Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Srikanth v. Chief Engineer, Karnataka Electricity Board, Bangalore And Others

Karnataka High Court
Jun 19, 1995
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner seeks quashing of Annexure-A, an order dated 11-3-1994 in which the third respondent rejected the petitioner's claim for appointment on compassionate grounds, and for a direction to appoint the petitioner to a suitable post.

Relevant factual chronology (as stated in the opinion):

  • The petitioner's father, Sri J. Siddappa, worked as a Mechanic, Grade-II in the respondent-Board for more than 20 years and died in harness on 24-4-1979.
  • He left behind his wife, six daughters and three sons. The eldest brother (Sri Nagaraj) and another brother (Sri Rajachari) are married and living separately; four sisters are married and living separately. The petitioner resides with his mother and unmarried sisters and is unemployed; he completed VIII Std.
  • The petitioner submitted an application on 11-3-1993 for compassionate appointment upon attaining majority. By a reply dated 11-3-1994, the Superintending Engineer (Annexure-A) informed the petitioner that he was not entitled to compassionate appointment because two of his brothers were already in the service of the respondent-Board.
  • The petitioner challenged that order by this writ petition, contending that the mere employment of his brothers is not a ground for rejection, that they were employed during the father's lifetime and do not support the family, and that he applied promptly on attaining majority and should have been considered under the Board's scheme.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to appointment on compassionate grounds despite two brothers being employed by the respondent-Board.
  2. Whether the respondent-Board's Circular dated 25-6-1990 and the Board resolution dated 8-10-1990 (which require no other wage-earner in the family for compassionate appointment) validly bar the petitioner's claim.
  3. Whether the long lapse of time (father's death in 1979; application in 1993) precludes grant of compassionate appointment because it defeats the objective of immediate relief to tide over financial crisis.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The employment of two brothers by itself is not a ground to refuse compassionate appointment.
  • Those brothers were employed during the lifetime of the father and are not supporting the family because they live separately with their own families.
  • The petitioner applied for appointment as soon as he attained majority and therefore should be provided employment under the Board's compassionate appointment scheme.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioner is not entitled to compassionate appointment because two of his brothers are already employed by the Board and are earning members of the family.
  • The scheme for compassionate appointment is intended to relieve the family of a deceased employee to tide over the difficulty caused by the sudden death of the earning member; it applies only where there are no other earning members in the family.
  • The Board's Circular dated 4-8-1978 read with the Circular dated 25-6-1990 and the Board resolution of 8-10-1990 provide for rejection of proposals where any family member is employed in the Board/Government/Semi-Government organisations, irrespective of whether the employment arose before or after the death of the head of the family.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Raja v. Karnataka Electricity Board, 1990 2 Kar. L.J 55 (DB) Held (as relied upon by petitioner) that employment of another son of the deceased by itself is not a ground for rejecting compassionate appointment. The court noted the petitioner relied on this decision but observed that subsequent Supreme Court decisions changed the legal position, and a Division Bench later held Raja's case was no longer good law.
Auditor General of India v. G. Ananta Rajeswara Rao, 1994 1 SCC 192 One of the Supreme Court decisions considered on circumstances for compassionate appointments (cited to show the evolved law). The court referred to this Supreme Court decision as part of later authorities which altered the legal approach post-Raja.
Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Mrs. Asha Ramachandra Ambekar, AIR 1994 SC 2148 Principle that courts must ensure compassionate appointments fall within the scope of law; relaxation allowed only when none of family members is gainfully employed; statutory/regulatory constraints bind statutory corporations. The court quoted this decision to support the proposition that compassionate appointments cannot disregard statutory rules and that relaxation is permissible only where none in the family is gainfully employed.
Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana, JT 1994 3 SC 525 Compassionate employment cannot be granted after a lapse of a reasonable period; it is not a vested right; object is to tide over financial crisis at the time of death. The court relied on this authority to hold that a long delay (14 years) defeats the purpose of compassionate appointment and that the family's changed circumstances in 1993 weigh against grant.
Jabhiulla v. Chief Engineer, Keb*, 1994 4 Kar. L.J 278 (DB) Division Bench considered the Supreme Court decisions and held that the law laid down in Raja's case was no longer good law. The court cited this decision to support the proposition that Raja's precedent cannot be followed because of subsequent Supreme Court rulings.
Susheela B. Bhakta v. Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation, 1995 4 Kar. L.J 6 Single Judge's dictum that authorities should enquire into the family's income and whether, but for employment, the family cannot tide over the crisis; mere employment of a son who has separated may not preclude compassionate appointment. The court distinguished that decision on facts and law (absence of Circular/resolution in that case and immediate application after death) and stated it was not applicable to the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded through these steps, based strictly on the material and authorities cited in the opinion:

  1. Fact assessment: The father died in 1979; the petitioner applied in 1993. By 1993 two brothers were employed and four sisters married. The family circumstances had materially changed between 1979 and 1993.
  2. Nature of compassionate appointment: The court reiterated that compassionate appointment is an exception to normal selection rules and is intended to provide immediate relief to the family of a deceased breadwinner to tide over sudden financial crisis. Therefore, the petitioner must conclusively demonstrate circumstances justifying departure from ordinary selection rules.
  3. Reliance on precedent and its current standing:
    • The petitioner relied on Raja's case to argue that employment of another son is not by itself a bar. The court observed, however, that subsequent Supreme Court decisions (including Auditor General, LIC, and Umesh) had refined the law, and a Division Bench (Jabhiulla) held Raja's decision was no longer good law.
  4. Statutory/regulatory framework and Board policy:
    • The respondent-Board had issued a Circular dated 25-6-1990 and passed a resolution dated 8-10-1990 providing that recommendations for compassionate appointments shall be considered only where there is no other wage-earner in the family; the resolution rejected applications if any family member is employed by Board/Government/Semi-Government organisations.
    • The court noted the Board is bound to follow its Circulars and Resolutions and that the LIC decision supports the proposition that statutory/regulatory constraints cannot be set aside for compassionate appointments.
  5. Temporal limitation and purpose:
    • The court relied on the Umesh Kumar Nagpal decision to conclude that compassionate employment cannot be granted after lapse of a reasonable period because the object is to meet the immediate crisis; the petitioner's application after nearly 14 years defeats that objective.
  6. Equality considerations:
    • The court observed the scheme allows application within three years of attaining majority, but also noted that compassionate appointments are extraordinary and, if granted when the family is not destitute, could violate equality under Article 16 of the Constitution. The court emphasised compassionate appointment is not a hereditary or perennial right.
  7. Evaluation of competing single-judge authority:
    • The court considered Susheela B. Bhakta, which held that mere employment of one son may not clinch the issue if that son had separated from the family; but the present case was distinguished because (a) the Board Circular and resolution expressly prohibited compassionate appointment where any family member is employed and (b) the application here was made after a long delay whereas in Susheela the application was immediate.
  8. Final application to facts:
    • The court concluded that, given the Board's Circular and resolution and the lapse of almost 14 years (with two brothers employed and four sisters married), the petitioner's family position had changed so as to negate the purpose of a compassionate appointment in 1993.

Holding and Implications

Holding: DISMISSED. The writ petition was dismissed; the court found no merit in the petition and upheld the rejection recorded in Annexure-A (11-3-1994).

Implications and consequences:

  • Direct effect: The petitioner is not entitled to compassionate appointment by reason of (a) the Board's Circular dated 25-6-1990 and the Board resolution dated 8-10-1990 which require absence of any other wage-earner in the family, and (b) the substantial lapse of time (application made in 1993 when the father had died in 1979) which, in the court's view, defeats the purpose of compassionate appointment.
  • The court relied on subsequent Supreme Court authority to limit the application of earlier precedents (such as Raja), and distinguished a single-judge decision (Susheela B. Bhakta) on facts and policy grounds.
  • No broader new legal principle was formulated by this court; the decision applies the Board's policy and established Supreme Court propositions to the facts and results in dismissal of the petition. The opinion confines itself to the direct effect on the parties as described above.

Show all summary ...

1. In this writ petition, the petitioner prays for quashing Annexure-A order dated 11-3-1994 wherein the third respondent rejected the claim of the petitioner for an appointment on compassionate grounds and for a direction to respondent to appoint the petitioner to a suitable post.

2. Sri J. Siddappa, father of the petitioner was working as a Mechanic, Grade-II in the respondent-Board for more than 20 years. He died in harness on 24-4-1979 leaving behind him his wife, six daughters and three sons. The eldest brother of the petitioner Sri Nagaraj is married and living separately, settled at Shimoga. Another brother Sri Rajachari is married and living separately at Jog. Four sisters of the petitioner are also married and living separately with their families. The petitioner is staying with his mother and unmarried sisters who are umemployed. Petitioner has completed VIII Std. and is unemployed. Petitioner submitted an application on 11-3-1993 to appoint him in the respondent-Board on compassionate grounds on his attaining majority. The Superintending Engineer by his reply dated 11-3-1994 informed the petitioner that he is not entitled to an appointment on compassionate grounds as two brothers of the petitioner Sri Nagaraj and Sri Rajachari are already in the service of the respondent-Board. The above order is produced as Annexure-A. The petitioner has challenged the above order in this writ petition on the ground that the fact that two brothers of the petitioner are already employed by itself is not a ground for refusing the claim of the petitioner. It is further contended by the petitioner that the brothers were employed even during the lifetime of the father and that they are not supporting the family as they are living separately with their families. The petitioner has submitted the application as soon as he attained majority and he should have been provided with an employment on compassionate grounds in accordance with the scheme framed by the respondent-Board.

3. The respondents have filed statement of objections in which it is submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to compassionate appointment for the reason that his two brothers are already in the employment of the Board and are earning members of the family. The scheme for compassionate appointment is intended to give relief to the family of a deceased employee to tide over the difficulty caused by the sudden death of the earning member. The Board Circular dated 4-8-1978 read with the guidelines as per Circular dated 25-6-1990 clearly provides that the proposal for compassionate appointment shall be considered only if there are no other earning members in the family. The Board has also passed a resolution dated 8-10-1990 to reject such applications where anyone or more members of the family are in employment of the Board/Government/Semi-Government organisations, whether employed before or after the death of the head of the family. In this case, the petitioner's brothers are already in employment and the rejection of the petitioner's application was proper.

4. In the light of the above, the question to be decided is as to whether the petitioner is entitled to an appointment on compassionate grounds. The father of the petitioner died in 1979 and the petitioner filed the application in 1993. At the time of the application two of the brothers of the petitioner are already in employment and four sisters are also married.

5. An appointment on compassionate grounds is an exception to the normal rule of selection by considering the case of all eligible persons. Unless the petitioner conclusively proves that circumstances exist to depart from the normal rule, the petitioner will not be entitled to relief. The application of the petitioner is rejected on the ground that two of his brothers are already gainfully employed in the respondent-Board itself and so the petitioner is not entitled to any compassion. The learned Counsel for the petitioner relied on a Division Bench decision of this Court in K. Raja v. Karnataka Electricity Board . 1990 2 Kar. L.J 55 DB, for the position that employment of another son of the deceased by itself is not a ground for rejecting an appointment on compassionate grounds. But it is to be noted that thereafter, the Supreme Court has considered the circumstances in which compassionate appointments can be made in the decisions reported in Auditor General of India v. G. Ananta Rajeswara Rao . 1994 1 SCC 192, Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Mrs. Asha Ramachandra Ambekar . AIR 1994 SC 2148, and Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana . JT 1994 3 SC 525.. These decisions were considered by a Division Bench of this Court in Jabhiulla v. Chief Engineer, Keb* . 1994 4 Kar. L.J 278 DB., and it was held that the law laid down by this Court in Raja's case, supra, is no longer good law.

6. The respondent has issued a Circular dated 25-6-1990 in regard to compassionate appointments. The Circular provides that recommendations for compassionate appointments shall be made if only there is no other wage earner in the family. The resolution of the Board dated 8-10-1990 is also to that effect. The respondent-Board is bound to follow the Circular and the Resolutions passed on the subject.

7. In Life Insurance Corporation of India's case, supra, at page 721, the Supreme Court observed as follows:

“The Courts should endeavour to find out whether a particular case in which sympathetic considerations are to be weighed falls within the scope of law. Disregardful of law, however, hard the case may be, it should never be done. In the very case itself, there are regulations and instructions which we have extracted above. The Court below has not even examined whether a case falls within the scope of these statutory provisions. Clause 2 of sub-clause (iii) of instructions makes it clear that relaxation could be given only when none of the members of the family is gainfully employed. Clause 4 of the Circular dated January, 1987 interdicts such an appointment on compassionate grounds. The appellant Corporation being a statutory corporation is bound by the Life Insurance Corporation Act as well as the statutory regulations and instructions. They cannot be put aside and compassionate appointment be ordered”.

8. In the light of the Circular dated 25-6-1990 and the resolution of the respondent-Board dated 8-10-1990 which the Board is bound to follow, the petitioner is not entitled to an appointment on compassionate grounds as two members of his family are already in employment in the respondent-Board itself.

9. The purpose of compassionate appointment is to assist the family at the time of crisis due to the death of the breadwinner. Unless it is done immediately, it does not serve the purpose. It is not also proper to give such appointments after decades when the family has got over the crisis overlooking the normal rules of selection. The same view was expressed by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal's case, supra, which reads:

“For these very reasons, the compassionate employment cannot be granted after a lapse of a reasonable period which must be specified in the rules. The consideration for such employment is not a vested right which can be exercised at any time in future. The object being to enable the family to get over the financial crisis which it faces at the time of the death of the sole breadwinner, the compassionate employment cannot be claimed and offered whatever the lapse of time and after the crisis is over”.

10. The father of the petitioner died in 1979 and the petitioner made the application in 1993, nearly one and half decades thereafter. By the time two of his brothers are already employed and 4 of his sisters are married. The financial position of the family is completely changed. No doubt the scheme provides that any member of the family can apply for compassionate appointment within three years of attaining majority. But it is well settled that, the extraordinary method of making compassionate appointments is to help the family in penury and without any means of livelihood. If such appointments are made even if the family is not destitute that will be in violation of the Constitutional guarantee under Article 16 of the Constitution of India. It cannot be claimed as a hereditary right.

11. In Umesh Kumar's case, the Supreme Court has said:

“The whole object of granting compassionate employment is thus to enable the family to tide over the sudden crisis. The object is not to give a member of such family a post much less a post for post held by the deceased. What is further, mere death of an employee in harness does not entitle his family to such source of livelihood. The Government or the public authority concerned has to examine the financial condition of the family of the deceased, and it is only if it is satisfied, that but for the provision of employment, the family will not be able to meet the crisis that a job is to be offered to the eligible member of the family”.

12. It was further observed:

“It must be remembered in this connection that as against the destitute family of the deceased there are millions of other families which are equally, if not more destitute”.

13. In the light of the above proposition laid down by the Supreme Court, the circumstances as existed in 1993 has to be taken note of. At that time, from the materials available in the case, it is clear that the position of the family has changed and that two brothers of the petitioner are already in employment and that the sisters of the petitioner are married. The provision in the scheme for making an application after three years of attaining majority does not stand the test of equality guaranteed under Article 16 of the Constitution of India. By 1993, the position of the family has entirely changed as it existed in 1979 when the father of the petitioner died and that the petitioner is not entitled to any compassionate appointment. Learned Counsel for the petitioner relied on a decision of this Court in Susheela B. Bhakta v. Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation . 1995 4 Kar. L.J 6, wherein, a learned single Judge of this Court after considering all the decision of the Supreme Court on the point, has said to the following effect:

“For appropriately dealing with an application for grant of appointment on compassionate ground it is incumbent upon the authorities to ascertain by holding an appropriate enquiry as to whether the family comprised of the dependants of the deceased employee had any income from any source to sustain their livelihood, and if it is found that but for a job being offered to one of the eligible dependants their family cannot tide over the crisis, compassionate employment should be given to the eligible dependant. Mere employment of one of the sons of the deceased cannot clinch the issue of granting compassionate appointment, if on facts it is found that he had separated from the family of the deceased even during his lifetime, because in such a situation it cannot be said that he was still a helping hand to the family”.

14. The dictum laid down in the above decision can have no application to the facts of the case for, in this case, the Circular dated 25-6-1990 and the resolution of the respondent-Board dated 8-10-1990 clearly prohibits appointment on compassionate grounds if any other member of the family is employed. Such a provision was absent in that case. Moreover, in that case, the application for appointment was made immediately after the death, whereas, in this case, it is made nearly 14 years after the death of the father. That apart, I have my own reservations regarding the statement made by the learned single Judge that:

“Mere employment of one of the sons of the deceased cannot clinch the issue of granting compassionate appointment, if on facts it is found that he had separated from the family of the deceased even during his lifetime, because in such a situation it cannot be said that he was still a helping hand to the family”.

15. Even under the scheme for compassionate appointments, only one member of the family will be entitled to such appointment. He may be married or unmarried at the time of employment. If unmarried may get married later. He may be appointed or transferred to any place other than where the family is residing. In that contingency, he will have to necessarily set up his family at the place of employment. These privileges cannot be denied to him by the other members by the mere fact that he got an appointment on compassionate grounds. It is also pertinent to pose a question as to what is the character or incidence of the salary which such person receives on employment. Is it family property or personal property? Is he a trustee for all the members of the family? Is he bound to account the same to the other members of the family as he obtained the employment on behalf of the family owing to the sudden death of the head of the family? If he neglects to look after the family, are the other members entitled to proceed against the salary? Even if one member gets an employment on compassionate grounds and if he neglects to look after the family, are the other members entitled to have another compassionate appointment on the ground that the member who got the appointment is not extending any help to the family. These are some of the problems which has baffled me for which I am not able to get a satisfactory answer. It is evident that compassionate appointment is given to one of the members of the deceased family to tide over the sudden economic crisis facing the family on the sudden demise of the breadwinner in the belief that he would look after the family which was being done by the deceased and not as a hereditary right. If one or more members of the family are already employed, it cannot be said that the family is penurious. In that view of the matter, the fact that two brothers of the petitioner got employment during the lifetime of the deceased father and that they are residing separate makes no difference and disentitles the petitioner from claiming appointment on compassionate grounds. Anyhow, I am not expressing any final opinion in this regard as this writ petition can be disposed of on two grounds, viz., the provision under Circular and the resolution and the lapse of nearly 14 years from the date of the death of the deceased. I leave the matter there.

16. In view of what is stated above, I do not find any merit in this writ petition and it is accordingly, dismissed.