Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Srinivas Ambaji Kulkarni v. Assistant Commissioner, Belgaum

Karnataka High Court
Feb 28, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Writ Appeal (M. Venkatesh Murthy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a Writ Appeal against the order in Writ Petition No. 41682 of 1993 which dismissed a Writ Petition challenging the order of the Assistant Commissioner, Belgaum Sub-division, Belgaum in RTS. AP. 65/93 dated 5-11-1993.

The Writ Petitioner is the son of A.G. Kulkarni. A.G. Kulkarni purchased 5 guntas and 4 annas of land in Survey No. 73/2/4 of Anagol Village, Belgaum Taluk under a registered Sale Deed dated 25-5-1956. The petitioner claimed that his name was not recorded in the RTC in respect of the 5 guntas and 4 annas and applied to the Tahsildar, Belgaum for correction of the record of rights pursuant to that Sale Deed.

The Tahsildar gave notice to the third respondent (the vendor), conducted a summary enquiry under Section 129 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, and found that the property under the Sale Deed dated 25-5-1956 was in the petitioner’s possession. The Tahsildar directed that the petitioner’s name be entered in respect of Survey No. 73/2/4.

The third respondent, aggrieved by the Tahsildar’s order in RTS. SR. 51/92-93 dated 30.4.1993, appealed to the Assistant Commissioner in RTS. AP. 65/93 dated 5.11.1993. The Assistant Commissioner allowed the appeal on the ground that the Tahsildar could not have effected the change because the request was made beyond twelve years and that the appellant (third respondent) was entitled to move the Civil Court. The petitioner challenged the Assistant Commissioner’s order by filing the Writ Petition (which was dismissed), leading to this Writ Appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Assistant Commissioner could reject the petitioner's claim for correction of the Record of Rights on the grounds stated by him (principally limitation and that the Tahsildar had usurped the jurisdiction of a Civil Court).
  2. What is the scope and effect of a summary enquiry under Section 129 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act (Chapter VI) in relation to entries made in the Record of Rights and the appropriate forum for adjudication of disputed title or possession.

Arguments of the Parties

Writ Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The land (5 guntas and 4 annas) was purchased by A.G. Kulkarni under the Sale Deed dated 25-5-1956 and was mutated as Survey No. 73/2/4A; RTC extracts stood in the father's name and thereafter in the petitioner’s name.
  • The petitioner sought correction of the RTC extracts to accord with the mutation (sub-division into 73/2/4A) and obtained such correction from the Tahsildar after a summary enquiry which found the petitioner in possession of the land.
  • The petitioner’s claim was that the Tahsildar’s order was lawful and should stand; the Assistant Commissioner’s overturning of that order was challenged in the Writ Petition and in this appeal.

Third Respondent’s Arguments

  • The third respondent admitted an earlier sale in favour of Shankar Ambaji Sonavalkar in respect of 7 guntas (variously dated in the opinion), and in relation to the Sale Deed relied on by the petitioner, the third respondent denied the Sale Deed (not always specifically) and asserted possession of the properties.
  • The third respondent contended that the Tahsildar could not decide contested matters of title and possession and that only a Civil Court could adjudicate those issues; on that basis the Assistant Commissioner held that the Tahsildar had usurped the functions of a Civil Court and allowed the appeal.
  • The third respondent’s counsel relied on prior decisions (Payappa Nemanna Huded v. Chamu Appayya Huded; S. Halappa v. Assistant Commissioner, Shimoga Sub-Division; Rayanagouda v. Rajasaheb Balsaheb Jatgar) to support the contention that the Assistant Commissioner’s order was not open to challenge and that matters of title/possession fall within civil jurisdiction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in This Opinion
Payappa Nemanna Huded v. Chamu Appayya Huded, 1969 2 Mys. L.J 198 Shows a circumstance where the Deputy Commissioner ordered recording of a name in the Record of Rights and the court declined to exercise writ jurisdiction. The Court noted the decision but explained the broader principle that where authorities have recorded entries after enquiry, the court will not lightly disturb such administrative action; however this precedent does not support allowing the Assistant Commissioner to set aside a proper summary enquiry when the enquiry was within Section 129's scope.
S. Halappa v. Assistant Commissioner, Shimoga Sub-Division, 1993 1 Kar. L.J 82 Holds that the Assistant Commissioner cannot exercise jurisdiction that properly belongs to a Civil Court (example: misidentifying the land sold by survey number) and that wrongful exercise of such jurisdiction justifies judicial intervention. The Court relied on Halappa to stress that where an Assistant Commissioner exceeds power, writ jurisdiction can be exercised; used to distinguish circumstances where administrative action went beyond the scope of Section 129.
Rayanagouda v. Rajasaheb Balsaheb Jatgar, W.P. No. 2156/1977 (order dated 21-10-1982) Illustrates that issues going beyond the scope of enquiry under Section 129 (for example, allegations that a deed was nominal or contravened the Inam Abolition Law) are not amenable to the summary mutation process. The Court cited this decision for the proposition that some disputes are beyond the scope of Section 129 enquiries; but used it to emphasize that where the apparent tenor of a document supports mutation, the summary enquiry should give effect to it and leave contested title matters to Civil Courts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court’s reasoning proceeds from statutory context and the facts discovered by the Tahsildar:

  1. Statutory framework: The Court summarized Chapter VI of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964:
    • Section 128 — acquisition of rights to be reported;
    • Section 129 — registration of mutations and the procedure for such registration (summary enquiry);
    • Section 129A — issue of patta book containing copy of Record of Rights;
    • Section 130 — obligation to furnish information for compilation/revision of Record of Rights and bar of suits against State officials for having the entry made, while reserving the right to seek correction of entries against persons who deny such rights.
    The court emphasized that entries made after enquiry under Section 129 are always subject to final adjudication between the parties, and that the Section 129 enquiry is essentially summary in nature.
  2. Application of facts to law: The Tahsildar conducted the summary enquiry under Section 129, gave notice to the third respondent, and found that the petitioner was in possession of the land conveyed by the Sale Deed dated 25-5-1956; the Tahsildar directed that the petitioner’s name be entered.
  3. Critique of the Assistant Commissioner: The Assistant Commissioner allowed the third respondent’s appeal on the ground that the Tahsildar could not effect the change because the request was beyond twelve years and that the third respondent should move a Civil Court. The Court found this approach erroneous for several reasons:
    • The change sought was to delete 5 guntas and 4 annas from Survey No. 73/2/4 to reflect a prior conveyance (the land had been sub-divided into Survey No. 73/2/4A by a pencil entry and later regularly, apparently in 1960-1961) — thus the relief was corrective of the Record of Rights to accord with existing mutation and possession.
    • The Tahsildar’s enquiry had established the petitioner’s possession of the relevant land; in these circumstances the Assistant Commissioner should not have rejected the claim on limitation grounds or accused the Tahsildar of usurping civil jurisdiction.
    • The Assistant Commissioner “lost sight” of the true nature of the correction sought and misconstrued the Tahsildar’s function. The Court held that the Assistant Commissioner’s conclusion that the Tahsildar acted as if it were a Civil Court was misconceived and unsustainable.
  4. On the third respondent’s contention (that denial of the Sale Deed and assertion of possession made Tahsildar’s finding impossible): The Court rejected this contention. The Court observed that the initial subdivision entry (73/2/4A) had been on the records since about 1960-1961 and remained unaltered; if the third respondent had bona fide objections he had not prosecuted them earlier and had effectively “slept over the matter.” The Court emphasized that a mere objection in Section 129 proceedings does not automatically render the enquiry futile or compel the applicant to seek vindication in a Civil Court. Only objections of such a nature as to require fuller adjudication should shift the matter to a Civil Court.
  5. Synthesis with precedents: The Court reviewed the cited authorities and explained that the precedents confirm the limited scope of Section 129 enquiries — specifically that the apparent tenor of document ought to be given effect and parties disputing title may seek redress in Civil Courts. At the same time, where the administrative officer has not exceeded the statutory scope, the administrative finding following a summary enquiry should not be lightly set aside.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The order of the Assistant Commissioner, Belgaum Sub-division, Belgaum in RTS. AP. 65/93 dated 5.11.1993 is set aside and the order of the Tahsildar in proceedings No. RTS. SR. 51/92-93 is restored. The parties are directed to bear their own costs.

Implications:

  • The direct, operative effect is that the Tahsildar’s mutation (entry in the Record of Rights in respect of the petitioner’s 5 guntas and 4 annas) stands restored and the Assistant Commissioner’s contrary order is quashed.
  • The opinion reaffirms the limited, summary nature of enquiries under Section 129 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act and the principle that administrative mutation should be given effect according to the apparent tenor of the documents unless the matter clearly calls for full adjudication by a Civil Court.
  • The Court did not purport to lay down a new broad precedent beyond applying established principles: the decision resolves the dispute between these parties by restoring the Tahsildar’s order and notes that parties disputing title may in appropriate cases seek Civil Court remedy.

This summary is based exclusively on the contents of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond the text of the judgment.

Show all summary ...

M. Venkatesh Murthy, J.:— This Writ Appeal is against the order in Writ Petition No. 41682 of 1993 dismissing the Writ Petition challenging the order of the Assistant Commissioner, Belgaum Sub-division, Belgaum in RTS. AP. 65/93 dated 5-11-1993.

2. The Writ Petitioner is the son of A.G Kulkarni who purchased 5 guntas and 4 annas of land in Survey No. 73/2/4 of Anagol Village, Belgaum Taluk under registered Sale Deed dated 25.5.1956 The petitioner claiming that his name has not been recorded in the RTC., in respect of 5 guntas and 4 annas of land, made an application to the Tahsildar, Belgaum for necessary correction of the record of rights in terms of the Sale Deed dated 25.5.1956 The Tahsildar gave notice to the third respondent herein who was the vendor and conducted a summary enquiry and found that the land claimed by the petitioner was in his possession and directed the entering of his name in respect of Survey No. 73/2/4 of Anagol village. Being aggrieved by the order of the Tahsildar in RTS. SR. 51/92-93 dated 30.4.1993, the third respondent appealed to the Assistant Commissioner, Belgaum Sub-Division in RTS. AP. 65193 dated 5.11.1993 The Assistant Commissioner allowed the appeal on the ground that the Tahsildar could not have effected the change on the ground that the request was made beyond twelve years and that the appellant was entitled to move the Civil Court. Being aggrieved by the order of the Assistant Commissioner, the appellant herein filed the Writ Petition as aforesaid and lost his claim. Hence, this appeal.

3. The case of the Writ Petitioner before the Tahsildar and in the Writ Petition was that his father A.G Kulkarni purchased the land measuring 5 guntas and 4 annas under a Sale Deed dated 25-5-1956 and thereafter the land was mutated in the name of his father as Survey No. 73/2/4A and since then, the RTC., extracts are standing in petitioner's father's name and thereafter in his name. The third respondent, meanwhile, under a Sale Deed dated 5.11.1959 sold an extent of 7 guntas of land out of the balance of 7 guntas and 8 annas to one Shankar Ambaji Sonavalkar. Thus, the third respondent had possession and title to only 8 annas of land in Survey No. 73/2/4 of Anagol village. Apparently, the petitioner sought correction of the RTC Entract to accord with the mutation in Survey No. 73/2/4A. After the sales referred to above, the authorities were obliged to make corresponding deductions in the RTC extracts relating to Survey No. 73/2/4. However, the same not having been done, the petitioner approached the Tahsildar for the necessary correction and obtained the same. The Assistant Commissioner set it aside as aforesaid.

4. The question is, whether the Assistant Commissioner could have rejected the claim of the petitioner for reasons stated by him?

5. Before the Tahsildar, the third respondent filed a written objection admitting the sale dated 9.11.1959 in favour of Shankar Ambaji Sonavalkar in respect of 7 guntas of land under the Sale Deed dated 5.9.1959 However, in respect of the Sale Deed under which the petitioner claimed, he sought to deny it though not specifically. The Tahsildar conducted a summary enquiry in accordance with Section 129 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act and found that the property under the Sale Deed 25.5.1956 was in the possession of the petitioner in terms of the Sale Deed. At the stage of arguments, the third respondent appears to have denied the execution of the Sale Deed dated 25.5.1956 and asserted that he was in possession of the properties. It has to be noticed that the third respondent never sought to challenge the enquiry conducted by the Tahsildar either before the Assistant Commissioner or in the Writ Petition or in this Writ Appeal as being violative of natural justice or otherwise.

6. Chapter VI of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 (hereinafter called ‘the Act’) deals with maintenance of Record of Rights. Section 128 deals with acquisition of rights to be reported, Section 129 deals with registration of Mutations and the procedure for such registration, Section 129A deals with issue of patta book containing the copy of the Record of Rights pertaining to such land. Section 130 deals with the obligation to furnish information for compilation or revision of the Record of Rights and as to the bar of suits against the State Government or its officials in respect of claims for having the entry made in the Record of Rights, reserving expressly the right to seek a correction of the entry in the Record of Rights against persons who are interested in denying such a right. It is clear from the above provisions that the entries in the Record of Rights made after enquiry as provided for in Section 129 of the Act is always subject to a final adjudication of the rights between the parties to the land in question. At this stage, it is also necessary to observe and reiterate that the enquiry is essentially summary in nature.

7. The contention on behalf of the third respondent was that the order of the Assistant Commissioner is not open to challenge is as much as the Assistant Commissioner found that the Tahsildar could not have usurped the functions of a Civil Court adjudicating on title and possession of the property. In support of his contention, the learned Counsel for the third respondent relied upon the decisions reported in Payappa Nemanna Huded v. Chamu Appayya Huded . 1969 2 Mys. L.J 198. and S. Halappa v. Assistant Commissioner, Shimoga Sub-Division, Shimoga . 1993 1 Kar. L.J 82. and a decision in Writ Petition No. 2156 of 1977 dated 21.10.1982 Rayanagouda v. Rajasaheb Balsaheb Jatgar . W.P No. 2156/1977 dd 21-10-1982..

8. An examination of the case of Payappa Nemanna Huded's case referred to above would show that the Deputy Commissioner ordered the recording of name of the first respondent therein in the Record of Rights and in that circumstance, the Court declined to exercise its Writ Jurisdiction. In the case of Halappa this Court interfered with the order of the Assistant Commissioner on the ground that though Sale Deed pertained to survey No. 82/2, the Assistant Commissioner could not have held that the lands sold was Survey No. 82/1, which jurisdiction was exercisable only by a Civil Court. Having found that the Assistant Commissioner had exercised the jurisdiction wrongly, the Court restored the situation by directing that the land registered in respect of Survey No. 82/2 according to the ‘apparent tenor’ of the Sale Deed. So, it is clear that where the Assistant Commissioner exceeded his power, as in this case, Writ jurisdiction could be exercised by the Court. Even in the decision in Rayanagouda's case relied upon by the Learned Counsel for the third respondent, the contention against the mutation being effected in the name of the purchaser was that the deed was nominal and the transfer was in contravention of the Inam Abolition Law. This Court rejected the claim on the ground that the same was beyond the scope of an enquiry under Section 129 of the Act. Thus all the decisions referred to above are very clear in the interpretation of the scope of the enquiry under Section 129 of the Act holding that the appellant tenor of the document should be given effect to leaving the party contending otherwise to his remedy in a Civil Court.

9. The Assistant Commissioner who passed the order apparently lost sight of the fact that what was being done on the application of the petitioner was to delete 5 guntas and 4 annas of land from Survey No. 73/2/4 of Anagol Village that was apparently conveyed under the Sale Deed dated 25.5.1956 The land of the petitioner has already been sub-divided, first by the way of a pencil entry and thereafter regularly, as Survey No. 73/2/4A. Therefore the question of the claim of the petitioner being barred by limitation was a matter, the Assistant Commissioner himself could not have found against the petitioner especially in the light of the fact that the enquiry of the Tahsildar brought forth the fact that the petitioner was in possession of the land measuring 5 guntas and 4 annas. The order of the Assistant Commissioner that the Tahsildar acted as if it were a Civil Court was itself misconceived. Therefore the Assistant Commissioner's order cannot be sustained and requires to be set-aside.

10. The Learned Counsel for the third respondent sought to contend that when once third respondent denied the Sale Deed and asserted possession of the land there was no way by which the Tahsildar could have found against him and only a Civil Court could decide the matter and therefore the order of the Tahsildar is unsustainable. This submission requires to be mentioned to be rejected. It has to be seen that the first entry of sub-division of the land into 73/2/4A stood may way-back in the year 1960-1961 and it stood unaltered and unchanged upto this day. If there were any bonafides in the claim of the third respondent he would not have slept over the matter all these days. His objection to the petition before the Tahsildar almost to be opportunistic. If he has a grievance against the apparent tenor of the document he has executed in favour of A.G Kalkarni and the Sale Deed executed in favour of Sankar Ambaji Sonavalkar it is the Civil Court which could settle his contention. It is needless to state that mere raising of objection to mutation by a party in proceedings under Section 129 of the Act, does not render the enquiry futile forcing the applicant to vindicate his title in a Civil Court. The nature of the objection raised must be of such a nature as to lead to a conclusion that the decision to be taken on the application is more appropriately one that has to be taken by a Civil Court.

The appeal is allowed. The order of the Assistant Commissioner, Belgaum Sub-division, Belgaum in RTS. AP. 65/93 dated 5.11.1993 is set-aside and the order of the Tahsildar in proceedings No. RTS. SR 51/92-93 is restored. The parties are directed to bear their own costs.