- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kuttappa v. Katrikolli Somaiah
Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff filed O.S. No. 162 of 1975 in the Additional Munsiff's Court, Virajpet, seeking a declaration of title and delivery of possession in respect of Sy. No. 113/1 (2 acres 6 guntas). The plaintiff obtained an order under Order 26 Rule 9 C.P.C. for appointment of a Commissioner. The defendant challenged that interlocutory order before this Court in C.R.P. No. 620 of 1979. The defendant (who was the revision petitioner in that challenge) died on 30-11-1983. The present Revision Petitioners are the persons brought on record as the legal representatives of that deceased defendant.
The present Revision Petitioners were brought on record in the earlier revision petition (because their application in that revision petition was filed within time) and that revision petition was disposed of in February 1984. No application by the plaintiff to bring the legal representatives on record was filed before the learned Munsiff within the period prescribed by law. On 20-4-1985 the plaintiff filed an application under Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C. to amend the cause title of the plaint to mention the legal representatives who had been brought on record in the earlier revision petition. The plaintiff also filed three other applications: (1) to condone delay, (2) for setting aside abatement, and (3) to bring on record the legal representatives of the deceased defendant.
The learned Munsiff allowed the application under Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C. and, viewing the fact that the legal representatives had been brought on record in the earlier revision petition as benefitting the plaintiff, gave directions concerning the other applications. Aggrieved by that order, the legal representatives (the present Revision Petitioners) preferred the present Revision Petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the fact that the legal representatives of the deceased defendant were brought on record in a revision petition (an ancillary/proceeding directed against an interlocutory order) enures to the benefit of the plaintiff in the original suit and, consequently, whether the suit abated for failure to file a legal-representatives' application in the trial Court within the prescribed time.
- Whether an application under Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C. to amend the cause title of the plaint to insert the names of legal representatives (who had been brought on record in an earlier revision petition) was maintainable and/or properly entertained by the learned Munsiff.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants / Revision Petitioners' Arguments
- They contended that the observations of the Supreme Court (relied upon by the respondent) in the cited decision are merely obiter and therefore not binding on this Court.
- They contended that even if the legal representatives had been brought on record in the revision petition, an application under Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C. to amend the cause title could not be entertained; consequently, the learned Munsiff was not correct in granting the amendment prayed for.
Respondent / Plaintiff's Arguments
- The respondent relied on a Supreme Court decision reported at AIR 1965 SC 1794 (Rangubai v. Sunderabai) and the Privy Council decision reported at 1917 P.C. 156 (Brij Indar v. Lala) to submit that when legal representatives are brought on record at one stage of the suit (including in an ancillary proceeding such as a revision against an interlocutory order), that introduction enures to the benefit of the parties for all subsequent stages of the suit, preventing abatement.
- The respondent submitted that because the legal representatives had been brought on record in the earlier revision petition within time, that circumstance benefitted the plaintiff in the original suit and justified amendment of the cause title under Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1965 Supreme Court 1794 (Rangubai v. Sunderabai) | The Supreme Court held that an order bringing legal representatives on record at one stage of a suit enures for the benefit of the subsequent stages of the suit; illustrations include bringing representatives on record in interlocutory proceedings or appeals. | The Court relied on this decision as directly applicable: the present facts correspond to the third illustration given by the Supreme Court, so the order bringing legal representatives on record in the earlier revision petition enures to the benefit of the plaintiff in the original suit. |
| 1917 P.C. 156 (Privy Council) (Brij Indar v. Lala) | Principle quoted: "But the introduction of a plaintiff or a defendant for one stage of a suit is an introduction for all stages..." — introduction at one stage is an introduction for all stages and non-presence of representatives would not afford ground for abatement. | The Court quoted this passage as foundational support for the Supreme Court's formulation and as confirming that bringing representatives at one stage prevents abatement. |
| (1969) 1 SCC 91 : AIR 1970 Supreme Court 1597 | Referred to in the opinion for the proposition that declarations of law by the Supreme Court, even if in obiter, may bind other courts if unambiguous. | The Court used the principle illustrated by reference to this decision to reject the contention that the Supreme Court's observations were mere non-binding obiter, holding that unambiguous obiter binds lower courts. |
| 1978 (2) Kar. L.J. 294 (I.T.I. v. State of Karnataka) (Division Bench) | Authority for the proposition that not only the ratio decidendi but also unambiguous obiter dicta of the Supreme Court bind all courts in India. | The Court relied on this Division Bench decision to support the conclusion that the Supreme Court's observations are binding on this Court even if characterized as obiter. |
| 1984 (1) Kar. L.J. 145 (Parvathi Textiles v. Director) (Division Bench) | Same proposition as above: unambiguous declarations of law by the Supreme Court, including obiter, bind lower courts. | The Court cited this decision alongside the 1978 Division Bench decision to reinforce that the Supreme Court's statements in the cited case are binding. |
| AIR 1973 P & H 351 (Harbans Lal v. Ved Parkash) | Applied the principle that legal representatives brought on record in an appeal against an interlocutory order (grant of interim injunction) enure for the benefit of all subsequent stages of the suit and prevent abatement. | The Court treated this decision as following the Supreme Court principle and as fortifying the Court's conclusion that bringing representatives on record in the earlier revision petition prevented abatement and benefitted the plaintiff. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court framed the dispositive question as whether bringing the legal representatives of the deceased defendant on record in the earlier revision petition (an ancillary proceeding directed against an interlocutory order) enured to the benefit of the plaintiff in the original suit so that the suit did not abate despite the absence of a separate application before the learned Munsiff within the statutory period.
The Court analysed the matter principally by reference to a Supreme Court decision (AIR 1965 SC 1794) which, relying on the Privy Council (1917 P.C. 156), stated the rule that introduction of legal representatives at one stage of a suit is an introduction for all stages. The Supreme Court decision also provided three illustrations demonstrating that where legal representatives are brought on record in an appellate or interlocutory context within time, that fact enures for subsequent stages of the suit.
The Court observed that the present case corresponds to the third illustration given by the Supreme Court — an appeal or revision against an interlocutory order where legal representatives were brought on record — and therefore falls squarely within the principle that such introduction enures for the benefit of all subsequent stages.
The Revision Petitioners argued that the Supreme Court's observations were obiter and not binding. The Court rejected that contention on two bases stated in the opinion:
- The Supreme Court's discussion was elaborate and not merely passing observation; thus it should not be treated as non-binding casual comment.
- Even if characterized as obiter dicta, the Court relied on authoritative Division Bench decisions of this High Court (1978 (2) Kar. L.J. 294 and 1984 (1) Kar. L.J. 145) and a cited Supreme Court decision ((1969) 1 SCC 91 : AIR 1970 SC 1597) to hold that unambiguous declarations of law by the Supreme Court, including obiter dicta, are binding on all courts in India.
The Court also noted that this principle had been followed in Harbans Lal v. Ved Parkash (AIR 1973 P & H 351), where legal representatives brought on record in an appeal against an interim injunction were held to enure to the benefit of subsequent stages and to prevent abatement.
Addressing the separate contention that an application under Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C. to amend the cause title could not be entertained, the Court reasoned that even if such an application were formally not maintainable under the circumstances, the legal fiction that the legal representatives had been brought on record in the earlier revision petition would itself suffice. The fact could be brought to the trial Court's notice and, by reason of that legal fiction, the Court should permit amendment of the cause title. Thus, the formal maintainability of the Order 6 Rule 17 application did not prejudice the rights of the plaintiff or justify setting aside the Munsiff's order.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court dismissed the Revision Petition and held that the learned Munsiff was right in permitting the plaintiff to amend the cause title to mention the legal representatives of the deceased defendant who had already been brought on record in the earlier revision petition.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The plaintiff's amendment of the cause title was upheld; the Revision Petitioners' challenge failed and the revision petition was dismissed.
- On the question of abatement: The Court held that because the legal representatives were brought on record in the earlier revision petition (an ancillary proceeding against an interlocutory order) within time, that circumstance enured to the benefit of the plaintiff in the original suit and there was no abatement of the suit.
- On precedent and doctrine: The Court confirmed and applied the principle (derived from the Privy Council and applied by the Supreme Court) that introduction of legal representatives at one stage of a suit operates for all stages; and it reiterated that an unambiguous declaration of law by the Supreme Court (even if in obiter) is binding on lower courts, citing Division Bench authorities of this High Court.
- No broader new precedent was announced by this opinion; the Court applied established principles to the facts and affirmed the trial Court's order.
Counsel Appearances (as stated in the opinion): Mr. C. Gowri Shankar & Mrs. Girija Shankar for Petitioners; Mr. M. Rama Bhat for Respondent.
Bench: Krishnan, J.
CASES REFERRED: 1. AIR 1965 SC 1794 - Rangubai v. Sunderabai (Foll) 2. 1917 PC 156 - Brij Indar v. Lala (Ref) 3. 1978 (2) KLJ 294 - I.T.I v. State of Karnataka (do) 4. 1984 (1) KLJ 145 - Parvathi Textiles v. Director (Foll) 5. AIR 1973 P & H 351 - Harbans Lai v. Ved Parkash (do)
Mr. C. Gowri Shankar & Mrs. Girija Shankar for Petitioners
Mr. M. Rama Bhat for Respondent
Krishnan, J.:—
The Revision Petitioners are the persons who are brought on record as legal representatives of deceased defendant in O.S No. 162 of 1975 on the file of the Additional Munsiff, Virajpet. Being aggrieved by the order of the learned Munsiff granting the prayer of the plaintiff to bring them on record as legal representatives, they have preferred this Revision Petition.
2. To understand the circumstances under which the present Revision Petition has been filed, only a few facts need be stated:— The plaintiff filed O.S No. 162 of 1975 against one Kambiranda A. Muthanna for declaration of his title to Sy. No. 113/1 and delivery of possession of 2 acres 6 guntas of land in the said survey number. The plaintiff filed an application under Order 26 Rule 9 C.P.C for appointment of Commissioner and that having been allowed, the defendant challenged the same before this Court in C.R.P No. 620 of 1979. The defendant (revision petitioner in the said case) died on 30-11-1983 and the present Revision Petitioners filed an application in that Revision Petition to bring them on record as legal representatives of the deceased Revision Petitioner and that application having been filed within time, they were brought on record and later on that Revision Petition came to be disposed of in February, 1984. No legal representative's application was filed before the learned Munsiff in whose Court the suit was pending within the period prescribed by law and an application was filed by the plaintiff under Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C on 20-4-1985 to permit them to amend the cause title by bringing on record the legal representatives of the deceased defendant who had come on record before this Court in the Revision Petition referred to already. The plaintiff also filed 3 other applications, one to condone the delay in filing the application, another for setting aside the abatement and yet another application to bring on record the legal representatives of the deceased defendant. All these applications were considered by the learned Munsiff and he held that because the legal representatives of the deceased defendant had been brought on record in the revision petition before this Court, that enured to the benefit of the plaintiff and allowed the application filed under Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C and in that view of the matter, he ordered, that the other applications should be filed. It is being aggrieved by this order that the legal representatives of the deceased defendant have preferred this Revision Petition.
3. That the present revision petitioners are in fact the legal representatives of the deceased defendant and they were in fact brought on record at their own instance, in the previous Revision Petition referred to already is admitted; that no separate application was filed within the prescribed time by the plaintiff before the learned Munsiff under Order 22 Rule 4 C.P.C to bring on record the legal representatives of deceased defendant is also admitted on behalf of the plaintiff. Therefore, the only aspect that has to be examined is whether the fact that the legal representatives of the deceased defendant were brought on record in the Revision Petition referred to already enures to the benefit of the plaintiff in the original suit and whether therefore the suit did not abate?
4. Learned Advocate for the respondent-plaintiff invited my attention to a Decision of the Supreme Court reported in A.I.R 1965 Supreme Court 17941 and pointed out that under similar circumstances, the Supreme Court has held that the order bringing on record the legal representatives at one stage of the suit would enure to the benefit of the parties in the original suit despite the fact that the said proceeding was directed against an interlocutory order passed by the original Court. Therein Their Lordships have referred to the Decision of the Privy Council reported in 1917 Privy Council 1562. It has been observed by the Privy Council at page 161 as hereunder:—
“But the introduction of a plaintiff or a defendant for one stage of a suit is an introduction for all stages, and the prayer, which seems to have been made ob mojorem cautelam, by the plaintiff, in his application to the District Judge Prenter, under Section 365, was superfluous and of no effect. Coates, the judgment-debtor, was only formally called, and the non-presence of his representatives would afford no ground for the abatement of the suit.”
5. The Supreme Court after referring to this principle recognised by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, has also given several Illustrations where the application of this principle is called in different situations. The Supreme Court has observed as hereunder:—
“But there is another principle recognised by the Judicial Committee in the aforesaid decision which softens the rigour of this rule. The said principle is that if the legal representatives are brought on record within the prescribed time at one stage of the suit, it will enure for the benefit of all the subsequent stages of the suit. The application of this principle to different situations will help to answer the problem presented in the present case. (1) A filed a suit against B for the recovery of possession and mesne profits. After the issues were framed, B died. At the stage of an interlocutory application for production of documents, the legal representatives of B were brought on record within the time prescribed. The order bringing them on record would enure for the benefit of the entire suit. (2) The suit was decreed and an appeal was filed in the High Court and was pending therein. The defendant died and his legal represematies were brought on record. The suit was subsequently remanded to the trial Court. The order bringing the legal representatives on record in the appeal would enure for the further stages of the suit. (3) An appeal was filed against an interlocutory order made in a suit. Pending the appeal the defendant died and his legal representatives were brought on record. The appeal was dismissed. The appeal being a continuation or a stage of the suit, the order bringing the legal representatives on record would enure for the subsequent stages of the suit. This would be so whether in the appeal the trial Court's order was confirmed, modified or reversed. In the above 3 illustrations one fact is common, namely, the order bringing on record the legal representatives was made at one stage of the suit, be it in the suit or in an appeal against the interlocutory order or final order made in the suit, for an appeal is only a continuation of the suit. Whether the appellate order confirms that of the first Court, modifies or reverses it, it replaces or substitutes the order appealed against. It takes it place in the suit and becomes a part of it. It is as it were the suit was brought to the appellate Court at one stage and the orders made therein were made in the suit itself. Therefore, that order enures for the subsequent stages of the suit.”
(Emphasis supplied)
The present case comes squarely within the meaning of the third illustration in the portion extracted above. The learned Advocate for the revision petitioners contended in the first instance that the portion extracted above and more especially in relation to the third illustration are just mere observations which have no binding effect and even otherwise they are in the nature of obiter and therefore they are not binding on this Court. Having regard to the elaborate way in which different situations which arise for application of this principle have been discussed, it cannot be said that these are only passing observations made by the Supreme Court.
6. Even assuming for a moment that these observations are in the nature of obiter, it is fairly well settled that the same are also binding on all the Courts in the Country and if any authority is required for the said proposition, I may usefully refer to the Division Bench of this Court reported in 1978 (2) Kar. L.J 2943 and also another Division Bench Decision reported in 1984 (1) Kar. L.J 1454. At page 153 in para 24, it has been observed by this Court as hereunder:
“Thus it is clear that it is not only the ratio decedendi of a case decided by the Supreme Court that is binding but any declaration of law even by way of obiter dicta, if it is declared unambiguous, binds all the Courts in India. That being so we are of the considered view that the law declared by the Supreme Court in the aforesaid Decision, reported in ((1969) 1 SCC 91 : AIR 1970 Supreme Court 1597) binds this Court and that the provision in Section 12(2) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947, includes even an export on sale by a seller.”
The statement of law made by the Supreme Court and extracted already, is clear and unambiguous cannot be disputed and when that is so and even assuming that they are in the nature of obiter dicta, they would be binding on this Court and there is no scope to take any different view of this matter. Therefore, it is clear that the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the observations extracted already, is absolutely clear that if the legal representatives of a party are brought on record even in an ancillary proceeding arising out of an order passed on an interlocutory application, that would enure to the benefit of the party and in that view of the matter, there is no question of abatement of the suit only because an application for bringing the legal representatives on record was not filed in that suit within the prescribed time.
7. This principle enunciated by the Supreme Court has been followed in Harbans Lal… v. Ved Parkash…. . AIR 1973 P & H 351.. In that case the legal representatives of the deceased defendant had been brought on record in an appeal preferred against grant of interim injunction and it was held that the fact that the legal representatives of the deceased defendant had been brought on record in such an appeal enured for the benefit of all the subsequent stages of the suit and it did not abate. This Decision also fortifies the view I have taken in this regard.
8. The learned Advocate for the Revision petitioner next contended that even assuming that the legal representatives of the deceased defendant having been brought on record in the High Court in the revision petition filed against an interlocutory order enures to the benefit of the plaintiff in the suit, the application filed under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC for amendment of the plaint cannot be entertained and therefore the learned Munsiff was not right in granting the amendment prayed for. Again assuming for a moment that no application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC could be filed for amendment of the cause title of the plaint, if by legal fiction, the fact that the legal representatives of the deceased defendant were brought on record in the High Court, would enure to the benefit of the party even in the suit which is pending before the trial Court, it appears to me that no other kind of application even, need be filed by the party and it is sufficient if this fact is just brought to the notice of the Court and on account of the above said legal fiction, the Court should permit the party to amend the cause title and in that view of the matter, even accepting the contention of the learned Advocate for Revision petitioner that an application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC cannot be maintained under such circumstances, it would not in any way enure to the benefit of the revision petitioner, in the view I have taken.
9. In that view of the matter, it is clear that the learned Munsiff was right in permitting the plaintiff to amend the cause title of the plaint by mentioning the names of the legal representatives of the deceased defendant who had already been brought on record in the Revision Petition adverted to already. Therefore, it is clear that there is no merit in this revision petition and accordingly, it is dismissed.
Alert