- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Usharani v. D.S Lakshmaiah
Factual and Procedural Background
The Revision petitioners filed a petition under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure before the J.M.F.C, Sidlaghatta, seeking maintenance of Rs. 500 per month each from their father-respondent. The Magistrate dismissed the petition for petitioners 1 and 2, who were majors at the time of filing, but granted maintenance of Rs. 150 per month to petitioner 3 until she attained majority on 30.4.90. Aggrieved by this order, the petitioners preferred the present Revision Petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether petitioners 1 and 2, being majors, are entitled to maintenance under Section 125 Cr. P.C.
- Whether maintenance payable to the 3rd petitioner should be restricted only up to the date she attained majority.
- Whether the quantum of maintenance awarded to the 3rd petitioner was adequate or requires enhancement.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioners' Arguments
- The learned Magistrate erred in dismissing the maintenance claims of petitioners 1 and 2 on the ground that they were majors.
- The restriction of maintenance payable to the 3rd petitioner only until she attained majority was incorrect.
- The maintenance amount of Rs. 150 per month awarded to the 3rd petitioner was meagre and needed enhancement.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ismail Sheriff v. Nasarin, 1963 2 Mys. L.J 233 | Held that a major son or daughter is entitled to claim maintenance under Section 488(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, as the age of the child is not relevant if the child is unable to maintain himself or herself. | The Court distinguished this precedent, noting it arose under the old Cr. P.C. 1898 Section 488(1) which did not restrict maintenance claims to minors, unlike Section 125(1)(b) & (c) of the 1973 Code which explicitly limits maintenance to minor children or major children unable to maintain themselves due to physical or mental abnormality. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the distinction between the provisions under the old Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (Section 488(1)) and the current Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Section 125). It noted that the 1898 provision did not specify "minor" and allowed maintenance claims by major children unable to maintain themselves. However, the 1973 Code explicitly restricts maintenance claims to "minor" children or major children who are unable to maintain themselves due to physical or mental abnormality or injury.
Since petitioners 1 and 2 were major and not shown to be unable to maintain themselves due to any abnormality, they were not entitled to maintenance under Section 125(1)(b) or (c). Similarly, petitioner 3’s claim after attaining majority was not covered as she did not suffer from any such abnormality. Therefore, the Magistrate’s dismissal of claims for petitioners 1 and 2 and limitation of maintenance for petitioner 3 until her majority was legally sound.
Regarding the quantum of maintenance for petitioner 3, the Court considered the respondent's income sources, including agricultural land and a grocery shop, and the absence of any other liabilities. While the respondent had a moral obligation to maintain all unmarried daughters unable to maintain themselves, the legal provisions limited the maintenance. Taking these factors into account, the Court increased the maintenance from Rs. 150 to Rs. 400 per month for petitioner 3 for the relevant period.
Holding and Implications
The Court’s final decision was to allow the Revision Petition only to the extent of enhancing the maintenance amount awarded to the 3rd petitioner from Rs. 150 to Rs. 400 per month for the period up to 30.4.90. The dismissal of claims of petitioners 1 and 2 and the limitation of maintenance to petitioner 3 until she attained majority remained undisturbed.
The decision clarifies the application of Section 125 Cr. P.C. 1973 regarding maintenance claims by major children, emphasizing the statutory distinction from earlier law and limiting claims to minors or major children with physical or mental incapacity. No new precedent was set beyond affirming the statutory interpretation and adjusting maintenance quantum based on respondent’s means.
Krishnan, J.:—
Though this matter appears for orders, it is taken up for final disposal by consent of both the sides.
2. The Revision petitioners had filed a petition before J.M.F.C, Sidlaghatta in C.M.C 46/88 under Section 125 of Code of Criminal Procedure against their father-respondent herein for grant of maintenance of Rs. 500/- per month to each of them. The petition so far as petitioners 1 and 2, came to be dismissed. So far as petitioner No. 3 is concerned, the learned Magistrate directed payment of separate maintenance at the rate of Rs. 150/- per month from the date of petition till 30.4.90 on which date 3rd petitioner also attained majority. Being aggrieved by this order of the learned Magistrate, the petitioners have preferred this Revision Petition.
3. That petitioners 1 and 2 were majors even as on the date on which they filed the petition under Section 125 Cr. P.C is undisputed. So far as 3rd petitioner is concerned, that she also attained majority on 30.4.90 is also not disputed. The contentions urged on behalf of the Revision petitioners are—
1) The learned Magistrate was not right in holding that petitioners 1 and 2 are not entitled to maintenance because they are majors; and
2) the learned Magistrate was not right in restricting the maintenance payable to the 3rd petitioner only upto 30.4.90
3) Even otherwise the maintenance at the rate of Rs. 150/- per month awarded to the 3rd petitioner is very meagre and that has to be enhanced.
4. The first two contentions urged depends on the aspect whether the son or daughter of a person who has attained majority is entitled to claim maintenance when he or she is unable to maintain himself or herself. The learned Advocate for the Revision petitioners invited the attention of the Court to the Decision of this Court in Ismail Sheriff v. Nasarin . 1963 2 Mys. L.J 233., and pointed out that in that Decision it has been held that the major boy or girl is also entitled to claim maintenance. It is no doubt true that it has been held so in that Decision but it was with reference to a petition filed under Section 488(1) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898. The said Section reads thus:
“If any person having sufficient means neglects or refuses to maintain his wife or his legitimate or illegitimate child unable to maintain itself, a Presidency Magistrate, or a Magistrate of the first class may, upon proof of such neglect or refusal, order such person to make a monthly allowance for the maintenance of his wife or such child, at such monthly rate, not exceeding (five hundred rupees) in the whole, as such Magistrate thinks fit, and to pay the same to such person as the Magistrate from time to time directs.”
(Emphasis is supplied)
In this Decision relied upon by the learned Advocate for the petitioners it has been observed as hereunder with reference to the aspect that the age of the child is not at all relevant while granting maintenance under Section 488(1) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898:
“The relevant point for consideration under Section 488(1) Cr. P.C is whether the child is capable of maintaining himself or herself without the aid from the father and it has nothing to do with the age. If really the Legislature intended that the word ‘Child’ in sub-clause (1) of Section 488 Cr. P.C would have reference only to a boy or a girl below the age of 18 years nothing prevented the Legislature for making it quite clear. As rightly pointed out by some of the learned Judges the Legislature could have made it clear by saying ‘minor child’. The fact that the Legislature has not done so and has instead used the word child in sub-clause (1) of Section 488 Cr. P.C supports the view that the Legislature did not intend to restrict the application of this provision to a boy or a girl below the age of 18 years.”
It may be noticed that we are dealing with a case not under Section 488 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, but a case arising under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The qualifying word minor which was not there in Section 488(1) of Cr. P.C 1898, has been introduced in Section 125(1)(b) of Cr. P.C 1973. Sub-sections (b) & (c) of Section 125(1) of 1973 Code, which refer to the right of a child to claim maintenance read as hereunder:
“(b) his legitimate or illegitimate minor child, whether married or not, unable to maintain itself, or
(c) his legitimate or illegitimate child (not being a married daughter) who has attained majority, where such child is, by reason of any physical or mental abnormality or injury unable to maintain itself, or”
It may be noticed that the Parliament in its wisdom has enabled only a minor child whether legitimate or illegitimate to claim maintenance under Section 125(1)(b) & only one exception has been made by enacting sub-section (c) which enables the child which has attained majority to claim maintenance. That is a case where the child by reason of any physical or mental abnormality or injury is unable to maintain itself. It is not the case of any of the petitioners that they have any physical or mental abnormality or injury or on that account they are unable to maintain themselves. Therefore, it is clear that the case of petitioners 1 and 2 does not come under either sub-clause (b) or (c) of Section 125(1) and the case of the 3rd petitioner subsequent to 30.4.90 does not also come under any of these sub-sections. In this view of the matter, the Decision relied upon has no application to a case arising under Section 125(1)(b) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. Therefore, the learned Magistrate was right in negativing the claim made by petitioners 1 and 2 and restricting the claim of 3rd petitioner to that date.
So far as the third grievance regarding the quantum awarded is concerned there is material to show that the respondent is having lands which are fed by well and that he also has been growing mulberry and other crops. Further, there is also material to show that he has been running a grocery shop, the photograph of which has been produced as per Ex. P-6. No material whatsoever has been placed on record to show that the respondent has any other liability. As it is though it is his moral obligation to maintain even petitioners 1 and 2 because they are unmarried daughters unable to maintain themselves, he is getting over that liability on account of the language employed in Section 125(1)(b) and (c) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. Therefore, this aspect cannot be lost sight of in fixing up the quantum of maintenance to be awarded to the 3rd petitioner. Having regard to all these aspects, it appears that in the interest of justice, a sum of Rs. 400/- per month would be the adequate amount to be awarded to the 3rd petitioner for the above said period.
In the result, the amount awarded in favour of the 3rd petitioner is enhanced from Rs. 150/- per month to Rs. 400/- per month for the above said period of two years. Except this modification, the order of the learned Magistrate in other respects shall stand undisturbed. The Revision Petition is allowed only to the extent indicated above.
Alert