Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

B.M Marappa v. B.V Nagaraj

Karnataka High Court
Mar 18, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The judgment was delivered by K.S. Puttaswamy, J. The matters before the Court are appeals and cross-appeals arising from a common order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Bangalore Bench, dated 30 June 1975, which had reversed an order (C.R 62/1601/73-74 Acq. (B)) dated 12 February 1975 of the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Acquisition Range, Bangalore, made under Chapter XX-A of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

Material factual background: An immovable property (No. 1011/44, 1st Main Road, IV Block, Rajajinagar, Bangalore-10) was owned by Smt. Girijamma (transferor). On 3 August 1973 she transferred the property by a registered instrument to four transferees (B.M. Byrappa, B.C. Hanumanthappa, B.M. Marappa and B.V. Nagaraj) for a stated consideration of Rs. 80,000. On 1 February 1974 the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner recorded reasons under section 269C of the Income-tax Act concluding that the fair market value (FMV) exceeded the apparent consideration by more than 15% and directed issue of notices under section 269D of the Act.

Notices under section 269D(1) were published in the Official Gazette on 18 May 1974; notices to the transferees and transferor were served on 25 March 1974 and 20 August 1974 respectively. The transferees and transferor filed objections claiming the apparent consideration was the true consideration and represented FMV as on 3 August 1973. After hearings and with prior approval of the Commissioner, the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner found FMV exceeded the apparent consideration by more than 25% and on 12 February 1975 made an order under section 269F(6) for acquisition under Chapter XX-A.

The transferees appealed to the Tribunal under section 269G (Appeals Nos. 31–34 of 1975). Before hearing, they obtained leave to add an additional ground asserting that service of notices on them before publication in the Gazette invalidated the proceedings; the Tribunal allowed the additional ground, accepted it and allowed the appeals, while nevertheless recording against the appellants on FMV. The transferees and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner filed cross-appeals to this Court under section 269H.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the issue of notice under section 269D(2) of the Act, before the publication of the notice under section 269D(1) of the Act in the Official Gazette, vitiates the jurisdiction of the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner and the order made by him under Chapter XX-A of the Act?
  2. Whether the authorities functioning under the Act are required to regulate the acquisition of the property under Chapter XX-A of the Act in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Board circular instructions dated 27 November 1975?
  3. Whether the determination of the fair market value of the property by the Tribunal and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner are legal and valid?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Transferees)

  • The appellants (transferees) sought to add a ground before the Tribunal that the service of notices on them prior to publication in the Official Gazette amounted to an invalid assumption of jurisdiction, rendering the acquisition proceedings void.
  • Counsel for the appellants (Sri G. Sarangan) also relied on a Board Circular (F.N 283/1/75-IT(INV) dated 27 November 1975) and stated that the appellants had made applications under the Voluntary Disclosure of Income and Wealth Act, 1976 (the 1976 Act) before the Commissioner, which were pending consideration; this was advanced to argue that acquisition proceedings should be regulated in light of that Circular and the later enactment.

Respondent's Arguments (Inspecting Assistant Commissioner / Income-tax Department)

  • Sri K. Srinivasan, appearing for the Income-tax Department, contended that the Tribunal erred in allowing the belated additional ground before it and that acceptance of that ground was plainly illegal.
  • The respondent argued that the acquisition should be affirmed without regard to the Board circular issued during the pendency of these appeals before this Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
I.T.A. Nos. 5 to 8 and 25 to 29 of 1976 (A. Premchand v. IAC), [1985] 153 ITR 774 (Kar) The Tribunal committed an error of law in allowing a belated additional ground at the hearing; the conclusion reached by the Tribunal on that ground was erroneous in law; principles for valuation of properties relevant to Chapter XX-A acquisitions. The Court relied on Premchand to hold that the Tribunal committed an error of law in invalidating the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner's order on the additional ground. The Court further directed that, if FMV had to be determined, it should be done in the light of the principles enunciated in Premchand and vacated the Tribunal's and Inspecting Assistant Commissioner's findings on valuation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court structured its analysis on the three issues raised and addressed them in order.

Point 1 (Validity of notices served prior to Gazette publication):

The Court noted the respondent's contention that the Tribunal erred in allowing the belated additional ground and that acceptance of that ground was illegal. The appellants supported the Tribunal's decision. The Court recalled its earlier decision in Premchand's case in which it had held that the Tribunal erred in allowing such an additional ground and that the Tribunal's conclusion on that ground was erroneous. As Sri Sarangan (appellants' counsel) did not urge any reason to depart from Premchand, the Court held that, for the reasons stated in Premchand, the Tribunal committed an error of law in invalidating the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner's order on that additional ground.

Point 2 (Effect of Board circular dated 27 November 1975 and the 1976 Act):

The Court examined whether authorities under the Income-tax Act are required to regulate pending acquisitions in accordance with the Board circular (F.N 283/1/75-IT(INV), 27 Nov 1975), which was issued in the context of the later-enacted Voluntary Disclosure of Income and Wealth Act, 1976. The Court observed that the Board was competent to issue such circulars under the Central Boards of Revenue Act, 1963 and section 119 of the Income-tax Act and that such circulars are binding on authorities functioning under the Act.

The text of the Board circular was set out in the opinion: it clarified that acquisition proceedings would be dropped where parties comply with specified conditions (for example, declarations under the Ordinance disclosing the appropriate difference between apparent consideration plus 15% and FMV and filing an affidavit undertaking cooperation, or both transferor and transferee making declarations admitting consideration approximating FMV).

Because this Court is exercising appellate authority under the Act, it must take note of subsequent events and circular instructions and regulate the appeals accordingly. The appellants had stated that they had made applications to the Commissioner under the 1976 Act which were still pending. Given those pending applications, the Court reasoned that any order under Chapter XX-A must await the Commissioner’s order on those applications. Therefore, it was appropriate to set aside the Tribunal's and Inspecting Assistant Commissioner's orders and remit the cases for reconsideration in light of the Commissioner’s forthcoming decision and the Board circular.

Point 3 (Validity of the determinations of fair market value):

The Court held that a determination on the validity of the FMV findings would arise only on the order to be made by the Commissioner and the applicability of the 1976 Act to the case; hence that question had to be left open. The Court further stated that, if valuation becomes necessary under Chapter XX-A, it must be done in the light of the valuation principles enunciated in Premchand's case and therefore the findings of the Tribunal and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner on valuation should be vacated.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court made the following dispositive orders:

  • ALLOW the appeals and SET ASIDE the orders of the Tribunal and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner.
  • Remit the cases to the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner with directions to restore the proceedings to the original file and re-determine the acquisition proceedings with due regard to:
    (a) the orders to be made by the Commissioner on the applications made by the appellants under the 1976 Act; (b) the law regulating the same; and (c) the observations made in the Court's order. The Inspecting Assistant Commissioner was directed to record or collect such further evidence as may be placed before him.
  • The Inspecting Assistant Commissioner was expressly directed not to permit the appellants to urge any contention on the validity of Chapter XX-A of the Act or on the validity of the proceedings initiated by him on the ground urged before the Tribunal or the Court and found against them in this order.
  • The Income-tax appeals were disposed of in the above terms, and the Court directed that the parties bear their own costs.

Implications: The immediate, direct effect of the Court's decision is to annul the Tribunal's and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner's orders and to remit the matters for fresh consideration consistent with the Board circular and any order the Commissioner may make on the pending declarations under the Voluntary Disclosure regime. The Court left open the substantive question of the correct determination of fair market value until after the Commissioner’s determination; valuation (if required) is to follow the principles in Premchand. The opinion does not itself purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond applying and following the earlier decision referenced (Premchand) and the binding effect of the Board circular on authorities under the Act.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

K.S Puttaswamy, J.:— These appeals and cross appeals are directed against a common order made by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Bangalore Bench (Tribunal), on June 30, 1975, in Appeals Nos. I.T.A (Acq.) Nos. 31, 32, 33 and 34.Bang/1975–76, reversing the order No. C.R 62/1601/73-74 Acq. (B), dated February 12, 1975, of the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Acquisition Range, Bangalore, made under Chapter XX-A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (Central Act No. 43 of 1961) (“the Act).

2. An immovable property bearing No. 1011/44, situated on 1st Main Road, IV Block, Rajajinagar, Bangalore-10, was owned by Smt. Girijamma (transferor). On August 3, 1973, the said transferor, under a registered instrument of transfer, transferred the said property to Sriyuths: B.M Byrappa, B.C Hanumanthappa, B.M Marappa and B.V Nagaraj of Bangalore (transferees) for a consideration of Rs. 80,000. On February 1, 1974, the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner recorded; his reasons under section 269C of the Act to the effect that the fair market value of the property exceeded the apparent consideration by more than 15% and directed the issue of notices on the same day under section 269D of the Act. While the notices issued under section 269D(1) of the Act was published in the Official Gazette on May 18, 1974, the notices issued to the transferees and the transferor were served on March 25, 1974, and August 20, 1974, respective. The other notices under section 269D of the Act were duly effected in due course.

3. In response to the notices served on them, the transferees and the transferor filed their objections before the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner, inter alia, contending that the apparent consideration stipulated in the instrument of transfer was the real consideration paid and received and the same was the fair market value of the property as on August 3, 1973. On an examination of the objections filed, the evidence placed before him and affording an opportunity of hearing, the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner, with the previous approval of the Commissioner, found that the fair market value of the property exceeded the apparent consideration by more than 25% and made an order on February 12, 1975, under section 269F(6) of the Act for the acquisition of the property under Chapter XX-A of the Act.

4. Against the order of the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner, the tran-ferees filed appeals in Appeals Nos. 31, 32, 33 and 34 of 1975, under section 269G of the Act before the Tribunal. Before the hearing of their appeals, the appellants sought leave of the Tribunal to urge an additional ground to the effect that the proceedings initiated by effecting service of notices on them even before the publication of the notice in the Official Gazette was an invalid assumption of jurisdiction by the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner and the completion of proceedings for acquisition were void at law and invalid. On allowing the said additional ground to be urged, the Tribunal by its order dated June 30, 1975, has accepted the same and has allowed the said appeals, however, holding against them on the fair market value of the property acquired by the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner.

5. Aggrieved by the finding recorded by the Tribunal on the fair market value of the property, the transferees have filed ITA Nos. 1 to 4 of 1976 before this court under section 269H of the Act. Aggrieved by the same order of the Tribunal invalidating his order, the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner has filed ITA Nos. 2 to 5 of 1978 under section 269H of the Act. In the appeals filed by the transferees, the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner is the common respondent. In the appeals filed by the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner, the transferees are the respondents. In the course of our order hereafter, we will refer to the transferees as the appellants and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner as the respondent.

6. At the hearing of the appeals, Sri G. Sarangan, learned counsel for the appellants annexing a copy of the Circular Instructions No. F.N 283/1/75-IT(INV) dated November 27, 1975, issued by the Central Board of Direct Taxes regulating the acquisition of properties under Chapter XX-A of the Act on the basis of the provisions made under the Voluntary Disclosure of Income and Wealth Act, 1976 (Central Act No. 8 of 1976) (“the 1976 Act”), has stated that they had made applications under the said Act before the Commissioner of Income-tax, Karnataka, Bangalore (“the Commissioner”), who has not so far made his orders on them and they are still pending consideration before him.

7. Sri K. Srinivasan, senior standing counsel for the Income-tax Department, has appeared for the respondent.

8. On the contentions urged before us, three points arise for our determination and they are—

(i) Whether the issue of notice under section 269D(2) of the Act, j before the publication of the notice under section 269D(1) of the Act in the Official Gazette vitiates the jurisdiction of the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner and the order made by him thereto under Chapter XX-A of the Act?

(ii) Whether the authorities functioning under the Act are required to regulate the acquisition of the property under Chapter XX-A of the Act in accordance with the terms and conditions of the circular instructions dated November 27, 1975, issued by the Board?

(iii) Whether the determination of the fair market value of the property by the Tribunal and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner are legal and valid?

9. We will deal with them in their order.

10. Re: Point No. 1.—Sri Srinivasan contends that the Tribunal committed an error of law in allowing the belated additional ground urged by the appellants before it and the acceptance of the same was plainly illegal.

11. Sri Sarangan has sought to support the decision of the Tribunal on the very grounds found by it and other grounds also.

12. On very similar facts, we had occasion to examine the very point in I.T.A Nos. 5 to 8 and 25 to 29 of 1976 decided on February 27, 1985 (A. Premchand v. I AC, [1985] 153 ITR 774 (Kar)).

13. In Premchand's case, we have held that the Tribunal committed an error of law in allowing the additional ground urged at the hearing and that even otherwise the conclusion reached by it on that ground was erroneous in law. Sri Sarangan did not urge any new ground for not following the same in the present cases. For the very reasons stated in Premchand's case, [1985] 153 ITR 774 (Kar), we hold that the Tribunal committed an error of law in invalidating the order of the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner on the additional ground urged before it by the appellants.

14. Re: Point No. 2.—Sri Sarangan contends that the authorities under the Act are bound to regulate the pending acquisitions with due regard to the Board circulars.

15. Sri Srinivasan contends for affirming the acquisition without reference to the circular of the Board issued during the pendency of these appeals before this court.

16. When the Tribunal and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner decided the cases, the 1976 Act had not been enacted and the Board issuing circular instructions thereunder did not arise. But the Board, with due regard to the later enactment, has issued circular instructions on November 17, 1975, which it was competent to do under the Central Boards of Revenue Act, 1963 (Act No. 63 of 1963), under which it has been constituted as also section 119 of the Act which are binding on all the authorities functioning under the Act.

17. The circular issued by the Board on November 27, 1975, reads thus:

“F.N 283/1/75-IT (INV)

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

CENTRAL BOARD OF DIRECT TAXES

New Delhi, the 27th November, 1975.

A copy of the Press Note explaining the circumstances under which the acquisition proceedings initiated under Chapter XX-A of the Income-tax Act would be dropped in cases where declarations in relation thereto are made under the Ordinance is forwarded for information and guidance.

(Sd.) (D.N.S Sinha)

Under Secretary,

Central Board of Direct Taxes.

1. All Commissioners of Income-tax.

2. All Additional Commissioners of Income-tax.

3. Director of Inspection (Income-tax and Audit)/(R.S & F)/(Investigation)/(Special Cell)/Director of O & M./Director of Training, Nagpur.

4. All Officers of the Central Board of Direct Taxes.

Press Note

Chapter XX-A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, provides for acquisition of immovable properties in certain cases of transfer. The question whether the acquisition proceedings initiated under this Chapter could be dropped in cases where declarations in relation thereto are made under the Voluntary Disclusure of Income and Wealth Ordinance, 1975, has been examined.

18. It is clarified that the acquisition proceedings would be dropped in cases where—

either

only the transferee makes a declaration under the Ordinance disclosing income equal to the difference between:—

(i) the apparent consideration plus 15% thereof, and

(ii) the fair market value estimated by the competent authority and also files an affidavit to the effect that—

(a) he had paid the extra money as admitted by way of purchase consideration to the transferor;

(b) he undertakes and to co-operate fully in the matter of assessment of the transferor; and

(c) he agrees that the affidavit may be utilised in the assessment of the transferor.

the transferor and the transferee admit payment of consideration approximating to the fair market value of the property estimated by the competent authority and each of them makes a declaration under the Ordinance disclosing an amount equal to the difference between:—

(i) the apparent consideration plus 15% thereof; and

(ii) the fair market value estimated by the competent authority.”

19. This general circular issued by the Board is undoubtedly binding on all the authorities under the Act. We are exercising our powers in these cases as an appellate authority under the Act and, therefore, we are bound to take note of the subsequent events and the circular instructions issued by the Board and regulate these appeals on that basis. What is true of this [court is also true of the other authorities under the Act.

20. We find that the Board Circular directs the dropping of acquisition proceedings on the parties complying with the terms and conditions stipulated therein and not otherwise. Before us, the appellants state that they have made applications before the Commissioner under the 1976 Act and they are still pending before him. When that is so, any order to be made Under Chapter XX-A of the Act must necessarily await the order to be made by the Commissioner on such application. In these circumstances, we consider it more appropriate to set aside the orders of the Tribunal and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner and remit the case to the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner to regulate the same on the basis of the order to be made by the Commissioner. Re: Point No. 3.—We need hardly say that a determination on this question would arise on the order to be made by the Commissioner and the applicability or otherwise of the 1976 Act to the case. We have, therefore, necessarily to leave open this question. Even otherwise, we are of the view that the determination of the fair market value of the property, if that becomes necessary under Chapter XX-A of the Act, has necessarily to be done in the light of the principles enunciated in Premchand's case, [1985] 153 ITR 774 (Kar), on the valuation of properties for which purpose it becomes necessary to vacate the findings of the Tribunal and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner on this aspect.

21. In the result, we make the following orders and directions—

(i) We allow these appeals, set aside the orders of the Tribunal and the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner.

(ii) We remit the cases to the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner with a direction to him to restore the proceedings to its original file and redetermine the proceedings initiated by him with due regard to the orders to be made by the Commissioner on the applications made by the appellants under the 1976 Act, the law regulating the same and the observations made in this order after recording all such further evidence as may be placed before him and to be collected by him. But we, however, direct the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner not to permit the appellants to urge any contention on the validity of Chapter XX-A of the Act or on the validity of the proceedings initiated by him on the ground urged before the Tribunal or before us and found against them in this order.

22. Income-tax Appeals are disposed of in the above terms. But, in the circumstances of the cases, we direct the parties to bear their own costs.