and not Rule 43‑J. |
| K. Chowdaiah v. Deputy Commissioner, Mandya | Another decision in the series bearing on whether Rule 43‑G applies to Rule 43‑J grants. | Referred to as one of the cases in which courts have consistently held that Rule 43‑G applies only to grants under Rules 43‑C and 43‑D, not to Rule 43‑J. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a textual and contextual analysis of the Rules governing grants (Rules 41 to 43‑L as substituted by the 1960 amendment). It identified three distinct categories of grants contemplated by the Rules:
- Grants under Rules 43‑C and 43‑D in respect of unoccupied land available for disposal;
- Grants under Rule 43‑H for cultivation of plantation crops (a self‑contained provision); and
- Grants under Rule 43‑J to persons who were already in occupation pursuant to temporary leases.
The court examined the language and scheme of Rules 43‑E, 43‑F and 43‑G and concluded:
- Rule 43‑G is expressly prefaced by the words “Grant of lands under the preceding Rules shall be subject to the following conditions,” which, in context, refers to Rules 43‑C and 43‑D that deal with grants of unoccupied lands. That express wording signals that Rule 43‑G was intended to govern the preceding Rules and not subsequent ones.
- Sub‑rules of Rule 43‑G (for example, the bar on alienation for 15 years in sub‑rule (4), the obligation to bring land under cultivation within two years in sub‑rule (6), and the relevance of grantee taking possession after grant) presuppose grants of unoccupied land where possession is delivered after grant; those provisions are incongruent with the situation of occupants already in possession under temporary leases (the scenario envisaged in Rule 43‑J).
- Rule 43‑J itself commences with a non‑obstante clause: “Notwithstanding anything contained in the preceding rules ... the land may be granted to the lessee.” This non‑obstante language emphasises that the grant to lessees already in occupation is to proceed notwithstanding the preceding Rules (which include Rule 43‑G).
- The distinct policy purposes and mechanics of the three categories of grant (different eligibility, reservation, priority, conditions, and extent of land) further support construing Rule 43‑G as applying only to the first category (unoccupied land grants under Rules 43‑C and 43‑D).
On the contention to use the PTCL Act (a later statute) to interpret Rule 43‑G and Rule 43‑J, the court reiterated interpretive principles: a later statute generally cannot be used to construe an earlier statute unless the earlier statute is ambiguous and the later statute can serve as legislative exposition. The court found Rule 43‑G's language plain and unambiguous and thus declined to invoke the PTCL Act to alter the meaning of the earlier Rules. Even on the merits, the PTCL Act merely invalidates transfers contravening the terms of grant or the law providing for grant; it does not itself prescribe the content of those terms or the law — therefore it does not assist in interpreting whether Rule 43‑G applies to Rule 43‑J.
After reviewing the scheme, text and history of the Rules and the earlier line of authorities (including Siddamma's case), the court concluded that Rule 43‑J grants form a separate category and that Rule 43‑G conditions were inapplicable to grants under Rule 43‑J. The court expressly stated its respectful agreement with Siddamma's construction and answered the referred question in the negative.
The court declined to express any opinion on two additional questions that had been argued but were not referred to the Full Bench: (a) whether the authority granting land under Rule 43‑J may impose conditions at the time of making the grant; and (b) the effect of a condition imposed in the Saguvali Chit by the Tahsildar (such as the fifteen‑year prohibition) when that condition was not imposed by the order of the authority making the grant.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Full Bench answered the referred question in the negative: the conditions prescribed in Rule 43‑G are not applicable to grants made under Rule 43‑J.
Implications:
- Direct legal consequence: The court determined, on construction of the Rules, that Rule 43‑G's conditions (including the fifteen‑year bar on alienation contained in Rule 43‑G(4)) do not, by virtue of the Rules themselves, govern grants made under Rule 43‑J.
- Limitations of the holding: The court did not decide whether an authority granting under Rule 43‑J may nonetheless impose specific conditions at the time of grant, nor did it decide the legal effect of the fifteen‑year condition which the Tahsildar added on the Saguvali Chit. The court expressly refrained from opining on those questions as they were not part of the reference.
- On precedent: The Full Bench stated its respectful agreement with the earlier Division Bench decision in Siddamma's case and reaffirmed the interpretive position that Rule 43‑G applies to grants under Rules 43‑C and 43‑D (unoccupied lands) and not to Rule 43‑J (grants to occupants under temporary leases).
No further pronouncement was made in this opinion on the validity of individual transactions in the cases before the Court insofar as those transactions raise issues separate from the specific question referred (for example, the validity of a condition inserted by the Tahsildar in a Saguvali Chit).
Raveendran, J.:—
A Division Bench of this Court has referred the following question for decision of the Full Bench:—
“Whether the conditions prescribed for grant of lands under Rule 43-G of Mysore Land Revenue (Amendment) Rules, 1960 are applicable to grant of lands under Rule 43-J of the Rules?
2. The facts of these cases are briefly as under:—
Portions of Sy. No. 160 of Menasikyathanahalli Village and Sy. No. 96 of Heggur Village of T. Narasipur Taluk, Mysore District, were temporarily leased to certain persons belonging to Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes before the commencement of the Mysore Land Revenue (Amendment) Rules, 1960. Subsequently, those lands were granted to the respective lessees or their legal heirs under Rule 43-J of the said Rules at a price of Rs. 500/- per acre. By Official Memorandum dated 7/12.3.1968, the Assistant Commissioner, T. Narasipur Division, confirmed the grants in favour of the occupants, subject to payment of Rs. 500/- per acre and requested the Tahsildar to issue permanent Saguvali Chit to the occupants. No conditions were imposed in the said memorandum confirming the grants in favour of the occupants. In pursuance of it, the Tahsildar issued permanent Saguvali Chits to the occupants in the year 1968 in the form entitled “Grant Certificate” acknowledging receipt of the occupancy price and stipulating the terms and conditions subject to which the Saguvali Chit was issued. In all these certificates, the Tahsildar has added in hand, a term that the land granted shall not be alienated for a period of fifteen years. But the grantees sold the granted lands to the appellants herein immediately after the issue of Saguvali Chits, i.e, within a few months.
3. The Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978 (‘the PTCL Act’ for short) came into force on 1.1.1979 In proceedings commenced under Section 5 of the Act, on the applications made by the grantees/their legal heirs, the Assistant Commissioner declared the alienations in favour of appellants were null and void on the ground that they contravened the term of grant prohibiting alienation within 15 years; and consequently directed resumption of the lands and restitution to the grantees/their legal heirs. The said orders were confirmed in appeal by the Deputy Commissioner. The purchasers challenged the said orders by filing Writ Petitions and a learned single Judge of this Court, by his order dated 10.12.1991, upheld the orders of the authorities (reported in Chikka Kullegowda v. State, ILR 1991 KAR 4557). Feeling aggrieved, the purchasers preferred appeals from which this reference arises.
4. The appellants contended that the grant under Rule 43-J was not subject to any condition prohibiting alienation; and Rule 43-J of Mysore Land Revenue Rules as amended by the Mysore Land Revenue (Amendment) Rules, 1960 (‘the Rules’ for short) under which the grants were made do not contain any term prohibiting the sale either permanently or within any specified period; as the grant of agricultural lands were in favour of persons who were already in occupation in pursuance of temporary leases granted before the commencement of the Rules, the grant was governed by Rule 43-J, and Rule 43-G of the Rules which stipulated several conditions (including bar on alienation) subject to which regular grants had to be made, was inapplicable to grants under Rule 43-J. It is further contended that the Assistant Commissioner ordered the grant of the lands by issue of permanent Saguvali Chits to the lessees who were in occupation of the lands subject to payment of Rs. 500/- per acre, without stipulating any conditions. Thus, neither the Rules relating to grant, nor the terms of grant prohibited sale of granted lands. Therefore, the sales of the granted lands by the grantees in favour of appellants immediately after the grant, were valid as they did not contravene the terms of the grant of such land or the law providing for such grant. It is also contended that as the Assistant Commissioner who is the authority empowered to make the grant, did not stipulate any condition barring alienation, it was not open to the Tahsildar who was only entrusted with the ministerial act of issuing the Saguvali Chits in terms of the grant, to stipulate a condition that the grantee shall not alienate the property for a period of fifteen years, while issuing the Saguvali Chits and, therefore, the said condition not being a term of the grant, was ineffective and invalid and had to be ignored.
5. On the other hand, the grantees contended that the grants made under Rule 43-J were subject to and governed by Rule 43-G as the grantees belong to Scheduled Castos and Tribes; therefore, the bar on alienation for a period of fifteen years contained in Rule 43-G(4) applied to the grants in their favour; at all events, the Saguvali Chits issued to them in pursuance of the grants contained a specific condition that the land should not be alienated for a period of fifteen years. The sales were all within a few months of the issue of Saguvali Chits. Section 4 of the PTCL Act provides that if the alienation was in contravention of either the terms of grant or the law providing for grant, the same shall be null and void. In these cases, the sales were in contravention of not only the law governing the grant, viz., Rule 43-J read with Rule 43-G(4) but was also in contravention of one of the terms of grant contained in the Saguvali Chit which specifically prohibited alienation. Hence, the sales by the grantees in favour of the appellants were void under Section 4 of the PTCL Act and therefore, the orders of resumption and restoration under Section 5 of the Act were in order.
6. Thus one of the questions that arose for consideration before the Division Bench was whether grants under Rule 43-J was subject to conditions prescribed under Rule 43-G. It was found that an earlier Division Bench of this Court, in Smt. Siddamma v. Chikkegowda & Others, has held that the conditions stipulated in Rule 43-G were inapplicable to grants under Rules 43-J. The Division Bench, however, felt that in principle, there was no distinction between grants under Rule 43-C & D and grants under Rule 43-J, as the only difference in regard to grants under Rule 43-J was that the grantee was already in occupation of the land granted on the date of grant. It felt that Rule 43-J ought not to have been interpreted in such a manner as to exclude the applicability of Rule 43-G. As the Division Bench found some difficulty in following the construction of Rule 43-J in Siddamma's case, but was not inclined to refer all the matters relating to the appeal to the Full Bench, it has only referred the aforesaid question to the Full Bench for decision under Section 7 of the Karnataka High Court Act.
7. The grant of lands were regulated by different Rules at different points of time. Rules 41 to 43-M of Mysore Land Revenue Rules, framed under Section 233 of the Mysore Land Revenue Code, 1988, in regard to grant of lands were substituted with Rules 41 to 43-L, by Rule 2 of the Rules with effect from 10.5.1960 These amended Rules were in force when the grants were made. Let us briefly refer to them.
7.1 Rule 41 contains the definitions. Rule 42 deals with the power of different Revenue Officers in respect of grant of lands. The authorities who can grant the lands are the Tahsildar, Assistant Commissioner and the Deputy Commissioner having regard to the extent of land and value of the land as provided therein. Rule 43 contains the procedure for disposal of lands for cultivation. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 43 requires persons seeking grant of lands under the control of the Revenue Department, to make applications to the Tahsildar by giving the particulars required therein.
7.2 Rule 43-A provides for preparation of lists of lands available for disposal in every village by the Tahsildar. As per the said Rule, the Tahsilar shall prepare a list of the lands which have been or have to be assigned for special purpose under Section 39 of the Code, such as for free pasturage, for village cattle, for forest reserve or for any other public purpose including cattle sheds and stands, sites for stacking hay and other agricultural produce, manure pits, extension of Gramatanas, provision of sites for school buildings, playgrounds and gymnasia, sites for other public buildings like offices of Village Panchayats and Co-operative Societies, burial and cremation grounds. It provides that only unoccupied lands fit for cultivation remaining after reserving sufficient extent for the aforesaid purposes, shall be included in the list of lands available for disposal.
7.3 Rule 43-C permits to ordinary grants of lands to individuals, that is, to any adult who is poor and who is a bona fide agriculturist and grant of lands to adjoining or nearby land holders for better enjoyment of the lands held by them. Rule 43-D deals with grant of lands to (a) political sufferers; (b) displaced holders and displaced tenants; and (c) Educational institutions.
7.4 Rule 43-E provides that out of the lands available for disposal in a village, certain percentage should be reserved for disposal in favour of persons belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, political sufferers and residents of the village and provides that notwithstanding the reservations provided for, the land available may be granted to displaced holders and displaced tenants.
7.5 Rule 43-F stipulates the following order of priority to be applied in regard to lands available able for disposal in a village after reservation of the extent referred in Rule 43-E for grant to members belonging to Scheduled Castes and Tribes and political sufferers:—
i) Displaced holders and displaced tenants ordinarily resident in the village;
ii) Displaced holders and displaced tenants ordinarily residents in a neighbouring or nearby village;
iii) Educational Institutions;
iv) Poor and landless persons ordinarily resident in the village;
v) Ex-Servicemen;
vi) Insufficient holders ordinarily resident in the village;
vii) Poor and landless persons ordinarily residing in neighbouring or nearby villages;
viii) Insufficient holders ordinarily residing in neighbouring or nearby villages.
It also provides the extent of land that can ordinarily be granted.
7.6 Rule 43-G prescribes the conditions subject to which the grant of lands is to be made under the preceding Rules. The said Rule is extracted below:—
“43-G. GRANT OF LANDS UNDER THE PRECEDING RULES SHALL BE SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:—
(1) In the case of grant of lands to applicants belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, and to other applicants, who are unable to pay the occupancy price on account of poverty, the occupancy price may be waived up to rupees two hundred and the balance recovered in three annual instalments;
(2) In the case of grant of land to applicants who are ex-servicemen the occupancy price shall be waived upto the extent awarded by Government under the Military Concession Rules;
(3) In the case of grant of land free of occupancy price, the grant shall be subject to the condition that the grantee shall pay contribution or betterment levy in respect of the land and the value of trees standing on the land;
(4) Where the grant is made free of cost, or is made at a price which is less than the full market value, the grant shall be subject to the condition that the land shall not be alienated for a period of fifteen years from the date of the grantee taking possession of the land, after the grant.
Provided that such land may be alienated with the previous sanction of the Government and subject to such conditions as the Government may specify, if the Government is of the opinion that the circumstances of any case, it is just and reasonable to permit such alienation either for purposes of acquiring some other land or for any other purpose.
(a) the alienation of any land in favour of the State Government or co-operative society as security for loans obtained for improvement of the land or for buying cattle or agricultural implements for cultivation of the land, or alienation for cultivation of the land, or alienation of any land in favour of the Indian Coffee Board as security for loans advanced by the Indian Coffee Board under the Coffee Development Plan;
(b) the leasing of any land by a person who is widow, a minor or who is subject to physical or mental disability or who is a serving member of the armed forces.
(5) the grantee shall cultivate the land personally;
(6) the land shall be brought under cultivation within two years from the date of the grantee taking possession of the land;
(7) the grant is liable to be terminated and the land resumed if any of the aforesaid conditions is not fulfilled, and on such resumption the land shall vest in Government free from all encumbrances.
Provided that no land shall be resumed under this clause except after giving an opportunity to the grantee or his successor in interest to show cause why the grant should not be terminated and the land resumed.”
7.7 Rule 43-H deals with grant of land for cultivation of plantation crops. In contains provisions relating to price, conditions of grant, extent to be granted and termination. There is no dispute that the conditions stipulated in Rule 43-G are inapplicable to grants under Rule 43-H.
7.8 Rule 43-J deals with grant of land to persons to whom lands have been leased temporarily. The Rule is extracted below:—
“43-J. Grant of land to persons to whom lands have been leased temporarily:— Notwithstanding anything contained in the preceding rules of this chapter, in the case of agricultural land leased by competent authority to any person for purposes of cultivation at any time before the commencement of the Mysore Land Revenue (Amendment) Rules, 1960, if such land is available for disposal and if the conditions of the lease have been complied with, the land may be granted to the lessee.”
7.9 Rule 43-K makes it clear that nothing in the Rules should be deemed to confer any right to the grant of any land, and the authority competent to make or sanction the grant may pass orders as it deems fit, taking all the relevant circumstances into consideration. Rule 43-I deals with cancellation of grants which have been obtained by making false or fraudulent representations. Rule 43-L provides that the State Government, if it is of the opinion that in the circumstances of any case or classes of cases it is just and reasonable to relax any of the foregoing provisions of the Rules, it may by order direct such relaxation subject to such conditions as may be specified in the order and thereupon land may be granted in such a case in accordance with such direction.
8. The question whether grants made under Rule 43-J were also subject to the conditions stipulated in Rule 43-G, came up for consideration before this Court repeatedly, it is sufficient to refer to (i) Chikkegowda v. State of Karnataka,2 (ii) Shivanna v. State of Karnataka,3 (iii) Venkatamma v. State of Karnataka,4 and (iv) K. Chowdaiah v. Deputy Commissioner, Mandya,5 and the decision of the Division Bench in Siddamma's case referred to above. It has been consistently held in these decisions that the conditions prescribed in Rule 43-G are applicable only to grant of land made under the Rules preceding Rule 43-G, that is, Rules 43-C and 43-D and will not apply to grants under Rules 43-J. The reasoning given by the Division Bench in Siddamma's case, to hold that Rule 43-G cannot be invoked in regard to grants under Rule 43-J is extracted below:—
“The rules indicate that list of lands available for cultivation should be prepared and thereafter the persons desirous of applying for the grant of land are entitled to apply and when such applications are received, the concerned competent authority is required to consider those applications and select the application for grant having due regard to the merits of the applications and also bearing in mind the priority for grant prescribed under the rules. These provisions obviously have no application to the grant of land made under Rule 43(J) to persons to whom the land had already been leased temporarily for cultivation. In the case of grant of land under Rule 43(J) there is no question of considering the applications of other persons. The competent authority concerned is required to find out as to whether the land had been granted for temporary cultivation to the person concerned and secondly as to whether he had fulfilled eligibility for grant of land and once those conditions are found to have been fulfilled the authority is competent to grant the land. One special feature about the grant is the person concerned would have already been in possession and enjoyment of the land for several years even before the grant of land and he would have invested money and time and engaged in cultivating the land even prior to the grant of land under Rule 43(J). Therefore, of such a grant falling under Rule 43(J) no other condition is imposed as is evident from the non-obstante clause with which it begins. Rule 43-G cannot be invoked to the grant made under Rule 43-J, also for the reason Rule 43-G expressly makes it clear that the conditions prescribed in the said Rule is applicable for the grant of lands made under the Rules preceding it.”
The referring Bench has expressed an opinion that the above construction of Rules 43-G and 43-J in Siddamma's case confers an undue advantage on the grantees under Rule 43-J and therefore requires reconsideration. We will therefore re-examine the matter with reference to the Scheme and intent of the Rule.
9. The Rules contemplated three types of grants: (i) grants under Rules 43C and 43D in respect of unoccupied land available for disposal; (ii) grants under Rules 43H, for cultivation of plantation crop; and (iii) grants under Rule 43-J, to occupants who were already in occupation in pursuance of temporary leases and who had fulfilled the conditions of such lease. While there is no dispute that the conditions in Rule 43-G, were applicable to grants under Rule 43-C and 43-D, and inapplicable to grants under Rule 43-H, there is a dispute about the applicability of the said conditions in Rule 43-G, to grants under Rule 43-J.
9.1 Rule 43-E related to reservation of lands for grant to applicants belonging to Schedule Castes and Tribes and political sufferers, from out of the land available for disposal in a village. Rule 43-F enumerated the order of priority for grant among applicants in regard to the lands available for disposal. It is evident from Rule 43-A that lands available for disposal in any village refer to unoccupied land fit for cultivation remaining after providing for special purposes enumerated therein. The wording of Rule 43G also made it clear that it was intended to apply to unoccupied lands; firstly the opening words ‘grant of lands under the preceding Rules shall be subject to the following conditions’, refer to Rules 43-C and 43-D which relate to grant of unoccupied land; secondly, sub-Rule(4) contained a bar on alienation for a period of 15 years from the date of grantee taking possession of the land after the grant, which meant that the Rule applied only to cases where the land was unoccupied at the time of grant and grantee was delivered possession after the grant; thirdly Sub-Rule (6) provided that the grantee shall bring the land under cultivation within two years from the date of grantee taking possession of the land which again implied that the Rule applies only in regard to cases where the granted land came into the possession of grantee after, the grant. Thus, a careful reading of Rules 43E, 43F and 43G discloses that they were applicable only to the first category of grants, that is, grants of unoccupied lands available for disposal, made under Rules 43C and 43D.
9.2 In regard to the second category, that is grants under Rule 43H, the provisions regarding reservation, priority and conditions of grant contained in Rule 43E, 43F and 43G are inapplicable, as Rule 43H is self-contained.
9.3 In regard to third category, that is grants to occupants under temporary leases, as the lands not unoccupied land, Rule 43E, 43F and 43-G were inapplicable. The grants under Rule 43J were contemplated only in favour of persons who were already in possession in pursuance of temporary leases, who had complied with the conditions of such leases. In such cases, grantees would have already been subjected to certain conditions at the time of putting them in possession on temporary lease and, therefore, there was no need or no occasion for stipulating any further conditions which were applicable to fresh grants relating to unoccupied lands. It may be noticed here that temporary leases were introduced with the intention of increasing the food production in the State by Government Order dated 11-4-1942 (clarified by Government Order dated 13.6.1942) which directed the Deputy Commissioners to lease unoccupied cultivable lands, to persons agreeable to bring such lands under cultivation, temporarily for periods not exceeding three years in the first instance with option to the lessees to purchase the lands at reasonsable upset price at the end of the lease period (such price not exceeding the market value of the land at the time it was given out for cultivation).
9.4 There is yet another difference among the three categories of grant. In grants under Rules 43C and 43D, the extent that can be granted is specified as two acres of garden/wet land with assured irrigation facilities from tanks and/or four acres of other kinds of wet land or ten acres of day land with a provision for grant in excess, subject to availability. On the other hand, in the second category (grants under Rule 43H) the grant can be upto 50 acres in regard to coffee/tea/cardamom cultivation and upto 25 acres in regard to rubber/pepper/cashewnut cultivation. In regard to third category (grants under Rule 43J) the question of any maximum extent being specified did not arise as the grant was in regard to land already in possession of the grantees.
9.5 In view of the distinct nature of the three types grants, the scheme of the Rules contemplated the conditions stipulated in Rule 43G being made applicable only to grants under Rules 43C and 43D. Rule 43G clearly states that it will apply to the grants under the preceding Rule (Rules 43C and 43D), thereby making it clear that it will not apply to the grants under the subsequent Rules, that is, Rules 43H and 43J. Rule 43J also starts with a non-obstante clause emphasising that notwithstanding anything contained in the preceding Rules (which includes Rule 43G), the land can be granted to the occupants if such land is available for disposal, that is, if such land is not required for any of the special purposes specified in Rule 43A.
10. But for the doubt expressed by the referring Bench, it would be unnecessary to examine the scheme and intent of the Rules to find out whether conditions stipulated in Rule 43G were applicable to grants under Rule 43-H, in view of the dear and express language used in Rule 43G, which start with the words; “Grant of lands under the preceding Rules shall be subject to the following conditions”. If the intention was to make the conditions in Rule 43-G applicable even to grants under Rules 43-H and/or Rule 43-J, then Rule 43G would have began with the words: “Grant of lands under these Rules shall be subject to the following conditions”, or with the words: “Grant of lands under Rules 43-C, 43-D and 43-J shall be subject to the following conditions”, instead of using the words “Grant of land under the preceding Rules shall be subject to the following conditions”. It is now well settled that were the language used in a Statute is plain, unambiguous and dear, effect must be given to it irrespective of the consequences. It is only when the language employed is vague or ambiguous, it will be necessary or permissible to call in aid the tools of interpretation. Having regard to the dear provisions of Rule 43G, it is not possible to apply the conditions mentioned in Rule 43G, to grants under Rule 43-J.
11. The Respondents contend that in regard to matters arising under PTCL Act, the question whether Rule 43G will govern the grants under Rule 43-J or not, should be decided with reference to the provisions of PTCL Act. The principles regarding interpretation of earlier statutes with reference to later statutes are well settled. A later statute will not be used as an aid to construction of an earlier statute. But if the earlier statute is ambiguous, a later statute on the same subject, may be used as a legislative exposition of the earlier statute. It is permissible to take and construe together, different statutes made at different times, and not referring to each other, as one system and as explanatory of each other, only if those statutes are of similar scope or on the same subject. But where the subject matter of the two statutes are different and there is nothing in the later statute, which is intended to be an interpretation of what is contained in the earlier statute, there is no question of later statute being called in aid to interpret the earlier statute. There is nothing in the PTCL Act, which is of any assistance to interpret Rule 43G and Rule 43J. It is, therefore, not permissible to call in aid, the provisions of PTCL Act to find out whether conditions stipulated in Rule 43G were applicable to grants under Rule 43J. Even assuming that provisions of PTCL Act should be employed for the purpose of interpretation of Rules, the position would be no different. Section 4 of PTCL Act invalidates any sale made in violation of the terms of grant or the Rules governing the grant. PTCL Act does not however prescribe the conditions, violation of which, will invalidate a sale. Only when the terms of grant or the Rules relating to grant are violated, the PTCL Act Will come into play. Hence, PTCL Act is of no assistance to interpret Rules 43G and 43J.
12. The Respondents next contended, supporting the decision of the Learned Single Judge, that Rule 43-G will be inapplicable to grants under Rules 43-J, except where the grant is to a person belonging to Schedule Caste or Schedule Tribe. We do not find how the very same Rule can be subjected to two interpretations in case of two classes of persons unless the Rules or any law relating to the matter provide for and contemplate such exception being made in the case of persons belonging to Scheduled Castes and Schedule Tribes. Section 11 of the PTCL Act, on which reliance is placed, provides that the provisions of the said Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any other law for the time being in force or any custom, usage or contract or any decree or order of a Court, Tribunal or other Authority. Section 11 is not attracted as we are not concerned with any law in force, as the Rules were repealed by the Mysore Land Grant Rules, 1968, long prior to PTCL Act came into force. Secondly, there is nothing in the Rules which is inconsistent with the provisions of PTCL Act. The provisions of the PTCL Act will apply only if the transfer of a granted land is in contravention of the terms of the grant of such land or the law providing for such grant. To find out whether an alienation or transfer is in contravention of any term of the grant or the law providing for such grant, it is necessary to look to the terms of the grant or law providing for such grant. In this case, to find out whether the transfer contravenes the law providing for such grant, we have to find out whether the transfer contravenes the provisions of the Mysore Land Revenue (Amendment) Rules, 1960. Thus, Section 11 of the PTCL Act has no relevance to find out whether conditions in Rule 43G apply to grant of lands under Rule 43J does not arise.
13. The above discussion makes it clear: (a) Rule 43J contemplated grants to persons who were already cultivating the lands for several years, by being in possession in pursuance of temporary leases granted to them, who formed a separate and distinct class; and in such cases, there was no need to stipulate any of the conditions specified in Rule 43G which were applicable to only grants relating to unoccupied lands where possession was yet to be delivered; (b) In view of the non-obstant clause with which Rule 43J began and in the absence of any indication in Rule 43J that the grants under that Rule to persons who were already in possession would be governed by the conditions in Rule 43G and having regard to the express provision in Rule 43G that the conditions therein would apply only to the grants made in the preceding Rules (that is, Rules 43C and 43D), the only inescapable conclusion is that conditions stipulated in Rule 43G were inapplicable to grants under Rule 43J. We are thus in respectful agreement with the views expressed in Siddamma's case. We, therefore, answer the question referred for opinion in the negative.
14. Considerable arguments were addressed on the question whether the Authority granting land under Rule 43J can impose any conditions at the time of making the grant; and on the effect of a condition imposed in the Saguvali Chit by the Tahsildar that the grantee shall not alienate the land for a period of fifteen years when such condition was not imposed by the order of the Authority making the grant. We express no opinion on these questions as they have not been referred for our opinion.
Alert