- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. Metro Malleable Manufactures (P) Ltd., Bangalore v. M/S. Canara Bank, Bangalore And Another
Malimath, J.:— When this appeal came up for admission we asked the learned Counsel for the appellant to explain to us as to how this appeal is maintainable. The order challenged in this appeal is made by the Company Judge on Company Application No. 58/80 during the pendency of proceedings for liquidation of Metro Malieable Manufacturers Private Limited. The petition for winding up was presented by respondent-2. Respondent-1 the Canara Bank made an application under Order I Rule 10 C.P.C read with Rule 101 of the Company (Court) Rules for impleading it as petitioner-2 in the petition for winding up. The said application was opposed. But the Company Judge has allowed the said application by his order dated 4th July 1980. It is the said order that is challenged in this appeal under Section 483 of the Companies Act (hereinafter called the Act).
2. It was contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the language of Section 483 of the Act is so wide as to entitle the aggrieved party to prefer an appeal against every order made by the Company Court. Section 483 of the Act reads as follows:
“Appeals from any order or decision given in the matter of winding up of a Company by the Court shall lie to the same Court to which, in the same manner in which, and subject to the same conditions under which, appeals lie from any order or decision of the Court in cases within its ordinary jurisdiction.”
Though Section 483 of the Act reads as though an appeal is competent from any order or decision of the Company Court, it is obvious that it is only such orders which have the effect of affecting the rights of the parties that can be appealed against under Section 483 of the Act. Orders of procedural character which do not affect the rights of the parties are not orders against which appeals are contemplated under Section 483 of the Act. A provision similar to Section 483 of the Act, i.e, Section 118 of the Mysore Land Reforms Act, 1961, came up for consideration before a Division Bench of this Court in Govinda v. Mary Fernandes(1). The language of Section 118 of the Mysore Land Reforms Act is in pari materia with the language employed in Section 483 of the Act. The Division Bench following the decisions in Central Bank of India v. Gokalchand(2) and Bant Singh v. Shanti Devi(3) has held that an order which does not affect the rights and liabilities of the parties is not one which can be appealed against under Section 118(1) of the Mysore Land Reforms Act. The order appealed against in the case on hand is one permitting respondent-1 the Canara Bank to be impleaded as petitioner-2 in the winding-up petition. Merely because respondent-1 has been permitted to come on record as petitioner-2 in the winding-up petition, it does not follow that the said order has the effect of affecting any of the rights and liabilities of the appellant. That being the position, it is not possible to accede to the contention of Sri Dwaraka Nath learned counsel for the appellant that the impugned order of the Company Judge is liable to be appealed against under Section 483 of the Act. Hence this appeal is rejected as not maintainable.
Alert