Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Karnataka Board Of Wakfs v. Hazrath Attulla Shah Dhargah

Karnataka High Court
Jan 14, 1992
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Karnataka Board of Wakfs v. (Connected Matters)

Factual and Procedural Background

These are appeals by the Karnataka Board of Wakfs against the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge dated 15th December 1989 in several connected writ petitions, including Writ Petitions Nos. 5141 & 5142 of 1982 filed by the Board.

The dispute concerns a parcel of land measuring 325 feet by 125 feet in R.S. Nos. 1 and 2 of Annipura village, Kasaba Hobli, Bangalore North Taluk. The land was Devadaya Inam Land said to belong to the Hazarath Attulla Shah Dargah. The second respondent purchased the land from one Ghouse Bi by sale deed dated 4th December 1946; on 13th September 1947 a half portion was sold by the second respondent to the third respondent.

On 28th July 1947 the Sajjada of the Dargah petitioned under Section 10 of the Mysore Religious and Charitable Institution Act, 1927, seeking a declaration that the land belonged to the Dargah, that the alienations in favour of the second and third respondents were void, and that the land be restored to the Dargah. These proceedings continued, including appeals and remands, until about 1974 before the Special Deputy Commissioner in Muzrai appeal No. 72/67-68. By order dated 23rd August 1974 the Special Deputy Commissioner required the land to be restored to the second and third respondents.

The Dargah appealed to the Commissioner for Religious and Charitable Endowments. By that time the Wakf Act, 1954 had come into force in Karnataka (effective 15th January 1955) and the Wakf Board had issued a Notification under Section 5 showing the land as belonging to the Dargah. The Wakf Board was impleaded in the appeal, contending that the land belonged to the Wakf Board and that the question of title should be decided by a Civil Court in light of Section 6 of the Wakf Act. The appeal was dismissed (Wakf Board held to have no locus standi) and subsequent appeals by the Wakf Board and the Dargah to the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal were also dismissed.

Thereafter Writ Petitions Nos. 5141 and 5142/1982 were filed by the Wakf Board impugning the Tribunal's order. The second and third respondents also filed writ petitions to the extent not material here. The learned Single Judge rejected the Wakf Board's contention that the Notification (or inclusion in the list) had abolished the interest of the second and third respondents in the land.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the persons claiming title (the second and third respondents) fall within the expression "any person interested therein" in Section 6(1) of the Wakf Act, 1954, and therefore are subject to the special one-year limitation period in the proviso to Section 6(1) for instituting a suit contesting inclusion of property in the list published under Section 5(2).
  2. Whether the list of Wakfs published under Section 5(2) is final and conclusive against persons who are "persons interested in the Wakf" and whether a Civil Court suit contesting title is barred after one year from the date of publication (here, relevant notification dated 11th July 1965).
  3. Whether disputes as to title of properties included in the Section 5(2) list must be decided by a Civil Court except where the dispute is raised by the Board, the mutawalli, or a person interested in the Wakf (and in such cases subject to the one-year limitation).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Karnataka Board of Wakfs)

  • The Wakf Board contended that the land in question belonged to the Wakf (as shown in the Notification under Section 5) and that the title question ought to be referred to a Civil Court under Section 6 of the Wakf Act.
  • The Wakf Board sought to be impleaded in the administrative/appeal proceedings and relied on the Wakf Act scheme and the finality provisions for published lists of Wakfs.

Second and Third Respondents (as addressed in the opinion)

  • Counsel for the second and third respondents (Mr. M.S. Gopal) relied on prior judicial interpretations (including a Single Judge decision in Anjuman-E-Islamia v. Sakeenabi) to argue limitations on who qualifies as "any person interested" under Section 6, and the scope of the right to institute suits under that provision.
  • It was also pointed out (by respondents' counsel) that the Tribunal had earlier found that the land had ceased to be Inam land as far back as 1973 and that purchasers at that time had been non-Muslims, and that the Dargah had no interest in the land (as held by the Tribunal).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
THE Board of Muslim Wakfs, Rajasthan v. Radha Kishan, AIR 1979 SC 289 Interpretation of "any person interested therein" in Section 6(1) of the Wakf Act — held that "therein" refers to the Wakf (not Wakf property) and that only those interested in the Wakf (Board, mutawalli, or persons interested in the Wakf) are empowered to file the suits; non-Muslim strangers are not bound by the Section 5(2) list within the one-year limitation. The court applied the Supreme Court's construction to hold that "therein" refers to interest in the Wakf and that Muslim persons who are entitled to worship/participate (per Section 3(h)) are "persons interested" and therefore subject to the proviso one-year limitation.
Anjuman-E-Islamia v. Sakeenabi, AIR 1986 Karnataka 75 (Single Judge) Held (at that time) that Section 6 enabled only Board, mutawalli, or persons interested in the particular Wakf to institute a suit and suggested "any person interested" meant a person interested in maintaining that particular property as Wakf property. The court regarded this Single Judge decision as no longer good law in view of the Supreme Court decision in Radha Kishan, which clarified the meaning of "therein" and the scope of persons covered by Section 6(1).
Cheedella Motaiah v. Wakf Board, Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1978 Andhra Pradesh 34 Interpreted Section 6 read with Section 3(h): right to file a suit confined to the Wakf Board, the mutawalli, or persons interested in the Wakf; list's finality applies only against those persons; does not bind absolute strangers/non-Muslims. The court observed this authority but found it did not take the matter further for the present case given the Supreme Court's subsequent pronouncements and the facts before the court.
Corporation of The City of Bangalore v. Mysore State Board of Wakfs, 1973 1 Mys. L.J 103 Held that where municipal/corporate lands were listed as Wakf property, the corporation's rights, if any, were unaffected; disputes between the Wakf Board and the corporation must be decided by a competent Civil Court. The court noted this decision but found it not decisive for the present dispute given the statutory scheme and the Supreme Court's interpretation of Section 6.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the statutory provisions of the Wakf Act (notably Sections 3, 4, 5 and 6) and the effect of the list published under Section 5(2). The key analytical steps were:

  1. The court set out the relevant statutory scheme: Section 4 (appointment of Commissioner of Wakfs and survey), Section 5(1)-(2) (forwarding the survey scheme and publication by the Board of a list of Wakfs), and Section 6(1) with its proviso (permitting the Board, the mutawalli or "any person interested therein" to institute a suit, and providing a one-year limitation from publication).
  2. The court relied heavily on the Supreme Court's decision in Board of Muslim Wakfs, Rajasthan v. Radha Kishan, which construed "any person interested therein" in Section 6(1) to mean persons interested in the Wakf (i.e., the Wakf itself) and not persons merely claiming that a particular parcel of property is not Wakf property. The Supreme Court had held that non-Muslim strangers are not bound by the list and are not subject to the one-year limitation.
  3. Having adopted the Supreme Court's construction that "therein" refers to the Wakf (not Wakf property), the court examined Section 3(h) which defines a "person interested in a Wakf" to include anyone entitled to receive benefits or to worship or perform religious rites in institutions connected with the Wakf (including a dargah).
  4. Because every person professing Islam has the right to worship or perform religious rites in a dargah or other institutions connected with a Wakf, and because the second and third respondents did not contend that they were not Muslims or were not so entitled, the court concluded on a plain reading that the second and third respondents are "persons interested in the Wakf" within the meaning of Section 3(h) and therefore fall within the category subject to the proviso to Section 6(1).
  5. Application of the one-year limitation: the notification (the list under Section 5(2)) for the land was published on 11th July 1965. Accordingly, any suit by a person interested in the Wakf contesting inclusion should have been filed on or before 11th July 1966. The court held that the second and third respondents cannot file such a suit now as the statutory one-year period has expired.
  6. The court rejected the argument that earlier findings by other authorities (for example, that the land ceased to be Inam land or that the Dargah had no interest) altered the statutory position created by the Wakf Act. The statutory limitation and scheme govern the consequences of inclusion in the published list as against persons who qualify under Section 6(1).
  7. The court observed that earlier judicial decisions (for example the Single Judge decision in Anjuman-E-Islamia) that took a different view on the meaning of "any person interested" are no longer good law in light of the Supreme Court's authoritative construction.

Holding and Implications

Holding: These appeals are allowed. The court set aside the judgment and order under appeal and specifically set aside the order of the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal dated 1st August 1981 (Annexure 'L') and the order of the Commissioner for Religious and Charitable Endowments, Karnataka, Bangalore dated 5th December 1977 (Annexure 'J').

Implications (direct effects on the parties):

  • The court concluded that the second and third respondents are "persons interested in the Wakf" within the meaning of Section 3(h) and Section 6(1), and therefore the special one-year limitation in the proviso to Section 6(1) applied to them in relation to the notification dated 11th July 1965.
  • Because the one-year period expired (by 11th July 1966), the court held that the second and third respondents cannot now file a suit under Section 6(1) to challenge the inclusion of the property in the Wakf list; the statutory position created by the Wakf Act governs notwithstanding earlier administrative findings to the contrary.
  • The specific orders of the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal and the Commissioner for Religious and Charitable Endowments were set aside as a result of allowing the appeals.
  • There shall be no order as to costs (i.e., the court made no costs order against any party).

Broader legal precedent: The court did not purport to create a new principle of law; it applied the Supreme Court's earlier interpretation of Section 6(1) (Board of Muslim Wakfs, Rajasthan v. Radha Kishan) to the facts before it and rejected inconsistent lower-court authority as not being good law in view of the Supreme Court decision.

Show all summary ...

S.P Bharucha, C.J:— These are Appeals filed by Karnataka Board of Wakfs against the Judgment and order of the learned Single Judge dated 15th December 1989 in several connected Writ Petitions, including Writ Petitions Nos. 5141 & 5142 of 1982 filed by the Board.

2. This dispute relates to land ad-measuring 325 feet by 125 feet in R.S Nos. 1 and 2 of Annipura village, Kasaba Hobli, Bangalore North Taluk. The land was Devadaya Inam Land that belonged to the Hazarath Attulla Shah Dargah. It is the case of second and third respondents to these Appeals that a number of alienations of the said land had taken place and it was not longer Inam land. The second respondent had purchased the said land from one Ghouse Bi under a registered Sale Deed dated 4th December 1946 and on 13th September 1947 a half portion of the Said land had been sold by the second respondent to the third respondent for valuable consideration.

3. On 28th July 1947 the Sajjada of the Dargah made a petition under Section 10 of the Mysore Religious and Charitable Institution Act, 1927, to declare that the said land belonged to the Dargah and alienations in favour of the second and third respondents were void. He also sought restoration of the said land to the Dargah. These proceedings continued until the matter was pending in or about the year 1974 before the Special Deputy Commissioner in Muzrai appeal No. 72/67-68; that these proceedings had taken so long was due to the fact that there had been several appeals and several orders of remand. By his order dated 23rd August 1974 the Special Deputy Commissioner, required the said land to be restored to the second and third respondents. Thereagainst the Dargah filed an appeal before the Commissioner for Religious and Charitable Endowments. By this time the Wakf Act, 1954, had come into force in the State of Karnataka (with effect from 15th January 1955) and the Wakf Board had issued a Notification under Section 5 thereof notifying the Wakfs in the State. The Notification showed the said land as belonging to the Dargah. Consequently, the Wakf Board made an application to be impleaded in the appeal aforementioned filed by the Dargah before the Commissioner of Religious and Charitable Endowments. Upon being impleaded it took the contention that the said land belonged to the Wakf Board and the question of its title should have been referred to a Civil Court having regard to the provisions of Section 6 of the Wakf Act. The appeal was dismissed, the Wakf Board being held to have no locus-standi. Appeals thereagainst were filed by the Wakf Board as also by the Dargah before the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal. These were also dismissed.

4. Thereupon Writ Petitons Nos. 5141 and 5142/1982 were filed by the Wakf Board impugning the order of the Tribunal. The second and third respondents also filed Writ Petitions impugning the order of the Tribunal to an extent with which we are not here concerned. The lerned Single Judge rejected the stand of the Wakf Board. He said he could not accept the contention that it had abolished by one stroke the interest of the second and third respondents in the said land.

5. Section 4 of the Wakf Act empowers the State Government to appoint a Commissioner of Wakfs to make a survey of Wakf properties existing in the State on the dates of commencement of the Act and to make a report thereon. Under Section 5(1) the State Government is required, upon receipt of report made by the Commissioner, to forward a copy of the scheme to the Wakf Board constituted under the Wakf Act. Section 5(2) states that “the Board shall examine the report forwarded to it under Section (1) and publish in the Official Gazette a list of Wakfs existing in the State …. containing such particulars as may be prescribed.” The relevant portion of Section 6 reads thus:

“Disputes regarding Wakfs-

(1) If any question arises whether a particular property specified as Wakf property in a list of Wakfs published under sub-section (2) of Section 5 is Wakf property or not or whether a wakf specified in such a list is a Shia Wakf or Sunni Wakf the Board of the mutawalli of the Wakf or any person interested therein may institute a suit in a Civil Court of competent Jurisdiction for the decision of the question and the decision of the Civil Court in respect of such matter shall be final;

Provided that no such suit shall be entertained by the Civil Court after the expiry of one year from the date of the publication of the list of Wakfs under sub-section (2) of Section 5.

(4) The list of Wakfs published under sub-section (2) of Section 5 shall unless it is modified in pursuance of a decision of the Civil Court under sub-section (1), be final and conclusive.”

Section 3(1) defines a ‘Wakf’ to mean “the permanent dedication by a person professing Islam of any movable or immovable property for any purpose recognised by the Muslim law as pious, religious or charitable.” The expression “person interested in a Wakf” is defined by Section 3(h) to mean any person who is entitled to receive any pecuniary or other benefits from the Wakf and includes -

“(i) any person who has a right to worship or to perform any religious rite in a mosque, idgah, imambara, dargah, khangah, maqbara, graveyard or any other religious institution connected with the Wakf or to participate in any religious or charitable institution under the Wakf.”

6. In THE Board of Muslim Wakfs, Rajasthan v. Radha Kishan . AIR 1979 SC 289. the construction of the words ‘any person interested therein’ in Section 6(1) was considered. Certain property which was Wakf property was claimed by two persons who were not Muslims. They contended that the Wakf Board was not entitled to include their property in the list of Wakfs published under Section 5(2). The Rajasthan High Court made the Writ Petition absolute. In its view the Wakf Act did not invest the Wakf Board or the Wakf Commissioner with power to decide the question whether a property belonged to a Wakf or not, more so where the person claiming title was a stranger to the Wakf. Consequently, the failure of a stranger to the Wakf to institute a suit in a Court of Competent jurisdiction to decide whether a particular property was Wakf property or not could not make the inclusion of such property in the list of Wakfs published by the Wakf Board under Section 5(2) final and conclusive under Section 6(4). Having examined the scheme of the Wakf Act, the Supreme Court held that it was a complete code dealing with the better administration and supervision of Wakfs. It then considered the scope of Section 6(1). It found that the claimants to the property were non-Muslims and, consequently, had no right to file the suit contemplated by the sub-section; therefore, the list of Wakfs published by the Wakf Board under Section 5(2) could not be final and conclusive against them under Section 6(4). The question that arose for consideration, therefore, was: who are the parties that could be taken to be concerned in a proceeding under Section 6(1) and whether the list published under Section 5(2) declaring certain property to be Wakf property would bind a person who was neither a mutawalli nor a person interested in the Wakf. The Supreme Court said:

“33. The answer to these questions must turn on the true meaning and construction of the word ‘therein’ in the expression ‘any person interested therein’ appearing in Sub-section (1) of Section 6. In order to understand the meaning of the word ‘therein’ in our view, it is necessary to refer to the preceding words ‘the Board or the Mutawalli of the Wakf’. The word ‘therein’ must necessarily refer to the ‘Wakf’ which immediately precedes it. It cannot refer to the ‘Wakf property’. Sub-section (1) of Section 6 enumerates the persons who can file suits and also the questions in respect of which such suits can be filed. In enumerating the persons who are empowered to file suits under this provision, only the Board, the mutawalli of the Wakf, and ‘any person interested therein’, thereby necessarily meaning any person interested in the Wakf, are listed. It should be borne in mind that the Act deals with Wakfs, its institutions and its properties. It would, therefore, be logical and reasonable to infer that its provisions empower only those who are interested in the Wakf, to institute suits”.

The Supreme Court approved the finding of the Rajasthan High Court that “it could never have been the intention of the legislature to cast a cloud on the right, title or interest of persons who are not Muslims. That is, if a person who is non-Muslim whether he be a Christian, a Hindu, a Sikh, a Parsi or of any other religious denomination and if he is in possession of a certain property his right, title and interest cannot be put in jeopardy simply because that property is included in the list published under sub-section (2) of Section 5”. The Supreme Court said that “it follows that where a stranger who is a non-Muslim and is in possession of a certain property his right, title and interest therein cannot be put in jeopardy merely because the property is included in the list. Such a person is not required to file a suit for declaration of his title within a period of one year. The special rule of limitation laid down in proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 6 is not applicable to him. In other words, the list published by the Board of Wakfs under sub-section (2) of Section 5 can be challenged by him by filing a suit for declaration of title even after expiry of the period of one year, if the necessity of filing such suit arises.”

7. Now the second and third respondents, who lay claim to the said land, are Muslims. The question is: Does the special rule of limitation laid down in the first proviso to Section 6(1) apply to them. It will be noted that Section 6(1) says that if any question arises whether a particular property specified as Wakf property in a list of Wakfs published under sub-section (2) of Section 5 is Wakf property or not, the Board or the mutawalli of the Wakf or “any person interested therein” may institute a suit in a Civil Court of competent jurisdiction for the decision of the question and the decision of the Civil Court in respect of such matter shall be final. The proviso to Section 6(1) states that no such suit shall be entertained by the Civil Court after expiry of one year from the date of the publication of the list of Wakfs under sub-section (2) of Section 5. Clearly, therefore, this special Rule of Limitation is applicable to a suit filed by “any person interested therein”.

8. The Supreme Court held that the word ‘therein’ refers to the Wakf and not to Wakf property (see paragraph 33 quoted above). What we may consider, therefore, is whether the second and third respondents are persons interested in the Wakf. By reason of Section 3(h) a person is interested in a Wakf if he has a right to worship or to perform any religious rite in a mosque, idgah, imambara, dargah, khangah, maqhara, graveyard or in any religious or charitable institution under the Wakf. Every person who professes Islam has a right to worship or to perform any religious rite in a mosque, idgah, imambara, dargah, khangah, maqbara, graveyard or any other religious institution connected with the Wakf or to participate in any religious or charitable institution under the Wakf. It is not the case of the second or third respondent that they are not Muslims or are not so entitled. It must, therefore, be held that, upon a plain reading of the relevant provisions of the Wakf Act, that the second and third respondents are persons interested in the Wakf and to them the special period of limitation prescribed by the first proviso to Section 6(1) is applicable.

9. This view is reinforced by the aforementioned Judgment of the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court has clearly stated that it followed from the concerned provisions of the Wakf Act that “where a stranger, who is a non-Muslim and is in possession of a certain property, his right, title and interest therein cannot be put in jeopardy merely because the property is included in the list issued by the Wakf Board under sub-section (2) of Section 5”.

10. Our attention was drawn by Mr. M.S Gopal, learned Counsel for the second and third respondents to the Judgment of a learned Single Judge of this Court in Anjuman-E-Islamia v. Sakeenabi* . AIR 1986 Karnataka 75.. The learned Judge observed that Section 6 only enabled the Board or Mutawalli of a Wakf or any persons interested in a Wakf to institute a suit. It did not require of a person who disputed the Wakf itself to file a suit. “Any person interested” did not mean that each and every Muslim was included. The words ‘any person interested’ would connote that the person must be interested in maintaining that particular property as Wakf property. If any person disputed the Wakf itself he did not come within the phrase “any person interested therein”. In the case before the learned Judge, the defendants contended that the particular property was not Wakf property. Therefore, the defendants could not, in his view, be considered to be ‘persons interested’ in the Wakf property within the meaning of Section 6.

11. This Judgment is no longer good law in view of the Decision of Supreme Court aforementioned. The word ‘therein’ in the phrase ‘any person interested therein’ has been interpreted by the Supreme Court to mean interested in the Wakf and not interested in the Wakf property”.

12. Our attention was drawn to the Judgment of a Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Cheedella Motaiah v. Wakf Board, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad . AIR 1978 Andhra Pradesh 34.. The alienee of property which was listed by the Wakf Board under Section 5(2) was a non-Muslim. Interpreting Section 6 read with Section 3(h), the Division Bench held that the right to file a suit was confined only to the Wakf Board or the Mutawalli or persons interested in the Wakf. As a consequence, the finality of the list of Wakfs published would only be as against such persons who were entitled to file a suit. Section 6 had, therefore, no application to an absolute stranger to Wakf, being a non-Muslim.

13. Lastly, our attention was drawn to the Judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in Corporation of The City of Bangalore v. Mysore State Board of Wakfs . 1973 1 Mys. L.J 103.. The petitioner, as will be seen, was the Corporation of the City of Bangalore. Its case was that several lands belonging to it had been listed as Wakf property in the list published under Section 5(2). It was held that the Corporation's right in respect of such properties, if it had such right, remained unaffected by the notification of the list of Wakfs. Any dispute between the Wakf Board on the one hand and the Corporation of the City of Bangalore on the other had to be decided by a competent Civil Court.

14. It is difficult to see how the aforementioned two Judgments carry the matter before us, any further.

15. It was submitted by Mr. Gopal that the Tribunal had held that the said land had ceased to be Inam land as far as back in 1973 and that its purchasers at that time had been non-Muslims. The Tribunal had also held that the Dargah had no interest in the said land. Having regard to the provisions of the Wakfs Act, it appears to us clear that the question of title of properties which are included as Wakf properties in the list published by the Wakf Board under Section 5(2) must be decided by as Civil Court, except where the dispute is raised by the Board or Mutawalli of a Wakf or any person interested in the Wakf, in which event the suit can be filed only within the period of one year from the date of publication of the list. In the present case that Notification was published on 11th July 1965. The suit ought, therefore, to have been filed by the second and/or third respondents on or before 11th July 1966. They cannot file such suit now, nor can the fact that other authorities had held that the said land had ceased to be Inam land or that the Dargah has no interest therein make a difference to the statutory position created by the Wakf Act.

16. In this view of the matter, these Appeals are allowed and the Judgment and Order under Appeal is set aside. The order of the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal (Annexure ‘L’) dated 1st August 1981 and the order of the Commissioner for Religious and Charitable Endowments, Karnataka, Bangalore (Annexure ‘J’) dated 5th December 1977 are set aside.

There shall be no order as to costs.