- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S. Narayana Setty v. The State Of Karnataka
Summary of the Legal Opinion — Tax Revision under the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957
Factual and Procedural Background
The petition is a tax revision under section 23(1) of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957 directed against an order of the Tribunal in S.T.A. No. 555/79 dated December 20, 1979.
The petitioner is a registered dealer who, for the assessment year 1972–73, declared purchases of groundnut seeds valued at Rs. 10,76,816.94 and claimed exemption for that entire turnover on the basis that his five sellers were the first purchasers in the State. The petitioner produced declarations in form 32 from those sellers.
On enquiry, the assessing authority found (through verification with the sellers) that groundnuts worth Rs. 4,45,152.00 were purchased by the petitioner from stocks the sellers had acquired in inter-State transactions. The assessing authority therefore held the petitioner to be the first purchaser to that extent and levied tax under section 5(4) of the Act on that portion of turnover, giving exemption on the balance.
The petitioner appealed to the Deputy Commissioner (Appeals) and then to the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal; both appeals were dismissed. The present revision challenges the Tribunal's decision and the assessment so far as it levied tax on the disputed purchase turnover.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether production of declarations in form 32 by the seller is conclusive evidence that the purchaser is not the first purchaser for the purposes of exemption under section 5(4) of the Act.
- Whether the burden lies on the purchaser (assessee) to prove that he is not the first purchaser and, if so, what evidence is sufficient beyond form 32.
- Whether the assessing authority and appellate bodies acted properly in relying on cross-verification information from selling dealers and in refusing to consider or properly scrutinise additional documents (such as purchase bills) produced by the assessee.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner contended that form 32 is conclusive for treating him as a purchaser who is not the first purchaser in the State and that he had no means to verify whether the goods purchased from sellers had already suffered tax.
- The petitioner maintained that he had faithfully acted on the declaration forms issued by suppliers in form 32 and therefore could not be made liable to pay tax on that turnover. (As reflected in the petitioner's response quoted in the record.)
- The petitioner asserted that if sellers misused form 32 to evade tax, the proper course was for the taxation authority to take action against those sellers rather than recover tax from the purchaser who relied on form 32.
Assessing Authority / Revenue's Position
- On cross-verification the assessing authority recorded that groundnut seeds worth Rs. 4,45,152.00 sold to the petitioner were sold out of the sellers' inter-State purchases; accordingly, the petitioner was treated as the first purchaser liable to pay tax on that portion under section 5(4).
- The assessing authority issued a notice informing the petitioner of this finding, disallowed exemption for that portion, and levied tax of Rs. 11,762.92 (allowing exemption for the remaining turnover).
- Appellate authorities proceeded on the basis that the assessee had no evidence except form 32 and dismissed the appeals; they therefore upheld the assessing authority's position.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Govindan & Co. v. State of Tamil Nadu [1975] 35 STC 50 | To claim benefit as a second sale, the purchaser need not show that his sellers actually paid tax; it suffices to show that the earlier sales were taxable and that tax was payable by the sellers. | The court relied on this principle to explain that an assessee need not prove actual payment by sellers, but still must do more than merely produce form 32 to discharge the onus of proof. |
| Sha Pannalal Pemraj & Co. v. Commercial Tax Officer, Hassan Circle [1975] 35 STC 109 | Similar observation: production of form 32 is not the only manner of proving that a sale is not a first sale; evidentiary burden principles apply. | The court cited it as supporting authority for the proposition that production of form 32 alone does not necessarily absolve the purchaser from the burden of proof. |
| B. V. Bhatta v. State of Madras [1965] 16 STC 441 | The benefit of assessability at a single point is in the nature of an exemption; the burden of proving entitlement to that exemption lies on the dealer because the relevant facts are usually within his special knowledge (invoking section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act and section 10 of the Sales Tax Act). | The court invoked this case to emphasise that the onus is on the dealer to produce material facts within his knowledge to establish entitlement, and thus production of form 32 by itself may be insufficient absent corroborative evidence. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by identifying the statutory and regulatory framework: groundnuts are "declared goods" in the Fourth Schedule and, under section 5(4) of the Act together with rule 26(9)(a) of the Rules, tax on declared goods is leviable at a single point — in the case of groundnuts, at the first purchase in the State.
The court then analysed the evidentiary position. It acknowledged that the petitioner had produced form 32 declarations issued by registered selling dealers. However, the court reiterated established principles (drawn from cited precedents) that:
- While an assessee need not show that his sellers have actually paid tax, the onus of proving entitlement to the single-point assessability/exemption rests on the dealer claiming it; the burden arises because the decisive facts are often exclusively within the dealer's knowledge.
- Mere production of form 32 does not automatically absolve the purchaser of liability if he is in fact the first purchaser; additional acceptable evidence may be required to support the contention that the sellers were liable to pay tax as first sellers.
Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the assessing officer had made enquiries with the selling dealers and obtained information that some groundnuts sold to the assessee were out of the sellers' inter-State purchases. That information was communicated to the assessee in a notice. The assessee denied the allegations and produced purchase bills to support his claim that he was not the first purchaser.
The court observed that the assessing officer appears to have relied solely on information gathered from the sellers (cross-verification) and did not properly consider the purchase bills produced by the assessee; the assessment order does not indicate scrutiny of those bills. The appellate authorities likewise proceeded on the assumption that the assessee had no evidence other than form 32.
Given that the assessing authority's finding was based primarily on information collected from sellers and that the assessee was not given an opportunity to inspect sellers' account books or have his documentary evidence properly considered, the court concluded that the revenue authorities had not carried out the necessary balanced evidentiary assessment. The court also noted that if form 32 had been misused by selling dealers, the proper course was for the assessing officer to initiate proceedings against those sellers under the Act and Rules.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision petition is allowed and the assessment order, as affirmed by the Appellate Tribunal, so far as it relates to the levy of tax on the purchase turnover of groundnut, is quashed.
Implications / Consequences:
- The assessing officer is directed to afford the assessee an opportunity to produce evidence and to redo the assessment in accordance with law and in light of the court's observations. The assessee is permitted to adduce any evidence to show that the sellers were taxable under the Act.
- The court emphasised that if declarations in form 32 have been misused by selling dealers, the assessing officer should initiate proceedings against those sellers; the proper enforcement action is to be taken against the sellers rather than automatically recovering tax from the purchaser who relied on form 32 without a fair opportunity to have his evidence considered.
- The petitioner is directed to appear before the assessing authority on 16th July, 1984 to receive further notice. The court made no order as to costs.
- The decision does not announce a novel legal principle; it applies established precedents about the burden of proof and the evidentiary value of form 32 and remands for proper reconsideration of evidence. In particular, it reaffirms that production of form 32 alone may be insufficient and that assessing authorities must consider additional evidence and follow proper procedures before levying tax on an otherwise claimed exempt turnover.
Note: This summary is strictly confined to and derived from the content of the provided opinion. No additional facts or inferences beyond the opinion's text have been introduced.
1. This tax revision under section 23(1) of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957 (the "Act"), is directed against the order of the Tribunal in S.T.A. No. 555/79 dated December 20, 1979.
2. The petitioner is a registered dealer under the Act. For the assessment year 1972-73 ending on September 30, 1973, he declared that he had purchased groundnut seeds of the value of Rs. 10,76,816.94 and claimed exemption in respect of that entire turnover on the ground that his sellers, five in number, were the first purchasers in the State. In support of his contention he also produced declaration in form 32.
3. The assessing authority made some enquiry with the sellers who issued those declarations in form 32. It was in the enquiry revealed that groundnuts of the value of Rs. 4,45,152.00 were purchased by the assessee from the turnover relating to inter-State transaction. Accordingly the assessing authority held that the petitioner is the first purchaser to that extent liable to pay tax under section 5(4) of the Act.
4. It may be stated that groundnuts and oil-seeds are declared goods in the Fourth Schedule. The tax in respect of the goods would be on the purchase by the first or the earliest of the successive dealers in the State.
5. The assessing authority issued a notice to the petitioner stating :
"The cross verification made in this behalf has revealed that the G.N. seeds valued Rs. 4,45,152.00 were purchased by you out of the G.N. seeds purchased by your sellers in the inter-State trade or commerce. Therefore, you have become the first purchaser liable to tax on this turnover of Rs. 4,45,152.00. In other words, your claim for exemption in this behalf is allowed only to the extent of Rs. 6,31,664.94. The details of G.N. seeds purchased out of inter-State stock of your sellers are as under.
Particulars.
"We submit that we have no further detail except furnishing the name. We have purchased the goods against form 32 submitted to you at the time of scrutiny of account. We therefore submit that unless it is provided that the goods purchased by us from the respective dealers relate to sales effected by them out of the seeds purchased from outside, no presumption could be drawn and subjected to tax. We have faithfully acted on the declaration forms issued by our suppliers in form 32 prescribed under the Act and therefore we are not liable to pay tax on the said turnover."
6. The assessing authority, however, disallowed the claim for exemption and levied tax of Rs. 11,762.92 giving exemption in respect of the remaining turnover.
7. Being aggrieved by the assessment order the petitioner preferred an appeal to the Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appeals), who dismissed the same. His second appeal to the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal was also dismissed.
8. The question urged before the authorities below and reiterated before us is that form 32 is conclusive in the matter of treating the petitioner as a first dealer and the petitioner has no other means to verify whether the goods purchased from the sellers had suffered tax or not. If form 32 has been misused by such sellers for evading their tax liability although they are the first sellers in respect of those goods, the taxation authority upon verification must take appropriate action against them and not to recover tax from a person who is not liable to pay under the Act.
9. The dealer who sold the groundnuts to the petitioner were undisputedly registered dealers. They have obtained form 32 from their respective assessing authorities. Rule 26(9)(a) of the Karnataka Sales Tax Rules, 1957 (the "Rules"), provides :
"Every dealer in goods taxable at the point first sale or first purchase in the State, shall, where he is not liable to tax in respect of such goods by reason of his not being the first seller or the first purchaser, furnish to the assessing authority a declaration in form 32 obtained from the registered dealer who sold the goods to him and for this purpose, the seller of such goods shall issue the declaration to the buying dealer."
This rule is referable to section 5(4) of the Act which inter alia provides :
"Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), a tax under this Act shall be levied in respect of the sale or purchase of any of the declared goods mentioned in column (2) of the Fourth Schedule at the rate and only at the point specified in the corresponding entries of columns (4) and (3) of the said Schedule on the dealer liable to tax under this Act on his taxable turnover of sales or purchases in each year relating to such goods."
10. The combined effect of section 5(4) of the Act and rule 26(9)(a) of the Rules is that in respect of the declared goods mentioned in column 2 of the Fourth Schedule there shall be only a single point levy and that too at the first sale or purchase in the State. In respect of the groundnuts, it should be only on the first purchase.
11. In the instant case, it is no doubt true that the assessee has produced form 32 issued by the dealers registered under the Act. But, it is well-established that mere production of form 32 does not absolve the assessing from the liability to pay tax if he is the first purchaser. It is also equally well-established that the assessee need not prove that his seller has, in fact, paid the tax as the first seller.
12. In Govindan & Co. v. State of Tamil Nadu [1975] 35 STC 50, the Madras High Court observed that to claim the benefit of tax on the ground that the sales effected by the assessee are second sales, the assessee need not show that his sellers have, in fact, paid tax. It is enough for the assessee to show that the earlier sales were taxable sales and that the tax was really payable by his sellers. To the same effect are observations made by this Court in Sha Pannalal Pemraj & Co. v. Commercial Tax Officer, Hassan Circle [1975] 35 STC 109.
In B. V. Bhatta v. State of Madras [1965] 16 STC 441, the Madras High Court observed thus :
"....... that the benefit of assessability only at a single point and non-assessability at other point is really in the nature of an exemption, and the burden of proving that this exemption is available to him is laid on the dealer. The reason for it is obvious. In almost all cases, the question whether a sale is a first sale or a second sale will be primarily a question of fact. This will be entirely within the special knowledge of the dealer, and it is for him, who is in possession of the material facts to supply them. Such an obligation of discharging the burden of proof can be deducted from section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, apart from section 10 of the Sales Tax Act. What section 10 lays down is, therefore, the same broad principle enunciated in section 106 of the Evidence Act, that the onus is on the person who is in possession of special facts exclusively within his knowledge, to disclose them to the Court, when he seeks to obtain any benefit for himself on the basis of proof of those facts ...."
13. Section 10 referred to therein is similar to section 6a of the karnataka act inserted by Karnataka Act No. 9 of 1964.
14. No doubt, the burden is on the assessee to prove that he is not liable to tax. He cannot discharge that burden by merely producing form 32 which was passed on to him by him sellers. He must produce some other acceptable evidence to lend credence to the contention that he has purchased the goods from a dealer who is liable to pay tax under the Act. If once the evidence is put on record, then it is a question of appreciation and comparing the evidence of the assessee with the evidence produced by the sellers or collected in accordance with law by the assessing officer from the sellers. If an assessee has produced acceptable evidence in addition to form 32 to show that he has purchased the goods from a person who is liable to pay tax, it would be proper for the assessing officer to accept such evidence unless he comes to the conclusion by other positive proof that the selling dealers were not liable to pay tax on the concerned goods.
15. The assessing officer, in the instant case, appears to have made an enquiry with the selling dealers and found that some of the groundnuts sold by them to the assessee were not of their inter-State transactions. That was no doubt intimated to the assessee in the proposition notice. But, the assessee in reply to that notice has denied those allegations. The assessing officer however formed an opinion that the selling dealers purchased the disputed groundnuts in the course of inter-State transactions. There was no other evidence on record except the information gathered from cross verification. The assessee has had no opportunity to look into those account books of the selling dealers. The assessee on his part has produced purchase bills to substantiate his contention that he was not the first purchaser. The assessing officer appears to have not considered the purchase bills. At any rate, the assessment order does not indicate that. He appears to have relied solely on the information collected by him from the sellers, without due regard to the documents produced by the assessee. The exercise of the Revenue should not be in the direction to have a second bite of the same cherry.
16. The orders of the appellate authorities are no better. They have proceeded on the basis that the assessee has no evidence except form 32. We have earlier pointed out that the assessee had also produced purchase bills which ought to have been properly scrutinised by the authorities.
17. If the declarations in form 32 have been misused by those selling dealers, the assessing officer should promptly initiate proceedings under the Act and the Rules to take action against such sellers.
18. In the result this revision petition is allowed and the assessment order as affirmed by the Appellate Tribunal so far as it relates to the levy of tax on purchase turnover of groundnut is quashed. The assessing officer shall give an opportunity to the assessee to produce evidence and redo the assessment in accordance with law and in the light of the observations made. The assessee is permitted to adduce whatever evidence he chooses to show that the sellers in question were taxable under the Act.
19. The petitioner shall appear before the assessing authority on 16th July, 1984, to receive further notice.
20. In the circumstances, we make no order as to costs.
Alert